STAR or SCRUB? Caleb Williams All-22 Highlights & Analysis
Вставка
- Опубліковано 19 чер 2024
- Let me know which player you want to see in the next video!
Please like, comment and subscribe for more football content!
* Copyright Disclaimer Under Section 107 of the Copyright Act 1976, allowance is made for "fair use" for purposes such as criticism, commenting, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, and research. Fair use is a use permitted by copyright statute that might otherwise be infringing. Non-profit, educational or personal use tips the balance in favour of fair use.
-This video has no negative impact on the original works (It would actually be positive for them)
-This video is also for teaching purposes.
-It is not transformative in nature.
-I only used bits and pieces of videos to get the point across where necessary.
We make these videos with the intention of educating others in a motivational/inspirational form. We do not own the clips and music we use in most cases. Our understanding is that it is in correlation to Fair Right Use, however given that it is open to interpretation, if any owners of the content clips would like us to remove the video, we have no problem with that and will do so as fast as possible. Please message us on Twitter if you have any concerns. - Спорт
Love how there's no fluff in these videos. Straight to the point. Keep it up
That's why _I_ subscribed.
That backside dig throw he made in the notre dame game was high level. Love to see he can stay in the pocket and go through his progressions. We need that in DC lol
Yessir. I'm happy with this years draft because we just have so many different options. We can trade up, trade back, stay put, draft a qb, draft o- line and many more options. Excited to see what this new ownership, gm, hc, etc have in mind for the future of this franchise.
As a bears fan, you can have him.... I'll take maye all day
This aged well 😂
I’m a Bears fan we need to get more weapons on the receiver side, another RB, Oline, more defense help. This is what we need to do.
Also, we need a new QB.
@@Lobaniumain’t gotta be #1 pick tho bruh. How many #1 QB prospects work out to be so? Not many at any position tbh. NFL is a different beast compared to college. Not to mention the pressure that comes with it. Some humans in general aren’t built to deal with it. Hate to be bold but most fold. And yes I rhymed on purpose 😂
@@Lobanium NOT A ROOKIE QB... ESPECIALLY A SHORT ONE
As fellow bears fan were good at running back solving the line issues solves the ability to run also . Now we definitely need an edge rusher a 3tech tackle guard and wide receivers
@@Lobaniumyeah you’re of course one those fans those games you that want to lay it all in Justin’s lap as though the organization put him position to prosper . Year one he’s thrown in behind a trash offensive line no real weapons to speak of barely made out alive.
Year two new management steps it all the way down to spare parts trash offensive line trash defense no number 1 receiver in sight .
Yeah there starts out horrible because this revamped offensive line doesn’t have but one starter player consistently threw the first 8 weeks
the defense is atrocious one they all time worst in league history it was giving 30ppg for almost 20 games . Field is it hurt he comes back to healthy offensive line they acquire Sweat they’ve won 3 off the last five worth a better defense and consistent line play but all y’all wanna say is is Fields firstly it’s his fault this team has been ran like sh*t for decades and is learning in the fly how to construct a winner around a QB something they’ve only done once and at the same time develope a QB something that only done once in 40’s and 50’
they fields had yet to have an experienced offensive coordinator or head coach but he’s the problem 😂😂😂. Caleb Williams is definitely not the answer .
I appreciate this scouting report. It is balanced and stays away from the “Pat Mahomes” comparisons. I think you’re spot on with the Russel Wilson comp for his throws on the run. I am a Bears fan and think we should keep JF for another year. None of the QB prospects wow me in this draft. This kid has the potential to be good but I question whether he can be great. Thanks again for the work you put in to this.
The bears org doesn’t have the best track record at deciding on QBs or what QBs to draft 😂 never forget we passed on Mahomes for trubs
And there were plenty of Bear fans that wanted Trubisky going into the draft saying that they did not want a "running" QB like Mahomes or Watson.
Mahomes and Watson were more NFL ready than Williams and I really don't want the Bears to draft him.
Too much backyard football, weak character issue and he just screams "can't be coached".@@Sealab1985
The only thing is they need to do something at OC. Getsy has accommodated some for fields but isn't using him to his full potential. I agree and think Fields hasnt earned the title of the guy yet but earned another chance with his resilience and continued production.
