Beyond the Supernatural Horror of the Nishi Daak Ghost | Monstrum

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 21 вер 2024
  • Don’t miss future episodes of Monstrum, subscribe! bit.ly/pbsstori...
    The lines between demon, spirit, and deity are often blurred in the cultures of the Indian subcontinent, where the clear “good vs. evil” dualism that is seen more commonly in the Western hemisphere don’t exist in quite the same way. The complex nature of a nocturnal entity called Nishi reflects this, although it does fall firmly into the malevolent end of the spectrum.
    For audio descriptions, go to Settings - Audio Track - English Descriptive.
    *****
    PBS Member Stations rely on viewers like you. To support your local station, go to: to.pbs.org/Dona...
    *****
    Written and Hosted by: Dr. Emily Zarka
    Director: David Schulte
    Executive Producer: Amanda Fox
    Producer: Thomas Fernandes
    Editor/Animator: Jordyn Buckland
    Illustrator: Samuel Allan
    Executive in Charge (PBS): Maribel Lopez
    Director of Programming (PBS): Gabrielle Ewing
    Additional Footage: Shutterstock
    Music: APM Music
    Consultant: Dr. Sayantani DasGupta
    We would like to sincerely thank Dr. DasGupta for her expertise and invaluable candor. Special thanks also goes to Dr. Suchitra Samanta for her wonderful translation and her knowledge of bhoots, both of which were likewise invaluable to this episode.
    Descriptive Audio & Captions provided by The Described and Captioned Media Program
    Produced by Spotzen for PBS Digital Studios.
    Follow us on Instagram:
    / monstrumpbs
    ----------------------------
    Bibliography
    Banerjee, Rahul. “Nishir Daak: Haunting Legend.” Storymirror, storymirror.co....
    Basu, Helene. “Listening to disembodied voices: anthropological and psychiatric challenges.” Anthropology & Medicine, vol. 21, no. 3, 2014, pp. 325-342.
    Bhairav, J. Furcifer. Ghosts, Monsters, and Demons of India. Blaft Publications, Ltd., 2020.
    Hauntings: Bangla Ghost Stories. Translated and Edited by Suchitra Samanta. Katha, 2000.
    Morton, Lisa. Ghosts: A Haunted History. Reaktion Books Ltd, 2015.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 264

  • @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache
    @Just_Some_Guy_with_a_Mustache Рік тому +495

    Imagine you see a spectral lady in a lake expecting a rad sword and all you get is an aggressive bath.

    • @shadowkingdarksin3980
      @shadowkingdarksin3980 Рік тому +19

      specter: hey boy wants some of this😉
      me: hell no😒
      friend: yeah pass😒
      other friend: nope not today😒
      random guy: HELL YEAH LETS GET NASTY🤪

    • @Winteramen
      @Winteramen Рік тому +21

      Gamer mistake. When I play RPG I find myself fighting enemies i shouldn't have approached thinking i was finding a special item

    • @svtfoesuperfan7438
      @svtfoesuperfan7438 Рік тому +25

      She's a watery tart 😂

    • @MaryamMaqdisi
      @MaryamMaqdisi Рік тому +7

      @@Winteramenor a new NPC, such as Lost Girl in Terraria

    • @thomilsvlog4544
      @thomilsvlog4544 Рік тому +34

      Well, you get what‘s coming to you. After all, strange ladies lying around in ponds distributing swords is no basis for government… or indeed any other form of power

  • @notimetolive12
    @notimetolive12 Рік тому +427

    I am a Bengali and there are so many versions of Nishi.
    In some versions, they don't necessarily only mimic the voice of a dead person, but an alive one as well. The person it is mimicking can literally be sleeping in the other room. The freakiest part is that nobody else can hear them other than the victim.
    Another version includes a pair of owls (called pecha-pechi) where the female owl calls the victim and the male one kills him.
    There is a version, where they call the ghost 'Stree (wife in Bengali)'. Here, they usually only target males and calls seductively, mimicking the voice of any woman that the guy has a crush on. Bollywood made the movie 'Stree' using this lore.
    Finally, there is a version where it is literally no ghost or visible entity. In this version, it is literally the night that calls them. Yes, they believe that the night itself is something to fear.
    But in all of these versions, one thing is common, the victim disappears with no trace. It is as if they vanished into the thin air.

    • @kid14346
      @kid14346 Рік тому +14

      Honestly if we look at this scientifically this might have been born out of a mental illness like schizophrenia. You hear a voice you know when you are alone and then if anyone stops you mentally you are like, "No I'm sure I heard it!" The dead Nishi talked about in the video seems very close to how people behave under extreme grief.

    • @notimetolive12
      @notimetolive12 Рік тому +23

      ​@@kid14346Schizophrenia is the explanation of so so many ghost and paranormal stories obviously. But Nishi is also related to sleepwalking as she said.
      It also came from the fear of the darkness and night by rural people who can't have enough source of light at night.

