Jill, I love you and your videos! One of the things I love about your content is that you aren’t afraid to be critical and that you don’t just gush over every single book. Because of that, I trust your opinions more. I really respect your honesty. I hope the Yellowface video doesn’t scare you away from being critical of books that deserve it.
Jill, I just discovered you through a favorite booktuber of mine, abookolive. I want you to know that there are very few critical people out there. What is sad, is that they seem to be the most vocal. Keep being you, your genuine self. I can't wait to hear more of your bookish opinions. I will have to try to finish Demon Copperhead. Maybe I was in the wrong head space when I was reading it because I just couldn't get through it. But I love well crafted beautifully written books. SO it'll go back on my list.
Ive read more of your recomendations than anyone else and you are always spot on for me. I know people have strong opinions out here in the ether. However, like you said ,we have a great community here and a few people with too much time on their hands can't spoil that. We love you JILL!!!
Negative comments like that can make somebody really question themselves and I can totally see how that experience could trigger thinking about one's online presence. I think about this sometimes too and don't necessarily have a great answer, but overall the booktube community seems incredibly positive, esp. compared to other corners of the internet. I definitely need to get to Demon Copperhead but it takes me a while to pick up traumafic b/c I have to be in the right mood!
Definitely there is lots of trauma in Demon Copperhead but it's balanced so well with humour and joy and love that it doesn't feel like you are reading trauma porn (like A Little Life, or something).
I enjoy your videos so much Jill. First I watched them for the wonderful and thoughtful comments you share. I still do of corse, but you have the most delightful and pleasing personality on youTube. So many of your recommendations I have enjoyed and I look forward to. Opinions are just that. Opinions aren't facts. You're the best!!
Online presence is something I've been thinking about a lot lately. I constantly flip between: sharing more, sharing less, review more and then not feeling like I have anything to contribute, while at the same time really don't want to invite the unfriendly commenters. But also want to participate in the community more. I don't know what will happen in 2024, it all so often depends on life around reading. Looking forward to your thoughts on books in 2024
No lie, I’ve often wondered how you dealt with that video and I wondered if it impacted your relationship with booktube 😢 I love every time you post so I’ll always be here! But you’re so right that the negative comments really stick with you. I love Patricia Highsmith! She’s always at least interesting, even when she’s not at her best.
We seem to be living in a very intolerant society. A democracy is supposed to be about free speech. Listening to differing points of view, keeping an open mind, and agreeing to disagree are values that seem to have been lost. You have a right to your opinion without being attacked for it.
I love Kingsolver and after your strong rec, just put Demon Copperhead on my library hold list Also, I love that you bought it at Brazos because I live in Houston and love that bookstore! You're a gem!
I went to Brazos at your recommendation! It was a lovely store and the staff were so excellent. If you ever run into Susan at Brazos again, tell her I say hi!
I love Highsmith and Deep Water has been on my TBR for awhile. loved Strangers on a Train and Sweet Sickness were both excellent and Ripley of course. I want applause as I recently finished David Copperfield. I read it after reading Demon and wanting to see how Kingslover paralleled the two. I don't recommend it. I liked Demon better before I saw how closely it had taken from Dickens. I love Kingsolver--have read many/most of her books and would never consider skipping one of her novels but I would recommend not reading Dickens to understand Demon better. Sometimes one can look to long and deep. Love your videos. I took my first trip to Montreal and Quebec city on Thanksgiving week and believe it or not I thought of you and wanted to tell you how much I loved all I saw.
Ok I'm so glad to know I don't have to read David Copperfield hahaha!! I am not a Dickens fan so you have absolved me of this requirement. I hope you had a good time in Quebec! Montreal is a cool city, but I've never been to Quebec city myself! I need to make an effort to get there. Thanks for your thoughtfulness 🧡
New subscriber to your channel! I'm sorry you had to deal with an unpleasant reaction to one of your videos. There are lots of toxic people on most of the Social Media platforms, they thinly disguise their narcissism through dismissive comments. Lean in to all of the positive comments you receive!
