Good & Evil - Full album - Tally Hall
Вставка
- Опубліковано 10 тра 2018
- Zam 440 - Never Meant To Know
3:39 - &
6:53 - You & Me
9:43 - Cannibal
13:11 - Who You Are
16:51 - Sacred Beast
19:12 - Hymn For A Scarecrow
24:00 - A Lady
25:04 - The Trap
29:35 - Turn The Lights Off
32:29 - Misery Fell
36:03 - Out In The Twilight
38:52 - You
41:47 - Fate Of The Stars
44:00 - Zam 440
First song: Wow, this is really calm
Second song: LOOOOVE OF THE SOOOOONNNNNN
i think it's "love of the son". immediately after that he mentions a martyr who "came back again". in other words it's jesus
@@asdffdas254 I also think the first song might be about The Tree of Knowledge. According to the bible the knowledge of good and evil were things that we were never meant to posess and we only gained from eating the tree's fruit.
*_AND ALL OF US COMBINE TO ONE AND ALL OF US AROUND THE SUN_*
Did day break?
@@asdffdas254 Not sure it's Jesus. The martyr didn't come back again, but the speaker, who is shaming the martyr. If I knew what "either perspective of and" meant I feel like it would be more clear to me what exactly it means.
I'm really liking this "Best of Good & Evil" compilation
i get it
@@goldogemania6760 Yes, the joke that was made is that all of the songs in Tally Hall's album "Good & Evil" are very good.
@@mysteriouschicken8456 i knwo that why i sed i get it
@@goldogemania6760 dude had a stroke while writing
@@halidmussi2272 shhhhhhhush shushs shsuh my figers are ccold
I don't care what anyone says, Never Meant To Know is one of the best intro tracks to an album ever.
good day, introduction to the snow, joe hawley attacks, ghost and miss melody: bruUuUuUuh
agreed 😎
it is really good though, one of my favorite songs of all time
Jenny Was A Friend Of Mine would like to know your location
"State of the Union" sets a mood for "Deltron 3030" (2000? or 2008?) really well
@@nicoreii ghost isn't that great tbh
i feel like this album has the most road trip potential out of any album i listen to
I feel like MMMM is more road trip potential. You should listen to the album Flight of the Knife by Bryan Scary and the Shredding Tears. That's a major road trip album.
@@AN-vs5pb I listen to Flight Of The Knife as a daily ritual.
Ok but like, have you ever listened to the album “People Who Can Eat People Are The Luckiest People In The World” it’s by AJJ The Band
@@kokichioma4775 I listen to that album also, although not as much.
@@tychoonthemoon6824 ok that’s cool
I wonder who made this album... The cover is so mysterious...
hmmmmmmm..
could it be, Tally Hall? HAHAHAHAHAH no
@@ray4275 yes, yes, that would be... unorthodox to think!
Tilly and the Wall
probably Hally Tall
finally a band i dont feel embarrassed to listen to when i know my parents can hear
nevermind i discovered the magical mystery tour whatever its called album
@@Likes_Trains Marvin’s Marvelous Mechanical Museum?
Magical Mystery Tour is an album by the Beatles, and not coincidentally, is also great.
@@thezombiecreeper *whoosh*
Everybody gangstar until they find mucka blucka
@@Kuriboh1008 every single poultry item has been quiet since that dropped
You know, You appears a lot in this album: You & Me, Who You Are, You, even the Whole World and You in Marvin's Marvellous Mechanical Museum. I'm starting to think You might be a recurring character in the Tally Hall lore.
UPDATE: "that you offered, you have offered to give me life," was a lyric in Never Meant to Know, it's clear to me that You is probably, like, a really cool person.
I think about this all the time
"You is probably, like, a really cool person" Is a very wholesome sentence.
You could even be the person in &!
Yeah, i think no one is better than you
A really cool person for knowing this band
Tally Hall is the only band I listen to albums at a time.
*Miracle Musical* Let me introduce myself.
Joe Hawley with Ross Federman and Bora Karaca made the album Hawaii: Part II under the name Miracle Musical, which is often called Tally Hall: Part II, as many of the songs originated from Tally Hall demos and many of the original members performed in the songs.
This album is absolutely incredible, with an evolved version of Tally Hall sounds, many genres, and an interconnected story. If you loved Tally Hall, do yourself a service and check it out!
Try Solid State - Jonathan Coulton ,i think you might enjoy it
Lemon demon is also something
@@DaneelTarr Yeah. Neil Cicierega, otherwise known as Lemon Demon is an awesome artist, and even Joe Hawley's a big fan of him.
"LOOOVE OF THE SU-" *ad*
..oof
the way this happened when i saw your comment-
@@chaeli2345 SAME
indeed 😔
can relate
@@jamespeters6842
the official lyrics actually put s*n so that people would have their own interpretation, so no it's not son
My favorite part about & is that the “love of the s*n” part is censored in the official lyrics so you can decide whether is “sun” or “son”.
"Love of the sin"
Love of the syntax error
Love of the sans
Love of the snsnndnsndjjsjjshdhdhjdjjdbdjjdjskwooqosoiiueueujsjakksdkddnsnsnanjqiwiiwuuuururuwjjwjsn
@@bryztoe8754 sussy baka
Lemon Demon: Wait a sec knives are dangerous. I don't wanna get hurt :(
Tally Hall: Stop the peace and keep the violence.
*m o d i f y* tho
lemon demon
@@AmericanMan lemon demon
@@WhyIsEverythingTaken demon lemon
@Redchi fruit devil
"You" is gonna be my favourite just because how sympathetic and soft it sounds, it's like a warm hug
YES i love it especially when im having a panic attack or somethin
Bottom
@@pumpkinuser2624 yes
@@4skin-gaming
@@Felix-pi9gf 🤨
Damn, didn't know that this and Hawaii: Part II were connected.
Incredible, right? You can hear it a little more clearly with Variations Upon a Cloud (Hawaii: Part II) and Ruler of Everything (Marvins Marvelous Mechanical Museum).
@@ReinerEvans Wait I'm confused.
@@umbrella6011 Variations Upon a Cloud isn't necessarily apart of any album; it was just released by itself by Miracle Musical. It has a part that has the same melody as Ruler of Everything, but with different lyrics.
Reiner Evans oh thank you!!!
