F1 Game Comparison (2010 - 2017 PIT Stop Gameplay Comparison)

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 26 сер 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 335

  • @Throneful
    @Throneful  6 років тому +1

    F1 Game Comparison (2010 - 2018 PIT Stop Gameplay Comparison)
    ua-cam.com/video/kjZ1VvHBGxg/v-deo.html

    • @saxon1963
      @saxon1963 5 років тому

      I don't want I don't want

    • @saxon1963
      @saxon1963 5 років тому

      F1 20000000000009

  • @miguelsaez340
    @miguelsaez340 7 років тому +570

    The guy responsible for pit stop entry maneuver animations should be fired

    • @AmericanHairlines69
      @AmericanHairlines69 7 років тому +27

      Miguel Sáez Yeah, that shit is pure garbage. And from 2010 it seems like...

    • @ivanplis5554
      @ivanplis5554 7 років тому +17

      2010 and 2011 are ok

    • @ferenctoth1801
      @ferenctoth1801 6 років тому +25

      the stop exits seems to be OK in 2017 but the netry is garbage as in all previous games.

    • @gabevalenzuela1356
      @gabevalenzuela1356 6 років тому

      Miguel Sáez they’re actually pretty accurate

    • @miguelsaez340
      @miguelsaez340 6 років тому +1

      Anonymous Anonymous in 2017, you should be able to spect more than what you get

  • @JonasH0707
    @JonasH0707 6 років тому +26

    0:57 you can hear the disappointment and anger in his voice
    “Go, go now and never come back“

  • @KierzYT
    @KierzYT 7 років тому +511

    4:27 honestly?

    • @flick6291
      @flick6291 7 років тому +1

      Kierz I don't get it?

    • @y0Special
      @y0Special 7 років тому +22

      12345 blue flag blue flag

    • @user-fr3ke7vz1v
      @user-fr3ke7vz1v 7 років тому

      Kierz I

    • @Borni84
      @Borni84 7 років тому +41

      honestly, What are we doing here?

    • @starby1243
      @starby1243 7 років тому +21

      Kierz Imagine if it was Alonso getting that radio, he'd be like I don't want anymore radio leave me alone you @#£&@

  • @noah_jnsz
    @noah_jnsz 7 років тому +240

    4:27 Oh lol it's ironic

  • @ryanbean28
    @ryanbean28 7 років тому +14

    3:50 the front wing they took off was Kimi's

  • @MGAviationNZAircraftVideos
    @MGAviationNZAircraftVideos 7 років тому +260

    Gosh F1 2014 sound is so Shit

    • @andyt9550
      @andyt9550 6 років тому +1

      Damn true

    • @MGAviationNZAircraftVideos
      @MGAviationNZAircraftVideos 6 років тому +3

      Joshua Kelm Yes may have been the transition from V8 to the V6 Era however Codemasters rushed it

    • @dudeonlygamingandotherstuf7791
      @dudeonlygamingandotherstuf7791 6 років тому +1

      i dunno why but the sound got fixed in 2015 and also engine

    • @Cousinouf
      @Cousinouf 6 років тому +2

      Well also in real life the noise was worse in 2014 than the years afterwards, the V6 improved

    • @Cousinouf
      @Cousinouf 6 років тому +1

      The game sound is still shit tho 😂

  • @radityaindera3442
    @radityaindera3442 7 років тому +96

    So 8 fucking years and they still cant get it right

    • @jasonvh8372
      @jasonvh8372 7 років тому +8

      Raditya Indera shut up
      Do it yourself then dumbass

    • @lnonno9321
      @lnonno9321 7 років тому +16

      JasonTT it's objectively unpolished and left shit

    • @bennybouken
      @bennybouken 6 років тому

      Anonymous Anonymous nope, still shit

  • @yoshifan04
    @yoshifan04 7 років тому +116

    Oh my god that F1 2014 engine sound......

  • @beazywhite7537
    @beazywhite7537 7 років тому +144

    Best F1 games
    1. F1 2010
    2. F1 2017
    3. F1 2013

    • @konts6611
      @konts6611 7 років тому +19

      The biggest difference has done in f1 2016 ...

