Mariah Carey - Vision Of Love (Live at Costa Mesa 2003 & BET Blueprint 2005) | Reaction
Вставка
- Опубліковано 8 лют 2025
- Original videos - • 03 Vision Of Love - Ma...
• Vision Of Love (Live @...
For more content check:
Patreon - / brunoduarte226
My Second Channel - / @brunosbackyard_22
Contact info - brunoduarte06.business@gmail.com
#reaction #mariahcarey #visionoflove #vocals #highnotes
Fortunately, both of these are fully live, and she never lipped it until 2023.
Yeahh I hate that some reactors are so traumatized from all the “this was actually lipped” moments with her that they start thinking vision of love could ever be lipped in the 2000’s 😭
Yesss omg im so glad!!!!!!!!!
❤️❤️❤️
@@_brunoduarte_06you should've reacted to zurich 2003 instead 😭, i think that one was better than costa mesa
edit: i think you already reacted to it actually haha. but maybe just some clips of it. but it really is much better then the ones in this video
@@augustmomentsthe way only lambs say "heeey that's lipped" Whitney, Celine, Beyoncé fans would never, and I don't know if it's a good thing jaja
It’s not a crack, it’s called an intentional vocal break my guy lol. Great reaction! Check out Mariah’s “Can’t Let Go” live on SNL. One of my fav performances 🔥
The raspiness isn’t a result of any kind of strain. It’s from the nodules on her vocal cords sort of tapping together which makes that crackly sound. In this era specifically, if she was going to strain at all she would growl it instead.
The disrespect. Both performances were live. She is MARIAH CAREY that's why she shounds great. If you know Mariah, it's so easy to notice when she singing live and when she is lipping.
It is not that easy to tell because she's also good at lip-syncing and if you watched any of my reactions to Mariah you would know i mean no disrespect, knowledge goes both ways!😁
The way you can tell if she's lipping or not is by her jaw there's this thing she does with her jaw when she sings she tends to push it forwards or just look at her mouth when she hits the note
@@_brunoduarte_06WHAT? Mariah is a terrible at lipping that’s why I was shocked you thought she wasn’t singing live
@@_brunoduarte_06 gurl she's horrible at lip syncing lol. The queens of lipsync are beyonce and celine. Although she's bad at lipping, it takes a long time to get used to telling which is live and which isn't.
I think it's the constant looking for it! Enjoy the ride and have faith. This is why she should have performed less, her lipped performances unfortunately lead to these concerns. But we all have days out voices are great and you could see she was so comfortable and having fun during that performance!
7:30 this is her background singing the adlibs like every version. It’s just louder here
This was all live
Both performances are fully live, I'm so glad to say. 2003-2005 her voice its much more health than 1997-1999.
Raspy belting does not mean bad belting. There are many raspy singing that can sing “clear” singers into a corner
Exactly
It’s live but she’s inconsistent in some parts. She’s a human and not a robot.
It was her background singer singing the climax backgrounds lol
Her voice is rarely balanced she can have a strong whistle but weak belts or strong belts and weak whistles , its part of the magic of nodules
mariah has never lipped vision of love till 2023. literally never. it's the only song in her whole discography you can say that with. every performance is 100% unique. just mentioning so you know for future reference, if its vision of love pre 2023 its 100% live so you don't have to worry about guessing about lipped vocals. and yeah that was a background singers. If you want to see any more fully live performances you can react to literally any vision of love performance pre 2023 and you’ll get different vocals
Her last live performance was in 2022 and her voice was absolutely shot but she still sang it live and even attempted the whistle. Her lipping it in 2023 kinda signified a new era of lip syncing since she has committed to singing it live for over 30 years
unless you count the quarantine performance in 2020 which was prerecorded
This is a fact ❤️
Both are actually fully live!!!
ye that person signing in the background was a backup singer they usually do that
btw neither performance was lipped
both fully live
right .. an actual lamb would know this already like what??
2003-2005 was her second vocal prime
And about putting her hands to her ears, it's just a habit from the 90s; in-ear monitors hadn't been invented yet, so she was checking if her voice was on pitch.
Vision of Love is 100% live, but you can hear in the 2005 performance that it was dubbed in some places
Lambs are still dreaming of hearing the undubbed version😂❤
Definitely over analysed, you guys need to have more faith in Mariah’s prime vocals lol 😂 Just because she sounds good she’s lip syncing?!?!
Well yes because in other videos when i was surprised by her vocals people would tell me they were liped so now im gonna be questioning every time thx to yall
@@_brunoduarte_06 people really be doing too much in the comments and in lambily communities. just let people enjoy her voice. no wonder many people get turned off by the community
Bruno Bruno Bruno...thank you for reacting to this one! Let me help my boy out and do some explaining.