    • @ohmyumbrella
      @ohmyumbrella Рік тому +7

      stree is not a Bengali legend though is it ? I've only heard of nishir daak and pecha pechi so far. And there is a version where victim is simply found dead in their bed ( when they wake up hearing the call and answer immediately ). In this version nishi traps the life of the person and then uses it to heal another dying person in exchange of money or something else ( source: grandma )

    • @notimetolive12
      @notimetolive12 Рік тому +8

      @@ohmyumbrella Bro, Nishir daak is mainly a bengali folklore, yes, but obviously it extended to many parts of India also. Stree is basically the version popular in the western or middle part of Bharat, i believe.
      There are so so many versions of this, some with little difference, while others with significant differences.

    • @jellysharkbat
      @jellysharkbat Рік тому +4

      That's so spooky

  • @jankay8569
    @jankay8569 Рік тому +175

    I love that you guys cover these obscure, non-western "monsters" that we might have never known otherwise.

    • @horsetuna
      @horsetuna Рік тому

      My friend Karen, an artist, does art of the Squonk and I need to get Storied to cover it somehow

    • @megamanx466
      @megamanx466 Рік тому +1

      Even some of the old local U.S.A. "monsters" would be interesting to hear about too... such as "The Jersey Devil" or such! 😀

  • @abhirupmajumder4522
    @abhirupmajumder4522 Рік тому +102

    Nishi translates to night in Bengali, and Daak translates to call. I am a Bengali, and I have been living in the city throughout my life, so I am quite unfamiliar with the village atmosphere, but I did hear fascinating stories from my grandma, who once stayed in the village in her childhood for a long time, and this Nishir Daak was the scariest of all. It is said it can mimic any voice, not just dead people, but living ones, so you can literally think it's your mom calling you from the other room. The moment you answer it, you are caught in the spell of the Nishi and fall in the trance. No victim of Nishi is ever found, not even the corpse, so there is no way to describe how it really looks like, most people can only assume. If you ever visit a Bengali village, it is just miles and miles of lush green fields, small huts and bamboo forests. No one is seen wandering in the night as it is easy to lose your way, and Nishi might just be only one of the many things to be the cause of it.

  • @miss_shiney1
    @miss_shiney1 Рік тому +68

    We have a similar legend in West Africa from my mom's hometown in Benin. If you hear someone calling you and you can't see the person, do not answer or they might steal your soul. Always be sure you can see the person calling you before you acknowledge them. I'm not sure what the spirit is called but this video brought back memories of that.

  • @ChrisConnolly-Mr.C-Dives-In
    @ChrisConnolly-Mr.C-Dives-In Рік тому +82

    All the guest presenters are really interesting, this one drove home the point about passing the stories to the younger generation to build cultural identity for them. Fitting that she writes books for younger readers.

  • @ButterflySeraph612
    @ButterflySeraph612 Рік тому +31

    I love the statement near the end about folk stories are used within the diasporic community to keep its members tied to the roots of their motherland. As a second generation Filipino American, I've always had a fascination for the supernatural creatures of the Philippines (hence why two of my favorite episodes here are the manananggal and the tikbalang). I'm not sure how to explain it, but there is a sense of awe in learning about the creatures and stories that connected you to your ancestors.

  • @arnabbhattacharjee3618
    @arnabbhattacharjee3618 Рік тому +38

    As a native bengali my mom always told me that the nishi calls thrice. If you don't come out by the third call it stops. But honestly as a kid I knew these were auditory hallucinations

    • @notimetolive12
      @notimetolive12 Рік тому +4

      Yeah, there are many versions. I also heard yours as a kid. But most versions say that they call twice.

    • @rimondas6729
      @rimondas6729 Рік тому

      @@notimetolive12the call twice
      If it's a real human ask it to call once more

  • @עומרשרייבר-ל4ר
    @עומרשרייבר-ל4ר Рік тому +28

    I love it when you talk about creatures from less talked about cultures. South east Asia in general has some really terrifying creatures.

    • @maxredjasper55
      @maxredjasper55 Рік тому +1

      Netflix has a couple good horror movies with monsters from South-east Asia. I wish there were more though. Korea also has some terrifying asf creatures.

  • @Bloooopp
    @Bloooopp Рік тому +124

    This is really great overall but I wish the title didn’t call the Nishi “Indian” but rather more accurately called the Nishi Bengali. It was even covered in the video that the Nishi comes from not only West Bengal in India but the nation of Bangladesh as well. And throughout the video, the Nishi is more accurately referred to as Bengali. By calling the Nishi Bengali, we acknowledge the region as a whole and avoid excluding Bangladesh, a nation that is often overlooked when the west considers South Asia.

