@@nidaeshaque Some people and their convictions walaahi are dangerous, they are leading people ashtray and desperation with their comments. Its crazy how he makes such bold claims witouth any evidence. Its just a statement. Baffling walaahi.
I just find this out :( so many ways Allah swt made worship easy for us and we are losing those avenue due to people being negligent about sunnah and not teaching each other.
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
Jazak Allah Khair brother. I used to wipe my shoes when at work to perform my wudu however I was worried that if that wasn't acceptable I would be be grave danger of my all my years of Salah not being valid. But this has given me hope insha'Allah that this one way of Allah SWT and huzur saw making it easy for us to follow Islam. Subhan Allah
Asalaam alaikum and jazakallahu khayr for all these videos they help so much alhamdulillah. Could you please do one on how to perform witr prayer ASAP ? May Allah reward you all in dunya and akhirah ameen
Assalaamu-alaikum Dear brother and producer of video...would you kindly mention according to which school of thought your information is from..I.e. Hanafi,Maliki,Hanbali,Shafi.(.A.R) JazakAllah
How to wipe over socks in wudu The way in which one wipes over them is to put one’s wet fingers on the toes then pass them over the feet to the shin; the right foot should be wiped with the right hand and the left foot with the left hand. The fingers should be spread when wiping and it should not be repeated. (See al-Mulakhkhas al-Fiqhi by al-Fawzan, 1/43). Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah. If we assume that he cannot use one of his hands, then he should start with the right before the left. Many people wipe the right foot with both hands then the left foot with both hands, but there is no basis for this as far as I know. No matter how it is done, wiping the top of the slipper (or sock) is sufficient but what we have said here is best.” (See Fatawa al-Marah al-Muslimah, vol. 1, p. 250) You should not wipe the sides or back of the sock because there is no report concerning that. Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin said: “Someone may say that it is the bottom of the slipper or sock that should be wiped, because this is what is in contact with dust and dirt. But if we think about it we will see that wiping the top of the sock is what makes sense, because this wiping is not for the purpose of cleaning, rather it is an act of worship; if we were to wipe the bottom of the sock that would make it more dirty.” And Allah knows best. (See al-Sharh al-Mumti’ by Ibn ‘Uthaymin, vol. 1, p. 213)
Jazakom Allah khyran. Would you kindly share the evidence for the permissibility to wipe the sole of shoes/socks? All that I've come across is instructing us to wipe over only.
Just one question. If I make wudu then put my socks on and then for some reason I take them out and put them back on does it still count as pure or no?
No,...you need to perform wudu again without socks, put them on after and when wudu is invalidated/broke, you can wipe then onwards. But once you take them off, you have to perform wudu.
If u have Maken the wudu then put socks and then remove it when ur in the state of wudu then brother ur wudu is not broken at all remove and wear socks in the state of wudu as much as u want but if u wore socks after doing wudu and then after wearing socks ur wudu is broken then u 've 24 hours if ur a resident and 72 hours if ur a traveller to wipe over it but if after wiping ur put off your socks ur wudu will be broken
I have fungal infections in both of feet toes (means - in between the last and second last finger). And i wear cotton socks. So can i refresh my wudu by wiping over fabric socks. Becoz i use water everytime - the infection is growing. Please guide Jazaak Allah min khair.
@Sarfaraz I am not biased against any one. I am against those who called themselves Ahle-hadees or salafis not because they have different opinion but purely because they are creating fitnah worldwide. You mention Imam Hambal that he has opinion socks should be thick and can walk wearing it. Simple question: how thick. define the word 'thick' here and how much walk. when you try to explore these two questions you will come to believe me
Thick means the socks are not transparent, not see through, when you wipe over them you don't feel the water on your skin, they don't have holes, they're covering the feet up to the ankles and they're clean of course.
@@madiallo3366 it is your imagination of a thick socks. I have never seen socks which are transparent!!! In fiqh or law every thing is defined. Already thick socks are also defined by fuqah based on sahabah practice not based on your own thinking.
@@smartbear9598 Well, usually people don't see their brains too but it doesn't mean that they don't exist - I have seen transparent socks. I'm not innocent of Fiqh as you may imagine. You're likely in your imagination too otherwise show us the textual evidence of the definition you're implying from the Sahabah, not that of the Fuqaha.
@@madiallo3366 you will find the evidences/definition of thick socks from practice of sahabah as mentioned in my first comment on this video about a month ago. Islam is easy but that does not mean you change it according to your convenience. Practice of wiping over cotton socks started sometimes around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permissible to make masah over cotton. This practice is reported and criticized by imam Nawawi (who compiled Riyadhussaliheen)
I thought the socks had to have certain requirements? like being able to walk in them for a certain amount of miles without wearing out. Or that they have to be waterproof.
