Attack on Titan Chapter 139: "Freedom" (Full chapter remake)
Вставка
- Опубліковано 30 вер 2024
- It's finally here, my remake for the last chapter of Attack on Titan.
Now, I know not everyone agrees with Isayama's ending, but that's no reason to demean him or verbally harm him, he still gave us an amazing story and I wouldn't be making edits on AoT if he didn't. I don't agree with how AoT ending, but I respect Isayama's hard work and passion he had for his story.
Making this was certainly a pain in the ass, the editing software I have is pretty trash so it'd export the parts with frozen frames and missing transitions, but I got there in the end through trial and error.
Just to clear a few things up: This is not a shipping video, it's just my vision for the ending, as a passionate and dedicated fan. I'm no writer and I certainly can't make a story as good as Isayama, but you can bet I tried.
Historia and Eren shouldn't be "in love", aot was never about love. AoT is a tragic story, and I stuck to that in my remake.
Do not repost without credit, your video will be flagged if you do so.
I do not own any of the music in this video, all artists and composers allow for me to use them with fair use, please go check out the music through these links:
1st ost: • Attack on Titan Season...
2nd: • Attack on Titan S4: Wa...
3rd: • "AntiHero" Attack On T...
4th: • Attack On Titan OST (...
5th: • Attack on Titan - "Cal...
6th: • Attack on Titan Season...
7th: • Attack on Titan Season...
#attackontitan
#aot139
#aot139remake
Eren : i have no choice, but to kill everyone and everything
Armin : Noooooooo.... anyway, lets see the ocean Eren.
@@wut2697 no, Hitler ruled with fear meanwhile Eren simply slaughtered the world by crushing them quickly. They all got quick deaths
@@linusbirgersson Running for their lives in a hopeless attempt to escape being ultimately trampled to death. Sounds quick to you? How stupid.
@@youmode562 it also flaw with eren too
His goal with the rumbling beside there's no choice to save the paradis was because he wanted to save his friend and want them to live longer than him
while here he just killed them contradiction ,
about fritz i think it will more fit with karl since he's the one who started the helos conspiracy
tbh to me this ending is better than the og
@@youmode562 Bruh, this is literally the third comment I've seen you complain to other people. Again, no one's trying to be Isayama. It's a FAN ending.
@@bored_potato man are you commenting after very comment I made?! 😂 like I told you before I rated his ending as if it was an actual ending because that’s why he made this video because that’s what he liked it to be... but by rating it accordingly you can see that I t has a big plot hole and if isayama made something like that it would have been considered as both a plot hole and a plot device.
"Eren, I swore to devote my heart to the resurrection of mankind. There is no greater glory than dying for that belief."
Is such a great callback to Season 1 when Armin tried to convince that cowardly commander that Eren could be a greater ally than an enemy.
yeah but OMG it ended up as the worst enemy.
I dont really know about some holes in plot that there can be about this ending,but correcting some things It is far better than thr original one.
They didnt break eren's characters,neither make a naruto type ending and it felt like reading aot.
i continue to say this is the ending we all deserved and the ending we were expecting. you did a great job, considering you’re not an artist nor writer. truly gave me the chills, good job!!
did ymir reborn as historia's child
Yes
so first off = awesome work yuma
secondly, so let me get this straight, king fritz was the big bad but eren defeated him, then talked to his friends and then he killed them and returned to historia ?
"I won't let your deaths be meaningless even If I'm the last one standing."
This is a quote from the second opening called Jiyuu no Tsubasa. I like to think this is how Eren remembers his comrades.
How many lines must we draw on a prison wall of all the incredible foreshadowing for an ending with Eren coming out as the tragic living victor in this manga. Just to know it, and witness it was flushed away?
I always thought that quote was a nod to Armin since they showed him at the same moment the lyric played
@@soggyfan123 In the original ending it's for Armin. But in this version I think it would fit Eren too.
I think that refers to Levi actually. He was always tormented by the deaths of his comrades, which he wanted to repay and to give a meaning to, and when Eren was killed and the world was saved he demonstrated to have kept his promise, at the cost of basically remaining the only soldier alive if we exclude the Alliance.
That opening is the one of the Female Titan arc, where his squad gets introduced and also murdered, so this makes a lot of sense.
@@justinfever9787 could you enlighten me of other lines that you think were flushed away? Don't get me wrong, I just want to know and possibly explain them. The Akatsuki no Requiem ending still makes sense since Eren still killed 80% of the world, and the world being a completely flat blanket was his concept of freedom.
A meeting between Eren and King Fritz is everything I never knew I needed.
Same here. It makes no sense, but l love it.
It makes sense on why the vow of renounce war stayed in place for so long
Same
@@ErenYeager-fn6lw You kinda…….smell like a baka
@@hiroshiramasendjews9539 It makes sense because the Titan curse just ended after Eren dies with no further explanation.
King Fritz being the big bad all along is actually a pretty sick idea. Erasing his vow of hatred from the world is a legitimate reason for the rumbling to start and reach its conclusion. Currently everyone is born from a tainted seed and to free this world they need to step aside and let new life grow from the pure soil of a new world. If I had to compare it to the Matrix, its like instead of rebooting the Matrix, The One actually ended the system and everyone connected to it.
👏👏👏
But the destruction of life is totally unnecessary, isn't it?
@@陳潔明-w6y could a founder with royal blood break the vow to renounce war? No. But apparently zeke magically pulled it out his ass. Nothing in aot makes sense.
@@Yumais but zeke could be a royal who is the descendant of the sibling of the king of the walls and not from his progeny like historia, thereby not bounded by his vow
@@陳潔明-w6y it was necessary ASSUMING ur in PARADIS SIDE that is. The world gave eren no other option but to eliminate everything outside the WALL remember? The world decided they were evil b4 even knowing them & eren's running out of time.
now that isa fckd the fumbling if u seen the latest leaks panel they said paradis got destroyed🤦
-eren accomplishes nothing
- theres still a titan they said 😂
- History repeats itself & everything is pointless
- mikasa had a child w/ jean (looks like) apparently 🤦
this fan ending made a lot more sense.. not that crappy love fetish ymir did I thought ymir is so much more🤦 this fan made gives justice to her character..... Especially to erens character.....✌️✌️
Holy God when you think about it it almost fits this I almost original ending he wanted to kill everyone off
This ending is so much superior to the shit one we got. I hope true fans or better writers like you remake failed stories like attack on titan or shaman king to rewrite it into better stories that are much more satisfying and better and fit into their themes, like the Spider-Man ps4 game, the resident evil remakes, and the final fantasy 7 remake.
I'm just gonna pretend that the original was just some wierd fever dream Armin was having
Our dark lord Armin the great lol
copium
It was an alternate path of events where eren was testing the founding and screwed everything up. Also canon if you remember eren said the founder confused him with past present future being combined.
Yeah u guys r rude. It’s not like the ending was bad...y’all are spoiled baby’s
@@drmosaddegh lol
Having King Fritz as the final-ish boss is so much better than that weird "Ymir is actually in love with Fritz" plot twist.
Edit 2: I misjudged you "Mr. Survivor", you still suck on debating but you made good points, you shinzhou sasageyo'd to the damn end
@Jardel Edeza yeah but with how bad I feel about the original ending, im accepting anything else but that at this point
@Jardel Edeza yeah, king fritz as the final boss seems like an epic ending because it closes the theme of oppressors reign coming to an end.....but it makes less sense, why would he have the walls built or even let eldians be oppressed then?
@Jardel Edeza you likely won't but thanks anyway
@@tannaikamath773 Edit: I found one comment that made Fritz's appearance a little more believable. It's likely that he's simply a hallucination made from Ymir's broken mind, the part of her trauma that instilled the belief that she will always be a slave and she can never escape from him even in death. Eren freed her of that terrible belief and thus, defeated "King Fritz".
(Man, I wish that was the one Isayama put instead of making her "in love" with Fritz, what was the man thinking?)
@Jardel Edeza many things in canon version of ALL story does not make sense, it is a "fantasy", not realism-based story, just add another element as a twist and even the Fritz final boss would make sense
I actually felt like I'm reading Attack On Titan for once, If u know what I mean
We can pretend it's real. Isayma pretty much got the idea of his ending from looking at chats from fans so that ending was pretty much fan-made. And since this was his original plan it's pretty much cannon.
Ikr this was fucking awesome
@@antiskeii2616 It for sure has its flaws. Throughout the video I kept asking myself how Fritz gained access to the paths or where him eren and ymir were and some lined were pretty cheesy and some even cringy but this ending just connects perfectly to the akatsuki no reqiuem video where eren is visiting his friends‘ graves on paradis. I consider this canon now lmao
Not me, I don't wanna put up with this shit anymore since people hate all the characters execpt for Eren and Historia for no dumb reason.
