Israeli official admits plan ‘hasn’t worked’ because IDF have not used enough ‘brute force’ | LBC
Вставка
- Опубліковано 6 чер 2024
- Does Israel have a 'credible plan' for Rafah? That's what Antony Blinken wants to know ahead of a long-feared offensive in the city. Nick Ferrari asks spokesman David Mencer if the IDF have such a plan to safeguard civilians.
Mr Mencer says that the current plan has not been working because it has been missing a crucial element: 'brute military force.'
00:00 Israeli spokesman, David Mencer.
03:52 British Officer in the Palestinian Territories, Brigadier John Deverell.
Listen to the full show on Global Player: app.af.globalplayer.com/Br0x/...
#nickferrari #israel #palestine #gaza #LBC
LBC is the home of live debate around news and current affairs in the UK.
Join in the conversation and listen at www.lbc.co.uk/
Sign up to LBC’s weekly newsletter here: l-bc.co/signup
This man tries to insult the intelligence of the majority of us
😂😂😂,oh yes !
Most LBC listeners vote Labour, so clearly intelligence is massively lacking in this country
" we must Expel Palestinians at alllll coasts" Ben Gourion to Haganah, Irgun, Stern, years later " If I was a palestinian I would never negociate with Israël because we stole their Land" , " If I don't steal your home someone else will " Jacob American settler to a palestinian woman, just like 97% in Israël. this is the Real History
He's an absolute fool
Palestinians didn’t want this either!
You were forced upon them 75 years ago and made them second class citizens in their own country.
Big deal, tell them to get over it just like the Natives on North American reservations did, or Australian Aboriginies! Oh wait...
@@PatJamesRicketts or they won't get over it like the south africans, like india, like any other african country and in the end they will get their country back? after all a lot of countries have been colonized and than liberated.
South Africans didn’t get over it- they got their country back.
Algerians, Burmese, Vietnamese, Mozambique, Kenyans, Namibians didn't accept been 2nd class citizens to a colonial master class, they fought back in a nasty brutal wars of liberation-Israelis are delusional, thinking that this is a war that they can win by more oppression of Palestinians with or without the support of the white majority western govts and elites...
This conflict has ALL the potential for devastating escalation...
@@PatJamesRicketts what you are wishing or doing to others, that will also be done to you, just wait for it...
Apartheid states are not "democracies" in a meaningful way
@@victormeidan1062 Israel shouldn't be in middle east, it should be in UK, USA or Germany
@@MSDAKM-cs5nf
Jews come from Judea.
The "d" was lost in Modern English, but it still exists in Dutch, German, Danish, Swedish, Latin, Hebrew & Arabic.
@@victormeidan1062Judaism is a religion, not a people, and if you're referring to Judea, they were certainly not Europeans. Moreover, considering the entire story of Moses, they are not indigenous to that land, neither then nor now.
“Judea" was a made up province of the Roman Empire with appointed vassal kings-same is true for the crusade era vassal county of Tripoli et al...
@@victormeidan1062 if one were to base a right to land on claims as old as Judea, the Anglo Saxons would have no claim to England.
Let’s also remember the over a million Palestians who’ve been killed or dispossessed by the Israelis over the last 75 years!!
Including my grandparents and great grandparents
Under president Biden Hammas must surely feel supported by the American people.
There's no direct leadership for or against Israel.
Just dithering as usual.
But it must surely give Hammas and Hesbolla etc the sense that the momentum is on their side!
After the Massacre on October the 7th and the taking of 240 Hostages. Israel has had to retaliate with one hand tied behind it's back.
When people don't heed the warning that an area is going to be attacked when they have the choice to go, but choose to remain as Martyrs.
There's going to be a lot of deaths.
Hammas also dress up as civilians and count their own dead amongst the Palestinian casualties.
That sounds antisemitic !
@@adamsalman6327 Tell me, what doesn't to the people who talk about 'Human animals'?
It never happened.
NEVER BELIEVE ANYTHING FROM THIS EVIL STATE!!
💯
Agree!!