    • @MessiahNerves
      @MessiahNerves 7 років тому +10

      1. F1 2013
      2. F1 2016
      3. F1 2017

    • @Edits_Panic0
      @Edits_Panic0 7 років тому +19

      1 2017
      2 2013
      3 2012
      4 2016
      5 2010

    • @c-woods1214
      @c-woods1214 7 років тому +11

      BEAZY WHITE I agree 2010 was so cool!

    • @beazywhite7537
      @beazywhite7537 7 років тому +2

      Brendon Dutra nah bro F1 2012 was shit because you got too much penalties for nothing

  • @IEleMenTIx
    @IEleMenTIx 7 років тому +40

    In 2015 automatic steering in pitlanes was introduced to F1....
    Honestly, if they could program the steering motion in 2010 and 2011 what went wrong after the games in 2015??? Is it because the new game engine doen't let them move the drivers arms in pit lanes? haha

    • @Fabianz
      @Fabianz 7 років тому

      IEleMenTIx 2013 already have automatic steering in pit.. maybe u shouldnt talk when you know nothin ^

    • @NoiseSignal
      @NoiseSignal 7 років тому +7

      still he is right. it's just really bad how the steering wheel moves and how the car enters his pit. he may be wrong about the time but do you really need to say it that way?

    • @IEleMenTIx
      @IEleMenTIx 7 років тому

      I didn't mean the automatic steering assist smartass.. it was meant to be ironic, it looks like if the cars pit automatically because theres no steering wheel motion in 2015 which looks idiotic

    • @MessiahNerves
      @MessiahNerves 7 років тому

      Its because he play on the pad the steering always looks shit on that

  • @hashrulsubzero
    @hashrulsubzero 7 років тому +38

    Little by little. We can see a small amount of changes on each of their games. For example, look at the wheel gun hoses as the car go through and besides it (see the car go through it at 1:32).

    • @krishnan9801
      @krishnan9801 6 років тому

      hashrulsubzero xx

    • @IStMl
      @IStMl 6 років тому

      The thing is, pitstops were still better in F1 2010 than 2017

  • @jamiengo2343
    @jamiengo2343 7 років тому +16

    2010 was so much fun

  • @reinodeespana7
    @reinodeespana7 5 років тому +3

    4:27
    Vettel: *Honestly?*
    Alonso: Jeff, *I love your sense of humour*

  • @alexxnnnn3161
    @alexxnnnn3161 7 років тому +63

    Gamefail: 3:50 they take of the frontwing with the number 7

    • @FLEX89
      @FLEX89 7 років тому +23

      not only that, but they don't seem to be in a hurry at all...

    • @thedaimerr
      @thedaimerr 7 років тому +4

      maybe 5 sec penalty assuming he hit the lotus since he also had to stop

    • @chris-kn8nx
      @chris-kn8nx 6 років тому +1

      FLEX he didn’t make the call to box, they weren’t ready

  • @KayoMichiels
    @KayoMichiels 7 років тому +27

    Anybody else noticed how creepy the guy (who took off the nose) is looking at you in the 2017 clip?

    • @brainstew1723
      @brainstew1723 7 років тому +8

      MK3424 he's got a helmet, how can you say he's creepy if you can't even see his face?

    • @andoidski
      @andoidski 5 років тому +1

      @@brainstew1723 he said the way the guy is looking at the player

    • @andoidski
      @andoidski 5 років тому

      @@brainstew1723 not the way he/she looks like

  • @lorenzorinna3097
    @lorenzorinna3097 7 років тому +142

    Why wets when dry

    • @thelegendofawesome4483
      @thelegendofawesome4483 7 років тому +42

      Lorenzo Rinna in the older games there were one set of drys and one set of wets and since the dry tyres are similar to today's hard compound, there was (usually) no need to fit an extra dry set.

    • @rabbitbaj134
      @rabbitbaj134 7 років тому +24

      In these games that is not the case, as if you do a normal race you have to pit else you get disqualified. It is probably because he didn't set the tyres to dry on the menu.

