Companies that would be NOTHING without that one group

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 1 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 338

  • @Rumifilms
    @Rumifilms 2 місяці тому +29

    pin me please

  • @5S.F7
    @5S.F7 2 місяці тому +377

    To think that neither starship nor cube would have survived the crisis during covid if it had not been for ive and gidle...

    • @Mal.victory
      @Mal.victory 2 місяці тому +40

      By now sm would've gave ive their own solo & acting careers if sm touched wonyoung she would've been b.o.a leeHyori 2.0

    • @bmcplays4349
      @bmcplays4349 2 місяці тому +13

      Starship has actors though.

    • @vixxexo6855
      @vixxexo6855 2 місяці тому +34

      Starship has Monsta X and lots of actors. They would survive without IVE.

    • @LavenderPeach99
      @LavenderPeach99 2 місяці тому

      @@vixxexo6855Not really Starship’s shares were low until IVE, and now they get most of their profits from IVE

    • @lavienrosewon8811
      @lavienrosewon8811 2 місяці тому +13

      ​​@@vixxexo6855
      I did mean as kpop industry no acting (subiritary company is king kong for the actors)Monstax isn’t that now..they re okay but can't never beat ive's achivement with awards and high sales + concert sold out

  • @REI.12-r5f
    @REI.12-r5f 2 місяці тому +131

    Just imagine ive's success if the management team was actually good 😭

    • @SamEricLlort
      @SamEricLlort 2 місяці тому +5

      By good management you mean by paying payola like Hybe?

    • @miminkotube
      @miminkotube 2 місяці тому +27

      ​@@SamEricLlort no, they meant promoting the songs in South Korea for more than 2 weeks, having all of the members participate in variety shows and get them to be in magazine covers, interviews and other types of exposure and also getting their release schedule fixed because both I'VE MINE and IVE SWITCH eras were a mess when it comes to the singles' release and promotions, Either Way and Off the Record were poorly promoted even though they were singles and Starship let Accendio flop.

    • @REI.12-r5f
      @REI.12-r5f 2 місяці тому

      @@SamEricLlort no one asked troll, it's not my problem that your life isn't good enough go away and bother someone else

    • @dianamilla2732
      @dianamilla2732 2 місяці тому

      @@SamEricLlortwhats payola?

    • @SamEricLlort
      @SamEricLlort 2 місяці тому +1

      @@dianamilla2732 Paying to get radioplay and get high charting.

  • @vangyul
    @vangyul 2 місяці тому +234

    For real though, starship is cursed to remain a mid sized company forever if they don’t change their mentality.
    It’s like they don’t ever know what to do when one of their artists blows up and they never push themselves to do more than the bare minimum

    • @stnbti3189
      @stnbti3189 2 місяці тому +33

      starship usually overworks their idols, tour on tour, comeback after comeback, more activities, more competitions (monsta x, wjsn, cravity and ive stan here sobs)

    • @loopy-q1h
      @loopy-q1h 2 місяці тому +24

      @@stnbti3189 naur they push their idols, but they don't push themselves. their marketing and management SUCK, i swear on it. i didn't even learn about ive's past few comebacks until i saw youtube shorts about it. like at one point, yes, by pushing their idols to exhaustion, they are providing some marketing, but it just ain't enough. idk how to explain it, it just sucks and we don't even know why.

    • @dibidibidis3367
      @dibidibidis3367 2 місяці тому +21

      This is so real, for a while Monsta X was BTS’s biggest competitor for the biggest boy group in the west. They did so much for K-pops mainstream popularity in the west just for starship to fumble all of it

    • @stnbti3189
      @stnbti3189 2 місяці тому +7

      @@loopy-q1h yes!! its like they lack the resources for promotions, i thankfully know ive's and cravity's past because i used to stan x1 and iz*one but they never capitalise on the succes that they once had, baffling honestly

    • @loopy-q1h
      @loopy-q1h 2 місяці тому +4

      @@stnbti3189 its like if i trained for the 400m race for 4 years, went to the olympics, got pumped on steroids (did not get caught) and got a 300m headstart in the 400m race and STILL lost. starship had SO many chances to turn the big4 into the big 5, yet they fumbled so hard, especially with izone. even now, they are one of the top followed 4th gen gg accounts, a little over three years after their disbandment.

  • @MuattarFatima-mn2bz
    @MuattarFatima-mn2bz 2 місяці тому +44

    Yuehua's money maker is yena because they don't have to manage a group but a soloist which is the advantage for them. Managing a soloist mean less outfits less money everything is less when managing a soloist that's why they give her 2 comebacka year and also she appears on a lot of other platforms

  • @SuperChika32
    @SuperChika32 2 місяці тому +115

    I don't think that Starship's next group will be as successful as IVE, in fact I think that IVE will be their last successful group, their marketing team sucks, they often fail to capitalize on potential success.

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому +67

      I don’t think their next group will be successful either, especially cause it’s gonna be a boy group and this is not the era of boy groups since people still seem more invested in ggs. Starship got lucky with ive, it was a mix of factors such as people falling head over hills with their music and getting so invested in their concept, yujin and wonyoung already having a fandom and all the other girls also catching the attention of the general public. These are not things you can easily recreate and i have to agree with you, i think ive (and to an extent monsta x) will remain starship’s only successful groups.

    • @mianmian3984
      @mianmian3984 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@@soft4taengand what about sistar ? You don't count them as a successful group ?

    • @vixxexo6855
      @vixxexo6855 2 місяці тому +17

      @@soft4taengSistar were also succesful. They are not called summer queens for nothing.

