Ranking All Of The Eyeshadow Palettes I've Tried In 2023 So Far
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 лип 2024
- Shop My Favourite Products Here! - shoplist.us/martinalily
Hi Friends,
Today we are ranking all 17 of the eyeshadow palettes I have tried so far this year! And yes, that is a lot of eyeshadow lol PS Let me know what your fave eyeshadow palette is so far this year!
Videos Mentioned:
Adept Cosmetics Review - • Trying Adept Cosmetics...
Oden’s Eye Review - • Oden's Eye Perfect Wor...
Tom Ford Cherry Smoke - • GRWM Using An Almost F...
Tom Ford Forbidden Pink - • Tom Ford Traceless Sof...
Pat McGrath Labs Ritualistic Rose - • GRWM Pat McGrath Labs ...
Pat McGrath Labs Nocturnal Nirvana - • A Lot Of New Makeup Fi...
Pat McGrath Labs Love Collection - • Pat McGrath Labs Love ...
Kaja Orange Blossom - • Full Face Of My Favori...
Victoria Beckham Beauty Silk - • Full Face Trying New V...
Natasha Denona Zendo - • Full Face of New (To M...
Natasha Denona Circo Loco - • GRWM Trying The Natash...
Natasha Denona Mini Pastel - • Natasha Denona Mini Pa...
Eyeshadow Palettes Mentioned:
Tom Ford Cherry Smoke Eyeshadow Quad
AU: go.shopmy.us/p-1208723
US: go.shopmy.us/p-1208683
UK: I couldn’t find it in the UK sorry!
Oden’s Eye X Makeup Just For Fun Flora Story Palette
Worldwide: go.shopmy.us/p-1165775
Oden’s Eye X Lauren Mae Beauty Sea Talk Palette
Worldwide: go.shopmy.us/p-1165776
Pat McGrath Labs Blitz Astral Quad in Ritualistic Rose
Worldwide: go.shopmy.us/p-1145439 (Currently Sold Out Sorry!)
Pat McGrath Labs Velvet Liaison Palette
Worldwide: go.shopmy.us/p-1110807
Pat McGrath Labs Blitz Astral Quad in Nocturnal Nirvana
Worldwide: go.shopmy.us/p-1174665
Victoria Beckham Silk Eyeshadow Palette
Worldwide: go.shopmy.us/p-1248533
Pat McGrath Labs MTHRSHP Sublime Seduction
Worldwide: go.magik.ly/ml/1qxd1/
Pat McGrath Labs MTHRSHP Iconic Infatuation
Worldwide: go.magik.ly/ml/1qxd1/
Natasha Denona Zendo Palette
AU: go.magik.ly/ml/1qunk/
US: go.shopmy.us/p-1035991
UK: go.shopmy.us/p-1035992
Natasha Denona Circo Loco Palette
Worldwide: go.magik.ly/ml/1qoem/
Cult Beauty: go.magik.ly/ml/1qoen/
Natasha Denona Mini Pastel Palette:
US: go.magik.ly/ml/1pywm/
AU: go.magik.ly/ml/1pywl/
UK: go.magik.ly/ml/1pywo/
Kaja Orange Blossom Beauty Bento
AU: go.shopmy.us/p-1103415
US: go.shopmy.us/p-1103417
Worldwide: go.magik.ly/ml/1r9mi/
Tom Ford Forbidden Pink Eye Color Quad:
go.shopmy.us/p-1075981
Adept Cosmetics Arrow Inspired Palette (Not Available anymore sorry)
Adept Cosmetics Minka Palette
Worldwide: www.adeptcosmetics.com/
Natasha Denona Mini Love Palette
AU: go.shopmy.us/p-1248539
US: go.shopmy.us/p-1248538
UK: go.shopmy.us/p-1248539
Timestamps
00:00 - Intro
01:15 - 17
02:42 - 16
04:39 - 15
05:51 - 14
07:16 - 13
08:53 - 12
10:33 - 11
12:16 - 10
14:25 - 9
17:10 - 8
19:10 - 7
20:22 - 6
21:57 - 5
23:09 - 4
24:34 - 3
26:34 - 2
27:59 - 1
*My Favourite Brushes:
Rephr Brushes
Worldwide: rephr.com/?vr=malily
BK Beauty Brushes
BK Beauty Brushes - Use code MARTINA10 for 10% off (PS code is not affiliated but link is)
Worldwide: go.magik.ly/ml/1j9h3/
*Affiliate Links (PS If you shop through these I make a small commission. PPS if you do shop through these thank you so so much! All the money goes straight back into my channel and creating content for you guys! xx):
Pat McGrath Labs: go.magik.ly/ml/19h2i/
Sephora US: go.magik.ly/ml/19hed/
Sephora AU: go.magik.ly/ml/19hec/
Cult Beauty: go.magik.ly/ml/19hef/
Beautylish: go.magik.ly/ml/19heg/
Revolve: go.magik.ly/ml/19heh/
Beauty Bay: go.magik.ly/ml/19hei/
♦ SOCIAL MEDIA ♦
INSTAGRAM
@martina_lily_
/ martina_lily_
TWITTER
Martina_Lily17
/ martina_lily17
Email for business or PR enquiries -
martinalily17@gmail.com
A Little About Me:
Skin Type: Combination Skin
Skin Undertone: Neutral - generally I am a light neutral shade
Thank you for watching!
