maybe they thought she got fat on herbs? or maybe she just hid away in hr den a lot and some how there was nothing wrong going on in that part of time. idefk
+soapitysoap1114 I think Brambleclaw mentioned it in one of those plays on the official website or something similar. He said, well, thought to himself that the great amount of prey that year was showing so that even Leafpool, someone who is said to be be very small and lithe, was increasing weight. What he didn't know was that she was actually pregnant.
5:06 why does nobody understand?! Billystorm and Harveymoon were kittypets but joined SkyClan, but went back to their twolegs at night, so they wanted to combine their kittypet names with warrior names (which is both logical and weird in my opinion).
In The Darkest Hour, there should’ve been a scene where Firestar realizes that he and Scourge are kin, so he tries to reason with him. Like, he gets sent a dream about him and Scourge being kin. Idk. Someone write it.
Firestar gazed at Scourge, as he staggered to his forepaws holding hisself up. " We share the same father, we're kin Scourge. " Firestar raised is gaze towards the small black tom, missing the color of his callor. The tom smirked as he swiped his pink tounge over his muzzle, only smearing more blood around. " Blood? Blood... " He seemed to pause for a moment as if somecat told him the same thing. " Blood, its nothing but something runing in your vains, keeping you and I alive. " Unexpected he leaped at firestar, planting his dog claws onto his shoulders, holding the tom down roughly. " We are no kin. " he yowled as he raised his forepaw over head, firestar quickly kicked the Tom's underbelly, as the black down staggered backwards, firestar yowled as he staggered to his paws tackling the tom, rolling on the ground with him, scraping at the Tom's flank as they parted, firestar then felt a rage flood over him, He then snarled as he pinned down the tom from behind, planting his claws into his shoulders, as the callor that was easily to big for the tom hanged down the dog teeth drizzled with dried blood. Firestar then dug his fangs into his scruff shacking his head wildly as scourge hissed firestar then felt the Tom's constant struggles fade away, as he stepped back, it had been done, he killed Scourge. [ I'm board so ima just say whitestorm'is now leader lol ] Whitestorm darted away from the dog, kicking up grass as he hoped the dog would lose interest, he then turned around arching his back, his white pelt shot upward as he hissed loudly, the dog ignored his warning, and leaped at him, Whitestorm felt jagged teeth into his torso as he then felt the harsh ground, the dog roughly planting it's paw on his belly, the white tom closed his eyes, ready for the worst, thinking about his mother and father, as the pain never came, he slightly opened his mouth as the recognizable sent reatchef the top of his mouth, he then opened his eyes as he saw Firestar tackling the dog, sinking his claws and teeth into their side, as he clinged on the dog, the dog shook his pelt, blood filled the air as the dog stood to his hindpaws as it flopped over on its side, firestar hissed as Whitestorm gathered his strength to stand. He then forced hisself up, as with wild eyes he saw the two go closer to the edge of the cliff. `` Firestar, watch out! `` he yowled, as the white tom started towards him. Then the dog stood to his paws, as Firestar was flung off, gently landing to his paws with small grunt, as he launched hisself towards the dog, climbed to his snout as the dog whined, then the two fell off the cliff. `` No! `` Whitestorm yowled as without hesitation leaped after his leader. He gagged as water rushed into his mouth, opening his eyes as he saw firestar, sinking towards the bottom of the water, Whitestorm raised to the top for a gasp of air as he dropped back down. He clung his teeth gently into his scruff, the tent of them both a light blue. He then raised to the air as he yowled for help. He felt his leader's flank against his as he grew tired, he then felt the heavy weight of Firestar lift and he drew his attention towards Greystripe who was formally a Riverclan warrior, he nodded towards the grey tom with darker stripe down his back all the way towards his tail tip. Like the never ending Thunderpath, Whitestorm found his self at Firestar's side, as he raised his head towards Greystripe, Sandstorm, and Spottedleaf, with grief in her eyes. `` Cant you help him, please! `` Whitestorm pleaded as he pressed closer to the Tom's side, shivering with the lost of hope on his yellow eyes. `` Whitestorm...he's gone.`` She walked towards the Tom's side as she rest her soft tongue over his head, he looked over towards the limp leader digging his head into his neck, drowned with grief as he pleaded that Starclan knew what they were doing. [ lol ima just keep coming back to this adding stuff on, now I'm out of ideas ]
African Lion Yeah, there is a whole serise. Ravenpaw Path, SkyClan and the Stranger, Graystripe’s Adventure and I forgot the name of Sasha but she has one. They all have three books in them, besides Scourge’s stand alone. There is one coming out about Silverstream on June 2nd.
What about Mapleshade being only cat punished for being in love with a cat from other clan? Also, Princess WAS mentioned in second arc! By CoDy! Am i the only one that remember?
@@themediocremen1128 True, I believe that was because Brokenstar was still alive, since he was prisoner in ThunderClan's camp, so Nightstar took his leader name without getting his nine lives
Well, yes. But you are disregarding the code (Just like the authors half the time) The code states that the deputy will become leader after their leader retires/dies. They cannot just say "Oh hey. This guy is evil. We won't give him nine lives." Two days before their ceremony because that would be vialsting the code THEY created. So, they really didn't have a choice. Sorry if this makes you see me as one of those annoying fans.
Nightstar, a good warrior who is proven loyal : can I get 9 lives? Starclan: haha no Tigerstar, a murderous and dangerous tom who killed Thunderclan's deputy for power and almost killed its leader: can i get 9 lives? Starclan: *oh sure, i have no problem with that*
Brokenstar was still alive. That's why Nightstar wasn't given nine lives. Also because "he wasn't right for leader." Or something. Same thing happened with Sunstar and Pinestar, Sunstar only got eight lives because Pinestar was still alive as a kittypet.
I NEVER SAW Writers write themselves into the GROUND so hard. What an amazing Book-Series and what amazingly bad Quality it has. It literally just continueing on and on and on and on hurts it more than even Ice-Age was hurt by being-milked and that’s a Feat! I mean, let me in the following list JUST some of the things coming to mind before it all went down the drains with the Zombie-Apocalypse many knew about and no one told Firestar about, leading to his Death by basically ‚Thunder Clan Betrayal’ we had Cliches and Things just endlessly repeating itself. Firestar is a great Leader, but ‚only’ as much as his broken, broken Culture allows. He’s a ‚relatively’ good Leader as much as he’s restrained: His World literally does not consider things like Trade or Peace-Offerings Moral. Both Concepts are EVIL-HERESY-OF-EVILNESS. If both sides have something the other wants and suffers withuot it, the Books present 2 Options ‚War or Peace-in-the-sense-of-suffering-in-Solemn’. If this is not recognized by the Author as objectively problematic than no one IN the Book will ever go and change the s-it. HENCE why the damn Romeo-and-Juliet Plot REPEATED ITSELF 1000 Times, making me scream.
Them: SkyClan is never mentioned ever again Me: **cough** *A vision of shadows* *cough* *Edit: Ok, so a lot of people are saying this was out before ‘vision of shadows’ but I watched this video long after it came out, and I didn’t check the date it came out. I realise that now it came out before ‘A vision of shadows.’
Be more chiiiilll In the end they said they did this 4 fun and it was a joke, CHIIIIIIILLL. Also love u Blixemi ur songs r paw-some! No? U sure? Okay, okay, it's no claws for worry. I'll go now.
Spoiler warning. 1:53 In The Darkest Hour, all four clans fight one clan. In The Last Hope, all the Clans are fighting against many evil cats along with cats from their own clans that were trained to be savage by the Dark Forest. 2:06 It explains more about the Clan's origins. 2:44 Firestar thought it was better that the cats didn't know about Skyclan, so he didn't mention it except when he was talking to Brambleclaw in series two about how he wanted to wait for Graystripe because he waited for him when he went on a journey. 3:46 The clan cats all thought he was insane. 4:19 Bluestar didn't want to question this because she didn't want any cats to be suspicious and she gave up Oakheart for her clan. 4:57 Longtail was named after his tail, just like Tallstar. That's what his mother thought of when he was named Longkit. 5:05 Billystorm and Harveymoon are daylight warriors, they wanted to keep part of their name. 5:27 Yellowfang didn't want any cat to know about her power, so she didn't show any sign of it. 7:28 Yellowfang was lying to Squirrelflight so that she would accept the kits. She tells this to Squirrelflight in a dream while she was pregnant with Alderheart and Sparktail.
ALSO in the book that YellowFang kills BrokenStar with death berries, FireHeart in his mind says that she seems like she has the effects of the death berries.
can we all metion the fact that one of the windclan cats is named "sneezepaw" like omg imagine this: mother: i just cant think of a name for my kit kit: *sneezes* mother: OMG ill just name him SNEEZEKIT me: -_-
(SPOILER ALERT) It makes me angry that almost every important character is related to Firestar. Brambleclaw, his son in law, becomes deputy and is part of an important prophecy. Squirrelflight, his daughter, is in and important prophecy and becomes deputy. Leafpool becomes medicine cat and receives the "blood will spill blood" prophecy. His grandchildren are part of a prophecy, have powers, and Jayfeather becomes med cat. Also, Greystripe may not be retaliated, but COME ON ERIN, he choose his best friend as deputy? I love Warriors, but, Firestars importantness is never ending.
