They're both the best of the best, but I think i've got a softspot for the slightly gruffer, more natural delivery Lillard's performance has evolved into
The late Casey Kasem. The most comedic and paranoid of the bunch. Matthew Lillard is a worthy successor. It’s interesting that the live action actor of an established cartoon character went on to voice the character officially. Scott Innes was a pretty decent replacement though.
@@ashwegerle4838Despite Casey Kasem voiced Shaggy until his retirement in 2009, he temporarily stopped voicing the character during the 90s because he was a vegan and was asked to voice Shaggy for a Burger King commercial. IIRC, when Kasem came back to voice Shaggy during the 2000s, Shaggy was a vegan.
My favourites are both the Original Shaggy himself Casey Kasem, and Matthew Lillard the first live actor of Shaggy did an amazing job as Casey Kasem's successor.
Obviously, Casey Kasem is the best and most legendary Shaggy, but MAN Matthew Lillard came in a great second place, he nailed the voice almost identically!
For me it's a tie between Casey Kasem (still miss him) and Matthew Lillard. These guys were BORN to play Shaggy and I can't decide which is better. I think Scott Innes, Billy West and Will Forte are also really good
I grew up with Scott Innes. I really didnt watch much Scooby Doo except for Mystery Incorporated while growing up, but i absolutely loved Scooby Doo First Frights and Scooby Doo and the Spooky Swamp.
Scott Innes is my Twin Brother's favorite voice for Shaggy. His voice was just right during 1999, 2000, and 2001. 😃. My Twin brother loves his voice so much he chooses that one specifically whenever he does his Shaggy impression.
Same honestly, It's a mix between Matthew and Scott. At first I was like, why that one but I just can't help it, it's iconic to me since Scooby Doo Project
"hahaha hey scoob how are you? i'm doing amazing! i just stuffed some children into animatronics and kill them HAHAH how are you scoob?" scoob:"shaggy you need a therapist"
Matthew is just perfect for the role. It's crazy how well they did casting him in the live action movie. I also love Billy West. Sam just sounds like a dude. Like, i would never know that was shaggy or even a cartoon character at all just by listening.
No one could have been a better successor of the late Casey Kasem than Matthew Lillard. The dude purposely destroyed his vocal cords just to sound raspy like shaggy, and was so good in his live action role he rightfully became the official voice actor in future renditions of the show. You can tell how much he loves the character.
1. Casey Kasem: The legend! 2. Matthew Lillard: Lillard's voice for Shaggy is a great successor for Kasem, and it helps that he was live action Shaggy. 3. Billy West: Despite having a bit of Fry and Doug Funnie in there, he is a great stand in for Kasem. After this a short drop. 4. Will Forte: No, it doesn't sound like the others but it's a good performance if he just add a bit more rasp to it. 5. Scott Innes: As much as I like him as Scooby and Scrappy he is miscast here. 6. Scott Menville: This sounds too much like Zack from "Where on Earth is Carmen Sandiego?" I don't like it. 7. Sam Richardson: I don't care for "Velma" so this speaks for itself.
Obviously Matthew Lillard and Casey Kasem are absolutely legendary and deserve to share that #1 spot together, but Billy West and Scott Innes were both insanely good as well. Hell, Billy West sounded almost unrecognizable when compared to his other roles; that dude’s *insanely* talented.
I love how when you listen to Casey, then Listen to Mathew if just sounds as if Mathew's shaggy is the hd version of the same charector whata great preformance
Matthew Lilard and Casey Kasem are the best and OG’s for playing the voice of Shaggy since the beginning when I was growing up and now ugh the feels all over ❤❤❤❤❤
Scott innes voiced shaggy and scooby in the games night of 100 frights and mystery mayhem. His work makes shaggy feel most at home for me, but the others are great too, especially Matthew illard and casey kasem
Matthew Lillard of course he has an amazing Shaggy voice and he even did the Shaggy voice in front of his daughter, and I love Matthew Lillard 😍🥰 Matthew Lillard is so 🥵❤🔥
From top to bottom on my favorite Shaggys. 1 = Best and 7 = Okay-ish 1. Casey Kasem 2. Matthew Lillard 3. Scott Innes 4. Billy West 5. Scott Menville 6. Will Forte 7. Sam Richardson
Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard would be my favorite voices for Shaggy, although Billy West, Scott Innes, Scott Menville and Marc Silk are not bad in my opinion. I don't fully dislike the performances of the two most recent actors to voice him, they just seem not to quite capture either the familiar spirit or vocal idiosyncrasies of Shaggy as much.