Martina Lily
xx
#eyeshadowpaletteranking #paletteranking2023 #patmcgrathlabs #natashadenona
FTC Disclaimer: This video is NOT sponsored. All opinions are 100% mine. I only talk about products I genuinely like and only give honest reviews.
ALL LINKS are affiliate links * Affiliate links meaning if you click the link and purchase items through that link, I will receive a small commission on that purchase*
So many pretty palettes! One thing though, MTHRSHP and Mothership are different and have always been designated that way. Her 10 pan palettes with the special shades are Motherships. The 6 pans without special shades are MTHRSHPs (all caps, no vowels). She used to release a MTHRSHP with the Motherships as a complimentary palette. It’s been a while since she’s done that, but the 6 pans have been designated that way since the beginning. It’s unnecessarily confusing, but they are different
Edit to add the Bridgerton MTHRSHPs are the first and only 6 pans that included a special shade
I know.... but I still think they should have a special shade hahaha For me it's Pats signature so she needs them haha 💗💗
Thank you for sharing! Interesting tidbit
@@MartinaLily I have a feeling she’s having trouble sourcing ingredients for her special shades. Bridgerton was the last time we saw a true special shade. One was clearly just gigabyte renamed. The blue one in the first Bridgerton palette was basically just Astral white with more blue pigment/glitter added. Mothership X, while gorgeous, didn’t have any of the baked Blitz Astral shades. Your Nocturnal Nirvana quad definitely has a different texture than my OG one did. You got an OG Ritualistic Rose, which is one of the reasons I think you might like that one better. If her next Mothership doesn’t return to having the 4 baked shades, it’ll cement it in my mind that there’s a supply chain issue
@@stefaniemezigian414 Yeah makes sense to me. I hope it's changed for this years mothership!
I have tons of palettes I just swatch and they make my heart happy ❤ so I don't think it's silly at all if it brings you joy! I love your videos, and your swatches and explanations of why you love them!
I second this!
I'm sorry, but I really do not understand such waste. If you want to swatch pretty shades, go to the stores and go for your life with every brand and colour laid out before you. Unless you're one of the rather wealthy who can afford to purchase rather expensive palettes simply to swatch the 'pretty shades', I think this is a terrible waste. People are starving and homeless, with others living through what seems never ending wars. There are very real issues going on in the world today that's far more important than sticking fingers into eye-shadows instead of wearing them. I have no objection with you buying all the palettes you like to enjoy wearing whist appreciating the shades and packaging. Yet to purchase an item, not for its intended use, but simply to swatch pretty colours is not only selfish but rather immature as well. Why not buy endless expensive high-end fashion to display but never wear? Where does this silliness stop? Each day I see evidence of societies around the globe becoming even more self absorbed and selfish. No-one even cares enough to check on the welfare of a neighbour anymore. The decline in values that were held above all else are nothing but a far distant memory now. It's by spouting such ludicrous statements such as being so self-centered to only think of your own joy that is the decline of societies. By all means, purchase things that make you happy and bring you joy, yet not in such a flippant and wasteful manner where you're not using the product for its intended purpose. That, I cannot agree with. If you love colour, become an artist and then the possibilities of colour are endless! Maybe, become a make-up artist and use these lovely shades on another whilst bringing both of you great joy. Why not experience the joy of gifting some of your "tonnes of palettes" to those who cannot afford a single one? Imagine the joy that can bring you and that person if you let it. I don't mean to come down on you, but with the endless waste throughout the world, someone has to eventually state the facts and I'm afraid it's your turn today. I simply live in hope of making this a better world where we can share our joy and not keep it solely to ourselves when we know so many have never experienced your privilege nor mine. Please don't take this as a personal attack, as it's not. I'm just so frustrated at the decline in societal values today that I felt I needed to say something that may even inspire you to find a way to spread your joy. We can only live in hope. Take care.💖🕊
Thank you so much! 💗💗
I love that Zendo was higher up your list than I anticipated. I LOVE Zendo. It does not get enough praise!
