The limits of learning - kids in crisis | DW Documentary
Вставка
- Опубліковано 9 тра 2021
- Surveys show that the majority of German students feel hopeless, listless and even depressed as a result of the long lockdown. Homeschooling is overwhelming for many of them, and some families are struggling to cope. We visited students at home.
Every morning, 14-year-old Catharina sits down at the dining table and tries to study Latin, Math, or English. Her 10-year-old brother, Philipp, sits next to her. He also has to study - and likes using Catharina as a teaching assistant. How are either one supposed to concentrate? Their single mother can’t help, because she is a doctor and has to go to work. Anna has it a little bit easier. She is 16 years old and considers the time she has spent in lockdown to be the most productive of her life so far. She can finally concentrate, and work in peace. Leandro is 14 and can't understand this. He feels completely overwhelmed by the massive heap of tasks. What should he tackle first and how should he do it? He can't provide the structure and guidance he used to get every day in the classroom for himself, and often has trouble getting out of bed in the morning -an indication of early-onset depression. Axel Rowohlt visited Catharina, Philipp, Anna and Leandro, and also spoke to Felix, their student representative. He conducted a survey among students in Berlin - with alarming results.
ـــــ
DW Documentary gives you knowledge beyond the headlines. Watch top documentaries from German broadcasters and international production companies. Meet intriguing people, travel to distant lands, get a look behind the complexities of daily life and build a deeper understanding of current affairs and global events. Subscribe and explore the world around you with DW Documentary.
Subscribe to:
DW Documentary: / @dwdocumentary
DW Documental (Spanish): / dwdocumental
DW Documentary وثائقية دي دبليو: (Arabic): / dwdocarabia
For more visit:
www.dw.com/en/tv/docfilm/s-3610
Instagram:
/ dwdocumentary
Facebook:
/ dw.stories
We kindly ask viewers to read and stick to the DW netiquette policy on our channel: p.dw.com/p/MF1G
"I question my existence' coming from a mouth of a child - heartbreaking.
He's 14, and it's not that weird, many humans start thinking about the meaning of life at an early age
Not really, as I feel it shows a very developed intellect for a child his age. German of course!
i understand wat he means tho...
@@ttttg5302 Questioning existence of life, while being stuck at home all the time, sounds like suicide in making.
🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️🤦🏻♂️😭😭😭
As a student, I felt constantly ignored and almost everyone invalidated my suffering. SO THANK YOU SO MUCH FOR THIS.
And reliable comment throught a person from a tough background. Keep breathing and live a day each time. In no time you get over it. And learn how to cope joyfully with situations like depression, incomprehension, loneliness, etc unbearable is an ilusion. But never force yourself too much. Winsdom comes with time
Expect comprehension from others is the perfect road to disaster. With time you start to comprehend your own problem and be your own cure. Just dont push yourself over your limits. But always transpassing it. The way you get tougher.
True. I am in University now, but am still living at home, due to the pandemic and family circumstances. I have been getting comment from my parents, how easy it is for me, since I can just sit at home all day. I don't meet anybody but my family for months at a time, I have absolutely *NO* daily routine and my studies feel like a complete waste of time. Im staring on a screen 6 hours a day, while learning nothing, at a time that has a huge influence on my future life. But at least I can "sit at home all day"
@@Max-kh1cf I know how frustrating it can be. I'm sure things will get better soon now that people are actually talking about this.
I had no opportunity to be student
Now imagine kids who have no
Proper access to the internet 😟 this is happening in Germany and I can’t even imagine what’s going on in developing countries 😓
We studied on 5-6 Inches of mobile phone ... that was really hard...
That's one of the major problems that developing countries have been facing since the school started last year like here in the Philippines. Our country has a bad internet connection and one of the slowest in the world. There are also many students here that have no access to the internet. I hope this situation will be back in normal as soon as possible.
It's not only hard for the kids but also for teachers. Live teaching is almost impossible because you need stable internet connection and sufficient internet quota. Those are like luxury for many students. Furthermore, some of them rarely paying attention to any materials or assignments given by their teachers since they have to help their parents who already have less income or even jobless due to pandemic. The teachers also can't do much facing this difficult situation.