    • @SuperChika32
      @SuperChika32 2 місяці тому

      @@soft4taeng In general, unless you're from a Big 4 company, it's difficult for a group to become popular. ZB1, despite doing so well due to their survival show background is still struggling against groups from big4 agencies, just like IVE, and they are already finding success. The market is that saturated. I don't see a boy group making a difference when Cravity hasn't even been able to achieve big success. In my opinion, they should have focused on helping Cravity grow.
      On the other hand, a better strategy would be to promote their trainees through survival programs. Maybe that way, their next boy group could find success. However, I also understand that given the bad reputation Starship got with the Produce case, they might be hesitant to send their trainees, lol.

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому

      i can see their new girl group making it somehow big because of ive's success, but yea i agree that their next boy group will probably not make it big like at all

  • @CaptainElijahAviation
    @CaptainElijahAviation 2 місяці тому +37

    Soyeon = cube’s stability and money

  • @queenhiyyih2759
    @queenhiyyih2759 2 місяці тому +74

    Yuehua would still thrive without Yena bc they are extremely successful in the Chinese market

    • @amorelockster1023
      @amorelockster1023 2 місяці тому +8

      Yes don’t they also have actress and actors in their agency

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому +5

      but they wouldn't thrive in the korean market at all

    • @havensohn3821
      @havensohn3821 2 місяці тому +7

      Yeah its like saying avex wont thrive in korea when they are literally the big3 of japan. They dont need to thrive in korea when they already conquer another market.

    • @queenhiyyih2759
      @queenhiyyih2759 2 місяці тому +2

      @@bi11lietsuki in the Korean market yes. But tbh they can probably stay afloat bc they can get funding from their Chinese branch

    • @brennathecatlover4360
      @brennathecatlover4360 2 місяці тому +1

      @@bi11lietsukiwhy would they need to when they’re basically one of the big 3 in China

  • @LeonorIsabel
    @LeonorIsabel 2 місяці тому +149

    Some people for some reason like to deny, but if Blackpink didn't debut 8 year ago they would go bankrupt for sure

    • @vixxexo6855
      @vixxexo6855 2 місяці тому +22

      I don’t think they would get bankrupt. Ikon and Winner did earn money and had some hits like Love Scenario and Really Really. Winner still have songs that charts well, but Ikon did fell off after B.I left. YG would not be as big as it is now, but will definetly not go bankrupt.

    • @LeonorIsabel
      @LeonorIsabel 2 місяці тому +8

      @@vixxexo6855 They would, they had the "bar" to high during 2ne1 and bigbang after them leaving and with all does scandals do you really believe they would be able to keep their "lifestyle" and keep the rest of their groups?, they would not, this is not a hate to other YG groups, its just that does groups all together dont keep YG and their finances!

    • @MCFCJake
      @MCFCJake 2 місяці тому +3

      I mean yeah look at YG's scenario right now. Their profit is down a lot even after BM and their boy group is active.

    • @MCFCJake
      @MCFCJake 2 місяці тому +6

      ​@@vixxexo6855their profit is now in million Korean wons and dropped off from the billion mark it tells you the story on how much BP carried them and even though BM and their BG is active.

    • @cvyyjg
      @cvyyjg 2 місяці тому +9

      ​@@LeonorIsabel Y'all seem to forget that YG don't just do Kpop. They also have actors,
      models and other area focus.
      Can we stop pretending like we know how to run a label ? If they didn't debut BP they would definetly have debuted someone else for y'all to worship.

  • @wandeesthoughts
    @wandeesthoughts 2 місяці тому +182

    Those companies should be treating their money makers like gods but they’re mistreating them

    • @loopy-q1h
      @loopy-q1h 2 місяці тому +10

      its like playing kick the buddy. the more you abuse them, the more torturing devices you can buy, therefore the more money you can make.

    • @SamEricLlort
      @SamEricLlort 2 місяці тому +6

      No idols should be treated as gods. These idols hardly do anything useful for mankind.

    • @cvyyjg
      @cvyyjg 2 місяці тому

      ​@@SamEricLlort thank you

    • @reshmashrestha5694
      @reshmashrestha5694 2 місяці тому

      ​@@SamEricLlort they're not talking about general leople treating them as gods. They're talking about their companies treating them that way because idols make their company tons of money yet the company treat them like shit.

    • @MLedZeppelinZoSoA
      @MLedZeppelinZoSoA 2 місяці тому

      I believe they invest about 100k per year for one idol. If there are a lot of trainees, let’s say 25, that’s 2.5 million a year and they need to recoup their investment if just one group succeeds.

  • @adrianaf1194
    @adrianaf1194 2 місяці тому +35

    yuehua is doing alright in china tho

  • @queenhiyyih2759
    @queenhiyyih2759 2 місяці тому +39

    Also I’d add p1harmony to this list bc FNC is horrible at management and seems like p1harmony is the only one keeps them alive nowadays. They messed up with Cherry bullet who had such a good concept and the girls went on gp99 got a lot of hype esp bora. Yet they barely capitalized it, and two members left the group. It used to be AOA im pretty sure but AOA is disbanded. I’m pretty sure the only groups they have expect p1harmony are k- rock band groups which I doubt they are active actually since I’ve barely heard anything about them and FNC is just- not good at frequent comebacks anyways

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому +19

      You’re right, FNC can only rely on p1harmony right now. Cherry bullet went viral with 2 of their songs, first it was hands up, then it was love so sweet, yet FNC did nothing. They also wasted their gp999 hype which is just such a stupid move. I’m convinced some companies should be banned from debuting ggs and FNC is one of them.