I know! I was so shocked when I found out.
i love how slow and mechanolic this ablum is and then
*Turn the lights off*
everybody likes to get taken for turns
@@NicoTheMilkman bro was 3 years late to the joke 💀
@@Showmaster-sj8wk not my fault 😭
One of those albums where every song is amazing.
As a fellow Tally Hall fan, I feel obligated to ensure that you've heard of Hawaii: Part II, an album made with the work of many of the original members and multiple Tally Hall demos.
Spirit Phone is like that too!
@@frocco7125 View-Monster is better IMO, it's less overly noisy, more lemon-y.
@@tau-5794 Haha, no
@@tau-5794 I honestly didnt enjoy spirit phone as much as view monster. The intro (However you spell it) Is one of the best tracks. But since you all are just naming my favorite albums off the top of my head, I reccomend Plastic Beach and Joe Hawley Joe Hawley.
Why is Good & Evil just Marvin's emo brother
Hawaii Part II is the weird (or cool) cousin.
not a trampoline is the goofy uncle
Joe Hawley joe Hawley is the homeless man across the street.
The albums of Tally Hall as a family.
@@DHMISFunniMan pfft-
For the most unfathomable reason, Cannibal feels like a song that I'd hear during the credits of a movie.
Cannibal reminds me of the most dangerous game
@@MinaWalker Wait, did Lord Zarroff eat the people he hunted? I though he just hung their heads in his trophy room and threw the rest of the body in some bins. But now that I think of it, it makes sense of why he would eat them. Just wondering.
@@Jaykilyourbrain i googled it and it says that he’s a cannibal (although I didn’t get that from the story)
@MinaWalker Okay thanks for letting me know! I didn't quite get that from the story either, I must've missed it.
Similar-ish feeling, but it’s for Turn The Lights Off, I feel like that would play during a montage of college students doing stupid shit. No clue why I think that.
Love the themes of black and white in this album, not just lyrically but how it's tied in with politics and religeon. The tracks misery fell, &, fate of the stars, you & me and out in the twilight really emphasise this. You can't have day without night.
@MoonPizza or just all of "&" with 90% of the lyrics naming things and their opposites
There's a storm for every spring
@@Notanegg. fax ong fr fr
If you did (have day without night), it'd be pretty *hot* (you'd be on a tidally locked planet).
That moment you have to sing nearly all their song like 5 octaves higher in order to sing it comfortably-
Heather Vaughn
That’s quite a lot of octaves actually-
Chase Gillingham 15 (STUDENT)
**w h e e z e**
smh maybe OP is just an opera singer
@Chase Gillingham 15 (STUDENT) an octave is actually 12 notes higher, even if it's literally named octave as in 8
@Chase Gillingham 15 (STUDENT) maybe it's named like that because of the 7 white keys??????
my favorite thing about tally hall fans is that the comments are always so fun to read
@@spacecadet_01 maybe, i don’t interact much with them
they definitely took the teacher's request to sign their name to a whole new level
All I do is sit and listen to this whole album and sing along and think about how good the music is and how I want to do some sort of animatic with every song and tie them together into a story.......Tally Hall always has that effect on me....
Bro do it
same here tbh
...uh oh, me too, it's spreading!
same lol
How’s this going?
Fate Of The Stars has to be the best song to end on off their career.
Hearing end of their career kills me, im dying for a new album :(((
@@Vilaa-w- It seems you haven't heard! Immediately following the hiatus of Tally Hall, Joe Hawley with Ross Federman and Bora Karaca began working on a new album under the group name ミラクルミュージカル (Miracle Musical). They released the album Hawaii: Part II, often called Tally Hall: Part II, as many of the songs originated from Tally Hall demos, and many of the original members performed in the songs.
This album is absolutely incredible, with an evolved version of Tally Hall sounds, many genres, and an interconnected story. If you loved Tally Hall, do yourself a service and check it out!
@@ReinerEvans Don't forget Rob Cantor's Not A Trampoline and Joe Hawley's Joe Hawley Joe Hawley, both of which are albums by the lead vocalists of Tally Hall
@@skelly1004 I'm fully aware of those wonderful albums, but are you aware of Tally Hall's Pingry EP and both their complete and incomplete demos, as well as Ross Federman's multiple mixtapes and Andrew Horowitz's Etudes I and II?
There's actually a database with most of their songs and projects with all of it being downloadable at tallyall.club/. There's so much content that even I've not explored yet, so I'm sure this could be used to entertain yourself throughout these troubling times.
club can't handle me
If you ever need to drown out the loud sobbing, just blast Tally Hall!
I am but it's in a Smith's parking lot
I’ve tried it a couple times : it works
@@kat_dna agreed lol
Y'see, I have this funny little thing called mental stability
@@spectoestis3106 hey I never said it's me who's sobbing
0:00 - Never Meant To Know
3:39 - &
6:53 - You & Me
9:43 - Cannibal
13:11 - Who You Are
16:51 - Sacred Beast
19:12 - Hymn For A Scarecrow
24:00 - A Lady
25:04 - The Trap
29:35 - Turn The Lights Off
32:29 - Misery Fell
36:03 - Out In The Twilight
38:52 - You
41:47 - Fate Of The Stars
Thank you
U
Leety Loo yes
It says that in the description
44:00 Zam 440
I have yet to see anyone comment about this but,
Every song in this album is opposite to another song. Either their meaning, lyrics, or title are opposites. And considering this album is about opposites I'm mostly positive about this.
Example:
Turn the Lights Off's meaning is about becoming a teenager. Meanwhile, Fate of the Stars title, I think, is about death. Now what I've all said is just speculation so don't yell at me if I'm wrong.
Tally halls songs are all different to one another lmao
@ like how marvin's is actually about pirates. Seriously that album has a thing fur pirates and I O not dkkbkw how to feel about it
Edit.
@@ethanriem9242 What?
@@gerardkline5725 Just listen to Marvin's, it's absolutely loaded with strange illusions to Pirates at every turn...
@ I don't think there is a Hawii 1
Okay, I'm sorry, but can we just-
I feel like they knew this was their last album. Fate of the Stars ends so just... Perfectly incomplete, if that makes sense...
The way the vocals just seem to trail off without concluding, and the very final note isn't the root note which is the very thing that brings so much satisfaction in music, but this song just builds up to one grand-yet-quite finale, but that's all. It just ends. There's no conclusion.