@@mr.alejandre9428 nope. Cyber school is better ohicical schools are more costly to families and others.
@@pinkclover8588 internet is easy to get and regular schools need good location, good electricity, good transportation AND good money. Get a grip. Defund the physical schools to get internet
Wake up in the morning, and think about existence as 14. 😔
No wonder the world’s best existentialists are German.
Some may Dare to Say... an OLD & tired Soul... Warm Regards dear friend.
Modern education needs to be reimagined for a future that is innovation and team focused. Rote memorization is pointless, remote learning just strips away the social layer that made it bearable before
Education is very hard to change. It requires educators who want change and have the skills necessary to bring that change about. It needs school systems and parents that are open to change. The most damming phrase in education is "We have never done it that way before!"
@@old-moose oh there are experimental schools in CA and elsewhere that are working on team based learning curricula. The challenge has always been DOE standardization and parental work constraints. WFH and remote learning is actually a real opening
@@rabbitsforyang8273 There are always bright spots but "testable" local, provincial, and national standards are a problem. I've spent half my career working in a polytechnic where the test is being able to do the job which is refreshing. Social media has been used successfully with adult students. Almost all programs at Sask PolyTech have a co-op ed or practicum requirement. We found that social media is a great way to support students and even help reduce problems with PTSD with medical field students. I haven't seen any work being done with k-12 students. (I'm retired now so I haven't been diligent in following research.)
@@old-moose social media lacks norms and information convergence, so can harm as well as help
collaborative media is the ultimate solution, achieve information crystalization through 1-1 contribution mechanism, which I am creating
@@rabbitsforyang8273 When I talk about social media in an educational context, I'm not thinking of open platforms like Twitter and Facebook but closed platforms like what you seem to be working on. When I retired, 6 years ago, those platforms were very new and had lots of room for improvement. Good luck on your project.
Saw this in German first. It really is unfair that kids are getting just the work for school without any of the upside: laughing with friends, small talk on the hallways, seeing a different environment... I hope we get them back in the classroom as soon as possible since that’s part of their (our) development.
And what about the one kid which feels more comfortable, and being productive, while isolated. Have we forgotten her?
@@PASBGR I guess some people just dont like those things as much,I personally miss being able to do those things but i know many who dont and its perfectly fine
@@PASBGR my daughter says this is the best year ever because she is more comfortable and productive. She’s on the fifth grade and is excelling even more than before. This is in Bethesda, MD. So no, I do not forget her or the girl in the report who’s also enjoying her remote learning.
But this is a utilitarian argument: more would be greatly benefited at the expense of the comfort of the few (mine included) if it means a student like Leandro will get more joy and growth out of this critical developmental period of their lives. And we could allow those students to stay at home if they want. But I would like to see them back in school for their own sake.
Also forgot bullying, beating and etc. School is not o ly flowers and butterflies.
@@robertasliutas2903 Also ridiculous amounts of pointless lessons like ethics, arts or crafts, even the important subject lessons sucks with crap teachers. All they need to do is to write better textbooks with full step by step explanations and quality youtube videos and thats all lol
Boy is asking very good questions that need to be answered.
too edgy to be honest
I’ve been a straight A student for a long time. I even managed to do it for two semesters of online learning while doing remote work study. However, this will not be the case this semester. I’ve been struggling a lot because of burnout. I feel like I’m not myself. I was so used to always having things together and keeping a routine but I’m just exhausted now. Thankfully, I will be graduating in a few days 😭 I look forward to getting a break.
I feel that. Props to you for pulling through. Me and a few friends talked about this and we all feel the same. My Impulse control is getting worse and I get less and less patient for everyday things. I feel weird In my own skin, because I have always been very easy going and non confronting.
Hopeless, listless and depressed is exactly how I felt over 40 years ago in the pre digital USA. I questioned the pointlessness of existence constantly and was told I was an ungrateful complainer. This reminds me of those times when everything was supposed to be great....but wasn't. I suppose everyone has their own psychic hurdles to overcome.
