Yes, you acknowledge there was a mistake or mishandling of the situation that caused the passenger her flight -- dapat lang bayaran nila yung nagastos sa kapalpakan nila.
I do believe that those incidents of harassment really happens in the B/Immigration, because my son experienced the same fate in one of the Immigration Officers in NAIA, Terminal 2 more than a year ago, who asked unnecessary documents. But when my son complied to all the documents being asked, he (Immig. Off.) did not even bother to look at it & just let him go. Can you imagine the trauma that it might bring to any passenger who were victims? That kind of employe should be subject for investigation & outright dismissal, if found guilty! Disgusting! 😡
@@aerollove1938 No. Public traction meaning drawing attention or gaining more publicity. Attraction is not the right term, grammatically incorrect when use in this sense.
so sad how they refuse to fire and hold the scum of an employee unaccountable for his actions and lack of professionalism. rotten eggs the whole lot of them
I would get the idea why some of these officers feel the need to intimidate some travelers but prolonging their stress for no reason that causes delays and cancellations, they need to realize invested time and money are no joke
Bringing a College Diploma or any School Achievement document is a red flag in Canadian border if you are a tourist. Because they will question why you are bringing this type of document if you are just a tourist. For them, it seems you have other plans than just being a tourist. I know because I've seen that in a Canadian security border show where a Filipina was denied entry because she has School and Work documents with her even if she will just be a tourist.
But the difficulty here is, it's the immigration officer's word against the passenger's. Passengers should be allowed to record/video the interview so that we have solid evidence in case the immigration officer is not following their procedure. Especially since the BI will not compensate the offloaded passenger unless their investigation reveals that there is indeed violation of their procedures by the immigration officer. Passengers should have a fighting chance to prove our cause, because this is serious, there is money involved and not all of us can afford to just rebook our tickets. BI should think about this. Are they not travelers themselves? Maybe they dont experience this kasi kapag sila nagtravel papalagpasin lang nila kasamahan nila. They seem to have no consideration, no empathy for the plight of passengers.
Yes, its should be recorded. Dapat may recorder sila. It can also be used to solve crime. Kung wala naman silang ginagawang mali, why not. Its also for their protection. Its protection for both side
@@jamiekatesalcedo6301 Dear, the conversation between an Immigration Officer is NOT a considered private conversation. Information gathered from the interview is recorded as a government record. That law protects private conversations. In this situation, Im saying the traveller can record the convo since its the Travellers information discussed. So I dont get how this law applies.
I’m glad this issue came out. So many Filipinos being silent about how immigration in the Philippines treat the Filipino people, asking stupid questions is not part of traveling as long as you have valid documents and return ticket. Why making it hard? It’s so unprofessional and disappointing. I wish they also friendly and nice when you greet them good morning . Most immigration officers in the Philippines are grumpy and also moody . Like what’s wrong with you! 🙄
True! I have bad experience of them and I almost missed up my flight 1 hour of interview which looks like I'm the only passenger and she also ask how much money I have in my bank account can I see it on the phone I just said I don't do online transactions. She also ask title of the land, my educational background and experience.a lot more I felt like prisoner on trial and same time under estimated the way they cater us..like they hate there jobs!
Immigration in the PI is the best as long you are not a suspicious character, more so they have to protect the departing passengers from possible harm as one is helpless once in the air. Irrelevant question is necessary to catch if one is lying or not.
@@juniortulo3823 protection with year book? after you buy an expensive ticket? They should know how to profile passengers mere assumption is bias they are destroying the image and the economy of the country. To travel is your right and privilege.
Tama .yung anak ko 3 beses na offload papuntang dubai.mahal pa naman ang tiket mga tax n binayan sa imigration d n kinuba ng anak ko dami daw pasikot sikot bago makubaha yung pera nya.kaya nàkakadala.
Naunahan mo lang ako to say that. If you have the means bro, i-post mo rin sa socmed re the recent development..."REASSIGNED LANG" @#$%*&₩¥¥£€!!!😡😡😡. Salamat sa pag raise ng issue👍
Exactly. Pag nangyari yan sa inyo just get their names and make a complain. To prevent human tracficking eh impertenente naman mga tanong nila. They need to know exactly ang mga documents na kelangan ng bawat tao na umaalis specially ofw at mga immigrants di yon kung ano ano ang pinapagawa. Harassing and abusing people is a no no bullying yan
BI should be the ones who will pay cancellation and rebooking fees incase passengers miss their flights due to unecessary questioning. Passengers should also be allowed to record conversations for their sake incase BI officers deny such questions
If the media is not bias. There are instances wherein they mess up the issue like the Bantag case. In the interview DG Bantag said, hinihintay niya ang desisyon ng mahal na pangulo pero ang report ng media e umaasa siyang mabalik sa Bucor. Ingat po kayo sa media kasi hindi na kayo good example sa usaping journalism sa school. Kulang sa journalism ethics ang media ngayon. You are being observed and so please do give due respect in reporting the truth.
