Polyandry in Hatti community in Himachal Pradesh

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ •

  • @honestea
    @honestea 2 місяці тому +46

    Such a balanced tone is lacking now in journalist reports ...really appreciated.

  • @pratikbshah
    @pratikbshah 2 роки тому +173

    What I liked in this video was how carefully the presenter has handled the subject. How beautifully narrated & concluded. Completely neutral about the ritual while giving all the information. Do watch it. Deserves a 👍🏻

    • @shivshankar7945
      @shivshankar7945 Рік тому +2

      Very informative presentation. We should feel proud in the living style and traditions of the tribes of our country. Kudos to the presenter of the programme.

    • @deeneyes5526
      @deeneyes5526 9 місяців тому +8

      Are wo Muslim nahi na isiliye content me maza nahi ata 😅

    • @rashmikantsahoo1728
      @rashmikantsahoo1728 8 місяців тому

      Then you're a Katwa😂😂​@@deeneyes5526
      Pakdaa gayaa🐷

    • @rahehaq9266
      @rahehaq9266 2 місяці тому +1

      😂😂😂😂 musalmaan nhi hai na isliye achha laga hoga

  • @krishnaschauhan4013
    @krishnaschauhan4013 2 місяці тому +14

    बहुत ही दिलचस्प रिपोर्ट , शानदार प्रस्तुति। ऐसी संतुलित रिपोर्ट देख कर पता चलता है कि हमारा समाज कितना विविधता पूर्ण है । आभार।

  • @poojarana6226
    @poojarana6226 2 роки тому +143

    Full marks to the screenplay writer he has conveyed the sentiments of the community without stirring the pot.

  • @gauravchauhan7447
    @gauravchauhan7447 2 роки тому +749

    अनेकता में एकता ही भारत की पहचान है। हाटी समाज को अपनी संस्कृति पर गर्व होना चाहिए और साथ ही यह भी ध्यान रखना चाहिए की वे यह प्रथा जबरदस्ती नई पीढ़ी पर न थोपें। अगर कोई इस व्यवस्था को चालू रखना चाहता है तो समाज उसे गलत रूप में न देखें और अगर कोई इस व्यवस्था के अंतर्गत विवाह नहीं करना चाहता तोह समाज को उसके निर्णय का भी स्वागत करना चाहिए।

    • @संदीपसनातन
      @संदीपसनातन 2 роки тому +18

      अच्छी सोच।

    • @Jayalalita91
      @Jayalalita91 2 роки тому +7

      Respect to them...👍

    • @kaifiazmi3948
      @kaifiazmi3948 2 роки тому +3

      Dharm se samjhauta nhi, lazim follow karna chahiye..

    • @manojnehra8503
      @manojnehra8503 2 роки тому

      ये जनजातिया जैसै रहना चाहती है वैसेरहने दो पालतु मे अपनी नाक घुसाना जरुरी है क्या,प्रकृति से जुडे़ लोग है ये।इनको देखकर लगता है येतनाव गर्सत है

    • @ajay_57
      @ajay_57 2 роки тому +13

      @Salmon fish आदिवासी हिन्दू नही होते बेवकूफ

  • @nidhiguleria7802
    @nidhiguleria7802 8 місяців тому +9

    Thank you Team for highlighting sensibly our culture ❤

  • @shashank_sharma400
    @shashank_sharma400 2 роки тому +89

    बिल्कुल ठीक कहा आपने, इस प्रथा पर गर्व और खेद दोनों की ही आवश्यकता नहीं है

    • @tgty8821
      @tgty8821 8 місяців тому +1

      😂😂

    • @GausMuhammadkhan-o2n
      @GausMuhammadkhan-o2n 8 місяців тому +1

      Aurat ki halat kaisi hogi 2_3 mardon ko leti hogi jab

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому +1

      तुम अपनी बेटी या बहन का शादी यही करना बहुत अच्छी परंपरा हैं एक बेटी के 10,20 पति मजा आयेगा तुम्हारी बेटी को बहन को और तुम्हे

  • @bpbadola7906
    @bpbadola7906 2 роки тому +12

    Polyandry in Himalayas के लेखक Dr Y.S. परमार ने बहुत अच्छा विश्लेषण किया था। आज के संदर्भ में यह प्रथा चल रही है, तो इसका सम्मान होना चाहिए, यद्यपि बाहरी शक्तियों के कारण इस पर प्रभाव पड़ रहा है। ऐसा हम किन्नौर और रोहरु क्षेत्र में देखते हैं।

  • @thakurneetishnegi07
    @thakurneetishnegi07 Рік тому +57

    Best part of the video ye hai ki ye log ladki ki baat ko sehmati dete hai, pehle us se decision puchhte hai jo ki bahut sahi hai. Baki jaisa Desh Vesa bhesh ❤

    • @awaaz3956
      @awaaz3956 3 місяці тому +3

      😂

    • @Free1thinker
      @Free1thinker 6 днів тому

      हलाला नहीं हे​@@awaaz3956

    • @orujnoori1836
      @orujnoori1836 2 дні тому

      Ye bas khne ke liye hot h

  • @blue_chamaeleon
    @blue_chamaeleon 2 роки тому +1235

    जनजातियों जी भर के जीओं । यह मिट्टी तुम्हारा है, यह पर्वत तुम्हारा है, यह पवन तुम्हारा है, यह गगन तुम्हारा है, तुम प्रकृति की संतान हो । जय भगवान बिरसा मुंडा ।

    • @Yashpalishu
      @Yashpalishu 2 роки тому +27

      @Main Bhi Bharat आप सही कह रहे हो और आपकी रिपोर्ट भी सही है, मैं भी इसी क्षेत्र का रहने वाला हूं, बहुपति प्रथा अभी भी इस क्षेत्र में बनी हुई है परंतु इसके उदाहरण अब बहुत कम मिलते हैं, और धीरे-धीरे यह प्रथा समाप्ति की ओर जा रही है!
      बाकी आप मेरी कविताएं भी सुन सकते हैं

    • @blossom_4849
      @blossom_4849 2 роки тому +7

      Sunder vichar

    • @princerahul3320
      @princerahul3320 2 роки тому +29

      Bhai birsa Munda ke sath prachin adiwasion ki bhi jai kiya karo Eklavya kewat shabri itihas main bharey padey hain

    • @ganeshsarve6082
      @ganeshsarve6082 2 роки тому +9

      हम जनजातीयो के जतन में विश्व में अग्रेसर है👍

    • @bhargavdhak5890
      @bhargavdhak5890 2 роки тому +5

      Johar

  • @chiranjeevi913
    @chiranjeevi913 2 роки тому +328

    Be proud of your identity, and never feel ashamed about it. Changes to be done should be decided among the community members, never by the influence of outer breaking forces.

    • @raazaaaa
      @raazaaaa 2 роки тому +26

      That's hypocrisy on your part.

    • @ashvasth407
      @ashvasth407 2 роки тому +8

      Leave 4 wife tradition.

    • @obaidajk
      @obaidajk 2 роки тому

      @@ashvasth407 OK then start from your mom find her two men and call them both pappa

    • @ilovemyindia2435
      @ilovemyindia2435 2 роки тому +10

      🤣 dropadi pratha = shareing just one ched With many dandas this is hindu culture

    • @swanubal508
      @swanubal508 2 роки тому

      @@ilovemyindia2435 and sharing one danda with your daughter's and sister's ched ..this is chuslim culture

  • @vangogh7230
    @vangogh7230 Рік тому +18

    Respect. It shows one doesn’t need to be educated to have common sense and intelligence. Such pragmatic and well spoken folks.

  • @onlineclassesofscienceandm7856
    @onlineclassesofscienceandm7856 2 роки тому +83

    Diversity is a unique features of tribal community that can be see in dance , local songs , food

  • @kd299
    @kd299 2 роки тому +105

    मेने एक चीज अभी तक देखी है भारत की लगभग जनजाति समाज में बोहोत सारी प्रथाएं ऐसी होती है जिससे घर टूटने या फिर घर में झगड़ा होने की सम्भावना खत्म ही हो जाती है❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️✔️✔️

    • @rajubhaivyas1450
      @rajubhaivyas1450 2 роки тому +5

      Kafi... logical, aur.. sahi baat kahi hai aap ne 🙏🏻💐 Jay Hind 🙏🏻 vande matram 🙏🏻💐

    • @rameshsanghani2248
      @rameshsanghani2248 9 місяців тому

      Q😊¹

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому

      पागल लोग स्वाभिमानी नहीं है ये लोग

    • @mansumansu1100
      @mansumansu1100 Місяць тому

      Haaa haa hum nhi kar sakte esaa mar jayenge hum yrr😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅😅

  • @amitarmori2729
    @amitarmori2729 7 місяців тому +8

    People are so mature ... And village kitna sundar he

  • @puransinghmandavi7057
    @puransinghmandavi7057 2 роки тому +81

    बहुत सुन्दर । एकता, समानता, शांति, ताल-मेल आपसी समझदारी और जिम्मेदारी आदि का समावेश देखने को मिला। Thanks

    • @kailashsharma7088
      @kailashsharma7088 Рік тому +2

      बहुत सुन्दर रिवाज है परिवार भी एक रहता है।
      I like it.

