Kelly’s rebuttal was literally the most savage shit I’ve ever seen in my life😂 both classy and harsh with getting to the point. I love her so much. The quote from her blog is in the description btw.
@SummerLover20 she was not attacking the notes or saying anything bad about Taylor in fact I believe she says that EVERYONE HITS A BAD NOTE, she was saying something mean toward the record label for downplaying her abilities as a singer because she got famous on American Idol.
@maryanneproductions She wrote over 60 songs for My December and then chose the ones that are on the album, she wrote all of them. She also wrote Because of You when she was 16 years old fyi she can write and she can sing.
@ParamorexFarro I know what you mean. She seems to suffer under nerves. When she's in a concert hall full of people there to see her because they love her then she's fine and sings fantastically. But when she's on live tv in front of millions including legends and then singing with Stevie Nicks. Who wouldn't get nervous?
Love both of them, but i think her record label shouldn't shade other peoples talent by criticizing the show that revealed them to make Taylor poor performance more accpetable, it was a stupid thing to do. Kelly had the right to defend herself and the show that turned her huge. Classy lady, amazing singer.
@caseynicholemusic Kelly wrote every song on My December, she also wrote Because of You which was an amazing song at the age of 16... yeah some songs she works with other writers or uses but she makes plenty of demos and wrote like 60 songs for my December before deciding the ones she wanted. She can write her music too. people do not know enough about the things they dislike.
@tracycookable I never disliked Kelly. I think she is just as talented as well. I just felt the need to stick up for Taylor because Taylor is a great songwriter. I feel as if everyone is bashing her just because she doesn't have the perfect singing voice. I'm sure Kelly has some good song ideas too but I can relate to Taylor's more for some reason. It doesn't mean I like Taylor better.
are you serioius? No competition. Kelly wins all the way. Kelly is one of my the best singers ever! Taylor is just another cutsie country singer with an ok voice and not a lot of singing talent. Kelly is so much more.
I love both of them so much they are both idols of mine but Kelly Clarkson is so inspirational to me and the Stronger song always lifts me up when im down so Kelly FTW
i also realized swift was holding all of those not deserved grammys. as kelly was doing her thing that she does best, singing and at the same time being good at it.
How is Taylor Swift the most emotional performer? UA-cam the video of her singing Brenda Lee's sad song "I'm Sorry." Notice how she's smiling the entire time.. (And flat, of course.)
@lightningshock12 Taylor wins time and time again, but i just don't get it. I guess it's for the teenybopper crowd. Not that I haven't enjoyed anything she ever did, I have. Just not on the same level as Clarkson. She is really moving in her songs.
I love both Kelly and Taylor, but really you can't compare the two. kelly is in a completely different league to Taylor, and has overall got a much better voice. that's obvious. In my opinion, what Kelly said was completely right. taylors label shouldn't put others down, to big up their own artist.
@iSAW7 lol then what's Katy Perry's excuse she sucks live too. A lot of musicians are chosen for style and looks and that is what they are. That with a fake voice that is showy and changed with computers. If compared to cars that would be like having a beautiful car but it doesn't start... you wanna hear that engine purr. Stupid analogy but it fits.
@SmileyV07 Yeah she was huge for like a second! Her Already Gone song sounds like a rip off of Beyonce's Halo. So that's toward how greatly interpreted Kelly is when it comes to song writing! How is Taylor overatted? I never heard people naming kelly the voice of the generation!
@BeatriceRyal I do like kelly but that was uncalled for. She doesn't have to say that just because Taylor Swift is more popular than she has ever been. Taylor has won more awards then her
no disrespect but the SEMI attractive face that LITERALLY always has and still does belong to taylor swift LITERALLY never has and still doesn't equal the attractive face that LITERALLY always has and still does belong to kelly clarkson
Kelly Clarkson is without a doubt one of the best pop singers of all time.I like Taylor Swift but she had no right saying that statement. I know it's not her that said that but this wasn't supposed to go out but that was sooo funny good one Kelly xD
She is 20. Im being serious when I say I thought she was teenager. I mean her fans always brag about her writing like its good. I guess I figured she was teen because she always writes about fairytales.
Taylor is one of my favorite singers, but she isn't the best. Kelly Clarkson is soo much better and her advice is useful. Not the best 'technical singer'? Oh yeah, I bet THAT cheered Taylor up.