If not for the incurred media attention,the incident would have gone un noticed ..but the abusive BI officer was said to have been dismissed but now the truth shows that the offender was just reassigned
She's not even sorry about it. No apology whatsoever, veiled or otherwise. You have no reason to hold any passenger from leaving if there's no Hold Departure Order issued against them. If you want to go after human traffickers, I don't think you'll find them in NAIA. We still have a law in this country that protects people's rights. Hindi mangyayari to kung si #PRRD pa ang presidente
This Immigration Officers are not professionals. Ang layo pa talaga nang Pilipinas sa mga neighboring Asian countries. So ano naman kaya masasabi ng Secretary of Tourism and si Magellan?
Seperate process: The government should propose to eliminate a long check at the airport and bring a pre-check or pre-adjudicate to the traveler (only for traveler have plenty of necessary checking or high risk) before the travel date and in a different place. This will eliminate a long line and miss the travelers' flight. Once the traveler had the pre-check interview before the flight date, the immigration should enter the information at their system and a stamp at the traveler's passport that they had been check and no other necessary check except verifying the traveler's identity.
These BIs should shoulder the expenses of the person they offloaded esp. If proven that the passenger is a real traveler. It will lessen these offloading incidents.
These officers need serious training or reeducation. The problem is the BI management only acts when something happens. For once can the bureau be proactive…just saying.
This is not the only offloading case due to BIs over questioning. If you google and check youtubes, a lot of filipinos voiced out their offloading experienced. Philippines is becoming like North Korea. As long as a passenger has valid passport, plane ticket and no hold departure order the passenger should be able to leave country without questions.
Its ashamed. I will tell my man about recent theft scheme from passengers and he will be extra careful. Padangug ra tuy gipangita para i release nila si passenger
Why didn't ANC interview the immigration officer to know his side of the story, not the spokes person? Is the Phil. Immigration hiding the truth? Is the immigration protecting their interview officer? That officer should be charged for passenger harassment for asking inappropriate and irrelevant questions that led to missing the passengers flight. He should also pay the passenger for missing the flight. Philippine airport is notorious in crime. First was the inserting dollar bill inside the passport as bribe, then the "planting bullet in the baggage" of travellers/passenger. Now the tediously harassing questions.
Maganda siguro may voice at video recorder ang interview room na walang control ang mga nagiinterview para hindi nila madelete yung narecord na conversation.
Allow the passengers to videotape every encounter with the BI as evidence in any confrontation. Minimize forms. If the passport has enough information, no need to enter the information again. It’s such a stupid and wasteful thing to do
ang tagal na nilang ganyan, sa totoo lang kung totoong illegal ang gagawin eh nakakalusot, dami nga magnanakaw dyan diba. pero yung mga legit ang pakay sila pa yung mga na-aabala. Share nyo lahat ng experience nyo para maging aware at magkaroon ng measure dyan, tagal ng issue yan buti nakarating na sa mainstream,.
So long line for our airport going abroad hope n pray that will b given solutions for more immigration personnel to be assigned please po! How can we inspire tourist of this kind of problem.
Can they get sued ? Stop apologising with human traffic. It's up to the person if the person wants to leave. You can only advise. Restricting people's freedom to travel is illegal internationally. It's called Freedom of movement get the law printed and sue them internationally against human rights in case they offload you.
Reporter forgot a crucial question: How will the passenger get reimbursed for the missed flight, as this incident is clearly not within the scope of DOJ's Memorandum Circular 036?
Went home last month, this immigration officer was so intimidating , bcoz I was kinda lost due to my first time to go back home. He was so irritated by me and gave me an attitude. . They need to get their act together . I’m a balikbayan, I can only imagine the people that just wants to tour abroad and being treated like a criminal. They act like their above the law…
Mga kabayan kong mag abroad pag nasa BI na kayo make it sure na ma record ninyo lahat na sinasabi ng officer. If bawal still do it secretly para may pruyba po kayo.
Modus iyan ALAM niyo na medjo walang kita sa panahon ni TANDA, hahahhah... Hindi kasi nag PADULAS iyan kaya pinahaba ang Interrogation, maganda siguro i suggest na magkaroon ng CCTV sa room/office para ma Review ang mga irrelevant na questions, o kaya payagan ang ini interrogate na ma record ang ginagawa ng OFFICER para DAPAT tanggal agad sa Trabaho... Ang Problema lang kasi, ang mga iyan ay may ninong iyan sa loob na matataas at dinidefensahan pa kasi Padrenohan iyan kaya nakapasok bukod sa minimum qualification ...
They should do one week interview before the passenger flight and ask for additional requirements if it's necessary. Para Hindi abala and no more questions ask na. Kainis lang hassle masyado. Yong ibang nationalities in and out sa ating bansa.
They should post those requirements na hahanapin nila sa mga passengers for the interview. Hindi ung on the spot ka hahanapan ng kung ano-ano (yearbook, BC etc.) na obviously Naman Hindi mo dala-dala because those are irrelevant sa pag-travel mo.