    • @mohammedmustaqeem4915
      @mohammedmustaqeem4915 9 місяців тому +5

      ​@@kailashsharma7088toh yeh pratha aap log kab suru kar rahe hai.???

    • @dhole-qz2st
      @dhole-qz2st 8 місяців тому

      ​@@mohammedmustaqeem4915आप कहना क्या चाहते हैं?

    • @GausMuhammadkhan-o2n
      @GausMuhammadkhan-o2n 8 місяців тому +1

      Mahan desh mahan dharm mahan pratha.

  • @lifethroughmyeyes449
    @lifethroughmyeyes449 2 роки тому +203

    They never force the girl, it’s her choice if she wants to get married with one man she is free,
    I from hatti samudaay,

    • @DH_ISL
      @DH_ISL 2 роки тому

      🤍

    • @fanofadam8038
      @fanofadam8038 2 роки тому +12

      Follow your beautiful culture with pride 🥰take positivity leave negatively 😇😇

    • @bharatiya804
      @bharatiya804 2 роки тому +10

      To stop the division of farm, house, money is the reason behind this pratha. May be less number of girls available for marriage is another reason.
      Anyway, they are our family

    • @sarv1542
      @sarv1542 2 роки тому +2

      Every culture is great for members of their society.

    • @rajivmittal904
      @rajivmittal904 2 роки тому +2

      ek ladki keh kitneh pati hote hai agar 10 bhai hon? Sabi ke common bivi hogi ,mean to say any upper limit

  • @OshoShakti
    @OshoShakti Рік тому +115

    I’m a Hatti from Sirmour thanking y’all for covering my culture and showing this to the world. ❤🙏🇮🇳

    • @jagdishsurin8628
      @jagdishsurin8628 Рік тому +1

      Johar

    • @Revanced23
      @Revanced23 Рік тому +3

      जा अपने भाई को call कर कही तेरी बीवी की ले ना रहे हो

    • @anilkumar-pl4vc
      @anilkumar-pl4vc Рік тому +13

      ​@@Revanced23, bhai theek kaha aapne. jis baat par inko sharm aani chaiye ,ye sasura khush ho rha hai.

    • @gulfamkhan3010
      @gulfamkhan3010 Рік тому +6

      Wah culture hey wah.
      Like animals .

    • @lifeonhigh121
      @lifeonhigh121 Рік тому +11

      ​@@gulfamkhan3010teraa Ghar maii bhii HALALA kaa prathaa haii wohh bhii bata de thodaa😂😂😂

  • @ranasarkar8408
    @ranasarkar8408 2 роки тому +38

    Documentary like this with a sensitive topic like this cannot be expected from breaking India TV studios operating from Noida. Kudos to your team for a unbiased rational portrayal of a community.🚩🚩🚩

  • @swatigaur2394
    @swatigaur2394 2 роки тому +103

    Very impressive delivery of the story. Amazed to learn about this culture and liked the statement that you don’t have to be ashamed if you are not proud of something in your culture. Living peacefully like this exhibits a lot about the values of the Hatti people.

    • @MsHanda17
      @MsHanda17 2 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/HFnoPJTECQw/v-deo.html

    • @EV-EV-EV
      @EV-EV-EV Рік тому +3

      It's very shameful

    • @healthcaretips2395
      @healthcaretips2395 Рік тому

    • @drabulhasandasankop3737
      @drabulhasandasankop3737 3 місяці тому

      One type of legalized prostitute culture. I saw video father & son marry a girl there are so many third class system iam seeing on utube they call it culture disgusting" What name they will give to their children & the mother how she will call the kids father's name.

  • @manaliranadive6262
    @manaliranadive6262 7 місяців тому +45

    Bohot samajhdar aur sulza hua samaj hai..
    Aise hi samudayo se hamare Bharat ki sanskruti bani hai❤
    Anchor has done a commendable job!

    • @yogeshthakur9159
      @yogeshthakur9159 5 місяців тому

      Dewar aur bhabhi ke charche aise hi thodi famous hai😂😂. Zameen share nhi krenge bhai but biwi share krlenge. Who in their right minds would allow that, incest porn dekhlia buzurgon ne sirmaur ke 😂

    • @shreyatr8059
      @shreyatr8059 5 місяців тому +8

      What sanskriti... it's backward and suppressing women 😢

    • @prathmeshkirve
      @prathmeshkirve 4 місяці тому +3

      @@shreyatr8059 usko force todhi na kiya hai .aur aaj kal 4 5 bf rakna use bhi modern bola jata hai

    • @shanydevbhumihimachal7007
      @shanydevbhumihimachal7007 4 місяці тому

      😊😊

    • @drabulhasandasankop3737
      @drabulhasandasankop3737 3 місяці тому

      Isn't it exploitation of women's there is no rights of ladies.

  • @vrabatoh4492
    @vrabatoh4492 2 роки тому +91

    ये बहुत सुंदर प्रथा है परिवार अकेला नहीं पड़ता एक कमाने जायेगा एक घर परिवार देखेगा न घर की चिंता न अकेले पन की चिंता बाकी समझ अपनी अपनी

    • @uttarakhand7645
      @uttarakhand7645 9 місяців тому

      😂😂 uss Bibi ka kya jo inko jelti hogi 😂😂 wo yadi Khush hai to tab to koi bat ni yadi dono ka Mann krta hoga sex krne ka tab unki Bibi ko kesa feel hota hoga jara usko v pucho 😂😂 yadi bhai samzdhar h tab to sahi hai dono haiwan hue to😂😂😂.

    • @AnkeshKumar-fx4dl
      @AnkeshKumar-fx4dl 8 місяців тому +7

      Kamane Jane wala akela nahi pada

    • @Guru_hoja_shuru
      @Guru_hoja_shuru 8 місяців тому +2

      पहाड़ों के हिसाब से सही है

    • @vinay249
      @vinay249 8 місяців тому +6

      Regressive hai. Equality nahi hai

    • @tgty8821
      @tgty8821 8 місяців тому

      😂😂😂

  • @astropolitan.i
    @astropolitan.i 2 роки тому +255

    I'm also Himanchali
    & This is exactly how we welcome our guests in Himachal as shown in the beginning.

    • @aaitiniti
      @aaitiniti 2 роки тому

      ua-cam.com/video/xL3-AZLUkbs/v-deo.html

    • @kolkata_mishti6590
      @kolkata_mishti6590 2 роки тому +5

      Paise diye honge camera team ne. Staged hota hai sab

    • @TheSunAgain756
      @TheSunAgain756 2 роки тому +11

      @@kolkata_mishti6590 Tumhare yahan hota hoga staged sb.. Pahadon me aao, log khule Dil se swagat krte hain yahan

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому +5

      संभोग का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @vishwajeet1089
      @vishwajeet1089 2 роки тому +6

      @@gsnarayanan respectfully puchoge to koi answer de dega

  • @luckysazta2047
    @luckysazta2047 10 місяців тому +19

    Love the simplicity and amazing culture of people
    love from shimla ❤

    • @Ironmanzq
      @Ironmanzq 3 місяці тому

      Its not shimla ,it's shillai

    • @luckysazta2047
      @luckysazta2047 3 місяці тому +1

      @@Ironmanzq bro i am not saying that it's Shimla, i am just appreciating the culture and watching this video from Shimla 🙏

    • @amrapali-gs3co
      @amrapali-gs3co 3 місяці тому

      Amazing culture 😗😆😆

  • @AnujSharmaRyan
    @AnujSharmaRyan 2 роки тому +335

    मैं भी हाटी समुदाय से ताल्लुक रखता हूं, लेकिन अब यह प्रथा हमारे समुदाय में बंद हो चुकी है। यह प्रथा बहुत पहले होती थी। मैने तो अपने क्षेत्र में ऐसी कोई शादी नही देखी है अपने जन्म से लेकर अभी तक , जहां जोड़ीदारी प्रथा हो।
    लेकिन यह बात सच है हाटी समुदाय के लोग सुंदर ,स्वच्छ, ठंडे पहाड़ों में बसते है। अगर आप सुबह सो के उठते हो तो आपके खिड़की के सामने सुंदर पहाड़ों की श्रंखला का नजारा दिखाई देता है। इन क्षेत्रों में अगर सरकार पर्यटन को बढ़ावा दे तो ये क्षेत्र किसी हिल पर्यटन सिटी से कम नही है।
    आपका बहुत बहुत धन्यवाद जो हमारे हाटी समुदाय के उपर आपने ये डॉक्यूमेंट्री बनाई 🙏

    • @sandeepsharma-pl8ic
      @sandeepsharma-pl8ic 2 роки тому +2

      Good👍

    • @deepakgoswami1971
      @deepakgoswami1971 2 роки тому +12

      Sharma title कैसे मिला??