Christ this is why our team sucks for the last 40 years
To me fields and caleb are very similar caleb is more of a natural arm talent and fields a more natural runner. But fields isn't to far off on arm talent. You have mahomes level then every other qb in the nfl. caleb is with mahomes but can he function in structure. Same question fields had. As a bears fan I rather keep fields since he's just starting to learn how to throw in structure. Caleb could but chicago is too impatient with young qbs I fear his confidence will be his demise here
Good analysis. But you didn't talk about his tendency to run with the ball in one hand and away from his body. People have complained about JF and fumbles. But Williams has had a ton of fumbles because of the way he carries the ball when trying to rush. I think he would be worse than Fields on that count. He's had some good games against a below 25 college team, but not so good in a game against a top 25 college team. In the NFL he will have trouble unless he can figure out and correct some of his weaknesses. I'll stick with Fields at this point. He has 3 years of experience and with the right OC he can be great. Getsy has to be replaced with a good offensive play caller and coach!!
Thank you for a SANE take on this situation.
💯
Get Caleb! Fields hasn’t done anything in three seasons. He’s lead the team to 10-27 while his backups are 6-9. There’s no question that Fields isn’t the answer.
@@sloebone7399 because Fields also plays on the defense that has blown doubke digit leads i the 4th quarter? You realize our defense has blow enough games that Fields would have had a playoff start by now?
@@badlt5897 So has Caleb. He was opposite the 5th worst defense in the NCAA and they were giving up 35 points a game. Now I don't know about you, but I personally think a 5 TD handicap to the other team might have an affect on how the QB plays, yeah?
But here's the difference. Williams still produced his ass off under those circumstance and won a bunch of those games.
Fields has seen more garbage time in the NFL than Oscar and he still can't pad his stats when defense are playing in fluffy prevent.In fact, he gets worse. Even the most incompetent passers on awful teams can put up 300+ in a blowout.
If it weren't for Justin's legs no one would even consider this insanity, because he's not a good passer.
I'll be glad when they finally trade him so people can stop defending a guy that isn't getting it done.
I'm not a USC fan or a Caleb fan (not until he puts on a Bears Jersey, if we draft him). That touch evaluation was just not true. I sat and watched video after video of this guy and his accuracy and touch were something I noticed he has and hes very good in throwing to tight windows. I want to keep Justin and build around him but if we get Caleb I think he will Handel some of the things Justin struggled with. That said the right coaching can help Justin overcome those issues.
As a Vikings fan, please draft this dude Chicago! Definitely don’t draft the trenches and build your team.
I rather have CW than Fields
It sucks for the Bears because if they move on from Fields and take Williams and he busts it sets the franchise back a few more years. If they dont take him and he becomes a star somewhere else while Fields continues to struggle Bear fans could riot. Its just a bad situation for Chicago. I think the safest play is to trade down for multiple picks and try to take Nabers and Latu which would give the Bears defense an absolutely devastating Dline while giving Fields another weapon to throw to because lets face it you have DJ Moore and nothing else. Even Kmet at TE is a just above average player.
You do not even have to put in the situation of Fields struggling because he has not struggled since week 6. There is 0 reason to move off Justin. Since week 4 he has lead an offense to 28, 40, 6 (this week he got hurt), 26, 12, 28, 17, and 27. This is normal for him now that is 23PPG. If the Bears role the dice your possibly getting rid of this every Sunday.
Mr nobody, Fields needs a completely solid Oline in front of him like he had in Ohio State, so the Bears have to address the Oline in their second pick of the 1st round after (hopefully) drafting Marvin Harrison, Jr. I hope they get the top Offensive Tackle from Penn State. They also need to draft a Center no later than the 3rd round
@@BigG6179rookie….deal……
Having the 1st pick overall is an incredible situation for Chicago lol. Don't be scared nobody lol. It's a gift.
@@BigG6179THERES LIKE 7 REASONS TO MOVE ON FROM FEILDS
Thanks for this not being a ‘hype’ video - you REALLY looked at his game and broke it down - not doing some whole ‘bust/reset the salary cap/etc etc etc stuff…good and honest take - good prospect with flaws that could turn out to be ok or his downfall.
Against decent defenses he struggles IN COLLEGE
@@thecrudepodcast5907Your comment is similar to someone I saw on a Lamar scouting video years ago. There isn’t an exact science on finding an elite QB. The team a player is drafted to can determine if a player will be good.