" we must Expel Palestinians at alllll coasts" 1937 Ben Gourion to Haganah, Irgun, Stern, years later " If I was a palestinian woman I would never negociate with Israël because we stole their Land" , " If I don't steal your home someone else will " Jacob American settler to a palestinian woman, just like 97% in Israël. this is the Real History
He is not israeli, he is a british MP 100% colonial land grabber
Instrumental in removing Jeremy Corbyn. And now a Isreali spokesman.... Says it all.
@pokemonjt British but never an MP - just a faction promoter in the British Labour party who then decamped to Israel.
@@Conner.YorkshireRichmond
Gammon alert.
@@Conner.YorkshireRichmond they didn’t come to take a British man’s house who has been besieged and thrown into a concentration camp, with his family killed, humiliated and starving for decades, they also didn’t change the name of Britain to “Pisrael” and fake pretend it’s a country with their friends
A dog born in a stable doesn't make it a Horse..
This man is pure evil.
He is just a radio host! Oh wait, you meant one of the other ones... My bad. Which one is evil? Just so I know who to be mad at...
The host is an ardent Israeli fan. So I'd say both. LBC is run by Hasbara clearly. They get rid of anyone who challenge the Hasbara narrative...: IE Sangita Myska@@PatJamesRicketts
@@PatJamesRicketts ROFL 😂
Which one?
@@bendyrland7213 not the radio host
Nick, How can you allow such a significant amount of lies to be spewed by the Israeli spokesman without any challenge?
He can because his guest is a pure Englishman like him
Because it’s LBC, they fired Sangita and replaced her with that massive slab of gammon for holding an Israeli spokesman to account
Because he supports the Zionists too that's why
Cos he is one of them..!
I think Sangita would have asked better questions and made more relevant challenges. Where is she?
Bring Sangita back!!!!
Her line of questioning was perfect👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼👏🏼
This show is beyond ridiculous.
"Her line of questioning was perfect"
which is why she'll never be back. Until the world finally turns against the nazis running Israel, and then all of the current supporters will pretend they never supported the IDF terrorists and their Likud masters.
He cannot articulate clearly because he is talking utter nonsense and he knows.
And thats after being questioned by a very pro isreali uk journalist.
The host didn’t even flinch after the israHell spokes man told him we killed over 16,000 innocent people
Nick suddenly turns into a big softie when he interviews Israelis. He sounds like Piers Morgan 2.0.
Want to keep its job. he's had no credibility for years..
He don’t wanna loose his job 😂
Yes sold his soul to the devil years ago 😊
What a BIG LIAR!!!
Starmer? Agreed
Nick you are the worst interviewer, just accept what the Occupier/Genocidal Goverment Spokesman says. The IDF have shown there no better than Hamas.
"Israel needs to be more brutal." That is the most Orwellian line I have heard this year.
This is just utterly and absolutely incredible.
More Orwellian than "We plan to repeat October the 7th over and over and over again" ?
Mind Begs the Question:
- Protocols of Zion
- Is deemed a Fabricated/Fake Document
- If Protocols can be seen signed into Law
- Fake Document or Plan Document?
@@peterkenyon3578 where's the evidence they said this? You just heard a story and you ran with it
@@aye.sha88 In an interview not long after the war started, a leading Hamas official said two very clear and very distinct things: October 7th was going to be repeated over and over again and that the Gazan peoples' interests were not their responsibility and should be taken on by either the UN or the Israelis. Ever since, the world's Useful Idiots have attempted to water down and even deny they were said. They can't because these things are out there. I know it. You know it. And I know that you know it. So denial isn't going to work.
We want sangita back
with his heavy "Middle Eastern" accent, I can't understand what he is saying, all I hear is B.S
Lolz
😂 he forgot to say “KKKHAMAS”
His accent is British not Middle Eastern!and by the way he use to work for some MP’s in the House of Commons the uk parliament .
@@Rudolf_Bottler I think you missed the sarcasm in the original comment
Evil.
I know, right? That set alone is so gaudy and tasteless! When is LBC gonna get their act together!? Oh wait, you meant one of the people on or against the team you support, my bad...
@@PatJamesRicketts it isn't about "supporting a team" dude 🤦♂️ ugh...
