The Yaesu FTX-1F Needs This: An Open Letter to Yaesu

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 19 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 113

  • @HAMRADIODUDE
    @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +12

    UPDATE: Yaesu public relations reached out to me after the video was released. They stated (summarizing on my part) they have a no interest in releasing a STEP, STL or other design on any radios currently in production or any future releases. I really appreciate all the support from everyone who agreed this was a good idea, but we cannot win them all. Thanks Yaesu for the response. - 73!

    • @labcat73
      @labcat73 2 місяці тому +3

      Pretty dumb, but not unexpected. I didn’t even think this is a revolutionary ideas / suggestion, just plain common sense in an age where every ham has a 3D printer. Alas this won’t change a thing, just delay it by the one week it takes somebody to take measurements and crank out a model. 🤷

  • @TonyYarusso
    @TonyYarusso 2 місяці тому +13

    Huh, clicked the thumbnail thinking “dude, it’s already too late for them to add any features”, but this is entirely doable. Definitely a good idea.

  • @JonathanKayne
    @JonathanKayne 2 місяці тому +19

    Let me just say, they could one up icom by simply releasing a step file instead of an STL.
    For creating things like cases or accessories, using an STL as a reference is horrific, especially when there are circular structures to reference (like mounting holes). It's about the worst file type for this type of stuff.
    STEP on the other hand, maintains all model features, making design of accessories super easy, especially when it comes to holes.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +4

      You sir, are correct. Thanks!

    • @xxmrrickxx
      @xxmrrickxx 2 місяці тому +2

      Ha! I just posted the same thing!

  • @LB5JJ
    @LB5JJ 2 місяці тому +9

    I really hope take your advice on this! I'm getting the radio no matter what, but having access to STL files would be a MAJOR win! And enable creating use-cases and solutions for this radio Yaesu hasn't even thought about!

  • @KC5TGTRadiosNMore
    @KC5TGTRadiosNMore 2 місяці тому +3

    Totally agree. This should be available by every manufacturer on the date of product announcement!

  • @jdgjhn1
    @jdgjhn1 2 місяці тому +9

    It’s a beautiful radio. Now give me a 100 watt version.

    • @taekehf
      @taekehf 2 місяці тому +1

      FT-710. There you go.

    • @Nolan-N4NJM
      @Nolan-N4NJM 2 місяці тому +1

      @@taekehf 710 doesn’t have VHF UHF or dual receive

    • @4X4-RADIO
      @4X4-RADIO 2 місяці тому +1

      That would be a FT-991A Replacement... FTX-2F..??

    • @Nolan-N4NJM
      @Nolan-N4NJM 2 місяці тому +1

      yes it would be awesome to get a 991a up date hopefully FTX-2F would have cross band repeat also

    • @alanb76
      @alanb76 2 місяці тому

      No. Plenty already. Give us a 30 Watt version.

  • @Josh-KJ7OEP
    @Josh-KJ7OEP 2 місяці тому +2

    I hope Yaesu listens. I couldn't have said it better myself.

  • @largestache
    @largestache 2 місяці тому +4

    But if they release the STL and 3rd party companies make accessories. How will Yaesu be able to charge way to much money for their accessories?

  • @johnlagreca6288
    @johnlagreca6288 2 місяці тому

    Great thoughts DUDE. A STEP file would be a fantastic addition for sure. Many manufacturers of industrial equipment post the STEP with the product data sheet. It should become a standard in the amateur community as well. Cheers.

  • @kokohenker9439
    @kokohenker9439 2 місяці тому

    100% Agree, I Waiting for this Radio. One STL could be Nice. Please Yaesu give us One STL. 73 from Germany

  • @moselblues8694
    @moselblues8694 2 місяці тому +1

    Would prefer a STEP file but I absolutely support this request 😊

  • @xxmrrickxx
    @xxmrrickxx 2 місяці тому +6

    Everybody asks for an STL. No! We want a STEP file. A STEP file is the standard for solid modeling and can be manipulated by all CAD software. STL files are shell coordinates for machines (3D printing, CNC, etc.). One can easily convert STEP to STL but you cannot convert STL to STEP without loosing information (screw holes are filled in, thread pitch is unreliable, small features missing, etc.). It drives me nuts when people only upload the STL on model sharing sites. I tried multiple conversion engines and could never get the IC-705 STL to convert to a solid model accurately. It was fun to 3D print it though.