@@thecrudepodcast5907lmao
He's not even the best QB in the last 10 draft classes
😂 bro couldn’t be anymore of a hater
@@SteelKreelI’m a bears fan and I’m embarrassed of the fan base. They are 100% insane
Caleb got BUST written all over him
How? Just wondering what do you see to make that conclusion
@@MaseratiMarty84 People opinions on the internet are worthless. He doesn't know anymore than the next man
Notre-dame embrassed him. He has played against really bad defenses @@MaseratiMarty84
@@MaseratiMarty84 looks like a 5th rd pick when he plays decent competition. also serious maturity issues. also, too small. very few 6 foot QBs make it. Also cannot play in structure. Hero ball cannot be your forte
Yep. I think 3 QB’s in this draft will be better.
All of the Bears future starts with coaching + direction they want to go with philosophy. Whats the choice regarding coaching? If they draft Caleb i think the fact he likes to play off script will influence who wants to coach him. Also he’s got new generation tone (I’ve seen the reports about him) and is giving Lebron/ gaudy WR / NBA superstar vibes - confident in his worth and likely wants heavy influence if he balls out - Bears ready for that kind of energy that will permeate everything, if he wins? Looks like he could be feeling himself real hard and I wonder where management and ownership will be with that vibe…I can’t telll how team oriented he is and what coach out there currently is ok with his flow which doesn’t seem traditional NFL style....🤷🏾♂️
I don't see where him and dj moore will be on the same page cause fields and moore like brothers
That doesn’t matter if you don’t have a great coach. Williams will be Zach Wilson on bears. Mahomes has Reid. Brady Belichick. Brees Payton, Russell Pete. Bears have no coaches. Harbaugh is going to the chargers most likely…Bears are a no for anyone QB. Texans got lucky because that coach is phenomenal and young.
@@PATRIOTTTT exactly. Being in the right situation as a rookie qb is everything! This is exactly why Caleb’s dad was saying they’d consider staying in school if it doesn’t seem like he’d be drafted into a good situation. A lot of talented qbs flamed out due to where they were drafted.
@@PATRIOTTTT Bears hired Shane Waldron as OC who turned an 8 year QB bust/backup Geno Smith into a top 10-15 QB. 2021 stats 4200+ passing yards, near 69% completion rate 30 Tds vs 11 Ints in 2022. In 2023 he threw 3600+ yards, 20 TDs vs 9 Ints and 64% completion. Before getting Waldron as an OC his best season was 2500 yards, 59% completion 13 TDS vs 13 Ints
yes, and the Bears Fumbled getting Mike Vrabel as the Head Coach and GM...That tells you that Bears are keeping Fields with Eberflus caleb Williams is going somewhere else mate. Fields are Ebers Guy.
He has a quick release which to me just as important as arm strength.
Justin Fields has to wind up to get that kind of torque.
Thanks for the videos. Key word is prospect, quarterbacks should get all the experience possible. Trevor Lawrence is learning on the job when he could've stayed and got the experience. Reps=TOT time on task giving them all the looks a defense can give, which means confidence in where and why you throw the ball to a certain spot.
SPOT
ON
ANALYSIS
Moore, MHJ, and Kmet is a scary top 3 set of receiving options
After that all you need is a good qb
@@g.hansonas u said but we can get a qb next draft or the one after those 3 will still
Be on contract at that time we can get value and continue to build a team around with this draft I see reason to rush again to throw a rookie in a odd team situation like we normally do
@finnegan8772 We got a good QB, Justin has improved each season, Have you heard of this thing called “development” that people won’t allow to happen.
@commonsense3921 We know what he is, he lacks the x factor on reads. Won't change any more than his dourness at the podium
@@g.hanson like a Caleb type 😂
I hope we go with fields. the haul of picks you´ll get for the number one, paired with the possibility of a Moore/Harrison Duo... its too attractive to lay the hopes on a positive development of Williams. A rookie QB is exactly NOT what my bears need right now.
Picks don’t matter if you don’t have a QB though. Most of Field’s issues have nothing to do with supporting cast or coaching scheme.
@@raider1063 we HAVE a qb. This bullshit of talking jf worse than he is is annoying
@@EmmErrKaaEssi thought you had a qb what happened
@@huhhuh3898 a decision happened.
Winning formula: Run the ball; Stop the run; Pressure the QB; Win the turnover battle. To me, this translates to OL, DL, and in our case, another WR.
I like this^ I don’t think a QB is going to come in and solve all of Chicagos problems
This was extremely well done.
Do Drake Maye and Micheal Penix next as they are a popular alternative picks.
better arm-talent than Justin Fields. But I'll take Justin with his NFL experience, DJ Moore, Cole Kmet & (hopefully)MHJ - with more improvements on the offensive line over Caleb Williams 9 times out of 10. Equally important is a new offensive coordinator.
