You can upload your song to controlla to generate a new voice. I can't answer the question about rights though: maybe check their FAQ? Thanks for asking this - it's a great question.
I make nerd metal music with Suno and most of the time I clean up my audio with coding written into the generations themselves and then take it all off to Diktatorial, but I have quite a few older songs that weren't generated the way I do them now that could use a service like this, so thank you for this video!
3:56 My feelings are absolutely opposite. I like this Suno original voice much more and "trust" it more. Also swapped voice has added reverberation that can make a mixing task more difficult. Just my humble opinion of course.
It works if the vocals extracted from an AI song is simple without too much instrument interruption. In my case the artifacts are 3 to 4 times heavier than your sample song. It doesn't work well on my club song because it has a lot of hihats. Words are misspronounced, the vocals come out like someone stuck their hand in the singers mouth while singing. LOL! The stem splitter needs to be better in SUNO and other software like Audimee, Kits, and Lalalai to mention a few. I've tried them all and they have all failed.
I agree.There is a TON of trial and error in this. I've tried prompting the vocals as Crystal Clear (as an example) and that helps. I also check "remove reverb" in the advanced settings and that can help as well. The results are sometimes better using different splitters, or just having Controlla pull the vocal from the Suno link (where it picks out the vocal from the full song). If you find any good ideas to improve the splitting results feel free to share them. Thank you so much for watching!
I neat thing you can do with the RipX DAW is if there is any bleed over from the instruments into the vocals or vice versa in the stems you can simply drag the notes into the correct stem, it's pretty cool.
Tested it. 1. Yes: It sounds amazing...but there are only 3 voices for testing, and, unlike Audimee, they are only working with english lyrics. Sounds like my american Co-Worker speaking german...But the quality of the Audio truely is amazing.
Thanks for the feedback! You can improve the output in other languages by changing the accent strength to “use source accent”. We’re also adding a ton more voices in the next few months! Appreciate your thoughts 🙏🏾
Question: Why didn't you tell suno about the vocas you want for this Song? Thats the first thing i put in brakets when I write my lyrics..[female, gritty voice, expressive, angry]
Hi chillwalker - that's a great question! I entered foreboding, tense, building and other descriptors when I generated my original Suno vocal but, for this video, the goal was more to demonstrate how you can get a cleaner vocal stem rather than tags. I touch on Suno tags in other videos and I will do more on that. Thank you so much for watching!
@@CreativelyMakeAIMusic I am working on a virtual project. So for 6 month I went deep (deeeeeeeeep) into suno and audime, build my own voice for "her". First I tried to build it up with a blend of known german artists. Did not work at all, to little clean material. Then, when suno got better with voices in german, I generatet a ton of Songs, learned how to prompt for the voices I want and got the trick how to get the same voices, long befor suno announced this "persona" feature. And how to prombt, that suno makes a vocal focussed mix or even an acapella, whenever I need. I have now a basis Tranig model, out of about 15 different Songs. On this basis model I edit 1-2 Songs of the Style I want. For example, when I need her to sing more Soul, or more Rock, I let Suno create something (thats why I came up with the question) that fits at the beginning of my model. So its always "her". Then I went thru audimees catalog and found a voice that has a supernice akzent...she "rolls" the "r" like you do when you are from a specific region in germny. Thats a cute and personal touch. I blend my actual modell with 30% of the audimree voice. Funfact: Train an audimee voice based on an voice that contends more than 10-20% audimee voice does not work at all. I always have to make a "mixed" voice with my basis model. Feeding Audimee with the end result is...."strange" Its somehow like inbreeding in real life: The offspring is nothing you'll be proud off ;-)(***) Now my Artists voice is somewhat presentable in its Version 5.2. And, yess, I should do videos about the process cause I know no-one who had gone so deep. (***) (This effect also accures, when you wanna make an image generation of a face, blending generated images from one source...it really starts with strange moles ad leads to creepy transformations....So the philosophicl question is: Is Nature or "Gods Plan" in everything? ) ua-cam.com/video/tQqaOPAAMg0/v-deo.html
I actually liked SUNO’s vocal more, than the swapped one. Still, these AIs are not good for live performance - they might work for making tracks for social platforms (if you are not serious for making your own music).