Why there’s no punishment for people like this they should be fired or maybe all of them are working together para mangkikil mang scam tapos hati hati sela
The BI head covers up for their employee... They are all the same. I had the experience wayback 2021 during my first travel. The Consulate General called their office to intercede in my behalf BUT, the head intentionally did not answer the call. Another thing, they keep on using the so called "Human Trafficking" issue as alibi to justify their nonsensical offloading scheme. They dont even respond to your messages whenever they were messaged online.
Dapat yong ginagawa ng immigration officer parang sa call center. Dapat ganito "Sir/Maam yong sagot po ninyo ay recorded". Dapat may protocol na sinusunod, di yong parang mga Poncio Pilato kung magtanong na kung ano lang gusto itanong.
It seems a lot of malpractice and unethical activities in the Philippine airport and immigration have again recently become widespread and slowly becoming the norm. Another way to put the country in the “hall of shame”. Im just wondering what corrective actions the government have for these situations? and if so, are they implemented strictly. Imagine being opressed, harassed, and unjustly treated by your own fellow citizen? These unethical activities going around the airport are ridiculous and truly sickening.
1st Experience: Noong June 2012 na interview din ako ng Immigration Officer noon sa NAIA. Bibisitahin ko kasi ang GF (now wife) ko sa Singapore noon. Ininterview din ako ng Immigration Officer, may mga tanong gaya ng ano ang trabaho ko (sagot ko: sabi ko family business), bakit 1 month ako sa Singapore (sabi ko: para masulit ang bakasyon kasi matagal na kaming di nagkikita), magkano ang dala kong pera (sagot ko: xx,xxx PHP + credit card), perstime ko ba mag travel (sagotko: opo) at iba pa na nalimutan ko na. Kala ko noon di ako aabot sa oras kasi malapit ng magsara ang gate. Buti nalang pinayagan akong bumiyahe nung lalaking immigration officer, kaya ayun takbo ako papasok ng gate. Grabeng kaba ko nun kala ko maiiwan talaga ako ng eroplano hehe! . 2nd Experience: Nagbakasyon kami ni misis sa Pinas ng 2014, tapos namin sa Tarlac ay dumiretso kami sa Boracay. Bale 1 week kami sa boracay. Tapos nung babalik na kami ng Singapore ni misis ay tinanong siya ng Immigration Officer sa Kalibo Airport, bakit daw naisipan namin mag exit sa Kalibo Airport gayung taga Luzon daw kami (Hahaha!). So sabi ko kay misis "pakita mo ang OEC mo" (OFW kasi siya) so pinakita ni misis (nalimutan nya kasi ipakita haha), ayun di na umimik ang Immigration Officer. . Napansin ko lang ha, bakit pahirapan sa pag labas ng bansa ang mga Pinoy? Bakit yung mga karatig bansa natin parang ang dali lang lumipad ng mga citizen nila. 🤔
Hahhaa only RE ASSIGN?? dapat pati yang Manager or HEAD ng mga Immigration officer PALITAN din dapat makarating kay IDOL SENATOR RAFFY TULFO lahat ng mga immigration big boss NAGTATAKIPAN lang dapat siguro tangalin din
Too lenient for all the inconveniences caused the traveler. Some BI employees love to power trip. Employees should be vetted at all times and not only because they know someone inside which cannot be denied.
This is disgusting. Reassigned!? That person should be sacked! Seems like BI is not sincere at all with their apology and not doing any real remediation at all
Hindi po ba recorded ang conversation ng BI at passenger para sa proteksyon ng parehas na party at para ma-monitor ng executives ang nangyayari sa ground nila?
Asking a diploma or yearbook or any proof should not be done during the day of the flight, that should be done during the interview when you applied for the visa . What kind of system is that ?
So what’s gonna happen to the plane ticket that wasn’t used because of the incident? Babayaran ba ng MIA or ng immigration staff na yun ang ticket na nasayang??? inilipat nyo lang ng pwesto eh pero hindi clear kung ano nangyari sa ticket na nasayang!
pinag tripan. abuse of power. sinungaling pa more. he even asked and himself checked for the email from the passengers celfone. thats violation of data privacy law
Kahit ano ano lang hinahanap at mga tanong.gusto lang niyo jan may mag bigay baka wala na kau pera kaya damay damay na ofload niyo agad.pag walang viral hindi naman kayo gagawa ng action.
The BI officer should be promoted and not reassigned. She's doing a good job. That lady was asked in random as most immigration usually do in routine check of passengers. Asking irrelevant question is necessary to check whether one is lying or not.
Matagal na issue yan. Wag kase lahatin ang pinaghihigpitan. Yung mga kaduda dudang mahuhuman traffic lang talaga ang gisahin. Yung mga normal travellers wag ng abalahin, kung kumpleto naman ang documents
Yung "normal travellers" kasi, pinahihirapan para magbigay ng pampadulaa. Lumang modus na yan. Yung human trafficking, bakit daming nakakalusot? NAGBABAYAD kasi.
Hindi raw sya nagtanong tungkol sa yearbook. So you mean nagsisinungaling ang nag complain??? LoLs! Nilipat lang? Hahaha… Kaya worst airport dahil sa style na bulok eh.