EXPERIENCE IT HASN'T BEEN A WINNING ONE I PASS
@@Oohesgotadirtymouthduh the team sucks that's why
@@raymondthomas1574 YOU MEAN JUSTIN FIELDS IS KIND OF ASSA
People keep saying Justin Fields hasn’t done anything well the Bears haven’t done much to put him in position to do any more than what he has done. No offensive line… no wide receivers to throw to. And last but not least shitty play calling from the coaches. If Justin had the coaching that Patrick and Lamar hell even Jordan Love this wouldn’t be a conversation. But go ahead draft Caleb they would be doing Justin a favor. Everything that’s wrong with him can be fixed with the right coaching
I'm terrified that washington will trade up to get Williams. He's got a lot of downside, and not worth all of the picks required. (Just like RG3 wasn't)
Hey have you had any issues with veritone?
Honestly I think the field trade talk is a smokescreen. It builds draft leverage and ultimately create more capital for trading the first overall pick. By alluring the ideal that we might draft a quarterback.
I, for one, hope you're right. Fields is my guy. I know Poles didn't draft him but he has to recognize what a talent they have in him. Moving on from him for an unknown commodity would be foolish for a team on the rise.
It does nothing to build draft value. If you act like your taking a QB then teams won’t waste their time with offers. How good the QB is and how desperate teams are to have him is the value. Competition between bidders.
@@tombreckinridge6218 it definitely does. If the team thinks you want what they want they’ll pay more to get it. Supply and demand. Imagine a bidding war in which the owner can keep upping the price to a substantiate level of their liking
@@jayvonS9214 how dumb do you think GM’s are? You’re either trading the pick or taking your Franchise QB. Pretending like you don’t want to trade it, does nothing for actually trading the pick. Having actual competition by two teams bidding between each other is how the price would go up.
@tombreckinridge6218 Oh, come on now. Are you seriously suggesting that GMs are that clueless? It's basic economics, my friend. If a team believes you want what they want, they'll be more willing to pay a premium. It's called creating demand, a fundamental principle of negotiation. Picture a scenario where teams engage in a bidding war, and the owner skillfully drives up the price to a level they find favorable. It's Supply and Demand 101. Take a crash course in business strategy before questioning others' intelligence. And from the looks of it the Bears organization is doing a fine job of it because NO ONE KNOWS WHAT THEY"RE GOING TO DO WITH THE PICK.
#Logic101 #SupplyAndDemand #GMsArentInfallible
@@tombreckinridge6218
Man his weaknesses are the same as JF1. Wouldn't it be ironic to draft him #1 and have all the same issues but without Justin's elite running?
I agree stick with justin caleb williams overrated
Where has his "elite" running taken us? He can't score in the 2nd half why doesn't he run to the end zone
Williams looks like a smaller less fast Fields with less leadership. Full pass. He also seems to be a Diva.
@@darthcy9790 good point. Character and leadership matter.
But we know Fields isn't the guy so theres that @@darthcy9790
Fire breakdown 🔥🔥🔥
This isn’t a “generational” QB
You would have absolutely no clue if he was or wasn’t
@@johnnychimpo7539 😂
@@300jet funny cuz it’s true?
@@300jet you had zero clue who mahomes was in that draft
@@johnnychimpo7539So did all the other “analysts”
He does not take the easy play. Needs to play in structure more often. As a Commanders fan, this is the exact problem we are seeing with Sam Howell. His highlights are up there with the best, but NFL defenses too good to let qbs live off of off-script plays.
As a bears fan I'd take Howell, he just needs more reps
Don't ever think about removing your white board with the writing sound effects. That sh*t is great!
Caleb is a bust. Do not draft him at all.
Great video and analysis!
Thank you!
Keep Justin, trade #1 pick get more good players
Dudes a good college player. His game isn’t going to transition well in the NfL. Dude can’t miss pre-snap reads and buy time to throw. He doesn’t have refined fundamentals to make the simple play. His footwork doesn’t match the WR/TE timing and he locks on bad situations because he can’t read a defense.
Honestly if you're a Washington fan, not taking the underneath routes and struggling against the blitz sounds a lot like how Sam Howell played this season. Really hope the new front office sees this on the tape as well and doesn't mortgage the future for a QB we basically already have on the roster.
As a Washington fan, I'm more inclined to support rebuilding the offensive line and give Howell another year to see what he can do with an actual line and and off season to work out the kinks. Then get a later round QB and a lower tier veteran free agent QB to push him. There are too many holes on the roster and trading down to me would be the route to go.
