Could Brock Purdy outlast the Lions without Deebo Samuel in NFC Championship? | THE CARTON SHOW
Вставка
- Опубліковано 7 лис 2024
- Deebo Samuel is 50/50 to appear in the San Francisco 49ers NFC Championship matchup against the Detroit Lions this weekend, and with Brock Purdy being known as a quarterback who relies heavily on his offensive weapons, many are questioning whether he'll be up to the task against the Lions' defense. Craig Carton defends Purdy against Greg Jennings and Willie Colon, who aren't so sure the Niners quarterback will shine in this game without Samuel.
#TheCartonShow #NFL #DeeboSamuel
SUBSCRIBE to get all the latest content from The Carton Show: sprtspod.fox/Su...
The all-new FOX Sports App, built for the modern sports fan: tinyurl.com/y4...
►Watch the latest content from The Carton Show: sprtspod.fox/Th...
▶First Things First's UA-cam channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
►UNDISPUTED’s UA-cam channel: foxs.pt/Subscri...
►SPEAK's UA-cam channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
►The Skip Bayless Show UA-cam Channel: sprtspod.fox/SU...
►What's Wright? with Nick Wright UA-cam Channel: sprtspod.fox/wh...
Follow The Carton Show on Twitter: / thecartonshow
Like The Carton Show on Facebook: / thecartonshowonfs1
Follow The Carton Show on Instagram: / thecartonshow
Follow The Carton Show on TikTok: / thecartonshow
About The Carton Show:
The Carton Show is a daily sports show live from New York City featuring Craig Carton, who will take on the day's breaking stories alongside a rotating group of co-hosts. Watch The Carton Show Monday-Friday at 7 AM ET on FS1.
Could Brock Purdy outlast the Lions without Deebo Samuel in NFC Championship? | THE CARTON SHOW
• Could Brock Purdy outl...
The Carton Show
/ thecartonshow
Check out The Carton Show on TikTok: www.tiktok.com/@thecartonshow
there is some personal stuff going on here by the reactions from these guys. he obviously struck a nerve is surrounded by pro bowl or potential hall of fame talent and yet Purdy is the one that gets called out on everything. they talk about the wet ball performance but ignore Love throwing the game away choking in the moment. dont think its purdy but the 49ers they hate. they hate the success. they want to see them fail
Get that clown Jennings off the show!
I'm convinced the media doesn't even watch the games. Brock has made TONS of difference making plays this year
It’s just for clicks bro. They can’t be that blind or just plain stupid. People should be praising him for what he has done instead of putting him down and to compare him to Jimmy G. Is just ridiculous.
It’s definitely not the same as having Jimmy G
yeah I am pretty sure him scrambling out to the right and throwing that dime to Kittle for a TD was making a difference. I am sure that him driving down the field to win the game was him making the difference. Something no other QB has done under Kyle S.
Fields over Purdy? That's beyond stupidity...😅
No it isn't. Fields doesn't see the field for sh*t. Just because someone has a strong arm doesn't make him elite
**Edit** I definitely misread your comment. I'm sorry! 😂
That's coming from the same guy who called Daniel Jones a top 10 qb after a season where he threw 16tds, Greg is literally the worst qb analyst out there he has no idea what a good qb looks like
I think the real problem for these two clowns in the middle is the way Purdy looks. Purdy replaced Trey Lance and that makes them angry and irritated for reasons that are pretty obvious. If Trey Lance had worked out with SF and was still with the team doing 50% of what Purdy is doing right now they'd be singing a different tune, they'd be all over Trey...
it's because fields is black and purdy is white. Jennings has been crazy racist since he started on tv
First year Justin had protection well Brock's never had a great oline
Thanks Craig for sticking up for my guy Brock!
How bout this....In the time that Brock has been the starting QB for the San Fran 49ers, his winning percentage is greater than Mahomes, Allen, Jackson, and every other qb in the league. And his includes 4 playoff games and regular season games against the ravens, the cowboys, the eagles just to name a few. He has spent most of his career playing against good teams, playoff teams, and he has the winningest record in the nfl during that time.
purdy can throw 8 tds and people will still say “its his team not him”
They will say the football threw itself.
