This is not the altar where Israel worshipped the golden calf

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 22 гру 2024
  • #maklelan2459 ‪@CrossExamined‬

КОМЕНТАРІ • 66

  • @jasonmoquin
    @jasonmoquin 2 дні тому +36

    Frank never lets the facts get in the way of his narrative.

  • @johnrichardson7629
    @johnrichardson7629 2 дні тому +30

    It's a miracle! Frank Turek puts aside his usual cluster and pat certainties and actually speaks cautiously about possibilities, except for that bit about the Saudis at the end.

    • @KaiHenningsen
      @KaiHenningsen 2 дні тому +3

      Yeah, for Turek, that was outright sensible. Red day on the calendar.

    •  2 дні тому +1

      well, and it can't be the calf alter from the bible

  • @stupendemysgeographicus5009
    @stupendemysgeographicus5009 2 дні тому +12

    It’s always a bit of a telling when apologists claim Muslim governments are hiding evidence of figures like Moses, Solomon etc…, when those figures are venerated prophets in Islam.

    • @hive_indicator318
      @hive_indicator318 День тому +3

      Very much venerated, too. They would be screaming about it if they thought it was The Place

    • @benjamintrevino325
      @benjamintrevino325 День тому +2

      The Final Judgement is going to be like an episode of The Dating Game when YHWH, God, Allah finally reveals if He wants bachelor #1, bachelor #2, or bachelor #3?

    • @NWPaul72
      @NWPaul72 День тому

      ​@@benjamintrevino325I honestly think he's gonna roll with the Mormons, they were the last ones he talked to. Or maybe the Scientologists, that would be a neat trick

  • @25dancemom
    @25dancemom 2 дні тому +38

    “Could” is doing a LOT of heavy lifting.

    • @nonprogrediestregredi1711
      @nonprogrediestregredi1711 2 дні тому

      Lmao. Yes, it most certainly is. It may be lifting the paradoxical rock that his god made that he can't lift.

  • @WhichDoctor1
    @WhichDoctor1 2 дні тому +20

    It’s one thing to see some pics online of a carving of one cow along with claims of it being the alter of the golden calf and mindlessly repeat them. There’s plausible deniability there. But to physically travel there and look at it with your own eyes and see the multiple carvings of multiple different animals and still make those claims is literally just straight up lying. I thought the very Ten Commandments themselves had something to say about that

  • @The_Other_Ghost
    @The_Other_Ghost 2 дні тому +10

    Please do video on Frank's description on biblical slavery.

  • @skraddypoo
    @skraddypoo 2 дні тому +6

    "And there on the moon? That COULD BE the peak of Dracula's castle" Well damn, it COULD be, I guess!

  • @tenchuu007
    @tenchuu007 2 дні тому +7

    Ancient archeological sites are gifts to all of humanity. I am very uncomfortable with how close that man is to my gift.

  • @chrisbornman5460
    @chrisbornman5460 2 дні тому +9

    I truly can not understand people's need for "proof". Is your god not enough proof?
    Dan, please write a book on how you have acquired the ability to deal with all of this, including my frustration. I admire and envy your patience.

  • @1970Phoenix
    @1970Phoenix 2 дні тому +8

    I found a piece of rotten wood. It COULD be a piece of the cross of Jesus, or maybe its a piece of Noah's ark - I haven't decided which one yet.
    Let me know if you're interested in purchasing this rare, valuable and definitely legitimate item.

    • @brucetownsend691
      @brucetownsend691 2 дні тому +6

      Why not both?

    • @1970Phoenix
      @1970Phoenix 2 дні тому +1

      @@brucetownsend691 I like how you think sir.

    • @hive_indicator318
      @hive_indicator318 День тому +1

      ​@@brucetownsend691you're onto something there. What other wood is strong enough to hold a deity?

  • @iamfiefo
    @iamfiefo 2 дні тому +10

    Aha! There's a drawing of a bull on this rock. This could mean one thing _and only one single solitary thing..._

  • @Will-xf3qe
    @Will-xf3qe 2 дні тому +4

    It could be! Its almost certainly not but it could be

  • @jamiegallier2106
    @jamiegallier2106 2 дні тому

    Thanks Dan. ❤

  • @kentstallard6512
    @kentstallard6512 2 дні тому +7

    This is where the mythical event actually happened!!
    😂

    • @NWPaul72
      @NWPaul72 День тому

      I have traveled some and there is evidence of Paul Bunyan all over these United States.

