The Cause of Anti-Semitism- Rav Aharon Feldman shlita

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 27 січ 2025

КОМЕНТАРІ • 140

  • @jonathandaniel2754
    @jonathandaniel2754 26 днів тому +8

    Rabbi Aharon Feldman was my favorite teacher when I was at Yeshivat Ohr Somayach back in 1973 - 1974.

  • @mattnewhouse1781
    @mattnewhouse1781 29 днів тому +10

    I've never seen this Rabbi before. I like him. My father, who survived the holocaust told me as a child the reason for antisemitism was one word: jealousy.

    • @Xanzia1972
      @Xanzia1972 27 днів тому +1

      Lol...nope.

    • @pbinnj3250
      @pbinnj3250 26 днів тому

      An American, a friend of the Jews, was asked by a Jew, “What can we do to make them stop hating us?” His one word answer was. “Fail.” Unlike most prejudice, the world is shocked that Jews succeed despite our small numbers. This is certainly true when it comes to Islam. Muslims are taught that theirs is the last and final revelation of God. But they face being so far behind the rest of the world. That undermines the entire premise of their religion, which told them they should conquer the world for Allah. (And to never return anything they conquered. See the Hamas charter, section 11.) Jewish success is the ultimate humiliation for Muslims who are so backward.

    • @elizabethmelnychuk6034
      @elizabethmelnychuk6034 24 дні тому +3

      So true! Thomas Sowell said the same thing.

    • @ruthietaylor8756
      @ruthietaylor8756 5 днів тому

      Yes loud and clear​@@Xanzia1972

  • @leowise206
    @leowise206 Місяць тому +9

    Some clear direction from Maran Rosh haYeshivah shlitah, even though I feel a bit like a sheigitz watching Kewoid Toraso on the internet, nevertheless I am very grateful for these videos. Our lights in the darkness the Gedoilei Torah Shlitah. It fills me with love for the Aibishter that He has given us outstanding Tzaddikim like the Rosh Yeshiva. Please keep posting....

    • @pbinnj3250
      @pbinnj3250 Місяць тому +1

      May I suggest that you spell “moron” differently? Perhaps “Moróne”. Your spelling is the same as an English word with an opposite meaning. Long press the “o” to get the accent marks.

    • @yochimevaseret4878
      @yochimevaseret4878 21 день тому

      Are you serious?

  • @pbinnj3250
    @pbinnj3250 26 днів тому +2

    He was needed at Ner Israel after the Rosh Hayeshiva passed away.

  • @kristine8338
    @kristine8338 Місяць тому +10

    An antisemite doesn’t make the differences this Rabbi is making. Unite Israel, unite. We need you 🗺️🇮🇱🗺️. ❤

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому

      Excellent nuanced observation.
      I'm not accepted by his crowd but I am seen by The hating crowd as of the crowd therefore I disagree with his sermon but here we are

  • @bijithomas2026
    @bijithomas2026 18 днів тому +1

    Shalom Good morning Rabbai

  • @Andy-yc3bq
    @Andy-yc3bq Місяць тому +6

    HaShem bless you Rav.

  • @Nola-2000
    @Nola-2000 15 днів тому

    10:18 the spiritual ascetism is found also in catholcism, hinduism, islam, buddism, taoism. All against self worship. And so the set of values to value spiritual over material is there in many religions.

  • @jacobsalomon6800
    @jacobsalomon6800 17 днів тому +1

    הרב צודק לגבי הרפורמים אך לא לגבי הציונות
    יש גם ציונות דתית ולא רק החילונית שאנחנו מכירים מביאליק ובן גוריון
    חבל שהחרדיות לא רוצה להתקרב לציונות הדתית

  • @lisaschuster686
    @lisaschuster686 Місяць тому +1

    Listen to what Netanyahu said about America today. Rest your weary soul.

  • @adamyitzhak9907
    @adamyitzhak9907 Місяць тому +4

    The gechazis are being awakened n the comment section

  • @judaismtreasures9606
    @judaismtreasures9606 23 дні тому +2

    He is great

  • @Xanzia1972
    @Xanzia1972 27 днів тому +4

    I suggest that you do not use the Bible as a land deed.

  • @HillelPorath
    @HillelPorath Місяць тому +2

    I find it somewhat odd that a great Rav is not living in Eretz Yisroel.