I'm so happy for you that you are in a good place and so happy, Jill! I have loved your channel for a long time regardless of the amount of content. Fully support the "Thriving"!😁🙃🤗
Love, love, love year end videos! I kept thinking why do I know Patricia Highsmith? Then I remembered the author of The Talented Mr Ripley, another great read. Copperhead is on my TBR (I also downloaded it on audio), so glad you enjoyed it. Happy Holiday Season! 🎄
I agree with and echo the previous comment here. Thank YOU and do not underestimate the way YOU touch others. I would have a hard time reading hurtful and hateful comments too. I am grateful for the time and talent like yours and others I have found on UA-cam in the worlds of book lovers and knitters. I don’t really knit, but they are a kind and thoughtful group! I also loved The Librarianist (strange childhood episode included). I have a sample of Demon Copperhead on my Kindle and your review has put it at the top of my next-to-read list. Cheers and kudos from this retired librarian!
I don't knit either but I've been thinking about trying to teach myself. It's good to know there will be a thoughtful community if I try to pick it up. Thanks for your kind comment🤍
I just want to say how much i appreciate and enjoy your videos. Was very excited to see this one pop up! Thank you! Looking forward to your end of year vids as well 😊
I posted a video, 'When Authors Aren't Good People', in December 2021. I originally made the video because people were finding my review of Lucky and asking me to comment on what had come to light about Alice Sebold. I decided to do it and expanded a bit in the video to talk about JK Rowling as well. It had the usual level of engagement for a couple weeks and then suddenly it started getting lots of views and comments from people outside the Booktube sphere. It ended up being my lowest morale moment making videos. I'm never doing anything like that again because it's just not worth the time and stress dealing with the comments. I'll post what I want when I want to. All that to say, you do you, girl. -Becks
I can't remember if you like personal essays but Yiyun Li's essay collection, Dear Friend, From My Life I Write to You In Your Life covers her (harrowing) experience growing up in China, her life in letters to other writers, and her mental health. Your videos are always a welcome sight and it's wonderful that you're doing well.
Okay, I hope this makes you laugh but I do not remember your Yellowface video but, many people I watch did not like it and seemed uncomfortable talking about it. I also hope this comment shows there are as many if us who are not bothered or don't remember the video. 😅
Love kitty 🐾🐾. It’s never about the quantity of books you read. If I can add one book to my TBR then it’s all good 👍 also being on social media exposes a person to the good, the bad and the ugly. I am a new subscriber and didn’t watch the Yellowface video, however I did love that book. I hope you keep on making videos because I really enjoy your reviews.
Oh please! Thank YOU! ☺️ I can’t imagine the work and time required to make these videos not to mention what creepy crawlies may come out of the crevices of the internet to be keyboard warriors. Deep Water sounds good!
I haven't read Yellowface yet so haven't watched your video yet. I look forward to viewing it once I do. I love hearing/reading differing opinions, and I have respected yours thus far.
I love end of year lists . I’m glad things are going well Gill. No need to feel guilty about not posting. Just as long as we know you’re ok 👍 I loved Demon Copperhead The Librarianist is on my wish list. The best books read in November are March by Geraldine Brooks The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store by James McBride Good Morning Monster ( nonfiction) 🍀👋☘️📚📖🇮🇪📕☕️💐
Okay so I didn't expect to add the three books I hadn't read from this video to my tbr but I have and I also kinda want to reread Demon Copperhead now? So I feel like that says something about how good you are at talking about books. Or maybe just that I want to love all the same books as you. Or maybe both 🤗
I love that cover of Wednesday's Child! I have the American cover with the dog. I've ordered books from the UK too. A recent example was The House of Doors by Tan Twan Eng. The UK cover was better, but the end papers were beautiful.
Jill, I love you and your videos! One of the things I love about your content is that you aren’t afraid to be critical and that you don’t just gush over every single book. Because of that, I trust your opinions more. I really respect your honesty. I hope the Yellowface video doesn’t scare you away from being critical of books that deserve it.
🧡🩷💙💚❤️
Jill, I just discovered you through a favorite booktuber of mine, abookolive. I want you to know that there are very few critical people out there. What is sad, is that they seem to be the most vocal. Keep being you, your genuine self. I can't wait to hear more of your bookish opinions. I will have to try to finish Demon Copperhead. Maybe I was in the wrong head space when I was reading it because I just couldn't get through it. But I love well crafted beautifully written books. SO it'll go back on my list.
Ive read more of your recomendations than anyone else and you are always spot on for me. I know people have strong opinions out here in the ether. However, like you said ,we have a great community here and a few people with too much time on their hands can't spoil that. We love you JILL!!!