I agree - I wonder how responsive they will get for use in live situation. I can't see that being far away! I find these tools a great way work out ideas while writing and before recording live vocals. Sometimes hearing a different ai vocals inspires new creative choices for me. I just posted a video about my experience with that (Can this ai tool actually help real songwriters)
I have heard recently that Songs uploaded on youtube created by Suno got copyright strike, can you tell how can we fix it or not get a copyright , any tips. Your insight on this topic would be helpful.
Thanks for watching! Good question - -I don't know about that specifically but If someone is using the free version, they don't own the copyright - its all in this link from Suno. help.suno.com/en/articles/2746945#:~:text=If%20you%20make%20music%20with,license%20to%20monetize%20those%20songs..
In Suno 4, if you have a paid subscription, Suno states that you own the copyright. Just open Suno 4 and look at what you get with the different paid tiers.
Dude...what do you expect? To get everything for free, but on a professional level, so that you can earn money at others costs? May I tell you what you have to pay for an hour of a professional Studio Musician or Singer? about 350 (low end) to 900,-
Thanks for watching! The free trial gets 1000 seconds of conversion with downloads, which is quite a bit of time. Keep your vocal sample really short until you find a voice you like, then put in the full vocal that you want - you can probably get 4 or more song length vocals out of your free account.
The companies that trained their own models from their own singers instead of scraping get a + in my book - better quality as well.; Controlla, Ace, a bunch of others do that. By the way, I like your kid's channel. I had a successful kids music project circa 2019 (all human created music; ai didn't exist), lots of fun bringing music to kids!
@@CreativelyMakeAIMusic Thank you . I didn't know you were an actual person, or an A.I. creation. My music was for the most part produced the old fashioned way, with musicians in a studio, like this song ua-cam.com/video/Ld_SWlBsHv8/v-deo.html
@@BuddyBearCreator I'm definitely a real person LOL - I've been professionally working in the music business for most of my life including touring with major acts and releasing music as a real human artist etc. I didn't realize my voice sounded robotic enough to sound like AI! I'll have to work on that.
Hi! We made this songs album with AI and we think is beautiful! What do you think? ua-cam.com/play/PLcdOknWRyqNamb11xFLBcz12CxkrpGitt.html&si=PLyFtS8UOoPvYGLr
I don't know how to downvote this any harder. Using AI for the creative industries is a massive slap in the face to the people who actually take the time to train themselves to do this kind of work. This is extremely discouraging. Everybody wants to get to the end, and nobody wants to do the work to get there. This is the en-crappification of everything, and you are making it even worse. Whatever the opposite of "thank you" is, that is the feeling that I wish to politely convey to you.
@staysickmusic5971 the dumbing down of society and culture continues. It's not you as the musician making this. Prompting a large language model that has been trained on other people's work is not making music, and it sure as heck isn't you making the music. It's a plagiarism machine plagiarizing because you told it to. There is no artistic merit in this, and can be no pride in this. It's pathetic.
I hear what you are saying and respect your opinion. I'm a trained musician, and have worked as a professionally as such or in the music industry for years ("many many many" of them LOL). Not everyone has the ability or opportunity to pursue music in traditional ways and these tools provide access to learn and create in a different way than you or I had the opportunity to, similar to DAWs, VSTs, samplers etc created new opportunities for new and experienced musicians.