It's like you get lost in the woods, and you never find your way home.
They knew what they were doing, and maybe this even signifies something. Maybe it's like the theory of the universe collapsing in on itself, and thus creating a new universe. And that universe shatters into it's own, new pieces of the former universe.
Idk, maybe I'm just thinking too deeply, but it's all just so perfect
Nah I completely agree
And it’s beautiful that the album ‘Good & Evil’ ends on the line ‘expectations all the same’
It’s honestly a beautiful song
Who knew the stars weren’t just the ones in the sky- but also the ones down here on earth playing to them
Shortened points: G&E is a Beautiful and Perfect albums from Tally Hall.
beautifully said
They have more albums after this
@@LegoCommanderCody Tally Hall does not have any complete albums after this
I cant believe you guys
Misery fell and nobody's gonna help her back up?
*helps misery up* wdym she's FINE
haha she got noobed
I've been watching Ruby Gloom lately and ahaha that's way too accurate
Sorry sorry, I’ll stop laughing, grab my hand Misery.
Missouri, not misery. Missouri has fallen so far that no one can ever save it
I feel like Tally Hall has the energy of having an existential crisis while still being incredibly comforting and warm. Ir maybe I'm just a weirdo. Vibes of all good things coming to an end, but that's ok. Stay stong, being reading this.
It's true
I couldn't stand Turn The Lights Off when i first heard it, but hearing it with the rest of the album makes it better. I guess this band will be my new obsession for a bit
update: still obsessed
I thought it was a short obsession 5 months ago, on the same train as you
@@valentinaaugustina Hello again!
Turn The Lights Off is one of my favs of the album personally (it was the song that actually sorta got me into Tally Hall) though I completely agree with the second part lol. One of my favorite bands now.
Been obsessed with them for a few years now, wish they'd come back one more time.
My favorite tally hall songs are
The whole world and you, and, you, and you and me, and and, and who you are
i like you and you and the whole world and you and you
see this is why commas are very imporatants
Break it down
This album isn't nearly as chaotic as MMMM but it's still really good and is filled with a lot of hidden gems. My favorite being Hymn For a Scarecrow :) (which may or may not be my favorite Tally Hall song. Only being rivaled by Ruler of Everything)
i feel like marvin's was the fun album, and then this one was them going all out on making the best music they could
@@sapphire4310 this is a perfect summary of MMMM and G&E
i thought you were literally saying "MMMMMMMM" help
@@eliko1724 ah yes, my favorite album MMMMMMMM
@@explodingegg123 *MMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMMM-*
Fun fact
I first listened to this album when I was 11.
I thought it was boring as fuck.
It's been years now.
I can't believe how I thought this was boring! This is amazing! This is one of the most upbeat, exciting, interesting, and, well, not boring albums I've ever heard!
This is up there with most of the other Tally Hall stuff, and I gotta say, I think this is even better than stuff like Not a Trampoline and Sketches.
I also wrote a snarky-ass comment about how this was "objectively worse" than MMMM, which is... just... completely wrong.
Im 12 and i literally like this album
Jeez.. Am I that weird..
@@AeroneDSA no dude i am literally another you this is a good album and you're just smarter or something lol
@@AeroneDSA no you're the coolest 12 yr old out there do me a favor and never change
When I was 6, I discovered banana man.
When I was 8, I discovered The Bidding & Spring and a storm.
When I was 10, I discovered Ruler Of Everything & Tally Hall.
I'm 11 yr old now, and after listening their songs everyday, my life became better, like, really better. Week ago I discovered Joe hawley Joe hawley and it's totally cool. Today I discovered sketches and Not A Trampoline.
Thats great i discovered this band
@AeroneDSA no, you just have good taste. I'm [UNSPECIFIED AGE BETWEEN 10-15] and I love this crap. Anyone can like tally hall.
In turn the lights off, there is a line "all good devils masquerade under the light" and the one bible verse I have memorized is II Corinthians 11:14, which in the bits right after has "Satan himself masquerades as an angel of light."
I like to think of A Lady as the introduction to the second half of the album
And it's the same tune as &!
it really has that feel, too. To me at least, the second half just has a completely different feel from the first half and its wonderful.
a transition from good to evil, perhaps?
@@darklatex4998 Not so sure that songs like Cannibal or & would be on the good side...
@@everythingpizzaandknuckles6268 they are good songs :)
i like how the first song makes you think its gonna be a basic album that would be seen on a classic rock radio station and then & hits you with "LOVEEE OF THE S*NNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN"
Jus an album I keep returning to... hearing the first song start never fails to give me a burst of serotonin
Would you like to hear a secret that will provide you with an unrelenting stream of serotonin?
@@ReinerEvans omg... yes 👀
@@brynnhill8848 There exists an album often tokened as Tally Hall: Part II.
Immediately following the hiatus of Tally Hall, Joe Hawley with the help of Ross Federman and Bora Karaca began working on an album under the group name ミラクルミュージカル (Miracle Musical), and they created the album Hawaii: Part II. Many of the songs of this album come from Tally Hall demos and many of the original members performed in the songs.
This album is absolutely incredible, with many different genres, an interconnected story, and an evolved form of Tally Hall sounds. Do yourself a service and binge it all, though I must warn you. You'll never be quite the same ever again.
@@ReinerEvans I ACTUALLY CAME HERE FROM HAWAII PART 2
I EFFING LOVE THAT ALBUM
@@brynnhill8848 I just had to make sure. Some don't people know, which is truly a sad thing.
