Kapil sir, I would like to request you to do a discussion on the Umar Khalid case, it's been 5 years and not even his trial started and he is still behind the bar, it's a classic example of process is the punishment. Thankyou.
Each panelist is highly articulated. Each one emphasized degeneration of office of Governor. Appointment of politicians as governors are acting as agents of centre. They have failed to discharge the role in federalism. Governors have asked for discretionary fund and they are misusing. No norms are followed. Kapil does a wonderful job as a journalist and moderator.
Pity that nothing can be done in the present dispensation. We can only watch such events. Only time can tell whether we can weather away such partisan misdemeanors.
To enforce constitutional morality we need people who understand constitution and have a profound belief and respect for it. Thanks for this wonderful chat.
Just was going through Sarkaria commission & 2nd ARC reports for upcoming exams. This Centre state relations have so many issues & then there's Governor. There should be independence of bodies & appointments. Very helpful as always Kapil sir. Thank you 🙏
My Great salute to NN vohra Sir .He is having a great command on the broad aspects of Governance and how to bridge the gap between Centre and States..He is having a great deal of being as Governor in state of JK...
Every Govt wants to abolish the conical mind set or colonial name etc , but why not this governor post. They are still interfering in state Govt affairs.
A very good morning respected learned Judge and President of India Bar Association Kapil Sibal sir. You are in fact the back bone of Indian judiciary system. Respect and salute to your unbiased decision and statement.
Very nice and thought provoking discussion ,if the union govt and the governors listened to the discussion should atleast act now and pave the way for.a better administration supported by them for the welfare of the people and the whole nation
Dil se is watched mostly by educated citizens with good understanding of our Constitution. The problems with the way the institution of Governors functions are quite well known .Therfore when the discussions in this regard ended leaving the solutions to the institution itself is somewhat disappointing
Hi Mr Kapil Sibal and other panelists It was a wonderful panel discussion with illuminaries from respective fields. Though readymade solution may not be available for the issue the discussion should be publicised through various social media to bring about Public awareness. Great job 👍
Congress had more than 50 years to remove such posts which are not liable to do any work...either remove the post or give them more power to do work... salary must be given as per work...even in govt jobs...
Yes, Governor post is yes man of Central Govt. In years back they did not talk too much about politics now they are using his chair as BJP spokesperson
Excellent conversation .. but beyond intellectual what has been done practically !! Ppl r so immersed in religious politics they don’t even seem to give a dam to these important issues. The understanding & awareness shd be generated among common ppl !!
Excellent conversation .. but beyond intellectual conversation what has been done practically !! Ppl r so immersed in religious politics they don’t even seem to give a dam to these important issues. The understanding & awareness shd be generated among common ppl !!
Country is being dismantled since last 10 years, and Opposition is busy giving press conferences and holding discussions. What an unfortunate situation:( PS: Huge respect to PTR, he is the worthy gentelman where BJP-RSS couldn't win a single seat and his interviews are worth watching.
The post of governor should be removed from our constitution.post of govrnnor has. no role of helping state goverment for making good of the people of the stste.
Understand , If the politicians, taking advantage of their political position , take law in their own hand ; THEN THE PUBLIC TOO SHOULD BE BOLD TO TAKE LAW IN THEIR OWN HAND TO AVENGE THE IMMORAL AND CORRUPT ACT OF SUCH POLITICIANS.
Thousands of job seekers in West Bengal are denied employment, there are cases of numerous corruptions...across the board affecting very poor strata...and all of these are not mere vendetta politics .... State government employees denied DA and not to mention the RG Kar case.... issue is that in his zeal to defend his client ....many a times morality and justice takes a back seat...a person may not get convicted by the court due to so many reasons in India ....but tat doesnt take away the fact that Injustice happened, exploitation happened and some people have benefitted at the cost of a vast majority.... I cant fathom how on earth this is moral.... in India an accussed is accorded an uneven advantage provided he has money and connections....be tat as it may...... in that scenario value judgements on others sound hollow ....
Why You r trying to block Justice of our little Doctor Sister and trying to save evidence destroyers ?👈🔥🔥🔥 But You can't 👈 Remember that Bcz Krishna with Us 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Manipur violence - The governor, isn’t that why most of them are IAS ? I thought their allegiance is to the constitution. If they are not part of the constitutional safeguards. What is then ? The judiciary is already in question from the looks of it.
What was the position of President post when Pratibha Devi Patil was in office what to say of Governor? Common people understand more than enough that those who have power will misuse it. Currently BJP is in power Congress and leftists are crying foul. When Congress was in power BJP was crying foul.