    • @vantefly
      @vantefly 2 місяці тому +5

      FNC debuted a new rookie boygroup recently called Ampers&one, the music is not bad but the problem is that there's no promotion or media exposure

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому +3

      aoa was that group before, but everything went down with the jimin x mina scandal

    • @queenhiyyih2759
      @queenhiyyih2759 2 місяці тому

      @@vantefly oh I heard of them! I didn’t know they were under FNC tho :(

    • @brennathecatlover4360
      @brennathecatlover4360 2 місяці тому +4

      Ft island sf9 and cnblue are huge in Korea

  • @squidwardtentakills7252
    @squidwardtentakills7252 2 місяці тому +12

    Alternative title: Most popular groups of each companies😂🤣

  • @gamjasong04
    @gamjasong04 2 місяці тому +89

    It baffles me how companies like IST and woollim haven’t gone bankrupt yet. I seriously doubt their artists are generating enough revenue for them to stay afloat. Give it a couple of years at most and they’re gonna shut down, trust.

    • @ji377
      @ji377 2 місяці тому +12

      I mean The boyz soll half a million albums in a Werk. Which is much Money. So I don't think ist is bankrupt

    • @Stay.2022.
      @Stay.2022. 2 місяці тому +8

      woollim fumbled the bag so hard with literally all their artists.

    • @dgls127
      @dgls127 2 місяці тому +7

      Don't underestimate the boyz

    • @vixxexo6855
      @vixxexo6855 2 місяці тому +4

      Does The Boyz company have more idols in the company? I thought The Boyz was the only ones in their company.

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому

      they waited 1 year to give eunbi a comeback and the song was not good at all. this girl deserves so much better cus everyone used to love her when she re-debuted as a soloist

  • @dgls127
    @dgls127 2 місяці тому +30

    IST isn't bankrupt because they're overworking the boyz like hell, they've had 4 mini albums, one single and LOTS of different world tours in 1 year only

  • @crishanenimoOfficial
    @crishanenimoOfficial 2 місяці тому +7

    I'm just gonna add Fantagio Ent. Well as we all know if without Astro or Cha Eun Woo, Fantagio will never ever gonna risse up and be able to buy and move to SM old building... It happened all they're success during 2021 era, which is Astro's best year...

  • @BelllieveKassidy
    @BelllieveKassidy 2 місяці тому +14

    Sistar walked so Monsta X and WJSN could… also walk

  • @bobbobbycarl7698
    @bobbobbycarl7698 2 місяці тому +72

    Monsta x ran so ive could save starships azz

  • @potatogoggle
    @potatogoggle 2 місяці тому +15

    I don’t think RBW is screwed. They’ve been trying to pull a HYBE and have multiple subsidiaries such as DSP (Kard’s label) and WM entertainment (oh my girl, Lee chaeyeon, b1a4, and onf) RBW also has young posse, purple kiss, oneus, Kara and Onewe

  • @bookobsessedgirly
    @bookobsessedgirly 2 місяці тому +24

    If only sse used IVE's money to do good marketing and investment 😔

  • @chuuislovechuuislife
    @chuuislovechuuislife 2 місяці тому +29

    Also, RBW has Purple kiss and Starship has WJSN, but honestly, both groups aren’t doing too well and are still relatively nugu.

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому +37

      It’s especially infuriating if you think about the fact that wjsn gained massive popularity with save me save you in 2018 and starship barely capitalized on that and let’s not even talk about the fact that starship continued to neglect them even after they won queendom 2…the mismanagement has been going on for years, it’s absurd

    • @chuuislovechuuislife
      @chuuislovechuuislife 2 місяці тому +19

      @@soft4taeng wjsn are basically royalty amongst nugu groups. it feels like everybody loves them but at the same time they are heavily overshadowed. they haven’t had a comeback in 2 years, some members left as far as I know. It’s a disaster.

    • @yeoreumite
      @yeoreumite 2 місяці тому +14

      It’s really sad to think about, as WJSN gained a lot of popularity from Queendom 2, and their comeback sold almost 200k albums, which is massive for them but starship just threw them in the dungeon. They had a lot of opportunities, specially with the attention SMSY, As You Wish and Unnatural got them. Its really sad to think about tbh
      Also, it’s frustrating to see how much RBW has fumbled the bag with purki and how each comeback sells less and less. They had a second chance with Sweet Juice but they clearly don’t know how to manage them. Its specially sad to see because they have great vocals, dance and imo one of the top 4th gen gg rap lines

    • @chuuislovechuuislife
      @chuuislovechuuislife 2 місяці тому +5

      @@yeoreumite and to think that As you wish is basically Korea’s New year anthem…they have so much popularity especially domestically but they don’t have good promotion.
      Purki are my second favourite group also, and while I really liked BBB, it was really unpopular amongst most people. I wish people would listen to their b-sides, they’ll find some amazing songs there. Swan also gets a lot of hate as well so a part of their publicity is negative. I was on her live recently and there were hate comment spammers, it’s truly sad how underrated they are.

    • @betterworld9580
      @betterworld9580 2 місяці тому +1

      @@yeoreumiteyepp promotion is rbw weakness🙄

  • @6MUSES
    @6MUSES 2 місяці тому +9

    G-idle is under soyeon not cube /j 😭😭

  • @ALan-gm3wj
    @ALan-gm3wj 2 місяці тому +3

    For Yuehua, i think
    Yena for Korean market (loved by gp, soloist ex-izone, variety show queen)
    While
    Everglow for International market (being the only artist having so many tour since debut) and still doesn't have lighstick, Yuehua must be think Forever is broke or financially poor.