I love Billy West's Shaggy sooo much more than I ever liked Scott Innes'! I feel like West's is really incredibly underrated but it makes sense seeing as he only did it for Zombie Island..
I think Casey Kasem WAS the best Shaggy until Matthew Lillard later on played Shaggy, making himself the "original" Shaggy now so now he irrefutably IS the best Shaggy in present times. Scott Innes is also one of the great voices of Shaggy for games but not suitable enough for cartoon movies. While on the other hand I don't understand under what circumstances were Will Forte and Sam Richardson hired to play the voice of Shaggy when you have the original Shaggy Matthew Lillard (or even Scott Innes as an alternative in the absence of Matthew)
Not that Scott Menville was a bad choice for Shaggy. It’s actually kinda fitting seeing how Menville is no stranger to Scooby Doo media. Also helping the fact is that Kasem played Robin in the 60s Superfriends cartoons and Menville just played Robin in Teen Titans. So it actually makes sense. But again, I think it’s more of the direction.
I first heard Scott Innes from First Frights, but I had played the sequel, Spooky Swamp, first, which had Matthew Lillard since he had officially been put in as Shaggy at the time. So going from SS to FF was... bizarre.
Matthew and Casey, 2 of the greats, feels like the biggest passing of the torch I've ever seen. One from the scowling in that Looney Toons movie and Mystery Inc as father and son. Im so glad they got Casey to voice the father of Shaggy before he passed away.
My favorites are a TIE between the OG Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard, matthew is so good as Shaggy that he have pretty much become the voice of Shaggy, the rest are also great...........with one obvious exception...........yeah the Velma one is easily the worst Shaggy hands down.
No one will ever voice shaggy like Casey Kasem. There's such a special quality to his voice, I always know when it's him who's voicing shaggy. Not to mention that he's the one who created the Shaggy voice.
Matthew lillard litterally screamed in his car until his voice was fucked up enough permenantly to do shaggy's voice easily. That guy deserves that role more than anybody
Damn most of these voice actors reallu naled it. Scott M sounds like Robin from teen titans with massive paranoia lol (i know its the same voice actor)
Also my impression is more in line with Zombie Island Shaggy and my friend is more like a Mathew lillard shag. And my favorite is all of them because shaggy stays on top even with will forte
Both Matthew Lillard and Casey Kasem are equally amazing as Shaggy Rogers.
Casey Kasem is the OG
@@bigmacintosh1766 yea Casey the classic and Matthew is the shaggy rogers
They're both the best of the best, but I think i've got a softspot for the slightly gruffer, more natural delivery Lillard's performance has evolved into
And don’t forget Scott
Eh, Scott Innes was pretty good.
1:28 Like scoob! I'M THE MAN BEHIND THE SLAUGHTER
Matthew Lillard was BORN to play Shaggy.
FULL AGREE
@@Kanonfangirl ZONIKS
The Man behind the.....
@@I6AM1GOD6 slaughter
@@psychicmouse1051 yeah BOY
The late Casey Kasem. The most comedic and paranoid of the bunch. Matthew Lillard is a worthy successor. It’s interesting that the live action actor of an established cartoon character went on to voice the character officially. Scott Innes was a pretty decent replacement though.
As much as I love Billy West in general, these 3 are the only ones that are worth anything.
agreed to all of this. i liked billy west's though@@GoldenWolf115
@@Fel1xF7WI can hear Fry in his voice hidden in there tho it’s distracting
Actually, I think Billy West has a little less of an accent so he sounds closer to Casey Kasem's
Scott Ines is surprisingly sounds really close to Casey Kasem, I used to think they were the same person till today!
I didn't even know shaggy had that many different voice Actors
Scott is definitely awesome
@@ashwegerle4838Despite Casey Kasem voiced Shaggy until his retirement in 2009, he temporarily stopped voicing the character during the 90s because he was a vegan and was asked to voice Shaggy for a Burger King commercial.
IIRC, when Kasem came back to voice Shaggy during the 2000s, Shaggy was a vegan.
Which Scott are you talking about?
Human.
Matthew Lillard and Casey Kasem are my favourites. No one can play Shaggy like they can. They both do an amazing job
1. Casey Kasem/Matthew Lillard
2. Scott Innes
3. Billy West
4. Will Forte
5. Mark Silk
6. Sam Richardson
7. Scott Menville
I knew Robin was at the bottom before hitting “read more” lol.
