Okay this is suddenly blowing up but, Taeyeon & IU are 2nd gen. This video is only for 3rd and 4th gen. Rosé, Siyeon and Jihyo are all weak vocalists compared to those on the list. They'll be in the top 30 or 40 or even further. So stop expecting your bias, this is pretty close to accurate.
@@hopeflakez you are too biaseddd i like this channel very muchh but i now unfollow this and i say to my friends also because i only say them to follow youu 💀💀 this time you disappointed mee you are to biaseddd ohh my goddd😐😐😐 and iu and rosie are not weak okkk they are in the top 10 okkk and iu and rosie are golden voice of korea and everyone say that but they are not good in vocals so why they are golden voice of Korea 😡😡😡
Whee-in is DEFINITELY an underrated vocalist. She has had so many songs that have showcased her vocals so well I’m surprised she didn’t debut as a soloist. Side note: I’m not surprised Wendy is first. I mean are you even a RV fan if you haven’t heard Wendy’s RAW vocals? I mean she must have amazing breath control.
Wheein is the pillar of MAMAMOO. Among Solar's powerful high note, Hwasa's husky voice, and Moonbyul's low note, she stands as the member that sings main melody and complete everything. MAMAMOO won't be MAMAMOO without her, and it works the same for other members too. Also, they all shine in their solo albums. But together as 4, MAMAMOO is stronger. It's your opinion but I don't think she supposed to debut as a soloist instead of being in a group, especially because her group is MAMAMOO, and she debuted with Solar, Moonbyul, and Hwasa. It would have been different case if she debuted in other group, not MAMAMOO.
jihyo isn’t here...the woman that trained for 10 years, and also get bullied in the pre debut days...the strong leader, main vocal, i love her so so much, she’s talented like the others! edit: lmao I don’t even stan twice anymore so just ignore this comment 💀
@@davaandira2015 I don't think you understood the point of the video. It clearly said 3rd to 4th gen artists. If 2nd gen was here, a whole bunch of SM vocalists including Taeyeon would dominate the list.
You people's are worst than shit... I scrolled the whole comment section but didn't find any comment where is written "rosé is my fvt" or "where is rose". I only find those comments "where is iu" "where is jihyo" "where is taeyon".. some peoples like you aways make blinks look bad.. but didn't even check is there even any comments like this.. now I realized you peoples are just JEALOUS of blackpink cz they are more popular and special cared than your favorites
@@sheldonsaidali5421 lol there are huge difference between Vocal and voice... rosé is golden voice of korea that doesn't means everyone calling her best vocalist of korea
@@JoshushuaCaratzendeobi Yes,but maximum. Now I understand that rose isn’t vocals Queen, but it’s so hard for me to accept it but reality is reality 😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞
@@rain-zy9oy really Have you ever heard mamamoo Their own boss collaborated with mamamoo for an award performance rather than having so many gg in his company
@@manifilms9681 so what does it have to do with anything.jpy Collabs with so many artist.Lily in just debut already a b- tier vocalist i don't know about mamamoo vocal tier though
@@manifilms9681 and have you heard nmixx? Both groups don't lipsync and they have one of the best vocal line or even best vocal as a whole group in their respective generation
Finally someone who didn't put weak vocalist in their ranking and finally someone who put these, who have potential and talent, not these, who are called "golden voices" by their own fandom. I'm not hating anyone, just writing facts and praising author of this video.
Can u be quiet I know ur telling our queen Rosè ur just jealous of her success as ur fav group is not popular as bp ur just jealous first go and listen to her vocals and come
@@marziyanafzal8205 Chill gurl, At 1st ; I'm not jealous of their succes or anything else-I have completely different aspirations in life. At second ; fame doesn't designates if group is good or not-I can like this group and you can like other group as well. Did you see the pinned comment? According to author of the video, some of singers are just to weak to be in top 15. But don't worry, these singers may be cool for you or anyone else. This video is actually a valuable film in my opinion-every of these idols, who are putted in this video deserved this and there's no reason to argue in comment section Have a nice day/noon/evening/morning :)
@@marziyanafzal8205my fave group isn't as popular but at least we have the most album sales and daesangs for gg. also they're the nation's girl group so yeah
Watch em blinks start asking where is Rosé Edit: okay 👌 since I found out most of you can’t read don’t reply just don’t it’s making me tired replying to you the same thing learn how to read and process information before you start getting mad and commenting🙄bye
Guys these are vocalists who would kill even outside of the kpop industry. Their technical skill and power is really up there and does not need the over production in most kpop songs for them to actually sound good.