    • @mgold3986
      @mgold3986 Місяць тому

      Why should the Rav move to a country that is the most dangerous place to live for Jews?

    • @iljab.3302
      @iljab.3302 Місяць тому

      ​@@mgold3986Israel is the safest place on earth

    • @yochimevaseret4878
      @yochimevaseret4878 21 день тому +2

      He did for many decades and moved back to the US when the yeshiva he currently heads requested his leadership. Must have been a hard decision.

    • @HillelPorath
      @HillelPorath 21 день тому

      @yochimevaseret4878 I still find it odd

    • @mgold3986
      @mgold3986 20 днів тому

      @@HillelPorath Why should the Rav? Israel is the most dangerous place to live. A Jew is not allowed to put himself/herself in a sakana.

  • @ThomasMullan-r5s
    @ThomasMullan-r5s Місяць тому +1

    Well said it the Israel government to blame not the Israel people

  • @iceberg1229
    @iceberg1229 Місяць тому +7

    Its a real mystery why nobody has sympathy for armed settlers being slain while stealing and squatting on peoples land

    • @eoinfitzpatrick1185
      @eoinfitzpatrick1185 Місяць тому

      Zionists are no different to nazis. Hitler used germanic descent and the downturn of fortunes to galvanise his position steal control of power and manipulate the German people into believing that strength was the answer, to do away with their past frailties. Hitler needed war and it us well documented that the Germans were incompetent and shit workers in the 30s. If it weren't for the war effort they would never have done as much damage and achieved so much under Hitler. This is the same with netenyahu, literally facism parallel. If it's not fascism in Israel then the nazis too are not fascism absolutely

    • @oorderconnect2188
      @oorderconnect2188 Місяць тому +9

      Israel is a sovereign state created by the UN at a time when many states were created. There was a partition plan to have a Palestinian state in that area which was rejected by that side.

    • @pbinnj3250
      @pbinnj3250 Місяць тому +6

      I assume you feel the same way about Puerto Rico, and want anyone not born there ejected. You know Yassar Arafat was from Egypt, right? And almost a million Israelis come from Arab countries they were ejected from? And that the West Bank ended up in Israel because of a war started by Arabs? AND
      The West Bank before 1967 was Jordanian, and Jordan was never asked why they don’t give that land to Palestinians. And Gaza was owned by Egypt and Egypt was never asked to make it Palestinian. Only after an unprovoked war started by the Arab countries did people demand Israel give it to the Palestinians.

    • @iceberg1229
      @iceberg1229 29 днів тому

      @pbinnj3250 if thee stealing from Puerto Ricans then yes, Arafat birthplace is irrelevant, mizrahi news were always aliens in Muslim land, and why should Arabs tolerate a settler colony of invaders?

    • @shlogoff
      @shlogoff 29 днів тому

      @@iceberg1229 excellent! You're able to repeat hamas's talking points to justify October 7th and all the terrorist attacks before and after.
      You get a free kafiya.
      Now try to connect this fantasy to reality, and show how
      1, the unarmed victims were "armed settlers"
      2, they "stole" land
      3, and they were "squatting".
      Take your time.

  • @danielpincus221
    @danielpincus221 Місяць тому +5

    It sounds like Rav Aharon Feldman has never met a righteous Muslim, or a pious Catholic, or a devout Protestant, or a Buddhist of any kind, or an other spiritual gentile. In his vision, either the righteous frum Jews, or the selfish, lascivious, murderous others. How limited. Bad, sad.

    • @andrewdavidshiller4158
      @andrewdavidshiller4158 Місяць тому +5

      I didn't get that sense from what said. He talked about jealousy, lust, and honor-seeking--self-worship. I didn't hear the slightest indication that he believes a sincere practitioner of one of those other faiths is absorbed in self-worship.Sounds like you missed his point.

    • @lesweizman388
      @lesweizman388 27 днів тому

      they dont exist....they are all oved avodah zarah

    • @donquijotedelamancha3529
      @donquijotedelamancha3529 26 днів тому +1

      @@andrewdavidshiller4158 I don't think DanielPincus missed the point at all.

    • @Nola-2000
      @Nola-2000 15 днів тому

      ​@@andrewdavidshiller4158
      10:18 the spiritual ascetism is found also in catholcism, hinduism, islam, buddism, taoism, zoroastrianism. All against self worship. And so the set of values to value spiritual over material, simplicity over pride, there in many religions.

