The myth of race | BBC Ideas

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 11 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 931

  • @bbcideas
    @bbcideas  3 роки тому +9

    Thanks for watching! If you found this video interesting, you might want to take a look at this one next... Why I'm still fighting racism at 90 👉 ua-cam.com/video/KUjZkmxnWV8/v-deo.html​

  • @traeucity6087
    @traeucity6087 Рік тому +48

    02:47 How strange that a people characterized as 'lazy', were the go to choice for perpetual servitude.

    • @brendilladederp
      @brendilladederp Рік тому +22

      it's not that surprising, before people get on board with slavery they need to not see the one's their enslaving as human, calling them lazy was a way to de-humanize them and get people on board with slavery

    • @reichen609
      @reichen609 5 місяців тому

      *The evil legacy (mostly) from white people (the privileged class, I mean).*

  • @kindnessfirst9670
    @kindnessfirst9670 3 роки тому +97

    There are people who debate whether Jesus was white or black and when I point out that he lived 15 centuries prior to the creation of the concept of white and black people they are shocked to find this out. In the time of Jesus a person's race was based on what language they spoke- not what they looked like. People are also surprised to learn that Israel is in Asia (but of course continents are a social construct also and people argue about how many continents there are).

    • @shamashatum7927
      @shamashatum7927 3 роки тому +7

      Best comment yet you are exactly right the construction of black and white as a class system started in 1700's Virginia I also don't buy the 7 continents thing either by definition there are 3 America, Asia, Antarctica. When breaking down geopolitical demographics I used Eurasia, Lurasia, Afrasia, and Australasia I agree with you other than the name of Ha Mashiach ( Messiah ) buts thats another conversation

    • @Koloviv48i
      @Koloviv48i 3 роки тому

      Human species decended from the black people of Africa anyway, in other words other skin colours are the grandchildren of the original melanitic man and woman including jesus.

    • @kindnessfirst9670
      @kindnessfirst9670 2 роки тому +2

      ​@@Koloviv48i "Black" is a racial category (created five centuries ago). Human skin tones range from very light brown to very dark brown. All humans alive today descended from the same woman in Africa. Jesus lived fifteen centuries before there was any such thing as "black" and "white" races.

    • @jo18533
      @jo18533 2 роки тому +17

      European people and African people are not a social construct though. And they are wildly different.

    • @Bryants1427
      @Bryants1427 2 роки тому +6

      Jesus was middle eastern

  • @JohnnyJackson746
    @JohnnyJackson746 9 місяців тому +7

    I noticed if you go to different spots on the planet there are slight variations of human genetics.

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +2

      It’s not as simple as that that’s what they used to think in the 1500s when slavery started but thanks to genetic testing we know that that’s not true.

    • @TheGhost-sl5gh
      @TheGhost-sl5gh 7 місяців тому +2

      @@Undergroundgossipwhy certain groups have different physical traits that gives them advantage in certain sports then??

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +3

      @@TheGhost-sl5gh they eat the same food, and they live in the same climate. Throughout the years, there ancestors genes kept adapting so they can have the best advantage in that particular area that they live in. It’s as simple as that.

    • @suzukisixk7
      @suzukisixk7 4 місяці тому

      ​@@Undergroundgossipand when that exact process takes place over long periods of time it causes differences. These differences can be large and take many many human lifetimes to change....
      So we need a label for these things that while they change, don't change in our lifetimes. Would you agree that's what race is?

  • @mrglasses8953
    @mrglasses8953 3 роки тому +13

    Genetic distances (bigger numbers = more genetic distance):
    Homo Sapiens and Homo Erectus: 0.19
    Homo Sapiens and Homo Neanderthalensis: 0.08
    Bantu and Western European: 0.24
    Bantu and Aborigine: 0.33
    Western Gorilla and Eastern Gorilla: 0.02 - 0.29
    Bonobo and Chimpanzee: 0.05 - 0.2
    Yes, I was shocked too.

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому +2

      Big if true, usually i thought that humans are a less diverse species compared to apes.

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому

      If you can, i would like the source 👍🏻

    • @John.Flower.Productions
      @John.Flower.Productions Рік тому +6

      Poodles and German Shepherds are less than that but I do not see any police departments using Poodles.

    • @byrondance8762
      @byrondance8762 7 місяців тому

      This is incredible information and I'm currently making a video specifically about exactly what you're speaking about here. Please if you could give over your references I would appreciate it every much.

  • @shirleyhollins943
    @shirleyhollins943 3 роки тому +31

    People would be surprised 😮 about race, it is a myth we are more alike then we think. They use this word to classify, group and then ultimately discriminate base on what they think it mean.

    • @correctpolitically4784
      @correctpolitically4784 2 роки тому

      Shirley you gest .we have just as much in common with a gorilla .

    • @bambam-uw3ox
      @bambam-uw3ox Рік тому +1

      Your brainwashed

    • @peterschaeffer
      @peterschaeffer Рік тому

      Humans share 98% of their DNA with Chimpanzees. Actually, humans share more than 50% of their DNA with Corn plants. Are humans Corn plants? Actually, they are not.

  • @DavidBrunnerstupidamerican
    @DavidBrunnerstupidamerican 2 роки тому +6

    2022, and still dealing with these silly ideals and concepts. If the human race survives, it is truly God's will. Because without Him, I can't see us making it more than another 20 years.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 2 роки тому +5

      Talking of silly concepts.. you do know humans are a species not a "race". Right? Don't engage in babel, as a Christian you should know where the word came from.

    • @John.Flower.Productions
      @John.Flower.Productions Рік тому

      @@straighttalking2090 If either one of you were Christians, you would know that The Bible and/or God is quite race conscience.
      According to The Bible, Jesus was very racist.
      Dogs are a species but police departments always use German Shepherds rather than Poodles.
      I wonder why?

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 Рік тому

      @@John.Flower.Productions Really.. wonder on.

