Should stolen African art be returned? | Inside Story

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 252

  • @adolfowilliams
    @adolfowilliams 3 роки тому +63

    Should something stolen be returned?
    Is that question real?
    Ignorant question.

  • @internationaltutor2941
    @internationaltutor2941 3 роки тому +50

    Stolen art or any other stolen items should always be returned to their rightful owners when possible. It's ridiculous to ask any victim of theft if their property should be returned to them.

    • @Pepe-dq2ib
      @Pepe-dq2ib 3 роки тому

      What if the leader of the country sold it?

    • @Pepe-dq2ib
      @Pepe-dq2ib 3 роки тому

      @Nathair So the corrupt Congo leader that sold Congolese art has to buy it back 80 years later? As far as i can tell, they won't pay a dime.

    • @Pepe-dq2ib
      @Pepe-dq2ib 3 роки тому +1

      @Nathair if its something that can proven to be stolen, then they should be returned. I agree that it gets tricky when museums buy them either legally or they "though" they bought it legally. They will demand to be compensated with currency inflation. There is also the situation where nobody is confident their government can keep the artifacts safe; mainly countries that get tied in wars frequently or have active terrorist groups that have been know to destroy artifacts.

    • @iseeyou2810
      @iseeyou2810 3 роки тому +1

      @@Pepe-dq2ib stop lying, nobody sold these arts and if they did is because the dictators who the west put in charge gave to them.

    • @Pepe-dq2ib
      @Pepe-dq2ib 3 роки тому

      @@iseeyou2810 stop lying, nobody stole these arts and if they did is because the Rothschild put in change gave to them.
      I guess everyone's innocent then if you just use convenient excuses. Look at the current legitimate Afghan government being the Taliban. I wouldn't be surprised if they decide to sell off all the Buddhist artifacts. Are you going to blame the west when the Taliban blew up two of the oldest Buddhist statues in 2001? I am guessing you went to the school of "only whyts can do evil".

  • @dvsxavier
    @dvsxavier 3 роки тому +56

    Is this a rhetorical question? Yes it should, along with all the other stolen priceless artefacts from Asia, Middle East, Central America, etc. etc.

    • @EuDouArteHipHopArtCulture21
      @EuDouArteHipHopArtCulture21 3 роки тому +6

      I even laugh at the title

    • @jonathansheats3583
      @jonathansheats3583 3 роки тому +5

      That's the first thing I thought when I saw the title. Why are we debating this? The fact that there are people fighting against it is incredible to me.

    • @fairuzdin3012
      @fairuzdin3012 3 роки тому +3

      Dont forget the gold,gems and diamonds too

    • @schneejacques3502
      @schneejacques3502 3 роки тому

      @@jonathansheats3583 It depends. For example a Japanese pirate stole Chinese and korean artifacts during 16th century. Should those be returned?

    • @jonathansheats3583
      @jonathansheats3583 3 роки тому +3

      @@schneejacques3502 I would have to say anything stolen should be returned to the rightful owner if possible. To me it's that simple.

  • @Mamba0809
    @Mamba0809 2 роки тому +7

    Not only returned but money are to be awarded as well.

  • @Art_Travel_and_Hobbys
    @Art_Travel_and_Hobbys 3 роки тому +15

    Of course it should be returned... It wasn't a gift. Smh 🤦🏾‍♂️

  • @eddahmwihaki4953
    @eddahmwihaki4953 2 роки тому +3

    Africa were highly civilized before colonial who elooted and demonizing and claiming African were illiterate..also deciphering them .

    • @TotalSwitchYoutube
      @TotalSwitchYoutube 5 місяців тому

      tell me any civilization in Sub-Saharan Africa that was highly developed and had any impact the modern world with something? Ethiopia maybe, due the contact with Egypt and Middle East, but that's it.

    • @elvisom.o.g4457
      @elvisom.o.g4457 2 місяці тому

      ​@@TotalSwitchUA-cam yr colonier mindset hv make u so stupid

  • @TauvicRitter
    @TauvicRitter Рік тому +4

    In the UK it's against the law to return stolen art from a museum. It's crazy but true. Not all law is based on justice.

  • @marcostation1000
    @marcostation1000 2 роки тому +5

    soon england will have only fish and chips on the museums.

  • @mrclatxx3007
    @mrclatxx3007 3 роки тому +9

    The title here is way off.....'should' is underated......it MUST be returned. It's our heritage, our culture.