Which one?? I see 2
When I was a child we used to play a game where you had to say something completely ridiculous without laughing. I suspect that something similar is used to help train Israel's spokespeople.
I think their game is to say something ridiculous to see if it gets reported, unchallenged, by mainstream media.
Is this the man that got grilled on Norwegian TV ? .. maybe LBC should take notes from Norwegian press on how to conduct proper interviews, and how to not fire a female staff member for r asking pertinent questions
They don't have to look at Norwegian TV. All they have to look at is Sangita Myska. Who used to work at LBC. Until she questioned another Israeli propagandist...
Please watch this vile man being interviewed on talk tv with james schneider. Very entertaining 😅
Get your people back? Some of them walked towards you waving a white flag and speaking Hebrew and you shot them - or have I missed something ?
An English Israeli 😂
Like another commenter said: I can barely understand him because of his thick middle eastern accent.
@@MisterNiles saying he has nowhere else to go give me a break
Pakistanis with english accents in Britain,it works both ways mate
Funny how Israeli spokespeople were born in London, or Melbourne, or Brooklyn, basically anywhere but the Middle East, and are fast-tracked into having Israeli citizenship. But the actual people who have lived there for centuries are expelled and forced to live in refugee camps
@@Conner.YorkshireRichmondLmao are you acoustic?? Lollllll
free Palestine, free Julian Assange
Free Israel from the 7th century settler colonists.
💯
How kind of you- you have a starved, traumatised and injured an entire population and forcibly displaced them - and send them a note to warn them you are going to attack them! What a moral force!
Dude said they’re sending them emails as if they have normal access to computers and internet
I was looking for the video "LBC admits sacking Sangita" when is that being uploaded?
Liar!
In 2018 Israeli soldiers shot over 6,000 Palestinians. In many cases they were shot with illegal expanding ammunition. So, did the present iteration of this problem begin on 7th October 2023 (1,200 casualties) or March/Dec 2018 (6,000 casualties) Discus ??
Europe are condemning Russia for taking Ukraines land. Yet it was Europe who had the barmy Idea of taking Muslim land and giving it to Jews.
It began 77 years ago... 1947 Partition Plan- 33 COLONIAL countries approved- and 23 countries did not support it- now 193 countries in the UN and 143 SUPPORT PALESTINE!!!
@@johnrussell3961Well said
@@johnrussell3961ps The Donbass was mostly of Russian ethnicity.. they went there to stop they slaughter going on there.. by the Far right loons..
@@johnrussell3961Wait and see who moves back to Eastern Europe
The IDF is already too brutal and given too much freedom, it's their idea of their goal that isn't realistic
You know he's emphatically lying, because his lips are moving.
Absolutely 💯
Absolute despicable. Bold faced liar. Shame on the whole regime.
Yes, the Hamas are pure Evil.
Hey be nice Nicky , spineless LBC bring back Sangita
He was the same guy who was being embarrassed in interview by Norwegian journalist couple of weeks ago when he couldn't present any arguments to prove his claim.
I see clips of six and seven year old children walking around Gaza, moved from pillar to post, dazed and confused saying things like "I just want to sleep in my bed" and the "the war has broken us" and this man comes out with such inhumane ideas.
Especially the orphans. How anyone can condone this is beyond me. It's like mass mania and psychosis. How can anyone not feel pain when you actually look at the Palestinian people? It's unbelievable, literally.
People with a clean heart have compassion and sympathy. They don't
you almost think they’re trolling
"Letting them know by email", you can't make this up. We are living in Black Mirror.
Why ?
Email in addition to text messages, mobile phone calls, radio programs, flyers dropped from aircraft etc etc.
@@victormeidan1062 So if the terrorists dropped flyers before 9/11, would that justify the attack?
Correct me if I am wrong!!!
So much respect is given to this apartheid state🥴
I can't correct you because you're not wrong
No, you are very, very right.
Yes and it has never deserved any respect. Free Palestine
This man IS hate.
This guy was the head of Labour friends of Israel and now he is the official spokesperson for the Israeli government. Foreign interference in the UK political process.
Sick version of musical chairs game where children dance around the disappearing chairs until the music stops. History won't judge them kindly.