I kinda love how sentimental this album sounds. Tally Hall will inevitably be remembered for their more “weird” content, the experimental stuff like Ruler of Everything and Banana Man, so this album often gets tossed to the wayside. But I love it for it’s pure charm, all of the songs in this album make me feel this intense nostalgia. Granted this nostalgia partially comes from me listening to this album on repeat while I was commuting home on the Chicago L train at the end of a long day, but I also listened to Marvin’s Museum, so the songs in this album must have been better at getting their hooks in my more sentimental side. Good and Evil has a much slower pace than most of Tally Hall’s works, and it’s lyrics are very literal. While there is a bit of abstraction in the songs, this abstraction is often presented very simply and in a way you can visualize. This already allows the viewer to be more invested in each song because they feel like they’re also along for the ride instead of just being an observer, but then the album truly shines in its pure emotion put in every song. Each song is just dripping with this pure feeling; Im not sure how to describe it. It varies with each song, but all of them feel like they’re purpose is just to encapsulate the complex feelings of a certain moment of ennui or uncertainty or devotion. It lets you just feel exactly what these song were made to provoke, as if they were snapshots of the very memory of a moment instead of the moment itself. Like for example, I interpret “cannibal” as being about an abusive relationship and its just purely syrupy love for a tormentor, plain and simple. With them being the “willing victim of a cannibal” encapsulating the feeling of knowing being with an abuser is bad for you, but staying with them anyway because you’re “fine with it”. It portrays this feeling with the irrationality that someone remembering their abusive relationship through hindsight would see it through. Understanding that they did say this stuff but through the lens of knowing how irrational it sounds. This is what I mean by each song painting the portrait of experiencing the feeling a memory gives you instead of the actual event or even the memory itself.
Overall, this is a beautiful and underrated album. If you’ve made it down here, I thank you for listening to my little ramblings, I hope you took something away from them. Have a nice day.
agreed
Not nostalgia for me
Discovered tally hall like less than a month ago and now I could kill if it meant they release a new album
LISTEN IDC WHAT MY FRIENDS SAY, THIS IS A PIECE OF MUSICAL GENIUS
Walking W.
Your friends aren’t gay.
cannibal is so underrated
*I AM THE WILLING VICTIM OF A CANNIBAL*
@@isakts8576 SHE RIPS OUT MY BONES JUST LIKE IM AN ANIMAL😩😩
@@ryanluvr *AND RIGHT WHEN I'M FEELING LIKE MY BLOOD IS DRAINED*
@@isakts8576 SHE CALLS IT A GAME
*BUT THE WOUND THAT SHE LEAVES IS UNMISTAKABLE*
I swear the piano part in Fate of the Stars (at around 45:40) is sampled in The Mind Electric during the distorted piano portion
I know TME is also sampling from Murders there but *right* after that you can hear opera singers just like here and the melody is the same too
Edit: right here, skip to 4:16
ua-cam.com/video/0vfZjdK8Ktw/v-deo.html
Tell me what you think!
i think thats a mozart song but reversed
(i dont know if they added the piano later)
I think one of the members played a part in The Mind Electric
@@_DF_ no, thats like saying 2008 banana man is the same as complete demos 2005 banana man
@@mr.vt_00ns78 I mean... yeah pretty much
@@mr.vt_00ns78 i thought it was common knowledge that miracle musical and tally hall had a lot of member crossover??
Lemme just steal some genius lyrics to follow, props to SparkKeys for finishing it off.
*Never Meant to Know - **0:00*
_[Verse 1]_
Woke up today with the lay of the land
Feather in cap and the sun in the sand
It was easy, it was easy to understand
Everything suddenly falls out of sight
Every attachment is made of the light
That you offered, you have offered to give me life
_[Chorus]_
See the sky and all the land together again
See the way the earth can stay below
Who do we think we are? Everything plays a part
There are some things we are never meant to know
_[Verse 2]_
Having enjoyed all the meat from the bone
Is perfectly equal to being alone
It was even, but you breathe and I turn to stone
Everything suddenly looks like a sign
Easy to see from the outermost clime
I believe in what I leave in the way behind
_[Chorus]_
See the sky and all the land together again
See the way the earth can stay below
Who do we think we are? Everything plays a part
There are some things we are never meant to know
_[Bridge]_
And all the parts combine to one
And all of us around the sun
Everything will fall away
To order from the disarray
See the sun the shadows cast
From all the times I floated past
See the ocean spinning out
With all the hope and all the doubt
_[Chorus]_
See the sky and all the land together again
See the way the earth can stay below
Who do we think we are? Everything plays a part
There are some things we don't understand
Reasons on the other hand
There are some things we are never meant to know
*& - **3:39*
_[Intro]_
Love of the S*n
(Son/Sun)
_[Verse 1]_
Came back again to make it clear that
He never said it would meet demand
Shame on a martyr claiming friends from
Either perspective of *&*
_[Chorus 1]_
Weak *&* Strong *&*
Wet *&* Dry *&*
Right *&* Wrong *&*
Live *&* Die *&*
Sane & Gone *&*
Love *&* Not *&*
All the *&s* that we forgot
_[Verse 2]_
So sing while you hear it, don't deny it
Leave if you can't stand the thought of it
Come back again to make things stand
With no disrespect to the *&*
_[Chorus 2]_
High *&* Low *&*
New *&* Old *&*
Stop *&* Go *&*
Hot *&* Cold *&*
John *&* Yoko
Dark *&* Light
It's almost time to say goodnight to it
_[Verse 3]_
They took a lesson from their fathers
Told them that they were the same command
Wait for their minds to make complete
Their lives stuck beside every *&*
_[Chorus 3]_
Words *&* Numbers
Sound *&* Silence
Stop the peace *&*
Keep the violence
No *&* Yes *&*
We digress
It lives with sad *&* happiness, Oh God
_[Outro]_
Big bad Betty of the 'pocalypse
She opens her lips *&* it goes like this
When the golden rule *&* the jungle meet
There'll be nothing to love *&* there'll be no one to beat
Oh the things we know, the things we don't
The things we think we can will *&* won't
We're loath to gather that nothing's left
We're all together *&* we're all bereft
Capitalists *&* communists
You did the hokey-pokey & it went like this
You hate each other *&* you love yourselves
It might be heaven *&* it might be hell
Oh the things we do
The things we say
Oh the things we wish we could wash awᵃᵧ
(Note: The "s*n" at the start is written in the official lyrics, as whether it's son or sun is up to interpretation.)
*You & Me - **6:53***
_[Verse 1]_
Starting out a road, carefully unload
Open-eyed and all the light is falling
Back and forth, and I concede of course
Maybe I am in the way recalling
_[Chorus]_
It's just you
...