EVERYTHING WRONG WITH THIS VIDEO 1. Scourges collar color is shown on the cover of the manga 2. It actually does mention Firestar and scourge are related in the series 3. You mentioned twice about Princess and Skyclan being forgotten 4. Skyclan is mentioned again, a lot actually 5. There is no evidence towards Firstar forgetting Princess since after the first series it isn't from his perspective 6. You getting unsubbed for this video is not a problem in the warriors series 7. The title should have been everything wrong with the warriors fandom since almost half of your points are whats wrong with the fans 8. Brightheart was a mentor to Jayfeather for a while 9. In the manga of Bramblestar's storm Yellowfang admits that she was lying, it was not just 'thrown out the window' 10. Firestar has many flaws 11. Mapleshade is not the only female villain 12. If you had read the guide then you would know why Tigerstar gets his lives 13. Thistleclaw is in the dark forest because he was training there before he died IM NOT TRYING TO BE MEAN OR HATE IN ANYWAY!
About the Firestar and scourge thing, it says in the ultimate guide that they are half brothers because their father is Jake. Also, squirrel flights white law is a genetic trait that she got from scourge. So, yeah.
I fell like people are stupid with the color of scourges callor what they don't read or seen the book before they just dash making up a color that's not true?! >:C
@@JlMMOTHY No, actually it's trying to point out facts and some of them are wrong while the person who made this should've had full details before putting what was wrong about that character / part of the book in the video. Don't try to defend the person who made this by calling people who are right asses when the only ass here is you.
Am I the only one who thinks Spottedleaf is a stalker at this stage? No wonder Mapleshade killed her, she must have wanted to be the only one who got involved in everyone's lives for no actual reason.
+WolfQuest Fan Just wanted to let you know, yes, he does. Then Spottedleaf goes to StarClan, and so on. (Into the.. 3rd arc?) Dark Forest comes and tries to take over, the prophecy of three, blah blah blah. Then, this happens and she’s killed again, by Mapleshade this time. Hope this helped ya understand more.
"Scourge was born on the edge of Twolegplace, the kittypet son of Quince and Jake, who went on to father Firestar and Princess with another kittypet, Nutmeg." p.197 of The Ultimate Guide Wow I didn't think I would need to pull out a book for that.
She did notice it!!!!! Read the book it will tell u! She had to give up her kits to riverclan so she chould be deputy and then become leader she made it look like a fox or bagger had taken them.
She did not. It wasn't like until halfway through that her CLANMATES pointed it out, and then she realised it and the events of her giving up her kids occurred afterwards.
Ikr?! Like, Leafpool ran away with Crowfeather, but when she came back, all the got was a light time out. Yeah she got her medicine cat position taken away, but she got it back not even a whole series later.
+TheSteel_Flame That was the leader's choice. Other cats who wee not banished had many cats wanting to banish them too.. And i think leaders these days are more understanding. I suppose they were all punished one way or another. If it helps, the leader who exiled mapleshade had his own punishment when mapleshade became evil because of that.
Fun fact, thistleclaw was indeed evil. Even if he didnt "kill any cats". He targeted spottedpaw/kit when hes way older than she is. (1) He led tigerpaw(claw/star) to train in the dark forest and was super hostile towards bluefur for no reason, clanmates should always be nice to each other. (2) :')
It was Mapleshade who led Tigerclaw/star into the dark forest, it says it in Tigerclaws Fury that Mapleshade apparently was guiding hus footsteps all of his life.
@@duxduxduckie well that is true however I do believe based on Bluestar’s prophecy he did have some influence on Tigerpaw’s (Tigerstar’s) actions since Thistleclaw made Tigerpaw attack Scourge when he was a defenseless kit and not only that he was harshly training him so although I do agree that Mapleshade did more stuff to Tigerstar but Thistleclaw (well at least how I interpreted it) did have some influence to some degree.
@@thumpernovember i personally think longtail is a better example (bc darkstripe is evil). he was never fond of rusty, and yet he was shown to be selfless and fiercely loyal to his clan, even saving fireheart from drowning.
13 - the cats needed a leader and they chose 15 - if there were to many reincarnation then itd be natural 17- they have their own live 20- bc it helps them feel more comfy 23 - american style 25 - because firestar and scourge never knew about it
I NEVER SAW Writers write themselves into the GROUND so hard. What an amazing Book-Series and what amazingly bad Quality it has. It literally just continueing on and on and on and on hurts it more than even Ice-Age was hurt by being-milked and that’s a Feat!
I’d like to add to the transgender cats... On the subject of Mosskit, they’re gender was male in the books that let you take a look inside the clans but years later it decided to become a girl and has been mentioned in a few books (Spottedleaf’s Heart, A look into the Warriors, etc) as Female. MAKE UP YOUR GODDAMN MINDS ERINS!
4:06 She didn’t have a hard time choosing which to be with though, she was struggling to realize that she couldn’t force herself to love Bumblestripe. She never loved him, this it was impossible for her to ever choose him. Even when she ‘chose’ him, she realized their relationship would never work out because they weren’t meant for one another.
The books haven't said directly Scourge and Firestar are half-brothers, but they have the same father (Jake), and Squirrelflight's white paw also symbolizes the half-brotherhood of Firestar and Scourge, just pointing that out! ^u^ -1 Sin(s)
+KatTheAnimator OMSC I am so offended he is not one of those! He just loved a lot! Whatever gender you are, I'm pretty sure you'll date/marry more than 3 guys/girls!
+Sydney Braun I love crow feather he's one of my favorite characters do he was thought of bad I'm just saying that's what we call boy whores is a fuckboi
*sins* why the heck do they have the most underdeveloped character kill a cat who could've been a more important character thats alive and more believable? Why couldn't a developed character kill spotted leaf?
not everything has to revole around complately developed characters. also it happened in the first god flipping book, there will be so little developed characters boi.
Scourge and Firestar ARE half brothers because they both have the same father, who was Jake, but different Mothers. Princess and Firestar's Mother is Nutmeg, Father is Jake. Ruby, Socks and Scourge's mother is Quince, and their father, Jake.
Gamer Cat Jackie sure, but I think they mean that we don't need to know. It's a nice little detail that makes Scourge more interesting, but it doesn't influence the story in any way, so they questioned why the Erins made that up in the first place ^^
I Said Meow But why did they make the two half brothers. This doesn't add the story and this fact does nothing. Jake could be replaced by any other tom and nothing would change. (Sorry for my bad english)
1.SkyClan is mention in the books, manly the hole 5th ark :l 2.TigerStar became leader because if he didd'nt, the erins said ShadowClan would of torn apart with no leader 3.Theres a whole ark detected to Firestar and he gets his own Supper Adision?
but their super editions add more to them, like firestars quest, introducing an entire clan, yellowfangs curse(?), the reason behind brokenstar even existing, dovewings silence: to show how it affects dovewing because she doesnt have her power anymore. i can go on, each of them has their purpose, we can exclude a few though, (leafpools wish, spottedleafs heart)
Tigerstar was made leader mainly because StarClan has to give a leader lives, no matter their morals. I think of it as, if a cat is able to get far enough and be so respected that they are able to take the role as deputy and then leader, StarClan sees it as an accomplishment and will give the cat lives no matter what they want to do with the Clan. Tigerstar was only chosen because ShadowClan thought Tiger was a sign that the Clan would be able to repair after the sickness (i think, haven’t read the books in a while and only remember about a prophecy?? Idk, correct me if i’m wrong).
"Most of the Main heros have the personality of a pile of sawdust." I know exactly what you mean... **cough cough** Lionblaze **cough** Sorry, something was in my throat.
Scrolling down, I see a lot of comments pointing out how SkyClan was major in AVoS and Sleekwhisker was also a female villain. Guys, check the release date of this video. This video was made before the fifth series (A Vision Of Shadows/AVoS). This video was made before SkyClan and Sleekwhisker in AVoS. If you don’t believe me, feel free to look it up ^^ This video was posted in 2015 while A Vision Of Shadows was released a year later, in 2016.
Onewhisker's name as an apprentice was onepaw and as a kit onekit. who in their right mind would name their kit onekit? That's some bad parenting right there......
I'd like to see JUST ONCE a character have 8 kittens in one pregnancy. that would be truley interesting. But then again Erin's might just kill them all in less than 2 years :/
The whole Ashfur thing drives me crazy. That "His only crime is loving too much" thing is total bull! Squirrelflight was under no obligation to accept his feelings. When your "love" causes you to obsess over someone for years and then try to kill her family, that's not love. That's an episode of Criminal Minds.
This should be a sin: can't the reins just agree on the colouring of cats? Longtails silvery pelt? Sandstorm being russet furred? Pale ginger tawnypelt? Mapleshade - tortie or orange and white? Come on erins
I think 12 is more so that people don’t hate on your own video.. Also, manga is a style of comic. It doesn’t need to be made in Japan. That idea is actually childish; I know japan, and that’s not where all manga comes from.
And once again, 25 is wrong. Because Alderpaw (heart) goes on a quest to find Skyclan. Also it leads up to Skyclan's Destiny ( I'm a wc nerd yayy ) ~Wolfmistress da wc nerd yayy
I love how people in the comments can't understand that just because it's a good series with a good idea, it doesn't mean there won't be flaws and assume if you agree with these points, you haven't read the books. You're right, they didn't just read them; they actually paid attention to details. Even with multiple writers, there is something called looking back and communicating with one another to make sure there are no mistakes. And you'd think with so many writers, they'd come up with better character attributes an flaws. I get more personality from Warrior Cats Oc generator than out of most of the heroes. And thus is my own say in this whole thing. Lighten up and just enjoy the video.