Butterfly Era was like '97 - '98 Mariah is divorced, hooray. Some issues with label and voice deterioration begins in latter part of '98, carrying into '99
Rainbow Era '99 - '00 ~ went on tour and definitely some condition and fluidity issues. Amazing agility, creativity, and melismas. Sis was tired and voice was just shot. Rest needed.
Glitter Era '01 - hospitalized for "breakdown" (girl just needed some downtime to rest), soundtrack released on 9/11, just not a good year for her
Charmbracelet album '02 - released at the end of the year. Into '03 it didn't really gain much traction.
Charmbracelet Tour '03-'04 - Mariah's longest running tour to date (69 shows). We've pressed her for hi-res footage of this tour & of Rainbow tour. Yes, that other voice you heard was her background singer. Her background singers can belt and run their arses off! This tour started off a little dodgy but into the tour her voice strengthened and her confidence rose to insane levels. I recall recently seeing that close to 70% of this tour was live, though, from what I understand, mainly "Make It Happen", "Vision Of Love", and "Hero" were performed toward the end of the set and were all fully live, a little different at each stop. I will argue that this tour was responsible for The Emancipation of Mimi album. Those fire vocals would have been recorded in 2004 for the album release in April 2005.
The Emancipation of Mimi '05 - great vocals but later in the year when she begins to tour and into 2006 we start to see more rasp come in. Also, some of the fluidity dissipates and Mariah begins taking on more of a staccato approach.
Hope that proves to be helpful. As for a suggestion, I would recommend "We Belong Together". There is the performance from BET Blueprint (same show as "Vision Of Love" that you just reacted to, and it is considered to be one of her few fully-live versions. It certainly ranks up there for fans. As for my own preference, I revere her performance at the 2005 MTV Movie Awards as probably her best live version. It is practically identical to the album version and it is fully live. I remember her commenting that she knew it was going to be a big deal to perform it at the awards show and so she went like 4 or 5 days without talking and using her humidifier to maximize her strength. She abso-f*ing-lutely crushed it! Peace homie!
Both are fully-lived performances. Im a fan of her and when she lips it easy to tell but here i know 100% its live.
Both are 100% live. She only started lipsyncing VOL in 2023. Watch her sing Vision Of Love at the 2016 Sweet Sweet Fantasy Tour, she was basically prime-riah hitting the notes with added rasp and power. Her voice was very "metallic" in 2016 and VOL 100% live. She hit great notes
As others have said, both performances are live. She said in a master calss interview a few years ago that because of the nodules, either her whistle register is stronger or her belt register. I think that's why she started that second performance with a whistle and ended it with a whistle, because she knew that day whistle register was better than the belt register 😊 And sorry if my English is bad lol
Perfect english and thanks for sharing that!💖
BET version is actually dubbed, not lipped. A dubbed performance has the sound edited before getting released. It was sung fully live, but she basically re-sings any part that was not good enough due to technical malfunction or even off key or cracked notes (which is probably what happened during the last whistle). You can find comparisons between the live sound and the dubbed sound for many of her performances and in most cases they are both just as good.
The only dubbed part is the falsetto after the big note in the end before the whistle.
The whole thing was originally chest voice until the whistle.
The whistle and the final belt were both live (I've seen the original live broadcast).
So disrespectful and ignorant. You're acting like an expert. Saying "I can't tell which is live, which is not." after claiming shes lip-syncing countless times. If you don't know, just stfu.
Well why don't you stfu🤣🤣 it goes both ways smartass
Both are fully live. The difference is that one is in a concert arena filmed on a cheap phone or video cam, and one is a TV performance which is a smaller more intimate setting and recorded on a professional camera . In an area all the mics have to be super loud including the choirs for people to hear them. Hence why in the first performance the choir is heard a lot more.
The TV performance was filmed on a professional camera , a lot closer up so of course the sound quality would be a lot clearer.
Those cracks you heard are intentional cracks, which she often does to add emotion to the song.
With regards to that rasp. Mariah has always had the rasp . Due to her vocal nodules she cant control it, also many of her fans love the raspiness it adds characters to her voice. A raspy belt doesnt mean she is struggling to hit the note. Also, hitting lower notes its easier than belting c5 or higher belts hence why the raspiness wasnt so present in the lower register. And whistles are the easiest part of Mariahs voice for her.
Lastly 2005 was Mariahs so called " second vocal peak " meaning her tone was everything then . She never lipped Vision of love till 2023 .