@@maeudaou7347 Absolutely true. Virtual communication is no replacement for real human interaction.
You were right, this world and education messed up. They are not trying go make people or kids happy. Just fear and survival for all.
@@mayormc But real human interaction can take place online if it is planned for and very few teachers are trained to build it into the class. It isn't the same as face-to-face but it can be done. And it isn't like this is something new. In 1974 I wrote a paper titled "If I haven't had a bloody nose from a playground accident, have I been to school" and looked at social interaction and distance education.
@@sunbox4700 Exactly Right! Kids are also picking up a lot of stress from their parents too.
High school felt like a pointless experience save for a few books and ideas I revisited as an adult. I feel that the reason why grade school provided hopelessness, listlessness, and depression is because of the approach to teaching.
For instance, what's the point of doing algebra and reading literature and history if you're simply being tested at face value? Literature, history, and mathematics are fields of study that have grown out of interpretation. Regurgitating facts won't make the future, problem-solving and creativity will.
I definitely find it’s harder to care about school, I lack motivation to do anything. To all students such as myself, don’t give up...From Canada 🇨🇦
oh im in Canada too, and it seems like kids are really unmotivated in this country, most wouldn't even work, it's sad :(
Where some children in poor countries have to walk every morning long distance to reach a school and they ARE motivated.
So stop complaining and suck it up!
@@miguelgt2010 That kid you replied to is dumb because he can choose between trillions of different cyberschools yet he chooses one that stresses him out. Physical schools destroy children's brains with pollution and junk food. Cyberschoo is better and makes kids educated while regular schools want money.
@@robertasliutas2903 I agree. Physical school I went too forced me to not bring a Geiger counter and I get suspended for 1 month because I brought a Geiger counter and recording the radiation reding. *THE RADIATION READING WAS AT A FATAL LEVEL AND THE POLICE CAME AND FINED THE SCHOOL TO REMOVE THE RADIATION SOURCE*
Bro same thing happened to me. Once I was in university I was competing first rank holder in my class but now I am not even able to submit my assignment at the given . These things happening because of lack of motivation
Dear DW, I must confess - personally for me, your documentaries is truly more fascinating then HBO serials or blockbusters. Because you are choose highly essential and interesting topics an showing them us professionally clear and objectively. Thank your for your work!
It's more interesting to learn from different prospective than just being entertained. I don't have a TV since 2009, but I gain a wealth of knowledge from different subjects
I have 2 kids (11 and 7). For parents: try to spend a time together with kids as much as you can. Have a conversation about ordinary things around house or routine. Have a plant pot or garden so they can connect to something else. Read together. Watch tv together. Kids need communication! If they can't get it at school, try to give some of your time. I know that it's hard to do, especially when you work. But we have to go through this anyway...
You sound like such an amazing and caring parent, thank you :)
And a pet
And who says that you are qualified to give advice
?
Leandro seems to be a very empathic and intelligent boy. Keep it up man!
Thank you! :)
Wait he actually replied
I think
@@aname7295 Greetings from Berlin!
@@leandroburgdorff8332 Greetings from Canada!
The kid was more cool and fearless than others!!!!
I think You Know Abusive Language 👍 My Prediction😎😎 Never Wrong🔥🔥
⁰⁰
0
Wow, can't believe a student at that age has that insightful thoughts.
It's not unusual, don't think kids are stupid and hollow
@@sheet-musicWho said the kids are stupid or hollow? I am just amazed by that boy. Btw, not all kids at that age are the same as him.
@@LedermannYT not all people of my age is like me, but it doesn't equals my being exceptional
I found it quite impressive as well. Unfortunately, he is part of the system and will always be. I think he needs to build a career either working with his hands or with people. I hope that he can make some serious discoveries about himself and how he wants to spend his life.
I'm about to turn 44 and already asked myself that question.
