I'm so glad you did this I have been opening bags like crazy I'm at around 33k bags opened and am just assuming the music box isn't in it anymore. But I did get a polyluminescent I think it's called the green one. Good luck for everyone opening
i never farm gold in this game. but there was ome exception, a couple years ago i was farming the mad kings labyrinth for a week, while watching all 8 seasons of dexter. afterwards i even looked at the best time of the year to sell the bags, i think it was in may. fast forward to may, i sold all my bags and made around 2k gold. decided to lose it all on ectoplasm gambling the day after. good times
Ive done a similar pool last year. Except i got no phsopho but did get an ember. Inverted results. Either way its better to just sell bags to the gacha goblins.
Thanks for the stats! I've been opening them. As a new player this is a good opportunity to level up my Magic Find, with the Essence of Luck. Not sure if there is a better way, but this event has been a huge boost. Also, I fish a lot so the Candy Corn is appreciated. I saw that starting in May of this year the price spiked, and eventually Candy Corn was going for over 1s each? Not sure why that happened, so I'm keeping that in mind. I assume bag prices will go up a lot as well.
you have a few options. salvaging blue unids with a copper fed. make sure you open them before salvaging. salvaging green unids: same deal as blue. this time you want to use a runecrafters salvage o matic. and salvaging ectos. these give you about 100 luck per ecto and about 1.85 dust per ecto.
@@pachabee salvaging ectos is a net loss. personally i just stick to greens. use mats to craft krait weapons and then salvage those int ectos and sell the ectos
You have good advice from ohers here .. green unids is the best method but trick-or-treat bags are great too! keep farming them. Ecto salvage is a net loss so don't go for that right now ... sometimes ecto salvage becomes net positive depending on prices but green unid is the best. Candy corn will go back up in price once halloween ends until next halloween! .. so stock up now!
Back in 2022 o opened around 5k and got a ember infusion In 2023 i opened around 70k and got a lot of infusions but none above 50g This year i opened 25k until now and still nothing yet
During my first year playing gw2, Halloween was one of the first festival that I encountered and engaged with in the game and I received, not 1 but 2 duckin Ember Infusions haha. Both came from the ToT bags that I received from wvw and pvp ... I wish I had not sold both of them back then, but at the same time, they used to go for 1.2-1.3k during Halloween, so I don't mind as much
@@coffeedart_gw2 2022 it was also my first time playing, 2 months previously to October, I had the 3 first expansions bought lol the ember infusion got me a false sense of what a life-changing item could be. I sold for around 700g and gave the money to my friend coz I didn't have anything that I wanted. I live fishing so i don't really need gold
I've gotten 3 of the weapon boxes this year which is up from zero since they have added that vendor with new weapons every year. It is about the only thing I could hope to get from these which I am happy for. Also candy corn will be useful for decorations.
I have a strong feeling that the rates get adjusted the more you open in a given time frame. For instance, black lion chest keys you get from world exploration always seem to have better luck than the ones you get on the trading post. I think that when you do a lot of a single thing, the game give you diminishing returns, just like when you farm most mobs. Probably wrong I guess, but it feels that way.
It feels that way, but it likely isn't. There is a way to find out though. ArenaNet exists as a subsidiary of NCSoft. NCSoft is based in South Korea where there is an actual patent on the exact thing you're talking about. For them to utilize that patent, paperwork would have to be filed. You can follow the trail if you really want to find out
This is probably not the case. Let’s take BL chests as an example. If you were to open 20 chests and you get one item of decent value like a 50g skin, you’re unlikely to feel lucky, because you’ve invested an amount where you would expect to get at least one rare drop. Even though loot boxes do not operate on a cumulative chance model. However if someone gets one key randomly and opens a single chest, and they get the same 50g skin, they’ll probably feel pretty lucky as the investment they put into that one key would have been far less. This also makes the occurrence memorable, because it’s a rare event and a good story. However, if this same person didn’t get anything of interest from a single chest, they’re less likely to feel disappointed because once again, their investment was low. It’s also much easier to forget a small loss as opposed to a big loss. This is why one off keys seem luckier, because you probably don’t remember the dozens of other one off keys where you didn’t get anything.
i have had the ember infusion drop twice now and i did not open as many like you said this is how loot boxes work you never know when your gonna hit big.
Grats! Yep luck does play a bit of a role in these. I mentioned in another comment here, but my first Halloween in the game I got 2 ember infusions too and the only ToT bags I opened were from pvp and wvw reward track. Not that many
Is it? I can see it on my end ... Edit: Yep, I see what you mean ..I'll update the link hold on Edit2: updated .. Hopefully it works now Thanks for letting me know
Calling it unrewarding makes no sense here because the buy price is dynamic and depends on the market. When would you say it's rewarding? If you get out more than it costs? That would just increase the market price and even out the profit. In the end the cost are very close to the value. If you would factor in the 3350 Quarz Crystals that's another 55g and you get a lot of account bound stuff. If you were lucky and get a high value drop you're probably making some gold. But on the global average the price is just what they are worth. What's maybe not worth it is the time for opening 100k of those. But opening the ones you drop is basically equal to the value / time for selling.