    • @John.Flower.Productions
      @John.Flower.Productions Рік тому

      @@straighttalking2090 I could cite dozens (literally) of examples from The Bible but not being a Christian yourself, it would not matter.
      That said, I still wonder why Poodles are not employed very often.
      After all, dogs are dogs.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 Рік тому +1

      @@John.Flower.Productions Sorry John but you're barking up the wrong tree (reference intended).
      1/ I don't believe in sky fairies so I'm just not interested there.
      2/ I'm fully up on taxonomic nomenclature so common parlance on 'breed' 'species' or 'race' is just semantics.. if you have a rational point to make - make it.

  • @MuhammadAli-ss6ej
    @MuhammadAli-ss6ej 3 роки тому +23

    This channel is verrry underrated. It deserves millions of views.

    • @mohammedsaquibkhan2592
      @mohammedsaquibkhan2592 3 роки тому +1

      True

    • @ramazanbumja2765
      @ramazanbumja2765 3 роки тому +1

      So true

    • @Britta_no_filter
      @Britta_no_filter 3 роки тому

      Your comment made me click the subscribe button. Of course the content of this video didn’t hurt either 😎

    • @meatalecider8597
      @meatalecider8597 2 роки тому

      1000%

    • @acortes7771
      @acortes7771 2 роки тому

      Listen Muhammad Ali, when a human dies and their skeletal remains are found there are always three distinct skeletal remains of what we know to be Homo Sapien Sapien. And that is Caucasian, Oriental and Negroid. This is also determined by scientific genetic testing of dna markers. These are concrete evidences that race distinctions are real and not a myth as these charlatan liars assume and want to propagate their nonsensical ideologies to the feeble minded.

  • @kindnessfirst9670
    @kindnessfirst9670 3 роки тому +23

    I am 60 years old with a university education, grew up in a very politically liberal family and have black friends and relatives. Yet it was only a few years ago when i read a few books on human genetics that I first learned that race was cultural rather than biological. Now it seems obvious to me and the evidence of it is overwhelming and consistent. There are two things I never knew growing up and was never taught in school but should have been at an early age. Number one: race is a social construct. Number two: all maps are inaccurate because there is no way to faithfully show a three dimensional object on a two dimensional surface.

    • @jo18533
      @jo18533 2 роки тому +7

      I'd say the evidence is actually overwhelming the other way around.

    • @kindnessfirst9670
      @kindnessfirst9670 2 роки тому +13

      @@jo18533 I'm talking about scientific evidence.

    • @jo18533
      @jo18533 2 роки тому +1

      @@kindnessfirst9670 So am I, specifically from David Reich.

    • @kindnessfirst9670
      @kindnessfirst9670 2 роки тому +10

      @@jo18533 Then you should check what he specifically said. And the widespread criticism he received for misrepresenting the scientific data. He used the term "racial construct" and "construct" is defined as: "an idea or theory containing various conceptual elements, typically one considered to be subjective and not based on empirical evidence".

    • @hydraelectricblue
      @hydraelectricblue 2 роки тому +1

      @@jo18533 We would call you and David Reich, racists. That’s literally what a racist is someone who believes in theories of race. That would also makes you about 200 years behind everyone else in evolution of thought 😂. Do you want me to treat your medical condition with leeches from the Middle Ages too 😂.

  • @Pradeep_889
    @Pradeep_889 3 роки тому +15

    2 eyes, 2 hands, 2 legs... how are we different then?

    • @blackniall8509
      @blackniall8509 3 роки тому +10

      Culture

    • @Pradeep_889
      @Pradeep_889 3 роки тому +4

      @@blackniall8509 Cultures are becoming irrelevant in this day and age. And rightly so.

    • @blackniall8509
      @blackniall8509 3 роки тому +5

      @@Pradeep_889
      They are not though divides are getting worse
      Everyone wants their culture and beliefs to be the dominate which is fair but in diverse society's it doesn't work
      Diverse society's always have fractures and divisions the more diversity the more fractures

    • @Pradeep_889
      @Pradeep_889 3 роки тому

      ​@@blackniall8509 It depends on the education and the awareness we create. With the help of internet and the free sharing of knowledge, that gap is slowly reducing. Ofcourse there will always be some people who will act as roadblocks. But they will eventually be overcome.

    • @rohiths3554
      @rohiths3554 3 роки тому +8

      Skin color, nose, height,

  • @tryphonkorm
    @tryphonkorm 3 роки тому +35

    So, my skin produces less melanin than that of an African person, not due to a genetic difference but because the sun doesn't shine so strongly here where I live. That is, if I migrate to the tropics and the African guy to the Arctic my skin will become black brown and his pink white. Propaganda at its dammest!

    • @skyking3210
      @skyking3210 3 роки тому +1

      You are of course right, you will not become black, there is a much tighter theory than the equatorial location to skin complexion being taught. Black people will stay black no matter where they are, something else caused the creation of recessive genes.

    • @Jesus.Is.Coming.Back1
      @Jesus.Is.Coming.Back1 3 роки тому +18

      @@skyking3210 I disagree. Black people only got dark because we lived in a region that fostered this need. If we all moved to Alaska, we would over time get lighter. It may take about ten thousand years but it would happen over time. The black people of the Melanesian islands are a perfect example of why this is so. Genes change over time and depending on the region we live in, they adapt to the environment for protection as well as for survival.

    • @cetnel65
      @cetnel65 2 роки тому +6

      @@Jesus.Is.Coming.Back1 watch on youtube the myth of race and the evolution of skin colors part 1, 2 and 3. This documentary explains how the different types of skin color originated

    • @brokengirl8619
      @brokengirl8619 2 роки тому

      But science findings are proving race does not exist and people didn't have white skin till 8000 years ago. Look it up.

    • @Jesus.Is.Coming.Back1
      @Jesus.Is.Coming.Back1 2 роки тому +3

      @@brokengirl8619 I agree race does not exist because we all came from Adam and Eve

  • @pranay561
    @pranay561 3 роки тому +15

    I don't fall under any category except human

  • @omardrfilms
    @omardrfilms 3 роки тому +29

    I just really hope one day we will find aliens somewhere else outside this planet so certain people can realize that they are not the center of the universe.

    • @jo18533
      @jo18533 2 роки тому +3

      What certain people?

    • @jo18533
      @jo18533 Рік тому

      @RussiaCollisionCourse17 lol I genuinely don't.