  • @jascam1
    @jascam1 Рік тому +8

    The descendants say they’re not responsible to pay reparations for the sins of their fathers. Those same descendants have no problem wallowing in the riches of their inheritance a direct result of said sins.

    • @tfordham13
      @tfordham13 Рік тому

      And? They didn't steal it

    • @pearls1626
      @pearls1626 8 місяців тому +1

      The Best comment.
      The descendants are also lotting our resources they too are thieves.
      “Can an Ethiopian change his skin
      or a leopard its spots?
      Neither can you do good who are
      accustomed to doing evil.”
      ‭‭Jeremiah‬ ‭13‬:‭23‬ ‭NIV‬‬

  • @SaraLima-s7n
    @SaraLima-s7n Рік тому +1

    IT IS NOTJUST ORDINARY ART WORK,IT HIS A library to THE PEOPLE OF BENIN,THE BRONZE WORK ,GOD BLESS THE BENIN PEOPLE AMEN

  • @inyourselfbelieve1013
    @inyourselfbelieve1013 3 роки тому +3

    Will they return lives lost, stolen and still being stolen in terms of African resources, and part of their GDPs African countries pay for gaining independence?

  • @eduwino151
    @eduwino151 3 роки тому +10

    If British museums returned all LOOTED artefacts there will be no museum left to visit

    • @AlexRoseLebreton
      @AlexRoseLebreton 3 роки тому +2

      Good. Then their countries can educate them on how it took centuries for them to return stolen heirlooms. As they rightfully should.

    • @ltaylor9878
      @ltaylor9878 2 роки тому

      Too bad for them I thought they had so much history as they claim!! History seems to be unfolding the story of real history!!

  • @yahnesaa.5520
    @yahnesaa.5520 3 роки тому +3

    It is cursing the takers. "Thou shall not steal."

  • @ajiroakomo9163
    @ajiroakomo9163 3 роки тому +4

    Would we be asking the same question,if Barclays Bank was ROBBED and we knew where the THIEF and MONEY were ???

  • @acemoney8427
    @acemoney8427 8 місяців тому +1

    Why should I have to travel to Europe to learn African history like I literally would have to travel and put money into Europe’s entire economy to learn my history. Instead of being able to travel back home learn Africa see Africa and know my history and see the art

  • @aab777barry5
    @aab777barry5 2 роки тому +2

    KNOW YE NOT YOUR BIBLE STATES: "WHATSOEVER A MAN SOWETH THAT SHAL HE REAP."

  • @aab777barry5
    @aab777barry5 2 роки тому +2

    HOW DARE U COLONIZERS???
    RETURN OUR PRICELESS ART NOW WITH PUNITIVE DAMAGES & THE TIME VALUE OF MONEY!!!

  • @marcostation1000
    @marcostation1000 2 роки тому +1

    england have no artis or art, so they cant give art back like spain, france or italy.
    because they can create their own art but england can not.

  • @heatherbooth4217
    @heatherbooth4217 2 роки тому +1

    Sorry? What kind of question is that? Of course they should.. it's embarrassingly long overdue on the European's part. I fear that taking too long to return will give the thieves an opportunity to fake them in place of the original. Museums will close at this rate and rightly so.

  • @AlexRoseLebreton
    @AlexRoseLebreton 3 роки тому +7

    Should the queens jewels be returned? I’d argue they weren’t hers in the first place.

    • @quantumsneak1773
      @quantumsneak1773 3 роки тому

      She doesn't own them,
      Rothschild and Oppenheimer do.

  • @alphaandomega1able
    @alphaandomega1able 2 роки тому +3

    Items shall be returned to owners. Europeans countries have hands and fingers. They can start making their own items from now. However the museum will loose money because African Arts items brings money to the museum and the European country that has stolen them.

    • @alphaandomega1able
      @alphaandomega1able 2 роки тому

      @Eternal Promises it seem to be the ultimate solution.

    • @tfordham13
      @tfordham13 Рік тому

      There artifacts they can't be replaced they should be kept safe

    • @ellishaindobo1794
      @ellishaindobo1794 Рік тому

      @@tfordham13 the arrogancy! why dont you borrow us that ugly mona lisa if you mean business?

    • @ellishaindobo1794
      @ellishaindobo1794 Рік тому

      @@tfordham13 EAD actually.