You should do my 90s vs 2000s vs 2010s vs 2020s same song vocal battle. You'll basically see an evolution of her voice hitting these same high belts and whistles.
Babe this our like 50th video her nodules make it so either her belts are top tier or her whistles are. If she’s fully balanced people say she lips it’s so unfortunate. But she has given us concerts or promotions worth so much because she gave us her all. ❤
0:18 bruh i thought my shit was frozen 😭
🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣
The reason why bet sounds lipped is because some parts were actually dubbed in the studio but she never lipped vision of love until 2023
I feel like you’re not being fair with your judgments at some points, one was a fan recording from the audience and the other was a edited televised version ofc the quality is going to be better??? like her voice declined but you’re acting like she lost the ability to sing entirely after the 90’s, her voice declined compared to her prime 😭
he seems not to know a thing he's saying 💀💀💀💀
@@eliasaraujo7579 literally
If he thinks she lost her ability to sing after the 90s he needs to go listen to the entire emancipation of Mimi album and react to that
I'd say with Mariah take everything from 1990 to 2005 as Live as mostly it's all live. From 2005 to 2010 I'd also take most of it as live. From 2010-2015 is half and half and after like 2020 basically mostly just lipped
You're thinking too much. But hey you're enjoying it!
I want to make a point. All singers will have good and bad vocal days. Mariah has always had nodules, which may cause more frequent vocal decline than other singers. However, this doesn't mean her vocals were always bad after her prime. I think you use the *Butterfly* era as a reference for her bad vocals, but she had some subpar performances since her debut due to her condition. There are many good performances even after her prime that surpass her prime performances. I suggest you watch her live performances of "My All" on SNL in 1997 and "Butterfly" live David Letterman in 1997. This may help you understand her vocal condition.
and fyi BOTH are fully live!!!
(BET is dubbed but she sang it fully live)
Singing well in one register does not mean she automatically has to sing others perfectly (whistle, best, lows - they mostly don`t have connection) One can sing great in falsetto but struggling with other registers. This is not what defines live from lip-sync. And it is clear that both are live due to the fact you can hear breath + other minor artifacts. It`s not polished, but damn sounds amazing, raw and emotional.
She has nodules and her voice changes from clear to raspy just as she said when she sick she can hit whistle notes better and when she not sick she can belt better
ua-cam.com/users/shortskH9fh4XxMrI?si=VJ8NZP0hDWqSUlnt
Very concerned about evaluating whether it was live or not and could not take advantage of the vocals. I believe it was live, with an edit on the voice later. A compressor can give that sound.
BRUNO PLEASE REACT TO I STAY IN LOVE 2008 AMAS live ( I’m not sure if it’s fully live but it’s really good)
❤❤❤❤
Dont be on her lipping when she isn't! Cant get a break! Evidentially she can sing and when she lips its fine and for thr vocal rest with how violent she is with her voice. Why would she lip those words at the end, she wanted the whistle to go up like the previous version you watched but she obviously couldnt get the whistle up. You can see the struggle with the whistle at the end, too airy to power it up. Beautiful though!
Why worry so much about a song being lipped? Just enjoy the performance my goodness
Since when Mariah has an ugly tone, specially in this era, tnink We belong together's tone or Fly like a bird .This entire special for BET is 100% live,. BET Blueprint is similar to MTV Unplugged, no backtracks only her and backup singers.
FYI at the beggining thats not whistle its head Learn to differentiate before commenting. Ths last note was whistle, compared them. She was doing aspirates gradual in the offset
Her tone wasn’t good in 05? Shake it off? We belong together? Fly like a bird, circle? Sir
nodules which she has are inconsistant which is why in the same performance she sometimes has clear and raspy belts
You don’t understand the voice much. lol.
Or how background singers work
It's in the name "background' it's supposed to be in the back not belting over Mariah🤣🤣 how tf was i gonna know smartass i bet you know a lot that's why you have a channel sharing your knowledge? Oh wait
@@_brunoduarte_06that is how vision of love has always been live though, that background note is important
mariah's singing voice is always changing, i saw 3 videos of her singing "i still believe" live and every single one had like a different voice, it's like one day her singing voice is higher then other day her voice is lower then other day is raspy, even today her singing voice is sounds "higher" than the 2000s or 90s
Oh, this was a painful watch
You still watched it tho 🤭
I think it would be intresting if you reacted to some of her more recent live performances to see how her voice changed, i would suggest vision of love live in amsterdam 2019, and ill be there live in las vegas february 14 2020, both fully live performances
Please do a reaction to morissette amon perf of this song ❤
Thank you!