@@SMonfyr730 Only on leather socks not on cotton socks. This condition is not in hanafi fiqh rather all fiqh. There is no sahih hadees to perform masah on cotton socks rather all are zaeef. The practice to perform masah on cotton socks started somewhere around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permitted. Even the ahlehadees scholars around 70 years ago were having the same opinion that it is only allowed on leather socks. Only modern ahlehadees scholars are saying it is permitted and even not all of them like Shaykh safiurrehman Mubarakpuri. About sahabah : some sahabah used to perform masah on jurab but but and but you should know about their jurab. Their jurab were used to be of two types: 1. Muna'alain (cotton socks with leather attached to sole part) 2. Mujallidain. Cotton socks with leather attached to the sole part and also covered some other part of upper side. Get knowledge and don't mislead.
as long as they cover above the ankles. you can wipe. The hanafis and some shafiis feel different. But dont worry about them. islam is easy. alhamdulila
@@issaibnaziz9122 islam is easy but that doesn't imply you change it according to your convenience. Fuqha have laid conditions on performing masah over socks keeping in mind the practice of sahabah. They did not put conditions arbitrarily. The so called ahlehadees have changed Islam in last 150 years be it the invention of 8 rakaat taraweeh, wiping over cotton socks, physical joining of feet during Slah and many more. One prophecy about qayamat: deviant scholars will emerge who will mislead the people with their ilm. So it is wise to believe and follow the scholar of early period who got knowledge directly from sahabah, tabaeen and tabe-Tabaeens.
Do i have to do a complete wuduk(washing feet) if in between i took a piss or no. 4? And i read once u take off ur socks, u're not able to wipe over the socks anymore. U have to make a full wuduk once again. 😊
Does wiping over socks contradict the Qur’an’s instructions for wudu in verse 5:6? The Qur’an provides clear instructions for performing wudu in Surah Al-Ma’idah, 5:6, which specifically mentions washing the feet up to the ankles as part of the ablution process. It would make it easier wiping over the socks but can you please elaborate, because to me it seems that this verse was explicit and hadiths cannot alter what has been revealed in the Qur’an, as the commandments of Allah are unchangeable.
This narration was From Ali R. about this that" in the religion was based on a penis we will give more priority to wipe both upper and lower side. But because prophet Muhammad ﷺ wipe over feet it is the actual Sunnah ❤️
@@AbuMoosaa sorry my brother . Are you saying not to follow a madhab ? If you look within our tradition. ALL the traditional scholars followed a madhab . Imam Nawowi Ibn Hajar Ibn Al Jawzi Etc Even amongst the later contemporary scholars Ibn Taymiya may Allah subhantallah be please with him followed the hanbali madhab.
It's not a Madhad, it's an established and well known Sunnah - if you read books of Hadith about purification/Wudu, you'll see all the details i authentic narrations.
Wuzu is only permissible on Leather socks which are thick socks which differentiates from regular thin socks which we wear daily and wuzu doesn't happen on that.
@Sarfaraz: Yes I am Hanafi and Deobandi. In first impression you appear to disagree with me and then finally agreed with me. Studdents of Imam Abu hanifah may have different opinion but we follow the correct opinion no if it is came from abu hanifah or his students. I am really do not know about the opinion of his students in this matter but you should also mention the basis of their opinion. Their opinion can not be taken and practiced just because they are students of Imam there should be evidence in support of their opinion. You mention that Imam Abu Hinafah changed his view. This is utterly wrong and seems to be a fabricated story assoicated with him (You should provide authenticity of this change of view). For the sake argument I assume for a while that he changed his opinion still we are not entitled to follow him in this matter until and unless there are evidences in the support of his 'new opinion'. We do not follow him in fiqh just becuase he is saying we follow him because he put evidence and logical conclusion for his opinion.
@@aliyahp9969 no. Whether you are resident or a traveller you can. The Prophet would wipe whilst resident also. Resident = 24 hours; Traveller = 72 hours
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
There is no evidence to support wiping the bottom of the socks. Ali mentioned that if the religion was based on intellect alone it would have made more sense to wipe the bottom of the socks. So great video, but where is the evidence for wiping the bottom?
Only on leather socks not on cotton socks. This condition is not in hanafi fiqh rather all fiqh. There is no sahih hadees to perform masah on cotton socks rather all are zaeef. The practice to perform masah on cotton socks started somewhere around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permitted. Even the ahlehadees scholars around 70 years ago were having the same opinion that it is only allowed on leather socks. Only modern ahlehadees scholars are saying it is permitted and even not all of them like Shaykh safiurrehman Mubarakpuri. About sahabah : some sahabah used to perform masah on jurab but but and but you should know about their jurab. Their jurab were used to be of two types: 1. Muna'alain (cotton socks with leather attached to sole part) 2. Mujallidain. Cotton socks with leather attached to the sole part and also covered some other part of upper side. Get knowledge and don't mislead.
@@smartbear9598 Al Awzai, Sufyan At Thari and many more scholars bought proof of wiping over whatever is considered a sock or shoe regardless of the material. You on here speaking from desires. It is best to just keep quiet sir.
@@esaabdullah2762 not true. You must know what type of socks were worn in those days. Either leather socks or juran with leather attached to it used to worn. All sahih Hadith about socks made of leather (khuffain). Only 3 Hadith are there in which jurab is mentioned and all those are weak of worst nature. Imam Muslim heavily criticised those weak ahadith.