    • @Nola-2000
      @Nola-2000 15 днів тому

      ​@@andrewdavidshiller4158 Spiritual ascetism is found in catholcism, hinduism, islam, buddism, taoism. All against self worship. And so the set of values to value spiritual over material, simplycity over pride there in many religions.

  • @מכוןברכתדוד
    @מכוןברכתדוד Місяць тому +4

    i dont wanna disrespect the rabbi i know he is a great man, but clearly he is disconnected from what is going on in israel. the torah here is a million times better, and the facilitator of the jewish conscious, we could connect to the rest of the world wirelessly. it is wrong to suggest that understanding what it means to be a jew doesn't include living in israel. and the ruling that all gentiles hate jews is wrong, they may have an inclination to hate and many fall, but non jews can surly be righteous and good, it sorta seems like he should of referred to them as humans that God immensely loves instead of only suggesting they are like wolfs, and some of us will suffer. perhaps what it means to be a jew would include motivating people to move to israel so that their kids don't assimilate as the reformers you mentioned, yet he prefers to keep allowing jewish school tuition to be so high and let the people continue sending to public schools and assimilate, the main thing is never to suggest that israel has plenty of areas that one could live in and conduct a fruitful religious life. and also these secular zionists perhaps still have a spark of yiddishkeit that if you would teach them moreh nevuchim and rav shamshon refael hirsh and so on it would do them good, instead American yeshivish jewery simply threw out study of jewish philosofy.

    • @lisaschuster686
      @lisaschuster686 Місяць тому

      Think of the tens of millions of us with one Jewish grandparent. It hits us viscerally when a Jew is in jeopardy. Jews should breed all over the world.

    • @gileadprigan4774
      @gileadprigan4774 Місяць тому

      Read the ravs book - eye of the storm

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому

      Well said, many are dullards and followers of sports ball and drek culture, lamentable indeed

    • @lisaschuster686
      @lisaschuster686 5 днів тому

      @@מכוןברכתדוד What?

    • @מכוןברכתדוד
      @מכוןברכתדוד 5 днів тому

      @ it’s pashut

  • @themissingpeace7956
    @themissingpeace7956 Місяць тому +8

    Israel had the sympathy of the entire world after October 7th. But it was Israel's response and clear disregard for human life that followed that turned the world against Israel. Starving the Gazans, cutting off their water and electricity and shooting at medical/humanitarian workers only fueled what you call antisemitism, but in truth the people of the world are not hating the Jewish people but are utterly outraged at the war crimes of Israel. To defend yourselves is one thing, but to have your so called "Holy IDF warriors" shoot at Palestinian children aiming at their heads when they pose no threat to you is the epitome of evil.

    • @mgold3986
      @mgold3986 Місяць тому

      Well said!

    • @familymed1
      @familymed1 29 днів тому +3

      Why portray the IDF as "child killers" as if that's the role and intent of the IDF? That's a slur. Of course it's awful that children die in war. But Hamas built it's military infrastructure under civilian infrastructure to use civilians as human shields and as "martyrs" for their version of Islam (martyrology). Hamas also wants to cause civilian deaths to use civilian deaths as a public relations tactic. Israel has the fewest ratio of civilian to fighter casualties of urban warfare compared to any other modern war, including the US battles in Iraq and Afghanistan. And, you can't help wondering why there were never protests in the US and Europe despite the markedly more deaths in Syrians civil war (>500,000) , the multiple millions of refugees and mass deaths in Sudan's current war, >300,000 dead in Yemen's civil war do to the Houthis.

    • @themissingpeace7956
      @themissingpeace7956 29 днів тому

      @ A million Iraqis were killed under U.S. occupation. Add another 250,000 Afghans, millions of people displaced. Libya now has open air slave markets where you can buy people for $400. I’m sure you’d say these nations were run by “dictators” and terrorists were hiding behind the civilians so that gives you the right to massacre them as well. The West wants to portray itself as moral and just but they don’t really give a damn about the lives of brown people.
      As for you trying to excuse the IDF, there have been plenty of reports of children aged 5-12 being shot in the head and or chest every single day by sniper fire. I’m sure they had terrorists hiding behind them as well, right?
      The more you try to excuse the crimes of Israel, the more you become a direct accomplice to the crimes that they commit.