A similar thing happened to Brightflower; she was upset that her kits died. I mean, *I* would be furious if my children were murdered! (I don't remember if a fox killed them or if Brokenstar did... I think Brokenstar...?)
The Mangled Pirate it was, the super edition said that there was no fox scent near their bodies, that or Brokenstar sent them to attack the fox, the fox treated them like Swiftpaw, and Brokenstar thought of this as a chance to frame Yellowfang, so to do it, he picked up their bodies after the fox left, dragged them to the clearing, and then made sure there was no trails of blood, along with no fox scent on the bodies
I have a few more Sin ideas: - Ivypool is the only main character without a love interest - Clear sky stealing 3 of his brothers crushes - Clear sky in general. - Bluestar becomes mates with/has kits with a Riverclan tom. Nobody really cares. Mapleshade becomes mates with/has kits with a Riverclan tom. EVEryone freaks the flip out and exiles her. - The Erins kill Ferncloud just because some people in the fandom wine to her about it. - Could you take off a few Sins because of how amazing Crookedstar's promise was? - Rainflower. - Clear sky again. - Most of the clan cats are "racist" (They hate kittypets) - I've noticed when it comes to sad deaths, they are like 90% females (Grey Wing's death was pretty sad) - The fandom in some parts Thanks for using my Yellowfang art by the way.
Nope, I am too. After 2 years of screaming "NO JUST FRIGGIN SHARE THE ROCKS" Starclan finally decided the only way to resolve it was tearing them up and kicking the cats out. 'No peace, no sharing, no service'
While I'm sure this has been mentioned and I agree with a lot of things said in this video, Harveymoon and Billystorm got their names due to being former kittypets. They were called "daylight warriors" who would join SkyClan by day and go home to their twolegs by night. Their prefixes are their kittypet names, their suffixes being, well, regular warrior suffixes.
Maybe StarClan gave Yellowfang the powers because they knew Spottedleaf would die without an apprentice. Clawface is one of the worst cats in the entire series, now that I think about it.
I haven't read tall stars revenge but I have read rise of scourge enough times (like 40 times XD) to know that Jake is scourge's father and also Firestars father, and It should be true because of how close they lived to each other in the start so Jake couldn't have went that far.
"of course yellowfang would welcome ashfur into starclan, she herself broke the code so many times she probably forgot what was in it" me : prntscr.com/dbu0o4
The 27th sin makes me angry (I agree with it). Like, in the recent books Dovewing was like "okay um I had Tigerheart's kits so I'm moving out" and everyone in ThunderClan, despite some being a bit bitter, were actually fine with it and didn't stop her
Scourge's collar is actually PURPLE. If you have TROS, look at Scourge on the cover. Your answer is right there. Edit: I know its different in other places. BTW, ty for the likes.
Actually, it depends on how people's eyes show it in certain lighting. Sometimes it's red, other times purple. On the Russian Cover, i'm pretty sure it's yellow.
SkyClan is mostly made up of rogues and loners who ended up obtaining full SkyClan blood after they'd joined. Also who here actually kind of loves Macgyver after Hawkwing's Journey? Love that guy now...
Forbidden love has no point cuz in Mapleshade's vengance all she did was fall in love and gets kits. Then Ravenwing tells the clan they get exiled. All the kits die and Appledusk runs off with another mate in like a day? And Thunderclan and Appledusk expect nothing to happen to them. Meanwhile, In the future, Every cat who does that is instantly forgiven. SO Mapleshade never deserved to be in the dark forest. They should just like take that part out of the code if nobody's ever gonna listen to it.
Sorry but if they took that out of the code, there wouldn't be a separation of clans... everyone would just combine. it wouldn't make any sense to do that... the 4 clans would be one. yes graystripe, leafpool, and etc were punished?? maybe not harshly but its not like they're going to kick them out of the clan or kill them...
No like make a rule that eceryone who does that ( If like all of the leaders agree ) they should be forgiven and the kits should be forgiven as well like seriously
2:00 because this battle was against the Dark Forest, who also wanted to take over StarClan. In the Darkest Hour, they did not need StarClan to fight for them! Logic. This video should be called: 'How to get hate comments in 9 minutes or less (aka, my opinion of Warriors)'
You know, all of these people are known for making positive and negative videos about Warriors. And let’s be honest, Warriors is amazing, but it’s also filled with issues.
I love Warriors, and it's so funny to see all these and be like "hey! I noticed that too!" there is soooo much wrong with warriors but it's still my favorite books series! its actually pretty funny when a cat's eye color changes mid-sentence.
3:36 I have noticed that most fully developed couples are the fandoms least favorites. I've been getting a lot of spottedleaf x firepaw, or Scourge and Ashfur, but I don't see a lot of people being interested for Firestar and Sandstorm, Lionblaze and Cinderheart, or Millie and Greystripe. When actually those couples are actually pretty sweet.
I could easily answer all of the questions you had. Without all of the occurrences, the books would have been extremely boring and straightforward. I don't know about you, but I personally wouldn't like to read a bunch of boring books. But maybe that's just me.
Most of the points were mistakes (because yes, the authors are human, they should not be expected to be perfectly in sync writers) and this person simply not actually thinking about the outcome of what happened.
+Faith paulus (Moonshine/toxic) You are both correct and incorrect. Its funny how people get butthurt over the collar's color honestly. If ya did your research (no offence) in USA manga version 'The rise of Scourge' it is indeed purple but on the Chinese cover of Darkest Hour it was brown. While in the Russian version it's yellow. This also explains why its color is never mentioned in the books. Cause technically its color that of a rainbow like Bone's collar. In other words, it doesn't have a specific color therefore could be any color.
Yes! And they use like some strange word usage, like "Let's you and me lead the way". Uncombined=Let us you and me lead the way. ('_')?? Oh wait it kind of makes sense now?
And what happened to Smudge? Did Firestar just forget about his best friend when he was a kittypet? He's never mentioned after the the second book, and they don't include him in the 'Outside Clan Cats' section after the first series, like, I know it's really scraping the bottom of the barrel, and I'm half joking, but still, I'm genuinely curious about what happened to him.
I'm pretty sure smudge is still alive but he's probably just forgotten I will never forget him though Edit: now thinking about it he could very likely still be alive. Kittypets do live longer lives than the forest cats and aren't exposed to much sickness, infection, battles, etc.
DesteLynx YT Actually in human years Dustpelt would’ve been like 23 or something and Ferncloud would’ve been like 19. That’s not bad. But yet Thornclaw and Blossomfall’s gap would’ve been like 20 years or something
The age gap between Thorn x Blossom and Dust x Fern aren't large at all for cats, it doesn't matter how much older one cat is. Pine x Leapord scares me though
@@caralynpatterson4901 No he wasn’t. Dustpelt got Ashpaw and Fernpaw was given to Darkstripe but maybe he took over her training after Darkstripe got exiled? They were really close when she was an apprentice though. He was the one who told Fireheart Fernpaw wanted to tell him about Swiftpaw and Brightpaw. Plus I’d doubt that Darkstripe actually trained his apprentice at all. But Ferncloud, Ashfur and Thornclaw barely even talk to Cloudtail even tho they were best friends as apprentices. Especially Ashfur and Cloudtail. Ashfur even started to ha kittypet when his best friend was born as one. Fireheart only told two cats about Cloudpaw getting taken away and that was Bluestar and Ashpaw. That really annoys me. No one has friends unless it’s relevant to the plot.
it's final. scourges collar is obviously a mood collar
So right
Yup
HAHAHAHAHyes
its purple in the books cover photo ist purple
OBVIOUSLY,STUPID WARRIORS FANS!
Whenever I think of Billystorm I think of a bunch of billy goats in a storm
Lol Quiet Rage did a vid on that😹
It was funny af.
Warrior cats taken literaly.
Omg
Same
Same lol
And how the hell did nobody notice Leafpool was pregnant and Squirrelflight wasn't
maybe they thought she got fat on herbs? or maybe she just hid away in hr den a lot and some how there was nothing wrong going on in that part of time. idefk
*Ding
some cats dont get big while pregnant.
my cat luna was pregnant and we didnt realise because she had long fur and didnt really show
Navi Chan Good point, but Leafpool was shown to have shorter fur. She wasn't fluffy like Cloudtail
+soapitysoap1114 I think Brambleclaw mentioned it in one of those plays on the official website or something similar. He said, well, thought to himself that the great amount of prey that year was showing so that even Leafpool, someone who is said to be be very small and lithe, was increasing weight. What he didn't know was that she was actually pregnant.
5:06 why does nobody understand?! Billystorm and Harveymoon were kittypets but joined SkyClan, but went back to their twolegs at night, so they wanted to combine their kittypet names with warrior names (which is both logical and weird in my opinion).
Finally someone said it..
L O G I C
A T
L A S T
Daylight warriors
r/woooooosh
What they are trying to say is that rusty became firestar and yet the others kept their names
They're called daylight warriors, Skyclan made them a thing but every other clan knew skyclan was a loser so they didnt do the same thing.