    • @abhinavsharma3819
      @abhinavsharma3819 2 роки тому +20

      @@deepakgoswami1971
      sharma hi Hain Bhai ye
      Bas Remote ilaake me rehte hain.
      Pandav time ki pratha hai ye, wo bhi to kshatriya the .
      We have changed over time, their culture is still intact.

    • @vishwajeet1089
      @vishwajeet1089 2 роки тому

      @@deepakgoswami1971 6:08

    • @ManojSharma-dw2jr
      @ManojSharma-dw2jr 10 місяців тому +6

      Ads bhi to ho jata hoga inko.

  • @madguds
    @madguds 2 роки тому +62

    Such an informative research. These ethnographic studies should be further encouraged to create awareness and also highlight tribal traditions.

  • @ravindersharma7479
    @ravindersharma7479 Рік тому +47

    आजकल शहरी जीवन में इतनी अपेक्षाएं बढ़ गई हैं कि एक पति पत्नी अपने रिश्तों को नही संभाल पा रहे
    ये त्याग की भावना ही है जो इस।परंपरा को खुशी खुशी निभा रहे हैं

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому

      तुम अपनी बेटी की शादी यही करना ज्यादा संस्कारी कहलाएगी उसके एक नहीं 10,15 पति होंगे जोड़ीदारी प्रथा यह की औरते चरित्रहीन है तुम्हारी बीवी तुम्हारे भाई से संबंध रखेगी तो अवैध कहोगे

  • @angrybirdreaction2481
    @angrybirdreaction2481 2 роки тому +45

    Very open minded people👍👍👍. Huge respect for them.

    • @JKY2024
      @JKY2024 9 місяців тому +2

      Weird hai bhai

  • @jagannathkujur5292
    @jagannathkujur5292 2 роки тому +20

    "मैं भी भारत"मैं आपके कार्यों का कायाल हूँ। पर आप ‌भी‌ जानते हैं कि आदिवासियों का सरनेम अमूमन पशु-पक्षी, जीव-जंतु, पेड़-पौधों यानि प्राकृति पर ही आधारित होता है। मैं जब ज्यादातर घरो में ब्लैक&व्हाईट टीवी था। तब से "मैं भी भारत को" फाॅलो कर रहा हूँ। शायद आप में भी समय के साथ परिवर्तन आया है।

  • @ranigoraya458
    @ranigoraya458 Рік тому +10

    Marriage is all about maturity n understanding Hati people have ingrained it from generations. Kudos to them 👏 💐

  • @dineshsharma6125
    @dineshsharma6125 2 роки тому +47

    Sensitive topic approached with utmost care. In ancient times polygamy and polyandry both were socially and economically the need of times. I bow my head down to the communities for keeping their old ways alive even the celebrations and all. Wish India gets prosperous and we are able make them rich where they live.

    • @tanvi8854
      @tanvi8854 2 роки тому

      Disgusting

    • @shazainbaloch2538
      @shazainbaloch2538 9 місяців тому +3

      This is mahan Sanatan Dharma 😂😂😂

    • @dhole-qz2st
      @dhole-qz2st 8 місяців тому

      ​@@shazainbaloch2538yes and ....❤

    • @Spreadlight2024
      @Spreadlight2024 Місяць тому

      ​@@shazainbaloch2538
      What is funny?

    • @Spreadlight2024
      @Spreadlight2024 Місяць тому

      ​@@shazainbaloch2538
      Conditions bring unique solutions and it can be abstract to others

  • @prabhanittoppo9663
    @prabhanittoppo9663 2 роки тому +78

    इस जगह देखकर लगता है मानवता ,समरसता, सादगी इस धरती पर और इन आदिवासियों में बसती हैं। इस धरती में मानो यही अप्सराओं का निवास है। यह धरती ही विश्व भर में बंधुआ को बढ़ाने का संदेश दे रहा हैं,जोहार जिंदगी आपको स्नेहिल नमस्कार।

    • @Yashpalishu
      @Yashpalishu 2 роки тому +5

      @Main Bhi Bharat आप सही कह रहे हो और आपकी रिपोर्ट भी सही है, मैं भी इसी क्षेत्र का रहने वाला हूं, बहुपति प्रथा अभी भी इस क्षेत्र में बनी हुई है परंतु इसके उदाहरण अब बहुत कम मिलते हैं, और धीरे-धीरे यह प्रथा समाप्ति की ओर जा रही है!
      बाकी आप मेरी कविताएं भी सुन सकते हैं

    • @jenl787
      @jenl787 2 роки тому +3

      छदम व्यक्ति को क्या पता कि अप्सराएं सिर्फ हिंदू धर्म की उपज है, आदिवासियों में नहीं होती.

    • @satishmankotia1404
      @satishmankotia1404 2 роки тому +7

      Pati ke marene ke baad duniya bina pati ke bhi jivan jitee hai.. Not satisfied with this traditional... Need to educate this society..... Very bad to see such things in HP.

    • @suneelsambyal7602
      @suneelsambyal7602 2 роки тому +7

      Ye tumhye adivasi dikhtye hai 😂😂😂😂

    • @Dreamcatcher0007
      @Dreamcatcher0007 2 роки тому +1

      Ya else hum sab to bewakoofo ki tareh brands ke peeche bhagte rehte Sara Paisa faltu me kharcha kar dete.

  • @abhaypant6722
    @abhaypant6722 6 місяців тому +3

    हां। एक मायने में तो ठीक बात है। द्रौपदी प्रथा से, आज जैसे दौरों में, गांव ज़रुर बच जाएंगे। क्योंकि, एक मर्द घर खेत की देखरेख करने के लिए घर गांव में रह जाएगा जबकि दूसरा बाहर जाकर पैसा कमा कर लाएगा।

  • @statesman01
    @statesman01 2 роки тому +33

    Interesting documentary! The best thing is that no moral judgment is being made on their culture.
    It is obvious that the women shown here seem happy and their marital relationships with their husbands is consensual and not exploitative to the women. Also the men are very mature to love all the children their wives have as their own and not waste time worrying which child belongs to which brother.

    • @navedkhan9007
      @navedkhan9007 2 роки тому +2

      Hypocritical statement.

    • @goofing_
      @goofing_ 9 місяців тому +3

      Better than polygamy I see, where there is bitterness

  • @physicsscenarioclasses9035
    @physicsscenarioclasses9035 2 роки тому +30

    So beautifully narrated the stories of Hatti community. Thanks a lot.

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому +1

      संभोग का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @armpull
      @armpull 9 місяців тому

      Sanatan ki khubsurti

  • @khtsh
    @khtsh 9 місяців тому +16

    My POV
    Let them live freely
    Let them decide what they want
    Let us not create
    Un necessary questions, divisions
    Within them
    If they are happy doing what they
    Are doing,❓
    Then be it.

  • @saranggharde8117
    @saranggharde8117 2 роки тому +10

    Be proud of your identity 🙏🙏🙏 if people feel tradition or customs are no longer needed then they alone should decide whether to continue it or drop it. No exogenous pressure should be put on them.

  • @pradeepsingta6680
    @pradeepsingta6680 2 роки тому +15

    बहुत ही शानदार। अद्भुत जानकारी हाटी समुदाय के बारे में अदभुत जानकारी देने के लिए आपका हार्दिक आभार।।

  • @user-sr4tb7tv6f
    @user-sr4tb7tv6f 7 місяців тому +4

    Beautiful and understanding culture. Another version of Hinduism. Does not feel vulgar at all, unlike the culture of people from peaceful community. Jai Hind ❤

    • @faisalalisyed4354
      @faisalalisyed4354 2 місяці тому +3

      Aapk kare to chamatkaar hum kare to balatkar...!! Gober dimag.!! Polygamy is much scientific than polyandry...!!

    • @user-sr4tb7tv6f
      @user-sr4tb7tv6f 2 місяці тому

      @@faisalalisyed4354 and what about your book. How scientific is it? Ask your brothers going to madarasa

  • @upendrathevlogger
    @upendrathevlogger 2 роки тому +47

    Good videographic representation of these Himachali people. Kudos to you for it. All In 1 RaviRajput is yet another channel that gives you a peep into life of people in villages of Himachal Pradesh.