Ganyan yan mga officer yun kasama ko matagal sa saudi d nakakauwi lagi kya d madyo aware sa politics. Tinanong cnu mayor nila at pagdi cya makasagot d cya papaalisin.
hehehehe putek na yan... oo nga noh graduate ng college yung mga empleyado ng NAIa pero w0w bat ganun? tsk tsk nakakahiya na NAIA... yung mga boss parang wala sila pakealam na paulit ulit nlng ang isyo sa NAIA... anu bayan... sana nmn magkaroon ng konting pagbabago sa NAIA...
Pls. Give Consideration to Philippines tourist , immigration. People need protection decent jobs good salary,from government agencies., private firms.For Filipinos at Philippines and abroad. What do you think fellowmen?Thanks for concerns.
Immigration department officials should be concern for people coming in, not passengers going out. For as long that they have all their documents presented, there should be no problem.
SENATE eto na ang worth it na investigation plssss! Make them accountable, sana pag proven they are require to reimburse rebooking expense, ewan ko na lang pag dipa magtino. Its time for them to know how it feels to be under that traumatic interview. BI your highness, i think you should suspend atleast a week or pay those rebooking expenses.
If you caused someone to miss their flight with no real evidence then you should be responsible for the ticket. While we appreciate you doing your job for everyone's safety if it becomes unreasonable, and power tripping..
Everyone should wear a Body Cam to record all conversation. Grabe kayo, palabasin pang sinungaling taong nagrereklamo.
WTH. Let that BI pay for the plane rebooking fee and missed hotel accommodation.
Completely agree, this way that person will hopefully learn a lesson.
This is my thought precisely. Have the BI officer refund the extra expenses incurred by the traveller.
Yes, you acknowledge there was a mistake or mishandling of the situation that caused the passenger her flight -- dapat lang bayaran nila yung nagastos sa kapalpakan nila.
The BI officer should be FIRED for abuse of power! Gusto lang ng LAGAY Officer kaya nya hino-hold pasahero!
As they should! No apology could even compare to the loss of time & money they’ve done to ‘do’ their job.
I do believe that those incidents of harassment really happens in the B/Immigration, because my son experienced the same fate in one of the Immigration
Officers in NAIA, Terminal 2 more than a year ago, who asked unnecessary documents. But when my son complied to all the documents being asked, he (Immig. Off.) did not even bother to look at it & just let him go. Can you imagine the trauma that it might bring to any passenger who were victims? That kind of employe should be subject for investigation & outright dismissal, if found guilty! Disgusting! 😡
We appreciate feedback but we will only take action if it becomes viral and gain huge public traction! That’s what Ms. Sandoval should be saying!
You mean traction...not contraction.
Should it be attraction? To gain huge public attraction.....
Lol
@@aerollove1938 No. Public traction meaning drawing attention or gaining more publicity.
Attraction is not the right term, grammatically incorrect when use in this sense.
so sad how they refuse to fire and hold the scum of an employee unaccountable for his actions and lack of professionalism. rotten eggs the whole lot of them
REASSIGNED?! SERIOUSLY?!!!!! NAKAKAHIYANG PILIPINAS
Pag nakalimutan na ng masa ibabalik rin yan sa pwesto
Backer system = no justice
Baka Malakas Ang Padrino...Bulok n sistema kaya Mabubulok lahat.
This will not be the last kasi ang papalit will do the same thing
Baka type the officer ang babae kaya maraming tanong
I would get the idea why some of these officers feel the need to intimidate some travelers but prolonging their stress for no reason that causes delays and cancellations, they need to realize invested time and money are no joke
That’s one way of forcing you to give in and give bribes ,it’s too vulgar if they will say give me $ and you will be out of here in no time
They are jealous what else.
Bringing a College Diploma or any School Achievement document is a red flag in Canadian border if you are a tourist. Because they will question why you are bringing this type of document if you are just a tourist. For them, it seems you have other plans than just being a tourist. I know because I've seen that in a Canadian security border show where a Filipina was denied entry because she has School and Work documents with her even if she will just be a tourist.
C O R R E C T!!!!!!!!!!
Only in the Philippines folks 😂only in the Philippines🇵🇭
PADULAS lang gusto ng mga buwaya sa NAIA after laglag bala, ngayon laglag pasahero
Correct.
Bakit naman niya kasi ipinakita ang mga papel na hindi naman hinihingi ng Canadian Immigration
But the difficulty here is, it's the immigration officer's word against the passenger's. Passengers should be allowed to record/video the interview so that we have solid evidence in case the immigration officer is not following their procedure. Especially since the BI will not compensate the offloaded passenger unless their investigation reveals that there is indeed violation of their procedures by the immigration officer. Passengers should have a fighting chance to prove our cause, because this is serious, there is money involved and not all of us can afford to just rebook our tickets. BI should think about this. Are they not travelers themselves? Maybe they dont experience this kasi kapag sila nagtravel papalagpasin lang nila kasamahan nila. They seem to have no consideration, no empathy for the plight of passengers.
Yes, its should be recorded. Dapat may recorder sila. It can also be used to solve crime. Kung wala naman silang ginagawang mali, why not. Its also for their protection. Its protection for both side
I dont any law forbidding citizens on recording during interview. The law says we cant vlog if its causing delay or distraction.