@@Tmtrnr22 no ending has no plot holes
Broke: accepting 139 as canon
Woke: accepting all well made fan endings as official alternate endings/PATHS
Whoever wrote this is a CHAD
@@bean181 man u got me
technically canon
That’s just so stupid, no matter how much you wish and want to accept these fan endings as the real thing, that doesn’t make them official. That’s all they are, fan fiction. Whether you want to or not, 139 is cannon
@@mrinfamous9862 139 is cannon that is true. The fact that a cannon ending is that bad is what surprises me.
Game of thrones vibes here about the ending.
6 of my friends who watched aot were dissapointed about the ending.
Before reading the manga a guy in my classroom was literally saying me this is the worst thing I've ever read in my life and that friend was a huge fan of aot since he was 12 years old LMAO
Man, this is more impactful than the real ending. I think this is the "The Mist" ending that Isayama really want.
The mist, now you convince me.
Imagine if this is what Mappa adapts instead of Isayama's ending..
BufferRen if this really happens then I will be very happy but it's a fan made ending. So, there are very less chances that MAPPA will adopt this ending instead of Isayama's ending.
@@mondeepengti8733 well unless the finale was like animated already, they will most likely at LEAST change the ending a bit, since how fans took the manga ending
You know what? Fuck this.
Why did the fan fiction break my heart and actually made me feel something than the canon material?
Because it payed off Erens main character development, and fullfiled the main narratives of AOT.
Well it didn't destroy any characters. And it wasn't that lazily written. In the leaked interview Isayama himself said he was careless on his writing, and that's why this whole chapter felt off because well, he just never wrote like this before.
Because people bitched about his original ending and wanted something lighter so we got what we got.
@@PgLangGang How is this a lighter ending?
@@pinkaengelz I’m talking about the real thing by the real author.
Holy SHIT this was fucking perfect. Eren feels so much like the Eren I used to know and the Devil Of All Earth part made me fucking scream. It manages to hold on to the themes of aot and still was able to introduce Fritz role for the end. Fritz having the exact opposite beliefs to Eren was genius. I always believed that the Attack Titan WAS Eren, thus why all the attack titans in history always fought and seeked out freedom. I also love how this handled the allience and I actually teared up at their deaths. And the fucking Armin parallel with Erwin was ingenious. This was an incredible experience and I actually felt the excitement of reading attack on titan again, the actual chapter feels like the fanfic after viewing. Thank you so much for this, this brings joy to my heart♡
Your copium is unreal lol.
@@Kobe_ found the eremika fan lmao
@@sweetinvictus654 Found the delusional lmao
@@Kobe_ you like the idea of family members fornicating please never use the word delusional again without looking at yourself
Eren yeager
This...is beyond fucking perfect, you took Fritz's character and turned him into this entity which knew the story all along and added a new ability to the attack titan, that part was masterful.
And how fritz could be in the paths if he never get a titan power? This is morr unreal than anything
@@gerardoperez7577 Cry
@@alphamale3060 you did it w this right
@@gerardoperez7577 keep crying
@@gerardoperez7577 And how a bird can put you a scarf?
Does that even make sense?
I feel bad for Isayama because I know he probably thought of an ending similar to this but was to anxious about the ending being perfect and passed this one up. Still appreciate the story he gave us tho
I saw this theory on reddit that the anime is going to have a different ending. There were a lot of good hints. Isayama's editor forced him to change the ending.
@@myaparker5510 so his editor could have forced him to change the ending for a goddamn sequel?!
@@megaavonaco9954 Who knows what his editor was thinking.
@@megaavonaco9954 On June 9th we'll get answers. Isayama's 3 hours long interview
@@myaparker5510 thats really sad because the ending was incredible. This one is alright. People are just complaining over stupid stuff with it. Half the questions they have on different things about it I can answer in a heartbeat because of things you can easily infer or have been in the story before to look back on.
i really like this ending! It may have some problems, but that's mainly because the whole Rumbling arc itself has established so many unsolvable mysteries. The edits themselves were godlike! You managed to make me cry twice, so: good fucking job! You have created a great piece of art!
I’m sorry but this ending has too many flaws. The first and most important one is that king Fritz can’t be in the paths not being Ymir descendant. I can tell you for sure that if isayama had made this ending. MANY people would have criticised it even more.
@@youmode562 If we assume Ymir created paths to fulfill King Fritz's mission in the first place, it wouldn't be farfetched to say he would be the one person who can reside there despite not being a descendant of Ymir.
It could also just be a fabrication of Ymir herself, a manifestation of her slave mindset, so to say. Compared to the original ending, those flaws can be explained just as well, while being way more enertaining by itself.
@@Fabiocean2000 no man it would not... the paths were there for her alone because of her desire to be free from even death. If isayma brought back the king he would have made him the ultimate villain like kaguya. It would have ruined the arc if he showed something like that. He is not needed especially not in the last chapter... and if isayama ever did something like that.... that type of flaw couldn’t be explained because we are shown that those paths are only there for Ymir’s descendant and she answers to the royal bloodline because of their connection with the king but he can’t be there. It wouldn’t make any sense.
@@youmode562 yeah this ending is just as bad and confusing Eren killing everyone just make him more edgier and him coming back from death as a collosal is just plot armor this have more flaw than the OG one
@@wut2697 I don’t think the og was bad but it was a bit rushed and it needed a better execution.
Have u read the leaks ?? 😂😂😂😂😂Wtf, isayama. Paradis was destroyed. And even the curse of ymir still existed. And lastly, mikasa and Jean with their children visited eren's grave. What the shitty ending. If paradis was destroyed then I like this part.. That's what they get for not listening to floch.. 😂😂😂😂😂
Eren would never kill Armin and Mikasa, we know he cared most about them. So this video was shit, with all its plot holes. I don’t agree with the leaks either, the ending for me was ended when I seen ‘fin’ on the last page, I ain’t even gonna look at those leaks.
In my opinion the ending would have been perfect if Eren killed all Marleans and let the Eldians only live. This video doesn’t do that. Having Eren as a true hero to eldians and a sacrifice would have made way more sense.
@@Nazoou_Neon we don't know if it is confirmed. But we have to wait for a month. 😂😂
@@jennyarpilleda4809 I doubt it’s true. Sounds like a load of Jean fans spread this rumour.
@@Nazoou_Neon the leaks are from Zekken, the person who leaked the Chapter 139 panels and everyone thought they were fake. So he's very reliable.
@@jennyarpilleda4809 It is already out
Nah this is kinda stupid tbh.
I know the real ending is still garbage but what u did is still not really good.
You're right. This ending is not really good.
Please, have a backup of this video. Don't let it die.
It's your version and it's good.
Petition for this to be what MAPPA animates? Anybody?
I know it's spliced together bits of the actual manga and isn't at least visually a complete story line. But it would be amazing to see this concept animated.
Yes please, this ending is more fits for attack on titan than the original.
Bruh mappa would never do it,maybe some minor changes but if they change the ending it would be a disrespect to Isayama.....but yeah if they animated this as an alternate ending it would be hella awesome
@@bruh-sy9kc yeah, I know they wouldn't do something like that seeing that they were trying to play it safe and go exactly by the manga shot for shot in part 1. WIT may have done something, but yeah probably not MAPPA.
@@bruh-sy9kc if isayama would think to give an anime original ending to anime work
Can we help this 10x better fan ending than the real one to get more views?
Like the owner of the video said its not perfect yet still much much better and actually feels like aot more than the shit we got
ua-cam.com/video/NbWnCcaS0pM/v-deo.html
what do u think about this fan-made ending?
its akatsuki no requiem ending
139 wasn't terrible. If you don't like it you don't have to force other people to hate it as well. I personally enjoyed the ending.
@@100factspitter8 he didnt force anyone as u see 72 people r agree with him
u r the one forcing others to dont comment their opinions
most of fans r disappointed from ending and some of them left the fandom
u think with defending a trash aot's reputation will be preserved?
no , isayama destroyed eren's whole career and ending was full of bugs and plot holes
just look at that above link its a fan made ending
@@erenthebirdyeager8076 I don't care for reputation it's just that yall expect everyone to hate the ending and keep posting "OMG the aot ending is trash how can you like it it's complete shit" that's what I meant. You're trying to make everyone hate the ending and get mad when someone doesn't have the same opinion as you. You're missing what aot is about. Freedom. I am free to have my own opinion about the ending as everyone does. All you do by saying the ending was trash is just starting a war. Just as Isayama said in an interview when aot ends it will hurt everyone. Basically a war about if its good or bad. Really pointless. Instead of arguing we all should just say #thankyouIsayama for a masterpiece that will inspire the next generation of story tellers. But guess that will never happen.
@@100factspitter8 u r a minority, most of fans r disappointed for ending
and some of them left the fandom like me
The ending of anime will change
btw, have fun with lord isayama's ending
I would have given this a 9/10 if you allowed Armin and Mikasa to live as well.
“You have to save Mikasa and Armin!”
I still can't believe mikasa dead like wtfff my brain nuuuu mikasa nuuu T.T
-
This was amazing though ngl, feels like I'm trippin tho after watchin this
Mikasa killed eren then how is he alive?