  • @artipal9272
    @artipal9272 2 роки тому +66

    सत्यता है जमीन का बंटवारा न हो इसलिए यह प्रथा रही है इनको अनुसूचित जनजाति घोषित किया जाना चाहिए 🙏🏼🙏🏼

    • @dadwaal8599
      @dadwaal8599 2 роки тому +3

      कर तो दिया है

    • @happy4981
      @happy4981 2 роки тому +2

      शर्मा को और कितना शर्मा होंगे

    • @pradeepchauhan6112
      @pradeepchauhan6112 9 місяців тому

      Bilkul sahi ye abhi High court me lambit hai
      18 March Tak suna hai decision hoga

    • @criworld007
      @criworld007 8 місяців тому +2

      Sharma he ye log to ye jannjati me kese

  • @rumbum67
    @rumbum67 2 місяці тому +1

    This is actually pretty logical and the people including the presentor are very graceful. Good luck to all!

  • @arunkumarbhattacharya9396
    @arunkumarbhattacharya9396 2 роки тому +94

    This marriage concept is welcome and logical, better than the marriage concept of some other community who is indulge in the marriage of brother -sister which is unscientific.

    • @xyz6124
      @xyz6124 2 роки тому

      Chutiye ye jahalat tujhe nazar nhi aati h

    • @raj97000
      @raj97000 2 роки тому +1

      भाई बहन में शादी करने वाली वो क2वा कौम है
      टोपीबाज पंक्चर चाप , हिंदुस्तान में फ्री की किरायेदार कौम , मुल्ला कौम

    • @anjumfathima9849
      @anjumfathima9849 2 роки тому +23

      it is cousins not brother sister u should be knowing the difference cousins are children of two different parents but the later of the same parents. So talk about others only if u know about it properly don't let your mouth to be a gutter. Bhagvan apko sadbhudhi da

    • @anjumfathima9849
      @anjumfathima9849 2 роки тому +6

      I don't have any problem with this Community it is what they felt is right for them but we should not point at others.

    • @SR-xz7nz
      @SR-xz7nz 2 роки тому +26

      @@anjumfathima9849 cousins are half blooded brother nd sister... So definitely that ultimately leads to inbreeding depression

  • @AnuragMishra-tq6nk
    @AnuragMishra-tq6nk 2 роки тому +12

    Well Explained Report on Hatti People.
    Best Wishes for Hatti brothers and Sisters.

  • @Purvi71237
    @Purvi71237 28 днів тому +1

    Really loved this Pratha, Family ko Bandh ke rakhne ka ek anokha rivaj. ❤❤

    • @Mirror3266
      @Mirror3266 24 дні тому +2

      There is nothing good in this pratha , family ko bandh kar dusray tareko say rakha ja sakta ha yeh rivaj nature kay or jazbaat kay bilkul khilaf ha

  • @shobhadevi8648
    @shobhadevi8648 2 роки тому +93

    मान्यता कोई भी हो लेकिन समाज में एकता बहुत है👍👍

  • @GudduSingh-ww7xr
    @GudduSingh-ww7xr 2 роки тому +17

    वाद्ययंत्र रणसिंघा ,ढोल से स्वागत हो रहा है आप सबका

  • @kumaranand1264
    @kumaranand1264 7 місяців тому

    Your Way of talking to represent our old tradition with move forward with equal respect to tradition and thinking or respectable debate on tradition is awsome

  • @PradeepSingh-fy1ed
    @PradeepSingh-fy1ed 2 роки тому +31

    कुछ चीजें समय पे छोड़ देनी चाहिए
    समय अपने आप हालात सामान्य कर देगा
    आप सभी अपना ज्ञान अपने पास रहने दो... 🤨

    • @Yashpalishu
      @Yashpalishu 2 роки тому +5

      @Main Bhi Bharat आप सही कह रहे हो और आपकी रिपोर्ट भी सही है, मैं भी इसी क्षेत्र का रहने वाला हूं, बहुपति प्रथा अभी भी इस क्षेत्र में बनी हुई है परंतु इसके उदाहरण अब बहुत कम मिलते हैं, और धीरे-धीरे यह प्रथा समाप्ति की ओर जा रही है!
      बाकी आप मेरी कविताएं भी सुन सकते हैं

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому

      ​@@Yashpalishu वहा पे लोगो को जागरूक करो कोई भी ऐसी शादी मत होने दो

  • @anilattwo
    @anilattwo 2 роки тому +68

    दुनिया के किसी भी कोने मे जाओ , हाटी समाज की कुछ अनूठी विशिष्ट प्रथाऐं इस समुदाय को अनूठा और अन्य से अलग बनाती है, 🙏🙏

    • @er.analysisfacts2998
      @er.analysisfacts2998 2 роки тому +1

      same tibet me bhi hai

    • @Dailylifetalkparamshanti
      @Dailylifetalkparamshanti 2 роки тому +2

      @सही है 😀 adivasi jangli ni hota ye... natural jgh pr rahne wale log h...

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому +2

      संभोग का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

  • @tanujsharma8839
    @tanujsharma8839 Місяць тому

    M b himachal se hu kangra distt. se...
    Jb m sirmaur m studies k lie gya tha tb mujhe pehli baar is pratha k waare m pta chla tha...
    M b hairan tha ki aisa b hota hai.

  • @suman49
    @suman49 2 роки тому +25

    चाहे जो भी है,लेकिन इन सब में अच्छा सामंजस्य बना हुआ है,,हम सबको इनकी मान्यताओं का सम्मान करना चाहिए

  • @inderjitsing4439
    @inderjitsing4439 2 роки тому +48

    खुबसूरत !किसी सरकार को इनकी परम्पराओं में दखल देने की जरूरत नहीं !

    • @ALS9
      @ALS9 6 місяців тому

      ईसी लिये कॉमन सिविल लॉ की जरूरत है हिंदू धर्म को😅😅😅😅

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому

      तुम अपना लो ये प्रथा 10 लड़के पैदा करो और एक ही लड़की से करदो जिसमे तुम्हारी बेटी भी तो होगी

    • @amrapali-gs3co
      @amrapali-gs3co 3 місяці тому

      Ye parampara hai??

    • @mehra764
      @mehra764 3 місяці тому

      ​@@ALS9uniform civil law a
      Ane do phir ye 2 kaudi ke adivasi bhagenge😂😂
      Jai shree ram

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 2 місяці тому

      @@amrapali-gs3co सामाजिक बलात्कार है समाज की मर्जी से ये गैंगरेप कहलाएगा एक पत्नी और पांच छः पति

  • @ramsware9581
    @ramsware9581 9 місяців тому +9

    अति सुंदर भारत की संस्कृति संभाल के रखे यह बहुत बढ़िया पड़ता है इससे विधवा होने का डर नहीं रहता है बहुत अच्छी पड़ता है

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому

      Tum apni patni ki shadi apne Bhai or khud se kar Lena thik hai vaise kitne bhayi hai 2,4,10 कितने भी हो कोई nhi kya huaa thik to hai

  • @kanikagulati8028
    @kanikagulati8028 2 роки тому +59

    Surprisingly logical 👏🏻
    If all the partners in the marriage are honestly comfortable and agreed to this then it can work...it is working actually 👍🏻

    • @chetanjaiswal8910
      @chetanjaiswal8910 2 роки тому

      How

    • @kanikagulati8028
      @kanikagulati8028 2 роки тому +6

      @@chetanjaiswal8910 video is very well explaining the same

    • @r.k3261
      @r.k3261 2 роки тому +13

      Lol it's totally illogical

    • @samkharra8502
      @samkharra8502 2 роки тому +1

      Is anyone who agree to marry two boys at the same time...(girl)

    • @samkharra8502
      @samkharra8502 2 роки тому +1

      And how do you they are honest and agreed etc

  • @pradeepsingta6680
    @pradeepsingta6680 2 роки тому +31

    पांडवों वाली प्रथा हाटी समुदाय में व्याप्त है। किन्नौर, लाहौल, पांगी में ओर अन्य क्षेत्र में भी व्याप्त है।।

    • @shivshakti1056
      @shivshakti1056 2 роки тому +12

      पांडवों कि कोइ प्रथा नहीं थी अपनी मां की वचन का पालन करना पडा था उनको मजबुरी में फालतू में अपने लालच को प्रथा का नाम ना दो औरत बट जाय पर जमीन ना बटे वाह हद है😈😈😈😈

    • @user-go9kw6wf4m
      @user-go9kw6wf4m 2 роки тому

      @@shivshakti1056 no read real man don't watch TV serials....draupadi got vardaan from lord Shiva that she will get 5 husbands in next birth. And polyandry was common at that time .

    • @handmadediystudio7862
      @handmadediystudio7862 2 роки тому

      @@shivshakti1056 shi bola apne aur aurat bhi kh rhi ki 2 hone jruri ek ko kuch ho jaye to wah y kya logic h

  • @sushhiii
    @sushhiii 16 днів тому +1

    Idk why but it is looking so normal to me at this age.. I would have looked at it from different angle few years back..