Honestly, your take comes off as pretty ignorant about the history of music and creativity. Let’s get real. artists have always borrowed, sampled, and built on the ideas of others. That’s how art evolves. From hip-hop producers flipping soul records, to rock legends inspired by blues, to EDM using presets and samples-great music comes from reinterpreting what’s already out there. Beethoven, Picasso, The Beatles-none of them created in a vacuum. They all took inspiration and elements from others, made them their own, and pushed things forward. So what’s the difference if an artist today uses AI as a tool? AI is just another instrument-like a sampler, a guitar, or a DAW. It’s not ‘stealing’; it’s transforming and innovating. Frankly, accusing someone of being ‘pathetic’ for using a tool they didn’t create is ridiculous when you’re probably using drum samples, presets, VSTs, and other tools someone else designed without crediting them either. By that logic, are you ‘pathetic’ for not making your own drum kit or synthesizer from scratch? Instead of whining about tools, maybe focus on how people use them to create something meaningful. Dismissing innovation outright makes you sound stuck in the past, and history shows us that those who resist change in art usually get left behind ;)
@@staysickmusic5971I was about to write the same thing, but you explained everything I wanted to say, even better 👍 AI is just another tool and it’s up to us how to use it
interresting Audimee alternative, I def. will check this out.
Thank you for watching. I will showcase more!
Thanks for this video! I can now finally record unlimited number of songs, because AI set me free from not so good singers! 😎
You're welcome 😊 =
Could also be used to revive old demos/tracks, or switch voices on demos for which you only have limited (ie, non-commercial demo) rights.
You can upload your song to controlla to generate a new voice. I can't answer the question about rights though: maybe check their FAQ? Thanks for asking this - it's a great question.
Oh wow awesome workflow thanks for sharing!
I'm so glad you watched - here is the a new video using Controlla -
ua-cam.com/video/m5SEY2H-YgM/v-deo.htmlsi=BuAZyKG64iQtcgAv
I make nerd metal music with Suno and most of the time I clean up my audio with coding written into the generations themselves and then take it all off to Diktatorial, but I have quite a few older songs that weren't generated the way I do them now that could use a service like this, so thank you for this video!
Cool! I will check out Diktatorial. Thanks for watching.
This is GREAT info!!!
Thank you so much! I am glad you enjoyed it.
Thanks for the info !
Thanks so much for watching!
I had to laugh when you said AI still sucks at wriiting lyrics. that's bc there are A LOT of terrible lyrics out there from humans! lol :D
It's definitely got a looooong way to go :) Thank you for watching; I enjoyed your comment!
3:56 My feelings are absolutely opposite. I like this Suno original voice much more and "trust" it more. Also swapped voice has added reverberation that can make a mixing task more difficult. Just my humble opinion of course.
Thanks for sharing that and for watching the video!
Try that again using music that has more mids and highs with your female vocal example. All that low end makes it easy to switch out female vocals.
It is Suno singer without any additional processing. There will be more videos with different voices.
It works if the vocals extracted from an AI song is simple without too much instrument interruption. In my case the artifacts are 3 to 4 times heavier than your sample song. It doesn't work well on my club song because it has a lot of hihats. Words are misspronounced, the vocals come out like someone stuck their hand in the singers mouth while singing. LOL! The stem splitter needs to be better in SUNO and other software like Audimee, Kits, and Lalalai to mention a few. I've tried them all and they have all failed.
I agree.There is a TON of trial and error in this. I've tried prompting the vocals as Crystal Clear (as an example) and that helps. I also check "remove reverb" in the advanced settings and that can help as well. The results are sometimes better using different splitters, or just having Controlla pull the vocal from the Suno link (where it picks out the vocal from the full song). If you find any good ideas to improve the splitting results feel free to share them. Thank you so much for watching!
I neat thing you can do with the RipX DAW is if there is any bleed over from the instruments into the vocals or vice versa in the stems you can simply drag the notes into the correct stem, it's pretty cool.
Tested it. 1. Yes: It sounds amazing...but there are only 3 voices for testing, and, unlike Audimee, they are only working with english lyrics. Sounds like my american Co-Worker speaking german...But the quality of the Audio truely is amazing.