@@ayxshhh448 As many others already said in the comments this has its flaws ofc you can criticize it but as the guy who made it already said in the description he’s just a fan himself as well so there might be heavy flaws. As for my answer to your question: Maybe the hallucigenia reconnected with Eren and resurrected him but that’s just a theory
@@ayxshhh448 because of paths i think, that is like titan heaven, so every titan soul is there, and Ymir can just resurrect anybody, I am pretty sure this also happens with Zeke so is really canon. (I mean he got fucking separated in 2, not even a titan has this level of regeneration)
And also times goes way slower in the paths so he can just live an eternity in paths while his head is cut out, like that zoom from flashpoint that got headshoted and survives for days
A possibility that might be able to explain why eren is alive could be : he used Reiner move to transfer his will to a part of his body. This way he could regenerate himself. Maybe ?
This ending fits more what Isayama was thinking. May it has plotholes too, but is very fitting to the story of SNK.
Obviously is better thant the original ending, that's for sure.
Thanks for trying another final to this amazing series!
I agree I really like this as well maybe in an alternate universe this is the ending he made
I’m sorry but this ending has too many flaws. The first and most important one is that king Fritz can’t be in the paths not being Ymir descendant. I can tell you for sure that if isayama had made this ending. MANY people would have criticised it even more.
@Goldmetal Alchesmith every show becomes shitty if you take things out of context... and that’s what that video is about. Happy you enjoyed it.
@Goldmetal Alchesmith what type of shit do you watch man? I’m a bit worried 😂
Why would it fit what isayama was thinking? The ending he wrote was the one obviously. Why would he even maka eren turn against his friends, for no reason or what? 😂💀 And historia? Seriously, obviously there was never a thing. Fans just want to bang her so they selfinsert themselves into eren.
This completely butchers the aot's concept of freedom,how are people liking this shit,I don't like ch139 that much but this is atrocious
I'm gonna tell my kids this is the real ending
Go for it
Fr
imma tell my whole decedents that this is the ending
You are a kid yourself.
Go for it comrade!
mind if I react to this? I'll put your channel in the credit of course.
Ayyyy I watched your rant respect from the yeagerbomb community!
I say do it lol. I loved your rant, expressed everything I was feeling.
Go ahead do it bro I’m sure he wouldn’t mind
Yesss...i wanna see you reacting to this!
Do it!
Fucking perfect. It fits erens character completely. it fits the theme of the story completely. It fits the message of the story completely. This ending should be the true fucking ending, its perfect.
Kinda. Except king Frits being in the paths doesn’t make sense. He has no Titan power. That is weird. But everything else was A1
not perfect but its good
Why Did he kill his Friends?
@Jardel Edeza Exactly, I could accept the rest of the story even with the flaws. But Eren killing his friends makes no logical sense whatsoever. EREN ALWAYS PROTECTED THEM IN ANY WAY HE COULD. He always prioritized his friends over everyone.
@@nobchopper9728 You do know that since before Grisha got the attack titan, Eren Kruger saw Eren's memories and specifically told him to save Mikasa and Armin. They are his priority even before he was born. And you're trying to tell me he would kill them? Sasha and the rest died in consequence of his actions, not by him. And let's be honest, if he didn't do all of this they all would've been dead anyway. It's not like Marley and the rest of the world would've spared them. I can only say that his Mom died because of him but then again, without her death he wouldn't have become so motivated to kill titans. And without angry german kid Eren, Paradis would've been doomed anyway. This was the only way he could give Mikasa and Armin their freedom. He didn't really care about his followers and definitely not about Floch. The most hard hitting death to him during this war was Sasha. You could tell how that broke him. And she was just a good friend. Mikasa and Armin are much more than that. Even in the anime when he said he wanted his friends to live long lives, he looked at Mikasa.
This is my opinion so don't take this personally.
This ending suits the anime perfect
Doesn't him killing mikasa and armin kinda goes against the ending of Season 2 or 3 when Eren Kruger told Grisha Yeager to save mikasa and armin?
What's with people's obsession with Kruger's speech? He was just getting memories from Grisha before he turned Eren into a titan. These were litteraly Grisha's last words
@@ruben4257 grishia didn’t know who admin or mikasa was, pretty sure those mementoes were from eren
@@zeplis7244 geisha knew who were armin and mikasa in the future lmao
@@Arya-zi8no I like how you were bothered to write that even though he knows that
@@dripalien4529 eh I was saying that grisha knows them in the future I.e it was simply a memory from grisha nothing to do with eren
Such a good ending. You got talent. This is my canon ending.
Yeah this is my ending. I'm going to ignore chapter 139.
@@myaparker5510 too bad chapter 139 is canon, can't change the fact. Let's hope Mappa can execute the ending better
@@twinz5694 Isayama choked, it ain’t canon. It’s canon in the EMtards universe, not reality.
@@mforvoiceovermemes you're in denial, just move on and accept it
@@twinz5694 Accept the literal shit on my plate? Yeah no, AOT no requiem.
I like the role you gave to king Fritz, that actually made perfectly sense. Glad I'm not the only one who noticed that Isayama in chapter 139 portrayed him sitting on a throne with the Yggdrasil - the symbol of the Paths - engraved on it, that was never there during the flashback. What was he thinking while he drew that chapter? I wish I knew how it came to it. Anyway your ending is sure better than the one Isayama gave to the story, the effort you put in it is evident.
Actually I think it’s good but it doesn’t make sense the king fritz was in paths since he was never a subject of Ymir
@@shin_a I think Yuma here made this choice mainly out of symbolic, allegorical reasons. And that symbolism was right there also in the original work although it was veeery, veeeery, veeeery subtle. There were many subtle hints in that flashback that indicated that he wasn't exactly just a normal man and that he was an allegory of something else. So, at least from a symbolic standpoint, that could've actually been a possible development of his character. But apparently Isayama lost his mind along with his balls, so. Whatever.
From a narrative standpoint you could be right, but he was an Eldian after all, and being an Eldian equals with being a subject of Ymir. I can guess that when he died he ended up in the Paths like everybody else and in the Paths past, present and future coexist, so he could've schemed something there while everybody thought he was gone. Of course that's just guessing and it doesn't hold much narrative consistency. But for what is worth, nothing makes sense in AoT anymore.
Anyway, I think Yuma could answer you better, I'm just guessing here.
@@nemesis5791 i guess that could explain it and makes more sense. i just hope for the anime adaptation mappa will do something about the ending, although at first i was okay with it. i noticed some strange things and plotholes but overall i was satisfied. i still am, i dont hate the ending, i just wish it was better written and not rushed, as isayama said.
Ye I guess you could explain this by Ymir forcibly bringing him. There or replace fritz with Karl fritz and have him want to destroy the eldian race while Eren wants to save it
@@bean181 It's not about the Eldian race, here, it's about... How to say it? The paradigm informing the world?
At some point the theme of Aot started to revolve around the actual end of the world, the actual Ragnarok, and the birth of a new one. I was expecting the series to go the Evangelion route, but unfortunately in the end the topic was dropped along with many other themes. The Founding owners were regarded as gods, and the hallucigenia, the source of the titan powers, was deemed as the source of organic life itself. This means that its actual potential and powers were much more than what we were shown. Well, in this context, all the previous Founding owners represent a reactionary force that, despite the goals they may had, never questioned the very order of things, the very nature of the world (a world that we are repeatedly told and shown is cruel and with no room for true freedom in it), unlike Eren, and that's where his ideology would clash against the others. In this context the first Karl Fritz would make a perfect "final boss" and gatekeeper for Eren because we can assume that he's not only fine with the current state of the world but he wishes for the world to be like that, because he's a psychopath who believes that the ultimate goal in life lays in conquering and domineering everything, and living and multiplying just for the sake of it. He only knows and believes in power, cruelty, violence and war and reveres them because he sees them as means of selection of the strongest and for assuring the survival of the fittest. But a world based on these premises equals with a living hell for whoever is not a psychopath and a soulless beast. And that's why he treats Ymir with such contempt because he couldn't possibly understand her and sees her just as a weakling, and so a slave and a tool. Of course he doesn't want the destruction of his race, but in his ideal view they are meant to be just a cold war machine aimed at world domination. And that's exactly what made them to be hated and regarded as demons by the world in the first place. Eren opposes this view, but since he recognizes the legitimacy and truth in it regarding the nature of the world, he goes to the length of destroying the world itself along with all its life to change this paradigm.
I think that would've made also the good ol' Fritz into a great character, and the possible seeds of this were just there, but unfortunately...
This doesn't fit with Eren's character at all
But it was better version than original.