  • @garycarter6773
    @garycarter6773 2 дні тому

    ❤❤❤❤❤❤thanks Dan!!

  • @user-gk9lg5sp4y
    @user-gk9lg5sp4y 2 дні тому +3

    Ignorantly or duplicitously or sometimes duplicitous ignorance are pretty much the apologist playbook.

  • @ChristopherBond-i5f
    @ChristopherBond-i5f День тому

    “Alright … let’s see it” 😊.

  • @VeridicusMaximus
    @VeridicusMaximus 2 дні тому +11

    It's good to see Frank using all that Xtian $$$, from devotees buying his crap, to travel the world and spin more apologetic BS! Good grift Frank!

  • @digitaljanus
    @digitaljanus 2 дні тому +3

    Even if the Israelites had been escaping Egypt, why would they have gone so far afield from their destination in the Holy Land _before_ God cursed them to wander the wilderness for 40 years? Is there an apologetic explanation for that?

    • @stupendemysgeographicus5009
      @stupendemysgeographicus5009 2 дні тому

      Isn’t there a verse that says that they took a different route so the the Israelites wouldn’t run back to Egypt after encountering the Philistines?

  • @twinnish
    @twinnish 2 дні тому +2

    He plays with a lot of wishy-washy words.
    I live in western Saudi Arabia and there are mountains that look like that and petroglyphs all over the region.
    Saudi is definitely trying to take steps to protect its historical landmarks. It’s not something they were particularly awesome at previously, but they’re trying to be better.
    This is a fun region to live in as I am right next to the Red Sea close to the dead Sea next to all these mountains that may be significant or not . . . The people that live here have a fascinating history. Granted it’s disputed to a great degree in many ways by many people with varying agendas and stories to tell.😊

    • @sagapoetic8990
      @sagapoetic8990 2 дні тому

      Aren't there also Roman forts near the Nabatean sites?

  • @markrothenbuhler6232
    @markrothenbuhler6232 День тому +1

    Everyone can come together and agree - this is bull!

  • @fordprefect5304
    @fordprefect5304 2 дні тому +1

    Yes you can go there and on an official Saudi tour
    *SAUDI ARABIA TOURS*
    *Explore the ancient land of Midian, the Split Rock of Horeb, and Jabal al-Lawz - the real Mount Sinai*

  • @Darisiabgal7573
    @Darisiabgal7573 2 дні тому +1

    “Jeroboam thought to himself, "The kingdom will now likely revert to the house of David. If these people go up to offer sacrifices at the temple of the Lord in Jerusalem, they will again give their allegiance to their lord, Rehoboam king of Judah. They will kill me and return to King Rehoboam." After seeking advice, the king made two golden calves. He said to the people, "It is too much for you to go up to Jerusalem. Here are your gods, Israel, who brought you up out of Egypt." One he set up in Bethel, and the other in Dan. And this thing became a sin; the people came to worship the one at Bethel and went as far as Dan to worship the other.”
    So let me take a shot and interpret this passage.
    The problem is that Luz (later Bethel) maintained independent practice to Asherah and El. We know this from later texts, the Jerusalem kingdom didn’t like this. If El is still practiced then Yahweh isn’t a high god, but a son god. El is the Bull, the son of the bull is the calf. While the northern kingdom still existed, Judea could nothing about this practice and it continued.
    Israel Finkelstein thinks that Jeroboam II was a powerful Israelite king, but there was no Jeroboam I. He managed to secure lands all the way to Aqaba. He probably also subdued Jerusalem. It is during his reign that the Kuntillet Ajrud inscriptions appear.
    But the reports of the northern kingdom seem to indicate there were conflicts with the god believers in the south, and thus these skirmishes in Kings appear to represent early skisms. Since Luz was close to the Judean bordered it was positioned between these two squabbling factions.
    Did Jeroboam make calves to offend the Judeans, where there a cult in Dan. These questions we cannot answer, but what we can say is there were multiple different Yahweh cults and in Bethel they preserved aspects of an older belief system that was abandoned in Judea. The fact that symbols of Asherah remained, even until the second temple period is testimony to the discussion in Jeremiah of the women blaming Yosiah’s reforms (impiety to Asherah) for the fall of the first kingdom.
    Thus the system whether or not it had golden calves or alters to ‘El is subordinate to the fact that it remained a cultic center to Asherah.
    Therefore I don’t so easily dismiss the golden calf idea, as we have seen the Bible takes a narrative in an older part of the Bible (1 kings) and inserts it into passages that were edited much later (Exodus) in order to make that practice look primitive using anachronistic insertions. We can compare the story of the man and his concubine from judges and compare it with the story of Sodom in Genesis. The story of Tamar in 2 Samuel 13 and compare it with Genesis 38, and so on. So it’s likely that 1 kings was the precedent.
    As we examine the Kuntillet Ajrud inscription, the scribe is referring to the YHWH of Samaria and his Asherah, another author refers to YHWH of the road south to Yemen. Still we have the cult of Bethel and that of the kingdom of Judea. Later developing was the Edomite god Qos. It should be considered that YHWH was not a unifying god like El, but a god prone to schism. The text in 1 king, even in its redacted state is reflecting the insecurity that having different versions of YHWH creates.

