Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell panel discussion | BFI

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 5 вер 2024
  • Subscribe: bit.ly/subscrib....
    Director Toby Haynes, producer Nick Hirschkorn and writer Peter Harness join actors Marc Warren and Bertie Carvel to explain how they turned Susanna Clarke’s epic novel Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell into a TV series. Panel chaired by journalist Benji Wilson.
    Watch more on the BFI Player: player.bfi.org.uk/
    Follow us on Twitter: / bfi
    Like us on Facebook: / britishfilminstitute
    Follow us on Google+: plus.google.co...

КОМЕНТАРІ • 33

  • @kai-leeklymchuk744
    @kai-leeklymchuk744 8 років тому +39

    Marc Warren was simply mesmerising in this role. Fantastic.

    • @isobelduncan
      @isobelduncan 8 років тому +3

      I know! He was so engaging!

    • @bibchr
      @bibchr 4 роки тому +3

      Almost never blinked. And his voice was so different.

    • @nancyfraunfelder9021
      @nancyfraunfelder9021 2 роки тому

      He was simply amazing!

  • @Dawnrunner42
    @Dawnrunner42 7 років тому +32

    I think the greatest example of this show's perspective on portraying magical effects is the sound of a huge door creaking ominously open whenever they summon the Gentleman. Nothing is seen...but everything is implied.

  • @joachim595
    @joachim595 9 років тому +13

    Such marvellous narrative, characters and detailing in historical feel. There's so much more to say though...

  • @ParanoidOwlet
    @ParanoidOwlet Рік тому +2

    Okay, I’m in love with Bertie, it’s cemented now.

  • @steveryan3589
    @steveryan3589 9 років тому +6

    Love it, love the use of subtle magic. I barely watch TV any more, it's all repeats, soaps and game shows and has been for a long time. Money is too important in this world

  • @fleinkantarell
    @fleinkantarell 9 років тому +26

    Bertie Carvel
    Is The Next Doctor... there you have it..

    • @joemachado33
      @joemachado33 9 років тому +3

      I really like that idea haha

    • @janinegove8045
      @janinegove8045 9 років тому +1

      fleinkantarell I did think Bertie Carvel sounds a little like John Pertwee in this.

    • @MGB_2024
      @MGB_2024 7 років тому +1

      I was just about to make that comment. He would be superb!

    • @aimeeinkling
      @aimeeinkling 7 років тому

      I wish it was true! I thought the same thing when I watched Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell...but alas, I doubt that's going to be the case.

    • @easternlights3155
      @easternlights3155 6 років тому

      Please, make it happen!!!! At least after Jodie Whittaker...

  • @chrisheroldt5871
    @chrisheroldt5871 3 роки тому +2

    BBC did about as well as could be expected adapting this massive book. Well done, old chaps!

  • @AkshayRawal
    @AkshayRawal 9 років тому +2

    Great Story, great cast and something new to look forward.

  • @joemachado33
    @joemachado33 9 років тому +11

    Season 2! Season 2! Please! Haha

    • @biocapsule7311
      @biocapsule7311 9 років тому +6

      No second book yet.

    • @isobelduncan
      @isobelduncan 8 років тому

      Susanna Clarke has actually announced that she's thought about

    • @aimeeinkling
      @aimeeinkling 7 років тому +1

      Clarke is working on the second book, but she's been in poor health.

    • @anggnalikadkomento6549
      @anggnalikadkomento6549 4 роки тому +1

      no season 2 T_T

  • @hermioneonice
    @hermioneonice 2 роки тому

    22:23 'It's quite rare, in my experience, to be allowed room to actually bring all of what you can do. And that's what we got. And that's really...rare.' The unspoken can we please work together again is the best take away. Production values that stand the test of time in the best way possible.

  • @albaghdady2007
    @albaghdady2007 Рік тому

    I enjoyed watching Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell. Are there any plans to write follow-up stories?

  • @sandramckeehan5679
    @sandramckeehan5679 3 місяці тому

    If you ever have writer, Peter Harness, on a panel again, I suggest he be placed on an end seat. Turning his back on the actors was a bit rude. It actually looked as if he can't stand being near them! Bertie Carvel did well trying to look around Harness without being annoyed. If that was acting, well done!😁 Oh, the body language .

  • @jovanport
    @jovanport 2 роки тому

    Best series ever its a wonderful thing that magic cant cure youre madness

  • @2charliep
    @2charliep 9 років тому +38

    So glad Peter Jackson DIDN'T make this.

    • @enomis916
      @enomis916 2 роки тому +1

      Peter Jackson is a fabolous director, but also toby haynes is great, his work on this, doctor who and black mirror is gold

  • @barbaratabler9904
    @barbaratabler9904 9 років тому

    I loved the series but am a bit confused on the ending. So I'm looking forward to reading the book now. Loved all the choice of actors. Been keeping an eye out on Eddie's career awhile now. Now I have many more to keep up with.

  • @kaduisaui4596
    @kaduisaui4596 4 роки тому +2

    Somebody mistook Childermass for an orange NOT an apple.

  • @dangelamarx80
    @dangelamarx80 4 місяці тому +1

    Missssssster Norrellllll Suhhhhh

  • @TheSlovenmind
    @TheSlovenmind 9 років тому +6

    I read this when it first came out, and loved it then.... I was waiting for it but I wasn't 100% satisfied with episode 1, it seemed to brush over the magic that made book, while understandable since it is tv, it went thru things without giving meaning/importance or charm like the statue scene, it should have been longer, basically the importance of each step was well summed up for tv. I just felt the first episode needed to be drawn out more, the parts they did use from the book did cross over well, but sadly the book details of event were lost. I was hoping this would be a slow paced series, or one that focused on maybe a portion of the book. Seven episode that will rush through the charm... You just don't get to love or feel for the characters, the whole death scene of the father and the servant lost its purpose....there are stories within stories here that are missing, that would have made each episode grand, and only show one grand magic scene in each episode. Its just my opinion on watching the first episode.

  • @enomis916
    @enomis916 2 роки тому +1

    Toby haynes should direct fantastic beasts