@@jennyarpilleda4809 As if Eren would't be like you tried to take away my freedom so i take away yours Eren would never say that to anyone of his friends this contradicts 108 and that Eren give his friends the freedom to Stop him becouse they are free Part of his family Armin and Mikasa are the people Eren wanted to Save the most showen many times example kruger also it would make all the characters except Eren look like Clowns all the things they done to Stop him and what they said and thought and then lose like that
@@jennyarpilleda4809 And also the Message for the reader in this is terrible this ending makes Eren into a Psycho Edgy Mass Murder and gives the reader the Message that Genocide solves problems and is justified he doesn't even regret it in the original he could not forgive himself for what he did
@@jennyarpilleda4809 Eren says he wants all of his friends to live long lives
@@tiagomonteiro161 what lesson was the original ending supposed to give then?
that genocide is okay so long as you wipe away only 80% of the population?
don't act like armin didn't justify what eren did in the original ending as well ("you became like this for our sake... thank you...").
don't forget that mks walked through lands of blood, bones, and dead bodies all the way to paradis just to write "most beloved" on anime hitler's grave.
don't forget that eren had no idea why he even did the rumbling in the first place ("it just felt like something i had to do...").
don't forget that ymir caused the bloodline of eldians to suffer just because she wanted king fritz's love.
don't forget that isym's view on love is so twisted that he:
- made a slave (ymir) fall in love with her abuser (king fritz)... a guy who sicced dogs on her, cut out her tongue, and forced their children to eat her.
- made a girl (mks) develop abandonment and attachment issues that she just accepted a guy (eren) who insulted her, and put her in danger.
- made a girl (historia) fall in love with a guy (farmer) who threw rocks at her when she was younger and who she didn't marry in the first place.
don't forget all of these were in the original ending too. chapter 139 enjoyers should never open their mouths ever again to diss on fandmade endings. the entirety of chapter 139 was a disservice to the franchise at best and an absolute atrocity at worst.
This remake just ripped my heart out and stomped on it. And I love it!
My one critique is that I felt the “You are Free” sequence was kinda quick. But overall, I’d give this a 9/10.
Great Work!👍
I was going to add more, but it was going to go on for way too long. I did try to show his expression when he arrived to where Historia was, but I obviously can't convey all that emotion in one panel. But thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it.
@@Yumais I understand. Still would have loved to see that though. But still, good job. I gonna share this video. It needs to blow up. You’ve earned it. Thank you for trying to wash that bitter taste of 139 out my mouth.
@@shawnellesmith Well if I find the time, I'll be sure to make that. I appreciate that, thank you.
I’m sorry but this ending has flaws. The first and most important one is that king Fritz can’t be in the paths not being Ymir descendant. I can tell you for sure that if isayama had made this ending. MANY people would have criticised it even more.
@@youmode562 the king isn’t Ymir’s descendent.
thats cool ending
God....i prefer the original one to be honest..
Why this one eren didnt die and paradise is free
Marley deserve it if they havent sent the titan to the wall then this wouldnt have happen
@@shinthelightning ok yes. But i don't like it.
This felt so much more in-line with the AoT universe I wanted to cry, had to remind myself this isn’t canon LMAO
Edit- if it makes any triggered EreMika shippers feel any better; no shit this ending isn’t perfect, still plenty of issues could be brought up. Thing is, I’d still take it over the 139 we have. At least this ending doesn’t do as big of an ass pull and retcon multiple characters to oblivion, create 100 new plot holes and leave me unsatisfied. Does this ending leave me with questions/objections? Yes. I don’t really think *everyone* , especially Mikasa/armin had to die, given the context of their characters’ willingness to side with eren if he were to talk to them. I also don’t think everyone in the paths would have just accepted their fate like that, even after getting all the details from eren. Again, where does the source of all life(the hallucinogenea or whatever the fuk) go? Idk It’s just kinda crazy how with this ending(despite it having its own problems), I don’t feel like eren turns into *50% off @ Walmart Lelouch.* And this is an ending that was created pretty quickly, whereas the canonical 139 was supposedly on the writer’s mind for some time, yet here we are with a dead eren who apparently loved Mikasa so much that it’s sad, talk-no-jutsu armin, Reiner who played wreck-it Ralph with 20% of the eldians, Annie played doll house with the scouts(and would do that shit again) but became armin’s girlfriend(XDDD), gabi being besties with crippled levi, the source of all life goes *poof* along with the 2k year Titan curse (XD?), mikasa’s literal 1 chapter character development in 138 that gets undone in 139 as she becomes a shell of who she was (but not after walking 6 thousand miles across the ocean alone I guess lmao), nazi Germany recreated under dead eren, but also with the remaining 20% of the world that can and WILL be coming to destroy the rest of them, because the eldians are 100 whole ass years behind in technology. Remember? Or did you forget that so you could cope better with the lackluster ending, and kiss-ass? Like, you all wanna bitch about the fan-made endings and scream the canon ending is good but when you get hit with questions/statements you can’t answer, you pivot to some dumb shit that’s mostly just your head-canon speculations(example: “eren obviously always loved Mikasa, cuz he said he’d wrap the scarf around her again hehe xd”. Well shit bro if I went by that logic, a lotta characters should have been in love with each other this whole time huh. Sit down.
Just pretend chapter 139 never happened. You can choose this as your ending.
B-but you don't uNdErStAnD the story. Lmao
@BlaZe Excalibur I don't even ship EH lol. And well, I agree Eren caring about his friends more than Hisu part. It shouldn't be something to discuss about... What I meant was about fans thinking they understand the story better than the other.
@BlaZe Excalibur kinda crazy how the “EH shipper’s wet dream” is actually far more backed up by the story than the EM shippers literal last minute “I always loved Mikasa and don’t want her with another man even after I’m dead” ass pull. Huh.
@BlaZe Excalibur good lord you are everywhere. Please go comment on a video you actually like instead of wasting everybody's time.
Please, save this and upload it on drive too like the other guy who used to make motion mangas.
We can't afford the chance to lose this masterpiece should UA-cam and Kodansha want to be assholes like usual
It was a theory that eren was the lamp devil but tbh I think he is the devil of all earth so I like this lol
Eren does not move forward = OG ending
Eren Moves Forward = RAGNAROK
The most fitting theme of AoT.
Bruh literal chills went down my spine reading this.
It's really pathetic of me to say this but I have read so many other remakes after 139 and every single one of them turned out to be better than the original. I looked up to Isayama so much and I still do respect him but how could he be so oblivious ? I don't have any major problems with the canon ending but there are too many flaws and unexplained things and plot convenience for Alliance to win. Also I wanted Eremika to be real but the way it was written feels superficial. Atleast he could have paced it better to make it believable. Shouldn't have left everything to the last chapter like Eren's POV , Ymir conclusion , Eren revealing he actually liked Mikasa etc.
He should have shown all this way before and used the last chapter to just explain stuff. All these fan theories are so well thought out , even they have flaws but they don't rub the wrong way real chapter 139 did
I heard Isayama would have never made Eremika a "sailed" ship, but I have no proof.
He didn't do any other chapter after 139 even if he wanted to explain the controversial stuff because he planned it from beginning to have 139 chapters representing...
13 years of ymirs curse and 9 titan shifter...🔥
@@aryanbhola3046 139,5*
Isayama bad
CRINGE AF 😂
You know you messed up your own story when the fans have to rewrite it for you.
Like Evangelion and Deathnote
@@jadeorbigoso5212 Deathnote? The original ending was bad???
@@blackairforce13 for me yes Since Light just betrayed his Morals and not able to remorse his self from the sins of killing innocent people, When L was still alive yes it's good but the way Light failed is so rushed
@@blackairforce13 some fans even make their ending that Light becomes a Shinigami then taking the throne and becoming leader of Shinigami Realm
Ok but the original ending still makes more sense than this. Like why the hell would he lie to his friends and turn them against him just to kill them for fun..? 🤨 And wth is that with historia, thats just a ship pulled out of nowhere anyways
*"We're just kids. How can anoyone blame us for what we did"*
Damn that actually hurts man. Well done on the writing. What the characters said in your ending version feels so natural
While I really like the idea of Fritz being the final boss...... It actually is not possible according to one of the most important rules related to Paths.
Eren can only communicate with descendants of Ymir. Fritz here is NOT one of them so he shouldn't be able to talk to Eren at all. (He was literally the husband)
Second problem..... Armin is somehow okay with all this insanity?
Third problem, Eren literally said he won't take away any of their powers because they were "free". But here, he does the exact opposite.
While it does maintain some aspects of Eren's character, it also contradicts the many others.
Not all Eldians are descendants of Ymir wtf are you talking about.
Descendants of Ymir = royal bloodline.
If everyone was hee descendant then everyone wouĺd have been able to use the Founder.
No.
Eren can talk to EVERY ELDIAN. They are the same race, the same genetics, but they are all distant blood relatives
@@valeriewinter6217Both Subjects of Ymir (Eldians) and the royal family descend from Ymir, wtf are you talking about? The royal family just has a more direct connection, king fritz can not be connected to paths whatsoever.