    • @TheMarksManBrBF4
      @TheMarksManBrBF4 7 років тому +1

      You're wrong. In F1 2010 for example, we have Option and Prime... Not only one set

    • @drs_tgc5446
      @drs_tgc5446 7 років тому

      Inters M8

    • @wezhowarth8981
      @wezhowarth8981 6 років тому

      Lorenzo Rinna I

  • @mathieuxavierluigiservant7423
    @mathieuxavierluigiservant7423 7 років тому +33

    2013 is the best by far

    • @luuduonghy659
      @luuduonghy659 4 роки тому

      2013 isn't the best, it is equally by 2014. 2010 is the worst, next is 2015.

  • @hugopetch5364
    @hugopetch5364 7 років тому +54

    I want f1 2018 to have like an overhead view of the pitstops

  • @davemeese6788
    @davemeese6788 7 років тому +28

    Why does the steering wheel not ten in 2015

    • @davemeese6788
      @davemeese6788 7 років тому

      *turn just a typo

    • @PsykoShox
      @PsykoShox 6 років тому

      Even in '17 it doesnt turn

    • @chris-kn8nx
      @chris-kn8nx 6 років тому

      formula 1 fan That’s because it elevens =P

  • @unknowngaming8022
    @unknowngaming8022 6 років тому +9

    I like the part where he pits

  • @skyecase5968
    @skyecase5968 7 років тому +6

    the graphics from 2016-2017 alone are a huge jump

    • @mclarenrob2
      @mclarenrob2 7 років тому +2

      the first proper ps4/xbox1 titles. Let's hope we see a similar jump with next gen

  • @210nitrous
    @210nitrous 7 років тому +19

    F1 2006 box exit is the most realistic, one day codemasters will get this right but for now 😖

  • @brainstew1723
    @brainstew1723 6 років тому +2

    For 2018 let’s hope they’ll make decent pit stop animations

  • @gst_styler2770
    @gst_styler2770 3 роки тому

    F1 2014 was the realest sound when the clutch appears on the pitstop

  • @TheFikri136
    @TheFikri136 7 років тому +26

    I think 2012 is the best.

  • @ElOscarbi
    @ElOscarbi 7 років тому +96

    blue flag bluue flag, blue flag! 4:27

  • @Mr.Goldbar
    @Mr.Goldbar 6 років тому +1

    F1 2012 had the best animations. F1 2014 and 2013 were really close though

  • @delirioususer9668
    @delirioususer9668 7 років тому +8

    1:04 AAAAARGH THEY'RE PUTTING WETS ON

  • @ludz5287
    @ludz5287 5 років тому

    3:28 That’s a slick Tyre!

  • @leventenagy4302
    @leventenagy4302 6 років тому +4

    So in f1 2016 they took kimis wing off sebs car.....

  • @tigerminolz1188
    @tigerminolz1188 5 років тому +1

    1 million views congratulation!!

  • @sovietonion72
    @sovietonion72 7 років тому

    The years weren't displayed making it confusing. But good video.

  • @SexyDragoness
    @SexyDragoness 6 років тому +1

    One thing never changes, the drivers never let go of that wheel. Wether in the garage, pit or flying through the air. They cling to that wheel for dear life. They probably walk around with that wheel between races.

    • @Vekkuli001
      @Vekkuli001 6 років тому

      The drivers let go of the wheel in garage, paddock, parc ferme and on track when celebrating...

    • @SexyDragoness
      @SexyDragoness 6 років тому +1

      Raz
      Yeah I saw that. Previously I had played 2016 where they almost never let go of the wheel.

  • @ANIMLFIRE
    @ANIMLFIRE 5 років тому

    That 2011 pitstop was hilarious, it tickled my giggle stick

  • @jasonquam695
    @jasonquam695 7 років тому +2

    My only thing is that no wing change on 2014

  • @Borni84
    @Borni84 7 років тому +41

    Congratilations to Codemasters! Seven years F1 Games with exactly the same grafics! Only higher resolution with new consoles.