I also love the Pastel mini! I really wish she’d redo Circo Loco in a midi. I’d snap it up!
I am surprised you don’t love Nocturnal Nirvana more! I love it so much-even the gold. I don’t think it’s different from the original one because the pan size is large. Her newer made quads (like in the last year or so) in the black lacquered packaging have smaller (but deeper) pans now. I think your swatches look like how mine swatches, and I got it when it was released.
I am getting so much use out of my all matte Pat 6 pan, too! Now I’m going to be greedy and ask her for an all matte palette in her 5 pan palette matte formula!
Zendo and mini pastel definitely took me by surprise for sure. I do love NN don't get me wrong, I think just compared to the other shades I have from her and from my indies it just isn't as unique and wowing as some of the other palettes in this ranking but I do love it still. And more all matte palettes! haha 💗💗
Loved the “ Hello friends” 😀. Great vid as always. 👍🏾Deb
Martina you are GORGEOUS! Love this look on you! I agree with you on the Kaja stacks! I thought you were gonna compare them to ND formula but they are so so good! I have 2 already and I have 4 more in the mail on their way to me bc Kaja had a big sale on some of them and I got them for like $8 a piece!
I love ritualistic rose, and it's so nice to have a quad like that one to travel (I wouldn't dare travelling with a big Mothership palette).
I wanted 2023 to be a NO BUY YEAR, but Lauren Mae did a collaboration with Oden's eye, which I love both of them. I had to break it immediately & get myself the treasure palette wink wink 🐚 🧜♀️ ❤ I expect nothing less from Lauren ❤
I'm prepared to see it ranking high in everyone's "best of 2023 palettes" video at the end of the year 😅🎉
I love the Oden’s Eye palettes so much! I’m happy you tried the brand!!
🌷Love Your Video Queen🌷
😻Gorgeous thumbNail Tho😍
Beyond Beautifully You Are
Ur Makeup Always On Point
😘Super Pretty Lipstick oN u🖤
Enjoy your Sunday Too
Have a Magnificent Week Ahead
😇Stay Bless N Be Safe Always😇
I bought the sea talk palette and I’m obsessed, it’s simply perfection. I also bought the palette spirit palette for a colorful look ❤since I don’t have the circo loco from nd i thought it could be a nice purchase
Your PML Noc Quad looks nearly the same on the eye. After wearing mine a few times and just now watching your swatch again, I do think it’s a different formula. It looks nearly identical tho but watching you swirl your pan? Mine doesn’t do that, it’s her original/harder formula (not hard pan) but it does have the dimension and is GORGEOUS on the eye (I’m happy they have their own base too!).
OTN: I do think your formula is more user friendly and doesn’t require a learning curve (how everyone used to complain that her formula did)
That's great to know thank you! 💗💗
Lipstick deets, please!!!
Gucci 510 Johanna Burgundy
Love you channel. ❤️😍
Watching from India 🇮🇳
Martina love❤ one of my shiniest eyeshadow I tried this year is the Bobbi Brown Luxe Eyeshadow Quad just released. Is the one with the moonstone and sunflare! If you haven’t try these baked shadows , pls do as they are limited edition. I got mine from Selfridges ❤
Ohh I'll check em out thanks Molly! 💗💗
I’ve been trying to resist but I just ordered the Oden’s eye Sea talk palette while watching this. 😂 so much for my no buy. 😇
Aw well I hope you love it! 💗💗
I really enjoyed your videos!! I agree with your #1 palette, it's beautifull
Thank you so much!! 💗💗
I love this lipstick on you 😊
I ordered Odens eye palettes yesterday . Thank you very much, Martina ❤
Oh I hope you love it! 💗💗
Fantastic vídeo, as usual!! I put my attention in your number 2 of PM.