@@pamayawat Anti wiretapping law, dear.
@@jamiekatesalcedo6301 Dear, the conversation between an Immigration Officer is NOT a considered private conversation. Information gathered from the interview is recorded as a government record. That law protects private conversations. In this situation, Im saying the traveller can record the convo since its the Travellers information discussed. So I dont get how this law applies.
@@pamayawat Thanks for the info. Gusto ko din malaman actually
I’m glad this issue came out. So many Filipinos being silent about how immigration in the Philippines treat the Filipino people, asking stupid questions is not part of traveling as long as you have valid documents and return ticket. Why making it hard? It’s so unprofessional and disappointing. I wish they also friendly and nice when you greet them good morning . Most immigration officers in the Philippines are grumpy and also moody . Like what’s wrong with you! 🙄
Talk to foreigners and you will be even more shocked.
Moody walang kita..mga buwaya
True! I have bad experience of them and I almost missed up my flight 1 hour of interview which looks like I'm the only passenger and she also ask how much money I have in my bank account can I see it on the phone I just said I don't do online transactions. She also ask title of the land, my educational background and experience.a lot more I felt like prisoner on trial and same time under estimated the way they cater us..like they hate there jobs!
Immigration in the PI is the best as long you are not a suspicious character, more so they have to protect the departing passengers from possible harm as one is helpless once in the air. Irrelevant question is necessary to catch if one is lying or not.
@@juniortulo3823 protection with year book? after you buy an expensive ticket? They should know how to profile passengers mere assumption is bias they are destroying the image and the economy of the country. To travel is your right and privilege.
Kung trafficking, madaling ilusot dyan pero sa legit na travellers, daming kuskos balungos to the point na ma miss ang plane.
Tama .yung anak ko 3 beses na offload papuntang dubai.mahal pa naman ang tiket mga tax n binayan sa imigration d n kinuba ng anak ko dami daw pasikot sikot bago makubaha yung pera nya.kaya nàkakadala.
Wow reassigned lang? Pero pag ordinary na pinoy magkamali sa sagot sa tanong denied agad. Bat di rin i deny ang job sa mga ganyan? 😂😂😂
May backer eh, ano pa aasahan mong hustisya diyan hahaha 😂😂😂
Naunahan mo lang ako to say that. If you have the means bro, i-post mo rin sa socmed re the recent development..."REASSIGNED LANG" @#$%*&₩¥¥£€!!!😡😡😡. Salamat sa pag raise ng issue👍
Its not having a backer but a Mafia style of extorting money, once the person was pressured and put to a shameful manner 😯😡😡
Nakakalungkot maging Filipino dahil kababayan natin ang mismong nagpapahirap satin
Correct!
Agree
Exactly. Pag nangyari yan sa inyo just get their names and make a complain. To prevent human tracficking eh impertenente naman mga tanong nila. They need to know exactly ang mga documents na kelangan ng bawat tao na umaalis specially ofw at mga immigrants di yon kung ano ano ang pinapagawa. Harassing and abusing people is a no no bullying yan
BI should be the ones who will pay cancellation and rebooking fees incase passengers miss their flights due to unecessary questioning. Passengers should also be allowed to record conversations for their sake incase BI officers deny such questions
Totoo to, Miss. I am also planning to travel to Thailand. Pero natatajot na tuloy ako kase baka sayang lang money na naipon ko. 😭
Kudos for still raising this issue. Media is really a big help to Filipinos
Yes
If the media is not bias. There are instances wherein they mess up the issue like the Bantag case. In the interview DG Bantag said, hinihintay niya ang desisyon ng mahal na pangulo pero ang report ng media e umaasa siyang mabalik sa Bucor. Ingat po kayo sa media kasi hindi na kayo good example sa usaping journalism sa school. Kulang sa journalism ethics ang media ngayon. You are being observed and so please do give due respect in reporting the truth.
If not for the incurred media attention,the incident would have gone un noticed ..but the abusive BI officer was said to have been dismissed but now the truth shows that the offender was just reassigned
She's not even sorry about it. No apology whatsoever, veiled or otherwise. You have no reason to hold any passenger from leaving if there's no Hold Departure Order issued against them. If you want to go after human traffickers, I don't think you'll find them in NAIA. We still have a law in this country that protects people's rights. Hindi mangyayari to kung si #PRRD pa ang presidente
Apologizing would recognize a mistake was made so she won’t
Well said.
Wala bang na-offload sa panahon ni PRRD dahil sa abusadong BI officer?
Dapat dyan kasuhan yung BI officer. It's clearly abuse of authority.
This Immigration Officers are not professionals. Ang layo pa talaga nang Pilipinas sa mga neighboring Asian countries. So ano naman kaya masasabi ng Secretary of Tourism and si Magellan?
pero graduate yan sila... tsk tsk...
For sure wla speechless mga yan
Seperate process: The government should propose to eliminate a long check at the airport and bring a pre-check or pre-adjudicate to the traveler (only for traveler have plenty of necessary checking or high risk) before the travel date and in a different place. This will eliminate a long line and miss the travelers' flight. Once the traveler had the pre-check interview before the flight date, the immigration should enter the information at their system and a stamp at the traveler's passport that they had been check and no other necessary check except verifying the traveler's identity.