  • @inferiorinferno8859
    @inferiorinferno8859 2 місяці тому +13

    (G)I-DLE isn't going to disband. Aside from being genuine friends, they each bring something to the table like Shuhua allegedly being Soyeon's muse for concepts. They give each other ideas and support each other during the production process and I highly doubt they would abandon that as it helps them evolve individually as well. They're simply going to reform somewhere else when the contract expires.

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому +2

      they're not going to disband, but they're definitely going to leave this company next year

    • @seleneluvsidle
      @seleneluvsidle 2 місяці тому

      apparently soyeon is gonna handle her solo activities under koz entertainment (one of the best hybe sub label as of now) and when their group contract ends they are gonna join koz

  • @chuuislovechuuislife
    @chuuislovechuuislife 2 місяці тому +6

    I can already see what company is gonna be here

  • @Yoonmisbaby849
    @Yoonmisbaby849 2 місяці тому +4

    Considering the fact that 4/5 Apink members decided to not renew their individual contracts with IST it's just a signal that IST is already going down and we're talking about Apink, their most legendary group despite the fact that they haven't managed half of their whole career...Tbf IST should just stop existing lmao. I would prefer if The Boyz were under another company 'cuz to be honest they were doing SO MUCH BETTER before and IST is clearly not treating them well and they already got rid of most of the freedom that the group used to have.

  • @Haifa386
    @Haifa386 2 місяці тому +2

    I don’t if you will see this or not but this in regards of the starship points you raised( yes ever gen starship has a group that super popular that helps the company from going bankrupt, in 2nd gen in was sistar, in 3rd it was monsta x and in 4th gen it was ive)
    I don’t if the bg after cravity would be successful because as more time goes on it seems like monsta x success can’t be replicated by starship both boyfriend( the bg before mx) and cravity are not bgs that are big( the aren’t nugus but not huge groups in their generations either) bgs are having a small comeback specially since it’s the beginning of the 5th gen and most successful bgs always debut in the beginning of the generation so if they time it right maybe but I honestly don’t specially since starship sucks at promoting group specially bgs and mx success was mostly because of the members not because of starship or no mercy( a lot of people were put off by no mercy and their was a huge solo stan problem at the time)

  • @TheMixdancemix
    @TheMixdancemix 2 місяці тому +6

    Hopefully, Starship won't forget the talented ladies of WJSN (my favorite gg these days).

    • @love4trollz
      @love4trollz 2 місяці тому +3

      They’ve been forgetting for years

  • @springss1861
    @springss1861 2 місяці тому +3

    Not including Woolim kinda goes to show off how off peoples’ radars the company is 💀

  • @darryl450
    @darryl450 2 місяці тому +5

    SM entertainment Groups are extremely Popular and legends Especially my ultimate favorite kpop group Emperor of K-Pop EXO

  • @lavienrosewon8811
    @lavienrosewon8811 2 місяці тому +3

    Ive is starship savior like the kpop stans love discredited ive's organic growth yet they rise up

  • @huzaifaahmad6723
    @huzaifaahmad6723 2 місяці тому +5

    JYP is nothing without Twice.The company was going bankcrupt at that time.Then Twice debuted and in 2016 their popularity skyrocketed.And they carried the company on their back.They were able to build a new building.And JYP made tons of money to create other groups like Stray kids,Itzy,Nmixx,NiziU,etc.Though JYP mismanaged Twice.They could have given Tzuyu more CF,acting roles and modeling.Also if other members were allowed more solo promotions.They would have been even more successful.They are the backbone if JYP.They made them Big3.Twice is still generating huge amount of money for JYP.They get the bare minimum but give the company the maximum amount of money.

    • @May-e1j
      @May-e1j Місяць тому

      They already had a lot of groups before twice like 2pm etc and they were also populair

    • @huzaifaahmad6723
      @huzaifaahmad6723 Місяць тому

      @@May-e1j They sure had other popular groups before Twice.But no one ever came close to Twice's level of popularity and impact.

  • @spongepatsquidkrabsforleni6216
    @spongepatsquidkrabsforleni6216 2 місяці тому +6

    Soft 4 Taeng: Companies that would be NOTHING without that one *group*
    Also Soft 4 Taeng: **puts Yena on Yuehua instead of Everglow or Tempest🤡**

  • @vidyuthaz3471
    @vidyuthaz3471 2 місяці тому +3

    IST entertainment will probably do another merger if the boyz left😂😂😂

  • @hardwellnatics6878
    @hardwellnatics6878 2 місяці тому +11

    In addition:
    JYP: Twice or ITZY
    Modhaus: tripleS or ARTMS
    BPM: BADVILLAIN or VIVIZ
    SM: NCT, RIIZE or aespa
    MLD: Lapillus
    ATTRAKT: Fifty Fifty

  • @g.2658
    @g.2658 2 місяці тому +3

    Infinite left Woollim, and they are stupidly incompetent in wasting these characters.
    Starship is seriously baffling to me. You have Monsta X. You have WJSN. What are you doing. Yeah Monsta X is doing military service, but still.
    Also good job Yuehua for fumbling Everglow and losing Woodz. Although they are doing well in China so they are gonna be fine.
    Cube beefing with Soyeon now is so stupid. Guys, Soyeon keeps the lights up especially since BTOB left.
    RBW just pisses me off. What the fuck is going on with Purple Kiss. Also OneUs is dear to me since they debuted and they are getting momentum but it's still far from paying the bills. (OneWe is also there but for bands its always harder)

  • @ibrahimabarry4937
    @ibrahimabarry4937 2 місяці тому +1

    Starships’ best investment was sending Wonyoung and Yujin to Produce 48 and paying money to get them favorable treatment in Produce 48.