@@syedzubair7122 Those methods still will not cleanse your soul, sins are still being committed, by countless people. Again proving obligatory requirements set forth in Islam are useless. Live in accordance to truth, not by rituals and superstitions.
@@pavanSingh-ts5ymProphet of Allah SAW said every son of Adam is a sinner. And the best of sinners are those who repent. We cannot be completely sinless but try our best to stay away and if commit then repent and make an intent not to repeat
Salah cleanses the soul if it's established properly ... If our soul is not getting cleansed even after regular prayers we need to reflect on the condition of our salah
@Sarfaraz You should know that khuffain means leather socks jurabian means cotton socks. all these hadees you mentioned either does not mention khuff/jurab just simply mentions masah that does not imply they can be taken as such. Moreover, all such hadees where jurab is mentioned are weak. You mentione Imam Ibne Taymiyah: do not mention what he said or what was his opinion just simply provide the basis of his opinion corrobarated with the practice of salaf. Imam Ibne Taymiyah also has opinion/fatwa that Taraweeh is 20 rakaat but here you so-called Ahle-hadees/salafis do not bother his opinion and current fitnah of salfiyah are adamant that Taraweeh is only 8 rakaat. Your 'Big Scholar' Albani once said that praying 20 rakaat is sinful bid'at (Astaghfirullah). Imam ibne Taymiyah also consider Taweez (Amulets) are allowed (you find it in the same book you mentioned)
No it's not wrong, all you need is to make sure you're in a state of Wudu before wearing the socks then can wipe over them until the time indicated is reached or you remove them, in sha Allah.
that is not the SUNNAH!! please be careful brothers and sisters... this is not the proper. Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said: “This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
Only on leather socks not on cotton socks. This condition is not in hanafi fiqh rather all fiqh. There is no sahih hadees to perform masah on cotton socks rather all are zaeef. The practice to perform masah on cotton socks started somewhere around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permitted. Even the ahlehadees scholars around 70 years ago were having the same opinion that it is only allowed on leather socks. Only modern ahlehadees scholars are saying it is permitted and even not all of them like Shaykh safiurrehman Mubarakpuri. About sahabah : some sahabah used to perform masah on jurab but but and but you should know about their jurab. Their jurab were used to be of two types: 1. Muna'alain (cotton socks with leather attached to sole part) 2. Mujallidain. Cotton socks with leather attached to the sole part and also covered some other part of upper side. Get knowledge and don't mislead.
This opinion is from some of the schools of thought but it is clear that some of the Sahabah wore socks with holes, socks made of different materials, so all of the conditions that people place on wiping are many times baseless
@@esaabdullah2762 jazakAllah khair, but i have read that the sahaba wiped over thick socks, and the socks they had were not like the thinner socks of today. do you have any sources or anywhere i can read more about what you said?
@@user-kd6nm7yn4s you can refer to fiqh As Sunnah also islamqa Al Awzai and Sufyan Athari held the view of wiping over whatever is considered a sock or shoe. Ibn Hazm at Zahiri also stated that wiping can be done over any sock and it doesn't have to cover the ankles. My dear brothers just because the 4 schools agree on something doesn't always mean it's the haqq. There are scholars who were even greater then the 4. The Prophet didn't put any stipulations on wiping. And Allah Knows best.
Dear brothers Please dont make your prayer useless bcz of ur lazyness. Its easy to remove your cotton socks, please do it and make perfect ablution. With some condition we are allowed to wipe on leather socks(huffah) but not on cotton socks. Prayer is a big deal try to make it perfect
@abbou1218 Shaykh al-Islam [Ibn Taymiyah] said: The difference between socks and khuffayn is that the former are made of wool and the latter are made of leather. It is known that such differences do not have any impact on shar‘i rulings. It makes no difference whether it is made of leather, cotton, linen or wool. By the same token, it makes no difference whether garments worn in ihram are black or white. … The most that can be said is that leather is longer lasting than wool, but this does not affect the ruling, just as it is not affected if the leather is durable. Moreover, it is well-known that the need to wipe over one is the same as the need to wipe over the other. As they are same in terms of the reason and need for wiping, differentiating between them would be differentiating between two similar things, which is contrary to the fairness and common sense that are promoted by the Qur’an and Sunnah, and that with which Allah sent down His Books and sent His Messengers. Those who differentiate between them on the grounds that one is permeable and the other is not has mentioned a difference that does not affect anything. End quote from Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (21/214)
In the Quran surah Al maidah it says wash your feet so what has ibn tahmiyyah got to do with it I thought we talk about authentic hadith not fabricated ones. The Sahabas did wear leather their was no such thing as socks so stick to facts. We have to clarify to follow ibn tahmiyyah or the Sahabas in what they wore. I know with time things has changed but we have to stick with leather socks waterproof.
What's the evidence for wiping on the bottom of the socks? Didn't Ali RA say the religion is based on evidence not intellect that's why we don't wipe on the bottom of the foot.