I'm a Washington fan and just like with Chase I don't want them to make that pick, I'd rather have Daniels, and you were spot on with the point about being just like Howell. Neither team Chicago or Washington can fall for the media hype and must do their homework here.
@@rbuthird a small move down to get more picks and still get a top OT should be the plan
Yes this season more than any other, Williams was not checking the ball down or going to his underneath routes…but if you look at his film from season prior, he did a much better job of that. This years usc team was bad and he was out there playing hero ball as he knew they needed to put up 40-50 points in order to even be in a game. That’s something that he needs to learn not to do and just take what the defense gives him most times. But he’s vastly more talented than Sam.
Merry Christmas everyone!
IT would benefit everyone to let Caleb Williams take his ass to Washington
I Agree best to be safe then sorry trade down stack your roster future assets
Caleb will be the Bryce Young of the 2024 draft! Come back and tell me I'm wrong, guess what, you won't
guys, go watch this same video he did on Stroud, it will make you want Caleb cause he was so wrong on Stroud lmao
where did you get the footage?
Very good breakdown.
We need to stick with fields, we need to build around him. Work on the O Line and get him one more weapon. IMO Caleb isn’t going to fix anything
THANK YOU. finally someone sees it. I've been saying everything you said all year and Im a USC fan. you get a sub. Penix is hands down the best qb out of this class. You should do him next.
*Ummm…No.*
The PAC12 plays zero defense, so you really don't know how Penix really is.
what happened to texas? @@hollo7906
Finally, a solid review of a big decision prospect for the Bears. Does Caleb finish games?
We know Fields doesn't
Forget finish, how about win ala Arron Rodgers
Caleb is 7-5 this season & his backup (freshman) threw for 6 TDs in the bowl game he just sat out of.
Caleb is the product of system. Search “Lincoln Riley” young man. That’s your homework kid 📚
@@jayvonS9214 he outplayed Spencer rattler and took his job who was supposed to be the bigger prospect and was older…rattler struggled in Riley’s system where Caleb went crazy…then rattler shows up at South Carolina and plays solid 🤷🏽♂️
Look at the team that the 49ers assembled, so strong all around that they managed to survive a complete NIGHTMARE scenario in giving away significant draft capital in order to move up to take an ABSOLUTE bust.
Their team was solid enough to survive that. The Bears are in a MUCH better position with JF1...
Continue to solidify this team at ALL the critical positions and if JF1 somehow turns out to not be the guy then you have a very very strong team To bring a new QB into
Good take 🔥
I wonder if Michael Pennix Jr ends up being the best qb of this draft
I guess there's a chance; although, it seems very unlikely.
CW is a scrub, $10 says he will be a bust in the NFL.
Against decent defenses he struggles IN COLLEGE.
Great analysis, fair and accurate in my opinion. I think Williams is certainly and early 1st round pick, but not really good enough to warrant the #1 pick and this "generational talent" talk going around is just ridiculous. I also believe he has some personality flaws that could get in the way of him becoming a good leader at the pro level.
I agree, but the So. Cal. thing will be in his favor. The sports press will hype him for that reason alone - like Sam Darnold.
I think you're right on point
Caleb reminds me of Fields 2.0
He’s excellent off-script, good scrambler, and has a great arm…
BUT he does not have what it takes to be an elite NFL QB because he’s more of a backyard player than someone who can read and dissect defenses and make anticipatory throws.
I like his throwing motion for the most part. It seems like he throws from the hips which should give that extra split second to throw into tight windows. I like that he's always looking for chunk plays, his ability to extend plays. If I closed my eyes, I would think you're describing Justin Fields. The Bears get the first pick. The Bears are ready to win now. JF has 3 years' experience and his passing yards per game grew by 33% this year. He has rapport with the team and is looked upon as a leader. I hope Caleb Williams does awesome in the NFL. I just hope it's anywhere other than Chicago.
Liked and subbed. Nice work. Why draft a guy when they already have a better version in Fields and so many other holes to fill?
Caleb looks like a great prospect for a team that has sometime to develop a QB at the feet of a savvy veteran and the Bears don't have that luxury. If they must take a QB with the 1st pick let it be Mayes.
Great review.
My question is, the speed of the NFL is so much faster than college.
So all that scrambling and all the tight throws Caleb makes... would they be successful and compete in the NFL vs faster D-line chasing him down and lightning fast cornerbacks closing those tight windows??
Plus he never plays under center.
So yeah all his scrambling looks incredible but yeah, Johnny Manziel did alot of that too in college.