I feel bad for Menville - he's got the inflection but the register ain't there :[
I mean at least Scott is white 💀
How is Sam Richardson not at the bottom of this list? 😂
Put Sam at the bottom and this list is 100% correct
Scott Menville sounds like Robin trying to voice Shaggy.
Agree
LOL
Wonder why 💀
@@The_Punisher 😂👏
Ironic because Casey Kasem voiced Robin from the Super Friends series in the late 70s and early 80s.
My favourites are both the Original Shaggy himself Casey Kasem, and Matthew Lillard the first live actor of Shaggy did an amazing job as Casey Kasem's successor.
Obviously, Casey Kasem is the best and most legendary Shaggy, but MAN Matthew Lillard came in a great second place, he nailed the voice almost identically!
It's facinating that all of shaggy's voice actors did a great job.
For me it's a tie between Casey Kasem (still miss him) and Matthew Lillard. These guys were BORN to play Shaggy and I can't decide which is better.
I think Scott Innes, Billy West and Will Forte are also really good
Lillard and Innes are the only ones that come close to sounding like the Kasem. They both come in at a very close second place for me.
I grew up with Scott Innes. I really didnt watch much Scooby Doo except for Mystery Incorporated while growing up, but i absolutely loved Scooby Doo First Frights and Scooby Doo and the Spooky Swamp.
Scott Innes is my Twin Brother's favorite voice for Shaggy. His voice was just right during 1999, 2000, and 2001. 😃. My Twin brother loves his voice so much he chooses that one specifically whenever he does his Shaggy impression.
But Casey Kasem is the OG
@@bigmacintosh1766 obviously
Same honestly, It's a mix between Matthew and Scott. At first I was like, why that one but I just can't help it, it's iconic to me since Scooby Doo Project
Because he is the best shaggy
"hahaha hey scoob how are you? i'm doing amazing! i just stuffed some children into animatronics and kill them HAHAH how are you scoob?"
scoob:"shaggy you need a therapist"
Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard.
Matthew Lillard (R.I.P. Casey Kasem)
I sure am going to miss him so much 😢
Matthew Lillard as Shaggy Rogers is perfect
1:28 Way perfect 😁👍👍
I like both Kasem and Lillard. In fact, when Casey Kasem started playing Shaggy, he was doing an impression of Richard Crenna in Our Miss Brooks.😊
Will Forte walks in and delivers the most god awful shaggy impression possible
I love how since Matthew Lillard voiced him after Casey Kasem retired from the role and passed away, Shaggy was sounding like "a total space cadet".
Mr. Lillard is the only worthy successor to Mr. Kasem himself.
matthew lillard is my favorite shaggy voice
Matthew is just perfect for the role. It's crazy how well they did casting him in the live action movie. I also love Billy West. Sam just sounds like a dude. Like, i would never know that was shaggy or even a cartoon character at all just by listening.
No one could have been a better successor of the late Casey Kasem than Matthew Lillard. The dude purposely destroyed his vocal cords just to sound raspy like shaggy, and was so good in his live action role he rightfully became the official voice actor in future renditions of the show. You can tell how much he loves the character.
0:08 Casey Kasem
0:17 Billy West
0:39 Scott Innes
1:29 Matthew Lillard (William Afton)
Why is Norville here? Bro thinks he's on a team! 😭
Like it or not, he is an adaptation of the character.
Dude's only Shaggy in name only. He doesn't even act like Shaggy at all. Hell the Jedi Sha'a Gi was a better Shaggy than him.
1. Matthew Lillard
2. Casey Kasem
3. Billy West
4. Scott Innes
5. Mark Silk
6. Sam Richardson
7. Scott Menville
8. Will Forte
Casey and Matthew were the best
Same goes to Billy and Scott, they're the best too. 😊👍👍
1. Casey Kasem: The legend!
2. Matthew Lillard: Lillard's voice for Shaggy is a great successor for Kasem, and it helps that he was live action Shaggy.
3. Billy West: Despite having a bit of Fry and Doug Funnie in there, he is a great stand in for Kasem.
After this a short drop.