Mere parents ab nahi rshe, har roj jhagra karte the. Ekdin himne gaya kiyoin itna chillata ho. Mummy ne kahe ni kal jao ,e apna dus mani hai. Am compeelled. Law of rule
Kapil Sibbal type sr Lawyer must watch themselves being movers of SC as a nexus. U R exposed. Present justice system skewed by congress through people like U eastablished by Britishers must be dismantled . Please be Bharat centric and have change of heart.
It suited The ROGUE CONGRESS TO USE THE OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR, THEN WHY YOU DENY SUCH ADVANTAGE TO B J P . OLD WRONGS OF THE SYSTEM CAN BE RECTIFIED BY B J P AT THEIR WISH AND OTHER PROGRAMMES . TILL THEN STATUSCO WILL HAVE TO BE MAINTAINED . CONGRESS CANNOT PLAY THE ROLE OF REFORMER NOW .
Kapil Sibal ji,I am very thankful to you for this message!
Sibbal is the greatest Rapist Advocate of India 😢😢
Kapil sir, I would like to request you to do a discussion on the Umar Khalid case, it's been 5 years and not even his trial started and he is still behind the bar, it's a classic example of process is the punishment. Thankyou.
Undoubtedly.
Facts speak for themselves.
Governors are not only acting as agents rather as touts of the government.
Thoroughly spineless.
Each panelist is highly articulated. Each one emphasized degeneration of office of Governor. Appointment of politicians as governors are acting as agents of centre. They have failed to discharge the role in federalism. Governors have asked for discretionary fund and they are misusing. No norms are followed.
Kapil does a wonderful job as a journalist and moderator.
Pity that nothing can be done in the present dispensation. We can only watch such events. Only time can tell whether we can weather away such partisan misdemeanors.
To enforce constitutional morality we need people who understand constitution and have a profound belief and respect for it. Thanks for this wonderful chat.
What a great and burning topic it was! but no one is talking about it because they have been diverted to hindutva politics only .
Appreciate the nuances of such conversations. 🎉🙏
Just was going through Sarkaria commission & 2nd ARC reports for upcoming exams. This Centre state relations have so many issues & then there's Governor. There should be independence of bodies & appointments. Very helpful as always Kapil sir. Thank you 🙏
My Great salute to NN vohra Sir .He is having a great command on the broad aspects of Governance and how to bridge the gap between Centre and States..He is having a great deal of being as Governor in state of JK...
Thanks for sharing it 🎉
Nice discussion like always.
Every Govt wants to abolish the conical mind set or colonial name etc , but why not this governor post. They are still interfering in state Govt affairs.
You can't block Justice of our little Doctor Sister .... 👈🔥🔥🔥
Governors have been “Governers” since the dawn of the Constitution. Let us not pretend all of this started in 2014.
Exactly. Just the misuse has escalated since 2014
A very good morning respected learned Judge and President of India Bar Association Kapil Sibal sir. You are in fact the back bone of Indian judiciary system. Respect and salute to your unbiased decision and statement.
Sir Every institution has been captured, intruded by the hydra...
we love your show and we always wait for the next episode. love u sir
That's what an intellectual discussion look like 😊.
Very nice and thought provoking discussion ,if the union govt and the governors listened to the discussion should atleast act now and pave the way for.a better administration supported by them for the welfare of the people and the whole nation
What a panel and great discussion. Thank you Sibalji. Pathetic is the best way to describe the situation. Ain't no shame
You are great sir ....Pranam
Dil se is watched mostly by educated citizens with good understanding of our Constitution. The problems with the way the institution of Governors functions are quite well known .Therfore when the discussions in this regard ended leaving the solutions to the institution itself is somewhat disappointing
Yes, it can be.
For example- Kerala, Bengal , and Tamil Nadu (extreme level)
So pleased to see ur most of the episodes. It was an outstanding analysis and fun banter.😅
Hi Mr Kapil Sibal and other panelists
It was a wonderful panel discussion with illuminaries from respective fields. Though readymade solution may not be available for the issue the discussion should be publicised through various social media to bring about Public awareness.
Great job 👍
Yes it is... Apointed by president ( the puppet) on recommendation of gov.. whata a joke
Congress had more than 50 years to remove such posts which are not liable to do any work...either remove the post or give them more power to do work... salary must be given as per work...even in govt jobs...
Namaste sir
Found to be best discussion
Well Governor can call upon whoever he wants. The Constitution doesn't say otherwise either.
Thanks Kapil sir.
advocate sibal get WELL soon!!!!!
Yes, Governor post is yes man of Central Govt. In years back they did not talk too much about politics now they are using his chair as BJP spokesperson
Excellent conversation .. but beyond intellectual what has been done practically !! Ppl r so immersed in religious politics they don’t even seem to give a dam to these important issues. The understanding & awareness shd be generated among common ppl !!