It’s not allowed to wipe over socks in non of the four madahiebs! Only allowed to do so over leather socks that can stand by themselves and don’t let water in and you could walk on them without them getting damaged and doing so only allowed wiping over the upper part of the leather socks NOT under the socks!!! And you must wear the leather socks directly after finishing your Wudu and then it’s legit to wipe over them later on during other Wudu’s These people are following their desire’s and are clueless about this issue.
you are completely wrong. You should respect the other opinions of the imams. Imagine saying the other schools of thought are following their desires. Rather انت جاهل
I can guarantee that shafi and hanafi madhab are not allowing cloth type socks I don't know about other than two madhabs Probably they might don't allow the socks as socks were not used by early stages of islam
@@ShahnawazKhan-me8mg he said this channel is following their desires. He us getting a taste of his own medicine. Respect other opinions, or you are a jahil
@@abdikadiribrahim3786 I'm sure everyone can understand what is being said, however many such as myself believe this can only be done with thick leather socks not regular socks and definitely not shoes
I removed my comment and apologize to the brother for misunderstanding him. I have tremendous respect for those that are having the opinion that the mash is not allowed on the socks we use in daily life. Thanks for clarifying Saqib
Alhumdullilah, this was informative, especially when at work and you’re on a very short break but need to pray your salah.
You can not change sunnah because of work. Wuduh not valid without washing feet
@@PAK_TV_Channelif Rasoolullaah ﷺ allowed wiping over the sock, then who are you to say otherwise??? Do you know better than him? Fear Allaah
@@PAK_TV_Channel Did you even watch the video?
@@nidaeshaque Some people and their convictions walaahi are dangerous, they are leading people ashtray and desperation with their comments. Its crazy how he makes such bold claims witouth any evidence. Its just a statement. Baffling walaahi.
@@PAK_TV_Channel It can also end up making you mroe dirty to pray barefoot in my experience
I just find this out :( so many ways Allah swt made worship easy for us and we are losing those avenue due to people being negligent about sunnah and not teaching each other.
As a Muslim working in New York City , always moving around , this just makes my life so easy Alhamdulilah
Ma sha Allah this helps a lot alhamduliallah, may Allah make us to follow the beautiful sunnah of our beloved prophet Muhammad SAW ❤
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
“This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
Jazak Allah Khair brother. I used to wipe my shoes when at work to perform my wudu however I was worried that if that wasn't acceptable I would be be grave danger of my all my years of Salah not being valid. But this has given me hope insha'Allah that this one way of Allah SWT and huzur saw making it easy for us to follow Islam. Subhan Allah
Alihamdulillah Robil Alameen. Jazakumullah khaeran fi Duniyah Wal Aqiroh for the video. It's very enlightening.
Love you Qari zakaullah saleem Form Pakistan Kaleemullah Muhammadi.
Nice info, I didn't know that. But I think I'll keep washing my feet every time :) Feels refreshing mashAllah
Yes!!!
Wearing wet socks can also be very uncomfortable...
@@artso1990 you just gotta wipe over it not drench it in water, also the socks should resist the water a lil bit wa allahu alam ❤
@@justanotheruser43 well that's not wudhu then... if the feet's not even wet...
@@artso1990did you even watch the video?
Asalaam alaikum and jazakallahu khayr for all these videos they help so much alhamdulillah.
Could you please do one on how to perform witr prayer ASAP ?
May Allah reward you all in dunya and akhirah ameen
Walaykum Asalam. JazakAllahu khayr for the suggestion.
Here you go.
ua-cam.com/video/05qZ0HwQr4A/v-deo.html
@@greenlanemasjid amazing cant thank u enough jazakallahu khayr!
Jazak Allahu Khayran for this video.
Allahumma barik, very informational video
Jazak Allahu for the video
Thank you for this clarification. I always get funny comments/looks when I'm wiping over my socks
That's why I always make wudu in home when I have to wipe over socks 😂
syukron katsiir, Ustadz
ماشاء اللہ تبارک اللہ عزوجل آمین
Jazakhalla khair. May Allah reward you.
Assalaamu-alaikum Dear brother and producer of video...would you kindly mention according to which school of thought your information is from..I.e. Hanafi,Maliki,Hanbali,Shafi.(.A.R)
JazakAllah
Never talking about this again😂 I talked about this. And all my muslim brothers laughed at me and said to stick to the old ways lol.
Barakallahu fik
Jazaak Allah akhi
God reward you with the best!
Very informative JZKL. Thank you for the upload.
JazakAllahuKhairan!
Great video mashallah!
Can this be applied for while wearing HIJAB as well? like after meeting all the conditions?
Thank you very much sheykh
I have eczema and some time i use cream i wear socks can i do masah?
Shaykh Zakaullah 🤍
Does it have to be leather socks or any.material as long as its halal
How to wipe over socks in wudu
The way in which one wipes over them is to put one’s wet fingers on the toes then pass them over the feet to the shin; the right foot should be wiped with the right hand and the left foot with the left hand. The fingers should be spread when wiping and it should not be repeated. (See al-Mulakhkhas al-Fiqhi by al-Fawzan, 1/43).
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
“This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
If we assume that he cannot use one of his hands, then he should start with the right before the left. Many people wipe the right foot with both hands then the left foot with both hands, but there is no basis for this as far as I know. No matter how it is done, wiping the top of the slipper (or sock) is sufficient but what we have said here is best.” (See Fatawa al-Marah al-Muslimah, vol. 1, p. 250)
You should not wipe the sides or back of the sock because there is no report concerning that.