  • @Mistysilvermist
    @Mistysilvermist 2 місяці тому +4

    For yg it’s 2ne1. Without them the groups they have wouldn’t be a thing plus so many fans are getting ready to buy tickets and merch. (Just my opinion. I do Agee BLACKPINK does help the company )
    For pledis honest all of their girl groups
    For cube clc because they would’ve been so big
    Rbw definitely hasn’t been promoting their groups like they need to.
    Everglow should’ve came back with a full album

  • @chewingonchewy7877
    @chewingonchewy7877 2 місяці тому +10

    Also tbh if twice didnt debut that company would be over (not saying othrr groups arent successful but its true) and ateez literally made kq.
    A company id say has a lot of different groups with the same impact is sm like they have tvxq, shinee, girls generation, fx, red velvet, exo, aespa, nct etc

    • @Rosie_Games_With_Pandas
      @Rosie_Games_With_Pandas 2 місяці тому +6

      JYP would be fine if it wasnt fot Twice. JYP and Hybe are the biggest companys rn, and JYP has Skz, Itzy, NMIXX, and more. And ik Itzy and NMIXX arnt as big, but JYP is in ability to give them a stable concept and promote them better to make them bigger.

    • @RUKA_BABYMONST7R
      @RUKA_BABYMONST7R 2 місяці тому +2

      ​@Rosie_Games_With_Pandas ur just proving his point. Twice mad the money for those groups to be able to form

    • @RUKA_BABYMONST7R
      @RUKA_BABYMONST7R 2 місяці тому

      Made*

    • @chewingonchewy7877
      @chewingonchewy7877 2 місяці тому

      @@RUKA_BABYMONST7R thank you pookie but last time I checked I am a girl 😭🫶🏻

    • @RUKA_BABYMONST7R
      @RUKA_BABYMONST7R 2 місяці тому

      @chewingonchewy7877 sorry as a guy myself I'm just really used to using male pronounce 🥲

  • @crystal8537
    @crystal8537 2 місяці тому +2

    Woollim Infinite!!!

  • @cvyyjg
    @cvyyjg 2 місяці тому +2

    Anyways these idols may be talented and it's true that lots of them diserve a better treatment.
    However they litteraly auditionned and benefited from their labels ressources as well so they can establish themselves and last time I check no one force them.
    None of them said " I wanna be in this group, this is our group's name and we're gonna debute this day". Let's not forget that behind an idol, an MV, a promotion, there are at least 30 people from producers to background dancers to make up artists, designers, editors etc... Even for the self produce groups like G-idle, straykids or seventeen.
    So these idols may be their labels biggest money makers but its still mostly thanks to their labels doing. Fans need to stop acting like they know how to run an agency and promote artists.

  • @Kpopcontentofficial
    @Kpopcontentofficial 2 місяці тому +3

    Sm ent is prob is red velvet or aespa,JYP is twice,NMIXX,Itzy and SKZ and HYBE is BTS,le sserafim,ILLIT and NewJeans,txt

    • @sophiaspells
      @sophiaspells 2 місяці тому +2

      Nope, SM is 100% Girls Generation and also Super Junior and SHINee. Red Velvet debuted waaaaay after that. In fact they were already big in the 90's with groups like H.O.T, S.E.S and soloist BoA.

    • @WarriorSageNeha
      @WarriorSageNeha 2 місяці тому

      ​@@sophiaspells😂😂 here discussing is about group that is keeping company alfoat .. As much as I respect group.. younger one like Rizze and aespa are doing well and keeping light on company right now..

  • @rickastleynevergonnagiveyo2199
    @rickastleynevergonnagiveyo2199 2 місяці тому +2

    I would like to add Star Magic would be nothing without BINI, sorry if it's ppop

  • @martakozak8547
    @martakozak8547 2 місяці тому +5

    definitely without bts there won't be hybe and most of groups there

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому +3

      You’re right, but at least hybe can rely on multiple groups that are very successful and are dominating the market, while other companies currently only have one moneymaker

    • @martakozak8547
      @martakozak8547 2 місяці тому

      @@soft4taeng true

    • @OnlyRoseannequeen-m5s
      @OnlyRoseannequeen-m5s 2 місяці тому

      Hmm right

  • @andershi1
    @andershi1 2 місяці тому +1

    WJSN could have been big if Starship didn’t neglect and screw them over

  • @emet17s
    @emet17s 2 місяці тому +10

    IMO, BP didn't make YG. YG established its brand long before BP. In fact, BP succeeded because of YG's branding, not the other way around. YG made BP. Similarly, Cube made GI-DLE, building their image with 4Minute first, but true success came with GI-DLE. I’m not discrediting BP success. But I can truly say, it’s the company that made them who they are today.

  • @aldi_akbar98
    @aldi_akbar98 2 місяці тому +4

    YG - Blackpink
    CUBE - (G)I-DLE
    Starship - IVE & Cravity
    IST - The Boyz
    RBW - Mamamoo
    DSP - KARD
    Woollim - Drippin
    FNC - P1Harmony
    Fantagio - Astro
    Yuehua - Everglow & Yena
    143 - iKON
    C9 - CIX & cignature

    • @hardwellnatics6878
      @hardwellnatics6878 2 місяці тому +2

      In addition:
      JYP: Twice or ITZY
      Modhaus: tripleS or ARTMS
      BPM: BADVILLAIN or VIVIZ
      SM: NCT, RIIZE or aespa
      MLD: Lapillus
      ATTRAKT: Fifty Fifty

    • @Kawaiigirl439
      @Kawaiigirl439 2 місяці тому +1

      Such a lie add psy and big bang and 2ne1 to that list dummy!