Are there any realistic comparisons to be made with Calebs success in college and like Johnny's?
Because when I watched Johnny Manziel in college, I thought he was exciting but I also always thought... NOT happening in the NFL!!!!
I watch alot of Caleb's plays and I feel the same... exciting as hell in college but definitely NOT happening vs NFL speed
'Best prospect since Trevor Lawrence' at this point not such high praise...Trevor's good but he's not the 'All Universe' player we were told to expect.
Great take. He's good but he doesn't offer enough above Justin Fields to warrant a #1 pick.
Marvin Harrison is a slam dunk and Malik Nabers might be the best WR in the draft. Grab one of those guys, pair him with DJ Moore and you lower the bar for what you need out of your QB.
A good WR core will elevate any QB, and Williams doesn't have a sufficiently higher ceiling than Fields to warrant a reset at the QB spot for the Bears.
100
Williams floor is as good as Fields is now in three years in the league he just started scrambling with his head up to look for the pass not run out 5 yards behind the line williams is doing that now. williams is by far a better passing on the run or in the pocket his best
It's what I've been saying. He's a smaller Fields. No thanks. I'd prefer Maye at this point, but that depends on if they keep Eberflus or not.
Caleb has zero pocket presence and no ability to slide in the pocket. His idea of this is dropping back further. He's not going through progressions during a play. Plus, he's soft. He's not an NFL QB.
I don’t see soft on the field honestly. He regularly (may not be smart) lead blocks for his running backs after he pitches it to them. Again not smart but will take on defenders for extra yardage eventhough he isn’t the biggest qb out there. I just haven’t seen soft 🤷🏽♂️.
@@HarijanKennels you haven't seen him paint his finger nails or cry in his mommies arms after a loss? you haven't seen how has play has suffered due to him not being able to handle the team losing games the second half of the season? he also doesn't stay in the pocket and makes passes while taking a hit. Caleb is soft.
The pressure on Caleb with the bears would be huge, he literally has to be the Patrick Mahomes the bears passed on...that is a lot to ask of him.
Why would any QB have pressure when Chicago has never had a good QB? It's not like the Bulls when Jordan retired. U kids say some of the dumbest things. Think before u talk.
I did think bug wit...if you don't think there is going to be ton of pressure on being the #1 pick QB on the Chicago Bears you have not watched a lot of football, or know much about the Bears. @@maximus4everjay119
Mahomes is good, but drafted in perfect situation. Andy Reid is your coach, Tyreek Hill and the TE were your receivers, great Defense. He was draft in a GREAT situation that most QB’s wish they had. Alex Smith was the QB 1 that went somewhere but Mahomes took over. As I said, Mahomes is great
@@timothyumunna4605 just referring to one of the best TEs in the game as "the TE" feels a lil disrespectful to Kelce a tad baahah
@@deshawnthomas Taylor Swifts bf
Williams sounds like Justin Fields except that he's less physically gifted and has less NFL experience. Bears should keep Fields and trade the pick and try build within the draft. This is what made the Lions so sucessful.
Are the Bears going to pay Fields Jared Goff money? They aren't paying him much of anything right now, and their team still isn't very good.
Watching all the breakdowns and scouting reports on Williams has me thinking how is this dude any different from Justin and his cons
I don’t know this Kid or not a fan but as a logical person after reviewing Caleb tape of 2022 and 2023 at USC I don’t know how a guy with only one 1st Round or 2nd Round talent Weapon ( Addison WR 2022 Also no O First Round or Second Round Offensive Lineman) can put up 90 TDs and over 8k yards be called a bust before he even step foot in the NFL
The Bears already have a QB on their roster who has way better college stats than that. He has a bunch of the all time records for a QB in the NCAA, but he didn't even get drafted. Quality of competition matters. It looks like Caleb folded when playing the best teams. He didn't seem to handle losing very well and that is what he will do with any team drafting him as they will be bad. Stats in college are tough because of the varying level of the teams played.
@@darthcy9790 your entitled to your opinion I watch hours of Tape on JF at Ohio State Caleb never had the supporting case that JF while at Ohio State the number of 1st Rounders drafted from Ohio State obviously he would have better state in college if that’s the case. As A Professional Qb he’s late on his read and drops back and he doesn’t hang in the pocket enough the o line is ranked 14th or 15th which isn’t as bad as people say it is
Bears need to fire their coaches, keep fields, and draft Harrison jr. all Justin haters can eat crow since they have no clue wtf they are talking about. They are just haters to hate and have no clue what the real issue is with the Chicago bears.. they just love to pin it all on fields cause he is the qb smh..