    • @MaryamMaqdisi
      @MaryamMaqdisi Рік тому +24

      Agreed, it also sounds more culturally sensitive in general

    • @pbsstoried
      @pbsstoried  Рік тому +72

      You make an excellent point. Changed!

    • @mythicalcreaturesdoctorsor3589
      @mythicalcreaturesdoctorsor3589 Рік тому +7

      ​​​​​​​​​@@pbsstoried nishi : Bangladesh nighttime jungle night spirit ghost woman hypnosis drown dragged boy

    • @ohmyumbrella
      @ohmyumbrella Рік тому +11

      I love that you mention Bangladesh. Because all bengali ghosts and legends originated from bengal as a whole ( or the Bengal, Bihar, Odisha region ). And west bengal is such a small part of it.

    • @subarnarekhapal3185
      @subarnarekhapal3185 Рік тому +9

      @@pbsstoried 'daak' means call. So it's not 'Nishi daak' ghost. You may call it the legends of the call of the Nishi. Would it be possible to look into the matter? I'm extremely overwhelmed to see Nishi as an episode of Monstrum.

  • @ladykoiwolfe
    @ladykoiwolfe Рік тому +69

    This was fascinating, I know so little of the creatures in the mythology and folklore of the Indian subcontinent.
    Edited for better accuracy.

    • @BigTuna-lt3sf
      @BigTuna-lt3sf Рік тому +1

      *Indian subcontinent. These folklores are part of the country of Bangladesh too.

    • @ladykoiwolfe
      @ladykoiwolfe Рік тому

      @@BigTuna-lt3sf oh. Thank you, I had no idea.

  • @eliscanfield3913
    @eliscanfield3913 Рік тому +32

    I keep meaning to read the rest of Dr DasGupta's series. The first one was right up my alley. The Aru Shah' series by Roshani Chokshi is a another good set kids' fantasy books based in Indian folklore. (Yes, I'm a grown up who likes to read kid-lit on occasion.)

    • @YakuzaSRC
      @YakuzaSRC Рік тому +5

      Nothing wrong with reading kid-lit. 😊
      I am 30, and just finished reading "where the Red fern grows", which is considered as children's book too...

    • @joanhoffman3702
      @joanhoffman3702 Рік тому +1

      You’re not alone! So do I,and I am way past the recommended age group. There’s a lot of great stories cleverly disguised as children’s books.

  • @skybluskyblueify
    @skybluskyblueify Рік тому +19

    Supposedly people in heavy grief have "grief hallucinations".They heard their loved one's voice after their death. I wonder if these stories are linked to that phenomena.

    • @Vor567tez
      @Vor567tez Рік тому

      Sometimes it said that after someone's death they heard the person's voice through Nishi Dak.

  • @BigTuna-lt3sf
    @BigTuna-lt3sf Рік тому +9

    THANK YOU FOR FEATURING THE BENGALI CULTURE! There’s SO much paranormal to unpack there, you’ll have a field day. Pishach, shakchunni, jokkh, and on and on

  • @pendragon2012
    @pendragon2012 Рік тому +27

    Reminds me of the crocotta in Supernatural that lure people to their deaths and then eat their souls. And in that episode, they say that it used to be harder to lure people to their deaths because their communities looked out for them but now it was easy because everyone feels so isolated. Great video, Dr. Z!

    • @rockinflemingo3075
      @rockinflemingo3075 Рік тому +4

      Crocotta is actually a borrowed legend of some sort from the Indian Lakadbagha/Yuyukkhura, which is itself based on striped hyenas pestering villages

    • @pendragon2012
      @pendragon2012 Рік тому

      @@rockinflemingo3075 Cool!

  • @zu_1455
    @zu_1455 Рік тому +14

    Dr. Zed? The hero we always need but never deserve.

  • @renecorrea892
    @renecorrea892 Рік тому +8

    I would like all these chapters to be in the future seasons of Monstrum.
    *Sea Serpents
    *Leviathan
    *The Headless Horseman ✅
    *Phantom Vehicles
    *Boogeyman
    *Ghosts
    *Possessed Dolls
    *Shadow People
    *Undead
    *Goblins
    *Bigfoot
    *Man-Eating Plants ✅
    *Creepy Clowns
    *Killer Robots
    *Swamp Monsters
    *The Mummy ✅️
    *Scarecrows
    *The Invisible Man
    *Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde
    *Merfolk
    *Demons
    *Skeletons
    *Stingy Jack (Jack of The Lantern)
    *Gnomes
    *Sea Monsters that attacked Submarines
    *Alien Abductions ✅
    *Ogres
    *Ghouls
    *Lich
    *Cyborgs ✅
    *Witches
    *Kaiju
    *Cthulhu ✅
    *The Rake
    *Revenants
    *Vampires
    *Dagon
    *Ogopogo
    *Colossal Claude
    *Spectral Carriages
    *Kappa
    *Flatwoods Monster
    *The Flying Dutchman
    *El Charro Negro
    *La Santa Compaña
    *Davy Jones & the Undead Pirates
    *Mutants
    *Beast People of Dr. Moreau
    *The Picture of Dorian Gray
    *Haunted Houses
    *Jiangshi
    *Ahuizotl

  • @atroposblack9492
    @atroposblack9492 Рік тому +12

    I am thrilled to see a mainstream folk tale channel I love address supernatural creatures from my culture. I am especially intrigued by the Nishi, because my maternal uncle and aunt have both claimed to have been called by it in their childhood. I remember the earliest warnings from my aunt asking me to not open the gates of my house when my parents weren't at home. I was to only open the door if the person called thrice. Thank you so much, Storied, for this segment. I hope you do more supernatural characters from India...