Putting so much trash into the rare category while putting the only valuable items in super rare to compete with the actually ultimate valuable items is the biggest, typical let down of any mmo.
The most annoying thing in gw2 is the excess of crap that you get. I dont even remember getting smth good from killing mobs, its just kill this to farm a little amount of gold, repeat 10x and finally you can buy good stuff. It sucks.
14 bag slots x 32 spaces per bag = 480 total spaces, plus 30 shared inventory slots if the game was bought prior to Heart of Thorns being bundled with the core game, 29 if not.
I opened 5k of them this year and got 2 unique weapons and pretty much nothing else of any real value except more corn and useless crafting mats that I already had 5k of.
![[ NERFED ] Homestead Fishing: Surprise Gold Farm or a Waste of Time?](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/o09XQYrkq4U/mqdefault.jpg)
Join Discord: discord.gg/eGcmjbDNS2
Data: cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1277783479244816404/1299625567641010227/Trick-or-Treat_Bags.xlsx?ex=671de221&is=671c90a1&hm=8accb7ce969c801c4ec4b27aa16cc4519bda2ad49f0fc7e737a5a5cfc35636ca&
Definitive Homestead decoration Guide: ua-cam.com/video/fIBm2W-TwRw/v-deo.html
Convert Karma to Gold: ua-cam.com/video/K2Fst71g1J4/v-deo.html
Fishing in Homestead and JW maps: ua-cam.com/video/_neCCCoihNQ/v-deo.html
Doing great work here! Thank you so much for the drop rate research!
Good luck on your further farm! I'm currently 196 stacks of ToT Bags in and have not seen an Ember or Musicbox either and only 1 Phospholuminescent
Thanks! I hope you have better luck in further openings!
I'm so glad you did this I have been opening bags like crazy I'm at around 33k bags opened and am just assuming the music box isn't in it anymore. But I did get a polyluminescent I think it's called the green one. Good luck for everyone opening
i never farm gold in this game. but there was ome exception, a couple years ago i was farming the mad kings labyrinth for a week, while watching all 8 seasons of dexter. afterwards i even looked at the best time of the year to sell the bags, i think it was in may. fast forward to may, i sold all my bags and made around 2k gold. decided to lose it all on ectoplasm gambling the day after. good times
Ive done a similar pool last year. Except i got no phsopho but did get an ember. Inverted results.
Either way its better to just sell bags to the gacha goblins.
Oh no I am the gacha goblin 💀
i feel guilty getting the music infusion in 1000 bags this Halloween holy yikes
holy....!! Gratz! Happy for you :)
Thanks for the stats! I've been opening them. As a new player this is a good opportunity to level up my Magic Find, with the Essence of Luck. Not sure if there is a better way, but this event has been a huge boost. Also, I fish a lot so the Candy Corn is appreciated. I saw that starting in May of this year the price spiked, and eventually Candy Corn was going for over 1s each? Not sure why that happened, so I'm keeping that in mind. I assume bag prices will go up a lot as well.
you have a few options.
salvaging blue unids with a copper fed. make sure you open them before salvaging.
salvaging green unids: same deal as blue. this time you want to use a runecrafters salvage o matic.
and salvaging ectos. these give you about 100 luck per ecto and about 1.85 dust per ecto.
@imanoobtuber Thankfully, I've been doing that to blues and greens. Didn't know that about echos though, thanks! I was selling all my ectos.
@@pachabee salvaging ectos is a net loss.
personally i just stick to greens. use mats to craft krait weapons and then salvage those int ectos and sell the ectos
@@imanoobtuber Going to do some research on that now! Haven't heard of the krait weapons
You have good advice from ohers here .. green unids is the best method but trick-or-treat bags are great too! keep farming them. Ecto salvage is a net loss so don't go for that right now ... sometimes ecto salvage becomes net positive depending on prices but green unid is the best.
Candy corn will go back up in price once halloween ends until next halloween! .. so stock up now!
Back in 2022 o opened around 5k and got a ember infusion
In 2023 i opened around 70k and got a lot of infusions but none above 50g
This year i opened 25k until now and still nothing yet
During my first year playing gw2, Halloween was one of the first festival that I encountered and engaged with in the game and I received, not 1 but 2 duckin Ember Infusions haha. Both came from the ToT bags that I received from wvw and pvp ... I wish I had not sold both of them back then, but at the same time, they used to go for 1.2-1.3k during Halloween, so I don't mind as much
@@coffeedart_gw2 2022 it was also my first time playing, 2 months previously to October, I had the 3 first expansions bought lol the ember infusion got me a false sense of what a life-changing item could be. I sold for around 700g and gave the money to my friend coz I didn't have anything that I wanted. I live fishing so i don't really need gold
I've gotten 3 of the weapon boxes this year which is up from zero since they have added that vendor with new weapons every year. It is about the only thing I could hope to get from these which I am happy for. Also candy corn will be useful for decorations.
Yea I am happy about the courtly weapon boxes too .. I'll save the extras for next year when they add more weapons to them
Happy i got all the stuff for crafting and ember Infusion from 4k bags
noice!! gratz on the ember infusion!