    • @MessiahNerves
      @MessiahNerves 7 років тому +38

      you should visite specsavers

    • @pietrekk1
      @pietrekk1 7 років тому +2

      He shouldnt. He's right.

    • @alejandroarm5637
      @alejandroarm5637 7 років тому +10

      Borni84 typical rat kid who dont have money and dont buy it

    • @dylangittinger7351
      @dylangittinger7351 7 років тому +4

      Waw how can u notice there is no improvement ? You fuckin' blind mate ... Just look that crappy 2015 edition compared to the 2016 which is a little bit better than the 2017 and don't say there is the same graphics ...

    • @under3155
      @under3155 7 років тому

      first...i thought the same...

  • @Kislesko_YT
    @Kislesko_YT 6 років тому

    3:50 Has anyone noticed, that the front wing, the pit crew took off Vettel's car, has has a No. 7 on it instead of 5 ?

  • @thesupremetaco5435
    @thesupremetaco5435 6 років тому +2

    Although F1 2014 was awful, I do kind of like the pit stop animation.

  • @IMOLDGREGG252
    @IMOLDGREGG252 7 років тому +25

    Pitting should be a button mash reaction mini game.

    • @Simracer1990
      @Simracer1990 7 років тому +10

      IMOLDGREGG252 Like they had in F1 Championship Edition

    • @IMOLDGREGG252
      @IMOLDGREGG252 7 років тому

      Simracer1990 ahhh I never had that version. Surprised it wasn't well received and became a regular feature.

    • @fra_dp
      @fra_dp 7 років тому +7

      It would make no sense at all, since driver doesn't affect pit stop times. Plus, it would be ridiculous.

    • @IMOLDGREGG252
      @IMOLDGREGG252 7 років тому +7

      franchiceddhu90 well thank you for that input. Just an idea to give the player some more control could be a button reaction like game that means tyre changes etc are done quicker rather than the pits just being random. Just my opinion that it'd make it more interesting and in control all of all elements in a race.

    • @urielwolfsbane8098
      @urielwolfsbane8098 6 років тому

      IMOLDGREGG252 when the F1 license was on a Sony studio (Cambridge I think) they had that, unfortunately it was always the same pattern for fuel and tyres

  • @HeximilianM8
    @HeximilianM8 7 років тому +1

    In F1 2017, I dont know about other cars but for the force India, it is very hard to see when the light goes green.

  • @BrainSeepsOut
    @BrainSeepsOut 6 років тому

    Mmm, delicious 2010 brown and bloom. If it isn't brown with bloom, it ain't 2010 gaming.

  • @jayive34
    @jayive34 7 років тому

    2017 has track side commentaries? Sweet!

  • @julioacceus253
    @julioacceus253 6 років тому

    I think it should cut to a cam where your stopping like it's televised and cut back to you when the pit crew's done. At least should be optionable.

  • @elite13
    @elite13 6 років тому

    Good video but one question
    Why do all the pit crews put inters on when it’s dry whether -_-

  • @utry_daniel438
    @utry_daniel438 6 років тому

    They need to add full control of the car in the pit lane

  • @8170youngwilliam
    @8170youngwilliam 6 років тому

    Blue flags piss me off in this too. I was black flagged for ignoring the blue flags and Sainz and Palmer were between myself and Hamilton who was coming up behind in first lapping is. I was racing Sainz and Palmer!!!

  • @AlexsmithGT
    @AlexsmithGT 6 років тому +1

    2013 an 2014 are far more faster. they should make it realistic how it takes them only 2 sec to change a tire instead of 5 sec. i know it takes alittle longer in real life to also change the front wig but in the game 9 or 10 sec. now thats not right. codemaster still thinks this is the 1980s

  • @zwixelyt5737
    @zwixelyt5737 7 років тому

    Omg that F1 2017 puncture hurts me

  • @Throneful
    @Throneful  7 років тому +307

    F1 2010 - 00:00
    F1 2011 - 00:38
    F1 2012 - 01:13
    F1 2013 - 01:48
    F1 2014 - 02:22
    F1 2015 - 02:55
    F1 2016 - 03:32
    F1 2017 - 04:15

  • @heyemhehe7100
    @heyemhehe7100 6 років тому

    2012 pit crew looks so smooth and realistic.