  • @charlesphilips2045
    @charlesphilips2045 Рік тому +41

    The Nishi seems to be the inspiration behind the terrifying monsters that are in the series "From". This series has terrified me immensely, but I can't stop watching it.

    • @blindleader42
      @blindleader42 Рік тому +6

      I just discovered the series yesterday, and have been binging a bit (only four episodes in). I thought exactly the same when I heard this story, and had to come down here to comment.

    • @EdenHolder
      @EdenHolder Рік тому +2

      I thought they were wendigos which the Nishi also remind me of.

    • @blindleader42
      @blindleader42 Рік тому +5

      @@EdenHolder The appearing and posing as someone the victim knows is the point that hit home for me. I don't remember enough about wendigos to know how they present themselves.

    • @dipayanchoudhury2720
      @dipayanchoudhury2720 Рік тому

      That series is really awesome just finished watching the 2nd season

    • @maxredjasper55
      @maxredjasper55 Рік тому

      @@EdenHolder Wendigos are a different ballpark from Nishi. People who know can become a wendigo or a wendigo spirit can possess your loved one but a Nishi seems more psychic.

  • @maliyathicca3132
    @maliyathicca3132 Рік тому +2

    Bangladeshi here. Thank you so much for covering Nishi. I grew up so many stories of Nishi from my grandmother.

  • @Tamo8
    @Tamo8 Рік тому +5

    Oh boy! This reminds of my grandmother's anecdotes. I'm Sylheti Bengali, my ancestors were from the Sylhet region of Bangladesh (then eastern Bengal). My paternal grandmother was APPARENTLY haunted by these in her childhood in rural Sylhet (pre-partition). She said that this entity would beckon her at night using the voice of her loved ones and knock three times on the door, this used to especially occur in Amavasya/new moon nights. My grandma's family had a tradition of knocking 4 times after dusk, she maintained this tradition post-marriage too. My uncles would prank her by knocking 3 times randomly at night. My grandmother was a sweet woman but I think she experienced something. Thank you for this video, this really reminded me of my gran and its such a niche representation of my cultural beliefs. Us Bengalis also have other classifications of ghosts/bhoots.

    • @chakraborty1989
      @chakraborty1989 15 днів тому

      Lol same experience with my elders, we are from murshidabad, western bengal.
      But instead of knocking 4 times it's 3 times with them as it's believed by them that Nishi can't call you thrice.
      A practice I still follow.

  • @ashlynbrown3728
    @ashlynbrown3728 Рік тому +2

    Wow i love learning about new monsters from around the world, learning about these creepy nishi makes me feel a little fearful of the night

  • @samwill7259
    @samwill7259 Рік тому +9

    I have lost both of my beloved grandmothers this year.
    And I hate to admit how easily this would probably work on me right now.

    • @Bildgesmythe
      @Bildgesmythe Рік тому

      I agree, it would be worth the risk of death to contact a lost loved one.

    • @varoonnone7159
      @varoonnone7159 6 місяців тому

      I'm sorry for your lost

  • @julphines
    @julphines Рік тому +5

    Thank you to Dr. DasGupta for appearing on the show and for having your lovely looking books displayed on the shelf! I took one look at them and starting writing down titles to read later!

  • @soumikroy6549
    @soumikroy6549 Рік тому +3

    I heard so many stories of nishi daak. It always involved my grandfather and his deceased mother. It is so nostalgic. ❤️

  • @AngryKittens
    @AngryKittens Рік тому +4

    What I find terrifying is the element of familiarity. It sounds like a loved one. But it's not.

  • @souravkamilya5352
    @souravkamilya5352 Рік тому +4

    It's very good to see Bengali ghosts in this show. Hope to see many more Bengali ghosts in future as Bengal is full of these folklores ❤

  • @notimetolive12
    @notimetolive12 Рік тому +8

    Bengali has so many different female or feminine entities. The Shakchunni is the most popular. There is also the Sikol Buri (water hag), which is the spirit of women raped or tortured and drowned by the wealthy warlords of the time or their husbands for not being able to give the dowry.

