I wondered what he hears in the headphones- A sequence for the entire song w/occasional keyboard parts? or is he so good, he just stays in time, knowing the keyboard part is coming up? Do you know if those are the old keyboard players actual parts, or is it all rewritten/sequenced for the post keyboards band? they make it look easy
@@criops I read somewhere that a fellow musician got a chance to listen to his headphone mix - it was just a deafeningly loud click track. He would certainly need a click throughout. Probably with prerecorded and live parts mixed in. Not much fun for him, poor old Bob - maybe we should beat him senseless? To my ears, the keyboard and other prerecorded parts always sounded a little different live than the record. Stripped down and more obviously sequenced/quantised, perhaps to help with timing. Maybe Kavus or someone else will tell us one day? Although I'm hoping not to find out TOO much...
@@criopsI like to imagine there was no click track and that it was just a recording of Tim shouting "SPEED UP! SLOW DOWN! STOP! THREE! THREE! NOW FOUR! STOP! SLOW DOWN AGAIN!"
@@cfwhitney I think it was the regional broadcaster who had camerapeople on stage. I guess the original poster bunnyflint might fill you in. He was both Cardiacs fan no.1 in my hometown AND working for that broadcaster at the time iirc
@@unknown6390 Well, you can see from Bunny's footage I guess. Some really like it, some are just bewildered. As it was a festival there was not really the fandom-thing going on you see in footage where it's just Cardiacs headlining. But since Cardiacs had played in Leeuwarden before in 1988 there were people in the audience who knew them and wanted to see them again. Like me and mister Bunny Flint himself ;)
This is brilliant why did I only discover them after the lead artist has passed grrrr it makes me wonder how many fantastic bands like this remain relatively obscure because most people struggle to get into it (this band were completely instant for me), saying that I don't think it would be very common to find people capable of memorising all this complex music to play live, no idea how they did it.
Thank you all for your reactions. Worthy of . . (you know) . . ! I have uploaded the final raw uncut track of the Frozenland concert (Duck & Roger). Soon to come: uploads of my/our very own former (1991-1995) band 'Les Chouchoux de la Maïtresse', inspired and often compared to Cardiacs. :-)
You can see that Tim gets a little annoyed because of the brutal camgirl on stage. Looks like he even bumped her. When he sings 'man stand far away' (at 3'29'') he looks in the camera and holds up 2 fingers as to say 'stand far away, two metres!' I almost felt guilty editing that . .
This band left GB far too little. The rest of us might have noticed them in time if they'd been a bit more out and about. Damn, I wish I could have seen them!
0:13 best part of this clip.
I am very proud to offer this historic moment to all the fishes in the pond 😇🤌✨💖
Hats off to Bob Leith for his uncanny ability to stay with all that very difficult sequenced material. So much more than playing to a click track.
I wondered what he hears in the headphones- A sequence for the entire song w/occasional keyboard parts? or is he so good, he just stays in time, knowing the keyboard part is coming up? Do you know if those are the old keyboard players actual parts, or is it all rewritten/sequenced for the post keyboards band? they make it look easy
@@criops I read somewhere that a fellow musician got a chance to listen to his headphone mix - it was just a deafeningly loud click track. He would certainly need a click throughout. Probably with prerecorded and live parts mixed in. Not much fun for him, poor old Bob - maybe we should beat him senseless? To my ears, the keyboard and other prerecorded parts always sounded a little different live than the record. Stripped down and more obviously sequenced/quantised, perhaps to help with timing. Maybe Kavus or someone else will tell us one day? Although I'm hoping not to find out TOO much...
@@criopsI like to imagine there was no click track and that it was just a recording of Tim shouting "SPEED UP! SLOW DOWN! STOP! THREE! THREE! NOW FOUR! STOP! SLOW DOWN AGAIN!"
I was there. Totally unforgettable. Happiness.
I hate you :P
What's with the onstage cameraman. Do you recall?
@@cfwhitney I think it was the regional broadcaster who had camerapeople on stage. I guess the original poster bunnyflint might fill you in. He was both Cardiacs fan no.1 in my hometown AND working for that broadcaster at the time iirc
What did the crowd around you think of them?
@@unknown6390 Well, you can see from Bunny's footage I guess. Some really like it, some are just bewildered. As it was a festival there was not really the fandom-thing going on you see in footage where it's just Cardiacs headlining. But since Cardiacs had played in Leeuwarden before in 1988 there were people in the audience who knew them and wanted to see them again. Like me and mister Bunny Flint himself ;)
The way they snap into place perfectly at 1:16 is really impressive.
This is brilliant why did I only discover them after the lead artist has passed grrrr it makes me wonder how many fantastic bands like this remain relatively obscure because most people struggle to get into it (this band were completely instant for me), saying that I don't think it would be very common to find people capable of memorising all this complex music to play live, no idea how they did it.
Welcome to the Pond :)
Tim’s music, influence and love remain.
@@pluviophilius2354 Exactly this!
@@pluviophilius2354 Yup, me too.
Well Frank Zappa and Mr Bungle did it too...
Thank you all for your reactions. Worthy of . . (you know) . . ! I have uploaded the final raw uncut track of the Frozenland concert (Duck & Roger).
Soon to come: uploads of my/our very own former (1991-1995) band 'Les Chouchoux de la Maïtresse', inspired and often compared to Cardiacs. :-)
Saw Cardiacs so many times between 87-90 as the seven piece. Truly superb memories. RIP Tim. X
Love these gig videos. Why did I only get into Cardiacs recently?
Better late than never, you're still part of an exclusive club simply by getting into Cardiacs at all :D
This is just phenomenal
Great recording.
brilliant! absolutely amazing!
Bloody Brilliant!!
Awesome!!!!
Tim forcing himself on Jim at the start. So horribly lovely.
so much wonderful ! thanks for uploading :)
Thank YOU...xxx
Love the side-glance to camera at 1:35
Amazing!
This is bloody brilliant thanks!
Thought a train was nearby at the start...
lol! the best! at 0:10 makes me smile!
Wowzer nice quality!!!
Zoinks! What a treat!
I love it!!! we want more !!!
Yes!
Weird to see them filmed 'properly' - I mean apart from 'Mare's Nest' of course.
All of it it was brilliant, but the twin guitar line-up just nudges ahead!
You can see that Tim gets a little annoyed because of the brutal camgirl on stage. Looks like he even bumped her. When he sings 'man stand far away' (at 3'29'') he looks in the camera and holds up 2 fingers as to say 'stand far away, two metres!' I almost felt guilty editing that . .
I thought that was kind of a UK version of what Americans use the middle finger for
@@That_Idiot_Bass_Player Yes it is!
1:17 to 1:32
Genius.
This band left GB far too little. The rest of us might have noticed them in time if they'd been a bit more out and about. Damn, I wish I could have seen them!
goose(gash) bumps
Judging by the flag at the beginning this is in Friesland, not Holland.
Nice performance.
Beautiful Have a carrot!
spoon lifts moon sounds like them
Nah, I'm sure he was just having a bit of fun.
Fantastic!!!!