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin said: “Someone may say that it is the bottom of the slipper or sock that should be wiped, because this is what is in contact with dust and dirt. But if we think about it we will see that wiping the top of the sock is what makes sense, because this wiping is not for the purpose of cleaning, rather it is an act of worship; if we were to wipe the bottom of the sock that would make it more dirty.” And Allah knows best. (See al-Sharh al-Mumti’ by Ibn ‘Uthaymin, vol. 1, p. 213)
Kindly also add the Reference and Sources of the Hadith !
Shukran
Very good information.😊
Wa♥️alaikumussalaam♥️wa♥️rahmathullah♥️wa♥️barakathuhu♥️
What if after this you are not in the start of istinja. Must the socks be removed or can you continue with the socks on?
Jazakom Allah khyran. Would you kindly share the evidence for the permissibility to wipe the sole of shoes/socks? All that I've come across is instructing us to wipe over only.
Subhanallah!
First like by me luv frm kashmir
Just one question. If I make wudu then put my socks on and then for some reason I take them out and put them back on does it still count as pure or no?
No,...you need to perform wudu again without socks, put them on after and when wudu is invalidated/broke, you can wipe then onwards. But once you take them off, you have to perform wudu.
If u have Maken the wudu then put socks and then remove it when ur in the state of wudu then brother ur wudu is not broken at all remove and wear socks in the state of wudu as much as u want but if u wore socks after doing wudu and then after wearing socks ur wudu is broken then u 've 24 hours if ur a resident and 72 hours if ur a traveller to wipe over it but if after wiping ur put off your socks ur wudu will be broken
I have fungal infections in both of feet toes (means - in between the last and second last finger). And i wear cotton socks. So can i refresh my wudu by wiping over fabric socks. Becoz i use water everytime - the infection is growing. Please guide Jazaak Allah min khair.
Use fungal cream
So you can also wipe over your shoes so that you don‘t have to take them off?
Jazak Allahu Khairan
Well, wiping over the socks, not the shoes unless the shoes are Khuff type
U can wipe over the shoes when you are praying with shoes on
But if you will take off shoes for prayer then you have to take off shoes for your masah as well
is it okay to wipe one by one? when you have to lift up your feet at the washbasin
At the same time it is recommended to wipe on both socks
@Sarfaraz I am not biased against any one. I am against those who called themselves Ahle-hadees or salafis not because they have different opinion but purely because they are creating fitnah worldwide.
You mention Imam Hambal that he has opinion socks should be thick and can walk wearing it. Simple question: how thick. define the word 'thick' here and how much walk. when you try to explore these two questions you will come to believe me
Thick means the socks are not transparent, not see through, when you wipe over them you don't feel the water on your skin, they don't have holes, they're covering the feet up to the ankles and they're clean of course.
@@madiallo3366 it is your imagination of a thick socks. I have never seen socks which are transparent!!!
In fiqh or law every thing is defined. Already thick socks are also defined by fuqah based on sahabah practice not based on your own thinking.
@@smartbear9598 Well, usually people don't see their brains too but it doesn't mean that they don't exist - I have seen transparent socks. I'm not innocent of Fiqh as you may imagine. You're likely in your imagination too otherwise show us the textual evidence of the definition you're implying from the Sahabah, not that of the Fuqaha.
@@madiallo3366 you will find the evidences/definition of thick socks from practice of sahabah as mentioned in my first comment on this video about a month ago.
Islam is easy but that does not mean you change it according to your convenience.
Practice of wiping over cotton socks started sometimes around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permissible to make masah over cotton. This practice is reported and criticized by imam Nawawi (who compiled Riyadhussaliheen)
I thought the socks had to have certain requirements? like being able to walk in them for a certain amount of miles without wearing out. Or that they have to be waterproof.
@@SMonfyr730 Only on leather socks not on cotton socks. This condition is not in hanafi fiqh rather all fiqh. There is no sahih hadees to perform masah on cotton socks rather all are zaeef. The practice to perform masah on cotton socks started somewhere around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permitted. Even the ahlehadees scholars around 70 years ago were having the same opinion that it is only allowed on leather socks. Only modern ahlehadees scholars are saying it is permitted and even not all of them like Shaykh safiurrehman Mubarakpuri.
About sahabah : some sahabah used to perform masah on jurab but but and but you should know about their jurab. Their jurab were used to be of two types:
1. Muna'alain (cotton socks with leather attached to sole part)
2. Mujallidain. Cotton socks with leather attached to the sole part and also covered some other part of upper side.
Get knowledge and don't mislead.
as long as they cover above the ankles. you can wipe. The hanafis and some shafiis feel different. But dont worry about them. islam is easy. alhamdulila
@@issaibnaziz9122 islam is easy but that doesn't imply you change it according to your convenience. Fuqha have laid conditions on performing masah over socks keeping in mind the practice of sahabah. They did not put conditions arbitrarily.