My heart goes to Leandro and to the child his mother told in the story; not everyone can handle this situation the same way, no matter if they have all the resources to do it or nothing at all. This truly breaks my heart. Also, I wonder what would be the outcome for this generation: would they be more self-sufficient, and resolve problems easier due to be forced to learn by themselves at such young age? Will they be more cooperative or isolated when they grow up? What kind of jobs will they choose, the ones with a screen 24/7 or something more analog? Let's see what the future holds, but let's be ready to be there for them because most of us adults didn't had to do this at that age.
I think we’ll have a Lot More of Loners. It’s so sad that they are having to go through this. It’s hard enough for adults to understand.
That male kid with the dark hair, sounds an awful like me before I got my adhd diagnosis.
He's clearly smart and sounds like he's trying more than the rest of them he mentioned 9hours work, it's exhausting work trying to concentrate(if you don't have adhd you just can't understand truly what's it's like), Especially if there's a disconnect. He's doing Extremely well.
I thought the same when I read the infobox about his struggles at finding structute and organisation by himself
But it might also be demotivation or depression or different learning style
Who knows
@@ttttg5302 totally agree, it just sounded familiar to me, it's hard to know though given that I didn't go through a global pandemic at his age.
The truth is that everyone has the same problems. Do you think that everyone else has it easy to concentrate on the subjects you do not enjoy. You have bad attitude thats all.
@@Cortesevasive
If there is a diagnosis, most likely something is actually different and not just bad attitude, do you think you know more than the doctors who study this stuff?
@@Cortesevasive the Truth is you have no idea what you're talking about, I'm not saying people aren't misdiagnosed, but my adhd is fMRI confirmed, I work harder than you will ever know. Just because I don't do well in school doesn't mean I'm stupid or lazy, I'm an engineer now but I had to study and work Way longer to achieve my goals because I find class environments unworkable. It's not about doing boring work, if you don't have adhd then you can't know.
Online school is straight up exhausting dead lines every day and considering my school didn’t have an academic break it just exhausting
Good. You should learn to work. Go to a new cyber school if you are mad. Be glad that your parents are saving money with this.
Regular school has deadlines too and weekly tests. In university you have tests and deadlines too. Whole distance learning actually saves you tons of time as you dont have to walk anywhere, and you dont have to worry about pointless subjects, you save a couple hours per day minimum. I mean lets be honest, you have all the time in the world to do your task , you have the textbooks you can even rewatch the lessons, but you just dont do it because nobody is controlling you. With that attitude you wouldnt do well in regular school or uni as well.
This has always been the unknown tragedy of PhD and research students. Welcome to our world of lonely studying and countless days in front of a computer screen!
Wow, Germany actually has school councillors. In my country they just lie about their existence.
At my school they said the PE teacher is the counselor, but she was just the school gossiper 🙄.
😂
Worldwide problem my friend, worldwide
In India even teachers don't know about counsellors.
In my country there are counsellors (well at least in my school), I tried to reach them out for help because I feel too much pressure from online school and even my home environment, I started developing some signs of depression and isolated myself from others, and yet they don't take it seriously, they asked about my ranking (my grades are falling down, and the fact that I used to be a top student makes me stressed bc I can't do what used to be good at), and they asked what I want to do in the future instead, which made me even more sad and started blaming myself for everything. My counsellors (and sadly my family too) said that I'm too sensitive and weak, I feel so invalidated because nobody can really understand me, :'
The whole “You weren’t paying attention!” Is a poor excuse it’s laziness! When I was a kid I got told the same thing yes, there were times I didn’t pay attention but a lot of the time I genuinely didn’t not understand a lot of things.
@@CR-rm4iy the textbooks are crap and with no written explanations.
Very truely said..this is really crazy time for everyone..just busy urself in what u like to do and u will realise there is no fear and u will start enjoying ur life..
Kids need to learn that elementary school doesn't matter. I was pushed so much due to my controlling parents, non of that mattered.
They need to start learning on what's important in life, in their lives.
Trebalo je više da te pritiskaju.
good call, though doing given tasks and time planning and maths and nature sciences are really important, writing and languages as well, just the tests and the textbooks are lazy written
Definitely need more on this topic. My son has learning disabilities and online learning is pure hell for him.
