The umpire got it right. Yogi always disagreed and I am sure he believed in his heart that Robinson was out. This is an iconic moment in baseball. The umpire was in the exact right place to make the call. Jackie Robinson will always be one of my heroes.
I disagree. Love Jackie, but he was clearly OUT on this play. Problem here is Jackie surprised the ump, too, who was out of position ~ couldn't see the play for his location behind Berra.
At 0:02, 2:24 2:34, 3:00 it’s hard to tell if he was safe or out. At 0:11, he appears out. At 3:13 appears Safe. But that still photograph at 6:02, appears he was definitely out. & it’s different than the still photo at 0:30. I have never seen that newspaper full page at 3:38 before. Did they make/ask Yogi to pose it that position? (That he’s analyzing the full page newspaper, in the wide open area, with no one else around him)
@@MikeCee7I don’t think it’s that ambiguous. The angles from behind the plate appear out because the glove is between the viewer and Robinson’s foot. The third base view shows a gap and yogi’s positioning slightly behind the front edge of the plate. Though it’s close and the frames are fuzzy, they show there was enough time for robinson’s foot to tough the bag before the tag. Since his foot was down, I assume he caught the front edge of the plate, and was safe. Ump agrees too.
The ump was out of position. He was also out of position two innings earlier when Billy Martin attempted to steal home. He looked obviously safe but the ump called him out. That play doesn't get the showings that Robinson's does.
The view from the camera from his backside shows he actually was safe. This view is never shown, only the view from the front, which makes him look out. The backside view should be shown a lot more often.
Brooklyn only won the 1955 World Series because Mickey Mantle was injured for Game 7, and didn't play; he only came off the bench in the late innings, and popping up to Pee Wee Reese at short.
Hangs on the wall in my home too. An example for my 11-year-old son, as to how to live life with faithful, determination, courage, intelligence and character.
At 0:02, 2:242:34, 3:00 it’s hard to tell if he was safe or out. At 0:11, he appears out. At 3:13 appears Safe. But that still photograph at 6:02, appears he was definitely out. & it’s different than the still photo at 0:30. I have never seen that newspaper full page at 3:38 before. Did they make/ask Yogi to pose it that position? (That he’s analyzing the full page newspaper, in the wide open area, with no one else around him)
Rarely does anyone show Billy Martin's attempted steal of home in the same game two innings before. He was out but looked obviously safe in the film. On both plays the ump was out of position.
Did the batter know (in advance) that Jackie was stealing home? 2:24 if not, Isn’t that kind of dangerous? because it looks the batter could swing, and hit Yogi with his bat.
The Dodgers lost that 1955 World Series game when Robinson stole home. And he was benched in game 7 because he wasn't hitting. The Yankees beat the Dodgers the next year with Brooklyn shutout in the first 9 innings of the last 3 games, including Don Larsen's perfect game 5. Robinson drove in Brooklyn's only run with a 10th inning single in game 6. In game 7 Robinson was 0 for 3 with a walk. He never played again.
According to an article by Robert Rubino in the Press Democrat, Santa Rosa, CA in 2015, Jackie Robinson was 36 years of age and had an injury-plagued season in 1955. Obviously, with his style of playing, he needed his wheels to be in good order. In 1947 when he was called up, he was 28 years old, so he was never bound to have a 10-year career, even if he was close. Here's a couple of quotes why he didn't play in the victorious world-series game seven in that year: Rachel Robinson, Jackie’s widow, when asked about her husband sitting out Game 7 in ’55, was quoted, “I don’t know why Jack didn’t play. I really don’t know. That was 50 years ago, buddy.” Don Newcombe, the Dodgers ace and a 20-game winner in ’55, whom Alston curiously chose not to use after a Game 1 loss, said Robinson sat out Game 7 because “he had a sore Achilles.” Carl Erskine, the Dodgers Game 4 starter, said, “It was his knees. Jackie had chronic bad knees from his college football playing days.”