    • @sakuranovaryan9261
      @sakuranovaryan9261 Рік тому +1

      Ugh used to know so many of these myths but don't remember now. Most of them from thakumarjhuli I think.

    • @notimetolive12
      @notimetolive12 Рік тому +1

      @@sakuranovaryan9261 Nah. The book, Thakurmar jhuli, is quite new to the scene; only published in 1907. The author, Dakshinaranjan Mitra Majumder collected many Bengali folklores and stories and wrote them in the book. But all of these stories are far far older than that. He was just a story collector, not the creator of them.

  • @skf101
    @skf101 Рік тому +19

    Great episode. Hopefully, the story of "Shakcunni" will also be discussed in the near future.
    ❤ from Bangladesh.

    • @3N4N
      @3N4N Рік тому +1

      shakchunni is exactly what I thought of after watching the episode

  • @i3osco717
    @i3osco717 Рік тому +17

    Thank you for another fascinating episode. I hope that you will one day do one about the Scandinavian “Myling”. Its origins will send chills down the spine all the while giving us a whisper of insight into the hardship women faced back in the day (And still do in some places) For those who don't have sleep on the schedule I recommend diving into the literature. Also related is “Ängla makerskor” (Eng: Angel makers)

  • @Suddenlyproblematic
    @Suddenlyproblematic Рік тому +4

    Thank you Dr.Zarka! I'm so happy!!! Love from Bangladesh 🇧🇩

  • @ianswinford5570
    @ianswinford5570 Рік тому +7

    Other creatures from India you could do videos on are the Vetala or the Rakshasa. I love these two particular monsters from Indian mythology.

  • @YatriTrivedi
    @YatriTrivedi Рік тому +1

    Dhannobaad to Dr. Sayantani DasGupta for her insights! Love seeing the Hindu/Indic Mythology reflected here. I love the call out to how "ghosts" are complicated by notions of reincarnation, and would strongly recommend fans of this channel to check out the movie Madhumati (1958), an Indian gothic horror piece which plays on that genre's traditional ghost tropes and touches on the idea of reincarnation and how it might play into that. (Also amazing to see Johnny Lever and hear Lata Mangeshkar from that time period, but I digress.)
    I'm from the other side of the subcontinent, and we have a different type of ghost - a jhand - which haunts travelers at crossroads and can also grab by stretching distances or distorting space. They also can mimic the voices of familiar loved ones (alive or dead), though they are very different from the Nishi Daak.
    The toughest part of the Nishi lore is that they haunt their victims and no one else hears their call. Definitely feels like it could be tapping into a different set of mental illnesses with that as well.

  • @sayaneemaaneetgupta
    @sayaneemaaneetgupta Рік тому +2

    I'm a Bengali from West Bengal India and those are the stories of our childhood. The elderlies of our households will tell these tales like bed time stories or to make us have our lunch. These are different versions of Nishi but most popular one was Nishi can call three times only .. so you must not answer until the person calls you for the fourth time 😅 .

  • @ryancan1550
    @ryancan1550 Рік тому +2

    I love everything Monstrum. Been in love with the channels since Monstrum was the channel’s name. It’s been helping me learn more about the world’s monster stories and culture when I haven’t been traveling.
    Was super happy when the manananggal (aswang) was given a whole video. Can we get another Filipino monster one day? There’s a lot of lore that can be revisted one day!

  • @highfive7689
    @highfive7689 Рік тому +2

    I found your tale of the Nishi Daak fascinating. It reminds me of a type of Eastern European vampire that preys on it's family. I love your channel. Great presentation Profesor.

    • @Vor567tez
      @Vor567tez Рік тому +1

      What makes it unique is it doesn't have any body. It's only a voice. Noone has seen it's actual form.

  • @SuperSasky
    @SuperSasky Рік тому +2

    In the Caribbean, lots of children ended up with play names or another given name that was never on their birth certificate but which everyone knew them , e.g, your registered name may be Jennifer but everyone knew you as Tricia for your whole life, by for a similar reason. It was felt that jumbies or douens may call children to their doom, so as a rule you never never answer on the first call.

  • @ravinakuwar1407
    @ravinakuwar1407 Рік тому +2

    As a Native to jangalmahal region of west bengal.
    I would say that NISHIS are actually cautionary tales to dissuade people from travelling in night.
    Cause forests in Bengal & in India were infested with Big cats such as Tigers, Leopard & Lions.

  • @50footbrewery
    @50footbrewery Рік тому +1

    I adore this series. Thank you for all the hard work.

  • @izual989
    @izual989 Рік тому +5

    Sounds interesting, the boy's story is similar to many Eastern European vampire stories of someone having their life force extracted by a dead relative (or something pretending to be the dead relative.

  • @thepodium6930
    @thepodium6930 Рік тому +3

    There's loads of interesting ghosts in the Bengali culture. Petni are female ghosts that have backwards feet, boba is a creature linked to sleep paralysis and my favourite as a kid was the maal, a water demon

  • @MJ-li7fo
    @MJ-li7fo Рік тому +1

    I'm loving these videos :) shout out to the illustrator, the art looks fantastic.