In The Darkest Hour, there should’ve been a scene where Firestar realizes that he and Scourge are kin, so he tries to reason with him.
Like, he gets sent a dream about him and Scourge being kin.
Idk. Someone write it.
Firestar looked at Scourge, “wait we are brothers!” He cried, “don’t care still wanna kill you” Scourge replied
ThE eNd
Firestar gazed at Scourge, as he staggered to his forepaws holding hisself up. " We share the same father, we're kin Scourge. " Firestar raised is gaze towards the small black tom, missing the color of his callor. The tom smirked as he swiped his pink tounge over his muzzle, only smearing more blood around. " Blood? Blood... " He seemed to pause for a moment as if somecat told him the same thing. " Blood, its nothing but something runing in your vains, keeping you and I alive. " Unexpected he leaped at firestar, planting his dog claws onto his shoulders, holding the tom down roughly. " We are no kin. " he yowled as he raised his forepaw over head, firestar quickly kicked the Tom's underbelly, as the black down staggered backwards, firestar yowled as he staggered to his paws tackling the tom, rolling on the ground with him, scraping at the Tom's flank as they parted, firestar then felt a rage flood over him,
He then snarled as he pinned down the tom from behind, planting his claws into his shoulders, as the callor that was easily to big for the tom hanged down the dog teeth drizzled with dried blood. Firestar then dug his fangs into his scruff shacking his head wildly as scourge hissed firestar then felt the Tom's constant struggles fade away, as he stepped back, it had been done, he killed Scourge.
[ I'm board so ima just say whitestorm'is now leader lol ]
Whitestorm darted away from the dog, kicking up grass as he hoped the dog would lose interest, he then turned around arching his back, his white pelt shot upward as he hissed loudly, the dog ignored his warning, and leaped at him, Whitestorm felt jagged teeth into his torso as he then felt the harsh ground, the dog roughly planting it's paw on his belly, the white tom closed his eyes, ready for the worst, thinking about his mother and father, as the pain never came, he slightly opened his mouth as the recognizable sent reatchef the top of his mouth, he then opened his eyes as he saw Firestar tackling the dog, sinking his claws and teeth into their side, as he clinged on the dog, the dog shook his pelt, blood filled the air as the dog stood to his hindpaws as it flopped over on its side, firestar hissed as Whitestorm gathered his strength to stand. He then forced hisself up, as with wild eyes he saw the two go closer to the edge of the cliff. `` Firestar, watch out! `` he yowled, as the white tom started towards him. Then the dog stood to his paws, as Firestar was flung off, gently landing to his paws with small grunt, as he launched hisself towards the dog, climbed to his snout as the dog whined, then the two fell off the cliff. `` No! `` Whitestorm yowled as without hesitation leaped after his leader. He gagged as water rushed into his mouth, opening his eyes as he saw firestar, sinking towards the bottom of the water, Whitestorm raised to the top for a gasp of air as he dropped back down. He clung his teeth gently into his scruff, the tent of them both a light blue. He then raised to the air as he yowled for help. He felt his leader's flank against his as he grew tired, he then felt the heavy weight of Firestar lift and he drew his attention towards Greystripe who was formally a Riverclan warrior, he nodded towards the grey tom with darker stripe down his back all the way towards his tail tip. Like the never ending Thunderpath,
Whitestorm found his self at Firestar's side, as he raised his head towards Greystripe, Sandstorm, and Spottedleaf, with grief in her eyes. `` Cant you help him, please! `` Whitestorm pleaded as he pressed closer to the Tom's side, shivering with the lost of hope on his yellow eyes. `` Whitestorm...he's gone.`` She walked towards the Tom's side as she rest her soft tongue over his head, he looked over towards the limp leader digging his head into his neck, drowned with grief as he pleaded that Starclan knew what they were doing.
[ lol ima just keep coming back to this adding stuff on, now I'm out of ideas ]
jacket addict
That was great 👍
@@axinitewolf thanks :>
jacket addict
No problem
"Scourges collar color has NEVER been mentioned!"
It's on the cover of the manga.....
*DING*
Mya Bento it’s different on front covers for different countries
allodoxaphobia
True, buddy 👍
I didn't think about that. Thank you for being polite about that and not writing some long rude comment ☺️
Night fury Gaming
I didn't think about that. I just expected that because they speak English they would read the English one
There’s a manga?
African Lion Yeah, there is a whole serise. Ravenpaw Path, SkyClan and the Stranger, Graystripe’s Adventure and I forgot the name of Sasha but she has one. They all have three books in them, besides Scourge’s stand alone. There is one coming out about Silverstream on June 2nd.
What about Mapleshade being only cat punished for being in love with a cat from other clan?
Also, Princess WAS mentioned in second arc! By CoDy! Am i the only one that remember?
once, possible twice, but still
who is cody
@@wolfquestfan8259 ONLY KG WARRIOR FANS WILL KNOW WHO CODY IS
@@gracie9306 Cody is leafpool's kittypet gf
@AyshaPlays :3 Do you have a problem with that? :p
Star Clan dosen't care if you're evil or not you will still get you're 9 lives
*Ding*
AbyssalWorld Thank-you!
They didn’t give them to Nightstar. He pretended to have them.
I like to think there is a reason for Tigerstar getting nine lives
I actually included that reason in a rewrite I'm working on
@@themediocremen1128 True, I believe that was because Brokenstar was still alive, since he was prisoner in ThunderClan's camp, so Nightstar took his leader name without getting his nine lives
Well, yes. But you are disregarding the code (Just like the authors half the time) The code states that the deputy will become leader after their leader retires/dies. They cannot just say "Oh hey. This guy is evil. We won't give him nine lives." Two days before their ceremony because that would be vialsting the code THEY created. So, they really didn't have a choice. Sorry if this makes you see me as one of those annoying fans.
Nightstar, a good warrior who is proven loyal : can I get 9 lives?
Starclan: haha no
Tigerstar, a murderous and dangerous tom who killed Thunderclan's deputy for power and almost killed its leader: can i get 9 lives?
Starclan: *oh sure, i have no problem with that*
Brokenstar was still alive. That's why Nightstar wasn't given nine lives. Also because "he wasn't right for leader." Or something. Same thing happened with Sunstar and Pinestar, Sunstar only got eight lives because Pinestar was still alive as a kittypet.
@@youknowwhatelseisbig484 well brokenstar also had one life like pinestar
Yeah this so true like wtf
I NEVER SAW Writers write themselves into the GROUND so hard.
What an amazing Book-Series and what amazingly bad Quality it has.
It literally just continueing on and on and on and on hurts it more than even Ice-Age was hurt by being-milked and that’s a Feat!
I mean, let me in the following list JUST some of the things coming to mind before it all went down the drains with the Zombie-Apocalypse many knew about and no one told Firestar about, leading to his Death by basically ‚Thunder Clan Betrayal’ we had Cliches and Things just endlessly repeating itself.
Firestar is a great Leader, but ‚only’ as much as his broken, broken Culture allows. He’s a ‚relatively’ good Leader as much as he’s restrained: His World literally does not consider things like Trade or Peace-Offerings Moral.
Both Concepts are EVIL-HERESY-OF-EVILNESS.
If both sides have something the other wants and suffers withuot it, the Books present 2 Options ‚War or Peace-in-the-sense-of-suffering-in-Solemn’.
If this is not recognized by the Author as objectively problematic than no one IN the Book will ever go and change the s-it.
HENCE why the damn Romeo-and-Juliet Plot REPEATED ITSELF 1000 Times, making me scream.
LMAO so true! I've always wondered why Tigerstar got his 9 lives
We have cats named Bone, Scourage. and egg?
Bitch we need a cat named pancakes, cupcakes, and food.
It's SCOURGE Not Scourage!! MY GOD
+Artistic_wolfii \
ScouRage
Score-Rage
RAGE!!!!
+Artistic_wolfii Calm down, it was a simple mistake, unlike Firestar people have flaws. Spelling can be one of them.
+layla coulson No, Waffles.
I agree -_-
Them: SkyClan is never mentioned ever again
Me: **cough** *A vision of shadows* *cough*
*Edit: Ok, so a lot of people are saying this was out before ‘vision of shadows’ but I watched this video long after it came out, and I didn’t check the date it came out. I realise that now it came out before ‘A vision of shadows.’
Niamh Murphy this was made before that
My only warrior cat book is a vision of shadows (I read my freinds warrior cat books XD)
She was talking about the SkyClan Journey, not the clan
The Broken Code cough.*
@@electrathejelliclekitten8063 Sorry. Haven't read Broken Code yet!
Mapleshade is the only female villian.
Sleekwhisker: Am I a joke to you?
Lololololol
Mapleshade: Well I am better, my plan worked, duuuuhhhh
Sleekwhisker: TRY ME
Lololololololololololol
before avos
this gives me life
Hi Blixemi! "this gives me life" Your comment gives me life.
Damn blixemi only 16 likes
Wtf blixemi I thought you and I were both Warriors geeks but rlly THIS VIDEO MAKE ME LOSE LIVE
Be more chiiiilll
In the end they said they did this 4 fun and it was a joke, CHIIIIIIILLL.
Also love u Blixemi ur songs r paw-some! No? U sure? Okay, okay, it's no claws for worry.
I'll go now.
Make a song about this :)
Spoiler warning.