    • @themissingpeace7956
      @themissingpeace7956 29 днів тому

      @ “Israel has the fewest civilians to combattants killed by percentage”, that’s because Israel considers any Palestinian male as a terrorist and any civilians that they kill are also reported as terrorists, children included. That’s why Israel keeps reporting these tens of thousands of “terrorists killed”.

    • @jerryslist
      @jerryslist 28 днів тому +2

      Your one-sided comment says nothing about Hamas and the Gazans indoctrinating children to be their soldiers, which in and of itself, is obscene. It says nothing about the tunnels,
      the weapons trafficking and the terrorists embedding themselves and their weapons in very everyday citizen areas, as if to prevent attacks on themselves and holding their "fellow citizens" hostage. Yours is a very one-sided account, and not understanding of the entire situation and the overwhelming threat that Hamas and the rest of the Iran proxies, represent to Israel.

  • @artichoke60045
    @artichoke60045 Місяць тому +2

    What about the mitzvah to live in the land of Israel? Is the mission of Jews eternal exile? It's written clearly that the protection of Hashem is greatest in the land of Israel. R. Feldman is described as Chaver. Who makes that designation? Kabbalistically, the Shekinah is exiled and wants to return to the land of Israel, with her people.

    • @BennyFitter
      @BennyFitter Місяць тому

      Go watch the other agudas yisrael video about making Aliyah. And look where they all live

  • @davidchin1828
    @davidchin1828 29 днів тому +1

    He's wrong to assert a simple dichotomy: there are Jews who are ashamed to be Jews (Reform and Zionist Jews) vs the proud Jews (the Orthodox). While Reform Judaism and Zionism came about for various reasons, for Reform a major cause was the application of reason and modern discoveries to the history of the Jews, which cast doubt about the divine origins of the Torah, and the monotheistic faiths in general. Indeed, because of the power of that knowledge, many "proud Jews" don't allow their fellow Jews even to be exposed to these ideas, perhaps because they fear the truth. (It's also true that many Jews remain Orthodox, who's faith survives despite modern discoveries, ideas, and insights). No doubt, sadly, Reform is very frequently a gateway to complete assimilation. But it's also true that there are many proud non-Orthodox Jews who don't hide that they're Jewish, and who recently started wearing big Magen David necklaces to project their pride in the current hostile environment. And Zionism came about in the 19th century as a prideful movement, asserting that Jews no longer need cower and be dependent on others for their well-being. They wanted to remain Jews, strong Jews, rather than disappear as communist internationalists or to be "Germans of the Jewish faith".

    • @mattnewhouse1781
      @mattnewhouse1781 29 днів тому +1

      Zionist Jews are not ashamed, what are you talking about? We are proud zionist Jews. Anti zionists are the unwelcomed minority in the family that comes about from bad parenting. Most orthodox Jews are zionists.

    • @lesweizman388
      @lesweizman388 27 днів тому

      many observant jews who are zionists

    • @donquijotedelamancha3529
      @donquijotedelamancha3529 26 днів тому

      Which means that there is total chaos within the Jewish community and they don't even know what and who they are. A lot of contradictions exist within the community. It seems that different groups of Jewish want different things. That's why religions in general should never be followed to the letter nor should they be a used as a guide. Cultures change, discoveries are made, people evolve, and communities are composed of different people with different needs.

    • @ruthietaylor8756
      @ruthietaylor8756 22 дні тому

      Reform = Deform

  • @תמימההרהבית
    @תמימההרהבית Місяць тому +1

    You have your head down now because when the Jews in the future will ask the age old question "Why didn't they leave?" They will look back on this video.

  • @BruceDevlin-y2n
    @BruceDevlin-y2n Місяць тому

    Have you ever lived in New York, dude?

  • @davidburrows4801
    @davidburrows4801 Місяць тому +7

    A sermon of total delusion.

    • @Mns-jn5qo
      @Mns-jn5qo Місяць тому +6

      A sermon which hits the nail completely on the head.

    • @davidburrows4801
      @davidburrows4801 Місяць тому

      Ju's literally went against Hashem non stop in the Tanakh ..yet now theyre the light bearers 😂 like i say delusion.also what is their light bearing consist of?

    • @Mns-jn5qo
      @Mns-jn5qo Місяць тому +2

      @davidburrows4801 The Jewish nation sinned and as a result we have been punished. However are small part of the Jewish nation has always been loyal to G-D and his Torah. This part of the Jewish nation is a light to the nations of the world.