  • @purnendu.mondal
    @purnendu.mondal Рік тому +6

    A Tantrik is the indian version of a voodoo priest. They are not magicians but are known to engage in practices that involve elements of black magic.

  • @trisharaichatterjee2578
    @trisharaichatterjee2578 Рік тому +2

    Also, thank you for the representation because my grandfather’s grandfather basically great grandpa three generations ago went through this petition. It’s still quite fresh within my fathers mind ! It is a chapter in my families history. That we don’t talk about for understandable reasons. The way I feel like it’s up to me to honor the sacrifice great grandpa made three generations ago.

  • @monkeykid797
    @monkeykid797 Рік тому +1

    Reminds me of the time I was wandering the woods after a friend of mine vanished, where we used to occasionally spend time together, and I heard her voice call my name but there was no one else around and it was not super close to the road either.

  • @debapomdas5895
    @debapomdas5895 Рік тому +5

    As Bengali I am too happy

    • @nilaykarmokar5188
      @nilaykarmokar5188 Рік тому +1

      Sei choto bela theke golpo suni bhooter ... Aj folklore hisebe dekhe besh gorbo hocche ... 😂

    • @sovandas8905
      @sovandas8905 7 місяців тому

      Haaa ei channel e banglar vut dekhbo vabi e ni😅

  • @michaelacker4493
    @michaelacker4493 10 місяців тому

    I used to sleepwalk as a kid also. The most embarrassing incident was when I was 6. My parents were having a dinner party. Around 10 pm, I came walking into the living room and over to the trash can where I proceeded to relieve myself. I then “flushed” the trash can and went back to bed. My mom is now 84 and she still teases me about that.

  • @adityamohan1773
    @adityamohan1773 Рік тому +1

    Good job bringing this story. Assamese and North eastern indian folklores has loads of such malevolent spirits. It would be great if you can show their stories too.

  • @penumbra84
    @penumbra84 Рік тому +2

    I genuinely love this series. What's interesting to me is that a lot of ghost stories in any culture is ghost result from improper mourning. Possibly I'm sensitized to this because I've been watching Six Feet Under, but, seriously: La Llorana is incorrect mourning because murder, nishi is incorrect failed mourning.

  • @pumirya
    @pumirya Рік тому +2

    Thanks for another interesting video.

  • @nicklindberg90
    @nicklindberg90 Рік тому +6

    Im only calling ghosts 'bhoots' from now on

  • @arghadeb9180
    @arghadeb9180 Рік тому +1

    Thanks for covering myth from my culture .. love from Bengal

  • @tenebrousoul9368
    @tenebrousoul9368 Рік тому +3

    God bless you, Doc and crew.

  • @pyotrtchaikovsky1840
    @pyotrtchaikovsky1840 10 місяців тому

    Somebody NEEDS to make a movie about this!

  • @suzannestrickland1586
    @suzannestrickland1586 Рік тому +1

    I hope you never run out of stories to tell us Dr Z

  • @kongkonasahadola2949
    @kongkonasahadola2949 Рік тому +1

    Thanks so much for covering a monster legend of our culture.....❤

  • @jacobjames5727
    @jacobjames5727 Рік тому

    Dr. dasGupta is a great expert, more from her would be great!

  • @2Daniel0full
    @2Daniel0full Рік тому +4

    I love this channel

  • @Observer-O
    @Observer-O Рік тому

    This is pretty cool, I'm from Cambodia and growing up we had a similar myth that was taught to us by the elderly.
    This video definitely reminded me of those old and long forgotten scares these stories gave me as a child.

  • @bryanabbott6169
    @bryanabbott6169 Рік тому

    When my grandmother was still alive, she used to call for me when she needed help, or had errands for me to run. When I couldn't hear her, she'd be upset with me and yell.
    My bedroom was on the second floor of the house, and it was harder to hear her the further away from the staircase I was. So I had to train myself to listen to her calling for me.
    One night I heard her call for me, but it was in a dream. I called out to her saying that I'll be right down as I was trying to wake up fully.
    My dad, who's room was on the same floor, told me to go back to bed, that my grandma didn't call for me.
    For a year after my grandma's passing, I've dreamed of her being disappointed with me. As time went by, I forgot her voice so she'd end up just staring at me in the dream.
    It's not hard for me to believe that I would've been lured by a Nishi Daak ghost, esp. so close to the passing of my grandmother if they had existed.

  • @catdairy367
    @catdairy367 Рік тому

    I m from Bangaldesh. I heard about Nishi Dakk as a kid. My aunt told me when we went to village, It's scary.