TS isn't the best singer from what i have seen of her, and I'm not a "fan" I'm not even from the States! But Kelly is a better singer technically, wither she won a Talent show or not! She's done quite well for herself, as has a great voice, and seems like a nice Girl to boot. ;)
The main difference between Taylor and Kelly is like her manager said Taylor's voice and how she sings is garbage when compared to Kelly's, Kelly has a higher range, a louder and stronger voice and when I saw her concert this year Kelly live = Better than her actual recordings and i'm not kidding! But I think Taylor's manager was WRONG when he said Taylor's more emotional, Has he ever heard Because of you,Cry, Stronger, Behind these Hazel eyes that's TRUE emotion! Team Kelly FTW!
come on comparing taylor swift to kelly lool if i was kelly i would probably just post a commeent saying "no comment" lool i never saw a flawless preformance by taylor i mean she doesnt deserve the fame she got kelly said it not only does she hit the high note she also hits the right note unlike other... hatts off for kelly
@SmileyV07 Miley songs get on my nerves she can't write anything the only reason she is famous is because her daddy! They were gonna have JOJO do Hannah Montanna but she didn't want to deal with wearing the wig and didn't want to do the show as long as they wanted. In my opinion JOJO would've made a better Hannah Montanna!
Taylor has nothing to do with this.It's Kelly Clarkson VS Taylor's stupid record company.Still Taylor is nothing vocally compared to Kelly.Nor emotionally o-O. Love them both though ;o
@maryanneproductions i think you dont know who is kelly clarkson !! who wrote " because of you " , " addicted " , " behind theses hazal eyes " , " sober " , " maybe " ... etc . at least kelly CAN sing any song PERFECTLY ... taylor SUCKS at singing her OWN songs !!
Kelly is a lot better at everything. I don't hate Taylor but come on. I still can't believe she is 20. This just proves what bad writer she is. She is way to repetitive to be considered great.
listen to Tay's first self album titled in 2006, pure country. Then 2008 Fearless, Fearless have different topics, not just dating a boy haha. But I agree. Both Avril Lavigne and Kelly Clarkson will destroy Taylor at live singing haha. Taylor is really terrible live.
@aboo00oode992 i know who kelly clarkson they are both talented, but kelly should stop getting so defensive when american idol is nothing but a fuckin joke anymore
kelly wins!!! duh!!! its obvious!!! taylor sings soo crappy live!!! which means she doesn't even sing good at all!! singing in live shows a singers true voice!! i'l giv u another example!! fergie!!! ever heard her live???? hahaha anyway kelly is my fav singer!! she rox!!! everyone knows dat!! plus kelly won american idol which is a LIVE performance! and she sings sooooo amazing!!! hw can ppl ever compare hr with taylor!!! taylor is so dead infront of kelly!!! (sry 4 ppl who
i don't like taylor at all! i think the music she does is only the same thing, it's anoying and boring, and besides she doesn't have a good voice or a voice that we can remember easily
Kelly’s rebuttal was literally the most savage shit I’ve ever seen in my life😂 both classy and harsh with getting to the point. I love her so much. The quote from her blog is in the description btw.
@megankalu1
She had "nerve" problems. To comment on her vocals you have to see her live in concert.
@SummerLover20 she was not attacking the notes or saying anything bad about Taylor in fact I believe she says that EVERYONE HITS A BAD NOTE, she was saying something mean toward the record label for downplaying her abilities as a singer because she got famous on American Idol.
@maryanneproductions She wrote over 60 songs for My December and then chose the ones that are on the album, she wrote all of them. She also wrote Because of You when she was 16 years old fyi she can write and she can sing.
You can't not blame other singers for your bad performance. I'm glad Kelly stand up to protect herself.
I like t swifts songs but I don't like when she perform vocals.Kelly can sing high notes.Kelly sings far better than taylor swift
@ParamorexFarro
I know what you mean. She seems to suffer under nerves. When she's in a concert hall full of people there to see her because they love her then she's fine and sings fantastically. But when she's on live tv in front of millions including legends and then singing with Stevie Nicks. Who wouldn't get nervous?
Taylor can born how many times she wants still would lose to Kelly
Love both of them, but i think her record label shouldn't shade other peoples talent by criticizing the show that revealed them to make Taylor poor performance more accpetable, it was a stupid thing to do. Kelly had the right to defend herself and the show that turned her huge. Classy lady, amazing singer.
@caseynicholemusic Kelly wrote every song on My December, she also wrote Because of You which was an amazing song at the age of 16... yeah some songs she works with other writers or uses but she makes plenty of demos and wrote like 60 songs for my December before deciding the ones she wanted. She can write her music too. people do not know enough about the things they dislike.
"not only do we hit the high notes, we hit the RIGHT notes" okay im a huge fan of both kelly and taylor but omg i love kelly haha
I remember this mic dropped moment by QUEEN KC...still hillarious after all these years! I love KC
taylor can become great live.,,just give her some time.