  • @thatonechickenman8611
    @thatonechickenman8611 6 років тому

    I really hate it when the car comes into the pits (2014 and up) and the driver barely turns the wheel, and by the looks of it in the 2015 game they didn’t even bother making the wheel move at all. I really hope they fix it in the future

  • @saxon1963
    @saxon1963 5 років тому

    In 2019 game I would like to see glitches in pit like on early version

  • @DimiLopez_
    @DimiLopez_ 6 років тому +1

    In F1 2016 they Took him a nose With the number 7 out!

  • @Khyte
    @Khyte 6 років тому

    can't imagine playing f1 2018 with a halo

  • @BeastsAndDragons
    @BeastsAndDragons 6 років тому

    Did anyone notice that the front wing at 3:55 had number 7 on it

  • @ofeliatrapsi2814
    @ofeliatrapsi2814 6 років тому

    1. F1 2010
    2. F1 2011
    3. F1 2012
    4. F1 2015
    5. F1 2017
    6. F1 2016
    7. F1 2013
    8. F1 2014

  • @whysoslow1999
    @whysoslow1999 6 років тому

    In every single racing game, the pit stops get lazier and lazier when years go on.
    In 2020, you just roll through the pit lane to get your car fixed.
    Calling it.

  • @danishdezembro1116
    @danishdezembro1116 6 років тому

    The third one sounds awesome!

  • @gold333
    @gold333 7 років тому +1

    Strange how the graphics look the same with very little changes in 7 years. Still looks cartoony, I expected some photorealism by now.

    • @jasam4756
      @jasam4756 6 років тому

      yes I totally agree with you

  • @ditanugroho5654
    @ditanugroho5654 6 років тому

    looks like f1 2014 looks cool at pitstop

  • @muhammadshofwan5309
    @muhammadshofwan5309 7 років тому

    the F1 2010 seems the perfect pitstop

  • @DarkestCheese41
    @DarkestCheese41 6 років тому

    the tires in f1 2017 are thick af bra I would clap them fr

  • @markb721
    @markb721 7 років тому

    As a f1 2014 player, its safe to say that the ferrari engine sounds like your stepping on a piglet when you redline it

  • @ianshonga7136
    @ianshonga7136 7 років тому +3

    4:27

  • @SimonZellox
    @SimonZellox 6 років тому

    And after 7 years they still haven't learned how to animate the car to make it look realistic when he turns from the pit lane into the box. What the fuck.

  • @starby1243
    @starby1243 7 років тому +1

    I stopped playing racing games that won't allow me to drive in/out the pits by myself.

    • @FranciscoFJM
      @FranciscoFJM 6 років тому +8

      So you stopped playing racing games in the early 90s?

    • @fieldmartan4426
      @fieldmartan4426 6 років тому +2

      In assetto corsa you can do it. They don't treat you like a baby, if you fuck up stopping in the right place you literally either have to drive through or reverse which is against some online lobby rules.

  • @maurizza3499
    @maurizza3499 7 років тому

    15'-17' game has the better physics and engine sound in my opinion

  • @DumyG4m3r
    @DumyG4m3r 6 років тому

    F1 2017 looks Sooooo awesome

  • @noessika2765
    @noessika2765 7 років тому +1

    V10 engine to toyota prius engine

  • @gooner3193
    @gooner3193 7 років тому +1

    2012 was all in all the best game ever made - good sound, good AI, weather changes were going on rapidly, and the input lag didnt even exist in my opinion

    • @SF-yq7xq
      @SF-yq7xq 6 років тому

      Gooner so no more weather change in 17?

  • @SirMclaren
    @SirMclaren 6 років тому

    F1 2010 best engine sound

  • @aGmanproduction
    @aGmanproduction 6 років тому

    Why are the pit times so damn long? Isn't around 3s a decently long stop? Also, why would you need to be changing the front wing every time?