In this version, it's the children who disappear
Why are they all british born spokespeople?
They think we'll fall for their lies if they speak like we do. Oldest trick in the propa-gnada rule book
The UK ships off all their bad eggs to Israel.
Ezrah hires native English speakers to do their PR for international audiences
Because they are the ones that started this mess in the first place, colonial land grab it’s not rocket science 😂
An Englishman owing allegiance to Israel, perhaps? There are lots of those treacherous creatures too.
Israel believes their people are special and have a destiny. As such they feel that they are entitled to an area of land that befits their status. Current occupants of these lands are viewed as ‘sub-humans’ and ‘human animals’. I wonder where they got these sort of ideas from.
Balfour declaration 1917
He's letting people living in tents know by EMAIL. UNBELIEVABLE
@rubzczo
Mouthpiece Mencer is so inept/eager to spout the Netanyahoo line that he actually forgets to include mentioning the leaflet drop. Just another example of how bewildered/on the back foot these hucksters are.
"You know Israel better than most of your listeners"
That's a strange comment
Because Nick is supporter of "Conservative Friend of Israel"
You said: "You know Israel better than most of your listeners."
Nick Ferrari being Jewish has visited Israel on many occasions and has donated generously to many of its causes.
This guy got smoked so bad by the norwagian guy. Also what part of him looks like middle eastern
He says he left the UK because of Corbyn, the absolute loser.
This man is beyond evil
con-cen-tra-tion cmap. Work that out Mr Mensa
Safe like aid workers were safe? Safe like Rafah was meant to be safe?
How do this man called Mercer even get up in the morning and look into the mirror without being violently sick.
Lots of the Israeli spokespeople have perfect English accents. There’s also a colonel who has a perfect Scottish accent. They are all very white as well, funny that eh?
But there are Jewish historical artifacts there dating back thousands of years! Surely that proves that white British, Jewish people are native to Israel Palestine? Right?
Just like Christian artifacts in that land prove that white English Christians are native to the middle east.
Liar!!
WHere is Sangita? We can't stand the lies.
Shes well gone
I'm sick to death of these liars being given airtime.
Which one? The presenter or the guest 😂
@@jake751 in this case, both.
We have did everything to get our hostages back ... accept wanting to negotiate a meaningful peace process
Bring back Sangita
Thé measures thé IDF have taken to prevent civilian casualties? Like telling a population to move to a ‘safe zone’ and then bombing them there? Like shutting off food and water? Like snipers shooting children in the head? Like destroying hospitals, schools, universities, homes, civilian infrastructure, indiscriminately.
No Israel is not being held to international standards. It is being shielded from those standards and that accountability by the US.
Several senior members of the Israeli regime have made genocidal statements in relation to Gazans and their actions are entirely consistent with those statements. They have clearly set out to destroy Gazan society and to make Gaza uninhabitable for its civilian population.
Will Israël be held to account? That remains to be seen but past history suggests they will probably get away with their depravity.
Where is Sangita!?
Is it even possible for Israelis spox to respond directly to questions put to them? It's pathological at this stage
Get an Israeli spokesman stop flying in forenigors for the accent
What a pack of lies
bring back Sangita
Why has no UK media reported on the killing of another UN worker today, in a UN livery car, by the IDF in Rafah. Plenty about it online, and from UN HQ, but no UK coverage
bye LBC
The Palestinians had you forced on them for 75 years.
Not true... Israel was taken from them. Israel and Judah formed naturally in around 1200BCE.
You should probably look at blaming old King Tiglath for all this. Should have just left them in peace...
@@2thre3 that's silly. what are you gonna claim next, that your ancestors used to live 10,000 years BC in Mesopotamia, so now you have to get back your ancestral home in Iraq? or maybe you'll be reaching for Africa next because you had ancestors there 100,000 years ago?
@everettbr - and in calling me silly. In using history. You completely sidestep how we got here... why its important we got here and why continuation of this and what has been has been the silliest thing in recent history.
@everettbr - my point is that this fight goes way back. All the way. You settle one dispute from the past, and someone digs deeper. And deeper. So I just went to what we could probably consider the first real conflict in all of this.