Thanks for the feedback! You can improve the output in other languages by changing the accent strength to “use source accent”. We’re also adding a ton more voices in the next few months! Appreciate your thoughts 🙏🏾
I've done similar with Udio
Thanks for watching!
Question: Why didn't you tell suno about the vocas you want for this Song? Thats the first thing i put in brakets when I write my lyrics..[female, gritty voice, expressive, angry]
Hi chillwalker - that's a great question! I entered foreboding, tense, building and other descriptors when I generated my original Suno vocal but, for this video, the goal was more to demonstrate how you can get a cleaner vocal stem rather than tags. I touch on Suno tags in other videos and I will do more on that. Thank you so much for watching!
@@CreativelyMakeAIMusic I am working on a virtual project. So for 6 month I went deep (deeeeeeeeep) into suno and audime, build my own voice for "her". First I tried to build it up with a blend of known german artists. Did not work at all, to little clean material. Then, when suno got better with voices in german, I generatet a ton of Songs, learned how to prompt for the voices I want and got the trick how to get the same voices, long befor suno announced this "persona" feature. And how to prombt, that suno makes a vocal focussed mix or even an acapella, whenever I need. I have now a basis Tranig model, out of about 15 different Songs. On this basis model I edit 1-2 Songs of the Style I want. For example, when I need her to sing more Soul, or more Rock, I let Suno create something (thats why I came up with the question) that fits at the beginning of my model. So its always "her". Then I went thru audimees catalog and found a voice that has a supernice akzent...she "rolls" the "r" like you do when you are from a specific region in germny. Thats a cute and personal touch. I blend my actual modell with 30% of the audimree voice. Funfact: Train an audimee voice based on an voice that contends more than 10-20% audimee voice does not work at all. I always have to make a "mixed" voice with my basis model. Feeding Audimee with the end result is...."strange" Its somehow like inbreeding in real life: The offspring is nothing you'll be proud off ;-)(***) Now my Artists voice is somewhat presentable in its Version 5.2. And, yess, I should do videos about the process cause I know no-one who had gone so deep.
(***) (This effect also accures, when you wanna make an image generation of a face, blending generated images from one source...it really starts with strange moles ad leads to creepy transformations....So the philosophicl question is: Is Nature or "Gods Plan" in everything? )
ua-cam.com/video/tQqaOPAAMg0/v-deo.html
I actually liked SUNO’s vocal more, than the swapped one. Still, these AIs are not good for live performance - they might work for making tracks for social platforms (if you are not serious for making your own music).
I agree - I wonder how responsive they will get for use in live situation. I can't see that being far away!
I find these tools a great way work out ideas while writing and before recording live vocals. Sometimes hearing a different ai vocals inspires new creative choices for me. I just posted a video about my experience with that (Can this ai tool actually help real songwriters)
I have heard recently that Songs uploaded on youtube created by Suno got copyright strike, can you tell how can we fix it or not get a copyright , any tips. Your insight on this topic would be helpful.
Thanks for watching! Good question - -I don't know about that specifically but If someone is using the free version, they don't own the copyright - its all in this link from Suno. help.suno.com/en/articles/2746945#:~:text=If%20you%20make%20music%20with,license%20to%20monetize%20those%20songs..
In Suno 4, if you have a paid subscription, Suno states that you own the copyright. Just open Suno 4 and look at what you get with the different paid tiers.
I’ve had no problems at all uploading songs I did in SUNO onto UA-cam. No copyright issues because they are new songs.
Thx. Good video.
Thanks for watching!
Not free. You need credits for this.
Dude...what do you expect? To get everything for free, but on a professional level, so that you can earn money at others costs? May I tell you what you have to pay for an hour of a professional Studio Musician or Singer? about 350 (low end) to 900,-
Thanks for watching! The free trial gets 1000 seconds of conversion with downloads, which is quite a bit of time. Keep your vocal sample really short until you find a voice you like, then put in the full vocal that you want - you can probably get 4 or more song length vocals out of your free account.