The title should’ve included “3rd and 4th gen” so that people won’t get confused and start going like “Sunye?” “Taeyeon,” 😭 But I wasn’t sure where to place Seunghee, she’s around A-AA like Ningning
The fact that lily and haewon both debuted less than a year ago and they’re both in the top 6 is just- ✨INSANE✨ Lmao blinks be saying “wHerE iS rOsÉ”🤬 like chill ima blink to but rosé definitely isn’t on the list and I bet y’all toxic blinks have never even heard any of the ppl on this list cus ur to focused on bp
@@marziyanafzal8205 first, I said I’m also a blink. Second, like I said, you probably don’t know a single person on this except maybe Wendy or ningning bc you consider yourself a “K-pop fan” when you probably only know bts and blackpink bc your a baby fan and don’t know much yet, so think before you speak and stop acting like a little kid. Third, if anyones toxic it’s you, bc blackpink is not “tHe BeSt” just bc they’re the most popular like miss gurl that’s not how it works.
@@marziyanafzal8205 "blackpink is the best" no... not really. u shud start stanning groups that can actually sing, you'll see how blackpink lacks in comparison. blackpink is one of the weakest groups in terms of vocals, like rose can't even sing and jisoo can't even support her voice properly. blackpink is only known as "the best" because they're popular, THATS LITERALLY IT. let's be fucking for real and go stan some groups with some actual talent ok ? like i know lisa can dance and jennie can kind of rap (and don't say she's the best rapper of all 3rd n 4th gen cuz there's a lot of idols that can outrap her, especially from 4th gen like yeeun from ex-clc, soyeon from gidle, and cocona from xg) STAN FOR TALENT, NOT FOR BANWAGON
Ppl be saying how some blinks say " where is rose" when there isn't even THAT MUCH comments about Rose like how y'all think it is ☠️🤌 I literally scrolled way too down but I only saw " where is taeyeon" " where is Iu" or "where is jihyo". Some ppl rlly make blinks look bad. If y'all think I'm rude whatever that's your prob.
@@biochemicalyparanoid4849 she's also much older than older idols, so she shouldn't be compared to them anyway. She on another level with hyolyn and ailee.
Ofc, i would like to add solji. Sure she's 100% good, bcs before she added as new member in Exid, she's their vocal trainer. That's why her age much older than averages 3rd gen female idols
Honestly i didn't expected Lily to be 3th (Better than Solar), but that doesn't better I'm happy that she's so talented although she's very young. And everyone knew Mamamoo was the best vocal GROUP💕
@@whatyoulookingat9888 I didn't saw any comment saying where is rose I see where is taeyeon Edit : thank you so much for 12 likes I never got this much likes
For those who keep asking "WHERE IS TAEYEON AND IU????" Taeyeon debut in 2007, IU debut in 2008, so technically BOTH of them are 2ND GENERS. While the video title states that this is about 3RD AND 4TH GENERS. So, can't you read?
Me seeing Ningning ranking 15th 💀 Like I think she's already good and I expect she's on 6th/7th but there are more better than her Also there's so many blinks that don't know Anything about vocals tho As a R0sé's stan....I am really embarrassed
EXID Solji should be on this list, please look into her if you haven’t, she is one of the best vocalists in kpop of any generation, both technically and talent-wise.
@@completely_unaware Depends, do you consider 2012 Second or Third gen? (EXO, AOA, NU’EST, etc.) Many people consider it the beginning of the third generation, and treat the groups that debuted then as third gen, so I was operating under the assumption that this person also considered 2012 the beginning of the 3rd generation.
It is so funny to see those delusional mention their favourite left and right, when the fact is their favourite is not even good enough technically to be a 'Main Vocalist'.
The moment I saw Ningning in the last place of this ranking, I know the popular group's main Vocalists (namely Twice and Blackpink's maik vocalists) would not make into the list. Let's be real. They are good. Actually Great. But not as great as those in this list.
Omg this is so accurate! You actually did some profound digging and didn’t go by biased-ness or popularity with idols like Taeyeon, Jihyo, Nayeon, IU or Rosé (they’re awesome tho). THANK YOU.
this is not biased, but i agree with you except for TAEYEON… she is a profound singer, she’s been proving that for years if you listen to SNSD or her solo stuff she def deserved a spot on this list. rose, iu, nayeon, jihyo are all mediocre vocalists
It is my great pleasure to see those from the certain fandom scream out their favourite idol name who is not in this list, which means she is actually not that good as they think she is.
solar is my personal favorite on the list she can do almost all vocal technics in a such a smooth way like : belting,vibrato,falsetto she's really good at those three also her resonance is crazy as well as her breathing too she can hold a note for a very long time she is so impressive probably my second role model in female vocalist
Why would they add them??if they are not the best??plus what's soo up thanking this creator??there's nothing wrong if u Stan a idol or support them or bias over them??they are called fans for a reason???rosé is definitely best vocalist according to her billions of fans
Hwasa, Wheein, Seulgi, Wendy, Jihyo and Jisoo have the best vocals for me. They have this type of voice that cannot be replaced. Like, so unique and you can easily distiguish who sings what... So pretty 💗✨
They're all really good but the vocalists on the list are sm better than them more like they're the best ones in kpop except taeyeon is def there on the list but she's second gen and Wendy is alr there lol
Actually, Lina is the 2nd gen since The Grace debut in 2005, same year with Super Junior. The best female vocalist of the first generation is Ock Juhyun from Fin KL. As for Ailee, many are not consider her as an idol since she's soloist.