  • @BabyHoolighan
    @BabyHoolighan 2 дні тому +2

    Poor Frank!

  • @bitcores
    @bitcores 2 дні тому +2

    Frank is throwing around a lot of "could be" when he COULD just ask the people who have worked on the site.

  • @jrt4927
    @jrt4927 День тому +1

    IS IT?! …no Frank, it isn’t

  • @epicofgilgamesh9964
    @epicofgilgamesh9964 2 дні тому +1

    Is there even one honest apologist? Just one?

  • @CraigGood
    @CraigGood День тому

    FYI, for some reason your audio has been at a very low level recently. The video you're commenting on sounds about right.

  • @inwyrdn3691
    @inwyrdn3691 2 дні тому +8

    "It COULD completely validate the beliefs I desperately want to maintain because it keeps the paychecks flooding in!"
    You're right, Frank. It could.
    You COULD also be a complete scam artist who has the moral integrity of well...the ghoulish monster you call your deity.
    I believe one of those is true - can you figure out which one?

  • @Fritz_Lost_Sanity
    @Fritz_Lost_Sanity 2 дні тому +1

    Ah good ol’ Frank out here, crushing the concept of faith by bending over backwards to present “proof” of stuff.
    “Is it the altar!? I dunno, but it sure is interesting!”
    Me: Are we in the matrix? I dunno, but it sure is interesting!

  • @larryalden79
    @larryalden79 2 дні тому

    But doesn't his fire consume the sons of Aaron and the sacrifice, in the very next chapter, of fat, liver, and the animal's pancreas?

  • @4everseekingwisdom690
    @4everseekingwisdom690 2 дні тому +9

    both aaron and Moses are myths so one wouldn't expect to find relics

    • @byrondickens
      @byrondickens 2 дні тому

      Yep. The Exodus narrative has nothing to do with a literal sudden mass migration.

  • @shanesullivan460
    @shanesullivan460 2 дні тому +4

    Oh, Frank, you silly goose. Midian is the cemetery where the Tribes of the Moon live.

  • @danjohnston9037
    @danjohnston9037 2 дні тому +11

    The Chump Is The Golden Calf Of The MAGA

  • @shanegooding4839
    @shanegooding4839 2 дні тому +3

    Frank 'could' be making stuff up about made up stuff.😁

  • @JL-fx2cd
    @JL-fx2cd 2 дні тому +1

    I don't understand why BELIEVERS always feel the need to LIE FOR GOD. Why make up this krap? If your God created the UNIVERSE... He doesn't need tlu idiots to lie for him.

  • @naomiandtommccabe
    @naomiandtommccabe 2 дні тому +2

    I think Frank worships a bit of bull himself.

  • @theoutspokenhumanist
    @theoutspokenhumanist 2 дні тому +1

    Frank Turek misleading people again. I'm shocked 😂

  • @randybaker6042
    @randybaker6042 2 дні тому +2

    😂

  • @Nudnik1
    @Nudnik1 2 дні тому

    Dan 👍

  • @Pasture_Prime
    @Pasture_Prime 2 дні тому +1

    left out
    Magna Mater (Great Mother of the Gods): Rome (Taurobolium ritual)
    Mithras: Roman Empire (Cult of Mithras)
    Zeus: Ancient Greece
    Apis (associated with Ptah, later Osiris and Atum): Ancient Egypt (Memphis)
    A significant amount🐄💩

  • @LoveAllAnimals101
    @LoveAllAnimals101 День тому

    It would be a miracle if Frank would stop insinuating improbable claims and assertions to fit his dogmatic presuppositions.

  • @Maltravers2011
    @Maltravers2011 День тому

    So this story is a lot of bull