    • @tfordham13
      @tfordham13 Рік тому

      @@ellishaindobo1794 what

  • @duanebidoux6087
    @duanebidoux6087 3 роки тому +3

    Seriously? The answer is so simple: yes.

  • @markeddowes1467
    @markeddowes1467 3 роки тому +5

    Copies to museums…….originals returned to their homelands.

    • @geoms6263
      @geoms6263 3 роки тому

      Copies to to their homelands……

  • @dewaeryadi7776
    @dewaeryadi7776 3 роки тому +5

    Of course, we also need to return their people, rich talented footballers, doctor and scientist

    • @maseratireid
      @maseratireid 2 роки тому

      Please tell me your not in America 🤣

    • @ellishaindobo1794
      @ellishaindobo1794 Рік тому +1

      How about the Gold and Diamonds too? How about you take all of your mining companies out of here as a bonus?

  • @williamkuhns2387
    @williamkuhns2387 2 місяці тому

    Yes absolutely return however the risks of museums being broken into and treasures stolen is big! Unless these treasures are kept under high security 24 hours a day they can be stolen and sold on private market. Even museum employees can be corrupt. Case in point what happened in Iraq national museum in early 2000s. US troops looted the treasures and the so-called Baghdad Battery has never been found.

  • @pearls1626
    @pearls1626 8 місяців тому

    Really Aljazeera? Who is right? 😢
    Someone stole my car, does anyone has the right to ask if my car should be returned to me?

  • @aab777barry5
    @aab777barry5 2 роки тому +2

    OUR STOLEN ART SHALL NEVER AGAIN BE SEEN ON THE LAND OF OPPRESSORS... RETURN OUR STUFF NOW SO THAT WE CAN SAFEGUARD WHAT BELONGS TO US!!!

    • @tfordham13
      @tfordham13 Рік тому

      Pfff you make me laugh no their safe where their at if returned they will be destroyed

  • @st.george007
    @st.george007 3 роки тому +2

    Why would the thieves wish to hold on to said loot? All that continued possession proves is that you are still in denial over the theft in the first place. Returning the loot would demonstrate compassion and a willingness to be a better global citizen. Good to see an institute that bears Jesus's name is following his teachings. Stone of Scone and Elgin marbles please, don't even have to leave UK or Europe on these two.

  • @saix81
    @saix81 3 роки тому +1

    To answer the question, should anything (whatever, from whomever) stolen from its rightful owner be given back?
    What sort of question is this really?

  • @aaroniquedemeritte5218
    @aaroniquedemeritte5218 2 роки тому +1

    They need to return Africa's people also so they can rebuild their kingdom again.

  • @alphaandomega1able
    @alphaandomega1able 2 роки тому

    President Macron Well done. Many French people live in Cameroon and they love Cameroon. Other European countries shall follow your example.

  • @zengoreseb1352
    @zengoreseb1352 Рік тому +1

    Remember god is watching and punishment will come one day

  • @abe_ismain
    @abe_ismain 3 роки тому +6

    Should stolen European art be returned? 🤪

    • @airwriq
      @airwriq 3 роки тому +4

      Sure why not... any examples?

    • @tulioferreira6523
      @tulioferreira6523 3 роки тому +1

      @@airwriq the Pathernon marbles from greece

    • @airwriq
      @airwriq 3 роки тому

      @@tulioferreira6523 Ofcourse, along with what the British hoarded from everyone else.

  • @corwinchelway9969
    @corwinchelway9969 3 роки тому +15

    The funniest part is if these artifacts were left in Africa... they would already have been sold on the black market.... Some Russian Oligarch would have them in his basement... so this is a piece about OUTRAGE over preserving these pieces better than the 'original owners' ever would have....

    • @ramijackson3978
      @ramijackson3978 3 роки тому +12

      Racist bullshit and nothing more

    • @KYM-12
      @KYM-12 3 роки тому +16

      Oh shut up, devil. If the true owners want to sell it, it’s their right because it’s theirs. I want to say more but Screwtbe won’t let me. 🙄

    • @BC-mj7gj
      @BC-mj7gj 3 роки тому +15

      It's no one's business whatever people do with their properties, that doesn't make thieves innocent

    • @littleseamstress
      @littleseamstress 3 роки тому +14

      canned colonizer language

    • @TheDaeroner
      @TheDaeroner 3 роки тому +3

      You're talking bullshit.