    • @K6ARK
      @K6ARK 2 місяці тому

      Yes, this. Mesh files are interior for what we really want to do with them - develop mods.

  • @alanb76
    @alanb76 2 місяці тому +1

    Excellent Video and reasonable request.

  • @W4TRI_Ronny
    @W4TRI_Ronny 2 місяці тому

    Printing that 705 STL now! 10.5 hours. New Creality K1 Max is the BEST printer i have ever used! just works!

  • @alvarogaitan2529
    @alvarogaitan2529 Місяць тому

    thanks, great job 73

  • @NRGTRONICS
    @NRGTRONICS 3 дні тому

    I agree 100%

  • @MentalWhiplash
    @MentalWhiplash 2 місяці тому +1

    I can't believe somebody actually called this "whiny"...lol. I think the more accurate word would be "proactive". Let's be honest. Hams accessorize with radios like the fairer sex does with shoes. Heck, I'll admit that my red MTR4b has a matching BamaKey TP-III. Releasing the STL of the radio isn't making any tinkerers rich. It's providing an environment for peripheral development that only makes the radio more appealing. There is no reason they shouldn't WANT to do that!

  • @jdschauss
    @jdschauss 2 місяці тому

    Yaesu would also get FREE product hype for the release if they did this. Great video, brother!

  • @4X4-RADIO
    @4X4-RADIO 2 місяці тому

    100% Agree...
    First thing I thought of was how to protect it.
    A Windcamp style wrap around cage/frame.

  • @robertmeyer4744
    @robertmeyer4744 2 місяці тому

    very good and well said. Radios today are great. Today when looking at new radio ,The first thing I hear is what accessories can I get for it ? Hams love their radios and want to take care of them. POTA and SOTA are HUGE now ! Having the STL file will be a big help for those that want a good backpack or protective case. Not having the STL file may cause some to buy a radio from someone else that has more accessories out and protective cases. I hope in the commings weeks we will see the STL file. Someone that gets one just may 3D scan the radio and we have it.
    I think shortly after the first ones get shipped we will see lots on printables and outher cities. I would like to see them release it now so we get a head start . 73

  • @timel64
    @timel64 2 місяці тому

    The accessories market is bigger than the base product. It boost sales of a base product and creates a fandom. Just look at what happened to the AR platform. Or the Ruger 10/22, I bought one just to mod it & make it unique. Look at the popularity of Overlander trucks & SUVs. People buy them just to put on external fuel cans, traction boards, rooftop tents, light-lift hacks, cargo baskets, off-road lights, just to shuttle their kids to school. Choppers, Hot Rods, you name it. HAM radio is the next big thing! Look at how many signature EFHW are out there. But none compare to the Dudetenna!

  • @adamjones8218
    @adamjones8218 2 місяці тому

    Good idea.
    My open letter to manufacturers including ICOM and Yaesu is we want a true field radio, not covered /pavilion picnic table POTA radio - IP66/67 rated at a minimum. Yaesu had 5 years to improve upon what the IC 705 released and I'm just seeing much of the same missed opportunities for a true field rated QRP rig.

  • @ChrisRobinsonKF6NFW
    @ChrisRobinsonKF6NFW 2 місяці тому

    I don't have a 3-d printer, however, even with the STL files available, I am able to design parts for my desire, and have them printed at a friends.
    I can decide the configuration that fits my needs. If the tuner doesn't fit my needs on the back, I can put it where I want it, or make a holder for the GPS antenna, or whatever other doohickey I may want or need with the rig.
    Absolutely release the kraken, I mean the STL files!

  • @kb8m203
    @kb8m203 2 місяці тому

    Great idea. Keep the videos coming.

  • @pen25
    @pen25 2 місяці тому +1

    this should have been a 100/50 watt radio

  • @dustyroaddestinations
    @dustyroaddestinations 2 місяці тому

    Would be cool to have stuff out for it on release day (or before). Sure looks like it's going to be a solid radio and definitely looking forward to being able to buy one.