These BIs should shoulder the expenses of the person they offloaded esp. If proven that the passenger is a real traveler. It will lessen these offloading incidents.
Make all interview recorded.
That immigration officer should have been fired not reassigned!
Bureau of Incompetence
Dapat yun ipangalan sa kanila
They should kick out that officer Abdula. He’s way of unprofessionalism is a pure shame to the Immigration.
These officers need serious training or reeducation. The problem is the BI management only acts when something happens. For once can the bureau be proactive…just saying.
Why reassign? Should be fire!!!
Wow! Only shows tolerated ang kabalastugan sa NAIA ...sarap niyong murahin😊
The problem is OFFLOADING! How do you counter that?
This is not the only offloading case due to BIs over questioning. If you google and check youtubes, a lot of filipinos voiced out their offloading experienced. Philippines is becoming like North Korea. As long as a passenger has valid passport, plane ticket and no hold departure order the passenger should be able to leave country without questions.
Its ashamed. I will tell my man about recent theft scheme from passengers and he will be extra careful. Padangug ra tuy gipangita para i release nila si passenger
Why didn't ANC interview the immigration officer to know his side of the story, not the spokes person? Is the Phil. Immigration hiding the truth? Is the immigration protecting their interview officer? That officer should be charged for passenger harassment for asking inappropriate and irrelevant questions that led to missing the passengers flight. He should also pay the passenger for missing the flight. Philippine airport is notorious in crime. First was the inserting dollar bill inside the passport as bribe, then the "planting bullet in the baggage" of travellers/passenger. Now the tediously harassing questions.
In short it was all power tripping!!
Maganda siguro may voice at video recorder ang interview room na walang control ang mga nagiinterview para hindi nila madelete yung narecord na conversation.
Allow the passengers to videotape every encounter with the BI as evidence in any confrontation. Minimize forms. If the passport has enough information, no need to enter the information again. It’s such a stupid and wasteful thing to do
ang tagal na nilang ganyan, sa totoo lang kung totoong illegal ang gagawin eh nakakalusot, dami nga magnanakaw dyan diba. pero yung mga legit ang pakay sila pa yung mga na-aabala. Share nyo lahat ng experience nyo para maging aware at magkaroon ng measure dyan, tagal ng issue yan buti nakarating na sa mainstream,.
So long line for our airport going abroad hope n pray that will b given solutions for more immigration personnel to be assigned please po! How can we inspire tourist of this kind of problem.
Can they get sued ? Stop apologising with human traffic. It's up to the person if the person wants to leave. You can only advise. Restricting people's freedom to travel is illegal internationally. It's called Freedom of movement get the law printed and sue them internationally against human rights in case they offload you.
Ang tinatanong kung required ba.? Di sinasagot
All BI interviews should be done with video/audio recording para hindi sila mag power trip at gawa2 ng question.
Yes, tulad ng call center calls. As long as aware yung both parties sa recording.
Reassignment? Why not removed?
Reporter forgot a crucial question: How will the passenger get reimbursed for the missed flight, as this incident is clearly not within the scope of DOJ's Memorandum Circular 036?
Went home last month, this immigration officer was so intimidating , bcoz I was kinda lost due to my first time to go back home. He was so irritated by me and gave me an attitude. . They need to get their act together . I’m a balikbayan, I can only imagine the people that just wants to tour abroad and being treated like a criminal. They act like their above the law…
So, hindi na mananagot sa nasayang na ticket? Di lang iisang daan ang halaga nun.
strict airport protocol = sheer incompetence
IO's in the Philippines masyadong powertrip
Mga kabayan kong mag abroad pag nasa BI na kayo make it sure na ma record ninyo lahat na sinasabi ng officer. If bawal still do it secretly para may pruyba po kayo.
Kulang sa lagay yung na-offload na pasahero.
Parang bumabalik na uli ang kalakaran sa immigration noong ML ni Apo Lakay.
Dapat ibalik ng IO ang gastos ng pasahero at moral damages sa pagkaka offload niya
Reassignment isn’t the solution to the problem/irregularity as the ‘bad apple’ is still in the system.
Modus iyan ALAM niyo na medjo walang kita sa panahon ni TANDA, hahahhah... Hindi kasi nag PADULAS iyan kaya pinahaba ang Interrogation, maganda siguro i suggest na magkaroon ng CCTV sa room/office para ma Review ang mga irrelevant na questions, o kaya payagan ang ini interrogate na ma record ang ginagawa ng OFFICER para DAPAT tanggal agad sa Trabaho... Ang Problema lang kasi, ang mga iyan ay may ninong iyan sa loob na matataas at dinidefensahan pa kasi Padrenohan iyan kaya nakapasok bukod sa minimum qualification ...
pansin ko walang issue gnyn nung time ni duterte
Tama ka dyan pera pera lang yan meron dyan barya tinatalo pa madalit sa bi pataygutom
Ireasign lang yung immigration officer involved dito? Dapat dyan sibakin nang hindi na pamamarisan.