4. Will Forte: No, it doesn't sound like the others but it's a good performance if he just add a bit more rasp to it.
5. Scott Innes: As much as I like him as Scooby and Scrappy he is miscast here.
6. Scott Menville: This sounds too much like Zack from "Where on Earth is Carmen Sandiego?" I don't like it.
7. Sam Richardson: I don't care for "Velma" so this speaks for itself.
I disagree. Scott Innes was spot on tbh
I'd personally have Scott Innes over Billy West
I was wondering if he did scrappy too. I could hear him in there.
Will sounds like he’s just talking normal
Innes definitely 3rd place.fantastic job.
My top 3: Matthew Lillard, Scott Innes, Casey Kasem
Obviously Matthew Lillard and Casey Kasem are absolutely legendary and deserve to share that #1 spot together, but Billy West and Scott Innes were both insanely good as well. Hell, Billy West sounded almost unrecognizable when compared to his other roles; that dude’s *insanely* talented.
I wish billy got to do more shaggy I just love hearing his shaggy impression
As I said from the previous video, the late great Casey Kasem is the best voice actor for Shaggy.
for some reason my video cut out at 2:23 it must have been a pretty weird glitch, strange there hasn't been any other shaggies past 2020
I feel like every shaggy except for scott Melville and will forte always did great jobs voicing shaggy while putting there own spin on the character
Matthew Lillard is the Best Shaggy Voice Actor
... currently alive.
FIFY
I love how when you listen to Casey, then Listen to Mathew if just sounds as if Mathew's shaggy is the hd version of the same charector whata great preformance
As a kid, I never noticed how different the Zombie Island Shaggy voice was from the original.
God, going from Matthew Lillaed to Will Forte is such a.. moment
Matthew Lilard and Casey Kasem are the best and OG’s for playing the voice of Shaggy since the beginning when I was growing up and now ugh the feels all over ❤❤❤❤❤
Casey Kassem and Matthew Lillard are two iconic Shaggy voices
To be completely honest, my very favorite voices of Shaggy Norville Rogers are Casey Kasem, Scott Innes, Matthew Lillard and Will Forte.
Scott Innes is my favorite.
Mine too. 😁👍
What about the Burger Kids Kids Meal commercial in 1996 was that Billy West or Tom Kenny. Casey didn't because he wanted Shaggy to be Vegetarian.
Scott innes voiced shaggy and scooby in the games night of 100 frights and mystery mayhem. His work makes shaggy feel most at home for me, but the others are great too, especially Matthew illard and casey kasem
I can hear Robin in Scott Menville's Shaggy voice
"Freddy?! Zoinks!!"
Prophetic.
Matthew Lillard of course he has an amazing Shaggy voice and he even did the Shaggy voice in front of his daughter, and I love Matthew Lillard 😍🥰 Matthew Lillard is so 🥵❤🔥
From top to bottom on my favorite Shaggys. 1 = Best and 7 = Okay-ish
1. Casey Kasem
2. Matthew Lillard
3. Scott Innes
4. Billy West
5. Scott Menville
6. Will Forte
7. Sam Richardson
Gohan: Couch cough norville... Cough
2:25 video ends here 2:55
Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard would be my favorite voices for Shaggy, although Billy West, Scott Innes, Scott Menville and Marc Silk are not bad in my opinion. I don't fully dislike the performances of the two most recent actors to voice him, they just seem not to quite capture either the familiar spirit or vocal idiosyncrasies of Shaggy as much.
Casey Kasem, Matthew Lillard, Scott Innes, Billy West and no-one else.
I like Billy as a voice actor, but his Shaggy isn't very good. I agree with your list. The drop off after Innes is deep.
I gotta say that Mathew lillard is my all time favorite
RIP CASEY KASEM 🙏🙏🙏❤️❤️❤️
I love Billy West's Shaggy sooo much more than I ever liked Scott Innes'! I feel like West's is really incredibly underrated but it makes sense seeing as he only did it for Zombie Island..
I love Casey Kasem, Scott Innes, Will Forte and the Great Matthew Lillard, cause they are so good at it.
I think Casey Kasem WAS the best Shaggy until Matthew Lillard later on played Shaggy, making himself the "original" Shaggy now so now he irrefutably IS the best Shaggy in present times. Scott Innes is also one of the great voices of Shaggy for games but not suitable enough for cartoon movies. While on the other hand I don't understand under what circumstances were Will Forte and Sam Richardson hired to play the voice of Shaggy when you have the original Shaggy Matthew Lillard (or even Scott Innes as an alternative in the absence of Matthew)
Not that Scott Menville was a bad choice for Shaggy. It’s actually kinda fitting seeing how Menville is no stranger to Scooby Doo media.