@@94mp99 I think she was when she debut with Heaven though she has been singing more kpop covers lately. Plus there are more soloists nowdays. an incredible and complete vocalist. I believe 2005 is last year of 1st Gen. Shouldn’t SJ be 1st Gen?
I'm impressed that u actually did research and gave a sort of unbias list. I was expecting this to be filled with the popular idols. U get my like, well done. But I do wonder why purple kiss didn't make it into this list?
everyone saying where is rosé but tbh as a blink i accept that rosé is not so good vocalist but she has a unique voice which is beautiful so in vocal category i know rosé is not good then them and btw stayc left the chat😂
Rosie❤ deserves to be no .1 position becuz she is officially known as golden voice of korean and you are not real blink and there are many once in comment section who are saying jihyo is best you don't seen this why only Rosie😢
lily having a higher position than solar? what world do you live in, solar destroys vocally ah lily deserves a better position and rose I'm not her fan but she has a beautiful and unique vocal.
Though I'm glad you didn't do some fan service and put any of black pink members cause let's be honest they can't be in top 20 even But I think mamamoo members should be higher they are all lead vocalist except moonbuyl but she has a charming low tone And i think you could put some of dreamcatchers vocalist or at least siyeon instead of few names you mentioned
The pinned comment clearly says that they didn't add Dreamcatcher or Siyeon because they're weak compared to the others here Edit: I don't mean no hate to you tho! Dreamcatcher's vocals are really good
Blinks, tho I am blink myself still I am saying it that DON'T BE SO BIASEDDD! I love rosie but multi-group fans already know that she is a weak vocalist For those who are commenting that Wendy shouldn't be no.1 : like have u even heard wendy's voice Rosie is a good and average vocalist, I love her but honestly as a multi-groups fan I know that she can't even make it to top-15 in this list
People don’t know how to read or what vocal technique is 😭 “Where is Taeyeon?” Maybe work on your reading skills first.. “Where is Rosé and Jihyo?” not in the top 15, move on it’s really not that deep you can still enjoy their voices, I do too enjoy their songs..
@@latte575 damn 😭 like the main vocal of the group isn’t there and ur asking about the 2nd lead vocal.. just need logical thinking at this point not even vocal technique knowledge
Idk how "bLiNkS" are going and just saying Rosé belongs on the top 15... Bro this isn't BP ranking, as you can see even though Rosé has incredible vocals and she is truly unique, you gotta stop this biased way like.. Not to be rude or anything but really..?
I scrolled the whole comment section but didn't find any comment where is written "rosé is my fvt" or "where is rose". I only find those comments "where is iu" "where is jihyo" "where is taeyon".. some peoples like you aways make blinks bad.. but didn't even check is there even any comments like this..
This list is pretty accurate, except the Lily and Haewon part. Trust me, I literally call myself the biggest nmixx defender- but do you really think Haewon deserves such a a high position? And Lily after Solar? Naw- Don't get me wrong, but I think putting Lily in top 10 was better than top 5 Edit: this comment was 9 months ago and Haewon didn't show much of her talent at that time. So hopefully yall understand where I was coming from
@@shujinko2944 shes great, but she isnt AS gd as some of the idols ranked below her. the confidence is there, the power is there. but technique wise, sometimes she lacks supports. when doing low note, her voice were shaky. and when doing high notes, her voice tend to strain. then again, being a better vocalist aint always abt highnotes. she still has alot to learn. but amongst gen4 shes definitely one of the top best vocalist yet
Okay this is suddenly blowing up but, Taeyeon & IU are 2nd gen. This video is only for 3rd and 4th gen. Rosé, Siyeon and Jihyo are all weak vocalists compared to those on the list. They'll be in the top 30 or 40 or even further. So stop expecting your bias, this is pretty close to accurate.
What about siyeon from dreamcatcher 🥺
IU are 2nd gen..she debut in 2008
@@cl4278 she's weak too. I mentioned.
@@hopeflakez you are too biaseddd i like this channel very muchh but i now unfollow this and i say to my friends also because i only say them to follow youu 💀💀 this time you disappointed mee you are to biaseddd ohh my goddd😐😐😐 and iu and rosie are not weak okkk they are in the top 10 okkk and iu and rosie are golden voice of korea and everyone say that but they are not good in vocals so why they are golden voice of Korea 😡😡😡
@@Park_chae2012 lol
People really can’t read huh lol.
„wHeRe iS tAeyEoN?“
@@hopeflakez YES, Niki ain’t called prodigy for nothing people can fight me on this (coming from a Lee Know bias)
@@hopeflakez but it's Shotaro>Niki right?
@@ssamu756 ofccc shotaro is incomparable
@@hopeflakez yeah niki is better, I would put him in tier 4 (kddd) and Lee know (tier 5)
@@hopeflakez lee know outdoes
Whee-in is DEFINITELY an underrated vocalist. She has had so many songs that have showcased her vocals so well I’m surprised she didn’t debut as a soloist.