This comment aged like fine wine
@tracycookable I never disliked Kelly. I think she is just as talented as well. I just felt the need to stick up for Taylor because Taylor is a great songwriter. I feel as if everyone is bashing her just because she doesn't have the perfect singing voice. I'm sure Kelly has some good song ideas too but I can relate to Taylor's more for some reason. It doesn't mean I like Taylor better.
Kelly Clarkson of course
Taylor Swift is soooooo amazing . She's a role model ! Best singer , and best inspiration !!
all these comments from years ago make me laugh.
amen, David Chapman or whoever is her producer should be awarded the grammy for fixing her voice like they do....
are you serioius? No competition. Kelly wins all the way. Kelly is one of my the best singers ever! Taylor is just another cutsie country singer with an ok voice and not a lot of singing talent. Kelly is so much more.
I love both of them so much they are both idols of mine but Kelly Clarkson is so inspirational to me and the Stronger song always lifts me up when im down so Kelly FTW
YOU GO KELLY!!! MAJOR BURN ON SWIFT!!!
Somebody once told me that singers and musicians are a dime a dozen but songwriters are what creates it all.
Kelly Clarkson is by far a talented musician than Taylor Swift....
i also realized swift was holding all of those not deserved grammys. as kelly was doing her thing that she does best, singing and at the same time being good at it.
Haha, what that Scott Bullshitta said was an obvious jab at Carrie, since she and Taylor are always being compared. Glad Kelly spoke the truth.
kelly is my idol, she is amazing a so down to earth, anbd if you dont know kelly is fan of taylor swift, kelly even cover her songs too
How is Taylor Swift the most emotional performer? UA-cam the video of her singing Brenda Lee's sad song "I'm Sorry." Notice how she's smiling the entire time.. (And flat, of course.)
@tracycookable Sorry I just had to stick up for Taylor because I felt that everyone was bashing her.
@lightningshock12 Taylor wins time and time again, but i just don't get it. I guess it's for the teenybopper crowd. Not that I haven't enjoyed anything she ever did, I have. Just not on the same level as Clarkson. She is really moving in her songs.
taylor she is amazing
I love both Kelly and Taylor, but really you can't compare the two. kelly is in a completely different league to Taylor, and has overall got a much better voice. that's obvious. In my opinion, what Kelly said was completely right. taylors label shouldn't put others down, to big up their own artist.
Listen to Kelly's third album that she wrote herself and you'll see true emotion. Pop is harder to show emotion in than in country.
Kelly all the way
@iSAW7 lol then what's Katy Perry's excuse she sucks live too. A lot of musicians are chosen for style and looks and that is what they are. That with a fake voice that is showy and changed with computers. If compared to cars that would be like having a beautiful car but it doesn't start... you wanna hear that engine purr. Stupid analogy but it fits.
WOW! ididn't realize how BAD of a singer swift is, of coarse i've always and forever will be a CLARKSON FAN!!! GO KELLY!
@SmileyV07 Yeah she was huge for like a second! Her Already Gone song sounds like a rip off of Beyonce's Halo. So that's toward how greatly interpreted Kelly is when it comes to song writing! How is Taylor overatted? I never heard people naming kelly the voice of the generation!
@BeatriceRyal I do like kelly but that was uncalled for. She doesn't have to say that just because Taylor Swift is more popular than she has ever been. Taylor has won more awards then her
Wow Kelly got really defensive but Taylor didn't have to earn her name from a tv show! Taylor writes her songs guessing Kelly doesn't!
taylor i mean, taylor has no natural voice
you cant compare them cuz kelly sings pop but taylor sings country and kelly just sing songs but taylor composes. i luv taylor and kelly.
no disrespect but the SEMI attractive face that LITERALLY always has and still does belong to taylor swift LITERALLY never has and still doesn't equal the attractive face that LITERALLY always has and still does belong to kelly clarkson
People are mad at taylor while taylor said nothing, lol, kelly is a fan of taylor
Kelly Clarkson is without a doubt one of the best pop singers of all time.I like Taylor Swift but she had no right saying that statement.
I know it's not her that said that but this wasn't supposed to go out but that was sooo funny good one Kelly xD
She is 20. Im being serious when I say I thought she was teenager. I mean her fans always brag about her writing like its good. I guess I figured she was teen because she always writes about fairytales.
Taylor is one of my favorite singers, but she isn't the best. Kelly Clarkson is soo much better and her advice is useful. Not the best 'technical singer'? Oh yeah, I bet THAT cheered Taylor up.
TS isn't the best singer from what i have seen of her, and I'm not a "fan" I'm not even from the States! But Kelly is a better singer technically, wither she won a Talent show or not!