Saying the Niners had the same success with Jimmy G is insane. For example, average score per game increased by about 10 points. Four players over 1000 yards this year.
I’ve been a long time Niners fan and it was obvious the difference between a Jimmy led offense compared to Brock. Under Brock he had Kittle and Aiyuk surpass 1k yards and almost for Deebo. And these weren’t check downs. For them to use Jimmy as an example is idiotic.
Greg Jennings went into hiding after the NFC championship game lol
As a 49er fan, who's watched every single snap, Brock Purdy brings a lot more to the QB position that Jimmy ever did. Do your research, stop being lazy and loud.
I'm not racist at all. I'm a Hispanic with a black guy as my best friend but out of all the talking heads, it's always the black guys hating the most on Purdy
Except for Richard Sherman
idk man nick wright, colin cowherd are some of his biggest haters.
@@juniorc1521 I would say it's fairly even. Although I do see that the people shredding Brock tend to have an affinity with running QBs and arm strength. Kinda odd, because even though Brock is more of a pocket QB, he's quick enough to extend plays with his legs, and although his arm strength isn't mind-blowing, he led the league in yards per attempt.
I loved Jimmy G when he played for my 49ers, but there is NO WAY he could have elevated these weapons into what Brock did this year. Heck when we were in the red zone, a TD is a rare treat against good teams as most of the time we knew it was most likely a FG by Gould. Not with Brock. Even in a losing effort against Baltimore, he drove it back within striking distance the first half. However, we get it. Mainstream sports media never liked Purdy because they view him as physically inferior to the bigger, stronger, faster, rocket-arm type of QBs they love. Purdy is one of only 3 people in NFL history to take his team to conference championships his first two years and still gets no credit. It has now become SF win=system/team and SF Loss=Purdy type of show.
People forget that the Niners only let Jimmy throw a combined like 20 times on the way to the Super Bowl. Purdy was allowed to throw 39 times in a rainy game because Kyle knew he would get it done.
Great point
Purdy isn't Mahomes or Lamar. Nobody says he is. He plays a very different style than those cats. It's more of a throw back, old school style. Purdy is smart, makes great decisions, is incredibly accurate and efficient.
Purdy almost gave away the division round away in the first qtr. Could have had 4 interceptions easily. He does what he has to do. Luckily for Purdy the talent around him hides all what he lacks. Still don't know why folks are not talking about Greenlaw winning that game for the offense and defense, played like he was on dry grass and everyone else in a wet storm.
couldve wouldve shoudlve lol what really happened is he led the game winning drive@@BayAreaSun
@@BayAreaSun The niners won that game. Purdy did not throw any interceptions.
@@BayAreaSun You mean he didn't do what the other worldly Jordan Love actually did? Almost means NOTHING at the end of the day.
Lmao! Justin Fields over Brock from the guy who said Daniel Jones was top 10 is pretty incredible
I find it amusing that the two "non-difference making" quarterbacks both led their teams to the NFC championship.
☝️
Lol so true. Real question is: where all your difference makers at? Home? Okay we'll ignore you 😂
Purdy *throws 10 tds for 1200 yards in a game. "Yeah, but did you see those potential dropped picks??"
To compare Fields and Purdy, just show how much they dislike Purdy. Jennings is willing to give Fields a chance but Purdy gets zero credit for what he has done.
Jennings is a Clown and lost all credibility, when he claimed D. Jones(Giants) was a top 5, TOP 5, quarterback at the beginning of the season.
Purdy is head and shoulders better than Fields merely from between the ears. This is like Pentium 7 vs Pentium 3 microchip comparison. Processing speed for Brock is much faster when he goes through his reads than Justin Fields. I use this analogy because Carlton calls Brock "the machine".
It is because he can run fast. Idiots like Jennings think that is what every great QB should be able to do.
This guy doesn’t know the difference between jimmy G and Purdy.😂
Brock being Jimmy is insane. If Jimmy was playing like Brock early in this game, Kyle would of resorted to running the ball. 39 pass attempts in a close game & the guy pulled it off.
Bro said "if you are a niner fan you know that" bro I'm a niner fan and I know he's different, Purdy is head and shoulders better than Jimmy G and I'm a Jimmy G fan.