  • @SaurabhPathak23
    @SaurabhPathak23 2 роки тому +50

    I think these communities are the essence of Bharatiya culture and are unique. We are in a way out siders and should not interfere in their mattes. It is time that so called modern humans start respecting other ways of life, because this modern world and the western culture has brough us at such a juncture in human history where we are struggling to survive. These indigenous communities have survived through difficult time in history and time has come where each so called modern human (like us) should find ways of coexistence rather then molding them into ours.

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @rahulmittal9875
      @rahulmittal9875 2 роки тому +7

      Perfectly fine, but I can't imagine sharing my wife with my brother.

    • @saptakmukherjee7615
      @saptakmukherjee7615 2 роки тому +4

      @@rahulmittal9875 then don't. Who asked you to share your wife with your brother?

    • @thomasfookingshelby8194
      @thomasfookingshelby8194 2 роки тому +3

      Aur agar yahi kam ek aadmi Kare to patriarchy. Hypocrisy ki bhi Seema Hoti hai

    • @samruddhisandvar1807
      @samruddhisandvar1807 2 роки тому

      This is not Bharatiya culture.This is adultery in the name of cultures!! I don't support neither polygamy nor polyandery. Most of indian modern women should not. Both are male dominating policies.Where men are superior.where ever they feel comfortable they grab the opportunity.The laws should be neutral. There are lots of pratha like sathi and Johar pratha which has come to an end.This pratha should also come to an end.This is happening because in remote areas women are not educated. Men force them to undergo such pratha in the name of culture. Having multiple partners might lead to various diseases. And I am sure many men might be mently very upset if they used to see there brothers sharing there wife in name of marriage.Male dominating society has made the rules as per their convenience in name of culture be it draupadi pratha or pogamy !!Hindu marriage act has abolished polygamy. Draupadi pratha is also not legal."modern world has given us lots of education,knowlege" educated person or,knowledgeable don't struggle in terms of monetry.There are category of people who do lust they suffer!! India has good population what is there to share partners.

  • @ssahasramorganics7664
    @ssahasramorganics7664 2 роки тому +10

    Three things are very important in these discussions
    1. Tradition
    2. Financial necessity
    3. Social security
    All three are important in remote areas specially if the family is based on agriculture
    Practice of dowry was also based on similar logic that the land should not get divided - girl takes her share in form of gold and cash leaving the land for the brother who is to stay back and look after parents
    I think if everyone agrees, then this Practice - draupadi prathaa - can provide a lady with Social security and make the family truly well-knit, stable and sustainable but as stated by Vikram - this Practice needs a lot of understanding and adjustment both by the males and the female

    • @Inner.divinity
      @Inner.divinity 2 роки тому

      What about morality? How moral is it to share wife with brother or any other person ? It looks like a very primitive and barbaric custom, morally not acceptable by today's standard of morality..

    • @ssahasramorganics7664
      @ssahasramorganics7664 2 роки тому +2

      @@Inner.divinity - we all know how moral are today's so called "modern day" men and women - Chaubay jee please check some modern terms like dating apps, threesome, wife swap, group s*x, cuckold and cougars, Gay lesbian marriages, Poolside/ farm house orgy - let me tell you, in our country and in most modern countries in the world they are not even punishable offense under law.
      Please don't try to judge simple rural cultures because often those who shout about morality at the top of their voice are most immoral in their secret personal life - 70% adult men and 30% adult women of India visits pornography sites regularly to watch others - let's not forget our own faults.

    • @Inner.divinity
      @Inner.divinity 2 роки тому

      @@ssahasramorganics7664 well..some of those things you mentioned are only acceptable to some morally depraved , perverted people , not to the majority.. i don't think most common people ever dare to experiment with such things in life..there is difference between watching weird stuffs in porn and practicing those things in life

    • @ssahasramorganics7664
      @ssahasramorganics7664 2 роки тому +1

      @@Inner.divinity jee - I would have been very happy if what you "think" about our "modern society" would have been correct but - research and statistics 😀 tells us a different story. I am not talking of the western world - let me furnish Indian data - its from net - so anyone can check
      Nearly 78.2% males are still unmarried when they have their first sex and 60% of them before they have completed their high school level education.
      Mean age of first sex was 21.1 years in males and 18.6 years in females and 17.6% were practicing risky sexual behavior.
      Homosexuality was observed in 33.4% men. Furthermore, 13.1% had exposure to commercial sex workers.
      Prevalence of sexually transmitted disease was 8.7%.
      50% school going girls get sexually harassed in India
      Most sexual harassment is NOT on streets but at home by relatives
      The overall condom usage at least once was reported only by 23.5% adolescents - means below 18 years. Complete knowledge about condom usage was found to be very low 8%.
      Another study on unmarried adolescent girls show these results -
      Out of the 320 adolescents presented to the OPD, only 165 consented to participate in the study. Prevalence of sexual activity was 16.9% (28/165) in the study. Eight (8/165) adolescent girls have not attained menarche and all were not having any knowledge of sex. Three girls were the victims of sexual exploitation. Around 64% of these girls were sexually active with their classmates. All the sexually active females were having intercourse through the vaginal route, however non-vaginal route was also practiced by 6 girls. Home (11, 39%) was the preferred place followed by the hotel (10, 35.7%) for sexual activity.
      All these studies apart - I am a doctor in private practice - leave alone married or unmarried women coming for abortion after unwanted sex with partners outside marriage - our hospital is approached by even school girls coming in their uniforms - as young as 14-16 requesting for an abortion paying from the money given bu parents for buying clothes or shoes - "doctor uncle safari karwa deejiye - Birthday pe paise milenge to payment kar doongi" - we oblige because if we say no - they either go to quacks risking their lives or commit suicide.

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

  • @s.hdurrani3392
    @s.hdurrani3392 3 місяці тому +2

    1. Best option to keep population down.
    2. Little stress on administration on food supply.
    3. Keep divisions of inheritance to minimum.
    Thus was also there in sikh religion before 1850

  • @yashpalmahajan9070
    @yashpalmahajan9070 2 роки тому +122

    I am also Himachali and belong to village Kotla in district Kangra Himachal Pradesh. I think with the development of education system and employment opportunities in our country this system is not practical these days. Each and every girl and boy should have liberty to marry as per his or her wish This is the need of hour. 🙏

    • @lopu8000
      @lopu8000 2 роки тому +6

      Kangra is not real Himachal . Real Himachal upper hai 😅

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому +2

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @rahulmittal9875
      @rahulmittal9875 2 роки тому +3

      @@lopu8000 school ni gya tu?

    • @lopu8000
      @lopu8000 2 роки тому +1

      @@rahulmittal9875 😂 ask anyone from Shimla what is old Himachal . Kangra was added later in 66

    • @rahulmittal9875
      @rahulmittal9875 2 роки тому +8

      @@lopu8000 ok, so Bharat is not a country for you before 1947 right?
      Himachal is Himachal my love, what is real or fake Himachal even within every district there is too much diversity, all we need to develop our attitude towards unity man!

  • @bornfreetreks
    @bornfreetreks 2 роки тому +15

    Have seen such families,they r quite comfortable with the set up....

  • @satendratiwari6097
    @satendratiwari6097 9 місяців тому +27

    इस प्रथा से फायदा यह है कि बिधवा शब्द शब्दकोश से हट जाऐगा , परंपरा का स्वागत है।

    • @thegame3265
      @thegame3265 8 місяців тому

      Yes..

    • @s.tmusicworld3930
      @s.tmusicworld3930 5 місяців тому

      Vidhva मतलब आज के समय में बिना विधवा हुए भी अकेले औरत रैहती है पागल कहिके समलैंगिक विवाह कार्लो सारे भाई मिले संपति का बटवारा nhi होगा 😅 स्वागत है वाह लगता तुमने अपनी बहन बेटी के लिए एक nhi 10,25 pati ढूंढे hai बढ़िया है बेरोजगार होगी तो एक दो मर भी जायेंगे तो बाकी है न ख्याल रखने के लिए

    • @mehra764
      @mehra764 3 місяці тому +1

      Ha sir to aap apne ghar me ye kab kr rhe ho

    • @hamaidmk
      @hamaidmk Місяць тому

      ji nhin

  • @ananyaakap
    @ananyaakap 2 роки тому +9

    Very beautiful and well balanced report! I'd love to interview or do journalism like the smart lady reporter. ✨

  • @Potatomatoo
    @Potatomatoo 2 роки тому +13

    Really well made documentry. Really liked the way it was done

  • @pratibhapande9748
    @pratibhapande9748 8 місяців тому

    ये परंपरा जिला सिरमौर में अभी तक है इस प्रथा के बहुत सारे फायदे भी हैं और बहुत नुकसान भी है। आपने इस को बहुत अच्छी तरह कवर किया है,, यदि दो या तीन भाई में शेयरिंग है तो बच्चे अलग अलग पिता को ट्रांसफर कर देते हैं,,

  • @Geeta_sinku
    @Geeta_sinku 2 роки тому +7

    Beautiful India..and beautiful our tribal people 🥰.......nice video with lots of information 🙏...