Negative comments like that can make somebody really question themselves and I can totally see how that experience could trigger thinking about one's online presence. I think about this sometimes too and don't necessarily have a great answer, but overall the booktube community seems incredibly positive, esp. compared to other corners of the internet.
I definitely need to get to Demon Copperhead but it takes me a while to pick up traumafic b/c I have to be in the right mood!
Definitely there is lots of trauma in Demon Copperhead but it's balanced so well with humour and joy and love that it doesn't feel like you are reading trauma porn (like A Little Life, or something).
I enjoy your videos so much Jill. First I watched them for the wonderful and thoughtful comments you share. I still do of corse, but you have the most delightful and pleasing personality on youTube. So many of your recommendations I have enjoyed and I look forward to. Opinions are just that. Opinions aren't facts. You're the best!!
Online presence is something I've been thinking about a lot lately. I constantly flip between: sharing more, sharing less, review more and then not feeling like I have anything to contribute, while at the same time really don't want to invite the unfriendly commenters. But also want to participate in the community more. I don't know what will happen in 2024, it all so often depends on life around reading.
Looking forward to your thoughts on books in 2024
No lie, I’ve often wondered how you dealt with that video and I wondered if it impacted your relationship with booktube 😢 I love every time you post so I’ll always be here! But you’re so right that the negative comments really stick with you. I love Patricia Highsmith! She’s always at least interesting, even when she’s not at her best.
🧡🩷💙 I appreciate you so much!!
Back at you. Please make videos when you can. I enjoy and appreciate them and you 😘
🧡 thank you
We seem to be living in a very intolerant society. A democracy is supposed to be about free speech. Listening to differing points of view, keeping an open mind, and agreeing to disagree are values that seem to have been lost. You have a right to your opinion without being attacked for it.
I love Kingsolver and after your strong rec, just put Demon Copperhead on my library hold list Also, I love that you bought it at Brazos because I live in Houston and love that bookstore! You're a gem!
I went to Brazos at your recommendation! It was a lovely store and the staff were so excellent. If you ever run into Susan at Brazos again, tell her I say hi!
I love Highsmith and Deep Water has been on my TBR for awhile. loved Strangers on a Train and Sweet Sickness were both excellent and Ripley of course. I want applause as I recently finished David Copperfield. I read it after reading Demon and wanting to see how Kingslover paralleled the two. I don't recommend it. I liked Demon better before I saw how closely it had taken from Dickens. I love Kingsolver--have read many/most of her books and would never consider skipping one of her novels but I would recommend not reading Dickens to understand Demon better. Sometimes one can look to long and deep. Love your videos. I took my first trip to Montreal and Quebec city on Thanksgiving week and believe it or not I thought of you and wanted to tell you how much I loved all I saw.
Ok I'm so glad to know I don't have to read David Copperfield hahaha!! I am not a Dickens fan so you have absolved me of this requirement.
I hope you had a good time in Quebec! Montreal is a cool city, but I've never been to Quebec city myself! I need to make an effort to get there. Thanks for your thoughtfulness 🧡
I love you book commentary! I also thought Demon Copperhead was excellent. Demon’s voice will stay with me for a long time.
🩷🧡
New subscriber to your channel! I'm sorry you had to deal with an unpleasant reaction to one of your videos. There are lots of toxic people on most of the Social Media platforms, they thinly disguise their narcissism through dismissive comments. Lean in to all of the positive comments you receive!
I'm so happy for you that you are in a good place and so happy, Jill! I have loved your channel for a long time regardless of the amount of content. Fully support the "Thriving"!😁🙃🤗
Thank you 😘
Love, love, love year end videos! I kept thinking why do I know Patricia Highsmith? Then I remembered the author of The Talented Mr Ripley, another great read. Copperhead is on my TBR (I also downloaded it on audio), so glad you enjoyed it. Happy Holiday Season! 🎄
I really want to read The Talented Mr. Ripley! I want to read it before the new Netflix series
Yes, Jill! I heard about the new series upcoming. The book & movie w Matt Damon is quite good! @@TheBookBully
I agree with and echo the previous comment here. Thank YOU and do not underestimate the way YOU touch others. I would have a hard time reading hurtful and hateful comments too. I am grateful for the time and talent like yours and others I have found on UA-cam in the worlds of book lovers and knitters. I don’t really knit, but they are a kind and thoughtful group!