  • @kpopworld2148
    @kpopworld2148 2 місяці тому +1

    JYP - TWICE

  • @anaya6928
    @anaya6928 2 місяці тому +3

    Uh would be trash without bp honestly and people debut in yg just bc of bp just like beom did

  • @soul_reaper1611
    @soul_reaper1611 2 місяці тому +2

    Don't agree with the YG one 2NE1 and Big Bang is from this Agency right?

    • @Kawaiigirl439
      @Kawaiigirl439 2 місяці тому

      Yes and your on the right point is was not bp they had more successful groups.

  • @gamechannel563
    @gamechannel563 2 місяці тому +10

    Y’all acting like YG didn’t give blackpink fame 😂😂 y’all should say big bang

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому +6

      Is bigbang still active though? I’m talking about groups that are keeping the company relevant right now. Yg has had many iconic groups but honestly, out of their current artists, nobody is as successful and relevant as blackpink

    • @Haifa386
      @Haifa386 2 місяці тому

      @@soft4taengbig bang is basically disbanded, their last comeback was kind of their disband song

    • @Kawaiigirl439
      @Kawaiigirl439 2 місяці тому +1

      So true!!!!

  • @adriansanchezzzc
    @adriansanchezzzc 2 місяці тому

    5:57 kep1er isn´t disbanding 🥳🥳🥳

  • @autumnrainn23
    @autumnrainn23 2 місяці тому

    It’s unfortunate yg doesnt know how to manage multiple successful groups at the same time. Like imagine if bigbang and 2ne1 were still active today. Yg could’ve been bigger.

  • @LxuiicasLabels
    @LxuiicasLabels 2 місяці тому +23

    JYP needs TWICE
    YG needs BLACKPINK
    SM needs NCT & aespa
    BigHit (HYBE) needs BTS
    PLEDIS needs SEVENTEEN
    ADOR needs NewJeans
    SOURCE MUSIC needs LE SSERAFIM
    CUBE needs (G)I-DLE
    IST needs THE BOYZ
    RBW needs MAMAMOO
    YUEHUA needs EVERGLOW
    THEBLACKLABEL needs SOMI
    Fantagio needs LUN8 & Cherry Bullet
    Wake One needs ZB1
    MLD is done (MOMOLAND)
    BBC is done (LOONA)
    ATTRAKT is done (FIFTY FIFTY)

    • @strawberry-lm1rz
      @strawberry-lm1rz 2 місяці тому +1

      It should be bighit needs bts because hybe is not an ent it's a label

    • @queenhiyyih2759
      @queenhiyyih2759 2 місяці тому +3

      I don’t think MLD is even surviving anymore lmao. Apparently they weren’t paying their staff and they all left last time I heard. So they have like 5 staff members now.

    • @LxuiicasLabels
      @LxuiicasLabels 2 місяці тому

      @@queenhiyyih2759 I hope MLD & CUBE go bankrupt

    • @LxuiicasLabels
      @LxuiicasLabels 2 місяці тому

      @@strawberry-lm1rz oh okay

    • @queenhiyyih2759
      @queenhiyyih2759 2 місяці тому

      @@LxuiicasLabels also Lun8 is under fantagio

  • @slavakaripova2172
    @slavakaripova2172 2 місяці тому +1

    Find similarities of companies that their name begin with letter Y?

  • @bi11lietsuki
    @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому +1

    no cus i'm still so shocked how much yuehua fumbled everglow. like wdym everglow, itzy and iz*one were the big 3 girl groups of 4th generation back in 2019 and 2020 and now everglow are literally unknown, struggling to keep up with the other groups. they were literally the queens of "boy group music made by girl groups", everyone knew them by that and loved their music, both 2019 and 2020 were their years, then they had 2021 which was also a good year for them and then everything went down in 2022. literally no comeback that one of the members went back to her home country and debuted solo there. then after almost 2 years of no music they finally give them a comeback with their sound but guess what? the girls lost all their popularity and fame in those 2 years without promotion that their comeback "slay" from last year flopped badly. these girls are so talented and deserve so much more but it feels like yuehua don't even care anymore about them. "zombie" was a good song but definitely not something to keep up with releases and trends nowadays that this one also flopped. i'm literally so mad cus i used to love these girls back in 2020, they were one of my fav groups (i still love them it's just that i'm not really feeling their newer releases)

    • @Shadowfae1878_
      @Shadowfae1878_ 2 місяці тому +1

      as someone who get into kpop BECAUSE of Everglow, it genuinely makes me so sad to see how Yuehua have let this group fall…

  • @ThatGurl.00
    @ThatGurl.00 2 місяці тому

    And lets not forget about Jype, Twice is the pillar

  • @peachy0604
    @peachy0604 2 місяці тому +21

    YG existed before BP, they will continue without them.

    • @5S.F7
      @5S.F7 2 місяці тому +30

      But back then they had legends like 2ne1 and bigbang, then those groups became inactive and bigbang also went through a whole scandal. YG would not be where they are now if blackpink never existed. Their newer groups will never match to their seniors' level of fame and success and YG would have massively declined without blackpink

    • @peachy0604
      @peachy0604 2 місяці тому +3

      ​@@5S.F7​This can be said with BB and 2ne1 too. People use to say that YG would be nothing without these groups as well. bP came and made yg what it is today. It might not be now, but newer groups or future groups can do it again for yg. Bp did it again for yg when bb and 2ne1 became inactive. Its just the reality of kpop. Bp gave tremendously to yg but they wont be the last to do it for yg nor for any kpop company. Yg was already established before they came.