One way that can possibly be explained would be that the King also ate Ymir’s flesh after she died, and it somehow connects him to the path. It would be a bit forced since the whole manga never establishes that titan power can be transferred this way. But I find it less absurd than Ymirs 2000 Stockholm Syndrome
@@toxin4609 you do realise king fritz is eldian witch mean he can be in the path
@@joeaverage9772 I feel like that would make sense. A power hungry man like him would probably want that sort of immortality
I really enjoyed it, I would give this an 8.5/10. I have problems with the pacing which can be all over the place at times. The Armin and Eren scene, while emotional is not how I would see Armin acting around the current Eren. Similar to how Armin thanking Eren for genocide came out of nowhere, Armin not even being mad at Eren made no sense (in my opinion). It would have been nice to see Armin argue his case against Eren, think of it as the final intellectual debate between the alliance and the yeagerists (alliance represented through Armin and the Yeagerists represented through Eren). Armin has disagreed with Eren's scheme ever since he told him, Armin would rather talk his problems out with Eren than fight. Addressing the main ideological motivations and giving service to Armin's main philosophical standpoint of not fighting but rather talking would have made this story a 9.5/10 for me. I believe it would have also allowed the audience to see more of Eren's POV and it shows how intelligent and how thought-out he really is.
Great job none the less!
Well to address some of your complaints:
Armin and Eren were talking in the paths for a long time, I just didn't really have the panels or the time to put it all in, yes the pacing is all the over the place, because I essentially had to export it on by one, my editing software would just brick itself every time I tried with more than one part. Armin wouldn't of agreed to Eren's way of thinking, but did he really have a choice? He didn't have any magical powers that Isayama gave him, he couldn't of stopped Eren realistically. In fact, they all should've died when attacking Eren to begin with, if Eren kept the mentality of "Get in my way, and I'll kill you." But they're his friends, as much as he wants to fight for freedom, he still has those feelings for them. I tried to show as much of that as possible, but it's pretty difficult when you have Isayama's mess of an ending to work with. If I could, I would rewrite everything from 137-139, there's plenty he could've changed to make the ending make more sense. I don't think Eren ever agreed with the Yeagerists mentality, especially Floch. He seemed to be on the outside constantly, working on his own and with Hisu. He was just using them to get to where he needed to be. Which is why Floch cried, and rambled the same lines he did when he spoke about Erwin in season 3. I was originally going to have Eren and Armin argue, but they have already fought twice and it would get repetitive. I could've done a lot more, sure but I'm not professional, just passionate about aot. Overall, I'm taking in every bit of constructive criticism I've gotten and I'm applying it to the extended ending I'm doing. I'm hoping I can apply it all to that. This is my first time doing sth like this so I appreciate the open minded mentality. Thank you.
@@Yumais I appreciate that you would be open to criticism, I look forward to seeing the extended version. Best of luck and have a good day.
" final debate between alliance and yeagerists " bruh . Each and every member of alliance has different views about the situation and Eren does not even share the same views as yeagerists. He was using them .
@@skandosh9025 That’s canon, this is a fan fic so the same logic doesn’t apply. That would be like saying “Eren is not the father” it’s true, but it has no relevance to the fan fic. Armin 100% represented the alliance core ideas and Eren is the leader of the Yeagerists. I think it would’ve worked.
@@bunfagam3021 Isayama tried to show that but I bet Alliance members dont even agree with each other . You know what , thats the fucked up part about this manga . He could have explored to much regarding this but instead made a fucking marvel avengers the manga version .
not perfect but better then 139. 7/10 but if we want a better ending we must change 135/6/7/8/9. Bc bad final started at 135, not just 139
True, eren should've not gave the alliance the freedom to stop him.
And we’re meant to believe ynir loved king shitz 🤦♂️🤦♂️
Yeah isayama fucked up there, Ymir was raped, enslaved and used by him lol
@@Yumais fucked up the last 3 chapters
@@lxfj2128 when he bring back the past titans, that's were I thought. I don't like where this is going...
He might change the ending in the anime since y'all don't like it :/
@@Yumais have you ever heard of toxic love or Stockholm syndrome if not plz search about it. Also the whole point isayama was using freedom as a poor moral to show it's disillusional value in the real world . But yet eren supporters are ment to believe that the are free to keep moving forward because they were born into this world and other bullshit excuses like that . This kind of philosophy is actually based on anarchist pages created from 14 year-olds . Taking it seriously make me believe that Indeed people are just doomed even more than I thought
God, this is utterly heartwrenching.
It's the pure Ragnarök ending we deserved.
Thank you.
Eren: Tremble before me Marley I am your reconning!
I have to admit, this ending looks like a better ending tbh. Fits much more perfectly
It’s also far more emotional.
And having the third ending playing in the background was the icing on the cake.
@@TheSupaman98 fr, music raises everything to another level
Yup
Because most of these may possibly what really happening or implicating through all the easter egg in the original series except one part, that King Karl is actually an illusion impersonated by the Hallucigenia that infested on Ymir then later transfer to Eren for one specified goal, reproduce more of its subordinates through mankind bloodline due to it parasitic lifeform and in return it provide the power of titan to its host.
Hey, this is a great work! Peak writing. 💯 I think this fits better with the aot world. Honestly, I would be extremely satisfied if this is what we got for 139. 😭 Anyways again, this is a masterpiece! Great work! 💐
This is so good
Why these fan endings have to be so good, it pains me that the ending is nothing like this
I loved the addition of the first King Fritz as main perpetrator of all the evil in the story and the creepy ending
The part that really got me Eren's scream after crushing mikasa. At least he has his daughter to keep sane.
Wait did eren kill mikasa and armin? If so why. I get eren killing the world, but killing his friends seems abit out of character. What do you think?
Bruh this is a fan ending. Everything about this ending is contradictory and based on personal wishes so its better to ignore it
Aot ending is just a rip off of Code Geass. Fight me.
Yeah but code geass mivie tho :|
Wait what if there was an aot movie and eren would be resurrected :o
@@shinthelightning the hell you mean? Code geass isnt a movie its a series!
it isn't even a good rip off tbh.
pretty dumb if you ask me..
Fritz doesn't have any influence on the world of paths, he is prior to the first titan appearance.. only through his words he controlled the Ymir to do his biddings..
plus other factors, this is just cringe
Not a perfect ending by any means, but still far far better than the original one. I love seeing all these different fan versions of the ending of AoT!
Yeah and you'll end up laughing at everyone getting killed off lol.
@@monster-mecha_enthusiast_2002 what are you trying to say
@@monster-mecha_enthusiast_2002 🤨
@@bhawanasarkar4329 I don't know anymore, all I can think about is that I'll probably retire from anime soon because of the headache I've been getting from the annoying AOT anime war between Mappa and WIT fans.
@@EpitomeOfLigma Meh, I don't know anymore.
I really liked the new explanation to why Dina's Titan ignored Bertholdt. Eren killing his mom was such bullshit, easily the worst part of 139 lol
Fans: We don't like chapter 139
Hajime Isayuma: Don't worry, I got ya covered 😏
Just got an update, its worse
@@TheFirstObserver57 isayama : just another day for the survey corps
@@TheFirstObserver57 What happened?
@@TheFirstObserver57 wait a minute, don't tell me 0_0
@@themostamazingstupid8285
Spoiler:
After Eren's death, the years passed..Mikasa ended up married to Jean and they had a son or daughter.
We can see an evolved world, with cars.
Later on Mikasa dies of age.
We are now in the 21th centeury, huge skyscrapers and..well the world we live in today. A war with Marley starts..Marley wins destroying their opponents country.
Now maybe even more 100 years have passed from the Victory of Marley.
Where we would once see the Great Walls and the distrects we remember, we would just see trees and nature.
The tree where Eren was buried has grown huge and a kid is shown running around the ex-city, we do not know who it is yet anyway.
This is all I could read. on chap.139.5.
It is very depressing seeing the remainder of the Survey Corps plus Pieck, Reiner, Annie, Gabi, and Falco getting crushed to death, but, frankly, it would at that point be better to leave that cruel world, especially given how they would reunite with their countless fallen comrades in a peaceful afterlife
Gabi , Reiner and Pieck deserve it for everything they've done.
@@AryanKumar-kh3qk Ohh god yes, but hey isayama gave them free pass for THATS NICE
@@AryanKumar-kh3qk Gabi did nothing wrong.
@@hnd1305 Joined and bootlicked an Army and Empire that dehumanised , discriminated , enslaved , and used her people as disposable weapons of war.
Wanted to genocide an entire island of her own people whom she didn't have any interaction with.
Got to know the truths about the island both from Willy Tybur and Falco , realised they were just defending themselves against the piece of shit Nazi Marleyans she was enslaved by , got to know just how much destruction the Warriors had caused them , and still chose to fight them.
Killed an innocent guard who was just concerned about her because she was a child.
Was about to kill another innocent girl until Falco stopped her.
Yeah man , 'did' nothing wrong. The bitch should have been kicked off the airship like she deserved.
@@AryanKumar-kh3qk Aside from "killing" that gaoler and attempting to kill Kaya all of her actions and emotions were pretty much justified and some of them were understandable . (Still not sure he was killed off by her tho.) You got a point there.
For her they deserved what Reiner and the Warriors did to them because they were devils who are gonna genocide the whole world anyway. So she doesn't care about it.