Side note: I’m not surprised Wendy is first. I mean are you even a RV fan if you haven’t heard Wendy’s RAW vocals? I mean she must have amazing breath control.
Wheein did have a solo debut? Or do you mean you're surpsised she debuted in a group at all?
@@dianevalentino8813 I’m surprised she debuted in a group at all. I love mamamoo but whee-In definitely would have made it as a soloist.
Wheein is the pillar of MAMAMOO. Among Solar's powerful high note, Hwasa's husky voice, and Moonbyul's low note, she stands as the member that sings main melody and complete everything. MAMAMOO won't be MAMAMOO without her, and it works the same for other members too. Also, they all shine in their solo albums. But together as 4, MAMAMOO is stronger. It's your opinion but I don't think she supposed to debut as a soloist instead of being in a group, especially because her group is MAMAMOO, and she debuted with Solar, Moonbyul, and Hwasa. It would have been different case if she debuted in other group, not MAMAMOO.
@@nxthxn_nn That is because RBW is poor before Mamamoo debut, they don't have money to let four soloist debut, so RBW put them into one group🌚
Lily and Haewon being so young and rookie make sense..Just wait,they'll improve. I'm sure Lily is gonna top this list one day
Yess
Definitely
yess
Those childish voices
@@gule_sur huh?
jihyo isn’t here...the woman that trained for 10 years, and also get bullied in the pre debut days...the strong leader, main vocal, i love her so so much, she’s talented like the others!
edit: lmao I don’t even stan twice anymore so just ignore this comment 💀
Compared to the ones on this list, jihyo is much weaker.
@@technicaleclipse7456 Taeyeon is also not here , do you think Taeyeon is also much weaker ?
@@davaandira2015 this is a ranking of 3rd-4th gen idols taeyeons 2nd gen
@@davaandira2015 I don't think you understood the point of the video. It clearly said 3rd to 4th gen artists. If 2nd gen was here, a whole bunch of SM vocalists including Taeyeon would dominate the list.
@@technicaleclipse7456
When you knew that *Wendy* will be the First!!! 🙌😥👑
she shouldn’t tho
@@hyvkqa3499 why?
@@nxthxn_nn bc AILEE EXIST
@@zeroc00k14 this is 3rd gen and 4th gen idiot
@@adorefim yes and Ailee is 3gen idiot
I'm really impressed by Haewon and Lily. Nmixx seriously needs more recognition.
If you don't think Wendy and Lily are one of the best vocalists in the industry..... there's definitely something wrong with you...
Well i think solar and wheein and wendy
Or my standards are just high 👁👄👁 cmon there are way better vocalist than them i can name you alot
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 then name some of em I wanna know
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 um ok name them
@@hinacharmbraceletera283 exactly my point
Someone who finally understands the vocals of nmixx
Everyone here is just underrating them too much
fr
Blinks raging is literally HILARIOUS. 💀💀
literally☠️
You people's are worst than shit...
I scrolled the whole comment section but didn't find any comment where is written "rosé is my fvt" or "where is rose".
I only find those comments "where is iu" "where is jihyo" "where is taeyon"..
some peoples like you aways make blinks look bad.. but didn't even check is there even any comments like this..
now I realized you peoples are just JEALOUS of blackpink cz they are more popular and special cared than your favorites
GoLdEn VOicE Of KOrEa what fucking joke
@@sheldonsaidali5421 lol there are huge difference between Vocal and voice...
rosé is golden voice of korea that doesn't means everyone calling her best vocalist of korea
I almost see no comment it's more like WhEre Is JIhYo or TAeyOeN
Sigh when will blink accept the reality that their idol isn't that perfect and there are SO MANY MORE idols who is talented than them
Trust me, they'll never accept.
fr
Theyll never accept, they are so toxic
@@JoshushuaCaratzendeobi I can't even see a comment of a blink saying rosè name's
@@JoshushuaCaratzendeobi Yes,but maximum. Now I understand that rose isn’t vocals Queen, but it’s so hard for me to accept it but reality is reality 😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞😞
I feel like Lily isn’t yet on the level that Mamamoo is vocally. Especially since Mamamoo NEVER lip sync. They just always sound amazing.
lily doesn't lip sync, nmixx doesnt either
@@rain-zy9oy really
Have you ever heard mamamoo
Their own boss collaborated with mamamoo for an award performance rather than having so many gg in his company
@@manifilms9681 so what does it have to do with anything.jpy Collabs with so many artist.Lily in just debut already a b- tier vocalist i don't know about mamamoo vocal tier though
@@chetnaprajapati8972
Hwasa = C+
Current Wheein = C+
Solar = B-
Prime Wheein = B
@@manifilms9681 and have you heard nmixx?
Both groups don't lipsync and they have one of the best vocal line or even best vocal as a whole group in their respective generation
Finally someone who's not biased and even add the groups that's not really popular. Finally 😭😭
Literally!