    • @jessicaF61985
      @jessicaF61985 Рік тому

      😂😂😂, that's a pipe dream sorry hunny no aliens are coming. Here's the good news racism and race will evolve into some into something else in the future, they will always exist in some form though. Not sure about the alien stuff 🤣😂😂😂, ah good old "humans" always seeking for a saviour, always trying to escape. THERE IS NO ESCAPE OR SAVIOUR, LIVE WITH IT.

  • @jasminhamilton1147
    @jasminhamilton1147 2 дні тому

    This is beautifully presented. Thank you!❤

  • @Utkarsh-w2d
    @Utkarsh-w2d 3 роки тому +47

    They are saying race is not biological. Does that mean, a white man and a woman can have a black child. Concept of race may not be useful, but saying that race doesn't even exist is a bit ignorant.

    • @lachsbrot
      @lachsbrot 3 роки тому +23

      Bruh. There are genes that determine your skin color. Race has nothing to do with genes. Its the Same Like Hair or eye color. If the Parents have Blue eyes. The Child will also have Blue eyes. If both are light Skinned then the Child will have light skin.

    • @blackniall8509
      @blackniall8509 3 роки тому +8

      @@lachsbrot
      Name me a good black swimmer
      And a good white sprinter?

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 3 роки тому +3

      @@lachsbrot You owe Black Niall an answer.

    • @kindnessfirst9670
      @kindnessfirst9670 3 роки тому +11

      It exists the way beauty does- it is subjective. It does not exist in biology. If it were biological you could test for a person's race by looking at their DNA. You can't- even the companies that use DNA to tell customers about their ancestries point that out to customers. I can't tell from a persons DNA whether a third person will consider them to be white, black or something else. It's like being tall. I can know your exact height but that can't tell me whether a third person will consider you tall or not because tallness (unlike height) is subjective.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 3 роки тому +1

      @@kindnessfirst9670 Of course its biological, what else could it be!? You're fixated on skin colour but it goes all the way deeper than that.Look at an Aussie Aboriginal and a Somalian - you can tell the difference straight away but they are both black. Race is literally defined by our DNA, written in code ACG and T (adenine (A), cytosine (C), guanine (G), and thymine (T)). What makes you think it is skin deep? It goes all the way to the bones guts muscle brain blood nerves and everywhere else in the body. The idea that it's a human construct is.. well, a human construct.

  • @inevski
    @inevski 8 місяців тому +8

    White and Black are political identities.
    Race is a competition

    • @robinsss
      @robinsss Місяць тому

      That's one definition

    • @inevski
      @inevski Місяць тому

      @@robinsss
      scientific and social facts
      Not ethnicities.

  • @stevencarr4002
    @stevencarr4002 6 місяців тому +16

    Race is a social construct, like currencies.

    • @vonelgamer3071
      @vonelgamer3071 4 місяці тому +1

      "Race? It is a feeling, not a reality. Ninety-five per cent, at least. Nothing will ever make me believe that biologically pure races can be shown to exist today."The creator of fascism said that, take that Nat sees

    • @stevencarr4002
      @stevencarr4002 4 місяці тому +1

      @@vonelgamer3071 Biologically real families don't exist either. My granddaughter has two grandfathers, not genetically related to each other.

    • @__Man__
      @__Man__ 2 місяці тому +1

      More like language. A language can be an independent language or a dialect or a creole or a pidgin or a new constructed language.

    • @stevencarr4002
      @stevencarr4002 2 місяці тому

      @@__Man__ Yes, language is a social construct. There is no such thing as pure English, as there are lots of varieties of English.

    • @__Man__
      @__Man__ 2 місяці тому

      @@stevencarr4002true. That's why they aren't called pure, but Standardised.

  • @daniels.os.
    @daniels.os. 3 роки тому +27

    False. Race is a real thing expressed in the genes but it is empowered by cultural and geographical factors for the most. Not all societies evolved equally. Using the humanitarian political correctness is a goodwill approach but there can be marked some racial differences and that doesn't mean we should treat us unequally and without respect. Just read "A Troublesome Inheritance" by Nicholas Wade.

    • @hydraelectricblue
      @hydraelectricblue 2 роки тому

      Which is why you are a racist because you ascribe to theories of race.

    • @John.Flower.Productions
      @John.Flower.Productions Рік тому

      The Bell Curve

    • @leststoner
      @leststoner Рік тому

      How many races are there?

    • @vonelgamer3071
      @vonelgamer3071 4 місяці тому

      "Race? It is a feeling, not a reality. Ninety-five per cent, at least. Nothing will ever make me believe that biologically pure races can be shown to exist today."Benito Mussolini was based

  • @duncanmcrae9982
    @duncanmcrae9982 Рік тому +6

    "Race is a social construct" The only race is the human race. What all of the hate and misunderstanding comes from is culture...there is only the human race and it is rather an argument about cultural insensitivity rather than throwing about the well tired "race" ideology

    • @EternalEmperorofZakuul
      @EternalEmperorofZakuul Рік тому +1

      Til It's time to tell the race from the skulls

    • @reactionwithyaboivic
      @reactionwithyaboivic Рік тому +3

      @@EternalEmperorofZakuulthat’s shits been debunked numerous times every one has different skull shape

    • @EternalEmperorofZakuul
      @EternalEmperorofZakuul Рік тому +1

      @@reactionwithyaboivic no shit. That's why we can tell races apart

    • @poody771
      @poody771 Рік тому +1

      ​@@EternalEmperorofZakuulNope. Geneticists and forensic anthropologists cannot.

    • @EternalEmperorofZakuul
      @EternalEmperorofZakuul Рік тому +1

      @@poody771 until they say this belonged to a African male age 34 or this belonged to a Asian female, age 20..then there isn't one race

  • @davism3800
    @davism3800 26 днів тому

    2:54 "these stereotypes have endured through the ages" hmmmm I wonder why

  • @hansladefoged382
    @hansladefoged382 2 роки тому +30

    Imagine looking at an Asian, African and an European and saying that race is a social construct. How stupid can people be?

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому +4

      It's an agenda, i believe, because some people don't want us to recognize differences, unless when it comes to giving free things to coloured people.

    • @Brandon-tz5pn
      @Brandon-tz5pn 2 роки тому +5

      You think it isnt? If so can you explain how?