The so called ahlehadees have changed Islam in last 150 years be it the invention of 8 rakaat taraweeh, wiping over cotton socks, physical joining of feet during Slah and many more.
One prophecy about qayamat: deviant scholars will emerge who will mislead the people with their ilm. So it is wise to believe and follow the scholar of early period who got knowledge directly from sahabah, tabaeen and tabe-Tabaeens.
Where is the proof for that, hanafi, shafii, maliki is composory, in maliki is even harder that is it should be leather.
@@mma7861 write English correctly first only then I will be able to reply.
what if we dont wipe
Daky wudu socks, perfect for work. 100% water proof
they dont have to be wudu proof to wipe over. According to the strongest opinion.
Can you describe the word "thick"
the timing part is an innovation or there is a specific hadith where our prophet mohammed peace be upon him said it
What if I’m at school and it’s too embarrassing to take off my socks everyday, what’s the rule for that?
Do full wudu at home and then you can keep your socks on in school and wipe over them
Do i have to do a complete wuduk(washing feet) if in between i took a piss or no. 4? And i read once u take off ur socks, u're not able to wipe over the socks anymore. U have to make a full wuduk once again. 😊
So if I'm not wearing socks and dont want to, can i just put them on so I don't need to wash my whole feet?
You have to have the wudu when you put your socks on. Then to renew you wudu, you can wipe them.
Does wiping over socks contradict the Qur’an’s instructions for wudu in verse 5:6? The Qur’an provides clear instructions for performing wudu in Surah Al-Ma’idah, 5:6, which specifically mentions washing the feet up to the ankles as part of the ablution process.
It would make it easier wiping over the socks but can you please elaborate, because to me it seems that this verse was explicit and hadiths cannot alter what has been revealed in the Qur’an, as the commandments of Allah are unchangeable.
Assalaamu Alaykum. I'm aware of the method of wiping over the top of the socks. What is the evidence for wiping the soles of the socks??
This narration was From Ali R. about this that" in the religion was based on a penis we will give more priority to wipe both upper and lower side.
But because prophet Muhammad ﷺ wipe over feet it is the actual Sunnah ❤️
@@sheikharifbillah2235 please check the translation from the shaykh
Mashallah
Gren-bonjour- well vlog~take care~ 😌
Asalamualeykum. Which madhab is this from ?
No blind following of madhab, but upon evidence...Quran and Sunnah as understood by the Sahabah and Salaf as-Salih
@@AbuMoosaa sorry my brother . Are you saying not to follow a madhab ?
If you look within our tradition. ALL the traditional scholars followed a madhab .
Imam Nawowi
Ibn Hajar
Ibn Al Jawzi
Etc
Even amongst the later contemporary scholars Ibn Taymiya may Allah subhantallah be please with him followed the hanbali madhab.
It's not a Madhad, it's an established and well known Sunnah - if you read books of Hadith about purification/Wudu, you'll see all the details i authentic narrations.
@madiallo3366 was ibn taymiyah and all the above scholars wrong then for following a madhab ?
@@traditionalmiddlepath3773sorry to say but this is not your blind hanafi channel so you may leave.
Is there a ruling on the type of sock we need for this to be legible?
Yes, the majority of the scholars are of the view that they should be thick enough to not let water seep inside.
@@adnanali2773 also it should be above ankle and other conditions
@@hatembaccari819 yes brother
They do not have to be water proof. They must cover the ankles.
Wuzu is only permissible on Leather socks which are thick socks which differentiates from regular thin socks which we wear daily and wuzu doesn't happen on that.
شكرن صحبي
@Sarfaraz: Yes I am Hanafi and Deobandi. In first impression you appear to disagree with me and then finally agreed with me. Studdents of Imam Abu hanifah may have different opinion but we follow the correct opinion no if it is came from abu hanifah or his students. I am really do not know about the opinion of his students in this matter but you should also mention the basis of their opinion. Their opinion can not be taken and practiced just because they are students of Imam there should be evidence in support of their opinion.
You mention that Imam Abu Hinafah changed his view. This is utterly wrong and seems to be a fabricated story assoicated with him (You should provide authenticity of this change of view). For the sake argument I assume for a while that he changed his opinion still we are not entitled to follow him in this matter until and unless there are evidences in the support of his 'new opinion'. We do not follow him in fiqh just becuase he is saying we follow him because he put evidence and logical conclusion for his opinion.
He didn't say all the conditions guys be careful dont do massah on the wrong socks
What conditions did he miss out?
?
i never even knew you dont have to wash your feet fully thank you
Well it's only if you can not at the time or if you are traveling
Only if you've got wudhu and have your socks on. One day for resident and three days for travellers
@@aliyahp9969 no. Whether you are resident or a traveller you can. The Prophet would wipe whilst resident also. Resident = 24 hours; Traveller = 72 hours
Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
“This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
There is no evidence to support wiping the bottom of the socks. Ali mentioned that if the religion was based on intellect alone it would have made more sense to wipe the bottom of the socks. So great video, but where is the evidence for wiping the bottom?