1:53 In The Darkest Hour, all four clans fight one clan. In The Last Hope, all the Clans are fighting against many evil cats along with cats from their own clans that were trained to be savage by the Dark Forest.
2:06 It explains more about the Clan's origins.
2:44 Firestar thought it was better that the cats didn't know about Skyclan, so he didn't mention it except when he was talking to Brambleclaw in series two about how he wanted to wait for Graystripe because he waited for him when he went on a journey.
3:46 The clan cats all thought he was insane.
4:19 Bluestar didn't want to question this because she didn't want any cats to be suspicious and she gave up Oakheart for her clan.
4:57 Longtail was named after his tail, just like Tallstar. That's what his mother thought of when he was named Longkit.
5:05 Billystorm and Harveymoon are daylight warriors, they wanted to keep part of their name.
5:27 Yellowfang didn't want any cat to know about her power, so she didn't show any sign of it.
7:28 Yellowfang was lying to Squirrelflight so that she would accept the kits. She tells this to Squirrelflight in a dream while she was pregnant with Alderheart and Sparktail.
Fishleap I though Tigerstar got his lives from StarClan cats, it is mentioned in the ultimate guide, Badgerfang gave him a life
Warrior Cat
Sorry for the late reply and thank you. I should do a bit more research...whoops.
Fishleap I agree with all of that other than the tiger star getting with his lives from the dark forest
Fishleap daayyyym
The truth
Right there
Mlpchoclate twilight
Yeah, I recently realized that ;-; I'm going to fix it now.
"Tigerstar"
+200,000 sins
"Dovewing"
+∞ sins
yes
Tigerclaw (he doesn't deserve the name tigerstar) like a God of cat hell
Avrap AJ YYYYYEEEEEESSSSSSS
Nope. More than that.
Tigerstar=
A billion+ sins
Actually Yellowfang didn't get special healing powers; she just got a power to get hurt when a another cat is hurt. It had NOTHING to do with healing.
dat timing that part was playing right when i scrolled down to see this comment accidentally
Yeah. Soo-
ALSO in the book that YellowFang kills BrokenStar with death berries, FireHeart in his mind says that she seems like she has the effects of the death berries.
can we all metion the fact that one of the windclan cats is named "sneezepaw" like omg imagine this:
mother: i just cant think of a name for my kit
kit: *sneezes*
mother: OMG ill just name him SNEEZEKIT
me: -_-
ikr
OMG LOL u are right!!!♡
And apparently Onestar was an only kit. (Onekit)
Elizabeth Pishkur and what about kinkfur? that one made me disspointed
+Wowie! is this at a house because they get a clan name
(SPOILER ALERT) It makes me angry that almost every important character is related to Firestar. Brambleclaw, his son in law, becomes deputy and is part of an important prophecy. Squirrelflight, his daughter, is in and important prophecy and becomes deputy. Leafpool becomes medicine cat and receives the "blood will spill blood" prophecy. His grandchildren are part of a prophecy, have powers, and Jayfeather becomes med cat. Also, Greystripe may not be retaliated, but COME ON ERIN, he choose his best friend as deputy? I love Warriors, but, Firestars importantness is never ending.
Soda Bomb PLEASE DEAR STAR CLAN DONT LET SPARKPELT BECOME DEPUTY 👏👏👏👏
Well it was said that Fire will save the clan ,so I guess that might be the reason
Woah Fire star was told to choose grey stripe
Agreed. Really sorry about the people trying to correct your opinion. like wtf
Lucky Moon AJ I saw somewhere that they wanted Cinderheart to be deputy
But she's Lionblazes mate
Come👏on
EVERYTHING WRONG WITH THIS VIDEO
1. Scourges collar color is shown on the cover of the manga
2. It actually does mention Firestar and scourge are related in the series
3. You mentioned twice about Princess and Skyclan being forgotten
4. Skyclan is mentioned again, a lot actually
5. There is no evidence towards Firstar forgetting Princess since after the first series it isn't from his perspective
6. You getting unsubbed for this video is not a problem in the warriors series
7. The title should have been everything wrong with the warriors fandom since almost half of your points are whats wrong with the fans
8. Brightheart was a mentor to Jayfeather for a while
9. In the manga of Bramblestar's storm Yellowfang admits that she was lying, it was not just 'thrown out the window'
10. Firestar has many flaws
11. Mapleshade is not the only female villain
12. If you had read the guide then you would know why Tigerstar gets his lives
13. Thistleclaw is in the dark forest because he was training there before he died
IM NOT TRYING TO BE MEAN OR HATE IN ANYWAY!
About the Firestar and scourge thing, it says in the ultimate guide that they are half brothers because their father is Jake. Also, squirrel flights white law is a genetic trait that she got from scourge. So, yeah.
I fell like people are stupid with the color of scourges callor what they don't read or seen the book before they just dash making up a color that's not true?! >:C
Leopard Breeze the whole thistleclaw getting chased into the dark forest by bluestar thing isn't true, it was a joke by the erins
Firestar and Scourge's father is Jake. But that's not surprising, Jake is everyone's father. Jake is your father.
Well nobody really trusts about what's in the manga other than the rise of scourge
How to make a fandom angry
Be critical of it when you've never read the source material
There you go!
Idk. This man read the first series then listened to his older sister and thats why he made this video
Woops. The idk was supposed to be ikr. Ugh they all look the same
This video is a joke.
How obvious is it that its not supposed to offend anyone. Dont be an ass about this, this video is for comedy and comedy only
@@JlMMOTHY No, actually it's trying to point out facts and some of them are wrong while the person who made this should've had full details before putting what was wrong about that character / part of the book in the video. Don't try to defend the person who made this by calling people who are right asses when the only ass here is you.
Am I the only one who thinks Spottedleaf is a stalker at this stage? No wonder Mapleshade killed her, she must have wanted to be the only one who got involved in everyone's lives for no actual reason.
um clawface kills spottedleaf not mapleshade
+WolfQuest Fan
Just wanted to let you know, yes, he does. Then Spottedleaf goes to StarClan, and so on.
(Into the.. 3rd arc?)
Dark Forest comes and tries to take over, the prophecy of three, blah blah blah.
Then, this happens and she’s killed again, by Mapleshade this time.
Hope this helped ya understand more.
@@_bentleyboy3000_
oh ok, I get it, I only read series 1 and 2
"Scourge was born on the edge of Twolegplace, the kittypet son of Quince and Jake, who went on to father Firestar and Princess with another kittypet, Nutmeg." p.197 of The Ultimate Guide Wow I didn't think I would need to pull out a book for that.
I need to cleanse myself by playing videogames and watching UA-cam.
THE SCOURGE'S WILL DESTROY YOU FOR SHARING THIS INFORMATION SYDNEY
True, hence why Fire star and Scourge were half brothers
Bluestar becoming pregnant and not noticing it herself.
Fucking spoilers...
You should've been able to figure that out by yourself from the nature of the video.
She did notice it!!!!! Read the book it will tell u!
She had to give up her kits to riverclan so she chould be deputy and then become leader she made it look like a fox or bagger had taken them.
She did not. It wasn't like until halfway through that her CLANMATES pointed it out, and then she realised it and the events of her giving up her kids occurred afterwards.
TheCatzFranzNeko Same with moth flight.
They gave him lives because he was willing to make Shadowclan strong again
*(Not my words, the creators)*
I live and breathe warriors but I have to admit this was funny! Glad to know the series isn't a series that's all perfect and dandy!
Fierce_Gamer 101 most of this was incorrect though....
Meme Kraken
just let people enjoy a goddamn video and stop being a killjoy. this video was made for ENTERTAINMENT purposes.
Fierce_Gamer 101 I love vid but I'm the biggest Warrior fan ever
Meme Kraken, technically speaking, saying “most” isn’t necessarily the best word... I’d say “half”
THE SERIES IS *PERFECT*
why is Mapleshade one of the only cats to be punished for having a mate from a different clan?
ikr
Ikr?! Like, Leafpool ran away with Crowfeather, but when she came back, all the got was a light time out. Yeah she got her medicine cat position taken away, but she got it back not even a whole series later.
+Bread Lord (Bread Jesus) Idk if you've read all the books, but that's not true. Although i might be mistaking you. What do you mean by "Punished"?
+Elka Wu She probably means cast out. Banished.
+TheSteel_Flame That was the leader's choice. Other cats who wee not banished had many cats wanting to banish them too.. And i think leaders these days are more understanding. I suppose they were all punished one way or another. If it helps, the leader who exiled mapleshade had his own punishment when mapleshade became evil because of that.
Princess was mentioned in Warriors: The New Prophesy
snowleopardfriends spelling?
Umm no
U are wrong please
snowleopardfriends prophecy
snowleopardfriends No she wasnt
PUBLIC PSA:
THIS WAS MADE IN 2015. AVOS WAS NOT IN EXISTENCE AT THIS POINT!
Sol doesn't believe in Starclan but yet he listens to a badger who believes in Starclan. How interesting.
im sad now i love warrior cats and this is killin me
sorry for hate
I know ALL WARRIORS FANS ARE HERE FOR YA!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!!!!!!!!!!!11!!!
Brad and Miranda Mann I'm a warriors fan and this is VERY accurate
I love warriors
Don’t say sorry
Im aswell a warrior fan
Ill say it now and get attacked by everyone. I love warriors and this was amazingly true and funny.