Thank you! 💗💗
Just started this video and wow, you look beautiful! I love this sophisticated chic look on you. The dark hair slicked back and deep lip are killer on you. ❤
Aw thank you so much 💗💗
Hi Martina! The circo loco palette looks intimidating that's true, I use it as a companion palette and surprisingly I use it a lot! And the ritualistic rose quad... I have almost all the quads from pat and I think it's my favourite, pure perfection
They are all pretty eye palettes! Out of all the ones you ranked so far, I have the pat mcgrath mat collection. ❤
Martina, I totally agree with your ranking. I too was very pleasantly surprised with the Sea Talk palette, and although I will get some creasing after about 5-6 hrs of wear, the color story is impeccable and the Smoky Pearl shade is one of my favorite all time shades out of my entire collection. I definitely have been reaching for it ever since I got it ❤
I'm so glad you are loving it too! And agreed the smokey pearl is amazing
I have such difficult needs!!!! I still buy palettes that I don't use!!!!! I really wear only dark, deep and cool colors. I hate rainbow shades. Moreover, I believe that a make-up must adapt to the context where it is worn. Well.... Denona Glam palette, Glamlite CHUCKY, J. Star Cremated, Melt Marie Jane.... These are my daily choices, yet I own hundreds of pallets 🙈🙈🙈Adept I don't know when I'll ever use it, except maybe for a pop of color on a dark and almost gothic structure😂
The SEATALK palette took me by surprise too! I've created so many looks with it and I'm still inspired. The combination of neutral but exciting colors is blowing my mind. My number one palette of this year so far, too. Would love to see more looks from you with this palette
Cannot agree with you more, it is so beautiful! And yes I will be for sure 💗💗
I picked number 1 as soon as I saw this video title!!! 💖💖💖
I sold your number #5 due to the MAJOR fall out…. No matter what I did and I can’t do my base after my eyes, I just can’t and know since I can’t I miss out on a lot of beautiful shimmers but it is what it is unfortunately
You looked absolutely stunning❤ I’m no longer interested in the TF Cherry Quad which is odd bc it was one of my most wanted! Looks like I need to get that Zendo palette! *whispers* I love the red shadow😅Omg that Kaja palette is gorgeous! That orange is calling me! Lauren’s palette is my fave of the Oden’s eye collab! I loved this video❤ I cannot wait until your year end ranking 💃🏿💃🏿 I don’t envy you because already there have been so many great palettes and it’s only March!😅
I just bought the Kaja Orange Blossom Bento box for $7. Chocolate Dahlia is one of my other favorites. They were having a one day flash sales. Now, they have a regular 30% off sale. I also love the Oden’s Eye Sea Talk Palette. Lauren put together such a cute color story. Yes, the formula is lovely.
OMG $7 that is a steal! She really nailed it didn't she
💋💋💋
I have to admit I'm surprised by a few ranks but I have to agree for the most part! Also, super love your #1
How I know our make up love and decisions are the same well…. Sea talk I only picked up the Flora and went back and fourth on Sea talk went back and it was sold out so YES I hope to pick it up when it drops, thought it was the 25th and now I will check and sure it’s going to fly after all the good reviews EEK
Edit it’s the 27th but can’t pick it up until Friday fingers crossed it will last
😆💕🥰 I knew that PML all matte 6 pan would be up there for you ☺💕 hope you’re having a good week 💕
Haha I'm too predictable! Thanks lovely, you too 💗💗
@@MartinaLily also more proof I believe we are sharing a brain when it comes to makeup …. My favorite shade in zendo is yama and i took ut the bright red shade 😂😉☺💕🥰
@@megdvs21 Haha twins!
I’m glad you like the kaja bento boxes. I’ve heard great things about them on YT, but the reviews on Sephora are iffy. People complain about the glitter fallout they get on their face, so I never wanted to try them at full price. I got a few for $7.80 to try this past week during a great sale.
What a great ranking! I knew the PM all matte palette would rank high, however I am surprised with your number 1! Only because you are more of a nuetral lover over color but your explanation of why makes total sense! I still haven't ordered Sea Talk or Flora. I'm trying to stick to my guns and hold back and waiting for the nxt PM, ND, Adept, and Glaminatrix releases! So much exciting makeup this year so I'm trying to be extremely choosy on what I decide to get! I am also surprised with your ranking of Nocturnal Nirvana. The older version of the green has a more noticeable purple flip and the Turquoise is a little different as well. The formula looks creamier in the new palette but I prefer the tones in the old version so there are pros and cons to each version. I knew you would LOVE Ritualistic Rose! That peachy gold shade is stunning and is a perfect companion to the all matte palette for gorgeous nuetral looks! ❤
Thanks Melina! Yeah I just love that all matte palette haha I don't know what it is about Sea Talk but I'm just obsessed with the whole thing lol And yes, there is soooo many good releases it hurts lol And yes I'm super surprised by how much I love RR! 💗💗
Can you do a tutorial on the makeup you're wearing? So lovely!