She's done quite well for herself, as has a great voice, and seems like a nice Girl to boot. ;)
i bet taylor swift wouldn't even make it past the auditions on American idol
The main difference between Taylor and Kelly is like her manager said Taylor's voice and how she sings is garbage when compared to Kelly's, Kelly has a higher range, a louder and stronger voice and when I saw her concert this year Kelly live = Better than her actual recordings and i'm not kidding! But I think Taylor's manager was WRONG when he said Taylor's more emotional, Has he ever heard Because of you,Cry, Stronger, Behind these Hazel eyes that's TRUE emotion! Team Kelly FTW!
come on
comparing taylor swift to kelly lool
if i was kelly
i would probably just post a commeent saying "no comment" lool
i never saw a flawless preformance by taylor i mean she doesnt deserve the fame she got
kelly said it not only does she hit the high note
she also hits the right note unlike other... hatts off for kelly
@SmileyV07 well i asume that everyone who are hannah montanna fans are too young! Miley Cyrus sounds like a goat giving birth when she sings live!
Kelly just jealous that taylor got 4 grammy :)
Swiftie Otaku seriously?? haha...Talent is more important
I think kelly is right and she did not said anything bad about taylor.
@SmileyV07 Miley songs get on my nerves she can't write anything the only reason she is famous is because her daddy! They were gonna have JOJO do Hannah Montanna but she didn't want to deal with wearing the wig and didn't want to do the show as long as they wanted. In my opinion JOJO would've made a better Hannah Montanna!
Love Kelly!
KELLY CLARKSON ALL THE WAY!
Taylor has nothing to do with this.It's Kelly Clarkson VS Taylor's stupid record company.Still Taylor is nothing vocally compared to Kelly.Nor emotionally o-O.
Love them both though ;o
Taylor is what? Twenty years old and "writes"
about fairytales....
I rest my case
@maryanneproductions i think you dont know who is kelly clarkson !!
who wrote " because of you " , " addicted " , " behind theses hazal eyes " , " sober " , " maybe " ... etc .
at least kelly CAN sing any song PERFECTLY ... taylor SUCKS at singing her OWN songs !!
KELLY CLARKSON
Kelly is a lot better at everything. I don't hate Taylor but come on. I still can't believe she is 20. This just proves what bad writer she is. She is way to repetitive to be considered great.
Kelly destroys Taylor at live singing
but Taylor destroys Kelly at songwriting hahaha
I lvoe them both but Taylor is too overrated
Kelly
Yeah, Kelly! You rock and talyor dosn't:)
TEAM KELLY! Kelly can high higher notes than taylor. Other than that Kelly is just perfect
KELLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY
@jakejackson101 At least Kelly actually eats...
TAYLORRRRRRRRR SWIFTTTTTTTTTT
All the way ! Dont compare her to Kelly, cause for sure..
TAYLOR SWIFT :)
-DIE HARD SWIFTY..
Bebe Balbuena feel bad for you that you listen to one tone, off key Taylor Swift
@maryanneproductions joke or not the contestents CAN actully sing !!!
taylor isnt great singer , she is BAD singer :)
is there any good excuse for taylor's record company...rediculous!
Taylor Swift is not the voice of the genration. She not really
listen to Tay's first self album titled in 2006, pure country. Then 2008 Fearless, Fearless have different topics, not just dating a boy haha. But I agree. Both Avril Lavigne and Kelly Clarkson will destroy Taylor at live singing haha. Taylor is really terrible live.
backing kelly up 11%
@aboo00oode992 i know who kelly clarkson they are both talented, but kelly should stop getting so defensive when american idol is nothing but a fuckin joke anymore
what is a Kelly Clarkson she must be a no body
marco dedominicis Rip english
kelly clarkson the best
Kelly is much better then Taylor in every way. Is this a joke?
GO kelly clarkson and Taylor Swift is not the voice of this genration
NOT THE BEST. but she's good.
kelly wins!!! duh!!! its obvious!!! taylor sings soo crappy live!!! which means she doesn't even sing good at all!! singing in live shows a singers true voice!! i'l giv u another example!! fergie!!! ever heard her live???? hahaha anyway kelly is my fav singer!! she rox!!! everyone knows dat!! plus kelly won american idol which is a LIVE performance! and she sings sooooo amazing!!! hw can ppl ever compare hr with taylor!!! taylor is so dead infront of kelly!!! (sry 4 ppl who
she's really good BUT SHE IS NOT BETTER THEN KELLY CLARKSON!!!!!! SORRY BOO BOO =)
i don't like taylor at all! i think the music she does is only the same thing, it's anoying and boring, and besides she doesn't have a good voice or a voice that we can remember easily