@@Gnofg that's exactly what Jackie did....just think about it...that era of baseball produced so many hall of famers......from an area of about 13 miles.....peace
@@kenneth7826 I have 16 signed baseballs from that era. One had Jackie's signature. It was our family's pride and joy. We brought it to Antiques roadshow(NPR) and it wasn't Jackie's signature. It had every other dodger with the exception of Roy Campanella who never signed baseballs. We were broken hearted. We do have one of the Cleveland Indians with 5 HOF's on it.
Okay. There is a different view of the play. And that shows that Robinson was indeed safe. Good job showing that angle.
His brother is a silver medalist at the Olympics 🤯🥈 talent runs in the fam.
What tha! 💭🤨
The umpire got it right. Yogi always disagreed and I am sure he believed in his heart that Robinson was out. This is an iconic moment in baseball. The umpire was in the exact right place to make the call. Jackie Robinson will always be one of my heroes.
it was a lazy tag too
I disagree. Love Jackie, but he was clearly OUT on this play. Problem here is Jackie surprised the ump, too, who was out of position ~ couldn't see the play for his location behind Berra.
At 0:02, 2:24 2:34, 3:00 it’s hard to tell if he was safe or out. At 0:11, he appears out. At 3:13 appears Safe. But that still photograph at 6:02, appears he was definitely out. & it’s different than the still photo at 0:30. I have never seen that newspaper full page at 3:38 before. Did they make/ask Yogi to pose it that position? (That he’s analyzing the full page newspaper, in the wide open area, with no one else around him)
@@MikeCee7I don’t think it’s that ambiguous. The angles from behind the plate appear out because the glove is between the viewer and Robinson’s foot. The third base view shows a gap and yogi’s positioning slightly behind the front edge of the plate. Though it’s close and the frames are fuzzy, they show there was enough time for robinson’s foot to tough the bag before the tag. Since his foot was down, I assume he caught the front edge of the plate, and was safe. Ump agrees too.
The ump was out of position. He was also out of position two innings earlier when Billy Martin attempted to steal home. He looked obviously safe but the ump called him out. That play doesn't get the showings that Robinson's does.
My dad was 13 year old and he got a autographs from Mr. JACKIE ROBINSON.
REST IN HEAVEN ROBINSON
I was born too late to see Robinson play. But!!! I am a huge fan, and I cannot get enough of this amazing man.
The view from the camera from his backside shows he actually was safe. This view is never shown, only the view from the front, which makes him look out. The backside view should be shown a lot more often.
Totally agree
Wrong. He was out. Berra swore to his grave Jackie was out, and he was right. Ump is out, too ~ out of position.
@@acousticshadow4032bud go watch the other view. Very clearly safe, unless you have eye problems.
@@acousticshadow4032It's a wonder Berra wasn't ejected from the game for arguing with the ump.
Brooklyn only won the 1955 World Series because Mickey Mantle was injured for Game 7, and didn't play; he only came off the bench in the late innings, and popping up to Pee Wee Reese at short.
Mrs.Robinson is still very Beautiful, Happy 100th Birthday DEAR LADY,JUST LOVELY💐🌹🌻🌺💮🏵️🌼💖
Brooklyn Dodgers!! 42 Legend
Hangs on the wall in my home too. An example for my 11-year-old son, as to how to live life with faithful, determination, courage, intelligence and character.
Great Piece.
Holy Cow!, Dolly Parton‘s mom, was at this game! 0:38
At 0:02, 2:24 2:34, 3:00 it’s hard to tell if he was safe or out. At 0:11, he appears out. At 3:13 appears Safe. But that still photograph at 6:02, appears he was definitely out. & it’s different than the still photo at 0:30. I have never seen that newspaper full page at 3:38 before. Did they make/ask Yogi to pose it that position? (That he’s analyzing the full page newspaper, in the wide open area, with no one else around him)
The angle at 6:02 is an optical illusion because the angle behind the play, whereas at 3:13 the angle takes us into his pathway to the plate.