Also helping the fact is that Kasem played Robin in the 60s Superfriends cartoons and Menville just played Robin in Teen Titans. So it actually makes sense.
But again, I think it’s more of the direction.
Thank you for uploading this video.
I never knew Billy west voiced shaggy
Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard. Will Forte is an awesome guy but I don't think he was right for Shaggy.
1:00 Shaggy: Nice try Scoob! Like catch me if you can!
I first heard Scott Innes from First Frights, but I had played the sequel, Spooky Swamp, first, which had Matthew Lillard since he had officially been put in as Shaggy at the time. So going from SS to FF was... bizarre.
probably every future voice actor will watch this vid when doing research for the role
I didn't actually know ol' legendary Billy West did Shaggy's voice at one point. He's not bad!
2:26 GET THAT FAKE SHAGGY OUT OF HERE!!!( Sam can stay tho.)
I'm Going As Shaggy For Halloween Wearing Converse
Mathew lillard / my childhood / springtrap / William afton
Scott and Casey sound the most similar to each other , but Matthew really owns it in his own very special way!
now Casey may be the original but as a guy who loves Mystery Inc i have to give it to Mathew Lillard because i'm just biased like that
Matthew and Casey, 2 of the greats, feels like the biggest passing of the torch I've ever seen. One from the scowling in that Looney Toons movie and Mystery Inc as father and son. Im so glad they got Casey to voice the father of Shaggy before he passed away.
My favorites are a TIE between the OG Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard, matthew is so good as Shaggy that he have pretty much become the voice of Shaggy, the rest are also great...........with one obvious exception...........yeah the Velma one is easily the worst Shaggy hands down.
i developed a late night obsession with shaggy voice actors, im so grateful this video exists
No one will ever voice shaggy like Casey Kasem. There's such a special quality to his voice, I always know when it's him who's voicing shaggy. Not to mention that he's the one who created the Shaggy voice.
Like, Matt all the way Scoob, he’s like, the best Shaggy
After hearing them all back to back Matthew Lillard is my favorite (but think my favorite cast was the one in the courage cross over)
Can't believe 2 Robin actors played Shaggy.
What 😳? I didn't know Burt Ward voiced Shaggy. I always thought Casey Kasem and Matthew Lillard were the only 2. Just joking 🙃.
Matthew lillard litterally screamed in his car until his voice was fucked up enough permenantly to do shaggy's voice easily. That guy deserves that role more than anybody
I think Scott Menville is better off as Robin and whomever he plays as in BO2
1st Casey Kasem 2nd Matthew Lillard 3rd Scott Innes............... imo anyway
Shaggy’s voice always cracks me up😂😂😂
Mathew Lillard 🐐
Casey Kasem (I did not know he died, but R.I.P) .
He passed away like back in the early 2010s, how do you NOT know that ?
@@skinnyweenie8679 I know right? Every news station was talking about that in 2014.
Damn most of these voice actors reallu naled it. Scott M sounds like Robin from teen titans with massive paranoia lol (i know its the same voice actor)
Casey kasem, billy west, Matthew lillard, Scott innes, Marc silk and will forte are both the perfect voice actors for shaggy
wow Matthew Lillard plays shaggy Roger's really good.
All of them.
Top 3: Casey Kasem, Billy West and Matthew Lillard
Scott innes usually plays shaggy in the Scooby Doo video games the online games and the CD ROM games for PC and the DVD games
Casey Kasem, Scott Innes and Matthew Lillard.
WB really should keep matthew lillard as their main shaggy like casey kasem animated and live action, his voice is spot on
Matthew Lillard hands down
OG shaggy voice actor and the shaggy voice actor for Scooby-Doo zombie Island
Idk will forte and I don’t know his career but he dropped the ball hard on the voice. The emotions tho were PHENOMENAL. I’ll give him that
Also my impression is more in line with Zombie Island Shaggy and my friend is more like a Mathew lillard shag. And my favorite is all of them because shaggy stays on top even with will forte
Casey Kasem and Mathew lillard will always be my shaggy rogers.
Mathew Lillard and Casey Kasem are my favorites, but Scott Innes and Billy West were good also.
I love Matthew Millard the most!
Casey Kasem, Scott Innes and Mathew Lillard fit the role perfectly
The Winner is Mathew Lillard.