  • @satishdikshit7621
    @satishdikshit7621 2 роки тому +22

    Very well explained 👏.
    It seems that passage of time and education among this community will see community members will forget
    and will adopt the prevalent system of marriage in Hinduism.
    I strongly feel that they must be given complete liberty.to decide .

    • @gurunathpai3443
      @gurunathpai3443 2 роки тому +1

      In course of time this community . Will gradually shed customs prevalent in Haiti society and willassimilate Hindu custom . .

    • @flyinggirl7886
      @flyinggirl7886 2 роки тому +5

      @@gurunathpai3443 this practice is based in Hindu culture. Draupadi in Mahabharata was not Christian 😂

    • @nazeerpasha2075
      @nazeerpasha2075 7 місяців тому

      @@gurunathpai3443 At least these tribals are saving and practicing the ancient Indian tradition.
      It is not just a tribal culture, but continuation of ancient Indian tradition. In Indian classics Darupadi was married to five Pandu brothers.

  • @Preet.Manvi.Chauhan.2593
    @Preet.Manvi.Chauhan.2593 8 місяців тому +2

    दो रिश्तों में तीन ठीक है। समझ के लिए साझा रखना अवश्य है।🎉❤

  • @dariusneidhart1068
    @dariusneidhart1068 2 роки тому +10

    Amazed at the comments being so encouraging and appreciative to this horrendous practice.

    • @KiranChauhan-o8b
      @KiranChauhan-o8b Рік тому +5

      It's not horrendous, sitting in a privileged place and educated background can give you the audacity of saying this, but this practice has not been forcefully imposed on anyone be it men or women, in older times this practice was to keep their financial and Family relationships better , the reason why joint family doesn't exist is because of the dispute between women of their homes , this people used to believe that if one husbands passes the wife shouldn't be the one to face any problem and should be living a normal life and the other things they didn't wanted division in their land

    • @reallyglad
      @reallyglad 9 місяців тому

      What's not forced seems right to people. If it were ince*st. They'll have the same response too. Smh

    • @shantanubhatt6576
      @shantanubhatt6576 8 місяців тому +5

      A man marrying 4 wives! Does it ring any bell? Nobody finds that Horrendous? It is a practice of that tribe and will slowly eradicate. Till then keep open and objective mind. Polyandry is very rare nobody is telling u to celebrate it but if people are not ashamed of polygamy then they should not find polyandry horrendous.

    • @AK.AK.12
      @AK.AK.12 8 місяців тому

      @@shantanubhatt6576yeah, most civilised people with a functioning brain consider it bad

    • @shantanubhatt6576
      @shantanubhatt6576 8 місяців тому

      @@AK.AK.12 ask muslim nations, they are proud of polygamy. Polyandry is vanishing slowly but polygamy is very much allowed in islamic nations. Unless you don't consider them as civilised.

  • @maheshchalva1796
    @maheshchalva1796 2 роки тому +6

    We don't need to be judgemental about unique practices of communities nd social groups,these things evolve over thousands of years,trying to live in harmony with nature nd society...
    Let them live they want,we should appreciate their efforts in maintaining their way of life,as they don't harm others in any way nor are they bad influence on others ...let's celebrate every communities lives nd practices 🙏

    • @EV-EV-EV
      @EV-EV-EV Рік тому +1

      We must judge what triggers disgust

  • @ashishkumarsamu3958
    @ashishkumarsamu3958 7 місяців тому +1

    कोई समाज जो अभी भी ऐसी किसी भी तरह की प्रथा से जूझ रहा है तो उसके पीछे का सिर्फ एक कारण है अशिक्षा। अभी तक उस समाज में शिक्षा नहीं पहुंची या किसी ने वहा शिक्षा पहुंचाने की कोशिश नहीं की। बल्कि उन्हें उसी जंजीर के जकड़न को मजबूत करने का काम किया है। अब जागने की जरूरत है🙏

  • @gayaramtandon9298
    @gayaramtandon9298 2 роки тому +8

    जो भी प्रथा है स्थानीय और देश काल के हिसाब से है,ईस तरह के रीति रिवाज को बाहरी दुनिया शायद ही मान्यता दे! " मैं भी भारत" इस चैनल को देखता हूं और प्रिय भी है,जिससे जहाँ पर हम जाना चाहे तो दो चार जगह छोड़ बाकी जगह पर नही पहुच पाएंगे। लेकिन एक बात अवश्य कहना चाहूंगा कि भाइयों और बहनों के (बाहरी दुनिया के हिसाब से) चेहरे को नही दिखाना था।

  • @kratos-le9gp
    @kratos-le9gp 2 роки тому +26

    M from this hatti community of Himachal pradesh....and I feel very proud on our tradition....our culture is more rich than u can even imagine...and this is a slap to those who says that two brother cant live peacefully.....and in case of polyandry it's the choice of a girl to marry whom she wants...there is no force marriage for the girls in our culture

    • @aayushdhiman8915
      @aayushdhiman8915 2 роки тому +6

      Then why people of India are against multiple marriage in Islam?? Even if it's her choice it's still barbaric and needs to change. I am ashamed that this kind of thing is still happening in Himachal Pradesh. It's the first time I felt ashamed to be a Himachali.

    • @kratos-le9gp
      @kratos-le9gp 2 роки тому +11

      @@aayushdhiman8915 ask from those woman who are suffering from the outcome of triple talak.....they have no place to go after their talak.....if u feel ashamed then either u r not from the Himachal or just transferred to Himachal who don't understand the culture of pahadis.....

    • @kratos-le9gp
      @kratos-le9gp 2 роки тому

      @@aayushdhiman8915 jiski ladki k 2 husband hai usse puch Jake ki r u happy or not...wo bataegi aapni puri kahani....whi pe jake un aurat se puch Jake jo triple talak se peedit hai

    • @kratos-le9gp
      @kratos-le9gp 2 роки тому

      @@adventurerr4558 aab jiska dimak lund me hoga wo to karega hi aesi baat

    • @kratos-le9gp
      @kratos-le9gp 2 роки тому +1

      @@adventurerr4558 iska jawab bhi video me hai....aache se suna hota to aabhi ye baat ni kar rha hota.

  • @PardeepFromShivaliks
    @PardeepFromShivaliks Рік тому +1

    These practices can be understandable in remote areas where we don't see any development or the very backward areas.
    But if someone like Hatti community is doing these practices in 2023 then it is very bad thing.
    The new hatti generation should stand against this practice.
    Its our duty to root out these malpractices.
    Dhanyawad
    Jai Hind

  • @YogeshSharma-dz7cj
    @YogeshSharma-dz7cj 2 роки тому +16

    A sensitive topic has been dealt with lot of maturity. Good job!
    As they say in the end. There is nothing to be ashamed about. If there can be Pandavs and Draupadi, then why not Hattis?😊

    • @tanvi8854
      @tanvi8854 2 роки тому +1

      Disgusting

    • @rims1104
      @rims1104 2 роки тому +2

      Then think about the health of those women when they suffer from multiple infections in their body or may be HIV due to multiple intimacy with different husbands. It's a serious issue where nobody is talking about in this entire comment section.

    • @sulekhagupta9019
      @sulekhagupta9019 Рік тому +1

      ​@@rims1104hiv can happen only if any one of the partners has it before. If 3/4 people are in a physical relationship HIV cannot happen

    • @fai3379
      @fai3379 Місяць тому

      ​@@sulekhagupta9019Exactly these people worry about sexual health of these people..But atleast this one woman has many husband.
      But if a woman has a cheater has husband
      Who knows he may sexual relationships with so many women,

  • @sunderlalchaudhary9597
    @sunderlalchaudhary9597 2 роки тому +15

    I respect and love this very nice community by heart and Soule
    I strongly appeal that haatti community should follow this joint family system for ever. No crime, no court cases and no family quarrel and every member of this community getting respect and living happy life.

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @ManjuSharma-ye8ww
      @ManjuSharma-ye8ww Рік тому

      You are right sir

  • @prakashmungekar3119
    @prakashmungekar3119 23 дні тому

    Let us respect all culture. Very nice narration. Thanks for sharing.