It doesn't matter if those soldiers came to defend their country. Of course she isn't gonna sympathize with enemies. They raided her hometown and she fought back. If you listen to what she said when she was boarding the zeppelin you can see how she still observes them as devils. And you can see she became a warrior candidate because she wanted to free her Eldians in the internment zones.
She vented her angers on the guard. All betrayals and losses were the reason why she was mad. As for Kayas situation she thought she was gonna do something to her. She's impulsive and doesn't think that much. And all these are nothing compared to what others did like Armin. She is a girl traumatized by war and isn't omniscient.
Levi being funny with armin is to good...writer is clever who leave no point of weakness in this chapter
Just shear this to everyone
I Will keep moving Forward until this ending Will be reproduce by MAPPA
I liked most of it until everyone Eren APPARENTLY WANTED TO LIVE LONG LIVES DIED! I think all of the world except Paradis dying would be more in tune with Eren's character. And while I don't mind EH, it's still weird for him to be so determined to save a child that he never even mentioned before.
That's the ending Eren deserves...
No tf he doesn’t. Man genocided the world
@@cavefilms1915 80% for nothing
@@ivanak8776peace for 1000 thousand years, his friends lived long time and happy life, what else you need 😂
@@KamleshPatel-md5kv
This ending destroyed Eren's character.
He had the potential to become a classic character like Paul from Dune. But because of chapter 139 we should ignore all his character development because now he is just a idiot and a raging incel.
This character deserved better
This ending pay off all Eren's character development through the story.
I am tired of this cope "MuH eren never changed" from ending defenders
This is the ending we all wanted. Aot will be remembered forever :D
Remembered forever of having a shitty ending.
Yoo I ain't even gonna lie, this is actually really cool! Although there are still a lot of problems with it, I liked how you incorporated King Fritz as some sort of final boss/reason behind everything. Also the added ability of the attack titan to reject the will of everyone else is epic! To be honest, I'm not really fw the Eren n historia baby plotline, but at least Ymir was reborn and finally freed. I feel like a lot of people hate and criticize the manga ending without providing a better/satisfying alternative, but you executed this quite well, especially for a fanmade chapter. This ending would still be really cool. Good job!
Yuma is making extended version.
These are my exact feelings lol. I hate the whole historia baby plot line. I didn’t want eren to be with mikasa either. I feel it would’ve been better for him to be by himself or something
@@eqoys1086 in the description he actually says its not a shipping video and that historia and eren shouldnt be in love. its more likely that eren just shagged her to let that baby be free or something like that
@@sweetinvictus654 yeah I read that I just don’t really see why he would want a baby to free. Why not himself?
@@eqoys1086 well both him and the baby will be free in the end, plus i may be pulling stuff out of my ass here but, i think he believes that since that baby will be born into a titan free world and a "free world" that itll mark the new era of humanity or something. idk im not that smart i just like aot lol
Nah bro this is even worse all his friends dying and only historia living??? nah erej dying is better
The ending we deserve
@BlaZe Excalibur Yeah , it could be better but at least it's better than the shit we got
@BlaZe Excalibur why should he care about any of them? the future of the island, the Eldians and future generations, the solution to the wheel of hatred, are of greater value, legitimate military goals are more important than military mates in real life
@@Sam-sv4yy Yeah, why should he care about anyone, really?
He kills literally everyone in the world, even the ones HE said were the people he loved, the ones he cared about the most (including the ones who risked their lives for him before, over and over and over), and then he goes TO LIVE HIS LIFE, repenting for his sins, WITH HIS FAMILY. All for the sake of Paradis. Very fair!
Eren became my hero after this new ending! Not only he kills everyone (except himself and his family, of course), but he turns his back on whom he has sworn to protect (Mikasa, for example. It seems that in the end he really really hated her, didn't he? He didn't even care to give her some kind of explanation. After all, he was in love with another woman... and Mikasa was just a clingy bore!). What a man!
Wow, now he's a real character! After all, he became GOD, and ONLY HE KNOWS who deserves to continue living!
Yes, this ending is PERFECT!
@@alcindomachado His "Friends" did want to kill him even if they knew that eren is doing all this to secure the future of his people.
What am I talking about?? They did kill him in the canon.Specifically , Mikasa,his "Lover" was the one to deal the final blow.This goes on to show that they prioritised their version of saving the world(prevent mass genocide) than to save their friend Eren.This alternative ending did the same thing but it took Eren's side.
Nobody said Eren is the hero of this story.AOT has been repeating this throughout the story that there is no hero. They are all fighting for Survival.
@@vortex8719 Well, I said he became my hero, not that he was the story's hero.
I guess everyone is entitled to have different opinions. Mine is that Eren was trying to commit murder (worldwide mass murder, no less) and that murder (especially mass murder) is morally wrong and legally prohibited. So, no matter how good his intentions could be, he had to be stopped.
However, even considering that we're talking about a fictional story, and in that realm genocide is not a hideous and unacceptable crime, from the beginning Eren said he wanted his friends to have long and happy lives. Krueger told Eren's father that breaking the cycle of hatred was the only way to save Mikasa and Armin, because Eren somehow sent him this message. Connie mentioned that Mikasa and Armin are the people that Eren loves the most. So, from the perspective of character development, it doesn't make much sense that he simply decides they have to die.
I'm sorry if my opinion displeased you. I was just pointing out the fact that, being as powerful as a god, Eren could have spared them if he wanted, but he chose not to do it. What they would do once the rumbling was finished? Opposition to the new regime? Duh.
I'm pointing out the fact that deciding that the whole world must die for Eldians to live is not as simple as who will be invited to a party and who will not.
Also, that it doesn't go well the idea of whoever has the power protects only what is theirs without bothering to harm others.
I really didn't like Ysaiama's end, almost everything in it disappointed me, but honestly, this rewritten ending was even worse.
Just my two cents.
i love the idea of eren conversing with karl fritz
I thought it was original king Fritz not Karl isn't Karl the one who erected the walls and sought peace?
Karl fritz is the son of maria fritz i think maria fritz is king klfritz daughter
@@cloudyelizabeth2097 Karl was the 145th King of the walls, Maria was daughter of original king, they're pretty far from each other on the family tree
Aot Ending
Changed but a closer ending to the original:-
Chapter 122/-
When Eren gives that speech to Ymir, she is able to be free from King fritz and accepts death and then just moves on, Due to ymir being gone she makes eren the new host for the parasite and the new founder for the paths, we see the host being attached to eren when zeke is holding on his head which means it accepted eren as its host.
Chapter 131/-
When Eren is talking in his head, he adds "if I do not do the rumbling I won't be able to protect and give long lives to my friends".
Chapter 133/-
When Eren brings his friends to the paths, he adds "I have given you the free will to stop me, you can stop me by killing me or can go back"
Chapter 135/-
Someone confirms that The ancient titans are mindless titans and that's why the alliance are able to put up a fight against the titans
Chapter 137/-
When Zeke and Armin are stuck in paths, zeke says to Armin that eren has now become the new host for the parasite and that ymir was enslaved to king fritz but eren was the only one who understood her and made her accept death and move on. The paths is a place where death does not exist, when ymir died she didn't accept death and so she was sent to the paths. Zeke says that they cannot leave the paths but after Armin gives that speech to zeke they seem to escape the paths and the Levi kills zeke to stop the rumbling.
Chapter 138/-
Armin is able to get out of the paths with the past titans shifters helping Armin and tells everyone to move away from him so he can transform,everyone gets away and he transforms killing eren in the process, in the steam due to eren dying the parasite comes out badly injured and tries to survive but Armin grabs hold of him and due to the fire emitted by Armin it burns to death. Due to the parasite dying the curse is gone.
Chapter 139/-
Eren starts the conversation with Armin in the paths(same like og ch 139),eren saying that he wanted to make them the heroes to the world, Armin asks eren why didn't he commit to the full rumbling? Eren says that it would have cost him his friends lives and he couldn't make himself do that.
While walking eren says that the reason ymir was bounded by king fritz for 2000 years because she was a slave to king fritz and that he was the chosen one to free her from that.
Eren says he was the one to let out zeke and Armin from the paths because he wanted zeke and Armin to come together and make zeke realise the meaning to live.
Eren also says that he was the one to bring back the past titan shifters and gave them the free will to either stop him or not.
Eren says that he couldn't kill the parasite while being attached to it and that Armin had to kill eren first in order to bring out the parasite and kill it.
Armin asks about what the Paradis island will do to their famalies when they are seen as traitors to eren.
Eren says that he already has talked it out with historia to give them protection(Chapter 131)
Eren says that this was the only path available where he was able to protect his friends, remove the curse and save Paradis.
Eren then has a breakdown on the sea, in which he says that he dosent want to die and wants to be with his friends but cannot because he needs to die in order to save his friends and paradis.
Eren apologizes to Armin and says that he will be the one to save humanity. Eren then says he will erase his memory and will be able to get it back after they have killed the parasite.
We see that Eren had talked to Armin during the time at the boat.
We see eren also talk to others using the paths.
We then see Armin waking up and the curse has been removed and was able to get his memory back.