Mixed too unfront.
Thanks for watching! This demo uses the raw output from Suno & Control. Mixing will get addressed in future videos.
Sorry but, when the subject is 'Amazing Vocals'l, I think you have to try this with the voice over in this video.
I'd check out to your voiceovers but I see you don't make videos, so there's that...🤣
I find AI as Video Voice over always annoying af. Even the good ones...
of course there's artifacts. a robot is making your music based off actual music it's learned and scraped the internet for
The companies that trained their own models from their own singers instead of scraping get a + in my book - better quality as well.; Controlla, Ace, a bunch of others do that. By the way, I like your kid's channel. I had a successful kids music project circa 2019 (all human created music; ai didn't exist), lots of fun bringing music to kids!
@@CreativelyMakeAIMusic Thank you . I didn't know you were an actual person, or an A.I. creation. My music was for the most part produced the old fashioned way, with musicians in a studio, like this song ua-cam.com/video/Ld_SWlBsHv8/v-deo.html
@@BuddyBearCreator I'm definitely a real person LOL - I've been professionally working in the music business for most of my life including touring with major acts and releasing music as a real human artist etc. I didn't realize my voice sounded robotic enough to sound like AI! I'll have to work on that.
Hi! We made this songs album with AI and we think is beautiful! What do you think? ua-cam.com/play/PLcdOknWRyqNamb11xFLBcz12CxkrpGitt.html&si=PLyFtS8UOoPvYGLr
That's impressive - Thanks for sharing!
I don't know how to downvote this any harder. Using AI for the creative industries is a massive slap in the face to the people who actually take the time to train themselves to do this kind of work. This is extremely discouraging. Everybody wants to get to the end, and nobody wants to do the work to get there. This is the en-crappification of everything, and you are making it even worse. Whatever the opposite of "thank you" is, that is the feeling that I wish to politely convey to you.
couldn't disagree more, I think these are tools that will revolutionize the way us as musicians make music.
@staysickmusic5971 the dumbing down of society and culture continues. It's not you as the musician making this. Prompting a large language model that has been trained on other people's work is not making music, and it sure as heck isn't you making the music. It's a plagiarism machine plagiarizing because you told it to. There is no artistic merit in this, and can be no pride in this. It's pathetic.
I hear what you are saying and respect your opinion. I'm a trained musician, and have worked as a professionally as such or in the music industry for years ("many many many" of them LOL). Not everyone has the ability or opportunity to pursue music in traditional ways and these tools provide access to learn and create in a different way than you or I had the opportunity to, similar to DAWs, VSTs, samplers etc created new opportunities for new and experienced musicians.
Honestly, your take comes off as pretty ignorant about the history of music and creativity. Let’s get real. artists have always borrowed, sampled, and built on the ideas of others. That’s how art evolves. From hip-hop producers flipping soul records, to rock legends inspired by blues, to EDM using presets and samples-great music comes from reinterpreting what’s already out there. Beethoven, Picasso, The Beatles-none of them created in a vacuum. They all took inspiration and elements from others, made them their own, and pushed things forward.
So what’s the difference if an artist today uses AI as a tool? AI is just another instrument-like a sampler, a guitar, or a DAW. It’s not ‘stealing’; it’s transforming and innovating. Frankly, accusing someone of being ‘pathetic’ for using a tool they didn’t create is ridiculous when you’re probably using drum samples, presets, VSTs, and other tools someone else designed without crediting them either. By that logic, are you ‘pathetic’ for not making your own drum kit or synthesizer from scratch?
Instead of whining about tools, maybe focus on how people use them to create something meaningful. Dismissing innovation outright makes you sound stuck in the past, and history shows us that those who resist change in art usually get left behind ;)
@@staysickmusic5971I was about to write the same thing, but you explained everything I wanted to say, even better 👍 AI is just another tool and it’s up to us how to use it