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому +17

      @@Brandon-tz5pn Because you can tell who is European, African and Asian by just looking at them...

    • @hansladefoged382
      @hansladefoged382 2 роки тому +1

      @@fallout1953 Thank you.

    • @Brandon-tz5pn
      @Brandon-tz5pn 2 роки тому +3

      @@fallout1953 how?

  • @laurice8056
    @laurice8056 2 роки тому +1

    Who else is watching this in February 2022, after Whoopie’s statements on the View?🤔

  • @saims.2402
    @saims.2402 3 роки тому +19

    Race is just one of the ways I recognize people, like eye colour and hair colour.

    • @shamashatum7927
      @shamashatum7927 3 роки тому

      100% correct hair color is the oldest way of identifying groups in ancient Sumer the birthplace of civilization. The Sumerians called all people with black hair ung sang ngigga and yellow haired people namrutum scientific circles the black haired variety of mankind are the Melanic and the yellow haired Xanthous and the light haired Leucous white variety

    • @paulbeauchamp5252
      @paulbeauchamp5252 2 роки тому

      Europeans INVENTED the races in 1790. Naming names: Johann Friedrich Blumenbach. Naming the year: 1789. Before that year, no culture anywhere referred to "races" or people belonging to any "race". Science has proven that races do not exist.

    • @angelagrant7874
      @angelagrant7874 10 місяців тому

      @@shamashatum7927How do you explain the brown skinned people with blonde hair and blue eyes?

    • @shamashatum7927
      @shamashatum7927 10 місяців тому

      @@angelagrant7874 the people of Sumer , Khemet, Harrapa and other ancient civilizations each had it's own way of classifying people, since Sumer supposed to be the oldest I'm using their classification for them and some anthropologist have adopted the same views in Sumer all black haired people despite skin color, hair texture, region, etc are the children of the sun in ancient Hindu chronologically these are the Solar race those anthropologist called these the Melanic variety of man despite skin color which was never a factor into very recently with the rise of the Anglos , prior to the Anglos, Europeans distinguish themselves by hair color, eye color etc resulting in the Nordic type, Alpine type etc, so to answer your question those people you referred to would be referred to as Xanthous

  • @victorwilliams1304
    @victorwilliams1304 Рік тому +17

    Knowledge is Power ✊🏿

    • @jamesabestos2800
      @jamesabestos2800 Рік тому +5

      Truth is Power

    • @bambam-uw3ox
      @bambam-uw3ox Рік тому

      Knowledge of what. Your very ignorant. didnt you know that when they digg someones bones up 500 years from now they will know what race that person was. It goes down all the way to the DNA. Race is real

    • @DGRIFF
      @DGRIFF Рік тому +3

      ​@jamesabestos2800 yes, this absolutely truth and people are living in a dream, but it's not their dream, it's the dream they were forced to live in.

  • @teemadarif8243
    @teemadarif8243 3 роки тому +13

    How about no boxes to ✔️. Very well done ☺️

  • @mattbl0x410
    @mattbl0x410 8 місяців тому +2

    Never lose your smile.

  • @Anonymous_Anon882
    @Anonymous_Anon882 2 роки тому +6

    There are definitely distinct racio-ethnic-groups and a definite sense of blackness (not least because of the distinct experiences of racism historically-directed towards black people specifically) but calling white people “white” hasn’t sat too-well with me of late. It would be a fallacy to pretend that we’re all exactly-the same (and there are biological differences beyond skin-complexion per se) but I feel like the division’s over-accentuated by people at times and you get black people who are so anti-white that they see them all as incipient Karens and Harleys and would rather not work/associate with them and I do understand where that comes from (especially if you’ve experienced a lot of racial trauma) but some of the division/passive hostility (I won’t call it reverse-hostility because that would just-be stupid and ‘disproportionate’) in general just seems to go a bit too-far. It’s a tricky one.

    • @taoliu3949
      @taoliu3949 2 роки тому +7

      The point is that the concept of race is a social construct and is very arbitrary. Different societies defines race differently and these definitions changes depending on the time and individual.

    • @Robert.Smith6969
      @Robert.Smith6969 Рік тому +1

      @@taoliu3949 yes the average Germanic man is VERY similar to the African man with a sloped skull and jutting monkey jaw, oh and don't forget the 40iq difference between the two

    • @taoliu3949
      @taoliu3949 Рік тому +3

      @@Robert.Smith6969 I didn't say they were "very similar", I said current definitions of race are arbitrary and inconsistent from a genetics perspective.
      Africans are more genetically diverse than the rest of the world combined, and yet they frequently get lumped together as "black". In other words, these racial categorizations are not a result of "science" but of social/cultural reason.

    • @john-us4zw
      @john-us4zw Рік тому

      >racio

    • @rickfrombohemia9550
      @rickfrombohemia9550 Рік тому

      There are variations in colour, bone structure, etc. for sure, but what I've learned so far it's caused by very small number of genes, it just strikes our eyes the most because it's on the surface. The real variability lies inside and doesn't correlate with "races" much.

  • @themeekkat
    @themeekkat 8 місяців тому +1

    2:10 Don't forget in Darwin's Decent of Man Chapter 7 he said "I could not have believed how wide was the difference between savage and civilised man… Viewing such men, one can hardly make oneself believe that they are fellow-creatures, and inhabitants of the same world. It is a common subject of conjecture what pleasure in life some of the lower animals can enjoy: how much more reasonably the same question may be asked of these barbarians!" He also alluded to this at the end of the Origin of Species.
    This is the reason why you still have people to this day associating people with dark skin as being closer to apes. Or why calling someone with dark skin to a monkey is considered offensive. It came from Darwin's theory. Doesn't matter if other people say today it is not true and we have moved past that. The memetics have already spread because of that theory and will continue with its existence. It is like a virus of the mind that can only be cured by truth, (if people were only willing).
    Stephen Jay Gould- "Biological arguments for racism may have been common before 1859, but they increased by orders of magnitude following the acceptance of evolutionary theory. The litany is familiar: cold, dispassionate, objective, modern science shows us that races can be ranked on a scale of superiority. If this offends Christian morality or a sentimental belief in human unity, so be it; science must be free to proclaim unpleasant truths. But the data were worthless. We never have had, and still do not have, any unambiguous data on the innate mental capacities of different human groups- a meaningless notion...."