Fields has proven that he can play at a high level in this league. Williams hasn't even taken a professional snap but he's talking about wanting an ownership stake in the team that drafts him.
Just say no to Williams. Bears fans want Justin.
He has? He’s been near the bottom ranked QB in nearly every meaningful stat. Not sure what games you were watching the last 3 years..He’s a solid backup, not an NFL starter.
Where can you look up avg time to throw
He’ll probably be a bust based on the sheer fact that the teams picking 1-5 haven’t been that great in developing young QBs. That includes New England, who are proving that Tom Brady was mostly responsible for his own success, not the coaches or the system.
Great video. I want to see your take on Drake Maye
Video on him coming soon 👀
Ball handling skills are superb though as I think you left that bit out - pure Harlem Globetrotters!
Bro his back up QB threw for 6 TD.. they said his team sucked
Will Levis threw 4 TDs in his first game in the NFL, what's your point?
EDIT: Pretty sure Mitch Trubisky had a like five or six TD game as well. Is he better than Caleb?
1:20 In the first video, Caleb missed a WIDE OPEN tight end at the bottom of the screen, at the 40 yard line. That would have been a first down. The guy he threw to was covered and didn't seem to catch the ball.
Yes he is.... Real GMs could care less for the most part about his stats or any other analytics amateur fans come up with about him because it doesn't compare to the eye test and natural god giving ability, Don't be crazy...
Finally someone who gets it. Caleb has the same problems Fields has right now (reading defenses, anticipation, progressions, holding the ball, turnovers).
There's a chance he will be better than Fields, but trading the #1 pick for more capital or players like Moore will be more beneficial as a whole.
Caleb simply hasn't shown that he is a must-have at #1
Avg time to throw only has value if you only sit in the pocket. Caleb clearly extends a lot of plays in to BIG time play which would heavily skew that metric.
The issue is that extending plays so often doesn’t seem sustainable at the NFL level
Thank you for this. A fair analysis and not a bunch of draft Caleb bc he’s generational narrative spewing. I honestly haven’t watched him play so idk if he’s generational or not, but what you showed me says he’s a smaller Fields with upside. If that’s the case, I keep Fields since he’s already taken his NFL lumps, and complete the roster around him while picking up more capital. Even if Fields struggles you can take next year’s generational QB bc you know the media is going to anoint someone after the draft in April. If the main reason people want to move on is the contract, just imagine how much Caleb will want before his rookie deal ends given he already making money from the college game. It might cost more AND you won’t have the draft capital. Even with all that in mind, I would understand the decision either way.
I feel like he won’t be a star if he gets drafted early.. but if he’s drafted later then he will be
Agree, he isn't a guaranteed upgrade to Fields - short (which can be a big drawback), looks small on tape & panicked when pressured - and super long dropback doesn't work in the NFL.
“When his process is rushed he doesn’t look that good”… every QB ever in The history of the world. Lol.
His strengths are great but biggest concern for me is He just doesn’t play in structure enough… which is a 🚩… I just need to see him do the boring things more often than the amazing things. The NFL is doing the mundane things 85-90% of the time and doing the amazing 10-15% of the time.
Jonny Manziel played the sane way. Always off script, never played the call. How'd that turn out?
Ok, So if Caleb is not good or a franchise QB, which talent in the draft is generational, franchise or a lock outside of MHJ? And you are building a franchise around a WR? So who is worthy of drafting at number 1?
Reading the field and accuracy and quick time to throw. Does he excel like Brady - or is he a gunslinger? I would trade the pick and stay with Fields.
Great breakdown, how about JJ McCarthy!
Thank you! JJ coming soon
So much better than qb school. Love how u get straight to the point and actually talk about the QB instead of breaking down every single concept and scheme on every play. The reason I come to the vid is to learn about the QB, not his coaches scheme. Keep it up.
Appreciate the support!
@@SGscouts np keep up the good work man!
All the negatives are very similar to what the Bears went through with Justin Fields. He will do well to take on the attitude that sometimes the best play is to avoid a sack or interception and throw the ball away. I noticed when Fields began to do this he began to play better. Good luck Caleb.
I hope he turns out ok ! Yet what I've seen over hyped
He's just a hopelessly tempting prospect for the same reason people can't quit Justin Fields. He won't be able to transition well into a system because he is more inclined to thrive on improv and being a magician. It must be his dopamine fix. Chances are he is much better than Fields under pressure and crunch time, where JF1 is absolute worst in the NFL this year.