Jimmy G WAS NEVER EVEN CLOSE TO BROCKS BUMBERS. STOP IT.
I am a 49er fan .. i lived it... maybe do a stat comparison where garapollo and prudy are during there years.. because i could tell right off the bat we got better with purdy
Brock's IQ is always overlooked and barely mentioned. One of the fastest processors there is. Extremely intelligent and poised. Those are his strong traits. Not height, speed, or arm strength.
Jennings lost any credibility he had for being a former player. WHEN did Jimmy LEAD the nfl in 20+ 30+ 40+ yard passes, ypa, airypa, TD %, cmp%, passer rating, 1st down %, 3rd in TDs, 5th in yards, 4th in air yards, while only 20TH in attempts behind a bottom 10 ranked pass blocking line. WHEN did Jimmy G ever do that Greg???????
So if we’re saying Kyle went to the Super Bowl with jimmy g as his quarterback discrediting Brock Purdy, can we say the same thing about John Harbaugh WINNING a Super Bowl with Joe Flacco at quarterback? But I guess Lamar is greatest quarterback with nothing around him and Brock Purdy is trash. I can’t stand these talking heads.
This the same guy that said Daniel jones is a top 10 qb
If people actually pay attention to the Brock Purdy saga he beat out Trey lance out of the building and he’s the starting quarterback over Sam darnold even after a huge elbow injury. He wins the nfc west conference and still in the final four to get to Super Bowl! I think if he didn’t get injured last year they would have beat the eagles and went to Super Bowl. But this year he’s still writing his script. There will always be doubters even if they win because this team is stacked with talent! But if you pay really close attention the defense is not the same as last year and Brock Purdy himself is making the offense play better despite of having cmc. He’s a third down machine! And not just short passes but gutsy over the middle with double coverage!
Jennings lost all credibility. What an abomination of a take
When I see Jennings name comes out I don't even bother to watch cos his incessant hatred towards Brock Purdy yields ridiculous takes. These idiots never watch the tapes but gives opinion they are not entitled to give.
Raheem rushed for four touchdowns in 2019 NFC Championship Game
In 2021 Jimmy Garoppolo threw zero touchdowns in the NFC Championship Game
Jimmy Cost us Championship wins. Brock has played leagues better than Jimmy ever did
Comparing Jimmy G to Brock isn’t even a contest. I could tell these guys don’t watch Niners games or Niners Film.
Seriously. I’m a 49ers fan. Our offense is so clearly better with Purdy than it was with Jimmy. Like come on.
Yall make no sense. If Patrick played for us you wouldn't use the team or coach element is why they winning
Carton...please tell those clowns that SHANAHAN HAS NEVER HAD A QB AS GOOD AS BROCK! NOT EVEN RYAN! Thats a reality. So get all those clowns off your show.
What do you mean? Difference maker. He led the team down the field for the game winner. Love didnt do it, allen didnt do it, flacco didnt do it... what more difference do you need. The difference between winning the game and losing that game was brock Purdy doing his job....
some people don't have the mental capacity to perform that kind of critical thinking
The niners going after Brady or Rogers to replace Purdy shows how high of a bar Purdy has set.
Ya they moved up to get Lance and he lost his job to Purdy playing better. Not a good argument there.
Brock leading the 9ers to a 31- 20 win
Jimmy g ain’t do the same thing
What Justin Fields over Brock!?😂Brock is a high IQ qb and also has quick feet if he has to. Most qb/rb are always running for their lives😅
Mans said Justin fields . 🤧
Who hired Greg Jennings to talk sports? Fire the guy that hired greg please for making us listen to this guy for even a second
he talks alot but doesn’t say anything. he doesn’t give reasoning for his negativity, but it’s obviously because he’s a salty ex-Packer who couldn’t beat the 49ers in the playoffs
Last time I checked Jimmy G threw 8 passes in the NFC Championship because we didn't trust him throwing the ball. Jimmy G isn't the 49ers franchise leader in Pass yards even though he had more time with the team 🤔 Jimmy G didn't lead the league in ANY QB PASSING CATEGORIES 🤔 so are we talking fact's and stats or are we talking because they're waiting for him to fail but he keeps proving them wrong making them look like they don't know what they're talking about when it comes to football, so now it's developed into pure hatred 🤣
I bet they are democrats
Jimmy G would have lost the game vs the packers like he did on every potential game winning drive he has been in post season
Hey Craig, you don’t have to do the “all he does is win” narrative for Brock. Just pull up his numbers and show film like Deebo said because clearly these guys don’t look at that.