Preach!
You bet!
+Hala Vest NOPE
my thoghts exactly
tru dat dude (I read ALL the books)
Fun fact, thistleclaw was indeed evil. Even if he didnt "kill any cats". He targeted spottedpaw/kit when hes way older than she is. (1)
He led tigerpaw(claw/star) to train in the dark forest and was super hostile towards bluefur for no reason, clanmates should always be nice to each other. (2) :')
It was Mapleshade who led Tigerclaw/star into the dark forest, it says it in Tigerclaws Fury that Mapleshade apparently was guiding hus footsteps all of his life.
@@duxduxduckie well that is true however I do believe based on Bluestar’s prophecy he did have some influence on Tigerpaw’s (Tigerstar’s) actions since Thistleclaw made Tigerpaw attack Scourge when he was a defenseless kit and not only that he was harshly training him so although I do agree that Mapleshade did more stuff to Tigerstar but Thistleclaw (well at least how I interpreted it) did have some influence to some degree.
clanmates arent required to be kind to eachother.
@@discountlivpig True,for example Darkstripe was not nice to Firepaw/heart/star
@@thumpernovember i personally think longtail is a better example (bc darkstripe is evil). he was never fond of rusty, and yet he was shown to be selfless and fiercely loyal to his clan, even saving fireheart from drowning.
13 - the cats needed a leader and they chose
15 - if there were to many reincarnation then itd be natural
17- they have their own live
20- bc it helps them feel more comfy
23 - american style
25 - because firestar and scourge never knew about it
I NEVER SAW Writers write themselves into the GROUND so hard.
What an amazing Book-Series and what amazingly bad Quality it has.
It literally just continueing on and on and on and on hurts it more than even Ice-Age was hurt by being-milked and that’s a Feat!
I’d like to add to the transgender cats...
On the subject of Mosskit, they’re gender was male in the books that let you take a look inside the clans but years later it decided to become a girl and has been mentioned in a few books (Spottedleaf’s Heart, A look into the Warriors, etc) as Female. MAKE UP YOUR GODDAMN MINDS ERINS!
Mosskit is female, its been confirmed, but Rowanclaw and Mosskit have had atleast one gender change throughout the books
i dont like the idea of literal kits being transgender when they probably have no idea what it means.
@@FanetOfJanet….its not being transgender. Its just inconsistency with the books😭what is wrong w you? 😭
wdym what is wrong with me? they said transgender cats, not inconsistency, and i wasnt even mad at them.@@thatonekid1277
4:06
She didn’t have a hard time choosing which to be with though, she was struggling to realize that she couldn’t force herself to love Bumblestripe. She never loved him, this it was impossible for her to ever choose him. Even when she ‘chose’ him, she realized their relationship would never work out because they weren’t meant for one another.
Agreed.
Duck duck Goose goose thank you!
Also, Bumblestripe is a bad bad. Need I say more?
I'm not going to hate on your video
I'm just going to silently disagree
*This video was made for fun, don’t take it too seriously* they say
Maya Ziman it wasn’t
Maya Ziman They DIDINT take it seriously!
This video is just a joke, be nice.
Dont shit on Disdorks because they made a video that WAS CLEARLY NOT TRYING TO OFFEND ANYONE and did.
The books haven't said directly Scourge and Firestar are half-brothers, but they have the same father (Jake), and Squirrelflight's white paw also symbolizes the half-brotherhood of Firestar and Scourge, just pointing that out! ^u^ -1 Sin(s)
Also, like so Disdorks sees this.
Also that Hollyleaf, Firestar's granddaughter, is black(although that could come from Crowfeather's side, Scourge was also black)
that's what's I was going to say and I've already said it in different video comments
that's what's I was going to say and I've already said it in different video comments
WHAT IS WRONG WITH YOU!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I love the warriors cat series I'm a little offended but this is so true that I can't be mad. Crow feather is a cat fuckboi not a cat where.
+KatTheAnimator EXACTLY.
+KatTheAnimator OMSC I am so offended he is not one of those! He just loved a lot! Whatever gender you are, I'm pretty sure you'll date/marry more than 3 guys/girls!
+Sydney Braun I love crow feather he's one of my favorite characters do he was thought of bad I'm just saying that's what we call boy whores is a fuckboi
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
True but I still love him >w
*sins*
why the heck do they have the most underdeveloped character kill a cat who could've been a more important character thats alive and more believable? Why couldn't a developed character kill spotted leaf?
PrimalKitCat Loves Gravity Falls and Art and Music because not everything has to be a more developed character. shut uo
Sketching Animals shh i dont want to cry because spottedleaf died
not everything has to revole around complately developed characters. also it happened in the first god flipping book, there will be so little developed characters boi.
Bluefeather329 shhh
skira 1,0026 DONT U DARE SHUSH ME YOU LITTLE TIGERSTAR CLONE. (i actiony cant think of any insults XD btw im just being radiculus rn :P)
Sorry, I'm helping Sparrowkit. He has greencough.
Smolest Sam ?
Scourge and Firestar ARE half brothers because they both have the same father, who was Jake, but different Mothers. Princess and Firestar's Mother is Nutmeg, Father is Jake. Ruby, Socks and Scourge's mother is Quince, and their father, Jake.
Gamer Cat Jackie sure, but I think they mean that we don't need to know. It's a nice little detail that makes Scourge more interesting, but it doesn't influence the story in any way, so they questioned why the Erins made that up in the first place ^^
I Said Meow But why did they make the two half brothers. This doesn't add the story and this fact does nothing. Jake could be replaced by any other tom and nothing would change. (Sorry for my bad english)
Nah I ranther have could tail and fire heart
We KNOW who the parents are!
shut up not everyone knows
as much as i love this series, these are so hilarious and true xDD
Agreed
agreed
Yeeh
+Bgecko104 yeah not yeeh
The 13th sin is actually pretty stupid:/
ok. Egg... his sister is flour, his brother is baking soda, his mate is oven. His mother is chicken as his kits her Cake, pastry and Pancakes
Half of these sins can be proved wrong or are your opinion.
Yea
THATS THE POINT
Go watch the CinemaSins video where they sin themselves.
@@thedarkoverlordofall how is that the point?
Mm.. no.
Sin 83
That one Hollyleaf quote: (I wonder if cats could grow wings) sparked the Cats with Wings part of the fandom
1.SkyClan is mention in the books, manly the hole 5th ark :l
2.TigerStar became leader because if he didd'nt, the erins said ShadowClan would of torn apart with no leader
3.Theres a whole ark detected to Firestar and he gets his own Supper Adision?
Patience Warren “Why not anyone else?” Do you know how many damn SE there are? lol and especially including *all those damn novellas.*
1. Mentioned
2. Mainly
3. Whole
4. Tigerstar
5. Didn’t
6. No period
7.Erins
8. Need a been
9. There’s
10. Dedicated
11. Super
12. Addition
but their super editions add more to them, like firestars quest, introducing an entire clan,
yellowfangs curse(?), the reason behind brokenstar even existing,
dovewings silence: to show how it affects dovewing because she doesnt have her power anymore.
i can go on, each of them has their purpose, we can exclude a few though, (leafpools wish, spottedleafs heart)
And you spelled arc wrong ._.
Tigerstar was made leader mainly because StarClan has to give a leader lives, no matter their morals. I think of it as, if a cat is able to get far enough and be so respected that they are able to take the role as deputy and then leader, StarClan sees it as an accomplishment and will give the cat lives no matter what they want to do with the Clan. Tigerstar was only chosen because ShadowClan thought Tiger was a sign that the Clan would be able to repair after the sickness (i think, haven’t read the books in a while and only remember about a prophecy?? Idk, correct me if i’m wrong).
"Most of the Main heros have the personality of a pile of sawdust." I know exactly what you mean... **cough cough** Lionblaze **cough** Sorry, something was in my throat.
lol
Nonie Kangas I agree with you, and he was BETTER then the stupid little brat who stole the main role for series 3 and 4!!!!
Who is that brat?
Nonie Kangas jayfeather
At least he has a personality and character arc!
Scrolling down, I see a lot of comments pointing out how SkyClan was major in AVoS and Sleekwhisker was also a female villain. Guys, check the release date of this video. This video was made before the fifth series (A Vision Of Shadows/AVoS). This video was made before SkyClan and Sleekwhisker in AVoS. If you don’t believe me, feel free to look it up ^^
This video was posted in 2015 while A Vision Of Shadows was released a year later, in 2016.
Talk about nerd.
No but your right
I honestly like firexsand
Dude, chill
Me too.
Same I like Firestar and Sandstorm
Me too
Wiktoria Marzok f you
5:09
LOOK AT THE COVER OF THE SCOURGES MANGA ITS CLEARLY PURPLE
NUUUU its violet
***** Yeah probably, and I'm just being that annoying person that must correct everything
+Hedwig Animations I am the same.
Kate The Creative the official pic in the guide is red/orange
The color collar varies in different countries/continents. Thank you for the inconvenience. :)
when you watch a video spoiling almost the intire series becuase your still on midnight but dont give a f*** > :P
Bluefeather is a pigeon I just started moonrise so 😂
hahaha yup. im waiting for my book order of the new prophecy to arrive XD
Dude im on twilight
I'm on sunset. Meh
I just finished the darkest hour
RiverClan = Graceful swimmers
WindClan = Good runners
ShadowClan = Skilled ambushers
SkyClan = Great Jumpers
ThunderClan = ...Uhhh... Perfect perfectness?