  • @prosperosifo9061
    @prosperosifo9061 3 роки тому

    Yes with immediate effect

  • @markmbiti3674
    @markmbiti3674 2 роки тому

    I wonder why the tsavo lions haven't been returned back to Kenya it's our heritage

  • @inyourselfbelieve1013
    @inyourselfbelieve1013 3 роки тому

    Africans should concentrate on getting their continent back. Treat their citizens well. Asking for artifacts is peripheral and a non-issue.

    • @juda210
      @juda210 2 роки тому +4

      The ignorance of this comment is baffling

    • @bishopshort6271
      @bishopshort6271 9 місяців тому

      Ignorant mufo

  • @quantumsneak1773
    @quantumsneak1773 3 роки тому +2

    Yes!
    And all the stolen people!

  • @ijBTeam
    @ijBTeam 2 роки тому +1

    Like my grandmom do say to me Be Good for Good is Good.....
    Since the whole W.... Stole from Bini
    Bini hardly steal from Nigeria or even within Bini if not fighting themselves as if their right stolen imagined themselves been the kriminal

  • @blaiseaggrey486
    @blaiseaggrey486 2 роки тому

    They should all be returned

  • @alankent
    @alankent 3 роки тому +2

    I think one or two items could remain but in exchange give the african museums a Picasso or a Rembrandt

  • @johnkesich8696
    @johnkesich8696 3 роки тому

    No, it was stolen fair and square.
    [sarcasm off]
    But seriously, what sort of dumbass question is that?

  • @hamedismaeal1288
    @hamedismaeal1288 3 роки тому +4

    Yes 100%

  • @user-en1zc5vd6y
    @user-en1zc5vd6y 3 роки тому +1

    Dear @InsideStory/aljazeera, your question is extremely offensive

  • @ThankGode
    @ThankGode 3 роки тому +15

    When it comes to the world of investing, most people don't know where to start. Fortunately, great investors of the past and present can provide us with guidance.*.

    • @sandrabliss7646
      @sandrabliss7646 3 роки тому +1

      Most intelligent words I've heard

    • @ericsonlinda8391
      @ericsonlinda8391 3 роки тому

      I heard that his strategies are really good..

    • @roylarson8934
      @roylarson8934 3 роки тому

      He has really made a good name for himself.

    • @cedricrick3684
      @cedricrick3684 3 роки тому

      Self trading is not advisable to newbies because it got strategies which only professional broker knows more than us.

    • @Kenan-gk7eh
      @Kenan-gk7eh 3 роки тому

      He's Really amazing with an amazing skills he changed my 0.3btc to 2.1btc..

  • @dvsxavier
    @dvsxavier 3 роки тому +1

    In reality, none of it will be returned.

    • @AlexRoseLebreton
      @AlexRoseLebreton 3 роки тому

      Correct, but can we at least dream that these people would hold themselves accountable at some point? I know that’s naïve but I hate the way things are and I wish we could speak more openly about that at least.

  • @richardhart9204
    @richardhart9204 3 роки тому

    Yes, it's all stolen property and should be returned. However, the very sad fact is, right now, they're safer where they are.

  • @edenheart3934
    @edenheart3934 2 роки тому

    If you really cared and valued your stuff, you would not let it be so easily stolen.

    • @elvisom.o.g4457
      @elvisom.o.g4457 2 місяці тому

      Criminal and colonizer mindset,thank God you know u are a thief😂

  • @digittechzonehd6753
    @digittechzonehd6753 2 роки тому

    The wakanda of this new world

  • @WHOHATESTOWORK
    @WHOHATESTOWORK 3 роки тому +2

    Same in Aotearoa, Stolen Taonga slowly making its wat back home, mostly tracked to european owners, go figure😆

  • @Nomasterss97
    @Nomasterss97 3 роки тому +2

    Yes of course must be

  • @aaroniquedemeritte5218
    @aaroniquedemeritte5218 2 роки тому

    Welcome to the program I'm hammer zum jum! Wtf🤔🤔🤔🤫

  • @kakiuw7543
    @kakiuw7543 3 роки тому +1

    I am not a nationalist, and considered these treasures of the whole humankind. I prefer them staying in places that is resourceful and can take good maintenance of these masterpiece. Don't want to see another loss such as the fire of National Museum of Brazil or the Cape Town libraries.