Excellent conversation .. but beyond intellectual conversation what has been done practically !! Ppl r so immersed in religious politics they don’t even seem to give a dam to these important issues. The understanding & awareness shd be generated among common ppl !!
Respected Sibal ji please discuse agreesion of Manipur in your dilse
Country is being dismantled since last 10 years, and Opposition is busy giving press conferences and holding discussions. What an unfortunate situation:(
PS: Huge respect to PTR, he is the worthy gentelman where BJP-RSS couldn't win a single seat and his interviews are worth watching.
universities emphatically must be free of all ideology
The post of governor should be removed from our constitution.post of govrnnor has. no role of helping state goverment for making good of the people of the stste.
Mr.PTR deserves Union finance portfolio ...
Understand ,
If the politicians, taking advantage of their political position , take law in their own hand ;
THEN THE PUBLIC TOO SHOULD BE BOLD TO TAKE LAW IN THEIR OWN HAND TO AVENGE THE IMMORAL AND CORRUPT ACT OF SUCH POLITICIANS.
What else Sir ? Governors are appointed by central government and can also be removed/shifted by it.
Sir there is already a mechanism in place i.e. The Zonal Council's . But it has been made dysfunctional.
Yes ji
Congress had imposed Article 356 so many times. At that time, what was the position of Governor?
Thousands of job seekers in West Bengal are denied employment, there are cases of numerous corruptions...across the board affecting very poor strata...and all of these are not mere vendetta politics .... State government employees denied DA and not to mention the RG Kar case.... issue is that in his zeal to defend his client ....many a times morality and justice takes a back seat...a person may not get convicted by the court due to so many reasons in India ....but tat doesnt take away the fact that Injustice happened, exploitation happened and some people have benefitted at the cost of a vast majority.... I cant fathom how on earth this is moral.... in India an accussed is accorded an uneven advantage provided he has money and connections....be tat as it may...... in that scenario value judgements on others sound hollow ....
A resounding YES ( unfortunately )
You need governors, but elected ones, not Centre-appointed. You need guvs elected by the assemblies of the province or state.
Why You r trying to block Justice of our little Doctor Sister and trying to save evidence destroyers ?👈🔥🔥🔥 But You can't 👈 Remember that Bcz Krishna with Us 🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩🚩
Everyone is looking like agent of RSS even congress 😂😂
Manipur violence - The governor, isn’t that why most of them are IAS ? I thought their allegiance is to the constitution. If they are not part of the constitutional safeguards. What is then ? The judiciary is already in question from the looks of it.
❤❤❤🎉🎉
Did Congress never select a politicsl governor? What hypocricy!!!
❤
Tnpsc g2 effect😅
Constitutional morality
agents of the crown
He is the agent of union government. No douth at all. No douth at all.
What was the position of President post when Pratibha Devi Patil was in office what to say of Governor? Common people understand more than enough that those who have power will misuse it. Currently BJP is in power Congress and leftists are crying foul. When Congress was in power BJP was crying foul.
U r very with lokur right but not with cji
देश के सांसद में आया है एक राहुल गांधी नाम के असली शेर जिसके आगे नरेन्द्र मोदी बीजेपी संघियो के सभी नेता ढ़ेर♥️♥️♥️♥️♥️
Dil se jha2 kapil sibbal
When was it otherwise, you just woke up after 70 years! Why don’t talk about it!
Mere parents ab nahi rshe, har roj jhagra karte the. Ekdin himne gaya kiyoin itna chillata ho. Mummy ne kahe ni
kal jao ,e apna dus mani hai. Am compeelled. Law of rule
Kapil Sibbal type sr Lawyer must watch themselves being movers of SC as a nexus. U R exposed. Present justice system skewed by congress through people like U eastablished by Britishers must be dismantled . Please be Bharat centric and have change of heart.
धिक्कार है तुम पर, कपिल सिब्बल
Sibbal ji U did not thought of role of governors when Congress was in power how Congress used to misuse them. U have been beneficiary all along.
देर आयत दुरुस्त आयत ❤
Kahe ko ghusa karta hai tum. Aaj Jaitley Sahab hote u cud not have dared say
Arun Jaitely Sir jaise respected learned aadmi ko kyon use kar rahe ho.
Kapil Sibal CIA Agent
This terrible man Kapil Sibbal is as usual talking big. I have been watching him on RGKar case. Shameful.
It suited The ROGUE CONGRESS TO USE THE OFFICE OF THE GOVERNOR, THEN WHY YOU DENY SUCH ADVANTAGE TO B J P .
OLD WRONGS OF THE SYSTEM CAN BE RECTIFIED BY B J P AT THEIR WISH AND OTHER PROGRAMMES .
TILL THEN STATUSCO WILL HAVE TO BE MAINTAINED .
CONGRESS CANNOT PLAY THE ROLE OF REFORMER NOW .