  • @kamnadhruw903
    @kamnadhruw903 2 роки тому +79

    सर🙏 मैं एक आदिवासी युवक छत्तीसगढ से, आपसे निवेदन है कि एक बार और आप यहा पधारे मेरे से जितना हो सकेगा आपको और स्थानीय आदिवासी से रहन सहन और अनेक पारंपरिक गुम हो चुकी, व्यंजनों से परिचित उन्हीं के बीच मे ले जाकर अनुभव करा सकू मेरा सौभाग्य होगा.... आपका छोटा भाई! 🙏🙏🙏

    • @itisalife2302
      @itisalife2302 2 роки тому +2

      Apna contect no.do..

    • @ज्ञानध्यानमोक्ष
      @ज्ञानध्यानमोक्ष 2 роки тому +3

      Aapki apni sanskriti ko jeevit rakhne ki dharna ati prashansniy hai 🙏🏻🙏🏻 app jaise logon ki Sanatan Sanskriti ko ati aavshyakta hai 🙏🏻🙏🏻

    • @AmarjitSingh-gs9un
      @AmarjitSingh-gs9un 2 роки тому

      @@ज्ञानध्यानमोक्ष .7

    • @gajshardul320
      @gajshardul320 2 роки тому +2

      हमु मन chhattisgarghiya अवं जी तोरे सगा पोर्टे त्

    • @thegodfather2271
      @thegodfather2271 2 роки тому +1

      😊🙏 जय हिन्द भाई 🚩🚩

  • @amritanegi1350
    @amritanegi1350 2 роки тому +39

    Very nice vlog 🙏🏼🙏🏼this is the tribal culture and we should feel proud to be a part of this 🌹✌️

    • @juicy11
      @juicy11 2 роки тому +2

      But weird. How you gonna know who's kids are who's.

    • @athleticprogram
      @athleticprogram 2 роки тому +6

      @@juicy11 one month is given to each brother with wife. To understand it better read about menstural cycles and how they are sure whose kid it is. If you are thinking about ORG y, they don’t do it.

    • @juicy11
      @juicy11 2 роки тому

      @@athleticprogram you gonna do the same ?? I thought muslims are weird but this one is more ridiculous.

    • @athleticprogram
      @athleticprogram 2 роки тому

      @@juicy11 I am a single child and if it was a custom in my part of Himachal, I wouldn’t oppose it.

    • @athleticprogram
      @athleticprogram 2 роки тому

      @@singeronwheelsrahul abe chu ti ye tabhi bolte hai ki padh likh lo, 2 baap ka ka bhi bhi 1 baccha nahi ho sakta. Or tujhe kyon problem ho rahi hai teri maa behen ko toh nahi kar rahe hai yeh. Is Desh ko tum jaise youtubers hi barbad karenge, na aand ka na gaand ka par gyan chodana hai brahmand ka.

  • @Sania34522
    @Sania34522 8 місяців тому +2

    India is a diverse country. Government must be give freedom to people to live their life happily and dont force one rule on all.. whether its polygamy or polyandry......but its must not be forcefully

  • @jyotishimanish6941
    @jyotishimanish6941 2 роки тому +74

    हाटि समाज के लोगों को मेरी हार्दिक शुभकामनाएं, आप अपने परंपरा पर अटल रहे, जय श्रीराम।

    • @sweetdoll137
      @sweetdoll137 2 роки тому +3

      Shi keh rhe ho ap

    • @shwetaverma7546
      @shwetaverma7546 2 роки тому +2

      To aisi prampra apne ghr pr Hui shuru kr de agr apko itni psnd a rhi h ye prampra jo bol rhe h atal rhe , apni patni ki bhi apne bhai se kra do shadi

    • @jyotishimanish6941
      @jyotishimanish6941 2 роки тому +3

      @@shwetaverma7546 , हमारे समाज में विभिन्न स्थानों पर अलग अलग परम्परा का प्रचलन है अगर उन्हें को समस्या या आपत्ति नहीं है तो भला हमें उनके व्यक्तिगत विषयों पर हस्तक्षेप करने का कोई अधिकार नहीं बनता है। धन्यवाद

    • @jyotishimanish6941
      @jyotishimanish6941 2 роки тому +1

      @@sweetdoll137 धन्यवाद

    • @sweetdoll137
      @sweetdoll137 2 роки тому +1

      @@shwetaverma7546
      Ye kya bat hui madam
      Tamiz se bat kre phle to
      Dunia me bht kuch hota hai jo universal accept nhi kia ja skta
      Wat do u mean apne ghar me bhi shuru kr de
      Ye ek janjati hai or sbhi janjatio ki kuch apni alg parmpare hoti hai
      Jra janjatio k bare me thoda padh lena fir akr bakwas karna

  • @HPVillagevibes
    @HPVillagevibes 2 роки тому +16

    Now people of this region are educated and changing mindset of others bringing them in to mainstream thereby changing traditional practices.Quality of Basic education in area is increasing, Digitally connecting with rest of world.

    • @deepikajishtu4494
      @deepikajishtu4494 2 роки тому +4

      Quality of education is always good in Himachal … yee ek prataha hai … joo yee log nibha rhe hai even ki mere purwaaj bhi yaahi pratha nibhate the

    • @satya007satya
      @satya007satya 2 роки тому +5

      What is mainstream if not farming and village ? Stocks, tv , media , UA-cam, crypto 😂 is this mainstream ?

    • @bornspecial2147
      @bornspecial2147 2 роки тому +2

      Mainstream? Why should one always think that theirs is a better thing? There are definitely some benefits of what they follow and if these people are happy with what they have they need not change their ways to fit in others.

    • @deepikajishtu4494
      @deepikajishtu4494 2 роки тому +1

      @@bornspecial2147 so true people should understand this but here are few bhudi jivi those who can’t understand the world means happiness and mind your own business and your own religion

    • @rajubhaivyas1450
      @rajubhaivyas1450 2 роки тому

      @@deepikajishtu4494 ye... baat ko.. except karne...me.. aur khulkar ke sab ke saamne likhit...me (writing)me rakhne ke liye bhot bada saaf Dil ❤️,swasth dimag, aur himmat aur Gurde me daam hona chahiye 🙏🏻💐 jo..aap me beshak hai 🙏🏻💐 Mai aap ko... pranam 🙏🏻 aur abhinandan Karta hu... kyonki jyadatar insaan,mard, Aurat sabhi log...suchhyi se.. Katra te hai 🙄... aur muh mod...lete hai 🙏🏻 Jay Hind 🙏🏻 vande matram 🙏🏻💐

  • @sharmin_hpoetries4035
    @sharmin_hpoetries4035 9 місяців тому +1

    I am amazed at how positive the reactions are in comment section just because they belong to hindu community. Then why do muslims get so much hate for polygamy. I watched a movie called bhrina which was based on this topic and it showed the dark reality of this practice.

  • @robb2024
    @robb2024 2 роки тому +15

    I think this community keep continue their practices without anybody's intervene not even Indian government. Their special marriage system is the symbol of unity. They are following the way of Pancha Pandavas and Draupadi. I support their culture and polyandry.

    • @Justices526
      @Justices526 8 місяців тому +1

      What muslims should not follow polygamy

  • @shridharvyas1511
    @shridharvyas1511 2 роки тому +109

    यह प्रथा नारी को ज्यादा सम्मान दिलाती है साथ में परिवार के स्थायित्व और उसकी संपन्नता को सुनिश्चित करती है भाइयों में बंटवारे की समस्या का निदान हो जाता है अगर यह प्रथा यहां पर सामाजिक मान्यता प्राप्त है तो इसे निश्चित रूप से चलते रहना चाहिए

    • @learnersparadise7492
      @learnersparadise7492 2 роки тому

      अरे मंदबुद्धि, परिवार में झगड़े हमेशा जऱ जोरू और जमीन को लेकर के होती है, यह तो लड़ाई बढ़ने की संभावना और ज्यादा हो जाती है क्योंकि जोरू एक है तो एक ही जोरु पे सारे अपने अपने हक जताएंगे और आपस में लड़ेंगे। प्रॉब्लम तो खत्म नहीं होती, यह कुरीति है जो चली आ रही है जो भाभी समाज मां के साथ देवर का दुष्कर्म होता है ऐसा कहीं उचित नहीं है। कुरीतियां खत्म होनी चाहिए और तुम कह रहे हो कि इसे रखना चाहिए।

    • @SBH3356
      @SBH3356 2 роки тому +24

      Seriously? A woman is expected to marry all brothers and she will be expected to bear every man a kid. What if there are more than 2 brothers? The only benefit I see in this tradition is that it solves the issue of property division for few generations.but I don't see it as woman emancipation in any way. Just for the sake of tradition she has to marry both brothers not out of her own choice

    • @arunkumarbhattacharya9396
      @arunkumarbhattacharya9396 2 роки тому +3

      I agree with u

    • @imsilent7405
      @imsilent7405 2 роки тому +6

      @@SBH3356 mam. it is also followed in all part of the world but not openly. behind the curtain all this hatti traditions are followed in many part of world.