  • @richard3470
    @richard3470 Рік тому +4

    Language is a social construct, does that make it any less of a reality? Even if race was entirely a social construct, what is the problem if some people identify as one thing, and some as another? Just as some people speak one language and some speak another. The only difference in this anology though is that the evidence for race is staring you right in the eyes whereas language is but a sound in your ear.

    • @poody771
      @poody771 Рік тому +7

      Could you name one human phenotype that is exclusive to one racial group.

    • @richard3470
      @richard3470 Рік тому

      @@poody771 My comment was made to make you ponder. As I said, even if race is entirely social, the historical and modern record provides the evidence that humans identify themselves in groups based on their physical characteristics. A nation is an extended family based on shared ancestry I.E blood ties. The word Nation has lost its meaning in the modern multiracial societies we find ourselves in within the Western world. However, the host nations (or races) within the West are still here and they know who is their kin and who is not. Perhaps the multiracial democracies day's are numbered.

    • @poody771
      @poody771 9 місяців тому +1

      ​@@richard3470Yep. Race a sociological phenomenon.

    • @dannewman8809
      @dannewman8809 8 місяців тому +1

      @@poody771 Right but there clearly are phenotypical groups I dont think this needs to be argued northern europeans are phenotypically quite distinct from say east asians. But if we are not going to use the word race which is understandable then what word do we use instead, some people say ethnicity but that more has cultural conotations then exclusively being about genetics. Like if we dont want to say race then what do we say instead to acknowledge these diffrences between groups?

    • @poody771
      @poody771 8 місяців тому +3

      @@dannewman8809 Distinct phenotypical groups don't exist in humans. Biologists use something known as *clines* when going over genetic differences within and between groups.

  • @jumpyX2
    @jumpyX2 2 роки тому +7

    Racial differences may not be real, but cultural differences are.

    • @hansladefoged382
      @hansladefoged382 2 роки тому +4

      Look up IQ statistics.

    • @hansladefoged382
      @hansladefoged382 2 роки тому

      @WKYT Absurd comment.

    • @hansladefoged382
      @hansladefoged382 2 роки тому +1

      @WKYT Yeah right, we are literally cavemen... European people btw. have achieved the most succes in human history out of all people.
      Actually Columbus thought that the Native Americans he encountered were unintelligent and easily amused. So you are lying to me about what he thought about them.
      Have you ever been to Europe? And why do you hate white people? And what is your race? I am suspecting that you are not white.
      Diallo Kenyatta is a communist and a unrealiable source of information. He has no professional degree.
      The book you reccomended is propaganda material, not scientific.
      You are a sad human. You believe in weird stuff that is objectively untrue.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 2 роки тому

      @WKYT How racist of you WKYT. What race are you?

    • @infinitekaister
      @infinitekaister Рік тому +1

      @WKYT Caucosoids moment! You teach 'em!

  • @StrategikMedia
    @StrategikMedia 2 роки тому

    What is a truth and what is a lie? Science has somewhat an answer

  • @BasedinReality1984
    @BasedinReality1984 3 роки тому +12

    They were observations , not stereotypes. Stereotypes are formed .

    • @John.Flower.Productions
      @John.Flower.Productions Рік тому +1

      Stereotypes are usually correct.
      That is how stereotypes are established.

    • @olol7311
      @olol7311 Рік тому +2

      @@John.Flower.Productions That is an inconvinient truth.

  • @AWayOfLiving84
    @AWayOfLiving84 9 місяців тому

    Every creature is a race

  • @jameseldridge3445
    @jameseldridge3445 Рік тому +6

    The inconvenient truth is that there is a biological/racial hierarchy in the human species. In terms of intelligence, conscientiousness, behavior, etc races (on average) differ drastically in these measurements on a genetic level. That is the reason for different outcomes. But the poor, impulsive, and irrational will always be the majority as the intelligent, wise, and temperate will always be the few. The poor, impulsive, irrational group is much easier to persuade and influence, that is why the western world caters to those groups politically. Anyone who opposes such belief is deemed evil, hateful, etc. which is the best way to formulate public opinion to support an ideology.

    • @TmanRock9
      @TmanRock9 Рік тому +4

      Never seen a study suggest that intelligence differs by race and for good reason because races do not exist this makes the rest of your example also meaningless. Populations exist race however isn’t a biological classifications and genetically makes no sense.
      What you said about difference in genetics being fairly large is also false. All humans regardless of location are 99.9% identical genetically.

    • @PeteS_1994
      @PeteS_1994 Рік тому +7

      Do you have any in-depth, well researched evidence for this?

    • @alekseyprokopev7409
      @alekseyprokopev7409 Рік тому +2

      ​@@PeteS_1994 try to guess if he does lol

    • @John.Flower.Productions
      @John.Flower.Productions Рік тому

      @@PeteS_1994 Those truths are self-evident.

    • @EternalEmperorofZakuul
      @EternalEmperorofZakuul Рік тому

      ​@gasenjoyer...4594that's being proved everyday when you go to videos regarding ancient Egypt and New World cultures

  • @AWayOfLiving84
    @AWayOfLiving84 9 місяців тому

    What gives me the right to wipe out a Carney? They are many reasons but what would be yours

  • @bradfordlangston836
    @bradfordlangston836 7 місяців тому +7

    Race is real. Do not submit to the propaganda.

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +2

      So where is the black and white DNA if it’s real?

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +3

      Scientifically race is not real. There’s no white or black genes. Genetically race does not exist.

    • @ssndknb
      @ssndknb 7 місяців тому +1

      ​@@UndergroundgossipHow do you explain then that children inherit from their parents skin tone, facial features, hair texture and other racial features?