    • @dustyroaddestinations
      @dustyroaddestinations 2 місяці тому

      OBTW received my wire winders - those are pretty darn cool! Think I got them yesterday maybe? Definitely looks nice with the white callsign! You should make a little bit bigger one (HINT HINT)! 😀

  • @Terry-ib6uv
    @Terry-ib6uv 2 місяці тому

    Agree 👍. Thank you! 73

  • @Blake-jl8lh
    @Blake-jl8lh 2 місяці тому +1

    The ham community is classically a tinkering community. In the modern era that means to enable said community you should enable 3d printing and its something that has only begun to become popular in the community.
    The cad files for this will come out one way or another. Yaesu has the opportunity to gain good pr by being the ones to publish them

  • @johnleonardelli_VE3IPS
    @johnleonardelli_VE3IPS 2 місяці тому

    I think the cage concept looks fraught as the optional items snapping onto the back would make a deeper cage or maybe thats a good things since the radio with all the wires will stay upright. I have the Z mount on my 705 and took it off when I got the Windcamp cage and just never found it as useful out in the field as thought.

  • @KS0JD
    @KS0JD 2 місяці тому

    Could not agree more! Free and open communication on the design will only enhance the buying experience! You called it a Ted Talk. I think its a Dude Talk! 73

  • @martyes2344
    @martyes2344 2 місяці тому

    Excellent, a bit forward thinking.

  • @johnratcliffe6438
    @johnratcliffe6438 2 місяці тому

    Yaesu need to make a competitor to the IC 9700. It's beyond frustrating that we don't have one yet. They can reuse the FTDX10 chassis and provide the same features and band coverage that the 9700 has.

  • @charlesvrogers
    @charlesvrogers 2 місяці тому +1

    Tastefully done.

  • @WA4TKG
    @WA4TKG 2 місяці тому

    What they SHOULD HAVE incorporated into this radio is a Packet Modem: APRS.
    I can’t believe they didn’t, would it have been THAT difficult?
    Unbelievable

  • @super66craig
    @super66craig 2 місяці тому

    Hey neighbor! Haven't heard you around the high bands in some time. I started an experimenters group for our area. I'll have to chat with you some time. KD9UQE CRAIG Antioch

  • @thorfinnolsen2635
    @thorfinnolsen2635 2 місяці тому

    Sounds like a good idea 🙂

  • @MI7DJT
    @MI7DJT 2 місяці тому +1

    Make the menus sane. Always had trust issues with Yaesu menus. They're beyond crap.

  • @joesagan23
    @joesagan23 2 місяці тому

    An stl file won’t get me any closer to designing accessories than dimensioning parts by hand, and starting from scratch. What we need is a STEP file.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +1

      I had pinned the comment mentioning this already. Thanks

  • @ssere
    @ssere 2 місяці тому

    WIsh they made this a 100 WATT Radio... We need a new mobile rig that supports SDR and allows us the option of being more portable.. Best one I have now is the IC-7000 (obviously not SDR) but neither Yaesu nor ICOM have come out with anything new in the mobile space for 50/HF/UHF/VHF in quite some time !

  • @ch716
    @ch716 2 місяці тому

    I agree, but the FTX-1F's design doesn't seem very conducive to racks and boxes due to the layout of the buttons and speakers. The IC-705 is perfect for that since everything is on the front. I'm excited to see what kind of things people make for the FTX-1F.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +1

      @ch716 I'd agree with your opinions!

  • @Steve-qn6bt
    @Steve-qn6bt 2 місяці тому

    Yaesu needs to release a decent portable HF radio like the G90 (only better quality) that the average people can afford. If Xiegu can do it for around $450, certainly the braintrust at Yaesu could do it for $600. I already have an FT891 that was around $600 when I bought it. But hauling a 100-watt radio and battery on a POTA activation is excessive. That's what I think anyway. But what do I know. I'm just a consumer. I already have VHF/UHF HTs that are Fusion-capable. I don't need that built in to a do-all radio. This FTX-1F is most likely going to end up at least two to three times the cost of the FT-818.

  • @Nick_G7IZR
    @Nick_G7IZR 2 місяці тому

    They want to release the CAT commands too as when the 710 came out there were enough CAT differences to affect operation with a lot of software. Maybe with it being another SDR radio, it will use the same command set as the 710, but there are bound to be some differences.

    • @ChrisRobinsonKF6NFW
      @ChrisRobinsonKF6NFW 2 місяці тому

      THIS. THIS has always bugged me with YAESU.
      I have the FT-897D. Its a CAT nightmare. I do not know of any bricked EEPROM's, however, I know of many that used the non standard commands on their rigs.
      If Yaesu would just be a little more transparent, and willing to interact with the amateur community BEFORE the problems start, and to create a more friendly relationship, I believe more folks would enjoy Yaesu products more.