ThunderClan = Boring main characters
Onewhisker's name as an apprentice was onepaw and as a kit onekit. who in their right mind would name their kit onekit? That's some bad parenting right there......
Agreed
Yup
I always thought it was because he was the only one in his litter, thus onekit. I could be wrong though.
He was the only kit,with his mother being Wrenflight,Tallstar's half sis
NOBODY CARES!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Sin: Dovewing *Adds a crap ton of points*
XD XD XD XD
The mangas, aren't that. They're graphic novels, so WHHHYYYY aren't they called that?!
A lot of these are incorrect. No hate but just saying
Just saying, look at the date.
Also, many are just repeated. And Dovewing, though we all hate her, would only be one sin.
Name one. Dovewing's eyes are, in fact, green, crowfeather's were wrong, and longtail is an AWFUL name.
True dat
Lil Starclan AJ I totally agree
There's the fact that they have usually up to 2 or 3 kits when in reality litters have 5 to 9 kits.
Izaya is My senpai yep
Izaya is My senpai they do that to keep the character numbers down. Would you want to have to remember 5 billion characters at one time?
EquinCrazy DisneyCraz I'm aware of that thank you. You don't need to be snotty.
I'd like to see JUST ONCE a character have 8 kittens in one pregnancy. that would be truley interesting. But then again Erin's might just kill them all in less than 2 years :/
DirtyBrownieMix Same
The fact a name 'PawClaw' or 'BreezeWind' could technically exist.
Also... the name 'ONEstar'
Pawkit? PawPaw? XD
or Starkit, then Starpaw, then Starpelt, then Starstar if they became a leader XD
Featherfeather can be a name.
Ha! True true!
SOOO true! I'm crying of laughter 😂😂😂😂 whoever hates doesn't know how to take a damn joke 😂😂😂
Ikr
Totally
I love warrior cats and this is so funny to me.😹😹😹
+Тoхι ВandιтLeap this wasnt a joke this stuff she sadi is so true theres noway u can say its a joke its definatly not
MissesKitty damn. I know it is. -looks like somebody didn't read the discription!- chill out.
"Most of the main heroses have the personality of a pile of sawdust."
They should be in Avengers then.
Does anyone else like the name Harveymoon?
Fuzzyrabbit824 Aj I do.
Fuzzyrabbit824 Aj I do
I do
All it makes me think of is harvest moon XD.
dragonrush DA Dragonite ikr!!!
The whole Ashfur thing drives me crazy. That "His only crime is loving too much" thing is total bull! Squirrelflight was under no obligation to accept his feelings. When your "love" causes you to obsess over someone for years and then try to kill her family, that's not love. That's an episode of Criminal Minds.
This should be a sin: can't the reins just agree on the colouring of cats? Longtails silvery pelt? Sandstorm being russet furred? Pale ginger tawnypelt? Mapleshade - tortie or orange and white? Come on erins
well, in my opinion he’s a light tan tabby, but silver is cool too, it’s k to have an opinion
greentails auto correct
Bramblelily's the Bae X3 yh but I would prefer it if they didn't keep changing and just choose one
you have to expect some inconsistencies when you have multiple people writing one book series under one pen name.
reins?
I think 12 is more so that people don’t hate on your own video..
Also, manga is a style of comic. It doesn’t need to be made in Japan. That idea is actually childish; I know japan, and that’s not where all manga comes from.
yeah, but part of the style of manga is it being "backwards" and really, they're just graphic novels.
2 is wrong, on the manga cover he has a PURPLE collar
XD
Lol rekd
Wolfmistress THATS TRUE!
Everything Wrong With Everything Wrong With Warriors! lolol wtf am I saying? XD
And once again, 25 is wrong. Because Alderpaw (heart) goes on a quest to find Skyclan. Also it leads up to Skyclan's Destiny ( I'm a wc nerd yayy ) ~Wolfmistress da wc nerd yayy
The reason Cinderpelt got a reincarnation is being she was never supposed to become a medicine cat, tigerclaw messed up her destiny.
Yeah but why did Cinderheart look different was the question. I do like that she was reincarnated though, she was always one of my favorite characters
You could make this argument for many cats. Like LongTail. His destiny was screwed by BigWig from WaterShip Down.
A hawk messed up snowkit's life
Anonymous User
and technically, bluefur messed up mosskit’s (very short) life.
Mutilated Ghost Dog i love big wig and hazel x
I love how people in the comments can't understand that just because it's a good series with a good idea, it doesn't mean there won't be flaws and assume if you agree with these points, you haven't read the books. You're right, they didn't just read them; they actually paid attention to details.
Even with multiple writers, there is something called looking back and communicating with one another to make sure there are no mistakes. And you'd think with so many writers, they'd come up with better character attributes an flaws. I get more personality from Warrior Cats Oc generator than out of most of the heroes.
And thus is my own say in this whole thing. Lighten up and just enjoy the video.
Love how one sin was just Dovewing in general
Lilywhisker going to the dark forest just because she was upset about having to retire to the elders den just because of her crippled leg
A similar thing happened to Brightflower; she was upset that her kits died. I mean, *I* would be furious if my children were murdered! (I don't remember if a fox killed them or if Brokenstar did... I think Brokenstar...?)
The Mangled Pirate it was, the super edition said that there was no fox scent near their bodies, that or Brokenstar sent them to attack the fox, the fox treated them like Swiftpaw, and Brokenstar thought of this as a chance to frame Yellowfang, so to do it, he picked up their bodies after the fox left, dragged them to the clearing, and then made sure there was no trails of blood, along with no fox scent on the bodies
Bria Nonya
i think that after brokenstar killed the kits, but put fox scent around them so no one would blame him and he wouldn’t be exiled.
What is my life? There was no fox scent near them
I have a few more Sin ideas:
- Ivypool is the only main character without a love interest
- Clear sky stealing 3 of his brothers crushes
- Clear sky in general.
- Bluestar becomes mates with/has kits with a Riverclan tom. Nobody really cares. Mapleshade becomes mates with/has kits with a Riverclan tom. EVEryone freaks the flip out and exiles her.
- The Erins kill Ferncloud just because some people in the fandom wine to her about it.
- Could you take off a few Sins because of how amazing Crookedstar's promise was?
- Rainflower.
- Clear sky again.
- Most of the clan cats are "racist" (They hate kittypets)
- I've noticed when it comes to sad deaths, they are like 90% females (Grey Wing's death was pretty sad)
- The fandom in some parts
Thanks for using my Yellowfang art by the way.
m I the only one thats glad they moved to the lake so we don't need to have that sunningrocks shit between riverclan and thunderclan
Nope, I am too. After 2 years of screaming "NO JUST FRIGGIN SHARE THE ROCKS" Starclan finally decided the only way to resolve it was tearing them up and kicking the cats out. 'No peace, no sharing, no service'
Hetalia!!! On Ice nope I'm glad that's over but now we got to deal with wind clans mouse dung ;-;
Lucky Moon more like Onestar's fox dung
Hetalia!!! On Ice
Lol nope
m0cha I know right
While I'm sure this has been mentioned and I agree with a lot of things said in this video, Harveymoon and Billystorm got their names due to being former kittypets. They were called "daylight warriors" who would join SkyClan by day and go home to their twolegs by night. Their prefixes are their kittypet names, their suffixes being, well, regular warrior suffixes.
Maybe StarClan gave Yellowfang the powers because they knew Spottedleaf would die without an apprentice. Clawface is one of the worst cats in the entire series, now that I think about it.
Togepony yeah, I actually liked spottedleaf ._. She's just sweet
I like ClawFace. His leader forced him into battle. He had a wife and kits.
It is mentioned in the books that fire star and scourge are half brothers just read 'the rise of scourge and tall star's revenge'
The father of both catsis a kitty pet named Jake
+Purple Particals tallstar is gay... It literally says in tallstar's revenge "but his heart will always belong to his jake..."
+Purple Particals Snowkit?
Misty thank u for actually providing evidence instead of just saying random things
I haven't read tall stars revenge but I have read rise of scourge enough times (like 40 times XD) to know that Jake is scourge's father and also Firestars father, and It should be true because of how close they lived to each other in the start so Jake couldn't have went that far.
"of course yellowfang would welcome ashfur into starclan, she herself broke the code so many times she probably forgot what was in it"
me : prntscr.com/dbu0o4
RuffleTheCat AJ XD
LMAO
Annalise Cook OMFG that is good
Annalise Cook lol
LOOOOLL XDD
8:49 Sleekwhisker is also a female villain but a lot of people seem to forget that just to make this point
Check the date
she didn’t exist yet
Ruby LPS doesn’t matter when it was made, I’m just sharing that *now* it’s been fixed so the Erins have improved
Ruby LPS well that’s not what *I* meant by it so uh 👁
The 27th sin makes me angry (I agree with it). Like, in the recent books Dovewing was like "okay um I had Tigerheart's kits so I'm moving out" and everyone in ThunderClan, despite some being a bit bitter, were actually fine with it and didn't stop her
Scourge's collar is actually PURPLE. If you have TROS, look at Scourge on the cover. Your answer is right there.
Edit: I know its different in other places. BTW, ty for the likes.