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +5

      @@ssndknb there is absolutely no such thing as racial features. That’s a horrible word I would never used it. Humans comes in all shapes and sizes. Skin tones colors. Especially in the African-American community two dark skin people can come out with light skin child. What you look like doesn’t necessarily determine how your child is going to look. There were twins one came out extremely light and the other dark skin. People had the nerve to ask scientist what race would each twin be and she responded HUMAN

    • @ssndknb
      @ssndknb 7 місяців тому +1

      @@Undergroundgossip what... then, can you explain, what is race for you

  • @Wheninrome6042
    @Wheninrome6042 Рік тому +1

    Race It is a feeling, not a reality ninety-five percent, at least, is a feeling Nothing will ever make me believe that biologically pure races can be shown to exist today National pride has no need of the delirium of race

    • @Grigori_Rasputin666
      @Grigori_Rasputin666 Рік тому

      😅Mussolini, icon of anti-racism.

    • @peterschaeffer
      @peterschaeffer Рік тому

      Air density at sea level is different than air density on top of Everest. Air (like race) is a gradient. Does that mean air doesn't exist?

  • @grimassassin9722
    @grimassassin9722 8 місяців тому +5

    Race simply doesn’t exist, the only difference between me and someone who is let’s say African is skin tone and culture and skin tone isn’t a reason to essentially label another skin tone as a different species

    • @SonoftheSteppes
      @SonoftheSteppes 6 місяців тому +8

      Someone clearly skipped biology and history classes.
      Imagine thinking skin color is the only difference,but everything else is the same 🤦🏻‍♂️.
      Have you ever heard of genetics,physiology and DNA,perhaps? Are those words alien to you?

    • @davism3800
      @davism3800 26 днів тому

      Did an AI bot make this comment?

  • @leststoner
    @leststoner 4 місяці тому +1

    No such thing as race

  • @christhedixiecrat3668
    @christhedixiecrat3668 Рік тому +14

    Misleading title, race exists.

    • @Raccon_Detective.
      @Raccon_Detective. Рік тому +4

      Only in Human phenotypes and nothing else.

    • @christhedixiecrat3668
      @christhedixiecrat3668 Рік тому

      @@Raccon_Detective. And into the human genome 😏

    • @Raccon_Detective.
      @Raccon_Detective. Рік тому +8

      @@christhedixiecrat3668
      Not really if race was truly based in looks a lot of the Sub-Saharan people in the U.S. should be considered mixed but we don't like to talk about because of how the Europeans genes got in there.....

    • @christhedixiecrat3668
      @christhedixiecrat3668 Рік тому

      @@Raccon_Detective. I mean if they are mixed so be it, how did the European genes get in?

    • @Raccon_Detective.
      @Raccon_Detective. Рік тому

      @@christhedixiecrat3668
      During the slave trade the slaw masters would forcefully have thier with the female slaves....

  • @ianmcgregor6002
    @ianmcgregor6002 3 роки тому +1

    Yet my maternal grandfather being one of eleven and one of only two surviving was insistent that his alleged privilege or total lack of was based on class? I'd say those privileged experts have been at the sherry.

  • @ezparisii
    @ezparisii 3 роки тому +8

    For me, race isn't a thing, just evolution.

  • @ForteExpresso
    @ForteExpresso 3 роки тому

    I thought its about race

  • @straighttalking2090
    @straighttalking2090 3 роки тому +9

    Can't believe the BBC put their name to this rubbish. That OU is part of this is very concerning- it devalues the degrees of thousands of students.

    • @Koloviv48i
      @Koloviv48i 3 роки тому +1

      @ Straight talking- Not a rubbish at all. It's a myth. Race is a social construct by the western caucaseans to put themselves on a pedestal. There's only one human species that originated in Africa and spread through genetic mutations that we see today on this rock called earth

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 3 роки тому +3

      @@Koloviv48i Don't you realise how ridiculous you sound? How did humans 'construct' black skin? Do you think some humans constructively changed the skin colour of other humans and then buried all history of it? Or do you think it is just biological evolution? Btw Earth isn't a rock and most humans on it don't call it Earth. You need to put some serious thought into your statements if you are looking for credibility.

    • @jo18533
      @jo18533 2 роки тому +2

      @@Koloviv48i So you believe a Danish man and a Aboriginal Australian are identical?

    • @galaxiegoddess
      @galaxiegoddess 2 роки тому +6

      @@straighttalking2090 Yeah, let me guess, and money isnt a social construct either because you can physically hold it LMAO i dont think you know what a social construct is.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 2 роки тому

      @@galaxiegoddess You are reacting to a conversation where a leading protagonist has removed their post. All you can do is guess. You know nothing about what I know about money and social constructs and I don't care what you think you know about about what I don't know. Congrats on the dumbest comment I've read this year.

  • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
    @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 8 місяців тому +1

    The idea of Race, is now and has been for quite some time a Religion.

  • @Vrey662
    @Vrey662 3 роки тому +6

    Nothing wrong with human races as long you dont think one is better than the others, races re nothing more than adaptacións to certain geographical conditions, same thing happens with animals and plants (40+ dog races and 4000+ potato races) but it turns offensive when talking about humans, BBC political correctness trying to delete the word race is stupid.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 3 роки тому +4

      Why not be able to say one race is better than another at something. Can't you say that West Africans are better sprinters than East Asians? Look at the Olympic scoreboard to evidence that claim. Also it's much more than geographical conditions that shape evolution. But you are right about trying to delete the word race and we should all respect out fellow humans for their character and not the colour of their skin.

    • @hydraelectricblue
      @hydraelectricblue 2 роки тому

      Actually yes, it is wrong because the theory of race is a mythology and anthropologists don’t not believe in the myth of the race anymore. Anyone who ascribes to theories of race are racist, period.

    • @hydraelectricblue
      @hydraelectricblue 2 роки тому +1

      @@straighttalking2090 More likely you just have a small pants size. Most racists struggle to get laid so they turn to racism instead. Stand up and be counted tiny man.

    • @paulallen2680
      @paulallen2680 Рік тому

      @@straighttalking2090”race” as in color of people skin is a dumb way to judge genetics. Ethnicity is way better way to judge genetics.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 Рік тому

      @@paulallen2680 Really Paul the best way to judge a word is to use a dictionary - then we can sink from the same song sheet. Genes are biological - ethnicity and race have two separate meanings (which is why we have two different words..).

