Black Arabs in the Negev? 🇵🇸 - Are they Palestinian or Israeli? 🇮🇱
Вставка
- Опубліковано 27 лют 2024
- Black Arabs in the Negev? 🇵🇸 - Are the Palestinian or Israeli? 🇮🇱
subscribe to my boy @insightfulNomad
thanks to Alec this video was possible!
Like my content? Support the channel! Become a member by hitting the “Join” button or clicking the link below!
ua-cam.com/users/thetravelingc...
THANK YOU so much for believing in me and helping me to get my message out there. This is my FULLTIME job, and I can’t do this without your support.
In order of preference, the best ways to support the channel are through:
PayPal: thetravelingfat@gmail.com
Buy Me a Coffee: www.buymeacoffee.com/thetrave...
Ko-Fi: ko-fi.com/thetravelingclatt
Patreon: patreon.com/thetravelingclatt
Your SuperChats and SuperThanks are also appreciated (UA-cam takes 30% of this though…)
Buy some fresh Clatt Merch and Rep the channel wherever you go!
teespring.com/stores/the-trav...
Finally, we have a new DISCORD server! Join us there: / discord
also follow me on IG here so see real time update of what I'm doing.
/ thetravelingclatt
The best music service for creators! Sign up for Epidemic Sound using my link! (it supports the channel)
share.epidemicsound.com/sgFGn
My favorite travel insurance for when Im out and about in the world!
safetywing.com/?referenceID=c...
LOVE YOU LONG TIME!
Bedouin people are genuinely beautiful people. I taught for ten months in Rahat in 2015. Such an experience and they are So hospitable. Thanks for this video Tal !
ask israelis how beautiful they are when they have to deal with carjackings, kidnappings,ransom and other. Tal is just naive for showing this. Are there good bedouins? Im sure there are. But these videos give a wrong impression and skip the negative reality unfortunately.
Rahat has really become a part of my heart
SO genuine and beatiful, especially when they ask for ran-som after stiling someones car in Isrel
What a beautiful video. Thank you, Tal!
Glad you enjoyed it!
The meal and hospitality shown here truly was heart-warming. Thank you for showing the true Israel, and the coexistence of all its beautiful people.
100% the hospitality was amazing
Great video. They are Israeli of course.They are peaceful and want to live harmoniously with everyone. Were they safe to visit their families in Gaza? The only Palestinians I’ve seen are the ones on the news post what they did in October. Also, can’t you tell the difference given how nervous you were when you did the West Bank story one year ago? My mother told me stories of her father taking her to visit people like this when she was a girl. She had wonderful memories. We made coffee in a finjan too.
Well there Muslim Arabs so not really Israel. These are the terrorists they claim 😂
Thank you for sharing, they are so polite! ♥️
They are unbelievable
Thank you. I’ve always wondered what Bedouin life looks like inside Israel. Great to see the large communal elements of their culture.
They are amazingly beautiful and compassionate people, I will return to make more.videos with them soon
@@TheTravelingClatt There are a few people in the chat who would benefit greatly from the widom of the Bedouin you visited, instead of obsessively hating on Jews.
ugh.
Thank you for another lovely video Tal. I should probably stop looking at the horrible comments. I don't know how you have the patience in the livechats with some of those guys, especially the death threat one. ❤️
One of your finest videos recently, Tal! I really enjoyed this one and learned something new about the Bedouin of Rahat! Thank you! ❤
Thanks Nat! ❤️
Bedouin don’t belong in Israel
This was so comforting to watch. In the middle off these insane times, to show how Bedouins and Jews live peacefully in Israel, is heartwarming. These communities are thriving in their beautiful lifestyle. No hatred there. Just glad to have all the good things in life. May they continue to thrive, in good health and prosperity, in the land of Israel.
Thank you for this wonderful and informative video ❤
P.S. Magloubah looks amazing. Found a recipe and going to try it out.
100% dude its just love here. This is the magic if Israel
I love this one so much and I really enjoyed the positive vibes.. It really made me smile
Beduins are the most hospitable people I’ve ever met..They dont ask questions, they just hand you a cup of tea, smile and say, welcome..