Good. Stop having kids and there is easy solution. Defund physical schools
Well maybe he doesnt
This totally breaks my heart
Thank you for the video. I hope that these kids find peace and not feel so terrible about what is happening around them. they should realize that nothing is their fault at the end of the day.
Good documentary DW as always ❤
I'm persuing my master's in psychology and after completing my 1st year I'm not willing to take admission for 2nd year i already pushed my admission for 6 months but not sure how much more i had to it's boring and feels like useless to get degree in such a way
Still at my bachelor, but feel the same. I Wish I took a break from my studies, when it started, and worked full time, so I could just resume my studies when will be over. At least that way I would have gotten some experience in my field. Its not like I am learning anything right now.
@@Max-kh1cf i can understand lucky this in not my 1st degree it's my 3rd degree hence I'm bot that much worried and currently I'm working too hence I just paused my study as of now
This is very good and spot on. The boy, 14 years old is amazing and very intelligent.
I wanna thank DW for showing this documentary because we students are struggling in this pandemic. In the Philippines, all of us students have to do home schooling or online schooling bcz our government doesnt allow us to go out or we only have to go out only for essential purposes. It's kinda depressing we cannot see our friends in person or our teachers stuffing us lots of assigments and staring at a computer, phone, or tablet for so long. If u r depressed, u r not alone bcz we are all depressed in this pandemic and that includes me. This pandemic makes us all depressed, anxious, angry etc etc etc. Hopefully this pandemic will end and we can all go back to our normal lives like in 2019 or early 2020. A message from a student in the Philippines. STAY STRONG EVERYONE 👊.
I feel so much for our future. I'm a teacher in Toronto, Canada and I see the same concerns from my grade 8 students but unlike most teachers I do not have deadlines, instead I have conferences with my class about what would be "doable" for them. If teachers are giving such strict guidelines, they need a talking to. Have they forgotten what it was like to be a kid? This virus needs to take a back seat to our children's mental well-being.
You have the leeway to have "conferences." Others don't. Consider the fact that there is a cultural and legal framework in which German teachers operate and that they're obliged to use methodologies they might not be personally fond of if they want to keep their jobs. It should have been fairly obvious that this isn't a matter of one or two teachers being rigid and old-fashioned, but that they have a systemic problem. In my experience, the German approach to most things tends to be cautious, rather than experimental. Once they decide to implement something, they do it thoroughly and competently, but the process is not fast. During an unexpected crisis like this, the lack of "agility" unfortunately is a major drawback. It's not the teachers who should be chided for this, but their lawmakers and ministers who should be pushing for reforms.
@@miaum1976 There are school systems like this in Canada and the US as well but both countries lack a national school policy and state/provincial policy are often fairly open for local school districts to do what they want BUT funding, beyond local taxes, is often based standardized test scores.
11:16 Such a bright young gentleman, very much self aware and self expressive. 👏 I really wish that he won't have to suffer this anymore.
Kinda crybaby, I mean kids will find excuses not to do something and will say whatever convenient for them. He needs to learn timeplaning, while having distance learning he actually saves a couple hours per day for not having to walk there etc, he has the ability to rewatch the filmed lessons etc. but the kid is just lazy, and he must be told that he is that way, because if you support his idea that he is a victim he wont develop himself and his efficiency in studying
*After 10 or 15 years when Leandro becomes something he will watch back this video and wonder well this ishow lockdown and pandemic affected my life😳*
Woow that's tru
Same as my country..
Greeting from Sarawak,Malaysia..
Stay safe,god bless everyone..especially the poor and the suffering citizens....Amen
Looks like I am one of those rare students who felt that this academic year of mine was the best in my life. I really enjoyed it and home learning didn't affect my grades, in fact, in most years I was really unhappy and moody for most of the day but this year I was far more happy.
Anyone had a similar experience?
Me, cyberschool helped me a lot.
"Some of us will miss this way of studying". Someone once said.
wow who?