I also loved The Librarianist (strange childhood episode included). I have a sample of Demon Copperhead on my Kindle and your review has put it at the top of my next-to-read list.
Cheers and kudos from this retired librarian!
I don't knit either but I've been thinking about trying to teach myself. It's good to know there will be a thoughtful community if I try to pick it up.
Thanks for your kind comment🤍
I just want to say how much i appreciate and enjoy your videos. Was very excited to see this one pop up! Thank you! Looking forward to your end of year vids as well 😊
Thank you 🍓🥹
I posted a video, 'When Authors Aren't Good People', in December 2021. I originally made the video because people were finding my review of Lucky and asking me to comment on what had come to light about Alice Sebold. I decided to do it and expanded a bit in the video to talk about JK Rowling as well. It had the usual level of engagement for a couple weeks and then suddenly it started getting lots of views and comments from people outside the Booktube sphere. It ended up being my lowest morale moment making videos. I'm never doing anything like that again because it's just not worth the time and stress dealing with the comments. I'll post what I want when I want to. All that to say, you do you, girl. -Becks
I am always happy to see you in a new video! If we lived close by I think we would be great friends.
❤️ hey, if you're ever in Ottawa, lmk!
I can't remember if you like personal essays but Yiyun Li's essay collection, Dear Friend, From My Life I Write to You In Your Life covers her (harrowing) experience growing up in China, her life in letters to other writers, and her mental health. Your videos are always a welcome sight and it's wonderful that you're doing well.
I looked up her back catalogue and saw this title. It definitely sounds up my street. Thanks for the recommendation! And thanks for watching 💙
Okay, I hope this makes you laugh but I do not remember your Yellowface video but, many people I watch did not like it and seemed uncomfortable talking about it. I also hope this comment shows there are as many if us who are not bothered or don't remember the video. 😅
Love kitty 🐾🐾. It’s never about the quantity of books you read. If I can add one book to my TBR then it’s all good 👍 also being on social media exposes a person to the good, the bad and the ugly. I am a new subscriber and didn’t watch the Yellowface video, however I did love that book. I hope you keep on making videos because I really enjoy your reviews.
Oh please! Thank YOU! ☺️ I can’t imagine the work and time required to make these videos not to mention what creepy crawlies may come out of the crevices of the internet to be keyboard warriors. Deep Water sounds good!
So many heroes behind the screen!
I think I'm going to read Demon Copperhead next year although I'm scared to feel things haha. loved hearing your thoughts as always! ❤
Don't worry! You will feel just the right amount. I feel confident you will enjoy it
Going to put Deep Water on my TBR what edition do you have?Love that cover.
I haven't read Yellowface yet so haven't watched your video yet. I look forward to viewing it once I do. I love hearing/reading differing opinions, and I have respected yours thus far.
Newbie to your channel. Absolutely loved Demon Copperhead. One of the best books I've read this year.
I love end of year lists . I’m glad things are going well Gill. No need to feel guilty about not posting. Just as long as we know you’re ok 👍
I loved Demon Copperhead
The Librarianist is on my wish list.
The best books read in November are
March by Geraldine Brooks
The Heaven & Earth Grocery Store by James McBride
Good Morning Monster ( nonfiction)
🍀👋☘️📚📖🇮🇪📕☕️💐
I really need to get to The Heaven and Earth Grocery Store! Thanks for always being here 🩷
Okay so I didn't expect to add the three books I hadn't read from this video to my tbr but I have and I also kinda want to reread Demon Copperhead now? So I feel like that says something about how good you are at talking about books. Or maybe just that I want to love all the same books as you. Or maybe both 🤗
I love that cover of Wednesday's Child! I have the American cover with the dog. I've ordered books from the UK too. A recent example was The House of Doors by Tan Twan Eng. The UK cover was better, but the end papers were beautiful.
Sometimes we simply must go for the aesthetics
Loved all these books. 😊 Patrick Dewitt is the funniest author of all time! I’ve read all his books..
Amen!!!! I need to read the rest of his backlist. I have loved all three that I've read
I love your videos 💖
Thank you 🥹
🥰
🧡🧡🧡🧡🧡