    • @cmn5463
      @cmn5463 2 роки тому +1

      Would you be happy if someone took your family heirloom because they belive you are not able to take care of it....even if it is belongs to your family they consider it to be a treasure for the whole human kind.!

    • @kakiuw7543
      @kakiuw7543 2 роки тому

      @@cmn5463 If I don't have proper condition to store them (like temperature and humidity regulating cabinets, or fireproof safes), I will be more than happy sending them to proper museum.

    • @cmn5463
      @cmn5463 2 роки тому +2

      @@kakiuw7543 Please stop lying. There is no way you will allow a stranger to take a sentimental family heirloom that has been past on from generations in the name of storage. These traditional artifacts are not treasures for the world. They are a cultural heritage of those communities and as long as one is not a part of that community they have no right over them. Insinuating that they should not be returned to their countries is supporting colonialism.

    • @ellishaindobo1794
      @ellishaindobo1794 Рік тому

      My preference is to own your spouse. I believe you would not take care of them properly.

    • @kakiuw7543
      @kakiuw7543 Рік тому

      @@cmn5463 Sorry for the belated reply. I think that, the current inhabitants of a land, might not necessarily be the cultural successor of a previous communities of the land. People conquer, expel, migrate, go into diaspora, move around, exchange and mix all through history. Sometimes, there is nothing called "their countries" to return to. (But may be for many ex-colony in Africa, the case is different. I am not familiar.) And secondly, it might just be a simple wish to preserve valuable artefacts, eg., when the communists came into power in china decades ago, many top scholars rushed to get artefacts out to Taiwan, to then British Hong Kong, lest them get destroyed. And those artefacts escaped the cultural revolution where numerous tombs, temples and schools across the country got burnt to the ground.

  • @colinpatterson728
    @colinpatterson728 2 роки тому

    Persians come and get them!!

  • @kayssehadji3734
    @kayssehadji3734 3 роки тому +2

    Stupid question al Jazeera yes yes yes......................................yes.

    • @geoms6263
      @geoms6263 3 роки тому

      definitely NO

    • @Komeshokakunanwene
      @Komeshokakunanwene 3 роки тому

      Aljazeera is one of them. But it is inevitable, they will have to return them in the end. It's not even a question of whether they want or not.

  • @イアンゴ
    @イアンゴ 3 роки тому

    My question as an African is ,will it still be in the same good conditions if it was in Africa? After africa was colonized and destroyed africa became A very poor continent, all these artifacts wouldn’t survive in Africa,before even talking about this issue,first we should be able to provide for our people basic needs like food,clean water,and electricity. These artifacts should be returned when we will be able to take care of them properly. We should think logically and not emotionally don’t let the title of this article to trigger you.(Africans)

    • @ranmaruthompson930
      @ranmaruthompson930 3 роки тому

      Uuum sure...

    • @Komeshokakunanwene
      @Komeshokakunanwene 3 роки тому +1

      You sound European!

    • @bishopshort6271
      @bishopshort6271 9 місяців тому

      This dumbo sound European, ofcause they would still be in good condition, why were they created in the first place

    • @elvisom.o.g4457
      @elvisom.o.g4457 2 місяці тому

      Take yr story to yr european ancestor, is non of yr business

    • @イアンゴ
      @イアンゴ 2 місяці тому

      @@elvisom.o.g4457 lol I’m African why you guys are always so emotional instead of rational, I didn’t say Europeans don’t need to bring it back I’m saying would it be keep in a good condition In africa since Africa is majority a poor continent with no good conditions to keep stuff like that for a long time .

  • @artdefiesgravity8013
    @artdefiesgravity8013 3 роки тому

    This network should Stop talking about Africa, esp since it’s main goal is to de stabilize it

  • @inyourselfbelieve1013
    @inyourselfbelieve1013 3 роки тому

    I wonder what games they're playing? 🤔🤔🤔

  • @otakusenpai3737
    @otakusenpai3737 3 роки тому +1

    Sooooo who r those who dont want to return the objects... their point of view?

  • @mohammadafridiofficial8452
    @mohammadafridiofficial8452 3 роки тому +1

    Please cover Tripura's (Indian North East State ) Muslim Genocide News

  • @tigerish7tiger12
    @tigerish7tiger12 3 роки тому +2

    Why not is that even question?

  • @matthewstewart5113
    @matthewstewart5113 3 роки тому +1

    Look threw the churches basement 👀👁 transparent as limestone and granite.