When Armin had transformed to kill eren mikasa was able to connect with eren in the paths, Eren tells mikasa to forget about him and move on, they say their goodbyes and Mikasa says "See you later eren".
We then see Armin being the one saying to the soldiers "I'm Armin Arlert and I am the one to kill Eren Yeager".
Time skip/-
The only difference is that mikasa is visiting the grave of eren everyday and then we see her wrapping the scarf around eren's grave and says that she will remember him always but will move on from him.
End
...Bruh THAT IS PERFECT. The ending should have been that, it didn't need to be needlessly complicated. Heck, I would be fine with Eren dying because it seemed like a fitting price to pay and fulfilled the greatest tragedy in the story: The boy who sought freedom the most became a slave to the very idea of freedom, Mikasa and Eren letting each other go would have been more meaningful, Armin instead of "thanking" Eren for turning into a genocidal maniac, promises to resurrect what's left of humanity... all that stuff could have been possible.
Which makes you wonder and stay up all night as to why the original ending ended that way when it could have been easily... that.
Yes, the Mikasa part especially moves me she finally gets to live free from Eren. I love to see independence for my female characters
That Mikasa ending is so goood omg
Please,someone convinces Mappa to made these changes when they animate Part 2,I'm begging!!!!!!
P.S.:In addition with these changes,Eren should be the father of Historia's baby,the baby is Ymir Fritz's reencarnation and the EreHisu child's name should be Ymir Reiss-Yeager,Mikasa and Armin should be the aunt and uncle of Eren's daughter as part of their last promise to Eren that they will take care of his child alongside Historia, Mikasa should have stayed with the alliance and their goal of ressurrecting the others 80% of mankind instead of grieving towards Eren's death(I know grief isn't easy, but she, at least, should not grieving towards Eren for the rest of her life) and Mikasa in Eren's grave should be replaced by a scene of Mikasa and Armin talking with Eren's daughter!
BRO THIS IS ACTUALLY PERFECT. I don't know you are still here, but this FITS THE THEMES of the story perfectly and doesn't change up much, while mostly is just changed by dialogue. I think this is honestly an ending both yeagerists and alliance fans can get behind. When I read 138, Thats basically how I thought 139 would go on, but I guess not lol.
Wow, that was - really moving, tragic, horrifying, depressing and really beautiful, all of which are the core of AOT. You using Yuugure no Tori at the end was the cherry on top, its my favourite song from the series. I've always imagined it as the song thats representative of the Rumbling and the conclusion of the story, i'm really glad you used it so well that it made cry for a bit. Thank you for doing this edit, i'm sure many many people appreciate what you did.
This is fucking epic. Far better than the garbage that we got. Just need few improvements here and there but it genuinely feels like something which resonates with theme of AOT.
I couldn't re-watch AOT after knowing how the story will end miserably. But ,with this ending in mind, I think I can finally re-watch it.
If you ask me since this was originally gonna be the ending to me this video of the full chapter is canon.
Bro please admit it this ending themes while it were extremely sad and tragic didn't have anything in common with the rest of aots themes and philosophy
@@koui4449 Aot themes are a realistic cruel world where the MC seek freedom, with this ending he achieve it in the true sense, Ymir becomes the first children born in a free world, but the price for this freedom is heavy it requires his firends to die, this ending and the characters are not contradicting the themes of AoT, while i do agree that this ending needs a bit more polishing specifically for the interactions between Eren and his friends, it's already better than the original by far....
I don't remember love being a main theme of AoT, or being a slave of fate too....
@@adelMN2 that's why I decided to ignore chapter 139 and make this my ending.
You can only do so much by changing just one chapter of the manga. For me , the story started going south during the battle between survey corps and eren founding titan.It would take modifying atleast 3-4 chapters at the end to make the ending reflect the same theme as rest of AOT.
This is basically EreHisu fan's vision
Absolutely dude, I agree! Every Eren x Historia shipper disappointed with the ending is coming out with their own alternate version. What's worse is that they never understood the essence of AoT at it's core.
And surprisingly, all these fanfics have completely omitted Mikasa's part, let alone understanding her contribution to the plot line.
Every time a fanfiction involves Eren being the dad, y'all get crazy
So what ? Its a fanfic, and there are plenty of other one's with mikasa 💀
EH makes sense with how isayama wrote their relationship and how he let people interpret some panels, its not only about shipwar.
Dudes can't handle fanfics fr
@@adene467 coz all your fanfics are the same. Isayama never planned EH, like how difficult was it to understand? If H had some role she wouldn't be disposed like that from the plot.
@@adene467 What is the point of Eren impregnating Historia? This ship was definitely not there in manga. And in anime, if such a thing happens, how exactly can it save the entire world? Endings like AnR and others with EH focus on Eren being the father and that will miraculously save the entire world, without any further explanation. I mean seriously? Is this what you think AoT is about? Romances and happy family!? Go and rewatch the anime, read the manga before commenting. Learn about characters like Armin and Mikasa, and their contribution to the storyline.
And, if you trust AoT's OPs and EDs as a valid source, then watch Akuma no Ko's official video.
@@adene467 I literally don't care about ships and fanfics. But I do care how the story is progressing. So when a person posts a fanfic meant for Wattpad under 'Alternate Ending' title, it does bother people.
And don't kid yourself when you say 'Isayama wrote their relationship'. You're embarassing yourself!
I am shaking...
In tears...
And just blown away by how amazing this is.
I got chills when Yurrgure no Tori started to play cus that's the VERY song I envisioned as well what would play when Eren has to kill his friends and all his loved ones through the rumbling.
*Chills.*
Amazing job homie.
Makes no sense, if fritz wanted to rule over the world he would've fight the other fritz who was against battle and war. Why only interefere 100 years later and not the moment paradis was created?
Paradis was created 100 years before Eren’s birth.
@Not Aku wasn't his wish basically Eldia rule the world?
The main issue with the original ending was how it suddenly strayed far from the main themes and concepts about Attack on Titan and unintentionally plunged the entire fandom into a shipping war--and ships was something no one really gave a shit about until 139 suddenly and conveniently brough it up.
Most people watched AoT not because of which girl Eren liked, but because of the show as a whole.
(And Levi.)
It dealt with complicated and complex themes of slavery, discrimination, gray morality, the tragedy of war, etc., but most importantly, about freedom. AoT had executed those themes perfectly in a way most animes can't.
But then to suddenly shift those complex and intriguing themes--to a cliche and unfitting romance story that's massively underwhelming compared to the ideas of the price of freedom or the cycle of vegeance that falls on children--in the final chapter no less--unintentionally plunged the fandom into a shipping war and what made the Attack on Titan story so great was left forgotten.
Because a lot of people, not all, are currently busy squabbling on which ship should have sailed or sunk...
To add: The worst thing about 139 (for me) was the Ymir-Fritz love story. All this time, I thought Ymir and Eren were fighting for the kind of freedom that's meant to free the Eldians from the discrimination and abuse they've become desentisized to. But then it turns out to Ymir was in "love" with Fritz, the whole aspect of what they're fighting for changes so drastically, and then the story again shifts from Eren being the "chosen one" to Mikasa... and well...
Hence why people like this kind of fan endings, even imperfect, as long as it still reflects the themes of the actual Attack on Titan story, then you're damn right that there would be people who would prefer endings like this than the original one that frankly felt rushed and out of place.
👏 That is correct. That's why I love this ending because it follows the theme of AOT.
Exactly. I adore how much this portrayed the original themes of aot
I guess it was true that ships ruin a show
My feeling exactly. I hate how the whole discussion around 139 devolved into ship wars. I wish ships and love wasn’t never hinted at in the story because that’s clearly not what it’s about. I feel like isayama was heavily rushed and couldn’t do all that he wanted. And after the leaks... I don’t even know anymore
@@eqoys1086 this is why I hate shipping it's a waste of time.
I guess saviors do come in times of peril. And I never thought I'd regain faith in Eren after damn 139 Aaron Yogurt appeared.
lmao Aaron yogurt
Eren is eren there's a no Aaron yogurt, swim in your denial dumbass
This alternate ending was MUCH more satisfying than the manga and anime ending! Good job! I have an extremely hard time believing Isayama couldn't come up with a better ending ... It doesn't make sense at all... There definitely seems to be some puzzle pieces missing
Isayama was forced by his editor to please the Eremika shippers that is 90% of the fandom in Japan
@@lain5858nah it is just Isayama was an overatted writer who wrote a trash ending.
He was good but we believed he was like a genius and we overhyped all his decisions and it is why we didn't see all his Bad writing before.
And no, Eremika isn't the reason of all his bullshits in the end it is just impossible
@@ConstantinDOSSOU-vy1zo
He received letters with death threats when he started the whole historia preganacy plot 💀
Who come her just after finish the last ep ?
This actually puts Isayama to shame. Whoever did this ending should be a mangaka or at least write some novel or so. Just wow. I really loved every single thing about this ending.