100% the leave politics at the door and just welcome you no matter what
What I have noticed is most public life is devoid of women in Muslim areas and states.
its called sexual apartheid and its the only real apartheid practiced inside Israel , practiced by muslims .
I didn't notice that until you said it, but yeah you're right... 🤔
I was thinking exactly this when they were eating the nice food and I thought that for sure it was made by a woman somewhere in the back
they don't allow them to be filmed
these women have dignity unlike de western women have no shame
I loved getting to see all of this! Thank you!
I'm so happy you enjoyed it friend!
Beautiful video. Their hospitality is crazy amazing and reminds me of a trip I took to Morocco over a year ago and the hospitality there and the smiles were incredible. Keep up the amazing work Tal 🙂
Happy you enjoyed watching this one friend
Very interesting video. Videos like this humanize the Arab and Bedouin community. It gives everyone a glimpse of a future that involves everyone living together in peace and happiness
They were great and very hospitable
All might live in peace if the Israeli didn't throw the other Palestinians like the relatives of this family to Gaza and another places out of their houses and land to be refugees.they could be live together in Palestine in peace as they lived before occupation.
@@marmar7934 before the state of Israel existed there was not peace in the land. Keep in mind the way towards a peaceful coexistence in the land is to look forward and build towards a future together.
@@marmar7934 ISRAEL DIDNT = UN & ARAB LEADERS DID - ISRAEL ASKED THE ARABS TO STAY & 160,000 DID - THERE ARE NOW OVER 2,000,000 ARAB ISRAELI'S . TRUE FACTS - OF COURSE THE LIES PUSH SOMEONES AGENDA FURTHER .
I really enjoyed this video.. thank you..
Thank you for watching!
What a cool video, one of my favorites in the last few months Tal ! Beduin culture is so interesting and I really admire their dedication to family. Would be interesting to learn more about their families/clans, or how they differ from Beduins in the North or from other countries
Thanks pal! It's nice to see ya in the comments again!
Yah,they are betrayal . 🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮🤮👎👎👎
This is a marvelous video! I am enjoying it very much. There is so much for me to learn and understand! Thank you!!
Such a beautiful people with the rich culture! Thanks for showing this film.
Thank you for sharing the true life of the Bedouin life , hope to see more of your blogs 😊
Appreciate you!
Nice video 😊these guys are very hospitable and friendly
interesting flag. what is the story behind it?
nice flag 👍.
What nice people. Thanks for sharing Tal 😊
It looks amazing, hospitality and sociability is build in.
Where are women?
Rosa, USA
Great video!! I hope their community gets all the resources it needs to thrive. The food looked delicious too 😄 I gotta be honest though, the title feels a bit clickbaity! I was really interested in hearing more about the Black Bedouins history etc! Do you think you could do a video on that?? Thanks again, I'm a new subscriber and happy to learn more!
I'm going to try for sure!
Love this vlog! Visited the same community 2years ago and met a very kind, hospitable, big-hearted lady (Housnia) and her family who cooked a meal for my team of
I saw one woman walking through the voting area, but none in the voting line-up. I suppose women do not vote?
this is the real apartheid practiced inside Israel , its called sexual apartheid and its practiced by muslims .
I'm not sure if they do or don't, I saw a few women in their cars waiting on people to return from.voting, but as for the law they have the right to vote under the state of Israel.
Whether or not they are permitted to by the community is a question I didn't even think of asking to be honest with you
The law in Israel - All the women, all the genders have the right to vote. Some religious arabic villages in the country take the rights from women.
Why should women vote?
Dear Tal!
Rahat is not only Israel's biggest Bedouin city, but the biggest in the world!
More importantly:
RIP Abu Ahmed Latif, a true Israeli hero, who I believe is from Rahat as well! Such a beautiful human soul, who died exactly the way he wanted, sadly this happened way to early!
May Abu's legacy as long as the world stands!
And at the same time there are people in the world who claim that Israel is an apartheid country 😂 thanks for this great video!