  • @urimtefiki226
    @urimtefiki226 3 роки тому

    Should be changed with Must.
    Archeology is the basis for development of a culture of a nation.

  • @ChrystalClear
    @ChrystalClear 3 роки тому

    They better return them.

  • @EL-ub2df
    @EL-ub2df Рік тому

    8:50

  • @kabumanuw163
    @kabumanuw163 3 роки тому

    Its good that the anglo empire is the weakest of all the empires that have risen otherwise they would be no people left

  • @EuDouArteHipHopArtCulture21
    @EuDouArteHipHopArtCulture21 3 роки тому

    I mean the question is priceless .

  • @aqoonqaate8109
    @aqoonqaate8109 3 роки тому

    Come one the most valuable ones is gone by private rich people

  • @livefromplanetearth
    @livefromplanetearth 3 роки тому +1

    should this question have to be asked

  • @townsville69
    @townsville69 3 роки тому

    Just give each African country a shopping cart and 60 minutes of free for all in the national museum. Fairs fair.

    • @townsville69
      @townsville69 3 роки тому

      @@Officialfantasiastoryteller Not true. I'm a culture vulture.

    • @Komeshokakunanwene
      @Komeshokakunanwene 3 роки тому

      @@townsville69 do you even know why this "artefacts" exist in the first place, Since you are a culture vulture?

    • @ellishaindobo1794
      @ellishaindobo1794 Рік тому

      We want everything.

  • @hw7318
    @hw7318 3 роки тому

    Ask the British Museum.

  • @ionwerks
    @ionwerks 3 роки тому +1

    We're just keeping them safe.

  • @AwilsonBLOGME
    @AwilsonBLOGME 3 роки тому

    What is all the african art found in louisville ky that was stored in a warehouse on the news

  • @patriciapalmer1377
    @patriciapalmer1377 3 роки тому +1

    If the stolen art in international museums and collections had to be returned, we'd be sitting here in 20 years still trying to figure out provenance.

    • @FlyingSpaghettiMonster2000
      @FlyingSpaghettiMonster2000 3 роки тому

      They set up companies to deliberately obfuscate ownership of art looted from Jewish families in wwii. Still not recovered, over 75 years later

    • @patriciapalmer1377
      @patriciapalmer1377 3 роки тому +1

      I grew up in a community of survivors, where blouse and shirtsleeves riding up arms often revealed tatoos. I'm familiar with what you're saying.

  • @chodesmond6373
    @chodesmond6373 2 роки тому

    Most of these artefacts won’t be in existence today if they weren’t taken to Europe. Regardless, I’ll imagine it caused a lot of pain to the indigenous people at the time these artefacts were taken. Hopefully they will be returned to our local museums So some of us can learn more about our history.

    • @titaniaxoxo6170
      @titaniaxoxo6170 Рік тому

      "Most of these artefacts won’t be in existence today if they weren’t taken to Europe" lol what????
      What an ignorant comment, do you have any idea of the damage the colonizers did?
      It would still be there in-fact we would have richer cultures, but they were all sniffed out of existence, a crime against humanity
      I can't believe someone would say such a thing

    • @ebonyd4ever
      @ebonyd4ever Рік тому +1

      This is disturbingly a paternalistic response. Are you implying that the people of Benin would not have been able to reverence their own history appropriately? Let's not forget that the reason these artifacts are in Europe is because of a punitive expedition that resulted in centuries of deprivation and interference because of colonialism?

    • @maxpower6979
      @maxpower6979 Рік тому

      It's funny because Africa produced and kept its cultural treasures for hundreds of years before Europeans came.

  • @teodoradinkova653
    @teodoradinkova653 3 роки тому

    YES

  • @airwriq
    @airwriq 3 роки тому

    Yes

  • @littleseamstress
    @littleseamstress 3 роки тому +1

    um YEA?

  • @jinchuriki7022
    @jinchuriki7022 3 роки тому

    Finders keepers

    • @TheDaeroner
      @TheDaeroner 3 роки тому +1

      Except, people were murdered for these heritage items. These things weren't found... They were stolen.

    • @iseeyou2810
      @iseeyou2810 3 роки тому

      Doesn't that show you how you people lie about Africa had nothing yet you are keeping and won't let go of art that people you called non human for centuries made?