  • @robertmeyer4744
    @robertmeyer4744 2 місяці тому

    UPDATE . That radio does not have FCC type acceptance as of AUG 31,2024. BY law in Japan and US That STL file and lots of information can not be released until the PART 97 of FCC comes threw. This takes time. Yaesu released some info before the part 97 went threw. This is coming from Yaesu . Once that type 97 goes threw will will have all the info. This is a part 97 radio not like the China part 15 FCC radio. 73

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks! I appreciate it! Yaesu is not going to release the STEP or STL files.

    • @robertmeyer4744
      @robertmeyer4744 2 місяці тому

      @@HAMRADIODUDE Yaesu is in Japan and laws are different. Once the part 97 goes threw things will change and we get more info on the radio . Once the first bach goes out I am sure someone will 3D scan it and we have a STL file. For now we have to wait. Just RED tape . The new Icom does have the part 97 approved. just waiting on shipping.

  • @don_n5skt
    @don_n5skt 2 місяці тому

    Great Idea

  • @tropenband
    @tropenband 2 місяці тому +1

    If Yaesu should not release the stl-file, I could create an accurate 3D-Model of the radio, but therefore, someone needs to donate it to me first, so I can take all the measurements. 😊
    In return, I then would make the file freely available. deal?

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +1

      As long as yaesu loans me the radio 😅

  • @sacredgongs
    @sacredgongs 2 місяці тому

    How about an app that can be used in conjunction with taking a 3D image and translating it to any file format so that someone can develop their own add ONS and this would not be restricted to any particular radio, personally I think this would be a better idea. I can’t see yaesu doing what you are mentioning.

  • @kimoclyde
    @kimoclyde 2 місяці тому

    What's up with the Max Headroom type editing. Do you do it to cut down the video length?

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +1

      I am Max Headroom. Kidding aside, I was reading from a script that was on the monitor below me, which caused me to continuously look down. I could put a teleprompter up, but I need to figure out where to put it.

    • @super66craig
      @super66craig 2 місяці тому

      ​@@HAMRADIODUDE I see guys using a screen next to the camera. You can see the eyes roving the script as they look at you. It works.

  • @tookthe5th182
    @tookthe5th182 2 місяці тому

    At least this radio has 2 antenna ports. That single issue kept me from buying a 705!

  • @KG-xf9ew
    @KG-xf9ew 2 місяці тому +1

    Anyone thinking of buying into this radio should remember the FT-991 / FT-991A debaucle and all the people Yaesu screwed.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      Except just out of curiosity, what does this have to do with my video?And the point that I made in the video? I'm trying to understand. Please fill us in about the ft991 STL debaucle. Or did you not watch the video? cheers

    • @super66craig
      @super66craig 2 місяці тому

      I usually have to loosen my debaucle after a big meal.

    • @KG-xf9ew
      @KG-xf9ew 2 місяці тому

      @@HAMRADIODUDE I was referring to Yaesu as a company and for people to be careful with adopting new products from them early. Early and expensive adopters of the FT-991 radio were left out in the cold when Yaesu released the FT-991A very shortly thereafter. Enhanced features made the FT-991 much less valuable and hurt the loyal Yaesu buyers who supported the FT-991 early. I might add, just me but I found your jumpy camera work to be really weird there Magoo. I did watch the video and if you're not English quit saying cheers.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      A Gatekeeper of speaking... got it

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      PS: cheers, Mate

  • @M0JSX
    @M0JSX 2 місяці тому

    0:20 oh look, it’s me!

  • @jerryKB2GCG
    @jerryKB2GCG 2 місяці тому +1

    Best of luck, Yaesu seems to be far less responsive than Icom in terms of responsiveness.

  • @bryantwalley
    @bryantwalley 2 місяці тому +1

    This is a great idea for all manufacturers.

  • @nehem11e
    @nehem11e 2 місяці тому +1

    I strongly agree with and support this concept

  • @jakep5121
    @jakep5121 2 місяці тому

    I'd like to see a plug in BRICK that was an amp and tuner in one unit. imagine. this radio in a moblie, and the brick under the seat or anywhere. When your mobile, you got a nice rig, when you get to the park you take out a QRP rig that's always with you. and the interface would require ZERO menu adjustments. if its plugged in the brick works. if not it doesn't. simple.

  • @ikeedwards5127
    @ikeedwards5127 Місяць тому

    Still want uhf, vhf radio with a viable band scope to do weak signal work. Oh 100w on hf is more practical.