I have nothing but the highest level of respect for the Bedouin peoples. My father, who was in the 6 day war, has instilled this respect in me by telling me these amazing stories about them. Eventually, I lived in Israel for a time and met many different types of cultures/people but, for me, the Bedouins are top tier human beings, awesome people.
The Bedouin’s are Arabs don’t trust them they could be enemies but hidden thoughts and they will never attack until it’s the right time for them have you forgotten the kingdom of edom they attacked kingdom of Israel those Bedouin’s can’t be trusted
Love these type of videos! Would love to see more across Israel!
Man I need to go there ❤
I could see the Beduins becoming the leaders of the Gazan and West Bank area. That probably would not be acceptable to the current Muslims identifying as Palestinians there, but it may be their best hope for peace and prosperity.
Actually that's not a bad idea but wow it could be amazing
🧠🪱
Most gaza people are bedouin who were kicjed of their lands
Stop the lies lmao
I don’t think these people would want to live among the radical gangs
@@valerieprice-wn9qb indeed no one want to live with zionist subhum8an
Negev oozes with Hospitality!
Abu Nigal got a dope house!
What an amazing dude
Abu nigga is a very nice person in the niggav desert
Judea was named 'Palaestina'(Palestine in English) by the Romans about 100 years after Jesus died.
This was written by the Romans themselves. It was right after 135AD that most Jews were expelled from Judea and the renaming it after the people who used to live in Gaza who were the enemies of the Israelites long before the Romans conquered.
Palestine is Israel 🇮🇱
It was so nice to see how the Bedouin people were so hospitable and welcoming to you again, Tal! And it was also nice seeing the cute camels at the end! One thing to note though, these unrecognized Bedouin villages are all in lack of bomb/rocket shelters, this is one area where Israel really needs to reflect and take seriously helpful actions, because many Bedouin have died due to stray rockets and no shelters. Israel also needs to legalize their villages immediately, otherwise it's fair to say that they are second-class citizens. I really liked this video, Tal -- thank you!
It would be interesting to know which Qu’ran verse was in the Shik.
True I should have asked!
Thank you for showing world Unity and for your Tikkun Olam
Are you Indian
@@user-wy8bo1ys9b what makes you ask that
Will watch later, commenting for the algo!
Appreciate you!
It looks like Bedouins in Israel can live a good life.
❤❤
Great! The mayor is very sympathic and hospitable!🌞
FRESH DATES - YUM ! 😊
Abu Nidal is smart, he knows very well what he’s talking about. Politics managed to make a gap within the Israelis (Left-Right, pro reform anti reform) and look what happens when we’re not united, it’s a weakness our enemies can abuse. Now after seeing this video I also want to visit Rahat❤
He said There’s nothing he can do to help relatives in Gaza. Why not protest for Change?
Just like the Japanese who say I am sorry for serving this trifle of a meal.
👍
Are there any Israeli flags in Rahat?
Yes there are, and Hebrew!
Nope Israel must do something about it fast
Does travelling Clatt speak Arabic? I thought he was Iraqi jew.
It is part of his ancestry but he himself was not born in Iraq.
I'm learning slowly n
@@stephenfisher3721 Of course. i forgot there are only a few Jews left in Iraq. Probably his grandparents knew Arabic.
@@TheTravelingClatt Fantastic. Me too. My mom's grandparents were from Yemen. Not Houthis side. LOL. Eastern part. They were sunni.
It's surprising encountering Black Arabs in Israel. I always want to assume they are Jewish and I automatically speak Hebrew to them. I worked with one in Jerusalem and had to stop myself from greeting him in Hebrew and instead had to remind myself to greet him in Arabic.
most Palestinians are fake Arabs Africans originally they entered Israel and then during Islam got Arabised now they think there Arabs , we Arabs don’t claim them Israel must deal with them and take the land back for its own Israeli people
out of curiosity, why do you wear that baseball cap while interviewing? is it a frum thing, or an american thing? for me it feels a bit disrespectful for its informality....outside, ok, but in the man's office/home? but i am from an older generation...otherwise, nice...