  • @adrianpaulfrancisco8875
    @adrianpaulfrancisco8875 7 років тому

    Those tire choices tho

  • @changhaoliu1222
    @changhaoliu1222 6 років тому

    The car turned, but he didn't turn the wheel...

  • @ianshonga7136
    @ianshonga7136 7 років тому

    Have u noticed he is in Australia and alonso

  • @cathyanderson1766
    @cathyanderson1766 5 років тому

    I love f1 games

  • @LXGMS-wk6ey
    @LXGMS-wk6ey 6 років тому

    BEST F1
    1 F1 2017
    2 F1 2013
    3 F1 2016

  • @legoldspy6851
    @legoldspy6851 6 років тому

    Who the fuck did those pit stop entry animations in f1 2015

  • @lecharentais135
    @lecharentais135 7 років тому

    The track is clear !

  • @nj3005
    @nj3005 6 років тому

    2010 was more accurate and better suit graphics in my opinion

  • @AvalancheOfficial
    @AvalancheOfficial 6 років тому

    3:58 why does Vettel have a Front wing with Kimis number?

    • @yonatanjesusgmailcom
      @yonatanjesusgmailcom 6 років тому

      the guy is in p22 i bet it's not the first front wing on that race, he finished his ones now continuing with the teammate ones

  • @mm11sslluuvv
    @mm11sslluuvv 4 роки тому

    2:35 to 2:40 what i call a real pitstop

  • @jonathandias592
    @jonathandias592 6 років тому

    V8s sounded like a devastatiom
    V6s Turbo sound like a cat whimp

    • @Mr.Goldbar
      @Mr.Goldbar 6 років тому +1

      what about the Mclaren MP4/4 and the Lotus 98T? did they also sound like cat whimps?

  • @danielalfonsodaniboy5906
    @danielalfonsodaniboy5906 4 роки тому

    Why are they putting you intermediates?

  • @MarcoCappio
    @MarcoCappio 6 років тому

    in F1 2016 quando a vettel tolgono l'alettone rotto, su quello non c'era il numero 5, ma il numero 7 (di Raikkonen)

  • @alessandrofarina2852
    @alessandrofarina2852 6 років тому

    In F1 2015 the wheels are turning without using the steering wheel

  • @BlackMonstered
    @BlackMonstered 6 років тому

    Love the pitstop of F1 2014

  • @alte5029
    @alte5029 6 років тому

    What is the name of the 2017 game one ?

  • @GenosGlory
    @GenosGlory 6 років тому +1

    I hated F1 2010 and the shitty forced fueling system. Always ran out of fuel. F1 2017 is my favourite and it has classic F1 cars what’s not to like.

  • @fernando929305
    @fernando929305 6 років тому

    2010 has a stuning sound, so loud.

  • @Us.chan07
    @Us.chan07 5 років тому

    1:32 wow

  • @hobattomi6067
    @hobattomi6067 6 років тому

    who is front? or no lifting in front?

  • @MrDieselakias
    @MrDieselakias 6 років тому

    Is F1-2010 compatible with THRUSTMASTER T-150???????

  • @dieselking6812
    @dieselking6812 6 років тому

    Why are you using rain tires

  • @rannygamer51
    @rannygamer51 7 років тому +3

    no 2015 o volante nem vira que doidera

  • @hamdanali9702
    @hamdanali9702 7 років тому

    Still dunno why f1 2010 looked like it had a sepia filter

    • @samueljones3668
      @samueljones3668 6 років тому

      Hamdan Ali Thats how all Codemaster games looked like in that era Grid, Dirt 1 and 2 all had that filter.

  • @jackholt9575
    @jackholt9575 7 років тому +4

    How is it possible for graphics to get worse?

    • @lucianoarebalo41
      @lucianoarebalo41 6 років тому +1

      Jack Holt you start watching at 5:00 and go in reverse

  • @ivanplis5554
    @ivanplis5554 6 років тому

    On F1 2016 Pit stop, Vettel´s car has the #7 front wing, and then is replaced with the #5. Wtf.

  • @samuelmuinoslejonbergh2358
    @samuelmuinoslejonbergh2358 6 років тому

    Why Did he use inters when it was dry?