    • @SinaiJudaism
      @SinaiJudaism Місяць тому +4

      ​@@davidburrows4801 You're LITERALLY PROVING The Rabbi absolutely RIGHT with your ignorant comments.

    • @davidburrows4801
      @davidburrows4801 Місяць тому

      @@Mns-jn5qo ,but you dont accept Gods punishment, you turn it into more hatred .

  • @moe2002m
    @moe2002m Місяць тому +5

    🇵🇸🇵🇸🇵🇸

    • @yehudar8744
      @yehudar8744 22 дні тому +3

      This is about you, hater

    • @andrewdube2422
      @andrewdube2422 22 дні тому

      @@yehudar8744 no this is about a genocidal terrorist country named is re al and the world including 90 percent of the JEWISH people I know wanting it to stop terrorizing its neighbours

    • @ruthietaylor8756
      @ruthietaylor8756 22 дні тому

      Fakeistine squatters from Jordan, Egypt

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому

      Remember your brothers from lebanon, 3000 men transformed from a jihadi army into a harem of blinded amputee eunuchs 🤯

    • @ruthietaylor8756
      @ruthietaylor8756 5 днів тому

      Fakeistine squatters from Jordan and Egypt

  • @donquijotedelamancha3529
    @donquijotedelamancha3529 26 днів тому

    What a difficult speech to follow. Instead of reading with all those punctuation mistakes and strange pauses, and the switching from English to Hebrew, he should've just talked to his audience in one language and used a higher podium so that he could actually look at the attendees and deliver better than he actually did. Anyway, it is evident that the Jewish themselves have no idea of what they are and what they need. Some Jews don't want the State of Israel; others do; some others are in between.... What a mess!

    • @yochimevaseret4878
      @yochimevaseret4878 21 день тому

      It is one language for that audience

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому

      Sniping and griping
      Losers will lose
      Nothing to add
      Commenting only to denigrate
      Almost as if your mind is closed

  • @billswisshelm1505
    @billswisshelm1505 Місяць тому +1

    You celebrate the death of innocents.....

  • @moshemankoff7488
    @moshemankoff7488 Місяць тому +2

    A load of crap.

    • @iljab.3302
      @iljab.3302 Місяць тому

      Yes your a load of crap.

    • @ruthietaylor8756
      @ruthietaylor8756 22 дні тому +2

      You need truth therapy

    • @moshemankoff7488
      @moshemankoff7488 21 день тому

      @@ruthietaylor8756 I'm not the one pretending that the ICC didn't issue arrest warrants for Putin and his cronies. I'm not the one claiming protesting a genocide is antisemitic. I'm not the one confusing Jews and Israel. I'm not the one pretending there's a difference between "secular" Zionism and "religious" Zionism. I'm not the one making up Hitler quotes. I'm not the one deliberately failing to notice the rise of the antisemitic far right.

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому +2

      Ruthie's right

    • @moshemankoff7488
      @moshemankoff7488 5 днів тому

      @@GreenCanvasInteriorscape No

  • @markmclean3954
    @markmclean3954 Місяць тому

    Moshiach Ra-El arrived in 2011 and the state of Israel rejected him.
    Imam Mahdi ( Aba Al Sadiq ) and the qaim have revealed their identities.
    You all know what this means.

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому

      99.99% of the Jewish world has no idea what you're talking about and I'm one of them, you don't make a case you only make a claim you threw out claims without proof and couldn't be more vague and less specific 😵‍💫😵😵‍💫😵

    • @markmclean3954
      @markmclean3954 День тому

      All you need to know is Moshiachs name is RaEl
      Imam Mahdi qaim is led by Aba Al Sadiq

  • @danielspivak3926
    @danielspivak3926 Місяць тому

    Here is a man who has no understanding of the world outside of the letter of the torah. Why bother learning about actual antisemitism in the real world, when you can point to where it says in the book "god says bad things will happen if you don't worship him hard enough"? He brings up Hitler and cherrypicks a quote that does not represent the nazis' views on Jews. He disgraces the intelligent tradition of rabbis.

    • @GreenCanvasInteriorscape
      @GreenCanvasInteriorscape 5 днів тому

      You should post the link to the video that you've done already that repudiates and rebuts his points.
      Let me know when you post it