Heres my fancast: Yuri Lowenthal as Silver. Silver seems like he would be pretty chill if you hung with him, but still a little cocky. And I think Yuri could perfectly capture that. (Editors note: I want Silver to be written as a cross between Sonic and Shadow. Calm Collected, and Serious most of the time. But willing to make or crack at a joke like Sonic)
I think Deven Mack's in the running for one of my favorite Sonic VA's. I'm so biased to Roger, cuz he's the one I'm most familiar with, but I do think Deven matches Sonic's modern character. He's got the attitude while keeping the heart, makes him sound a lot more like a kid.
Yeah, Deven is probably the best candidate, and if Roger were to drop himself from the role now I feel like Sega would seriously consider him. And if they did, it wouldn’t be the first time Sonic’s VA was replaced by someone who voices him in a TV show lmao
I'm good with the current VA set, but I don't have any objections to this one either. Without telling me which is which (or recognizing the line), I may not be able to tell between Ryan and Devan. Roger would make a good Knuckles, except I'm already used to him as Sonic, also Idris Elba is a good Knux and I like that Frontiers' VA pulled some inspiration from Elba's performance. Kirk is an amazing Shadow imo.
Besides Max Mittelman, i would love to hear Deven Mack could take over. Colleen o'shaughnessy might still remain as my favorite tails, second choice would be erika harlacher. Wait, So roger craig smith would fit knuckles?! Not a bad idea, i like it, maybe few change the character Besides current sonic. But,still not,sure for dave b Mitchell cause he's good for knuckles. Second choice will be mark meer. I don't know, how about abby trott? She might fit for amy, however I still think about Shannon Chan-Kent might take over. Ian hanlin might perfect for shadow or at least my choice for ben Pronsky, which probably makes sense for ian will voice two characters like shadow and big. Mike Pollock still my favorite eggman. Hopefully for Richard epcar or someone else. Or even brian Drummond. New idea for babylon rouge voices: Todd Haberkon as Jet Kira Buckland as Wave Patrick Seitz as Storm.
Might I suggest Amir Talai as Sonic, Jennifer Hale as Tails, and Ike Amadi as Knuckles? Scott Porter as Shadow, Rebecca Shoichet as Rouge, and Zeno Robinson as Silver? Kari Wahlgren as Amy Rose, Ross Marquand as Dr. Eggman, and Alex Hirsch as Jet?
For sonic i would have gone with a voice that fits sonic's dorky side. So mostly something like vincent's kai or something like bow in the she-ra reboot..
2:01 This is a decent fan cast and all, but I just have to derail from the topic of the voice, because I do not agree what you said about Mike Pollock's behaviour. I don't know every single story of his unacceptable attitude. Yet I have heard he done/said a lot of horrible stuff to people on Twitter; and to say "that app brings the worst out of everyone" is such an awful excuse to justify someone's cruel actions
If I were to give sonic a new voice actor… I think I would give the roll to Chris Pratt. Not only would he capture the energy of sonic the the hedgehog he would give a more mature take on the character.
Holy shit Roger sounds pretty good as knuckles. Why wasn't he casted as him instead?
Heres my fancast: Yuri Lowenthal as Silver. Silver seems like he would be pretty chill if you hung with him, but still a little cocky. And I think Yuri could perfectly capture that. (Editors note: I want Silver to be written as a cross between Sonic and Shadow. Calm Collected, and Serious most of the time. But willing to make or crack at a joke like Sonic)
Ian Hanlin Shadow appreciation 🙌🙌🙌
Roger was once batman so him as knuckles could work
1:09 i'm really surprised about how well Roger fits with Knuckles
I think Deven Mack's in the running for one of my favorite Sonic VA's. I'm so biased to Roger, cuz he's the one I'm most familiar with, but I do think Deven matches Sonic's modern character. He's got the attitude while keeping the heart, makes him sound a lot more like a kid.
Yeah, Deven is probably the best candidate, and if Roger were to drop himself from the role now I feel like Sega would seriously consider him. And if they did, it wouldn’t be the first time Sonic’s VA was replaced by someone who voices him in a TV show lmao
I'm good with the current VA set, but I don't have any objections to this one either. Without telling me which is which (or recognizing the line), I may not be able to tell between Ryan and Devan. Roger would make a good Knuckles, except I'm already used to him as Sonic, also Idris Elba is a good Knux and I like that Frontiers' VA pulled some inspiration from Elba's performance. Kirk is an amazing Shadow imo.
Besides Max Mittelman, i would love to hear Deven Mack could take over.
Colleen o'shaughnessy might still remain as my favorite tails, second choice would be erika harlacher.
Wait, So roger craig smith would fit knuckles?! Not a bad idea, i like it, maybe few change the character Besides current sonic. But,still not,sure for dave b Mitchell cause he's good for knuckles. Second choice will be mark meer.
I don't know, how about abby trott? She might fit for amy, however I still think about Shannon Chan-Kent might take over.
Ian hanlin might perfect for shadow or at least my choice for ben Pronsky, which probably makes sense for ian will voice two characters like shadow and big.
Mike Pollock still my favorite eggman. Hopefully for Richard epcar or someone else. Or even brian Drummond.
New idea for babylon rouge voices:
Todd Haberkon as Jet
Kira Buckland as Wave
Patrick Seitz as Storm.
I would put Deven Mack on Sonic probably. Curious that I was making Jason's Sonic sing Cupid
Might I suggest Amir Talai as Sonic, Jennifer Hale as Tails, and Ike Amadi as Knuckles? Scott Porter as Shadow, Rebecca Shoichet as Rouge, and Zeno Robinson as Silver? Kari Wahlgren as Amy Rose, Ross Marquand as Dr. Eggman, and Alex Hirsch as Jet?
1:22 I thought he was talking to me for a sec😂😂
For sonic i would have gone with a voice that fits sonic's dorky side. So mostly something like vincent's kai or something like bow in the she-ra reboot..
As for silver I'm tied with either zeno robertson or lucien dodge. Zeno for his work as hunter in TOH and lucien with his more danganronpa kiibo voice
Wait, Mike Pollock was Cailou’s dad 😂💀
2:01
This is a decent fan cast and all, but I just have to derail from the topic of the voice, because I do not agree what you said about Mike Pollock's behaviour. I don't know every single story of his unacceptable attitude. Yet I have heard he done/said a lot of horrible stuff to people on Twitter; and to say "that app brings the worst out of everyone" is such an awful excuse to justify someone's cruel actions
You only made this video just to be able to choose Dollip Daze for Jet. Didn’t you?
No. I only did it so I could choose Ryan for Sonic and Ashly for Amy lmfao
If I were to give sonic a new voice actor… I think I would give the roll to Chris Pratt. Not only would he capture the energy of sonic the the hedgehog he would give a more mature take on the character.
roger is horrid as Sonic but pretty good as Knuckles