Greatest athlete of all time imo
Rarely does anyone show Billy Martin's attempted steal of home in the same game two innings before. He was out but looked obviously safe in the film. On both plays the ump was out of position.
amazing 42
Did the batter know (in advance) that Jackie was stealing home? 2:24 if not, Isn’t that kind of dangerous? because it looks the batter could swing, and hit Yogi with his bat.
Y’all filmed the Glanville bits on actual eyes? Joint super clear
Originals by Adam Grant brought me here 😊
The Dodgers lost that 1955 World Series game when Robinson stole home. And he was benched in game 7 because he wasn't hitting. The Yankees beat the Dodgers the next year with Brooklyn shutout in the first 9 innings of the last 3 games, including Don Larsen's perfect game 5. Robinson drove in Brooklyn's only run with a 10th inning single in game 6. In game 7 Robinson was 0 for 3 with a walk. He never played again.
According to an article by Robert Rubino in the Press Democrat, Santa Rosa, CA in 2015, Jackie Robinson was 36 years of age and had an injury-plagued season in 1955. Obviously, with his style of playing, he needed his wheels to be in good order. In 1947 when he was called up, he was 28 years old, so he was never bound to have a 10-year career, even if he was close. Here's a couple of quotes why he didn't play in the victorious world-series game seven in that year:
Rachel Robinson, Jackie’s widow, when asked about her husband sitting out Game 7 in ’55, was quoted, “I don’t know why Jack didn’t play. I really don’t know. That was 50 years ago, buddy.”
Don Newcombe, the Dodgers ace and a 20-game winner in ’55, whom Alston curiously chose not to use after a Game 1 loss, said Robinson sat out Game 7 because “he had a sore Achilles.”
Carl Erskine, the Dodgers Game 4 starter, said, “It was his knees. Jackie had chronic bad knees from his college football playing days.”
Idk. Wish i could get a better look from behind. He looks out by a mile from Yogi's side, but still questionable from behind Jacky.
Thanks for hiding this from us espn,,,
Safe!!!!!!!!
I got my frist A in school on a report card in severe the grade doing an oral book report on Jackie Robinson
He was out. Yogi was right.
I thought 💭 he died in a plane ✈️ crash 💥
I think you’re thinking about Roberto Clemente who died in a plane crash
@@evefet5491 right
I love Jackie Robinson, but he was clearly OUT on this attempt to steal home in the '55 WS. Ump was out of position, and could not see the tag.
glad the empire didnt do some racist sheeeet
Love Jackie...one of the greatest....but, he was out
Jackie looked out to me, yogi had a legitimate beef
The ump made a serious error in judgment: Robinson was OUT at the plate!
Cry about it
He was out.
Didn't the Yankees win that game anyways
OUT.
First comment I think
He was a great player but he was clearly out
I agree he does look out but because of the latest technology...Jackie beats Yogi's tag by his big toe..peace
I think in the last replay he is safe. Yogi's glove is behind the corner of the plate and I think he gets his toe in there.
@@Gnofg that's exactly what Jackie did....just think about it...that era of baseball produced so many hall of famers......from an area of about 13 miles.....peace
@@kenneth7826 I have 16 signed baseballs from that era. One had Jackie's signature. It was our family's pride and joy. We brought it to Antiques roadshow(NPR) and it wasn't Jackie's signature. It had every other dodger with the exception of Roy Campanella who never signed baseballs. We were broken hearted. We do have one of the Cleveland Indians with 5 HOF's on it.
There's a photo from the opposite angle that shows he was safe.
That fact she is 100 looking like 60 - 55 shows that African American genes 🧬 are different 💯💯💯🙏
No offense but she looks 100.
@@notpaper-cr6ni 😒 🧢
@@detroitliveent7993 what does that mean?
She definitely don't look 100 but I'm thinking she looks around 70
@@12bthe factz 100