  • @learnersdisciple9950
    @learnersdisciple9950 3 роки тому +1

    Overt manifestations of racism may have been recent in history but its presence in the sub-conscious part of the humans is considerably an old phenomenon. Edward Said's Orientalism traces its representation in the European texts over the centuries. Before that, the interaction of the humans from different continents was minimal which explains the scarcity of the evidence of its presence in the earlier eras. Anyhow, it is a very useful video about the topic of Racism. I give you 3.5/5 marks.

  • @cyndimanka
    @cyndimanka 2 роки тому +4

    I disagree with a lot of this and says the opposite of other channels that doing much better job

    • @brokengirl8619
      @brokengirl8619 2 роки тому

      But science findings are proving race does not exist and people didn't have white skin till 8000 years ago. Look it up.

    • @cyndimanka
      @cyndimanka 2 роки тому

      @@brokengirl8619 so what are you gonna put down on your next form that asks you what race you are? No answer? What if it needed an answer? How about the census are you going to pass the census up?

    • @galaxiegoddess
      @galaxiegoddess 2 роки тому +2

      @@cyndimanka Race is real, and its also a social construct. You can identify with a race and also know there is not a gene for it. Humans made up the idea of race, even if the phenotypes for skin tones exist. Please understand what a social construct is, and how they work, because its obvious you dont.
      For example, money is a social construct. That must be baffling for you, but once you figure that out you can figure out race.

  • @pablobedoya5903
    @pablobedoya5903 9 місяців тому +2

    The fact that in the modern world almost all people are mixed, it does not change the fact that humans evolved in different races. Stop this nonsense. Of course there are races. Just like dog breeds are very different from each other and we can call those a different races from the same Species. We are the same species but not necessairly the same race. A pitbull and a chihuahua are more different than a Chinese and and Sub-saharan African but the dogs can have races we don't? We all have the same value but different people evolved differently indifferent parts of the world and that is a race, period.

    • @poody771
      @poody771 9 місяців тому +5

      Theres a study written by a couple of anthropologist going over why your dog breed-analogy is flawed.

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 8 місяців тому

      there are genetically more types of black Africans than every other croup combined. You are just looking at people and making them fit into spaces that were developed before you were thought of.

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +3

      All humans originated in Africa. And we all look different. But our ancestors mixed at some point and those genes can be pulled onto the next generation at any given time. People having the same physical characteristics, doesn’t mean that they are part of the same race of people. There are a lot of races. that have dark skin and coarse hair with no recent ancestors from Africa. Europeans used to have dark skin 8000 years ago because they originated in Africa too. People looking alike, has nothing to do with them being related. That’s what society used to think but thanks to genetic testing we know that that is not true.

    • @kudjoeadkins-battle2502
      @kudjoeadkins-battle2502 7 місяців тому

      @@Undergroundgossip besides people we consider black what you say is not true. There are black people who are more separated from Africa than non black peoples. However other people groups who look alike are fairly related. Black Andaman Islanders for instance are more kin to Asians than they are to Africans. However all Asian groups genetically are very similar.

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому +1

      @@kudjoeadkins-battle2502 why are you calling people black who do not identify as black. When people say black they’re really talking about the descendants of African slaves. Dark skin and coarse hair does not mean someone has ancestry from Africa. Asian people can have course hair and dark skin. So so-called Black people does not own that physical trait. Other so called races can have dark skin.

  • @KittySnicker
    @KittySnicker 3 роки тому +3

    Great video! I think race is indeed more of a spectrum of physical features than distinct categories.

    • @straighttalking2090
      @straighttalking2090 3 роки тому

      Yeah.. blue is just a human construct.

    • @kindnessfirst9670
      @kindnessfirst9670 3 роки тому

      Race is subjective- just as the categories are. They differ over time and by location. The US Census changes the race categories offered to choose from every time they conduct it. The 2020 Census offered fourteen choices for race (none of which was Hispanic/ Latino). People get confused by the newspapers and other media stories about the changing racial demographics of the USA. The articles talk about the portion of Americans that are white but if you read carefully you often find that they really mean non- hispanic whites rather than whites in total.

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому

      All distinct categories exist on a spectrum.

    • @taoliu3949
      @taoliu3949 2 роки тому +1

      @@fallout1953 The point is that these categories are largely arbitrary and has no basis in genetics.

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому

      @@taoliu3949 You think white, black and asian don't represent sub-groups within humanity? What you say is just incorrect and cliche.

  • @thetruthmaster1734
    @thetruthmaster1734 Рік тому +2

    Well races exist, stop nonsense mostly race is not based on skin colour but, but face structure and body structure. It is much more complicated that skin colour.

    • @poody771
      @poody771 Рік тому +2

      Give an example of a structure that is exclusive to one racial group.

    • @DimpzNYC
      @DimpzNYC 9 місяців тому +1

      Or skull shape right?

    • @Divine_wave23
      @Divine_wave23 7 місяців тому

      Evidence ? Any DNA difference ? Show evidence ?

    • @thetruthmaster1734
      @thetruthmaster1734 7 місяців тому +1

      @@Divine_wave23 evidence is that we are divided in halpogroups, we have genetic difference. Search halpogroups you will find the reality.

    • @Gaius_Julius_Caesar_Augustus
      @Gaius_Julius_Caesar_Augustus 2 місяці тому

      ​@@poody771 Give an example of a structure that's present in the Siberian tiger but not in a Bengal tiger?

  • @TallisKeeton
    @TallisKeeton Рік тому +2

    If there is no race then why all those videos about black ppl taking pride in other black ppl (and not other American citizens of whatever color) or thinking that there is no European culture (white culture) ? Race is not significant thing IMO, I'd rather see people as parts of USA or Europe.

    • @DoubleBeezy
      @DoubleBeezy Рік тому +5

      That’s not just blk, but it’s everyone.