I appreciate the creator
Good job for the creator 💯
Finally someone who didn't put weak vocalist in their ranking and finally someone who put these, who have potential and talent, not these, who are called "golden voices" by their own fandom. I'm not hating anyone, just writing facts and praising author of this video.
Can u be quiet I know ur telling our queen Rosè ur just jealous of her success as ur fav group is not popular as bp ur just jealous first go and listen to her vocals and come
@@marziyanafzal8205 Chill gurl, At 1st ; I'm not jealous of their succes or anything else-I have completely different aspirations in life. At second ; fame doesn't designates if group is good or not-I can like this group and you can like other group as well.
Did you see the pinned comment? According to author of the video, some of singers are just to weak to be in top 15. But don't worry, these singers may be cool for you or anyone else.
This video is actually a valuable film in my opinion-every of these idols, who are putted in this video deserved this and there's no reason to argue in comment section
Have a nice day/noon/evening/morning :)
@@marziyanafzal8205my fave group isn't as popular but at least we have the most album sales and daesangs for gg. also they're the nation's girl group so yeah
@@ecorpse404 completely agree with u
@@marziyanafzal8205 15 yr old spotted 😀
Wendy and ningning SM starts and SM ends BTW this list is non biased
The fact that there are more ppl hating on blinks than blinks hating on the creator💀
Yeaa
That's the truth
click “newest first” and you’ll see how it’s actually the other way around 💀
@@FrostyPlayzYTyeah ur right but still💀
Watch em blinks start asking where is Rosé
Edit: okay 👌 since I found out most of you can’t read don’t reply just don’t it’s making me tired replying to you the same thing learn how to read and process information before you start getting mad and commenting🙄bye
exactly
The real question is where Jihyo is 😭
@@winterrnightts jiyho is not top 15
@@thiagobatista1996 she literally trained for 10 years
@@winterrnightts that doesn't automatically makes her a better vocalist. Some people learn faster than others.
Haely being here, im so proud of them! they're still rookies too
The mamamoo vocal trio💗👏
Guys these are vocalists who would kill even outside of the kpop industry. Their technical skill and power is really up there and does not need the over production in most kpop songs for them to actually sound good.
Seunghee from OMG is definitely somewhere on the list y'all😭✋️.....
Can someone tell me where exactly she would rank?
@@cocomelon8117 why don't u tell me the accurate one if you know so well then?
The title should’ve included “3rd and 4th gen” so that people won’t get confused and start going like “Sunye?” “Taeyeon,” 😭
But I wasn’t sure where to place Seunghee, she’s around A-AA like Ningning
@@RelTheD.OSimp69 3rd + 4th gen was in the intro tho😭
Maybe High C+?
I think Taeyeon should be no.1 and Seunghee should be in the list
The fact that lily and haewon both debuted less than a year ago and they’re both in the top 6 is just- ✨INSANE✨
Lmao blinks be saying “wHerE iS rOsÉ”🤬 like chill ima blink to but rosé definitely isn’t on the list and I bet y’all toxic blinks have never even heard any of the ppl on this list cus ur to focused on bp
Ur just jealous that ur fav group isn’t popular as our queens Blackpink is the best u toxic thing
@@marziyanafzal8205 first, I said I’m also a blink. Second, like I said, you probably don’t know a single person on this except maybe Wendy or ningning bc you consider yourself a “K-pop fan” when you probably only know bts and blackpink bc your a baby fan and don’t know much yet, so think before you speak and stop acting like a little kid. Third, if anyones toxic it’s you, bc blackpink is not “tHe BeSt” just bc they’re the most popular like miss gurl that’s not how it works.
@@marziyanafzal8205 you're just jealous your fave group can't sing
@@jenodreams LMAO REAL
@@marziyanafzal8205 "blackpink is the best" no... not really. u shud start stanning groups that can actually sing, you'll see how blackpink lacks in comparison. blackpink is one of the weakest groups in terms of vocals, like rose can't even sing and jisoo can't even support her voice properly. blackpink is only known as "the best" because they're popular, THATS LITERALLY IT. let's be fucking for real and go stan some groups with some actual talent ok ? like i know lisa can dance and jennie can kind of rap (and don't say she's the best rapper of all 3rd n 4th gen cuz there's a lot of idols that can outrap her, especially from 4th gen like yeeun from ex-clc, soyeon from gidle, and cocona from xg) STAN FOR TALENT, NOT FOR BANWAGON
Ppl be saying how some blinks say " where is rose" when there isn't even THAT MUCH comments about Rose like how y'all think it is ☠️🤌
I literally scrolled way too down but I only saw " where is taeyeon" " where is Iu" or "where is jihyo".
Some ppl rlly make blinks look bad.
If y'all think I'm rude whatever that's your prob.
some of them really set up blinks for clout (even tho I find all blonks and other toxic stans annoying)
Looking for this comment for so long 😌
Really true 😌
Exactly true
I sawa lot of them mentioning rose wth are talking about
Lily and Haewon being rookies but are already in the top 10(I'm not sure if they're still considered rookies since they've been around for 2 years)
I love it is truly unbiased and, amazingly categorized, u can see that just by hearing the vocals of these stunning ladies
EXACTLY
@@lavieenive3138 YES!!