Idc what the narrative the media trying to spin, he’s not better than Justin. He’s never played a big game! Colorado almost came back to beat him. And he had a big lead all game
Justin has the worst release and footwork I’ve seen in a long time he was only good because of his legs not his arm talent
Stopped at arm talent "not elite". If you have a narrow definition of arm talent being strictly arm strength, Caleb throws over 65 yards consistently. If it's a broader definition, you're not watching the games.
His arm is impressive for sure, I think he’s a tier below the elite arms in the NFL though
Nice comp wit Russ he looks like Kyler to me just not as fast and he have to mention the system he’s in even the backup Came in and threw 6tds 😅 imagine if Bagent did that 😂 overall since flus is staying I’m about 80% sure fields is. I don’t think poles will make that same mistake of a defensive Hc on hot seat and rookie Qb like bears have done time and time again 😢 mhj and verse/ mims would be my first 2 picks 🐻 ⬇️
Haha bagent 😂 we’ll see what happens but the Bears need to fill out the rest of their roster and they have plenty of resources. A lot of attention will go to the #1 pick selection but they need to nail their other picks and FA as well
I remember you said CJ stroud shouldn’t be drafted top 10 and maybe you’d take a chance on him late first if you already had a good team. You said Bryce had more knowledge, Levi’s had a stronger arm.
I don’t think anyone would debate that Bryce wasn’t a smarter prospect or that Levis didn’t have a stronger arm. I might’ve undervalued strouds arm strength a bit, and his playmaking was inconsistent in his college tape. But Ohio States offence also made it tough to evaluate stroud as it was a lot of 1-read throws to elite WRs.
Fast forward to this past season and Stroud got put into a situation that helped him succeed. Two receivers in the top 10 in separation, great OC, solid line play. If you chalk up his success this past season to just being a way better prospect than the other QBs, that would just be untrue. But yes he’s a great qb nonetheless
Trade that pick and and build around Justin! We need a second receiver, an edge and a center. Build up the trenches in the draft, have these young cheap contracts over the next five years and make this TEAM a juggernaut
Bears should keep Fields trade back and take MHJ
Thank you. All his shit is off script. Plus he is a Lincoln Riley product Ala Baker M.
He is only 6'1 like Rex Grossman. I take the 6 picks you get for trading the number 1 and call it a day.
Minimum you get 2024, 2025, 2026 1sts....2024 2nd and a 3rd and 4th most likely in the trade. This guy skipped out on the UCLA post game press conference. Take the picks and the character Fields has displayed.
Qbs get better when you teach and let them be themselves. Let them make mistakes.
Caleb Williams is not a QB worth gambing your future over he too small to be a generational talent I think justin is the real generational talent here and will exployed with a good offense and team around him. I think the NFL don't want fields to be great or succeed they allow the dirty hits on him terrible refs bias it has to be racial and chicago cheap the media want him gone cause they scared of what he will become. Dual threat talent like fields black QB similar to lamar.
We take Caleb and Bowers. Assuming we dont drop further but with these next 2 against ATL and GB we might be in the double digits.
I haven't seen a single throw that Fields can't make or don't already make.
SLANTS and Throws down the middle. Cultist will always pretend there’s nothing wrong with their leader 🤣
Lmaoo. The arm talent and quick release already makes him a better passer than Fields.
@@maximus4everjay119quick release? 🤦🏽♂️ some of you who call yourselves Bears fans have a football IQ of .0000000001. But, you have this platform to express your thoughts & opinions freely so go ahead
@@antwaunbrunson3450are you talking about yourself
@@maximus4everjay119 what constitutes arm talent? And if you think that he has better arm than Field than you are crazy.
Keep Fields and get a HAUL for #1 pick. Draft MHJ and some linemen on both sides of the ball and you’re a competent coach and owner away from a Super Bowl baybeee
Chicago needs trade down and select Drake Maye and still get more draft picks in 2024&2025.
Justin is a certified magician as well
I’m sorry but you saying Williams doesn’t have an elite arm is actually insane. That’s literally his biggest strength and the day he’s drafted he’ll easily have a top 5 arm in the NFL. Horrible evaluation.
When is the Drake Maye video coming?
Soon 👀
First off, PFF ratings are a complete joke.
Imagine saying you’d keep a QB whose had 3 losing seasons and stats that make him a bottom 7 QB in the league and passing on a number 1 pick
He’s been doing well recently and another star WR could help Fields take the next step