I have a strong feeling that the rates get adjusted the more you open in a given time frame. For instance, black lion chest keys you get from world exploration always seem to have better luck than the ones you get on the trading post. I think that when you do a lot of a single thing, the game give you diminishing returns, just like when you farm most mobs. Probably wrong I guess, but it feels that way.
it does feel that way for sure.. would be nice to get data for that at some point
It feels that way, but it likely isn't. There is a way to find out though. ArenaNet exists as a subsidiary of NCSoft. NCSoft is based in South Korea where there is an actual patent on the exact thing you're talking about. For them to utilize that patent, paperwork would have to be filed. You can follow the trail if you really want to find out
This is probably not the case. Let’s take BL chests as an example. If you were to open 20 chests and you get one item of decent value like a 50g skin, you’re unlikely to feel lucky, because you’ve invested an amount where you would expect to get at least one rare drop. Even though loot boxes do not operate on a cumulative chance model. However if someone gets one key randomly and opens a single chest, and they get the same 50g skin, they’ll probably feel pretty lucky as the investment they put into that one key would have been far less. This also makes the occurrence memorable, because it’s a rare event and a good story. However, if this same person didn’t get anything of interest from a single chest, they’re less likely to feel disappointed because once again, their investment was low. It’s also much easier to forget a small loss as opposed to a big loss. This is why one off keys seem luckier, because you probably don’t remember the dozens of other one off keys where you didn’t get anything.
i have had the ember infusion drop twice now and i did not open as many like you said this is how loot boxes work you never know when your gonna hit big.
Grats! Yep luck does play a bit of a role in these. I mentioned in another comment here, but my first Halloween in the game I got 2 ember infusions too and the only ToT bags I opened were from pvp and wvw reward track. Not that many
sadge that in each exel list the profit/tax tab etc is deleted..
Is it? I can see it on my end ...
Edit: Yep, I see what you mean ..I'll update the link hold on
Edit2: updated .. Hopefully it works now
Thanks for letting me know
Do you manually type the drops in the file or do you have a program tracking your drops?
There are a lot of ways you can do so ... datawars2.ie, gw2efficiency farming tracker, blish hud modules. You can pick whichever suits you
Dude you are the man i am gonna start doing what you doing lol
Not only is it a waste of game currency, it's also a huge waste of time IMO. It's sad how unrewarding the game is for stuff like this.
Calling it unrewarding makes no sense here because the buy price is dynamic and depends on the market. When would you say it's rewarding? If you get out more than it costs? That would just increase the market price and even out the profit. In the end the cost are very close to the value. If you would factor in the 3350 Quarz Crystals that's another 55g and you get a lot of account bound stuff. If you were lucky and get a high value drop you're probably making some gold. But on the global average the price is just what they are worth. What's maybe not worth it is the time for opening 100k of those. But opening the ones you drop is basically equal to the value / time for selling.
Putting so much trash into the rare category while putting the only valuable items in super rare to compete with the actually ultimate valuable items is the biggest, typical let down of any mmo.
The most annoying thing in gw2 is the excess of crap that you get. I dont even remember getting smth good from killing mobs, its just kill this to farm a little amount of gold, repeat 10x and finally you can buy good stuff. It sucks.
@@D.r.S.m.o.o.t.h GW2 100% lacks content meaningful rare loot that actually has a decent drop rate.
@@elocfreidon Meaningful rare loot with decent drop rate? You do know that's an oxymoron, right? It can't be rare if the drop rate is decent....
How many bags you manage to farm per hour?
750-800/hr I would say
@@coffeedart_gw2 how do you do this? I make like half of what you do and I tag 90% of the mobs. Is it the luck? I have 400.
@@myselfme767 Yea the more luck you have the more bags you make ... I think I usually sit at around 650+ mf
how did you get so many bags for inventory T_T
@@user-ky1nx8sl6z buy bag slot expansion from gem store and craft 32 slot bags for each
14 bag slots x 32 spaces per bag = 480 total spaces, plus 30 shared inventory slots if the game was bought prior to Heart of Thorns being bundled with the core game, 29 if not.
What @HordrissTheConfuser said! Unfortunately, I only have 29 shared slots because I bought the game after the HoT and PoF bundle
I opened 5k of them this year and got 2 unique weapons and pretty much nothing else of any real value except more corn and useless crafting mats that I already had 5k of.
pretty much how that goes
i open bags to get candy for my gobbler :)
Love that gobbler
Really good and informative video. So basically sell them on the TP instead of opening them. O would higher magic find influence the outcome?
magic find does not affect opening the bags but magic find does affect how many bags you get while farming in the mad kings lab
I got 3 weapon boxes out of 750 bags
noice!
underwjelming droprates jeez
yep :|
Wow
I bought probably 10k and didn't get anything special
hope you have better luck in further openings!
my god indian accent kills me every fuckin time
watch all my videos after smoking up back to back then, you'll have a good time
@matteovisentini1630 Sounds like you have a skill issue 😂
@@coffeedart_gw2 What a chad response