  • @debayanchakraborty8148
    @debayanchakraborty8148 Рік тому +2

    As a Bengali I am grateful 😊

  • @ayaehab
    @ayaehab Рік тому +1

    there's a very similar legend or urban legend (?) here in Egypt as well! Especially, in the rural areas and upper Egypt, it's called النداهة or the caller/seeker.
    She calls on the people she used to know or has wronged her in a way, to lure them to their deaths eventually. Some stories say she traps them in a trance, till they die.

  • @rami_ungar_writer
    @rami_ungar_writer Рік тому +1

    Yay! New Monstrous video! I always look forward to these. Please do a video on the King in Yellow or the Slit-Mouthed Woman one of these days!

  • @audreyditlefsen3126
    @audreyditlefsen3126 Рік тому +3

    I Love your videos because i love mythology and folklore.Keep up the good work.💖🐉🐲

  • @reddhafallen7289
    @reddhafallen7289 Рік тому +2

    Any chance you could do a video about the kelpie and the each-uisge?

  • @gggg3690
    @gggg3690 10 місяців тому +1

    My mother told me nishi was used as a way to stop children from following strangers who called their names because they could get kidnapped (and hence disappear)

  • @andeeharry
    @andeeharry Рік тому

    I stumnled on this by accident and I must say, I get this a lot. Very often at random, I hear someone calling me and there is nothing there. Been hearing it for years.....

  • @nilaykarmokar5188
    @nilaykarmokar5188 Рік тому +2

    Love to see folklore from my culture ❤❤❤

  • @historyoptional8333
    @historyoptional8333 Рік тому

    As a bengali from west bengal, it's a pleasant surprise to see this video. Great job, keep it up.

  • @anikgypsy
    @anikgypsy Рік тому

    My grandma said she was called by Nishi when she was a little girl. Fortunately she woke up from her trance mid way through and went back home. We're from Bangladesh.

  • @mattcraft7164
    @mattcraft7164 Рік тому

    Zarka!!!!!! Missed you!

  • @craigm2484
    @craigm2484 Рік тому +5

    A Mimic in any culture has Bad intentions .

  • @jamestipton3342
    @jamestipton3342 Рік тому +1

    Fascinating! It is in someways similar in description to the Arabic Ghoul, the Scandinavian Draugr and the Scottish Banshee as well as the Hispanic La Llorona. Quite the interesting combination and comparison to say the least.

  • @Crescent-Adam
    @Crescent-Adam Рік тому

    We have pretty much the same thing in Egypt! She's called "El-Naddaha" literally the woman who calls out.

  • @adityanair6540
    @adityanair6540 Рік тому +5

    Finally an Indian monster

  • @jalepezo
    @jalepezo Рік тому +2

    We need a dakini and yogini special, assistants to the Devi in the Smashan , true masters of tantra

  • @trisharaichatterjee2578
    @trisharaichatterjee2578 Рік тому

    This story is something that my great aunt recently told me. Though I’ve heard the story from another one of her siblings. It could be a folk story that is relatively popular from that particular part of colonized undivided West Bengal.

  • @laysolo9175
    @laysolo9175 Рік тому

    Filipino culture also has this kind of malevolent creature, but the scarier fact is that it also applies to any one living. I forgot the name of the spirit/creature but it also calls you using the voice of a loved one either living or dead.
    Someone calls your name but then only calls twice you might want to wait for a third call before approaching that person...

  • @brendakrieger7000
    @brendakrieger7000 Рік тому +1

    Thanks😊

  • @sapphirejade5029
    @sapphirejade5029 Рік тому +1

    This is quite fascinating. Looks like I'll be using this for my next tale.

    • @notimetolive12
      @notimetolive12 Рік тому

      Can i read it? Nishi is one of my favourite ghosts.

    • @sapphirejade5029
      @sapphirejade5029 Рік тому

      @@notimetolive12 well, if you’re into Tarot, you'll be going for a little fun ride.😅 So far, I'm working on a short story that's inspired by 'The Star' tarot card. I have it in draft mode as of now but I hope to get it either online or published.
      The Nishi has given me an interesting idea and one of the characters is tied with 'The Lovers' card and the tale takes place during the 1930s. I'll be doing some research when I have the motivation and ideas ready to go. May need some ideas/advice about Indian history. I barely know any and school didn’t help.😖

  • @stevengreen9536
    @stevengreen9536 Рік тому

    This kinda reminds me of a story i read online years back. It was about a female monster from the Phillipines that abducted children. The kids in the story were staying over at their grandmother's house. When one of them notices an unusual looking old woman standing in the road staring at them. The grandmother who had a special sight. ( i think the term was dog eyes) Also noticed her and instructed the grand kids to sleep behind her and not leave the house for any reason that evening. The grandmother kept an eye on the creature all night until dawn when it either left or vanished.

  • @Domdrok
    @Domdrok Рік тому

    At the beginning of the video I thought Dr. Z said "benevolent" instead of "malevolent" and it took me a minute.