The argument to put Mahomes on the Niners doesn't even make sense... Unless Mahomes would like to take a pay cut... The reason Purdy is so valuable is because of how cheap his contract is and how well he is playing. There's no other QB that compete with his skill and pay.
Greg Jennings is just a salty ex-Packer who could never beat the 49ers in the playoffs. Notice how he’s talking alot but not saying anything.
Did Jimmy have 4 1000 yard from scrimmage players? NO, why? cause he's not as good as Purdy who has lifted his teams play. Yeah, LIFTED his teammates play, like you refuse to see. Take off your Purdy blinders and quit being so idiotic. Justin Fields as of right now couldn't carry Purdy's jock.
These guys are looking through racist lenses.
What!! Justin Field is a difference maker, according to Greg. Jenning. If Justin Field is that good then why Chicago Bear thinking about part away from him. @Greg Jenning is a hater, only wanna support his own kind.
It the swing because it so large from last to top 5, it like when Jack London say the coldest day he ever felt was a summer day in San Francisco, when he has been in Alaska. The swing in temperature makes it feel colder when it clearly not.
Yeah trey lance excellled in that offense😂 funny everyone played well in that offense
The HATERS 💯 do NOT watch the Niners tape! They watch highlights. Dude just turned 24 and balls out. No QB has a perfect game every game! Stop the BS and slander of this kid! Just appreciate the greatness that he puts out and he’s only going to get better. To compare him to Jimmy is hilarious. Jimmy not even on the same planet! Even on his best days…
Jimmy G was not a MVP/candidate. Jimmy was terrible on the deep ball. The criticism would be legitimate if it was Jimmy. Brock was leading in most QBs stats.
Anybody who doesn't see how different the offense looks with Brock compared to Jimmy doesn't actually watch the games. I don't know how anyone can't see the difference
@@strawberryreacts9585 and also there was 2 weeks of preparation with Deebo being a big puzzle piece. That’s what people don’t understand is how the offense changed completely when Deebo got hurt. It also shows that Brock can adapt. I like that he was able to run a spread. Kyle’s play action doesn’t fool anybody when we’re down… I loved what I saw in Purdy Saturday and I’m more confident moving forward (as long as it’s not raining🤪)
@@chicotata agreed!
Greg’s hurt part of his rant has touch emotion on it. It’s all right the packers will be back in the conversation.
Dude might have less hair but he has more brains lol
They really hate the organization just using purdy as the dart board
I've never seen this show but dude on the left speaks absolute truth. I think this is his show. OK so the 3 dudes on the right, the middle guy is a complete hater and lost in his own bias.
The fact that he compared Jimmy G to Purdy was enough for me. Now he’s just grasping at straws
So refreshing to see someone callout the pure hatred that these so called analysts hold. It'll take Purdy multiple Super Bowls for them to eat their words, when they're putting other players, with less success, up on a pedestal.
definitely, 4-3 without deebo... people forget he went 3-0 without deebo as a rook
Yup and the 3 losses are Deebo AND Trent.
@@martinyourbro this! Without Trent the oline is one of the worst in the league for pass blocking. The run game suffers without him also
Purdy has been to more championship games then Lamar Jackson. IJS purdy had the best statical year any QB the 9ers ever had and the jury is still out for the championship but it's looking very good. to mention Justin fields with purdy is like mentioning purdy with Maholmes at this moment. c'mon man.
It shows what his idea of a GOOD QB is. He thinks they have to be runners, period. Running does not make you a game changer. It just means you can run. People like him are beyond DUMB!
Brock could literally win a superbowl and superbowl mvp and they still would say it’s the player’s around him
"Take mediocre QB's and win games" - Check the stats dude. They trust the pass with Purdy more than any other mediocre QB. Every other season was Defense led and Run game led. This season is 100% Pass led. common man
Question did Patrick Mahomes or Lamar Jackson lead the League in "Every Passing Categorie"when they were in first or second year"NO They Didn't 😂
The guy who criticizes Goff & Purdy believes Justin Fields is a difference maker. Goes to show how much he knows about football. Just because you played in NFL doesn't make you an expert analyst. He lost all credibility in my book.