Only on leather socks not on cotton socks. This condition is not in hanafi fiqh rather all fiqh. There is no sahih hadees to perform masah on cotton socks rather all are zaeef. The practice to perform masah on cotton socks started somewhere around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permitted. Even the ahlehadees scholars around 70 years ago were having the same opinion that it is only allowed on leather socks. Only modern ahlehadees scholars are saying it is permitted and even not all of them like Shaykh safiurrehman Mubarakpuri.
About sahabah : some sahabah used to perform masah on jurab but but and but you should know about their jurab. Their jurab were used to be of two types:
1. Muna'alain (cotton socks with leather attached to sole part)
2. Mujallidain. Cotton socks with leather attached to the sole part and also covered some other part of upper side.
Get knowledge and don't mislead.
@@smartbear9598 Al Awzai, Sufyan At Thari and many more scholars bought proof of wiping over whatever is considered a sock or shoe regardless of the material. You on here speaking from desires. It is best to just keep quiet sir.
@@esaabdullah2762 not true. You must know what type of socks were worn in those days. Either leather socks or juran with leather attached to it used to worn. All sahih Hadith about socks made of leather (khuffain). Only 3 Hadith are there in which jurab is mentioned and all those are weak of worst nature.
Imam Muslim heavily criticised those weak ahadith.
I would like to see that evidence as well
How to cleanse and purify the heart? Urine and dirt soil one's clothes, and we use soap to clean them, but how about our soul (atma)?
By doing tauba for the sins, abstaining from the sins and doing zikr.
@@syedzubair7122 Those methods still will not cleanse your soul, sins are still being committed, by countless people. Again proving obligatory requirements set forth in Islam are useless. Live in accordance to truth, not by rituals and superstitions.
@@pavanSingh-ts5ymProphet of Allah SAW said every son of Adam is a sinner. And the best of sinners are those who repent.
We cannot be completely sinless but try our best to stay away and if commit then repent and make an intent not to repeat
Salah cleanses the soul if it's established properly ... If our soul is not getting cleansed even after regular prayers we need to reflect on the condition of our salah
@@pavanSingh-ts5ym oh we have a sihk over here. That's new normally hindus
❤❤❤❤❤❤
@Sarfaraz You should know that khuffain means leather socks jurabian means cotton socks. all these hadees you mentioned either does not mention khuff/jurab just simply mentions masah that does not imply they can be taken as such. Moreover, all such hadees where jurab is mentioned are weak.
You mentione Imam Ibne Taymiyah: do not mention what he said or what was his opinion just simply provide the basis of his opinion corrobarated with the practice of salaf.
Imam Ibne Taymiyah also has opinion/fatwa that Taraweeh is 20 rakaat but here you so-called Ahle-hadees/salafis do not bother his opinion and current fitnah of salfiyah are adamant that Taraweeh is only 8 rakaat. Your 'Big Scholar' Albani once said that praying 20 rakaat is sinful bid'at (Astaghfirullah).
Imam ibne Taymiyah also consider Taweez (Amulets) are allowed (you find it in the same book you mentioned)
Is it wrong to wash my feet and wipe it then wear my socks? because i don’t want my socks to get wet
As long as you have wudu it's ok
No it's not wrong, all you need is to make sure you're in a state of Wudu before wearing the socks then can wipe over them until the time indicated is reached or you remove them, in sha Allah.
In shafi whiping on socks is not possible but whiping on khuf is possible
that is not the SUNNAH!! please be careful brothers and sisters... this is not the proper. Shaykh Ibn ‘Uthaymin (may Allah have mercy on him) said:
“This means that what should be wiped is the top of the sock, passing one's fingers from the toes to the shin only, and one should wipe with both hands over both feet together, i.e., the right hand should wipe the right foot and the left hand should wipe the left foot at the same time, just as one wipes the ears, because this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah, as al-Mughirah ibn Shu’bah said, ‘Then he wiped them both.’ He did not say that he started with the right, rather that he ‘wiped them both’. So this is the apparent meaning of the Sunnah.
Is not allowed
Ummm thought this can only be done with thick leather socks?
Difference of opinion. As far as ik that is what the hanafi madhab says
In that case I'd rather play it safe and wash my feet during wudu. This is best for cleanliness aswell rather then wiping over cotton socks.
@@saqibtayyab8885 👍
@@saqibtayyab8885 Just so you know, Imam e azam Abu Hanifa changed his opinion few days before his death..
1:20 how to wipe your feet
JazakAllahuKhairan!
Only on leather socks not on cotton socks. This condition is not in hanafi fiqh rather all fiqh. There is no sahih hadees to perform masah on cotton socks rather all are zaeef. The practice to perform masah on cotton socks started somewhere around 6th century hijri when some shafi scholars started saying it is permitted. Even the ahlehadees scholars around 70 years ago were having the same opinion that it is only allowed on leather socks. Only modern ahlehadees scholars are saying it is permitted and even not all of them like Shaykh safiurrehman Mubarakpuri.
About sahabah : some sahabah used to perform masah on jurab but but and but you should know about their jurab. Their jurab were used to be of two types:
1. Muna'alain (cotton socks with leather attached to sole part)
2. Mujallidain. Cotton socks with leather attached to the sole part and also covered some other part of upper side.
Get knowledge and don't mislead.