Thank you! I'll try my best 💗💗
Sea talk yeayea I buy to have full order and cheaper tracking flight ,I say ok I try and now so crazy alva is beautiful but I prefer this crazy sea minty, greish- pinky purple reflects
Is my nr1 so lovely eyeshadows
Now I want clionadh
There are a lot of Zendo palettes available on the secondhand market right now (at least in the US) - I picked mine up in January, 100% untouched and still in the box, for around $30, and I absolutely love it! And thus began the slippery Natasha Denona slope ...
That's an awesome deal! 💗💗
Says she’d never wear a red shadow but buys a whole red Tom ford quad 😂😂
Haha right! Honestly I don't why but I didn't think it would be as red as it is lol 💗💗
I agree I didn’t think the TF quad would of pulled that red ,) Social Media I swear one has to explain themselves more than face to face ERRG
@@danielletrue1027 Yes! I'm so glad this wasn't just me haha
I love your Videos. 😊 as a video idea since i have seen this floating around. A theoretical declutter. Going through your collection and showing things you would keep and declutter if you were Not on UA-cam. 😊
Oh I saw Morgan doing this and was thinking the same actually! Could be fun... and stressful haha
@@MartinaLily i feel you 😂 deciding between my eyeshadow palettes would be like picking favorites among my children
@@Anniilein1990 Yes! xx
You look like a chic vamp!
I’m lost here so the highest spot is the least liked ( you know what I mean as you said you like all of them ) down to number one being the most liked or opposite ???
Yep so number is my favorite out of all of them
I would never guess that u wouldnt put pat on first place😮
I know! Who am I?! 💗💗
@@MartinaLily well I am already curious about end of the year ranking🫢
Martina, I have to disagree with you calling the Kaja Set a palette. In my opinion, it's three stackable singles. Anyway, you have surprised me with the rather colourful palettes you've been picking up lately. I don't see you ever wearing them though and not sure why you would waste your money on palettes you won't use, yet maybe it was for your Channel. I've been delving into Givenchy's Eye Palettes this year with only one to go. These shades are spectacular and just as special as those 'so-called special shades' from PML. The colour stories are more suited to you and the formula is faultless. I've never been serious about them before I bought the L/E Christmas 2021 Palette that only came to Sephora a year and a half after first released! We've yet to witness the 2022 Christmas Palette on our shores. I do hope that you managed to grab the Byredo Kalahari Palette from Mecca or at least put your name down to be notified. So far, out of my extremely vast collection of shadows, they are most probably number one in quality. PML doesn't come close! As a side note to everyone who raves on about Vegan/Cruelty Free Brands, let's first understand that it is China who is responsible for keeping animal testing going. By supporting brands like Adept, Oden's Eye, Sugar Drizzle, Nomad, plus endless more brands who tout themselves as being 'cruelty-free', they all have their eye make-up made in China! If we stop supporting the Chinese Beauty Industry, whilst demanding that these brands cease production in China, only then will animal testing cease. Many 'cruelty-free' Channels review make-up made in China/PRC (People's Republic of China) whilst hypocritically claiming they're against animal testing. This topic was bought up on another Channel the other day when Nomad released its new palette and someone stated that in this day and age, animal testing shouldn't be required. I agree 100%! Yet, I'm not the hypocrite that continues to support the Chinese Beauty Industry as I'm aware of the facts. I'd love to see someone who is brave enough to take on this topic - hint, hint. As you're no hypocrite and do buy from all types of brands, it puts you in the perfect position to take on this subject matter. What I wouldn't give to witness someone brave enough to state the facts, yet in an educational manner. Let the viewers know exactly where these 'cruelty-free' brands are made and what they can do about stopping these brands continuing to use slave labour in China and supporting their Beauty Industry at the same time in their home countries. You'd be surprised at how many cruelty-free brands are US Companies, yet use slave labour to have these made in China. I'm quite an expert when it comes to international affairs and one thing that ticks me off the most is hypocrisy! Have a think about it anyway and you know how to get in touch for any further information. I'd be happy to assist if required. Take care, Kris.🇦🇺💖🕊