Thank you for informative video.
I noticed that attitude makes a difference and having supportive parents who communicate with you makes a huge difference with stress.
Hi @Claudio H, thanks for watching and sharing your thoughts on the topic.
Ich schätze deinen Kanal sehr. Bitte mach weiter so.Ihre Nachrichten schätze ich mehr als amerikanische Nachrichten.
Machen Sie weiter so mit Ihrer großartigen Arbeit, die zum Nachdenken anregt. Ich lerne gerade deine schöne Sprache Deutsch. Bitte entschuldigen Sie meine Grammer. ,🙏😊
Yo I graduated high school in 15 so I'm an old boi now but I feel really bad for the kids that had to do this. I have no idea how you get through school without the social aspect. If you're reading this: you made it. You made it through some of the darkest times history has ever seen. Be proud. Stay strong. 🤠👍❤
I feel validated, thanks
So sad to see that girl sliding into the mother / teacher role for her little brother. Her own needs taking a back seat. I wonder how many other young girls have "stepped up" like this during the pandemic and are praised for "being so helpful and responsible" instead of being allowed to just have their own childhoods.
I've had to help one of my relative to make sure they pay attention in class. I also have to help them with certain assignments they don't get done.
I feel like I have some very mild sadness because I have a hard time sleeping every night. Now, I consider falling asleep at 10:40 PM or 11:00 PM normal. I also feel like all I do everyday is just snap at everyone. I feel like I'm acting like a terrible person, and the words escape from my mouth before I even fully process what the best thing to say is. Before this, I never really considered 'mental health' as very important. I guess I've learned the truth the hard way.😐
@@amylau4086 I'm so sorry to hear that. I hope things go back to normal soon, for everyone's sake.
@@Peterbrendanalbert Learning responsibility means learning to make your own bed, or holding your little sister's hand as you cross the street. This isn't that. It's taking on the role of teacher, the role of mother, at a time when this girl should be in school herself, just being a kid. That is sad.
I don't know if it was sad when you did it. You say you "took responsibility" but that's too vague to really tell me anything about what you were doing. Were you sacrificing hours of your day - focus you could have been giving to your own education - to teach your younger siblings? Did you give up the little play time you had left to cook and clean for them? Were your responsibilities a burden that aged you before your time?
Because with schools closed and parents working, this is the situation that faced many kids over the last year. Particularly girls. And many people don't even see anything wrong with putting a young girl in this position, because in their eyes, it's her natural role and good practice for future motherhood. Her own potential, her own needs, take a back seat.
I was such a child, praised for how "mature" and "responsible" I was. And now, in adulthood, my family can't understand why I don't want children of my own. But why would I? Would a mother whose kids have finally left home after eighteen years want to start the cycle again with a newborn? Of course not. She's exhausted, and wants to figure out who she is beyond the role of mom. Well, this is exactly what my parents unwittingly created in me. I'm great with kids but I've been there, done that, and have no desire to do it again.
Kids are not mini-adults. Teaching and parenting are jobs adults choose, and in the case of teachers and childcare practitioners, are trained and paid to do. Kids aren't. Kids should have kid responsibilities, like "brush your teeth at night" and "do your homework".
Many of the kids in this documentary already spoke about how hard it was for them to meet deadlines and be in control of their own attention span during e-learning. In the school environment, a teacher would provide structure and help keep them on track. And it's clear they miss that. "Learning responsibility" in this case hasn't made these kids strong. It's been too much for them. They're stressed out and falling behind. And no wonder! There's a reason we don't just toss kids into a school building with a video playing on a laptop all day. There's a reason they don't just teach each other.
Adult supervision and support is key to creating healthy, happy kids.
@@Peterbrendanalbert I know learning to be responsible is a very important skill, but with me, it's not exactly that easy. I feel more unmotivated to do things, and I'm almost a hundred percent sure I have some very mild depression. I've noticed the signs in myself. Now, I get irritated by the slightest things, and I have breakdowns every once in a while. I get annoyed with my sibling so often that it feels like they do nothing at all. I do almost all their dishes, I have to keep them on task while they get upset for me checking on their screen, I have to help them with assignments they should've done *IN* *CLASS* even though they are old enough to do those things themselves. I get mad at them everyday, and I feel like I do things for them that they can do themselves. I NEVER considered mental health important until the pandemic, and I feel sad knowing that there are other kids who are suffering more than I am.