This is pretty much Canon since this was the original ending. Isayama just picked and ending from fans it wasn't even his own all he did was draw if you ask me now is fan made since it will his ideal ending.
How did the curse of ymir get lifted?
@@sabirabdullah801 ymir was reborn as eren and historia's baby
@@myaparker5510 oh does that mean she finally left the paths and didn't have to serve eldians ending the curse? But why did she decide to get reborn wouldn't it be better if she just was put to rest after 2000 yrs?
@@sabirabdullah801 tell you the truth I have no idea what's going on😂 but Yuma is making an extended version so explain better hopefully.
I feel like this ending goes against Eren's wishes even more than chapter 139. Eren said he wanted his friends to live long lifes, not wipe the floor with them. I would say this ending would've been perfect(besides some plotholes, like Fritz being in the paths, which is impossible) if Eren wiped the entire world but the people of paradis.
Well ymir in love with king fritz is just another whole new level of plot holes though so its not that bad
@@kekbin1697 ymir love= learned helplessness + stockholm syndrome
Eren could have ment that in context that he wants to ensure they all live long lives by destroying the threat of the outside world.
Once his friends got in the way, all bets were off. He wants Eldia to be free, And Eren respects one thing above all else: Individuals who choose freedom. Win or lose, his friends chose to fight. He'll respect their wishes, but will get rid of anything in his way. Friend or foe alike.
Yeah, but on the same time Eren have no regrets to take Other Freedom if they try to take own. So Kill his Friends isn't complety Wrong on his character.
@@goticslayer1746 Kill slavers ≠ kill friends Also when eren infiltrated marley it was less than a year and what he thought during that time was that he wanted his friends to have long lives (and he already knew some things that would happen) eren's character starts in chapter 1, not chapter 91
Nice job with the fan ending. I really like the Fritz reveal if Isayama did that that would have been amazing. I personally do not think Eren would directly kill his squad mates maybe indirectly kill them like an ignorance is bliss type of deal but that just my opinion. Your ending is 9/10 good work!!
Holy sh* killing everyone was scary and satifying how it ends .
Question does the titans power still exist in this ending??
Fics like this makes me realise how much better the manga ending is
💀true thi
Makes me realize that ‘that’ ending was the only possible ending
They are at the same level
@@redcompote6252 no, eren killing his friends for ymir is the dumbest possible idea I’ve ever seen
@@someguy9496 Yeah that's actually a problem
*CANON*
Please someone recommend this ending to MAPPA STUDIO hahaha
I wish I knew how to do that.
Man, no words. Just literal goosebumps and tears. Had me pinned to my seat the whole time. Fucking perfect #AkatsukiNoRequiem
Nah, I admire the work behind all of this, but I just can't see the sense, so, Eren kills basically everyone except for the people living in the island, kills his friends (why though?) and he's the father of Historia's baby? Firstly, why would he leave eldians alive? It wouldn't stop the titans curse would it? Also, why would he kill his friends if they didn't do anything and did not affect his plan at all? Kind of understand it because of the titan shifters, but what about those who weren't? And finally, why would Eren be the father? I mean, this makes more sense than Historia getting pregnant and suffering without any motive, but Historia never loved Eren, just like Eren never loved Historia. And finally, damn for both endings I wish everyone saw the titan shifters who died, not just Eren, I wish the marleyans saw Bertholdt and Porco, even Zeke and Marcel, and that Historia saw Ymir, I feel like except for Zeke they were all just forgotten and they were an important part of the story and the characters' development
1) they are collateral. They chose to fight and were in the middle of it when he activated the Rumbling again 2) yes, there were NUMEROUS hints of him being the father in the manga 3) The titan powers is no more because Ymir is reborn
@@valeriewinter6217 all eren did was talk to historia and historia offered to have a child there werent alot of hints plus didnt eren say he didnt want historia to be a breeding machine, plus if he did get her pregnant wouldnt his whole life flash before his eyes
@@jinluver6636 then you are a speedreader
I think this is a ending for erehisu shipper & yeagerists
@@222dolly no-one liked the original ending except eremika fans. So this is the ending for everyone who was there for the plot and not the ship
Woke: killing gabi
Broke: killing falco
The official ending is not part of my canon, this is though. Creator was original up to the end, but decided to take the Game of Thrones root. Maybe because we didn’t deserve an ending that we want, but anyways. This is my canon ending for AOT.
This is great and nice try dude..
But you've made few mistakes..
1. King Fritz was not a founding titan or subject of Ymir..So he can't do these things
2. You've misunderstood Eren's real goals and his character..'"To save Mikasa and Armin'' It was one of his main goals only can be seconds to his own freedom desire.. But this alternate ending he killed them to save Paradis..Save Paradis was not his main goals..Because of his selfish personality..''Because you guys are too important to me'' ''I just only wants to live them long happy lives'' He actually didn't care much about Paradis or outside world more than his friends..But here he killed them to save less important thing to him..So this is completely out of character moment..
3. Also if rumbling succeeded that means titan powers will still exists and all of his sacrifices would be nothing in the end..Eldians will live as cursed people with lot of conflicts among them.
But I really like the stuff you did with Attack titan powers..It would be a crazy twist if Isayama used that..
Anyway nice try man❤
This Video is Yeagerist/Jeagerist Approved
To be honest this wasn't the ending I expected. I disagree with the King Fritz idea because he didn't have titan powers. I think Karl Fritz would have been better since he created the vow. I was utterly shocked when Eren killed his friends to free the world but he wanted his friends to have long lives. I wouldn't say it's bad ending, it was interesting but not what I preferred. BTW the music was lit
I’m sorry but I have some shit to say. First of all what the hell is up with King Fritz? How is that mf in the paths controlling Ymir? He is not her descendent, not eldian, why is he there and what the fuck is he trying to do? Rule the world? That mf is suppost to be dead and gone. And what was the reason for Eren to kill off his friends? Just because Ymir was a slave? A quick reminder: Eren did the rumbling so that his friends could live long and happy lives, but in here he himself just crushes them. Couldn’t he leave his friends out of this? Couldn’t he just spare them and kill off the rest of the world? “so yea guys Ymir’s a slave so I gotta need to stomp on all of you” And did he say that Jean took away his freedom or something? I don’t get it. Basically Eren did it for nothing, the power of titans still stayed around, he still died a few years later? Only Historia got to live out of all his friends? In conclusion: Eren didn’t achieve his goal, the power of titans remained, he still died, plus Historias child probably got one of the nine titans because Reiner, Armin and Annie (edit: pieck and falco too) were killed at the same time she was giving birth, so she will die 13 years later (I said probably, maybe she didn’t, maybe there was a lot of babies being born, I don’t know just a possibility) well nothing rll changed except that paradi island didn’t have enemies anymore (I’m 100% sure that they would start some civil war or something) so yea. Plus one thing that bothered me were the dry ass dialogs, King Fritz sounded like the cliche evil villain with that evil laugh, there was also something bothering me but I forgot what was it. I think that most people who praise this are erehisu shippers who overlook the flaws, anyways idgaf think what u want this was just my opiniom and some sort of letting my thoughts out, have a nice day
giving King Fritz much meaning to his character is terrible.
he did and said enough in the series
Except if he is actually hallucinogenia's soul that took over Fritz's statue which Ymir created as a secret reminder of whom she is loyal to, until Eren overcomes and defeats him.
20:26 is amazing. It reminded me of the cover of this chapter where they run to that tree.
Except some parts of it, I liked this alternate ending a lot. There are plot holes but it's mainly because of how the latest arc was handled.
Yuma is making an extended version
he just said he wanted them to live long lives and he wants the children to be free.. and he just kills them all? how is historia and her baby supposed to love a man who killed all her friends 💀 it’s too contradictory and king fritz situation wouldn’t be able to happen
Maybe if it was the Earth Devil instead of the King? Would that be better?
Also yeah, him killing his friends was a bit off (in my opinion). What he should've done was tell his friends the situation, then gives them two options, they can retreat back to the island where they can continue their lives or even start a brand new one, or they can stay although that would be pretty bad because he wants them all to live, but whatever their hearts tell them.
This is the best ending I don't care about the 139 chapter. This to me is Canon. I've already added to my favorites. It makes sense that Eren would do all this for his daughter even if it means his friends lives.
Thanks to yuma I can look at the anime and pick this as my ending.
Don’t you mean his friends die?
@@eliteforce8017 yeah
@@myaparker5510 It’s a sad story, but way better than the actual ending.
@@eliteforce8017 Chapter 139 doesn't exist to me, this is my real ending.
Shut the fuck oh god Eren cares more about his friends that about historia
So renier finally died
Well. He was practically asking for it back in Marley.
@@ub-minosfireborn5722 btw mikasa deserved better ending
@@eclipse8321 no kidding, they could have atleast made her move on from Eren after he died. Remember that movie home alone 2? Yeah, I can see where she's going with her life.
@@eclipse8321 she got an entire chapter dedicated to herself, didn’t think she needed more development.
@@Yumais i love the way mikasa was she didn't need to have any background story or character development.....all she needed was a better ending