Someone's loss is always greater and that justifies greater bloodshed... its like nothing was learned from the world wars that created this situation.
DO I CONDEMN HAMAS ? Only in the same way I would condemn the French Resistance for the way they opposed their brutal occupiers! History has judged the French people as Heroes.
The French resistance never broke through the German border to massacre hundreds of innocent Germans in villages and at a music festival.
@@justinmillette9110 yeh just sit quietly and take it
@@justinmillette9110 they probably did, you just dont know about it.
@@justinmillette9110 expanding on that analogy, they aren’t German borders though are they? They are occupied French territories.
Do keep up, Justin
To compare Hamas to the French resistance shows how sick your mind is.
Sangita is to honest,has integrity,unbias too professional she wont attract the clowns they will be to scared to be interviewed
When they need to deliver propaganda with minimal pushback, Nick's door is always open.
Disgusting. Your thoughts to his people??? This depraved society?
Israel is a beautiful Jewish country.Everyone knows Israel is holyland,not mecca
What liars.
LBC shills. My gawd
Where is SANGITTA ????
Bring back Sangita! We are tired of these so called journalists they just can't hide their bias even when they're trying their hardest... No Like!
FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
Free Israel !
@@victormeidan1062 yup! China helped and freed israeled from world map 😂😂😂😂
@@victormeidan1062stop taking drugs
Lie after lie and lie.
Where's Sangita
All the maimed people ……. No legs etc to run towards
They want to return to “co-existence” where one side oppresses the other and steals land. 😂 Jeno babies the lot of em.
Such a lovely English accent… ohh wait! 🙄
Mencer and his paymasters have the right to defend themselves against the starving displaced children of Rafah.
So he saying that hamas killed more than 25,000 of idf while they killed 13,000 hamas? Didn't the Israeli officials said that only less than thousand idf died? And how he know that 13,000 hamas killed. What evidence they had to prove this claim?
He said over "Israel's" history that they lost 25k and 5k- that's 77 years!!! We have seen Israel wipe out 35,000 Palestinians in 7 months!!!
Our lovely Nick quickly shushed the guy when he told Nick he knows Israel better than most...
The more they speak,the more they make the case for the liberation of the Palestinian people by revealing their own brutality, ruthlessness and hatred.
One cannot liberate a mythical peoplehood that never was.. It is physically impossible.
Err hello.... Palestinians also didn't want this war, they didn't ask for the Balfour declaration nor did they ask the Israeli to come to their land some 80 yrs ago and asked for Israel to be set up!
"You know Israel better than most of your listeners." Don't think you were supposed to say that. 😂
Why do so many "Israeli" people have British accents?
Strange that.
He’s so full of it. They’re all full of it.
you stole and killed innocence..yet war you did not asked for????
Yes, these medieval religious barbarians are despicable
Disgusting. How many ceasefire did you refuse? 8?
"We are sending them emails" JOKE OF THE CENTURY
"If I ever seen a weasel this man looks like one " ~ Sir Connor McGregor .
The total number of soldiers and civilians he mentions at the start who have been killed since the formation of Israel is less than the total number of people who have been killed in Gaza over the last 7 months. Let that sink in...
You call him sir?
After the Piers interview, they were told to say 16,000 going forward.
Looks like the figure of civilian victims has been declassifed. 😂😂😂
Estimated it may be less or more
Except 14,000 and 16,000 do not equal 35,000 MURDERED by Israel
It's too early for this type of BS
Nick
Do you have the testicular fortitude to call out the Israelis as terrorists and genociders?
16k pals civilians and 14k hamas -
Remembering the 25k and 5k Israel’s
Not sure your figures add up there 👆
Battle plan!!!!. Very dangerous those women and children.
What a lovely Israeli accent
Nick, stop giving the IDF spokespeople airtime…. I’m tired of having lies presented as news.
David Mencer = Lord Haw-Haw
He's the half-wit love child of Lord Haw Haw and Tokyo Rose.
All terrorists appart from them, disgraceful.
Yes, Hamas, ISIS, Al Qaeda, ISIS = terrorists.
Just media😂😂😂😂😂 that bans news agencies that don’t agree with them