Greg stop hating on San Francisco please. Detroit isn’t America’s team the Cowboys were supposed to be America’s team. I just seen a survey a few weeks ago. On Undisputed that had San Fran above the Cowboys as America’s team.
Ya’ll think u can just plug and play a QB. U cant put an athletic QB that cant read Defense(Fields) and say he’s gonna be more productive than Purdy. 🤦♂️
@CARTON SHOW THIS IS WHAT IM TALKING ABOUT.. YALL SITTING AROUND TALKING ABOUT BROCK ESPN TALKING ABOUT COWBOYS DRAMA!!! 😂😂
I absolutely love Purdy as a niner fan, but ya Purdy is not in the same class as the top guys. Both things can be true. Purdy is very good and has some mental elite traits but many people doubted Tom Brady until he won multiple championships so I’m ok with showing Purdy that same level of doubt. He deserves credit because he is the best QB the niners have ever had under Kyle with the niners but no he is not in the same category of the greats. At least not yet. He needs to win the SB and then continue to play at a high level and maybe win another to be in the conversation. Eli Manning is an average quarterback and yet he is going to the hall of fame because he played out of his mind and above his skill level to win 2 SB’s. Purdy can do the same but he hasn’t yet.
Historic numbers can’t be ignored. He’s definitely been playing great football.
@@707romo707 totally agree with you and I hope he keeps it up so niners win the SB. I still would trade him for Pat, Lamar, or Allen any day of the week. Also yes I would make the huge mistake of trading Tom Brady for A Rod early in their careers because A rod looked like a better QB but we all know now he is not. So if Purdy turns out to be like Tom then I will agree that my thinking was wrong on Purdy but no one will admit they were wrong if Purdy turns out to be just a good QB and not an elite QB.
@@DavidECoy I think that's fair. But the one guy also said he would take Fields over Purdy which is ridiculous imo (Fields doesn't process well at all, he doesn't see the field and misses wide open guys). He then went on to compare him to Jimmy G which is just ridiculous. Purdy is a clear upgrade over Jimmy G. The truth is Purdy lies somewhere in the middle.
Also I think people get a little too hung up on the physical traits of a QB. It takes more to play QB than a rocket arm and fast 40. I prefer pocket passers that are mobile, but that is just me.
You don't know football if ur calling Eli an average qb....
@@SoloDoloToker well in ur opinion I guess I don’t know football. In my opinion I know enough to say the guy is average. I respect ur opinion but I disagree.
Greg Jennings is a hater plain and simple,.despises Brock Purdy with his core. PURDY DOES ELEVATE HIS TEAM Jimmy did none of this
Joe Burrow doesn't have a SB, Josh Allen doesn't have one, Lamar doesn't have a SB either
"No, he is not." y’all realize that Deeboo is talking to all of you! Brock Purdy led the league in almost every single meaningful stat this season over all of those MVP players you all are so offended were brought up. He did this in his first full season as a starter.
"He doesn't have an MVP or Super Bowl ring" is one of the stupidest things I've ever heard as a knock on Purdy. Well, of course not. He has only been in the league for two years. How would he have won the MVP last year when he came in halfway through the season? He didn't get a ring? He suffered a season-ending injury in last year's conference title. How many players do you know, let alone those MVP players, have won a Super Bowl and MVP in their rookie year while coming in halfway through the season?
"Look at what Jimmy did." "Niner fans, you know." Yes, we do know, and from the get-go, we saw that Purdy was better than Jimmy. Not only do we see that, but the stats show that. Purdy broke our single record for passing yards this year; Jimmy never did that. Purdy has been the most efficient QB under Shanahan since Matt Ryan.
If the system just makes QBs great, how come Trey Lance isn't our starter? Why isn't Sam Darnold? Trey Lance and Sam were the 3rd overall picks in their respective draft classes. By those perspectives, they should be better than Purdy and the starter for the Niners, and yet they aren't. Why was Jimmy G traded away if he was such a talent and the system just needs anyone to make it great?