_[Verse 2]_
Off again we go, another seed to sow
Another part to keep in proper order
What have I begun? A getaway undone
I have seen the signs and I ignored them
_[Chorus]_
Now it's you and me
Divine, a circular design
Do do-do do-do
Time and place in mind
Points along a line
Do do-do do-do
_[Verse 3]_
Sitting in the park, I carefully remark
"Everything is better when you're learning"
You were in the dark, I was in the dark
Everything is made to keep on turning
_[Chorus]_
It's just you and me
Divine, a circular design
Do do-do do-do
Time and place in mind
Points along a line
Do do-do do-do
You and me return to be
In orbit all the time
_[Outro]_
You turn away and around
I've been coming down, I've been coming down
You turn away and around
I've been coming down, I've been coming down
(You and me divine a circular design)
You turn away and around
I've been coming down, I've been coming down
(Time and place in mind points along a line)
You turn away and around
I've been coming down, I've been coming down
*Cannibal - **9:43***
_[Verse 1]_
Looking for a cavern
A place where she can stay
Waiting for the darkness
When she leaves obsessed to make her way to me
Because it's getting to the time when she will need to feed
_[Chorus]_
And I am the willing victim of a cannibal
She rips out my bones just like I'm an animal
And right when I'm feeling like my blood is drained
She calls it a game
But the wound that she leaves is unmistakable
_[Verse 2]_
I'm not the only one that she has come to see
Dig up the skeletons of men who thought that they would be the one like me
Like they could be the ones to make her believe
But for now
_[Chorus]_
I am the willing victim of a cannibal
She rips out my bones just like I'm an animal
And right when I'm feeling like my blood is drained
She calls it a game
But the wound that she leaves is unmistakable
_[Bridge]_
Hiding in corners, disguised
She's a phantom, a glimmer inside
She keeps on feeding while I am conceding
So please, won't you tear me open wide?
_[Chorus]_
I am the willing victim of a cannibal
She rips out my bones just like I'm an animal
And right when I'm feeling like my blood is drained
She calls it a game
But the wound that she leaves is unmistakable
@@tuser8 since you haven't continued this in a month, i'll do it in your stead if that's alright
*Who You Are* - 13:11
[Verse 1]
You were the chosen appointment to be who you are
I have been sitting and waiting and hoping apart
You are in sight in the air in the night in the airplane
I am a light in the city your flight overcame
[Chorus]
How is it all of the people can know who you are?
Off in the distance emitting a glow in the dark
I see you
Not too far
[Verse 2]
Maybe there's something to being the one who you are
Holding the thoughts in as you pull away in your car
And I get to thinking a little too often
And all that I want is a little aloft and
Maybe it's all too much thinking and not enough heart
[Chorus]
How is it all of the people can know who you are?
Off in the distance emitting a glow in the dark
All of it subtle and all of it very bizarre
How is it all of the people can know who you are?
I see you
Not too far
[Bridge]
Armed to the teeth
You will sit at the fireside
We are the ones who have chosen the other side
It was easy to see
You were ready to be
And it all falls down
You rose up
And rode away underground
[Outro]
Alone, us finding our way to found
You rose up and rode away underground (How is it all of the people can know who you are?)
Alone, us finding our way to found (Off in the distance emitting a glow in the dark)
I see you
Not too far
*Sacred Beast* - 16:51
[Verse 1: Joe Hawley]
We live in the service of the king
Almighty in control of everything
As the queen decides who lives and dies
Tonight we will sing
[Refrain]
Love was never more than going
(Humming and whistling)
Easiest thing
[Verse 2: Zubin Sedghi]
Our mission is to slay the sacred beast
Who has come to claim our innocence at least
And though those who went before us won't return
For the feast
[Refrain]
We'll be riding high and going
(Humming and whistling)
[Bridge: Joe Hawley]
Worst of all it knows its only truth is made of lies
Wanting for aught and ever-wise
So there will need to be a compromise
Easier to close our eyes
See the other sides of our disguise
[Verse 3: Rob Cantor]
We thought we had found a separate peace
Thought all our pain had finally been released
But as long as it's alive we'll never rest
In one piece
[Refrain]
Meanwhile, may it join in going
(Humming and whistling)
I love how two of Andrew's songs from the two official studio albums are about the listener (even though one is kind of sarcastic). It's really sweet to me. And he has such a sweet voice, as well.
Its 2023 and Tally Hall still has better music than 99% of modern pop today
99.5%*
99.994563%*
i%*
Yes.
atleast over ♾%*
Duuuuude, that transition from "&" to "You & Me" was soooooo smooth. I actually thought it was one song, but looking for the lyrics I remembered "&" would have ended by now lol
the flash at 44:01 says Multiple pathways of the abstract patterns of reality bend around what isn't known
Look up Zam 440
@@dankhank4662 k
There's a lot of Rob songs in G&E, I just noticed- His songs have evolved since MMMM, and even more in Not a Trampoline, you can tell.
why do I keep seeing you on tally hall related videos
He has roughly the same amount of songs on each though.
Hi Tally Hall commenter
What is MMMM?
@@gerardkline5725 marvin's marvelous mechanical museum
THIS ALBUM WAS RELEASED ON MY BIRTHDAY!!!!
May 11th or June 21st? The album was first released on June 21, 2011.
hawaii part 1, in a way :0
i started violently choking when you & me started ending what does this mean
it means you should be more careful when eating your food
@@superkobster you beat* me to it
it means that you shoulld be more careful drinking or eating or doing whatever you were choking on
it means you are ending
It means take this off your bang playlist
i will never do the hokey-pokey with a capitalist
fucking commie
Fucking comrade.
Hello comrade ☭
dirty fucking commie
COMMUNIST DETECTED ON AMERICAN SOIL
Tally hall is one of those semi well known bands that stuck around for a bit and only made the best music the two albums and the demos are what I listen to daily
I used to be a pretty big fan of tally hall 2 or so years ago (slowly drifted away from the fanbase a little after the doc surfaced). Randomly felt an urge to start listening to it again a few weeks ago (terrible timing, I know). But even when I was a pretty big fan i never stopped to listen to Good & Evil in its entirety. I feel like half of me was afraid it was gonna be underwhelming, and the other half wanted to be in the perfect mood to listen to the whole thing. I finally decided to listen to it today and, holy shit, this album is GOOD. Like, i was not expecting to enjoy every single song as much as I did. I didn't like any of Rob's songs in MMMM, so You & Me and Out in the Twilight really took me by surprise (specially that ONE chord that plays during the chorus of OITT). I also didn't know what to expect from Zubin's songwriting, but let's just say cannibal is definitely going to one of those songs I play on repeat while drawing (also, am I the only one who thinks this song kinda sounds like a foo fighters song?)