    • @TallisKeeton
      @TallisKeeton Рік тому +1

      @@DoubleBeezy maybe so, but as far as I can see (in my small part of the medias, in my "echochamber":) ) the blk culture topics - or I should say rather blk anger abd lies about white culture - have dominated most medias in recent years. Why is that I dont know. Maybe as in many other topics, its all about money or about dividing us politicaly. Or both. :)

    • @DoubleBeezy
      @DoubleBeezy Рік тому

      @@TallisKeeton idk why we need race but since it’s here, I know to be considered blk in America is anyone with obvious west African ethnic and unless u directly from a white parent for example, you automatically seen as blk. Many blk Americans have a quarter + European ancestry and I don’t blame ppl who don’t know anyone so blame it on slavery of course but many know at least a great grandparent, which imo I thought y not accept it because how can u guess at that point. Overall many ppl mixed but In America, but that’s our race view on blk and u have ppl mixed with indigenous with background from Mexico, and identify as their nationality as a race, so it’s always a argument based on who’s considered mixed or not and what culture u have. I’m blk American but I only see it as a social construct and eventually America (USA) will have to become one culture or else it will get worse and again it’s not just blk, but instead yt Asian blk and other ppl identifying by nationality from a Spanish speaking background. I know other places have a culture but the melting pot would have to be melted at a certain point, which it already is imo. We will have to become one culture as the USA 🇺🇸, and hopefully get some race logic in America so it’s understood it’s a social construct because I know outside America many ppl identifying as Hispanic and blk would fall under mixed box until they a certain %(75%+ is considered full I think) because it’s sad how many sub labels ppl have in America. I came across videos like this when I realized nobody know what full blk or yt is because I see ppl in dna vids say both their parents blk but test show 60/40 and it’s automatically said slavery and she not half because her/his parents blk but on the other hand a person with a white parent is half. See how the logic pretty much blk is tainted with west African and unless u directly from a white or Asian parent then u blk. I’m just showing the confusion in the logic of ppl who say it’s one drop rules and apparently everyone is all these races. Me personally who of course is blk by race view, I would have my kids accept their mix and understand it’s a social construct and y we say blk(if my lady is in the blk box/remember anyone even with a white parent automatically labeled as blk box).
      I’m only responding late because someone liked my comment and your response never popped up on my phone, so I’m just responding. Btw I have my dna results on my YT page if u wanna see my point clearly on race being dumb 🇺🇸🫡

    • @sjacks3281
      @sjacks3281 10 місяців тому

      "Black" is also an ethnicity. European culture is not racial, it's ethnic. Race and ethnicity are not the same thing.

    • @TallisKeeton
      @TallisKeeton 10 місяців тому

      IMO black and white are not ethnicities. these are only colors. Ethnicity is Slavic or Bantu or Anglosaxon or Malay, or Cherokee. But modern nations are like USA - with many ethnic groups of different colors grouped together under one law and citizenry. thats how I see it :)

  • @Daisy_3500
    @Daisy_3500 Рік тому +1

    It's a tactic Satan uses to separate everyone. Separation is not what Jesus wanted us to do.

    • @themeekkat
      @themeekkat 8 місяців тому +1

      You're right Daisy. His methods are separation in many forms. From the fictional races, denominations, political parties, even sports teams of all things, etc.
      It's so much easier to treat others as human beings if you come to the knowledge that we are literally all apart of the same family from one man and one woman. Even more so that by one man we can all be saved. And that one man told us to love one another and not harm another. Even unbelievers.
      (sadly many people think the catholic church is "christian" and will quickly point to the crusades as if Jesus approved of it).

    • @Daisy_3500
      @Daisy_3500 8 місяців тому

      @@themeekkat You are so right, it is much easier to see & treat everyone as a human being. & about Jesus saving us all. 🙏

  • @Jezza-m5k
    @Jezza-m5k 3 місяці тому +1

    This is complete BS...

  • @mymensinghbritishacademy6680
    @mymensinghbritishacademy6680 3 роки тому +1

    Excellent I love it

  • @jameseldridge3445
    @jameseldridge3445 18 днів тому

    What j🎉w wrote this

  • @ohzone6464
    @ohzone6464 6 місяців тому

    Why doesn''t everybody will be of mixed- race. Why not????

  • @dollylove3430
    @dollylove3430 2 роки тому

    💕

  • @leratosetsiba
    @leratosetsiba 3 роки тому

    BBC IDEAS 🔥🔥🔥🙌🏾

  • @apoorvayaduvanshi1226
    @apoorvayaduvanshi1226 3 роки тому

    This video is another masterpiece added to their collection.

  • @Matthew8473
    @Matthew8473 Рік тому

    Your piece is heartwarming and insightful; akin to a book that was heartwarming and insightful in its message. "Rising From Within: Unlocking Your Innate Power to Conquer Adversity" by Vincent Starling

  • @Fundemons
    @Fundemons 8 місяців тому +2

    The whole idea of race really comes down to humans being hard wired to notice facial features that they are less familiar with. Like yes certain features are more common in certain geographical regions. But the features are not universal to the group.

    • @Undergroundgossip
      @Undergroundgossip 7 місяців тому

      Your DNA is what determines what you look like. not where you were born.

    • @Divine_wave23
      @Divine_wave23 7 місяців тому

      ​@@UndergroundgossipDNA evolves based on where you live . Eurppe doesn't have sun light . You didn't come from sky dude . All are homo sapiens

  • @qentrepreneurship9987
    @qentrepreneurship9987 3 роки тому +1

    Such concept is fully EURO CENTRIC AND CHRISTIAN...what humbuck.
    some fools continue achoeing such primitive mindsets.

    • @pureone8350
      @pureone8350 3 роки тому +1

      How is it Christian?

    • @necrotron5689
      @necrotron5689 2 роки тому

      Christians are the ones who proposed the idea of equality.

    • @AndrewArminRyan
      @AndrewArminRyan 2 роки тому +2

      Christianity entered Africa before it entered Europe.

    • @fallout1953
      @fallout1953 2 роки тому

      Cry.

    • @user-so2nm4gz6u
      @user-so2nm4gz6u 2 роки тому

      What concepts are you talking about?

  • @correctpolitically4784
    @correctpolitically4784 2 роки тому +1

    More like the myth , of the myth of race. It's not a construct and neither is gender.

    • @sasha69Xurgelash
      @sasha69Xurgelash Рік тому +3

      In the bible you guys claim to be Chrisitan show me one time they mention race!? They mention tribe's!

    • @correctpolitically4784
      @correctpolitically4784 Рік тому

      @@sasha69Xurgelash and they didnt mention cars either whats youre point ?