I wear it at the moment cause my hair is growing oddly and I haven't had the time to find a local barber yet. That's it. Hahaha.
My hair looks bad.
Wearing a hat is not disrespectful in any way
He's interviewing a guy wearing sunglasses inside, lol
I am so confuse as an Muslim from Bosnia! Sad part the Bedouins never had no where treat correctly. That’s sad!
Watching these videos just further shows how much of a cancer extremism is. It’s context that we need. THIS is normalcy. Hospitality, communing with one another. The issue isn’t religion, land, skin color, any of it. It’s extremism. Either side. We all pay for extremists. We have to get to a place we are tired of extremism and become a people that extremism can’t flourish around. We have to fight it on the ground in our homes daily. Thanks Tal. We need what you bring.
Agreed, extremism is the cancer to this region.
Shalom from Israel, I love the Beduin people 🇮🇱 I will one of these days go visit Rahat!
Shalom friend!
Truly Beautiful 🤍
You dont speak at all Arabic ? I thought in Israël everyone ad basic arabic class
I speak very little, my arabic is bad and I don't have confidence to speak it, I'm learning slowly.
Also when I lived in Israel I did have to learn it in school, it was mandatory
I live in Israel. My kids learn/ learned Arabic but it was more written Arabic
The Arabic taught in a school outside of the Arab education is literary and not spoken Arabic. These are two very different things. In addition, this education method is awful in my opinion (as a teacher I say this) most students do not really succeed in learning the Arabic language in this way, in addition to the fact that students do not usually study it for many years in schools. In my opinion, it should be taught more as spoken Arabic from grade 1 to grade 12 like the other Hebrew, but this is not the case.
We learn Fousha (Formal arabic), which isn't really spoken casually, if you tried to speak to a fluent arabic speaker in Fousha it'd be like speaking to a modern english speaker in Shakespearean english, they'd probably understand you but it'd be very unusual and you'd sound pretty silly.
@@brokenman8100 agreed. Two of my kids learned spoken Arabic in fifths and sixth grade and from a native Arabic speaker. But that was the extent of them learning the local spoken language .
I enjoy seeing your report ❤️❤️. But where are the women??? I always see men together but not women . I imagine it is culture .I would have love beeing born as a man in this beautifull place 😊
wise bedouin people! much respect to all the creatures who act for peace in the region
But at the end we’ll have to deal with them eitherway right now we can be peaceful with them meanwhile dealing with the Palestinians then the Bedouin’s we can kick them out into Egypt
Im Israeli, I was in the Rahat movie festival a few weeks ago, and was so happy to see how much the city progressed.
Sending love to beduins and everyone
Rahat deserves our love I'm so happy to here you visit there!
Why are the camels front legs chained together?
So they don’t run away because of the way they treat them harshly
How beautiful and heartwarming. Thank you! I only missed the women a little bit ☺️. Maybe easier for a woman to hang out with and film them..?
Arabian horses, crazy breed.
Agreed! I know them well. Very "spirited" 😅
The TV in the dione showed Hamas sneak attacks on the IDF.
scary that the school is named after abu obeida
That might be a school but I’m sure it has weapons hidden under there
😂😂😂😂nah bro not the abu baklawa from gaza
Lets say those black bedyines are more related to that area than a lot of ppl
They came from Sudan.
Whining terrorists will never have a state from any river to any sea that's for sure
This is proof ancient Egyptians were black because the Negev is next to Egypt
Unpacked, Iraqi Jews, Be there!
Sorry what hahaha?
@@TheTravelingClatt Unpacked Channel just did Iraq Jews history!! Check it out!!
@@TheTravelingClatthe just did a video on Iraqi jews
If you can live together with the Bedouins peacefully, why not with the other Palestinians? Would be good to one day see removal of checkpoints and the military occupation.
Probably because the Bediouns actually want peace...
Because unlike the "Palestinians" the Bedouins are ACTUALLY PEACEFUL, thank you very much
Where’s the women who made that food , sad to always see there women treated as hidden figures in the shadows
She was in the kitchen with us, we saw her, they just requested that we don't film her 😊
The hospitality and the generosity of Arabs , irritates me so much !