Joe and Andrew wrote most of my favorite Tally Hall songs, and this album has some of their best work for sure, but I won't talk about them since I've already listened to their songs religiously for years (specially hymn for a scarecrow, misery fell and &). But I really dig the prog rock vibes they were going for. One thing that stood out for me, though, is the fact that "you" is basically an edu song. It literally sounds like it was taken right out of Sketches 3d.
Overall, i think this album was a tremendous improvement for the band. I remember feeling kind of embarassed about listening to MMMM because some of it hasn't aged very well and it was kinda difficult taking the band seriously with songs such as banana man and mucka blucka (not that this is a bad thing, though! I love Lemon Demon and he definitely doesn't take things too seriously either).
But with this album it's very clear that every member had a lot of potential. It's really sad that they weren't able to record more albums. I'm really curious as to what direction they were headed to after this album.
what doc?
@@SKYPORF a few years ago a group of tally hall fans released a huge doc exposing Joe's problematic behavior. In the doc he was accused of a myriad of things, from racism and transphobia to being abusive to his girlfriends to offering illegal substances to minors. If I recall correctly, most of the stuff in the doc has been disproven and some tally hall members came forward and tried to justify the situation by claiming that Joe had undiagnosed schizophrenia. After a while the doc was privated and fans just moved on. This year, however, a second doc was released accusing Joe of more problematic behavior, and this time I think the claims had more substantial evidence, but the doc was privated again before I could take a look, so please don't take my word for granted and take some time to do your own research on the topic. A channel called tally ball released a video discussing the whole situation, I recommend checking it out
I ain't reading allat
@@the_eek2600 oh my god it's two paragraphs how the fuck is that too much to read
@@the_eek2600 it's two fucking paragraphs how much has tiktok warped your attention span
Andrew sings "You" to his kids at bedtime and you cannot convince me otherwise
Ross has a favourite child.
@@baron6541 Ross sings Mucka Blucka to his kids
@@bryztoe8754 also Hot Rod Duncan
@@baron6541 yeah, but he's just a drummer
@@maty5591 and time machine
This album specifically reminds me of don't starve. It always will. Idk why but it just- IT'S SO GOOD- THE VIBES ARE IMMACULATE.
holy shit it does
@@robloxmanface1 I honestly forgot I made this comment and now I'm gonna re listen to the album because I need don't starve vibes again
@@fizziefishie1930 hell yeah
@@fizziefishie1930 it's about time for a re-listen
Now I want to play don’t starve. Shit you’re right.
Feeling awful - so tired I’m having physical symptoms - and required to present one of the most stressful projects of the school year today - this is motivation to keep me going.
holy shit out in the twilight is one of my new favourite songs of all time
and the trap
okay but the first chord of Never Meant to Know-
Y E S
No one gives Never Meant to Know as much credit as it deserves mmmm I love it
I’d love to make an unofficial music video someday
the last note in never meant to know is also awesome :o
back in February of 2021 I thought Tally Hall would be a short lived hyperfixation. I was a bit wrong.
Did you find it through ruler of everything?
@@bryztoe8754 Nope! through my friend who was obsessed with The Bidding.
Tally Hall, the only band I crave more from every time I here even one second of their songs.
every single song in this album SLAPS
I havnt found many bands where I like all their songs and this is really one of them
hymn for a scarecrow gives me goosebumps every time
I woke up randomly last night at like half two with this playing and sat half asleep for like, 10 minutes not sure if it was a dream or reality.
wow cannibal is really good
right
for real
the sacred beast is Shia Labeouf
Y e s .
of all the connections to make to tally hall lmfao
I always thought it was fast food.
This is a certified Fumo prof pic comment
ok im actually confused... who's tally hall and why does every song they make is such a bop
no clue but the songs are BOPS
They're pretty awesome, also can I say that your pfp is awesome, nice to see a fellow Husk Records fan.
this comment is literally a year old, but here’s an oversimplified explanation: tally hall was band consisting of 5 guys just making music for fun and it was great until the group fell apart due to life and stuff, but there have been projects associated with members of tally hall which are still good (hawaii part ii, joe hawley joe hawley)
@@hanzaplast7155 ******JOKE
@@LucyWest370 oh, i didnt see the sarcasm in the comment, my bad then
Something i think is underappreciated about this album are the dualities between some songs. For example, Never Meant to Know is about the things that you're probably never meant to understand why they happen, while & is about understanding that things have dualities, even if you can't accept it. You & Me is about realising you found that special person in your life and Cannibal is about not wanting to get out of a toxic relationship.
The interesting thing is if I stare at the center of the album art for long enough some of the triangles begin to look Gray and also your see a few very defined black lines going through a center
same here
The black triangles start looking gray and if you take your eyes away from it, your vision is blocked by a spinning version of it.
After hearing all of tally hall's side projects, it's kinda weird to hear them play together.
SO REAL
To this day, Fate of the Stars is still the most underrated song of all time
Thai album sounds like someone melted Pink Floyd music all over Beatles music and made a whole album-sized mess and it was amazing
While I do hear the influence of The Beatles, this sounds nothing like Pink Floyd.
@@pineapple8055 Fate of the stars does tho
@@sampler1293 that because pink floyd see u at the dark side of the moon, only a part had solo and vocals like that playing. it doesnt like the beatles either.
@@isaiahsimmons5776 You dont have to be an exact copy to be reminiscent of something, fate of the stars shows a clear influence of pink floyds dark side of the moon, not because is exactly like eclipse, but because it has the same vibes, a progressive rock piece that sounds epic and closes the album with a flourish
@@sampler1293 idk dont hear most of a epic progressive rock piece. dont get the vibes for it, only that one part.
Waiter, Someone put an ARG in my tally hall album.
Good idea,ill do that maybe
@@SOLAR_INSANITYthe author of the video already did this
Multiple pathways of the abstract patterns of reality bend around what isn’t known.