They should do one week interview before the passenger flight and ask for additional requirements if it's necessary. Para Hindi abala and no more questions ask na. Kainis lang hassle masyado. Yong ibang nationalities in and out sa ating bansa.
They should post those requirements na hahanapin nila sa mga passengers for the interview. Hindi ung on the spot ka hahanapan ng kung ano-ano (yearbook, BC etc.) na obviously Naman Hindi mo dala-dala because those are irrelevant sa pag-travel mo.
Why there’s no punishment for people like this they should be fired or maybe all of them are working together para mangkikil mang scam tapos hati hati sela
You cant do that here in England kulong ka pag bigyan mo sila ng pera they dont accept bribe...sana all sa pinas
The BI head covers up for their employee... They are all the same. I had the experience wayback 2021 during my first travel. The Consulate General called their office to intercede in my behalf BUT, the head intentionally did not answer the call. Another thing, they keep on using the so called "Human Trafficking" issue as alibi to justify their nonsensical offloading scheme. They dont even respond to your messages whenever they were messaged online.
Dapat yong ginagawa ng immigration officer parang sa call center. Dapat ganito "Sir/Maam yong sagot po ninyo ay recorded". Dapat may protocol na sinusunod, di yong parang mga Poncio Pilato kung magtanong na kung ano lang gusto itanong.
Denied the yearbook issue? Let her forego lie dtector test if she wont then she is lying.
Passengers experiencing inconvenience from airport personels should be allowed to record conversations, from their cellphones, for evedence.
Yes, as long aa both parties are aware that the recording os being done.
It seems a lot of malpractice and unethical activities in the Philippine airport and immigration have again recently become widespread and slowly becoming the norm. Another way to put the country in the “hall of shame”. Im just wondering what corrective actions the government have for these situations? and if so, are they implemented strictly. Imagine being opressed, harassed, and unjustly treated by your own fellow citizen? These unethical activities going around the airport are ridiculous and truly sickening.
i think kulang cguro sa padulas........
How about the cost of the ticket
1st Experience: Noong June 2012 na interview din ako ng Immigration Officer noon sa NAIA. Bibisitahin ko kasi ang GF (now wife) ko sa Singapore noon. Ininterview din ako ng Immigration Officer, may mga tanong gaya ng ano ang trabaho ko (sagot ko: sabi ko family business), bakit 1 month ako sa Singapore (sabi ko: para masulit ang bakasyon kasi matagal na kaming di nagkikita), magkano ang dala kong pera (sagot ko: xx,xxx PHP + credit card), perstime ko ba mag travel (sagotko: opo) at iba pa na nalimutan ko na. Kala ko noon di ako aabot sa oras kasi malapit ng magsara ang gate. Buti nalang pinayagan akong bumiyahe nung lalaking immigration officer, kaya ayun takbo ako papasok ng gate. Grabeng kaba ko nun kala ko maiiwan talaga ako ng eroplano hehe!
.
2nd Experience: Nagbakasyon kami ni misis sa Pinas ng 2014, tapos namin sa Tarlac ay dumiretso kami sa Boracay. Bale 1 week kami sa boracay. Tapos nung babalik na kami ng Singapore ni misis ay tinanong siya ng Immigration Officer sa Kalibo Airport, bakit daw naisipan namin mag exit sa Kalibo Airport gayung taga Luzon daw kami (Hahaha!). So sabi ko kay misis "pakita mo ang OEC mo" (OFW kasi siya) so pinakita ni misis (nalimutan nya kasi ipakita haha), ayun di na umimik ang Immigration Officer.
.
Napansin ko lang ha, bakit pahirapan sa pag labas ng bansa ang mga Pinoy? Bakit yung mga karatig bansa natin parang ang dali lang lumipad ng mga citizen nila. 🤔
It seems you’re intelligent and smart Dana
Why is this happening to NAIA airport?????
Hahhaa only RE ASSIGN?? dapat pati yang Manager or HEAD ng mga Immigration officer PALITAN din dapat makarating kay IDOL SENATOR RAFFY TULFO lahat ng mga immigration big boss NAGTATAKIPAN lang dapat siguro tangalin din
Only reassigned? Dapat tinanggal na yan..
Nakakahiya ang pinas, binibiktima mga kawawang pasahero! 😢🇺🇸
Sandoval is Incompetent
Exactly puro nalang aaaa eee. She sounds like denying the allegations and has an arrogant aura.
Reassigned? That incompetent BI person should be made to pay reparations to the aggrieved party
Matagal yan huwag nyo ng pagtakpan eh gawain naman nyo yn.
Too lenient for all the inconveniences caused the traveler. Some BI employees love to power trip. Employees should be vetted at all times and not only because they know someone inside which cannot be denied.
isama nyo narin ang slumbook with question "what is love" love is like a rosary that full of mystery
wow ! eassigned lang malakas ata ang backer
This is disgusting. Reassigned!? That person should be sacked! Seems like BI is not sincere at all with their apology and not doing any real remediation at all
Wondering why they cannot fire those incompetent officers. Maybe there's indeed a syndicate inside.