Why we should be cool with people who massacre us from the vein to the aorta and want to eradicate the Palestinians from their lands ?!!
That's revolting 😢
Because we aren't enemies, your sick ideology is what pins us against each other.
@@TheTravelingClatt I'm not lying though , you are killing Palestinians, Lebanese and Syrians and u are confiscating farms and properties of Palestinians Bedouins in the Negev and in Beersheba ; you are litteraly the pariah of the region , then u come irritate us of you fake lying humanism !
By the way i saw a previous video of yours where you moke and ridicule Arabs and Muslims, so dont foolish us !!!!
@@TheTravelingClattkeep lying to yourseelf jew
We are enemies
You attacked and steal our land
I am an Arab from Iraq and would be honored to feed my Israeli brother because he is my blood brother 🇮🇶🇮🇱 you Palestinians need to return either to Yemen or Roma which is Italy
@@manofwar2354I’m an Arab Muslim from the gulf and I support Israel. 🇮🇶🇮🇱
I just want to know why are the bedouins being removed from their homes right now by terrorist settlers? genuinely curious of a answer.
From the River to the Sea Palestine Will Be Free✌
Blah blah blah
Go to sudia arabia arab peninsula and make us a video , you be save there ,don't listen to the media what they say .
Really??
@@TheTravelingClatt No, no don't listen to him. You can't be sure.
If he goes to Saudi and is not "safe", will you go there and "save" him?
אחד הדברים הבולטים ביותר בצילומים שלך הוא שלא רואים נשים.
Black African Jews and American Jews are they Israelies? 🤦🏽♀️
If they are allowed to live in Israel by the government then they are.
When I lived in Syria the government of Syria allowed Sudanese and Moroccans to live in Syria. If the government of a country allows people to come they can come.
What do you mean by '"Israelis"?
Do you mean Israelis, that is, citizens of the modern Israel?
Or do you mean connected with the ancient Israelites of the Bible?
Who tf is connected with the acient Israelies in the Bible? I am talking about Americans and Africans who are Jews
Yeah and Turks can come to Cyprus to their occupied territory of Cyprus and Ukrainians can come to many, so what?
Not every Jewish have Israeli citizen. Only the one that was born in Israel. There is no connection to the colour of the skin. Israel is not just jewish, and Jewish have all kind of colours.
HOPE BEDOUIN PEOPLE WILL LOVE PALESTINE CIVILIANS, LIVE HAPPILY ALONG SIDE, HELP ONE ANOTHER
They are Israelis and not part of the same country as the Palestinians.
Do they live in a separate community for their own safety or is it just a cultural more peaceful way of life for them?
if they knew your politics....
na dont say that..Tal thinks everyone is beautiful and nice. Flowers and Candy!
These are Israeli bedouin. They serve in the IDF. After October when many of them were unalived, they became even stronger Israeli patriots. FYI, Gazans didn’t treat this part of their community well at all. In the Al Jalla’a district there was an area called Al Abeed ($l@ve). It was the home to over 11,000 black bedouin.
@@SydPat was it destroyed by the IDF?
Did he forget to mention Israel just stole another 35 Bedouin villages in the Naqab? I'm positively shocked 😆
@@rev909a You mean those shanty towns built on state owned property verses the allocated places with infrastructure that the government put in places for these people? Without planning, Israel would have remained the swamps and deserts they bought at exorbitant prices from the Ottomans and absentee Arab land owners. Take a ride into the Negev and look at those places with no water, electricity, sewage disposal, garbage collection, etc. The homes are made out of scrap material, mostly corrugated metal and abandon vehicles are every where. One of the reasons they got hit so hard in October was because they didn’t put up b0mb shelters. And while you’re complaining about the treatment they get from the Israeli government, Israel is the only country that does testing on this population because it knows which tribes are susceptible to which genetic anomalies.