It took me a while to notice the fate of the stars melody appearing in other songs
I unironically pogged at how good each of these were
Looking for a cavern
A place where she can stay
Waiting for the darkness
When she leaves obsessed to make her way to me
Because it's getting to the time when she will need to feed and
I am the willing victim of a cannibal
She rips out my bones just like I'm an animal
And right when I'm feeling like my blood is drained
She calls it a game
But the wound that she leaves is unmistakable
I am not the only one that she has come to see
Dig up the skeletons of men who thought that they would be the
One like me
Like they could be the ones to make her believe
But for now
I am the willing victim of a cannibal
She rips out my bones just like I'm an animal
And right when I'm feeling like my blood is drained
She calls it a game
But the wound that she leaves is unmistakable
Hiding in corners disguised
She's a phantom, a glimmer inside
She keeps on feeding while I am conceding
So please won't you tear me open wide
I am the willing victim of a cannibal
She rips out my bones just like I'm an animal
And right when I'm feeling like my blood is drained
She calls it a game
But the wound that she leaves is unmistakable
Zam 440 - Why all the Theatrics?
44:00 - Why not the Theatrics?
Stone & Glass
Everything balancing
Every saint has a sin
Won't it last?
Resident present
I don't even want to ask
All the light is low
Where the time will go
All I know is that I can see anything
Out in the twilight
All is past
Everything interesting
Is it new?
Is it me?
Stone & Glass
Give me a reason it
Ought to be easy to last
All the light is low
Where the time will go
All I know is that I can see anything
Out in the twilight
And in between
Eternally
An even fall is all that will
Appear to be
Our story's old
And either end untold
The in-between goes on
Collect yourself and move into the street (out in the twilight)
The rest of our entire life is free (out in the twilight)
Collect yourself and move into the street (out in the twilight)
The rest of our entire life is free (out in the twilight)
My favorite song, idk why people on reddit hate it so much
People hate the song?
first song: damn pretty cool
third song: nom nom human groove
nom nom human groove is the fourth song
Just listened to misery fell for the first time and when it started i imidiatly started tapping my feet
Msr fll🥶 or iey e🥵
Noone:
Scientist's who study sun spots:. 3:39
FUNI
oK but being serious for a sec.
as of now i had a mucle spasm yesterday (look it up) after falling down a steep hill. My shoulder hurts like absolute hell, and its taken about 10 minutes to write this. Enough about that, but you get the point. Anyways ive been listening to this, hawaii part ll, pale machine, ect, and even though i cant sleep or move much, im doing pretty good, and i actually just discovered this genre lol so we vibing
I’m glad you’ve found this music 🙂
@MoonPizza prog rock?
this album is even higher quality than natural ketchup
Is it smaller than a bread box?
@@mothpuff7515 is it ketchup?
@@realcopoolmanYEAHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH
@@triktunia WOOO
I used to hang out at Tally Hall and eat funnel cakes. Who could forget Marvin at MMMM. He had a light from Alcatraz. So many memories. You know if you were there.
"Turn the Lights Off" made me reminisce of the early 2010s. Good stuff.
i wonder why
"A Lady"
"The Trap"
*Uh oh.*
*CANNIBAL*
I didn’t realize how amazing the piano is on Fate of the stars! Andrew did a great job 👏
Also 23:01 ?
I listen to this album for the first time on a farm and now strongly associate this album with farms
I agree heavily with you very farmy vibes, like a farm with a large woods behind it
@@Popthebop I've always envisioned a very specific image of people sitting around a bonfire in a field when I listen to Who You Are.
"farmer jim hums when he's all alone"
Did anyone else ever notice how they have songs called
The Whole World And You
&
You & Me
Who You Are
You
Also You & Me is a sequel to & and You is a sequel to The Whole World And You.
@@DownWithDC crikey
@@DownWithDC The Whole World and You and You dosen't have nothing to do with each other aside from the fact that they are both by Andy and both my the same band, i guess
And I think some songs also have “you & me” as part of the lyrics. The only one that comes to mind at this very moment is The Trap.
@@secluded_little_spot i know you are talking about You & Me, but there's also a song called HEY YOU! On Sketches 3D
Does anyone else kind of notice that 'a lady' kind of sounds like the ends of both black rainbows and white ball?
But mostly like And
@@staringatchairs7844 what
@@somsnosa They're saying that it sounds mostly similar to the song "&".
@@tylerjohnston2332 I only realised what they meant last night, sorry
@@somsnosa im cracking up over these replies
Guess I should write my name as &rea now.
Yes. Yes, you should.
do it.
when I listen to hymn for a scarecrow I can only imagine the scarecrow from ocarina of time/majora's mask
Apparently, the melody for the song was, funnily enough, written for that same scarecrow
@@paperaleks4896 woah, that's cool
Why isn't there a song in this album called "Me"
I know
They’ve got three with ‘You’
@@crownedcorn4380 "Me" "&" "You" :flushed:
@@JALETRATOR :flooshed:
@@JALETRATOR jk jk unless 😳
There are some things we are never meant to know *funky guitar line*
if the doctors ever say i have 50 minutes to live, i know what im doing
14:17 the cavemen paramedics driving me to the hospital telling me how much longer it is until we get there
lmfao
clever bastard
Those 7 people who disliked the album didn't know what they were doing
Its 8 now lmao
10 now
In protest of the stinkers who've disliked (19), I will be the 1000th like!!!
28 :(
@@elenaranja9265 27
Incredibly good album, glad Tally Hall is getting the recognition they deserve.
at 44:01 it says "Multiple pathways of the abstract patterns of reality bend around what isn't known"
Thanks for making this album, I always listen to it when I feel I need to escape.
UA-cam kept going "Hey listen to this album" "hey listen to this album" "hey listen to this albm" until I died. This album is good. I like it.
EDIT: THIS ISN'T SPIRIT PHONE
Another edit, this album really is amazing. That being said though, it definitely does drag towards the end, in my opinion. I love the melodies and general composition of this music, but it does lose it's identity sometimes. I find it's at it's strongest in it's most nature centerd songs, like the first song, or that sad one about scare crows.
Edit: Another update regarding my time with this album, I'd avoided it a lot recently, after having discovered Marvin's Marvelous Mechanical Museum. After having listened to the two, I just kinda decided Good & Evil couldn't compare, and stopped listening. But that being said though, that wasn't fair to this album. This time, I'm thinking much more from a perspective of the album as a whole, and it's themes.
I originally believe this one to be about Nature, while Marvin's focused more on people, and the human experience. Listening again, the subject of humanity appears in both, it's just tackled differently. This one is more abstract, and more.. Strange? I enjoy them both a lt.
Also, thanks for all of the likes. I only found out how many likes this comment had, and it's left me feeling very good about myself.