Lily and Haewon amazing 💗😍
solji from EXID deserved a spot here. absolutely one of the most talented vocalists in kpop yet she's so underrated.
isn't she 2nd gen?
@@biochemicalyparanoid4849 EXID is 2nd-3rd gen. somewhere in the middle. ^^
@@biochemicalyparanoid4849 she's also much older than older idols, so she shouldn't be compared to them anyway. She on another level with hyolyn and ailee.
Ofc, i would like to add solji. Sure she's 100% good, bcs before she added as new member in Exid, she's their vocal trainer. That's why her age much older than averages 3rd gen female idols
Honestly i didn't expected Lily to be 3th (Better than Solar), but that doesn't better I'm happy that she's so talented although she's very young.
And everyone knew Mamamoo was the best vocal GROUP💕
Age doesn't matter in talent anyways all Nmixx members are talented
Y'all some people do be like
WHeRe iS gOlDeN vOcAliSt oF kOrEa?
Fr 💀
True 💀
When did we say that?
@@saanvikumain1stkausani702 some blinks not all blinks
@@whatyoulookingat9888 I didn't saw any comment saying where is rose I see where is taeyeon
Edit : thank you so much for 12 likes I never got this much likes
For those who keep asking "WHERE IS TAEYEON AND IU????"
Taeyeon debut in 2007, IU debut in 2008, so technically BOTH of them are 2ND GENERS.
While the video title states that this is about 3RD AND 4TH GENERS.
So, can't you read?
Ya but doesn't rosè deserve a place since she is a 3rd gener?
@@lekasri1820 Nah.The other top 15 that were showed on the list are better than her
I see...anyways
Rose, IU and Jihyo
@@jennie_0fficial IU is 2nd gen and Jihyo and Rosé are npth weaker than NingNing on top 15
Wendy doesn’t need to explain why she’s on the top of this!!❤🎉
Wendy deserve it 👑
Solar is a better vocalist than Lily I guess.?
she isnt lily mix and head voice is better
solar is Def better.
She is ...
Other idols alws fight for 2nd position, because 1st position alws for Queen Wendy
🎤🎶💖👑Ningning💙💜 main vocal Queen👑
She’s awesome, but not the best
HELLPPP 💀💀 I've have an idiot arguing with me that Rosé is better than Lily and calling me an 11 year old 💀💀💀💀
My bad..
I mean, they are blinks, so...
I wanna say jyp hit the jackpit with nmixx members
Me seeing Ningning ranking 15th 💀
Like I think she's already good and I expect she's on 6th/7th but there are more better than her
Also there's so many blinks that don't know Anything about vocals tho
As a R0sé's stan....I am really embarrassed
seeing hwasa at 14 is shocking😵💫
I was so happy to see Yechan. She's such an amazing vocalist yet there's so many people who don't know her or her group.
Btw not that anyone cares but I first started liking her after I heard her cover of Monsta X's "Mercy", it was so good 😳
MAMAMOO ALWAYS THE BEST!!!!😭💚❤️✨
Lily is vocal queen of k pop 👑 because remember can't bb5 but lily can bb5
EXID Solji should be on this list, please look into her if you haven’t, she is one of the best vocalists in kpop of any generation, both technically and talent-wise.
Isn't exid a second gen group?
@@completely_unaware Depends, do you consider 2012 Second or Third gen? (EXO, AOA, NU’EST, etc.) Many people consider it the beginning of the third generation, and treat the groups that debuted then as third gen, so I was operating under the assumption that this person also considered 2012 the beginning of the 3rd generation.
thank you so much for adding yechan!! it makes me so happy to see people appreciating her vocals because pink fantasy are so underated😭💕😭💕
Imagine being just rookies and being only to include with greatest vocalist nmixx did that ❤️
It is so funny to see those delusional mention their favourite left and right,
when the fact is their favourite is not even good enough technically to be a 'Main Vocalist'.
fr
MY FAVOIRITE K POP VOCALIST IS ROSE BUT THE TRUE US THAT SHE CAN'T COMPARE THESE IDOL
I agree on the list, it's fair and not bias at all. Haewon and Lily being a rookie in this ranking but their securing a good spot 💖
Wendy my love😩
Let's be honest, we all knew who number one was going to be. (As she deserves)
@@Afraidsnbhd At number 1, of course, where she belongs.
The moment I saw Ningning in the last place of this ranking, I know the popular group's main Vocalists (namely Twice and Blackpink's maik vocalists) would not make into the list.
Let's be real. They are good. Actually Great. But not as great as those in this list.
Omg this is so accurate! You actually did some profound digging and didn’t go by biased-ness or popularity with idols like Taeyeon, Jihyo, Nayeon, IU or Rosé (they’re awesome tho). THANK YOU.
this is not biased, but i agree with you except for TAEYEON… she is a profound singer, she’s been proving that for years if you listen to SNSD or her solo stuff she def deserved a spot on this list. rose, iu, nayeon, jihyo are all mediocre vocalists
@@lexgf hmm perhaps ur right
Taeyeon IU from gen2 not 3,4 gen
Lol I didn't find any comment about rosé and nayeon
It is my great pleasure to see those from the certain fandom scream out their favourite idol name who is not in this list,
which means she is actually not that good as they think she is.