Charles Wylie In different countries the collar is different colours.
Actually, it depends on how people's eyes show it in certain lighting. Sometimes it's red, other times purple. On the Russian Cover, i'm pretty sure it's yellow.
+XxLunaWolfxX The lighting one is ridiculous, but in other countries its different colors.
Charles Wylie omg plz shut up about this! It doesn't matter, everyone seee a character differently
Marked By Music I don't need to shut up. I recently noticed some covers of the books are different, how about we ALL shut up about this?
Bluekit was spelled wrong, as bluetit
+WolfBloodAlpha ..XD
and Tigerclaw was spelt as tigerlaw
+mlp Midnightshadow (Midnight) and graypaw as grewpaw
Oh, and don't forget after Fireheart became a warrior, he instantly became Firepaw again and flexed his powerful legs.
and Cinderpelt as Cinderpaw (forest of secrets XD)
The dark forest can give lives.
Edit: Also what about GrayStripes parents?
Willowpelt and Patchpelt mating and being Graystripe’s parents was a genuine mistake on the Erins’ part.
And what about Ferncloud having kits with her uncle XD
actaully i think SKYCLAN has more kittypets XD
SplashFeather SkyClan is just a bunch of kittypet descendants of the Ancient SkyClan
THey have kittypets/loners/2.5 wild cats aka 5 wild cats, LEAF/STAR YOUR JUST LIKE FIRE/STAR NOW! >:P
SplashFeather it's true
SkyClan is mostly made up of rogues and loners who ended up obtaining full SkyClan blood after they'd joined. Also who here actually kind of loves Macgyver after Hawkwing's Journey? Love that guy now...
Lol, after Hawkwing's Journey... yeah I love everyone in SkyClan now, and I miss everyone that ended up joining StarClan.
Forbidden love has no point cuz in Mapleshade's vengance all she did was fall in love and gets kits. Then Ravenwing tells the clan they get exiled. All the kits die and Appledusk runs off with another mate in like a day? And Thunderclan and Appledusk expect nothing to happen to them. Meanwhile, In the future, Every cat who does that is instantly forgiven. SO Mapleshade never deserved to be in the dark forest.
They should just like take that part out of the code if nobody's ever gonna listen to it.
I know right it's so fricking stupid
IKR!!! I think that if she hadn't of killed all those cats, she'd be in starclan
+Braeden Sullivan Why should it even be part of the Warrior code
Sorry but if they took that out of the code, there wouldn't be a separation of clans... everyone would just combine. it wouldn't make any sense to do that... the 4 clans would be one. yes graystripe, leafpool, and etc were punished?? maybe not harshly but its not like they're going to kick them out of the clan or kill them...
No like make a rule that eceryone who does that ( If like all of the leaders agree ) they should be forgiven and the kits should be forgiven as well like seriously
Any one remember Runningnose?Yeah - WHO THE FUCK CAME UP WITH THAT?!
Oh yeah she is a medicine cat and can't cure her own cold. No wonder so many shadowclan cats died.
+ThisCatIsOnFire He*
The Annoying Commenter oops he
Yellowfang came up with it. :/
I like Runningnose :(
And, Squirrelflight’s “one white paw” represents Scourge and Firestar being half-brothers.
No it does not, she has nothing to do with Scourge
*What?*
2:00 because this battle was against the Dark Forest, who also wanted to take over StarClan. In the Darkest Hour, they did not need StarClan to fight for them!
Logic.
This video should be called: 'How to get hate comments in 9 minutes or less (aka, my opinion of Warriors)'
Moon Mist Healer of DappleClan i totally agree with u
MoonMist Of DappleClan fuck you
You know, all of these people are known for making positive and negative videos about Warriors. And let’s be honest, Warriors is amazing, but it’s also filled with issues.
MoonMist Skye Or you could shut up and let the video be
Leoniepard what is your problem ? These guys didn't even read the books so they just say that.
I love Warriors to heart, but sometimes it can get stupid, and I love this
When I was reading Crookedstar's promise I noticed when he became a leader they accidentally called him Crookedjaw instead of Crookedstar XD
XxBloodheartxX I noticed that to!
XD
XxBloodheartxX in one page in the german version a cat had all his 3 names at kitten age. It was weird.
*never name your kits “tiger” anything they turn evil*
I love Warriors, and it's so funny to see all these and be like "hey! I noticed that too!"
there is soooo much wrong with warriors but it's still my favorite books series! its actually pretty funny when a cat's eye color changes mid-sentence.
I agree
There is a cat named "Egg."
2000 sins for that
Abbygail Ng XD
Mapleshade is the only female villain? *throws in oc* GO FOXSTAR
(throws in oc) GO BROKENHEART ... Cmon get out of that!! ........ Forget it
rip
I love maple shade
. throws in oc. GO FLOODSTEM
*throws in oc* GO FIRESHADE (yes,name inspired on mapleshade)
*throws in another oc* GO SILVERCROW
3:36 I have noticed that most fully developed couples are the fandoms least favorites. I've been getting a lot of spottedleaf x firepaw, or Scourge and Ashfur, but I don't see a lot of people being interested for Firestar and Sandstorm, Lionblaze and Cinderheart, or Millie and Greystripe. When actually those couples are actually pretty sweet.
I could easily answer all of the questions you had. Without all of the occurrences, the books would have been extremely boring and straightforward. I don't know about you, but I personally wouldn't like to read a bunch of boring books. But maybe that's just me.
Sarah Clark Then answer all of them. Right now.
Sarah, I completely agree. I answered all but the only ones that truly were messed up. That was only like 4.
Bro this was just a joke vid for fun
Most of the points were mistakes (because yes, the authors are human, they should not be expected to be perfectly in sync writers) and this person simply not actually thinking about the outcome of what happened.
Im confused you didn't read the books?
You missed the fact that 10% of the fans are wrong with Warriors... That 10% are the ones who fight over the colour of scourges collar.
Agreed!
+BambinoCheeno i imagine his collar to be red, because maybe it got stained by blood
+tales-under-the-waterfalls it's purple! look at the cover of "The rise of Scrouge" it's obviously a purple collar!!
Faith paulus i said "i imagine"
+Faith paulus (Moonshine/toxic) You are both correct and incorrect. Its funny how people get butthurt over the collar's color honestly. If ya did your research (no offence) in USA manga version 'The rise of Scourge' it is indeed purple but on the Chinese cover of Darkest Hour it was brown. While in the Russian version it's yellow. This also explains why its color is never mentioned in the books. Cause technically its color that of a rainbow like Bone's collar. In other words, it doesn't have a specific color therefore could be any color.
This is so true and funny and I love warriors (I'm also that guy who points out flaws but tells no one so throughout the entire thing I was like IKK)
IKR*
+Braydon Santini Omg yes... Like I'll be reading and they'll say like, "Graypool" instead of Graypaw...
I can relate
Yes! And they use like some strange word usage, like "Let's you and me lead the way".
Uncombined=Let us you and me lead the way. ('_')??
Oh wait it kind of makes sense now?
+Toratan123
its a combination of before 21st century grammar and after.
like mid evil talk.
Dude i thought it was just green for Dovewing's eyes since it was literally on the COVER of the fourth apprentice.
I'm so glad she mentioned the part of the older cats still being warriors. I've been sooo confused on that and like how can that be!?!?!
And what happened to Smudge? Did Firestar just forget about his best friend when he was a kittypet? He's never mentioned after the the second book, and they don't include him in the 'Outside Clan Cats' section after the first series, like, I know it's really scraping the bottom of the barrel, and I'm half joking, but still, I'm genuinely curious about what happened to him.
I'm pretty sure smudge is still alive but he's probably just forgotten I will never forget him though
Edit: now thinking about it he could very likely still be alive. Kittypets do live longer lives than the forest cats and aren't exposed to much sickness, infection, battles, etc.
Maybe he died of age? I don't know...
I think Smudge might've died.
Press F to pay respects
He's been mentioned lots of times!!
Smudge appeared in firestar's quest.
i laughed my ass off when i heard "there is a cat named egg" XD
Age difference on couples to the creepy level?
* COUGH * Thornclaw x Blossomfall
Dustpelt x ferncloud. Wasnt he her mentor so he should be alot older than her
I mean their cats XD
DesteLynx YT Actually in human years Dustpelt would’ve been like 23 or something and Ferncloud would’ve been like 19. That’s not bad. But yet Thornclaw and Blossomfall’s gap would’ve been like 20 years or something
The age gap between Thorn x Blossom and Dust x Fern aren't large at all for cats, it doesn't matter how much older one cat is. Pine x Leapord scares me though
@@caralynpatterson4901 No he wasn’t. Dustpelt got Ashpaw and Fernpaw was given to Darkstripe but maybe he took over her training after Darkstripe got exiled? They were really close when she was an apprentice though.
He was the one who told Fireheart Fernpaw wanted to tell him about Swiftpaw and Brightpaw. Plus I’d doubt that Darkstripe actually trained his apprentice at all.
But Ferncloud, Ashfur and Thornclaw barely even talk to Cloudtail even tho they were best friends as apprentices. Especially Ashfur and Cloudtail. Ashfur even started to ha kittypet when his best friend was born as one.
Fireheart only told two cats about Cloudpaw getting taken away and that was Bluestar and Ashpaw.
That really annoys me.
No one has friends unless it’s relevant to the plot.