This is how we always abandon our land to whom ever comes to our land stream generosity and welcoming with blind eye and heart and mind anyway one day this will be ended INSHA ALLAH
Palestine forever ♥️
It's rahat, israel
I don’t think they would want them in their slice of heaven on earth how peaceful and beautiful it appears
Welcome 👽 back ✡️
Welcome home 🏡 🕎
Welcome you for over A 1000 years
Welcome to the so called the Promised land 🇵🇸
Welcome to your destiny
Welcome to your Fate
Welcome to the last destination
Welcome to the final journey
Welcome to the last resting place 🕎 ⚰️✡️🏴☠️
Why are you spreading hatred against the Jewish people in the name of Islam? I have seen your channel and your utter hatred against the Jewish people. What you are spreading is a deeply hateful Islamist interpretation of Qur'an and you are on a very, very, very wrong path. You are on the same path Hitler walked, may the Creator of the Universe guide you to the right path, the path of love, not of obsessive hatred against the Jewish people.
You are stuck in hatred because of false teachers who don't care about you. False leaders who would happily sacrifice your life just to make themselves wealthy.
Do you think they themselves would fight? No: they tell their own sons to stay away from battle and they hide in nations where they are protected. They don't care about you.
All they care about is their own greed. Wake up from your hatred and learn to love your fellow human beings as you love yourself. If you don't love yourself, learn to.
We weren't created to hate our fellow human beings.
STOP ISLAMIST HATE. STOP FOLLOWING EXTREMIST INTERPRETATIONS OF QUR'AN. LEARN TO LOVE YOUR FELLOW HUMAN BEINGS.
Celebrate the life that your creator gave you instead of celebrating death and wishing death on people just because they are Jews, just because you have been taught to hate them by false teachers.
Palestine welcomed the jews and gave them them food and bed when they were oppressed by the Nazis but unfortunately in return we've been occupied by them and treated below animal levels in the West Bank and Gaza for over 75 years now, and this has to be stopped immediatly, end the war and end occupation and let people live in peace and justice with same equal rights, but from what we see from this war I don't think there will be 2 states so we as Paledtinians and Arabs in the region realized that there should be one state as it's always been before the zionists occupied our land and now many educated israelis are now aware about this fact and they are speacking loudly than never before.
Lies lies lies. You guys were so welcoming to the Jews who weren’t even immigrants (local Jews who were living in Hebron that time), that you massacred them in 1929 (19 years before Israel). And maybe you guys would’ve had a state, if you weren’t rejecting the 2 states solution FIVE TIMES. Let’s not talk about the fact that Palestine was never a country to begin with and you guys rejected the partition plan the UN gave (UN are one of the biggest enemies of Israel but they actually gave you guys a decent deal, they fucked over Israel). Don’t be a منافق🙏🏻
Thank you for video
Free Palestine 🇵🇸
from the river to the sea Ameen
It's a video about pro israeli village rahat🤦♂️🇮🇱☪️🛐
From the river to the sea Israel will remain free
All those naive “Israel apartheid” people are punching the air right now seeing all this peaceful diversity inside Israel.
Unfortunately they aren't watching this video hahaha
I’m an Iraqi we are probably occupied by the Nazi republic of Iran but we still remain one hand with our descandents in the nation of Israel maybe our Israeli grandsons can free us from Persia one day in the future 🇮🇶🇮🇱
Bless you brother
It's Palestine, and even Christ's was from the same line blood of Palestinian before it was called Palestine.
Try again, buddy.
@@natalietamar 🦶🏻
What does "Christ's percentage" mean?
@@stephenfisher3721 Christ was from the same line blood of Palestinian👍🏻
@@stephenfisher3721 And one of their relatives still lives in Syria and can speak the language that Christ used to speak, and this is known in history, and you can research this.
Free illegally oppressed occupied Palestine 🇵🇸 😢😢😢😢❤
lol🇮🇱
Rahat, israel🇮🇱☪️🛐
I know there are a people that are called Palestinian but I’m pretty sure that a Nation called Palestine hasn’t happened yet
What gorgeous house and property. What a beautiful culture of hospitality.