  • @nomadynofficial
    @nomadynofficial Місяць тому +1

    They should release the STEP files; STL isn't nearly as useful.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  Місяць тому

      yes, good point! a few people in the pinned comments mentioned this already. However, this was a great reminder to start uploading step files for my stuff! Thanks!

  • @Scott_AI5EF
    @Scott_AI5EF 2 місяці тому

    Sad that it's not full duplex.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      so you agree with the video?

    • @Scott_AI5EF
      @Scott_AI5EF 2 місяці тому

      @@HAMRADIODUDE Yes, sir. 👍🏼👍🏼

  • @jptrade8575
    @jptrade8575 2 місяці тому

    How can you make a vid on something you have never used or owned?

    • @nehem11e
      @nehem11e 2 місяці тому +1

      Did you watch the video?

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      LOL. This has to, when the comment of the hour, at least. which part of my video did you disagree with........ lol

  • @myr382
    @myr382 2 місяці тому

    I love Yaesu but VERY Frustrating on many fronts - how about: follower versus leader, recycled designs, lack of a clear vision - if they have a vision they are not sharing-, Bluetooth that only works with their average but expensive headsets, DVI Vs HDMI and 1 USB port (come on!)…. Yaesu….This is 2024 not 2004. My vision … my next radio will be the IC7760. Sorry for being brutally honest.

  • @MacsForever1
    @MacsForever1 2 місяці тому

    Don't want to be a Debbie downer here but if they likely won't give away the STL file because they couldn't sell their accessories exclusively. Also considering what they did with fusion vs D-Star keeping their network proprietary they won't do it...but it can't hurt to ask Yaesu.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      I appreciate your fair observation! Thanks and fair point.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      PS, I didn't put it together it was THE K9AT! Nice! Hope you're well

    • @MacsForever1
      @MacsForever1 2 місяці тому

      @@HAMRADIODUDE I'm blessed to still be here and thanks for asking. Great videos as always...

  • @nealbeach4947
    @nealbeach4947 Місяць тому

    Rigs nowadays are starting to look ridiculous.

  • @W4TRI_Ronny
    @W4TRI_Ronny 2 місяці тому

    Yaesu.... STL?!

  • @floriangutzwiller5122
    @floriangutzwiller5122 2 місяці тому +1

    I'm a Yaesu Fan, but they are so backwards in terms of software and networking it's depressing. No chance against 705 in a million years.

  • @radioamigoscanariasespana8021
    @radioamigoscanariasespana8021 29 днів тому

    dejaramos De comprar equipos yaesus veras como se ponen las pilas .por mi parte yo no comprare mas yaesu .dx 10 murio ya no ay mas mejoras increible adios yaesu hasta siempre habra que volver al analogico.tanta tecnologuia y caros equipos ni traen blutou ni gps ni nada de nada solo menus y mas menus para entretenerte la plataforms de yaesu a muerto

  • @robertdickson6317
    @robertdickson6317 2 місяці тому +1

    another radio that's a waste of time unless your into p.o.t.a don't get me started on the icom I think I will stick with what I have here in the shack

    • @nehem11e
      @nehem11e 2 місяці тому

      By pota do you mean portable?

    • @nehem11e
      @nehem11e 2 місяці тому

      I see you edited to clearly show P.O.T.A but this radio is good for other O.T.A like SOTA, IOTA, lighthouses on the air, etc. Also pretty much most other portable setups where carrying the batteries or generator to run 100watts or more is more difficult. For shack stuff I agree you can run other rigs because you have the house power or in a lost power scenario big batteries or generator.

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому

      Traveling in airplanes, through airports... etc

  • @kurtbrauer855
    @kurtbrauer855 2 місяці тому

    Well its qrp Rig but Price will be qro!
    So what is QRP ? 😂

    • @HAMRADIODUDE
      @HAMRADIODUDE  2 місяці тому +4

      you didnt watch the video, i assume?

    • @MentalWhiplash
      @MentalWhiplash 2 місяці тому +1

      With the exception of extremely high-powered amplifiers there isn't a correlation between price and output. The cost of 100 watts is cheap. Building a quality high-performance QRP radio is a far greater, and more expensive, task than slapping 100 watts in a cheap radio. If wattage was the goal then everybody would just lug around FT-710's and IC-7300's with low end internal tuners and carry bigger batteries. That doesn't appeal to everybody, which is evidenced by the huge success of the IC-705. That's obviously why Yaesu knew they needed to design this radio.