  • @pssurvivor
    @pssurvivor Рік тому

    As a Bengali this was interesting. Some of the stories I was told as kid in hindsight just seem like things one would say to keep errant kids in check. For example, I was told never to stand under a tree at night coz that's where the spirits live. idk, as an adult it seems they just didn't want me out during a storm or something!

  • @robbabcock_
    @robbabcock_ Рік тому +1

    Terrific video!👻🔥☠

  • @roberthiltz2741
    @roberthiltz2741 Рік тому +1

    There is certainly a fine balance that needs to be achieved between cultural and religious rituals and the awareness of mental health issues. All cultures should be represented and respected but mental illness and emotional disorders are extremely important as well… What practices are truly harmful versus traditional should be decided by a mixture of science and acceptance of various beliefs. Wish it were that easy, for all of our benefit

    • @NovaSaber
      @NovaSaber Рік тому +1

      No, there isn't.
      You can't "decide" the answer to a factual question; what practice achieves what result has (ignoring the placebo effect) nothing to do with what anyone believes about it.

    • @roberthiltz2741
      @roberthiltz2741 Рік тому

      @@NovaSaber Fine point, but I disagree. Try implementing a new law created for the good of public health in a culture which arcane or superstitious practices are still honored the same way as hundreds of years ago and you will find obvious rejection from the public. When I used the word decided I meant the careful decisions of those in a position of authority that implement laws that protect the public interest- always a slippery slope

  • @natbatlightwood5288
    @natbatlightwood5288 Рік тому

    This is where it pays to not have a good family unit because if i heard one of my aunts calling me in the dark i'd walk the other way.

  • @ibrav7979
    @ibrav7979 Рік тому

    God I love this channel so much

  • @NyAppyMiku22
    @NyAppyMiku22 Рік тому +1

    I really enjoyed learning from this video but i kept having to turn up and down my volume when switching between Dr. Emily Zarka and Dr. Sayantani DasGupta :/

  • @fiberpoet6250
    @fiberpoet6250 Рік тому

    I used to hear a man call my name or my mom call my name as a kid when no one called me.
    This had my parents concerned
    Then In my early 20’s I went into full on psychosis and began hallucinating 24/7
    Then a few months later I was put on psych meds for schizoeffective.
    I still have rare break through hallucinations but it’s not bad and I know what they are.
    I remember tho, it began with voices calling my name as a kid.

  • @TeamChaosPrez
    @TeamChaosPrez Рік тому

    i'm so behind on monstrum, i'm gonna have to just binge these later lol

  • @johnjosephcapolino1650
    @johnjosephcapolino1650 Рік тому +1

    Really liked the episode, I learned something about a culture i know little about. Question though, i thought i heard the phrase "demonized exorcism," and it rang in my head as an oxymoron.

    • @poulomi__hari
      @poulomi__hari Рік тому

      In India, excorcisms are performed by Tantrics. Possession and excorcism requires the same knowledge and thus can be performed only by a Tantric. And Tantrics use help of various demons and spirits to get their job done.

  • @NewMessage
    @NewMessage Рік тому +1

    Man... we gotta get on inventing a real proton pack already.

  • @tonydiep6415
    @tonydiep6415 Рік тому

    These are fantastic. ❤

  • @sabbirmahmud1840
    @sabbirmahmud1840 Рік тому

    ❤Love From Dhaka,Bangladesh 🇧🇩 🤟

  • @iqbaalannaafi4944
    @iqbaalannaafi4944 Рік тому

    Hi, Dr. Zarka. Would you like to do a video about Nagas or Satyrs sometime later?

  • @trisharaichatterjee2578
    @trisharaichatterjee2578 Рік тому

    I’ve also heard this called the Indian banshee. I was at least from the village where my father lived in before he moved to the city of Calcutta when he was a small child. They also do the same job like banshees do. Calling families name until they’re supposed neither die pretty soon. Or like in this video actually leave them to their death. This could be the influence of the fact that we did have a pretty sizable Irish people marrying into the Bengali community

  • @megamanx466
    @megamanx466 Рік тому

    Sounds like a good tabletop RPG monster to use.
    I imagine a party is split up and either a PC or NPC dies, but in a way where everyone else can only assume the fate of the lost PC or NPC. Then, a Nishi appears and tries to call a member of the living party twice. If they have a guide for the area or make a successful "History" check or similar such knowledge check, then they should know to listen for a 3rd call out to them. 😅
    WotC get to work on it!

  • @artyfarty87
    @artyfarty87 Рік тому

    This was a cool/spooky episode, thank you xoxo

  • @cabicabi4636
    @cabicabi4636 Рік тому

    I'm a Bengali & I could remember when we were kids n were visiting my grandma's home in village some neighbours there used to say that "Don't go outside if you hear someone calling by your name only three times or crying for help in the middle of the night, that's not human that's NISHI"