    • @jxstadri
      @jxstadri 2 місяці тому +1

      Yeah and they did pretty well when 2NE1 were still active. And while there are other groups and artists signed to YG Ent., none of them have the success and reach that BP has managed to build up over the past eight years. And when it was uncertain wether the girls would stay with YG in any way, the profits dropped, like right down dropped. They knew BP would at least need to resign for group activities otherwise they wouldn‘t have been able to debut BabyMonster.

    • @peachy0604
      @peachy0604 2 місяці тому +3

      @@jxstadri profits drop everyday if you know how the market works. The only difference is that the profits are low but they are still profiting. BP has a huge reach and they will continue to do so but saying YG will cease to exist because BP is no longer under YG?? SM JYP and YG all have gone through extreme ups and extreme downs but saying a company will not exist because of just one group especially established compnays?

    • @jxstadri
      @jxstadri 2 місяці тому

      @@peachy0604 yea I know that. And YGE will still exist but if BP as a group and as individuals would have left the label, it would be in a crisis right now. Just like how JYPE was

  • @ron6472
    @ron6472 2 місяці тому

    MLD - MOMOLAND

  • @Kawaiigirl439
    @Kawaiigirl439 2 місяці тому +2

    UMMM REALLY? DONT FORGET THE POPULAR SONG PSY MADE HE WAS UNDER YG BEFORE BLACKPINK WAS EVEN THERE AND DONT FORGET BIGBANG. SHOW SOME RESPECT FOR THE OTHER MONEY MAKERS OF YG.

  • @joonsdimple
    @joonsdimple 2 місяці тому

    Saw the title and immediately thought of BTS, Twice, Blackpink, and IVE 😭

  • @iliekytps5461
    @iliekytps5461 2 місяці тому

    blockberry creative shouldve been included even if they only had loona but like.. they started from absolutely NOTHING to being a really successful gg

  • @exolovelyssexo309
    @exolovelyssexo309 2 місяці тому +1

    For yuehua yena is only for Korean and kpop wise cuz Justin, yibo etc are all way bigger than her in China the native countries

    • @MuattarFatima-mn2bz
      @MuattarFatima-mn2bz 2 місяці тому +1

      Yes they are one of the big company in chaina also in Japan so they are probably trying to maintain or make their company bigger in Korea as well because most of the international fan only knows about kpop. And they should treat everglow correctly if they want this to happen

  • @Chaechae-0Z0NE
    @Chaechae-0Z0NE 2 місяці тому +11

    No!BLACKPINK did not help YG into the big 3,BIG BANG did and 2ne1 kept it there,BLACKPINK followed them and made have been a big group and paved the way for the western K-pop fans to watch K-pop, but they didn’t pave the way for YG

    • @ana-xx6tn
      @ana-xx6tn 2 місяці тому +2

      Yeah they didnt but for sure they did help them to stay one , absolutely after 2019 and every drama that yg had on that year , they make yg became much bigger and right now they there most famous and there main money maker i mean just go and watch thus year numbers for them every company earn Billions for the second half of 2024 , but yg is just earn Millions , and just go and whatch this year number ( in general ) and compare them with last year that they just had a tour , or even 2022 that they had comback so , and a group dont need to be pave the way ,so they could be there company most important weapon or be the group that they need the most

    • @francoisdaureville323
      @francoisdaureville323 2 місяці тому +1

      Em we are talking about today, girl blackpink are literraly thr biggest girl groups in kpop history stop being delusional, bug bang is no longer in yg

    • @Ij_ld
      @Ij_ld 2 місяці тому +2

      Lol the video is about how 1 group is keeping a company afloat.
      Clearly bp is the only yg group ATM raking in money.

    • @Chaechae-0Z0NE
      @Chaechae-0Z0NE 2 місяці тому

      What abt AKMU,who have been trending in 2023 and baemon,with batter up being a hit and having a lot of controversies so they’re very big money makers saur…

    • @ana-xx6tn
      @ana-xx6tn 2 місяці тому

      @@Chaechae-0Z0NE as i said its not even just blink words , just go and look at evidence , the fame and money that they brought for the company , the award that they get , still after all this year bp is the fastest group to get perfect all kill at there debut , and they only have 32 song or something like that and for bp its not just about company , i mean they are one of the biggest group in kpop , and again you dont need to take my word just go and looke at the evidance , cause for sure they are one of the biggest in kpop ، you can even go and look at company shares at 2019 , 2020 and 2022 when they had a comback and there shares before there comback

  • @Sheepy16able
    @Sheepy16able 2 місяці тому

    I actually wanted to disagree with you on Starship but then you mentioned monsta xs enlisting and then it was fine 😂 i'm sure they still would be much more relevant if the military wouldnt be a thing

  • @perfectrevelvet
    @perfectrevelvet 2 місяці тому

    kepler aren’t disbanding?

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому

      not now, but they will in the future

  • @MyrkaylaAugustin
    @MyrkaylaAugustin 2 місяці тому

    I have a video idea: What are your thoughts on the kpop industry's attempt at going in the western market?

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому

      Thanks for the suggestion, i appreciate it! I still have to get more informed about this topic before i make a video on it, but i might discuss it in the future, it's a nice idea ☺

  • @nuveeeee
    @nuveeeee 2 місяці тому

    And starship got known thanks to sistar… they would be nothing without them… not ive

  • @Ren-nu9hw
    @Ren-nu9hw 2 місяці тому +9

    Jyp - twice

    • @REI.12-r5f
      @REI.12-r5f 2 місяці тому +1

      Not really

    • @botosanualexandra9543
      @botosanualexandra9543 2 місяці тому +16

      They have ITZY, Stray Kids, Niziu and Nmixx. All these groups have relevency. JYP would not go bankrupt without TWICE. They can relie on multiple groups to make money. This compagny does not fit the criteria for this video.