  • @queenform
    @queenform 3 роки тому +1

    they are safer in European countries

    • @johnnyjai6804
      @johnnyjai6804 3 роки тому

      good an excuse, it's never return to owner

    • @Komeshokakunanwene
      @Komeshokakunanwene 3 роки тому

      Sure, where they are auctioned off sometimes.

    • @queenform
      @queenform 3 роки тому

      @@Komeshokakunanwene in african countries they are either destroyed, end up in some corrupt politician's or warlord's toilet, or sold to european countries
      either way they're safer in european countries

    • @Komeshokakunanwene
      @Komeshokakunanwene 3 роки тому

      @@queenform yeah! And the museums there conduct auctions for some of this peaces (a proven fact) to hand it to some uncorrupt and honest individual Europeans to keep them safe anywhere but their toilets in their homes, away from destroyed Africa and it's corrupt politicians (a fact that is not proven, only assamptions). You have a point there.

    • @queenform
      @queenform 3 роки тому

      @@Komeshokakunanwene pretty much yeah
      either way it is safer in European countries

  • @pamelawing626
    @pamelawing626 3 роки тому +2

    Honestly, I'm kind of torn. I understand why countries want their artifacts back, but selfishly, if some of those items were in African, I would never have been able to see them. I know, I'll get trashed by some and that's fine, I just think the artifacts should not be hidden. Also, if there is a lot of chaos going on in a country, they are safer where they are. Look what ISIS did to many of the historical treasures in Syria, and I'll never forget the Taliban destroying the Buddha. I realize that figure would never have been in a museum, but the point is, where there is upheaval, these pieces can be destroyed or sold off.

    • @TheDaeroner
      @TheDaeroner 3 роки тому +11

      Yeah but we in previously colonised countries would rather our children and our children's children view them and know their history. You want to see them, then make a trip to Nigeria, China, Peru and all other pillaged countries

    • @CarolynHyppolite
      @CarolynHyppolite 3 роки тому +10

      Tourism in Africa is a thing.

    • @saix81
      @saix81 3 роки тому +10

      First of all, whoever created those artifacts did not do it for you to see them. Africans made them for themselves, not for you Pamela.
      Secondly, you talk of chaos going on in a country. Which country specifically? Or do you see all Africa as being a chaotic continent - all 54 countries, where we don't have museums that you can visit? To be honest, I think you share the same mindset with those plunderers of Africa. If the thieves that stole those artifacts were able to access them, what would deter you from seeing them in Africa?
      But always remember this: you don't really have to see them. They weren't made for your entertainment anyway

    • @Komeshokakunanwene
      @Komeshokakunanwene 3 роки тому +8

      Don't you people have art of your own making for your viewing and entertainment? Must you deprive the owners and makers of this art from seeing them and accessing them, just because you feel snatching this art from them for yourself is rather better and excusable? Consider the circumstances of the chaos you mentioned when they where stolen in the first place, Britain and their European cousins where at the center of this chaos just like they are today (though you might think they have nothing to do with it today, they orchestrated this chaos). Whatever you think does not matter, this is Africa's culture and history, it should not belong to anyone else but them, they should decide if you or any other non-African should view them or not.

    • @pamelawing626
      @pamelawing626 3 роки тому

      @@Komeshokakunanwene This isn't just viewing and entertaining, it's the history of mankind. A lot of these artifacts have been taken from museums and sold to fund the terror groups, or destroyed ,especially by ISIS and the Taliban. Those treasures are evil to them.
      ISIS nearly destroyed the ancient city of Palmyra and Syria has been trying to repair and rebuild it. Palmyra is one of THE most important cities of the ancient world and is a World Heritage site. The thing is, recreating the destroyed structures is not the same as the REAL structure, but It will have to do.
      So the debate goes on. The Museum Of The Bible returned over 5,000 pieces to Egypt not too long ago, as they should.
      So, it will be up to governments to figure it out. Also keep in mind that often residents of the countries from which this pieces came, were complicit in their removal, they were looted and sold to the highest bidder.

  • @faruqolatoyosi713
    @faruqolatoyosi713 3 роки тому

    Is this even a question?

  • @AbrarArman443
    @AbrarArman443 3 роки тому

    😲

  • @geoms6263
    @geoms6263 3 роки тому

    definitely NO

  • @quietcell
    @quietcell 3 роки тому

    Yes

  • @donaldfoster5959
    @donaldfoster5959 2 роки тому

    Yes