I was ready to throw hands when I saw Ningning at the bottom thinking you're gonna rank Winter higher than her
FRRRR
SAMEE😭
I personally would have also add EXID solji she's really awesome
My bad I forgot she's 2nd gen
When 3 out of 4 members in the list.. MAMAMOO can relate 🔥
solar is my personal favorite on the list she can do almost all vocal technics in a such a smooth way like : belting,vibrato,falsetto she's really good at those three also her resonance is crazy as well as her breathing too she can hold a note for a very long time she is so impressive probably my second role model in female vocalist
She has a terrible control in her Headvoice.
I'm subscribing because we need more fans like this who are real
I'm not fans of Aespa but I'm so shock when I see Ningning in the last position
Sometimes we all can have different opinions but we all can agree on wendy❤
Yechan (Pink Fantasy) sang On the Ground by Rosé (Blackpink)
And?
Great job Einstein
now this is a short. Unbiased and not trying to add only their faves, while also adding nugu idols and trying to be honest and true.
Thank you so much for not including blackpink here
God people are so obsessed with them that they don't acknowledge that others are BETTER!
LY 💕
Why would they add them??if they are not the best??plus what's soo up thanking this creator??there's nothing wrong if u Stan a idol or support them or bias over them??they are called fans for a reason???rosé is definitely best vocalist according to her billions of fans
Hwasa, Wheein, Seulgi, Wendy, Jihyo and Jisoo have the best vocals for me. They have this type of voice that cannot be replaced. Like, so unique and you can easily distiguish who sings what... So pretty 💗✨
I don’t think Jisoo could be put next to Wendy in amazing vocals Wendy is wayyy better
Jisoo?????? Crack Jisoo
Where is Wendy
@@Ayyyyaaaaa1fr😂
Not how they played the phsyco meme for Wendy 😅
what?
mamamoo being the best group of vocals having 3 members in the to 15 best vocalist list
3rd gen : Wendy & Jihyo my fav❤
Rosé and Jihyo crying in the corner
They're all really good but the vocalists on the list are sm better than them more like they're the best ones in kpop except taeyeon is def there on the list but she's second gen and Wendy is alr there lol
Iu is a second gen idol
Iu is 2nd gen
@@pd.z exactly almost all he people on this list are sm idols expect for lily yuju and etc
As they should
This girl is living in the past and…*rose has left the chat*
Bro rosie is way too far to reach Ningning's level and shes the least here💀
Why it's always blinks and blackpink??! What about jihyo,lia etc?
@@ice_cream3563 those 3 have great vocal but they dont really compare to these higher level idols
@@HeyItStop ik
1st Gen- Lina The Grace, 2nd Gen- Ailee, 3rd Gen- Wendy, 4th Gen- Lily
Actually, Lina is the 2nd gen since The Grace debut in 2005, same year with Super Junior.
The best female vocalist of the first generation is Ock Juhyun from Fin KL.
As for Ailee, many are not consider her as an idol since she's soloist.
@@94mp99 I think she was when she debut with Heaven though she has been singing more kpop covers lately. Plus there are more soloists nowdays. an incredible and complete vocalist. I believe 2005 is last year of 1st Gen. Shouldn’t SJ be 1st Gen?
@@inquisitvem6723 Last year of 1st gen is 2002. 2nd gen began with the debut of TVXQ in 2003.
OMG I DIDN'T EXPECT JUNGWOO TO HERE!!! BVNDIT is so underrated
I'm impressed that u actually did research and gave a sort of unbias list. I was expecting this to be filled with the popular idols. U get my like, well done.
But I do wonder why purple kiss didn't make it into this list?
most of the idols are from third gen, goeun is just slightly worse than ningning, but purple kiss do have an amazing vocal line
Was extremely happy to see nugu groups get exposure!
Especially happy for 12dal! Both of then are EXTREMELY talented vocalists
everyone saying where is rosé but tbh as a blink i accept that rosé is not so good vocalist but she has a unique voice which is beautiful so in vocal category i know rosé is not good then them and btw stayc left the chat😂
Rosie❤ deserves to be no .1 position becuz she is officially known as golden voice of korean and you are not real blink and there are many once in comment section who are saying jihyo is best you don't seen this why only Rosie😢
Wendy in number 1 as she should
sejeong unnie is suuper underrated as a soloist! guyss~ let’s give her lots of support, okay?~ c:
seeing people include my girl yuju makes me happy
why is solji (exid) always being left out of these like she is a 3rd gen idol too yknow..
That’s 2nd gen
@@crystalflake6888 shes a 3rd gen i think since she redebuted with exid
@@bussythrobbing2 Exid is 2nd gen
lily having a higher position than solar? what world do you live in, solar destroys vocally ah lily deserves a better position and rose I'm not her fan but she has a beautiful and unique vocal.