Edit: I just think this will look funnier the more edits I put in, so I'm gonna keep editing it every time I listen to it. This album has undertones of pirates, I feel like I hear pirate noises throughout a lot f their music? Very odd.
Edit: Guess what gamers, This album still rocks.
Edit: It's strang how some people will deliberately include ideas and phrases in their art that don't necesarily seek interpretation, but are more there for the sake of vibe and tone. Think about the title of "Fate of the stars"... Literally speaking, does that mean ? Maybe it's just me, but I'm pretty sure a star's fate in the end is nova or supernova -- this song isn't about novas! I think it's there for feeling -- "Fate", and "Stars". It's a dreamy song about fate and where we're headed. Anyways, here's more lolzors fr you gaymers:
So I just discovered that I can use wireless earbuds to listen to this album in my living room without bringing in my laptop and my family sees it and is like "Omg ethan's listening to the boyband agaainnn" because apparently Tally Hall is a boy band and that's a bad thing?? And then my dog is like "Lol ezthan you're horny for rob cantor" and like YEAH but like you don't have to draw attention to it during thanksgiving dinner, I'm trying to eat and now i have to explain to aunt martha who Rob Cantor is and why I'm so horny for him. And when my mom just says "Oh dear.." how am I supposed to respond to that. Yes, I know you want me to move out but I am ACTIVELY working to earnt ehemony to get ut of the hose. I swear to god you see me at my typewriter and you get that worried look on your face like you think me having hopes and dreams is this terrifying idea to you!! I mean GOD, Mom! Would it KILL you to let me pursue what brings me joy!! (Curator's note: This is satire, Ethan is not living with his mother. Do not worry.)
Edit: BRO THE & BEING THE SECOND SONG IS LIEK FROM THE & IN THE TITLE GODDAMMIT I ONLY JUST GOT THIS!!!!!!!
Edit: Why, oh, why, my life without joy, too much love for that toy....
Can't I feel the love that it thrusts just to let go of those dusts....
All the newly blooming sights, that can seep through long nights...
All the beautiful new world, where I've finally fufilled, all the itches I've felt, for so long and so far, so I can open my eyes, and I can look through the glass, and I can see into it, and I can see it for myself, and I ca
Edit: I know this doesn't relate to this specific album, but a family member saw the icon to "not a trampoline" by Rob Cantor, and burst into laughter. I don't know what they thought it was, but for some reason they found it hilarious.
Edit: APril fools! I've fooled you all by hiding eight typos in this, that weredn't here before!
The first to find all of them earsn a secret prise
Edit: Nobody found the apriln fools, so I win and I get to have the secret prisde. It was a clam, I call him robby. Robby is sad today, because he did not listen to tally hall good & evil, but that is going to change I pwomise.
We are listening to tally hall good & evil, lrobbie is a big fan so far. I wanna reach more likes than this video gas views, so if you wanna help please DM me at Radical Squid Ethan!#0072 @ gmail.com for 20 million cookies I hug cookies for yay i by
NEWS news NEWS news NEWS news
-----------------------------------------------------------------
I have a comment like thid coomment on MMMM!!!!!!!! Find it and like it and cherish it and love it because it Needs(needs) love(love) from(from) us(us)
Comprehension Amalgomation if you see this please do not delete this comment it is the only substantila success I have and without this success I will be very sad.
END OF THE NEW EDIT
Today when i came in to listen to the album, I saw this ad of a child who was doing stretches and breathing and counting to 10 but they sounded super sad. It's like they were trying to move on from some tragedy with exercise, but it just wasn't helping. I feel bad for you, tiny child... But I sitll won't download genshin impact.
________________________________________________________________________________
It's been 3 months. Right now, it is Thursday, August 5, 2021. I regret having waited so long to return. It's almost been a year. Anyways, back to your regularly scheduled furniture.
I kinda just wanna go home if I'm being real with you. I haven't been home in 15 years (that one ain't even a lie), it's left me in a fractured and rusty state. I feel like I've been buried in the sand (HAHHAAHAHHAHHAH GET IT) for 30 years, and I'm only now shuffling out of it... But I'm hundreds of mile under the sand.
Make sure to like this comment, I wanna reach enough that this kadamari of a comment is so big it'll make a beautiful star it'll be a shooting star like ZOOM
the REASON I forgot to update this comment for 3 months was because I was busy playing kadamari damasi
--
------------------
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Hmm. Let's see, Let's see. Loose ends, loose ends. Uhhh... Joe Hawley went to jail for posession of a neckbraceeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeee, ROb Conatoe went on to become senator of Missouri despite the US turning to a monarchy,,,,,,,,, U fot in the house, but inside there were beans.
Some of my friends are tallyhall fans. Some fo them might've seen this comment, or even been responders and not even realised it was me. I feel like they'd know though, they would know when I started slinging Lemon Demon quotes their way. It's cool. I should start a blog, should I start a blog?
---
I showed my husband homsar this album and he said it was and I quote "A christmas rhyme about cardboard squids". Homsar knows a lot about music.
---------- - - ---------- - - - - - - - - ------------------------------ - - - - - - - - --------------------------------- - - - - - - - - ---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I PLAYED SKYRIM! I played skyrim! Have you played skyrim? It's a fun gamejn ,! It's alkm game made for realy cool peos,l epleaiople like mes. It's abut advanced dofr people ddlike me, but im a resal gamer :)))
nh ij lreally sbhlike aksjytrim
skuyruim skryumd skyrimmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm
----------
asaassssssaaaaaasaaaaaasaaaaasaaaaaaaaaamal aaaaaasssspqwpoenw dewspsleinky sj qwhen wthe a snd ewhen a rtyou rdmom d tedls z yxioux tso s to ft rmme dsdtop f c fomign ting fcmrime ed s d dsan d toyre aieak ee wuee wwmw enwp apala aA Aamd duodur delike dddddfuc ck ck ck ov mfffff...
itfc it ti tic itc itc itc rawly fwifmfn f basb d babasnd abnsd absn abn abn abn.
ssssssssssssssssssssssands b ab b erth hdpelol? itb tg g fffffffffffffffffffffffffffffff
lol
@@crowbrainzz :)
When he died, they found an & etched into his spine
@@dunda563 that said when he died, an endless age of untold nightmares would be nigh
lemang damenn???lll;