It's true
i dont understand this is normal sock , this is not leather sock , why do you give a wrong information to people
i thought the socks have to be leather or thick enough that you could walk a long distance without tearing the socks?
yes that how it is supposed to be ... depend on the madhab maybe. Hanafi cannot do masaah over reguler socks.
This opinion is from some of the schools of thought but it is clear that some of the Sahabah wore socks with holes, socks made of different materials, so all of the conditions that people place on wiping are many times baseless
@@esaabdullah2762 jazakAllah khair, but i have read that the sahaba wiped over thick socks, and the socks they had were not like the thinner socks of today. do you have any sources or anywhere i can read more about what you said?
@@user-kd6nm7yn4s you can refer to fiqh As Sunnah also islamqa
Al Awzai and Sufyan Athari held the view of wiping over whatever is considered a sock or shoe. Ibn Hazm at Zahiri also stated that wiping can be done over any sock and it doesn't have to cover the ankles. My dear brothers just because the 4 schools agree on something doesn't always mean it's the haqq. There are scholars who were even greater then the 4. The Prophet didn't put any stipulations on wiping. And Allah Knows best.
@@esaabdullah2762 one question please, why are these 4 school's the only known ones and 99.99% Sunni Muslims follow them ?
Dear brothers
Please dont make your prayer useless bcz of ur lazyness. Its easy to remove your cotton socks, please do it and make perfect ablution. With some condition we are allowed to wipe on leather socks(huffah) but not on cotton socks. Prayer is a big deal try to make it perfect
this kinds of socks are not allowed to wipe and to do masa in islam
Kuffain leather socks, this is unhygienic as your socks will smell. I don’t agree with this at all.
If it's allowed then there is wisdom behind it. The sahaba wiped over socks
@@Mohsin427 don’t lie!!!
Not over normal socks!!!
@@abbou1218 fear Allah and don't accuse another Muslim of lies
@abbou1218 Shaykh al-Islam [Ibn Taymiyah] said:
The difference between socks and khuffayn is that the former are made of wool and the latter are made of leather.
It is known that such differences do not have any impact on shar‘i rulings. It makes no difference whether it is made of leather, cotton, linen or wool.
By the same token, it makes no difference whether garments worn in ihram are black or white. … The most that can be said is that leather is longer lasting than wool, but this does not affect the ruling, just as it is not affected if the leather is durable.
Moreover, it is well-known that the need to wipe over one is the same as the need to wipe over the other. As they are same in terms of the reason and need for wiping, differentiating between them would be differentiating between two similar things, which is contrary to the fairness and common sense that are promoted by the Qur’an and Sunnah, and that with which Allah sent down His Books and sent His Messengers.
Those who differentiate between them on the grounds that one is permeable and the other is not has mentioned a difference that does not affect anything.
End quote from Majmoo‘ al-Fataawa (21/214)
In the Quran surah Al maidah it says wash your feet so what has ibn tahmiyyah got to do with it I thought we talk about authentic hadith not fabricated ones. The Sahabas did wear leather their was no such thing as socks so stick to facts. We have to clarify to follow ibn tahmiyyah or the Sahabas in what they wore. I know with time things has changed but we have to stick with leather socks waterproof.
What's the evidence for wiping on the bottom of the socks? Didn't Ali RA say the religion is based on evidence not intellect that's why we don't wipe on the bottom of the foot.
😭😭😭 i didnt know this!!!😭😭 i didnt know you had to have thick socks that cover your ankles😭😭 i did salah wrong‼️‼️‼️😭😭
you wouldn’t be held accountable for it if you didn’t know
May Allah swt accept your salah ameen.
It’s not allowed to wipe over socks in non of the four madahiebs!
Only allowed to do so over leather socks that can stand by themselves and don’t let water in and you could walk on them without them getting damaged and doing so only allowed wiping over the upper part of the leather socks NOT under the socks!!! And you must wear the leather socks directly after finishing your Wudu and then it’s legit to wipe over them later on during other Wudu’s
These people are following their desire’s and are clueless about this issue.
Fear Allah, bring evidences to back your claims.
you are completely wrong. You should respect the other opinions of the imams. Imagine saying the other schools of thought are following their desires. Rather انت جاهل
I can guarantee that shafi and hanafi madhab are not allowing cloth type socks
I don't know about other than two madhabs
Probably they might don't allow the socks as socks were not used by early stages of islam
@Issa ibn Aziz you are very rude by calling someone a Jaahil. You are a extremist Salafi in who's eyes you are the only true Muslim
@@ShahnawazKhan-me8mg he said this channel is following their desires. He us getting a taste of his own medicine. Respect other opinions, or you are a jahil
Bhai saab I like your recitation but I would not follow you in this things.
@@abdikadiribrahim3786 I'm sure everyone can understand what is being said, however many such as myself believe this can only be done with thick leather socks not regular socks and definitely not shoes
I removed my comment and apologize to the brother for misunderstanding him. I have tremendous respect for those that are having the opinion that the mash is not allowed on the socks we use in daily life. Thanks for clarifying Saqib