I believe the rank is about vocal technique, so Rose wont be in the list because her artistic delivery is limiting her range and belts.
@@topzki47 oh thanks for the clarification
You’re delusional
Mamamoo members vocals are too good❤
Though I'm glad you didn't do some fan service and put any of black pink members cause let's be honest they can't be in top 20 even
But I think mamamoo members should be higher they are all lead vocalist except moonbuyl but she has a charming low tone
And i think you could put some of dreamcatchers vocalist or at least siyeon instead of few names you mentioned
The pinned comment clearly says that they didn't add Dreamcatcher or Siyeon because they're weak compared to the others here
Edit: I don't mean no hate to you tho! Dreamcatcher's vocals are really good
Finally a list that isn't biased !!!
JIHOY not being here is killing me so bad
Queen Wendy :) I love her so much ! (I love the others too ! They are so talented !)
how can wheein just in 13?? 😂
Wheein is C+
The fact that 3/4 mamamoo members are here. I stan talent
Winter and Seulgi really deserves to be here
SEULGI IS 18 WHILE WINTER IS 20........19 is from Weekly but i forgot
I wish Wheein could come back to the top. She used to be so much better.
Me too, Wheein really has it all, good techniques and unique voice.
Windy gives me goosebumps
Windy weather always gives me goosebumps, yes🥶
Lily is vocal queen of k pop 👑 because remember can not bb5 lily is bb5
Blinks, tho I am blink myself still I am saying it that DON'T BE SO BIASEDDD!
I love rosie but multi-group fans already know that she is a weak vocalist
For those who are commenting that Wendy shouldn't be no.1 : like have u even heard wendy's voice
Rosie is a good and average vocalist, I love her but honestly as a multi-groups fan I know that she can't even make it to top-15 in this list
Make it simple bro.. I can't really understand it
@@saudahchik1835 Rosie's vocal tier is D+ , vocalists in the video are C+
@@saudahchik1835 Just read the thing and you'll understand...U can spend atleast 60 seconds in reading right bro?
These blonks are mad rose isnt here if jihyo and nayeon arent here shes not even close to being here
3/4 mamamoo members are on this list, they are literal queens
Wendy's voice 😩💗
Blinks be like 💀💀🌚🌚
Blinks are so mad right now it’s kinda funny. Blinks are probably the worst fandom
If you talk about best vocal in kpop you should've add this name toooo~~
"Siyeon of Dreamcatcher"
"Yeonjung of WJSN"
Well no
Sitein can't support only 🤣
@@shizae Siyeon
vocal tiers:
NINGNING AND HWASA: C+
WHEEIN - LILY: B-
NAYUL AND WENDY: B+
ate
Lily is B and Wheein C+
Solar?
@@harurururu8372 B- or B?
People don’t know how to read or what vocal technique is 😭 “Where is Taeyeon?” Maybe work on your reading skills first.. “Where is Rosé and Jihyo?” not in the top 15, move on it’s really not that deep you can still enjoy their voices, I do too enjoy their songs..
Lmao forget abt jihyo and rose, someone literally asked wheres jisoo and i was like.. bro whut
@@latte575 damn 😭 like the main vocal of the group isn’t there and ur asking about the 2nd lead vocal.. just need logical thinking at this point not even vocal technique knowledge
Idk how "bLiNkS" are going and just saying Rosé belongs on the top 15... Bro this isn't BP ranking, as you can see even though Rosé has incredible vocals and she is truly unique, you gotta stop this biased way like.. Not to be rude or anything but really..?
I scrolled the whole comment section but didn't find any comment where is written "rosé is my fvt" or "where is rose".
I only find those comments "where is iu" "where is jihyo" "where is taeyon"..
some peoples like you aways make blinks bad.. but didn't even check is there even any comments like this..
@@ice_cream3563 The person isn't lying. There are many comments related to Rose and I am barely half way through them.
This list is pretty accurate, except the Lily and Haewon part. Trust me, I literally call myself the biggest nmixx defender- but do you really think Haewon deserves such a a high position? And Lily after Solar? Naw- Don't get me wrong, but I think putting Lily in top 10 was better than top 5
Edit: this comment was 9 months ago and Haewon didn't show much of her talent at that time. So hopefully yall understand where I was coming from
Cry about it but NMIXX is objectively THAT good.
Lily still have a lot to learn, but I'm sure she will surpass her senior in a short time
@@shujinko2944 shes great, but she isnt AS gd as some of the idols ranked below her. the confidence is there, the power is there. but technique wise, sometimes she lacks supports. when doing low note, her voice were shaky. and when doing high notes, her voice tend to strain. then again, being a better vocalist aint always abt highnotes. she still has alot to learn. but amongst gen4 shes definitely one of the top best vocalist yet
@@haesungshi SHE is though. Accept it. She beats almost all off MAMAMOO
@@shujinko2944 you are just bias at this point. its pointless