    • @chewingonchewy7877
      @chewingonchewy7877 2 місяці тому +3

      ​@@botosanualexandra9543 false. Twice literally saved jyp from going bankrupt in 2015. Without twice the groups you mentioned wouldn't even exist in the first place

    • @vantefly
      @vantefly 2 місяці тому +8

      @@chewingonchewy7877 exactly, in 2015. If twice disbands now, it would affect the company but they wouldn't go bankrupt at all. This video is for companies that relies only in one group. JYP have multiple groups now. It's like saying Hybe would go bankrupt without BTS when they have multiple successful groups

    • @chewingonchewy7877
      @chewingonchewy7877 2 місяці тому +3

      @@vantefly you have to realize without twice none of the groups would even exist

  • @seliyahsfairys
    @seliyahsfairys 2 місяці тому

    girl im pretty sure everglow and tempest are the money makers in yuehua besides yena but ok. also sistar were money makers of starship before even monsta x and ive debuted😒

    • @BaiXue27
      @BaiXue27 2 місяці тому

      Their moneymakers are their Chinese actors

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому

      Yena debuted before both of these groups (if you consider her debut in izone) and she already had a solid fandom, while everglow lost most of their fans during their hiatus and tempest haven't really been talked about that much, so yena is still their most popular artist in korea. And yes, sistar were the moneymakers back then but they are most definitely not money makers now since they have disbanded, so ive are now currently the ones bringing in the most money at starship.

    • @seliyahsfairys
      @seliyahsfairys 2 місяці тому

      @@soft4taeng ohh ok

  • @starlight0260
    @starlight0260 2 місяці тому +2

    Source Music would be nothing without Gfriend and its literally so sad how they kicked them out

  • @sohappyilltry
    @sohappyilltry 2 місяці тому

    the thing with jyp, sm and yg they have so many money makers - blinks are so delusional😂 when 2ne1 left yg struggled too, so babymonster and treasure will keep YG in line, blinks should stop, as if YG could only rely on blackpink, he still own the group, why do you think 2ne1 can only have comeback as a group in yg? all the credits is YG’s 😂

    • @bi11lietsuki
      @bi11lietsuki 2 місяці тому +4

      yg are not struggling in the kpop industry, but they do outside of it. blackpink are the biggest girl group in the world right now and since their last comeback yg hasn't been keeping themselves that good. babymonster are their current biggest active group (cus nobody really listens to treasure anyways) but still babymonster haven't achieved anything out of the kpop industry and fandom. usually people will know bts and blackpink as the only kpop groups, but not the others. meaning that blackpink are the only ones keeping yg that big of a company

    • @soft4taeng
      @soft4taeng  2 місяці тому +2

      I’m not even a blink but it’s obvious that after bigbang and 2ne1’s disbandments, yg would have lost relevancy and they would not be where they are if it had not been for blackpink’s massive success. Nobody said blackpink built yg, what i’m saying is that they are keeping the company relevant despite everything.

  • @VALENTINE-h8v
    @VALENTINE-h8v 2 місяці тому

    JYP=TWICE

  • @ana-xx6tn
    @ana-xx6tn 2 місяці тому +2

    Ok so for people who gonna come and say yg exist befor bp , yeah we know this but thats make no diffrent , cause we are not talking about past anymore , we are talking about present so yeah they didnt make yg a big three but for sure they help them to stay one , absolutely after 2019 and every drama and scandal that they made that year , yg became much bigger than what it was for them and right now they are there most famous and there main money maker , and if you would say they could manage without them ok then go and whatch this year numbers for them , every other big four company earn Billions for the second half of 2024 , but yg just earn Millions , you could even go and whatch this year number ( until now not just second half ) and compare them with last year that they just had a tour , or even 2022 that they had comback so , yes blink could tell lies but number dont and a group dont need to pave the way ,so they could be there company most important weapon or being the group that they need the most

    • @swan_pink
      @swan_pink 2 місяці тому

      Yes this , its not about pas but its right now that we are talking about

    • @ana-xx6tn
      @ana-xx6tn 2 місяці тому

      @@swan_pink it seems to me peopke just want to be dissagrea not seeibg the evidence

  • @nuveeeee
    @nuveeeee 2 місяці тому

    Yg would be nothing without bigbang, not blackpink…

  • @deggho5877
    @deggho5877 2 місяці тому

    this whole video is so superficial like what😭

  • @sptnixkaii
    @sptnixkaii 2 місяці тому +1

    hybe would be nothing without txt.

    • @WarriorSageNeha
      @WarriorSageNeha 2 місяці тому

      😂😂 They have BTS come on.. None of their new group touching BTS's level..

    • @TerrieWilliams-f5c
      @TerrieWilliams-f5c 2 місяці тому

      BTS is great, but Newjeans are also a growing groups and are great to.

    • @TerrieWilliams-f5c
      @TerrieWilliams-f5c 2 місяці тому

      Newjeans are great too.

  • @luckymars2410
    @luckymars2410 2 місяці тому

    to be fair, victon and weeekly were originally from PlayM, and the big money makers in that company were Apink. it's only after the merge with cre.ker (tbz company) that they became IST, and that's when things went downhill. everything is messy and so many artists (and regular employees) have left the company. it's not surprising a 4th gen group is keeping them afloat; they have a long way to go in their contracts.

  • @Clockatsevenohseven
    @Clockatsevenohseven 2 місяці тому +1

    FNC of P1Harmony

  • @MonstaXTrophyWife
    @MonstaXTrophyWife 15 днів тому

    Monsta X kept starship standing so that they could afford to debut ive and yet, they keep fumbling. Smh.