    • @SBH3356
      @SBH3356 2 роки тому +10

      @@imsilent7405 like where? Am interested in knowing. Till now I haven't seen any woman with more than 2 husbands in my part of the country. 1 is too much to put up with 🤣

  • @rizwanmallick4884
    @rizwanmallick4884 3 місяці тому

    Madam, bahot informative aur well worded program hai. Writer ne topic ke sath bahot insaf kia! Bus kabhi kabhi unfamiliar hindi lafz/shabad use kerke , non-hindi speaking ke liye samajhna mushkil ker dia. Overall easy to understand raha. Compliments for info. Provided.

  • @rdjoshi4635
    @rdjoshi4635 2 роки тому +24

    i love this cultural.... so beautiful .

    • @anil6191
      @anil6191 2 роки тому +4

      Apni patni se b puchle kya pta mann jaye wo b ap b follow kre itna acha lga h to

    • @dineshsharma6125
      @dineshsharma6125 2 роки тому +1

      @@anil6191 Idiot, it is an old and socio-economic requirement of such people. We in cities won't understand. I have utmost respect for these people and their old ways. They will move on over time.

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

    • @rishidevdhurwey2229
      @rishidevdhurwey2229 Рік тому

      @@anil6191 kyo ladke ker sakte hai ladkiya nahi

    • @EV-EV-EV
      @EV-EV-EV Рік тому +2

      ​@@rishidevdhurwey2229yes true, now go share your wife

  • @graceneupane5235
    @graceneupane5235 2 роки тому +19

    If a male can keep two or three wives together then why can’t a women keep two or more husband together. Good example of male and female equality.

    • @EV-EV-EV
      @EV-EV-EV Рік тому

      Because it's disgusting when a woman does it

    • @aminjawad7112
      @aminjawad7112 Місяць тому +1

      How will you decide father of the child born...will the woman be able to satisfy more than one man sexually.....what about sex when she is full time pregnant or when she has menses.....

    • @fai3379
      @fai3379 Місяць тому

      ​@@aminjawad7112In many communities which polyandry had there was tribe customs,tradition
      They did not engaje in sexual relationship while preganant and while she was in her periods.
      Sometimes polygamy also allowed,
      And when it come to father if fraternal polyandry elder brother consider as father,anyway same clan and same family name.
      There may be their traditiona if it non fraternal.

    • @aminjawad7112
      @aminjawad7112 Місяць тому

      @@fai3379 I can prove that in Nepal and Himachal Pradesh polyandry is practised with sexual relations...even in Haryana where male female ratio is skewed more than one male shares a female obviously for sexual gratification

  • @volcano24
    @volcano24 6 місяців тому +3

    ये प्रथा ठीक है। जमीन ही नहीं रहेगी तो लोग क्या खायेंगे पीएंगे और रहेंगे कहां।जनसंख्या नियन्त्रण की दिशा में यह प्रथा ठीक थी।

  • @RandhirSingh-fe3yv
    @RandhirSingh-fe3yv 2 роки тому +12

    I am in favour of your tradition.From Haryana.

  • @amarsinghbutola4987
    @amarsinghbutola4987 Рік тому +1

    सभी की संस्कृति का सामान होना चाहिए संस्कृति का विकास आवश्यकता व भौगोलिक परिवेश के साथ विकसित होती है

  • @sonusukla5654
    @sonusukla5654 2 роки тому +18

    भाई सनातन वैदिक धर्म मे हर जातियों का अपना अपना देवता, अपना अपना प्रथा, परम्परा होता है, सबका 100% सम्मान होना चाहिए🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏

    • @technomtk509
      @technomtk509 Рік тому +2

      Tu bhai, 3 talak or Muslim riti riwaz mai kyu tang lad ate ho aur keh rahe ho sanantani sanaskriti sabaka saman karti hai

    • @a.a.jamadar7841
      @a.a.jamadar7841 Рік тому

      😂

    • @a.a.jamadar7841
      @a.a.jamadar7841 Рік тому +1

      🚩🚩 "" सनातन "" ये कोई वैदीक धर्म नहीं है !! सनातन का मतलब .....पुराना ऐसा होता है !! 🚩🚩

    • @sonusukla5654
      @sonusukla5654 Рік тому +1

      @@a.a.jamadar7841 सनातन का मतलब होता है सबसे पुराना, कभी भी खत्म न होने वाला, सबको साथ लेकर चलने वाला

    • @NagendraKSahu
      @NagendraKSahu Рік тому +1

      सही प्रश्न
      ये ब्राह्मण
      हर हिंदू बुराई की रक्षा करने में आगे आ जाते है
      जब बात मुस्लिम से तुलना की हो तो

  • @sakuradey6271
    @sakuradey6271 2 роки тому +16

    I wish I were in Himachal's haiti community, sounds perfect.

    • @MrSam-mg5ut
      @MrSam-mg5ut 2 роки тому +7

      U can ask ur brother to share wife. Don’t need to be Haati

    • @sakuradey6271
      @sakuradey6271 2 роки тому

      @@MrSam-mg5ut My brother's experiences are not same as mine, get some brains may be? Oh and along with some IQ, expand your self-worth that you don't have to go around commenting random women. You can keep yours locked in BurQAAAAAAAAAAAAAA no one gives a shit.

    • @anil6191
      @anil6191 2 роки тому +3

      @@MrSam-mg5ut yes and i can be his brother

    • @rajubhaivyas1450
      @rajubhaivyas1450 2 роки тому +1

      Sakura Dey 🙏🏻💐... Dhanyawad 🙏🏻 Kafi himmat wala statement hai 🙏🏻 Jay Hind 🙏🏻 vande matram 🙏🏻💐

    • @gsnarayanan
      @gsnarayanan 2 роки тому

      संभोग SEX का अद्भुद प्रोग्राम कभ कभ और कैसे कैसे अरेंज करते हैं ये लोग, इसका भी क्लैरिटी होना चाहिए. कोन कभ चढ़ सकता हैं वगेरा etc etc. या सभ को मिल झूल के सात सात करना पढ़ता है. PLZZ can you explain........

  • @shivanimanna8645
    @shivanimanna8645 3 місяці тому

    Isse pta chlta h ki smaj mn jo prachalit hota h jo sbhi krte hn veh shi hojata h❤🙏

  • @pradeepsir3375
    @pradeepsir3375 2 роки тому +23

    EDUCATION..gives the logic
    What about the emotional bonding
    What happened if woman died?
    Jodi means bond of love in man and woman.

    • @harigyan782
      @harigyan782 2 роки тому +12

      If a women die they can marry again. But if a one man died woman will not be widow and alive brother other husband will take equal responsibility. These tribes consider Pandavs as there ancestors. Woman place is high in family society. In this tribes Woman's permission /guidance is must for every major decision.

    • @lifeybliss613
      @lifeybliss613 2 роки тому +13

      @@harigyan782 sheer non sense this is.. if the husband die, a woman can also remarry if she wishes too.

    • @vishwajeet1089
      @vishwajeet1089 2 роки тому +2

      Idk why questions are not raised when a man can married multiple wives

  • @uvrajpratap5723
    @uvrajpratap5723 2 роки тому +9

    अब यह प्रथा पूरे भारत मैं बहुत तेजी से बड़ रही हैं 🧐🧐🧐

  • @PhoolSinghpalPhoolSinghpal-e9c
    @PhoolSinghpalPhoolSinghpal-e9c Місяць тому

    प्रिय सज्जनों आपकी महानता को नमन करता हूं ❤🎉

  • @sharmasaphire8077
    @sharmasaphire8077 2 роки тому +5

    We r proud of our culture and custom,our ladies hv more right then feminist flag bearer.she can choose her husband one or multiple.she can marry multiple time without judging her character.she can be the boss of house,and order her children and husband's to support her in household works.All the things comes up with cost,yes polyandry also hv some demerits.But it is beneficial also in this type of geography.

    • @EV-EV-EV
      @EV-EV-EV Рік тому

      I love how Hinduism celebrates cuckoldry

  • @shaileshpal8671
    @shaileshpal8671 2 роки тому +41

    For the lady it's a backup husband and for men it's avoidance of dividing the resources. Not bad idea!! it can be considered for normal Indian as well if agreed upon.

    • @kaurk6127
      @kaurk6127 2 роки тому +6

      Ewwww never

    • @lenovodolby7517
      @lenovodolby7517 2 роки тому +2

      Not happening brother...

    • @anil6191
      @anil6191 2 роки тому +3

      To fir ap b follow ye culture

    • @lilmuffin9253
      @lilmuffin9253 2 роки тому +2

      Yess make it normal

    • @lopu8000
      @lopu8000 2 роки тому

      @@kaurk6127 guruan diyan vi more than one wife ci