Can you all just be honest and just say you hate Purdy so we can get past all of these ridiculous arguments?
I bet if Purdy had dreadlocks and tattoos and was darker they would love him
Didn’t Alex Smith lead the Chiefs to a Championship game the season before Mahomes??.. why don’t we criticize that??.. Also the Niners made a superbowl without CMC as well, but no one uses that logic to discredit him
Saying Purdy is no better than Jimmy G, that just shows how little you watch Niners football... Jimmy G got carried to the SB with the best defense and a great running game... He never threw the ball deep... Purdy is #1 on 20+ yards
Never has a home said watch the tape on Jimmy all we said was he wins 2 big differences
Sam Darnold can not do what Purdy does with the same weapons 🤷♂️
carton you got some real clowns on your podium
Subbed
He says if he doesn't win you need to go get someone else. How about Josh Allen? He hasn't gotten to an AFC championship. Justin Fields is a joke. He isn't getting his next team to the playoffs.
Purdy is 23-6 including playoffs, Trevor Lawrence is 21-31. Jags could use some help.
Thanks Craig!
Brock is better at footwork and moving on to read 1,2,3 and layering balls with better touch and faster at it, oh.. 10 yard split is the same as Lamar...that's about it...which is impressive...not a stronger arm or faster..but elite processing and layering anticipatory balls...
Doesn’t Purdy got more play offs wins than Lamar???
Explain to me how Brock will ever prove they won because of him when he is NEVER given credit for all of the success he's had so far? You want him to win with no talent? Every winning QB has talent around them. These shows just spew some Brock nonsense because they know it will go viral.
Stop criticizing Goff who took 2 teams to the NFC championship, & one of them to superbowl. What is Lamar Jackson's record in playoffs?
I have nothing against Lamar but I have to root against him just to shut these racist sports analyst up. Greg Jennings and his crew are more stupid than the 3 musketeers
Next Jennings is gonna say Trey Lance over Purdy.
Justin Fields didn't make a difference on the Bears' season and never has, how do you figure?
So it’s okay that fields have weapons but not Purdy
Brock Purdy is a Top 12 - 15 in the league! Brock is a difference maker and is not a game manager.
Jennings didn't watch film, Jimmy won playoffs games throwing less than 150yds and with 12 completions!
Against the Lions - 315yds (pass and run)
Do some research and watch film!
jauan jennings is no slouch and has had some good catches...chris conley has the experience ...not worried about it
Jimmy G “lit it up “?? lol
Jimmy did have the same casts but did not put up the same ridiculous numbers.
Can't smash the thumbs up harder or more than 1x SMH. Great take Carson
Jimmy g was never top in NFL in almost every category. Lol. Dude even says fields better and admitted he had decent talent this year. He didn't win. Purdy is winning and in NFC championship...
Every single skill position of the niners had a career year... why? Because of Purdy. They were good with jimmy g but kittle and everyone was having average years. Only player that always been Productive has been deebo because of his versatility. Let me put it like this with jimmy g at qb our skill position players were always hurt. Why? Because jimmy g was throwing hospital balls where the receiver can barely turn before getting rocked. Purdy doesn't do that he throws it in spots where only his receiver can catch it and throws it low if he feels his receiver will be in trouble after the catch he knows where to place a ball. I watch every niner game every single snap and all season I only seen Purdy throw one bad hospital ball to kittle other than that his decision making has been elite.
You’ve been spot , fair and objective..as I said..the national media NFL has been pushing DEI see my post below.
I’m sorry I loved JimmyG when he was with the niners but he couldn’t hit the deep ball if his life depended on it, escape from pressure, or read defenses.
PS: Greg Jennings hating on purdy cuz he was on the packers 😂
I can't take this guy serious on any show that he's on. Justin Fields, what a joke.
If 49ers can plug any qb in and be successful. Then their argument is flawed brcause it didnt work with lance
Puka is the best rookie wr.. and i think lamars mvp case is a joke.. flowers a stud, but puka different... i value truth more than anything... Brock the truth... dude has bad games like anyone else, but when he firing(most of the time) dude is an assassin
The hatred runs deep amongst the black sports analyst and to even suggest Kyles get Fields because he's a "difference maker" ? Difference maker in what exactly? Wow....