JBL 305P MKII vs KRK Rokit 5 RP5G3 || 6-Track Comparison
Вставка
- Опубліковано 23 гру 2018
- JBL on amazon DE: amzn.to/2GArwTi
KRK on amazon DE: bhpho.to/2uVPUX7
JBL on bhphotovideo: amzn.to/2GArzhW
KRK on bhphotovideo: bhpho.to/2uTxyWL
------------------------------
Follow me on instagram at / digitalstereophony for the latest updates and behind the scene look
-----------------------------
All the tracks used in this video can be found here:
• Test Tracks
----------------------------
Sound recorded using Zoom H6 recorder. Levels matched using SPL meter. All tone controls set to neutral - Наука та технологія
They both are great but JBL sounds more accurate to source to me.
Source track win )
Seriously.. maybe if they used a real condenser mic instead of A hand held recorder... no wonder source track sounds best LOL
JBL for me...sound a little more balanced and still hitting hard!
As a general pair of studio monitors, the JBLs would probably be my choice. The KRKs have too much my frequency emphasis, which would make them wear out the listener much faster, and it would cause the listener to take a lot of high frequency presence out of their mixes, which would result in duller mixes. Also, the JBLs have a much more clear mid range, which seems to me to be the most important focal point for smaller studio monitors.
I say all of this as an owner of the KRK 5s.
Robert Simpson I own the krks as well. The mids are are muddy from a hyped low mids/ lows. Just bought jbls
Can you do a comparison of small studio monitors in the future?
I would be radically interested in a versus of the following smaller ones:
- Yamaha MSP 3
- Presonus Eris 3.5
- AKAI RPM3
vs source track.
(Merry Christmas by the way... ))
Merry Christmas and Happy Holidays everyone!!! :)
which do you suggest for edm bedroom use ?
JBL
@@DSAUDIOreview Hey, thanks for your response .Last question. Ever heard of alesis m1 330 / monkey banana gibbon 5? Maybe you want to try those and make a video. No one really done that with these 2 mentioned. Thanks , happy holidays.
I have heard neither of those, can not promise any video with them any time soon... Cheers!
@@DSAUDIOreview Understood. You should try. The Alesis pair is quite impressive IMO! Bye Bye.
Sounds like the JBLs, when paired with a subwoofer that is set very, *very* subtly to fill in some of the bottom octave, would be just about an audiophile-grade rig.
budget monitor speakers trounce most boutique hifi bookshelf
i'm a new dj i'm at the second step to choose my monitoring speakers. the first step was done and i bought the roland dj 808. i'm lost in choosing studio monitors with a nice precision of low and high frequencies with a very precise sound rendering. i'm leaning a bit towards the adam series. what do you think about the adam t5v? or t7v? would it be a good choice?
I really want to hear these at volume low enough to not be heard by someone outside a room. I gather some speaker have issue with that
What buy for mixing/produced edm?
JBLs still on top for me here.
Sound of KRK as usual colored, but this time it's very accurate and gentle. Looks like not a bad option for typical home using, not producing music in a studio
У крк все прекрасно кроме 3 4 кгц где подъем. У джбл проблемки по всему спектру.
@@extremumone Zdrastvuyte. ya polzunok ekvalayzera na 8k uvelichivayu krk bolshe shipit . a na rayone 4k nechevo ne zametil. Skajite pojalusta kakie problemi u JBL. U KRK BASS na 85h 80h vishe a 40hz i 45Hz nije chem u JBL 305P (ne MK2). Sposibo
which one is good for mixing and mastering jbl 305 or rokit 5..?
А мне оба нравятся)
I've owned both (currently JBL). The JBLs have a wide open Soundstage, almost holographic 3D character whereas the KRKs sound bad if you move a few inches away from the sweet spot. However the KRK mixes translated cleaner and punchier in my car (possibly bc the speakers perhaps had similar characteristics). Both are good in their own way
I have the same thing with my RP5G3 in my car !! I have cool sound with good bassline ..... but on other systems, my tracks sound often with less body and too much highs :( Thus I'm searching for the same speakers but more flat .....
2:00 what track is ?
I think the test is flawed because when the krk was playing the highs was tweeted a bit
JBL for recording/mixing. KRK for multimedia/listening..
Thats from the reverberation between your ears
@@trollingisasport Ano pinagsasabi ng puking inang to? Hampasin ko ng makalawang na tubo to eh. Lol
Hi! Which one do you recomand for bedroom use? I’m not into producing/mixing, and i just want to use them for listening sessions (genres: drum & bass, techno, r&b music). Thanks and nice channel tho! 😁
For listening, Krk
KRK for multimedia and listening..
what was recorded
?
Which one is better for Making Pop,Rnb music , Mixing and Mastering ?
i have the same question lol ..... I have at home RP5G3, HS7 and eris 4.5 .... and each speakers has his problem lol ....
who plays castaways?
The JBLs sound a tad hollow
Krk have a wider soundstage and a bit crisper highs. I still prefer the jbl
oleg ozon I don’t understand
@@gigigigiotto1673 Use Google Translate lol.
He said: Not sure, it seemed to me that the JBL scene is better and the sound is less colored and better balanced.