Hindi po ba recorded ang conversation ng BI at passenger para sa proteksyon ng parehas na party at para ma-monitor ng executives ang nangyayari sa ground nila?
Asking a diploma or yearbook or any proof should not be done during the day of the flight, that should be done during the interview when you applied for the visa . What kind of system is that ?
Free of charge correct? No fees if youre going to a website talking about the e card
Nako jusko pag ito nangyari samin pag nag abroad kami, mag ska-skandalo talaga ako sa airport until sila magbayad ng rebooking ko. -_-
Sana magkaroon rin ng batas na pagkakulong pra sa mga nagbibigay ng padulas.
So what’s gonna happen to the plane ticket that wasn’t used because of the incident? Babayaran ba ng MIA or ng immigration staff na yun ang ticket na nasayang??? inilipat nyo lang ng pwesto eh pero hindi clear kung ano nangyari sa ticket na nasayang!
pinag tripan. abuse of power. sinungaling pa more. he even asked and himself checked for the email from the passengers celfone. thats violation of data privacy law
Kahit ano ano lang hinahanap at mga tanong.gusto lang niyo jan may mag bigay baka wala na kau pera kaya damay damay na ofload niyo agad.pag walang viral hindi naman kayo gagawa ng action.
Bureau of Intimidation😂
The BI officer should be promoted and not reassigned. She's doing a good job. That lady was asked in random as most immigration usually do in routine check of passengers.
Asking irrelevant question is necessary to check whether one is lying or not.
1:35 It means interested kayo lahat sa nagtatravel?kasi sa dami pa namang na offload niyo.😂for short inggit nga kayo😂😂
Matagal na issue yan. Wag kase lahatin ang pinaghihigpitan. Yung mga kaduda dudang mahuhuman traffic lang talaga ang gisahin. Yung mga normal travellers wag ng abalahin, kung kumpleto naman ang documents
Ma'am nag subscribe po ako sa channel nyo po...
extra modus po nila yan sa NAIA... gisahin tapos kikilan... extra po nila yan siguro...
Yung "normal travellers" kasi, pinahihirapan para magbigay ng pampadulaa. Lumang modus na yan.
Yung human trafficking, bakit daming nakakalusot? NAGBABAYAD kasi.
Hindi raw sya nagtanong tungkol sa yearbook. So you mean nagsisinungaling ang nag complain??? LoLs!
Nilipat lang? Hahaha…
Kaya worst airport dahil sa style na bulok eh.
Spill over yan ng hearing sa senado. Yung nakalusot na chartered plane.
Next time the travelers should bring with them the Transcript of Records.
They have to provide seminars to this immigration officer. They dnt know how hard to travel in Philippines
Ganyan yan mga officer yun kasama ko matagal sa saudi d nakakauwi lagi kya d madyo aware sa politics. Tinanong cnu mayor nila at pagdi cya makasagot d cya papaalisin.
Lol.... Powertrip lang kamo talaga, bakit sa foreigner di kayo mahigpit
Why he was reassigned??? He should be suspended and be named. Why he can't answers this allegations himself?
Partida mga graduate pa yang mga yan ng college, pero kung umasta daig pa ng tambay.
hehehehe putek na yan... oo nga noh graduate ng college yung mga empleyado ng NAIa pero w0w bat ganun? tsk tsk nakakahiya na NAIA... yung mga boss parang wala sila pakealam na paulit ulit nlng ang isyo sa NAIA... anu bayan... sana nmn magkaroon ng konting pagbabago sa NAIA...
@@niceonerandomvideos bingi gobyerno natin sa mga ganitong isyo
@@scoutbaudelaire7873 nakakalungkot na katotohanan.... tsk tsk wat to do... si Lord na bahala sa kanila....
pakisuspend nga, sabihin mo seminar ka muna. Iba tlga paggovernment employee, protektado ng backer
Pls. Give Consideration to Philippines tourist , immigration. People need protection decent jobs good salary,from government agencies., private firms.For Filipinos at Philippines and abroad. What do you think fellowmen?Thanks for concerns.
BI how will you compensate the inconvenience your people have done to the passenger?
He/She should be fired.
Pretty sure this is not the first time.
Why do you need your country's own immigration to travel? I'm confused. It thought you go through immigration of the country you're traveling to?
Ready mga phone lagi at video mga anomaly ng airport post sa social media .
Immigration department officials should be concern for people coming in, not passengers going out. For as long that they have all their documents presented, there should be no problem.
2:39 no we did not. It's not our part our job. Thank you
SENATE eto na ang worth it na investigation plssss! Make them accountable, sana pag proven they are require to reimburse rebooking expense, ewan ko na lang pag dipa magtino.
Its time for them to know how it feels to be under that traumatic interview.
BI your highness, i think you should suspend atleast a week or pay those rebooking expenses.
Only in the Philippines.
of course he will deny his unprofessionalism and inefficiency..
If you caused someone to miss their flight with no real evidence then you should be responsible for the ticket. While we appreciate you doing your job for everyone's safety if it becomes unreasonable, and power tripping..