And he right
Darius S yes, that’s why I said I still prefer the jbl
yeah but krk have shape in the sound and that's fucken important
Please test q acoustics 3020i vs. Jbl
which one would you recommend for recording?
JBL between those two
Thank u!!
No hip hop tracks? Do people really use KRKs for rock music?
looks like
Hi! For mix rap and trap, what monitors do you recommend?
Krk bro.
There's not any monitor made for one music style in specific, don't look monitors to mix rap or trap, you must go for the most flat response monitor, for me, KRK got too much bass which makes you believe your songs have a good amount of bass when is not really like that, JBL have more flat response and the waveguide helps you to be more comfortable in your sweetspot.
It doest matter which music style you work, you must be wise at the time to pick a monitor for your studio and that means to forget about the music you make and start to think in the real sound you must have at the time to mix and master, not matter what style you do.
Está buena la ideas pero date cuenta que atrabes del cl tu comparación no tiene resultado ok 👍
JBL, nice bass definition , KRK oversaturated highs...
Maybe the position of the MIC in the recording, KRK has the tweeter lower (or near the cone of the bass)
Me gusta el Rokit 5 se escucha mejor audio.
I prefer JBL, more flat to music production
BEAST STUDIO MONITOR AND MIXING KRK SAMPALE PLAY REAL SOUND JBL FQ LOOS GOOD KRK
KRK Rokit 5 RP5G3 its incredible , more sharp i like it !!!!!!!!!
KRK warmer, more pleasant sound.
305 tighter and smoother sound
warmer????? no
more bass at 85Hz 80Hz but at 45Hz epsent compare to JBL 305P
krk have more shape in the sound which is critical for mixing
Don't think so mate, that's just personal opinion though :) my take on krks is their mids are a bit muddy and their low end is boosted more than it should be, they sound fantastic to listen to music on, not so much for mixing and mastering, but again, personal choice
@@joshsmith7812 I have had the KRKs, Yamaha, 2 generations Of mackie's JBL, M-Audio's ... For Mixing and sound clearity/ quality i would take the JBLs hands down.
Krk Sounds Crispy
JBL just crossed Rokit’s
Krk is brighter ..has more highs but that does not traslates in more clarity..jbl sounds clearer more even and pleasing..imho.
No the krks has more low end then anything it lacks mids and highs .. mids are very muddy
@@IGoTDaaKeys true .... RP5 G3 too much bass and hollow between 1Khz and 6KHz ....
I can't tell if the source sounds more true in either speaker. The JBL sounds more pleasing to my ears but might translate to a shit mix.
JBL
krk sound more rich beacuase it a a/b class amplifier, its nociable, just need to develop better twetters, the jbl is clear but has no contagious, in my opinion krk are better overall, but the jbl has good energy saving because of the class D, wich will save more money in the end.
kRK GOT beat up on like Ableton did pro tools ... the krk 6's came back for the title in 2021... The JBL RULE was FOR THREE YEARS ! JBL should be smacking down krk with a new release looking for that... Krk lost the title 2018 to 2021 !
woah def buying jbls KRK and yamaha suck
Both have injection plastic baffles... Rokits have ICs from 2003 with 0.5% thd... THEY SUCK!!!
Suck my dj booth with stanton group hanpins from germany
GOOD FOR MIXING KRK JBL FQ LOOSE
if the speaker comes balanced like the jbl then it will be harder to mix bc the balance is already there duh
No that's actually the opposite, if the speaker is already giving you a warm sound and low end/mid boost, you're not going to focus on perfecting those (unless you really know your krks, you can get good mixes with them) but the JBL is balanced meaning it's easier to hear what you should boost and cut in the mix, if you have a speaker that's not balanced, getting a balanced mix on them is more difficult because you have to compensate for that, if your speakers are really bright already and your aim is to have a bright sounding mix, it isn't always easy to go about achieving that because your speakers already sound bright, instead of being overall tonally balanced where it's easier to then take away certain freqs and give your track what if needs to make it sound warm and bright - and it'll then translate well to other systems
If you've made a mix on bright sounding speakers, when it's played on other systems and less bright systems it (could) not sound good.
So I'm not saying you can't make good mixes with krks but I find they're too warm and punchy for my liking (great for listening to music) but I want to perfect my mixes on a speaker that reveals flaws and weak points in the track so that it sounds even better when played on other speakers.
@@joshsmith7812 thank you I got the jbl
@@dn_oux 😂😂
Josh Smith agreed i have the krks now and i cant mix .. and its frustrating like maybe it sounds good while im mixing but when i play them back on other devices it sounds horrible .. so what i’ll do is grab a pair of jbl’s for mixing then play them back on my krks !
WTF !!
krk shitsound
jbl are for movies and krk are for music
crack is for winners
DN OUX - lol... Your opinion is invalid, sorry.
Bahahah
@@trollingisasport you must be on crack if you believe what im saying lol itz a joke pluz I got the jbl and nobody in the game is producing movies like me 😆 i bet if you had the jbls you wouldnt even know how to use them properly! I bet you dont even know what volumes to produce at!
@@whodisguy7003 jaja im kiddng chill plus id destroy all competition with a pair of jblss
This is a nonsensical way to make a comparison. Wr are limited by two things. Your microphone and my speaker. This is a truly waste of time.