Bravo! Should expand more into this topic in the future docu!
That kid spitting truth like crazy I like it.
The boy at the end,his statement reminded me of sinor high school years just before facing real life and felt hopeless 😔
Keep going Leandro, we're with you!!!!
Thank you!
As an engineering graduate my entire final year got lost and even our final year project can't get done properly damn this covid
So beautiful , smart kids
What amazing kids!
This is a good documentary.
I understand your thoughts son. Don't bother about everything, just go on your own speed. When i was not successful in my school work , my mother always told me that failures are the pillars of success and slow and steady wins the race(btw education is a journey not a race ). In the meantime from my life experience i learned that our own health(both mental and physical) is the most important thing .
As a student , I can understand the boy. It is complicated to study at home , atmosphere at home is different and i also get short-sighted . I hope this lock-down will be ended in this year.
Thank u for sharing with us such kind of problems💓
I can relate so much to these children. My brother and I lived fending for ourselves every day because my mother, a single parent, had to go to work all day. We had to figure everything ourselves and be responsible of studying by ourselves. School was heaven to us. I can't image these children removing that important part of their lives. How do they get to understand society if they have been amputated from any social gathering. The problem is that it is not over, and we might need to extent this. How will these children and teenagers will be able to function in jobs if they did not get a chance to learn to live around others?
it's sad when I realize that as an adult I face the same issues as these kids.
I understand what this students go through learning online and at home is not always easy due to many reasons unlike physical classes where understanding and communication with the teachers are constant.
It's much the same in the US. I'm 17 and still in high school, and the workload is simply unmanageable. I'll be applying to universities soon and I don't know how I'll be able to keep up with schoolwork as well as my applications and all my other responsibilities when that comes, especially since many covid-related restrictions will still be in place next school year. My parents can't help me with my schoolwork because they don't really understand it, so I'm largely on my own to figure things out. It's incredibly frustrating and I wish the school system would acknowledge that and then take steps to make their policies less unreasonable, but they've been a brick wall this last year and some change - they're so stuck in their ways that I'm convinced they won't ever fix their problems.
The remarks at the last 2min are so touching. Like I am afraid to ask questions to my teacher. And his comment on being stuffed too much 😅 and being expected to 🤮 in an exam... It's sad.
In different classes I felt just the same and even at home. It feels so discrediting.
We are distanced from Mother nature and so much dissolved into artificiality that we started thinking that artificiality is the only world.
But remember if you wish to live; you have to be with ' Live ' and not dead artificiality.
You need to reconnect with nature to get rid of all this nonsense.
I personally think that kids nowadays are much more stress than i am when i was 14..i am so grateful that when i am in high school i can went through my teenage year with friends not at home sitting in front of a laptop..
you were at school for 6-8 hours remember? plus you had homework for like 2-4 hours? , the kids nowadays have it much easier, just they like to cry about it, but they dont study at all because nobody is regulating them from behind the screen and they are playing fortnite or i dont know watching youtube.
catherine and philip are very mature for their age....leandro is very sharp and mature too.....I wish my future kids could be like them
The pandemic has left us in soo much distress . I have been working from home for over a year now, I stay alone. My living room has turned into my office. My social interactions have been limited. All I do is work night and day, it's bad. UN should really sanction countries that are not upfront and forth coming with outburst of pandemics.
amazing
Das ist genau so auch bei uns.
goddamn that kid is still 14 and already aware of existential crisis. really ahead of his time and so relatable, amazing XD he's gonna have a bright future
with such a victim attitude he wont.
kids in war torn areas, kids with abusive parents, substance abuse parents, kids whose parents simply not making enough money to feed the family, those are the real 'kids in crisis'
I think that if I was at school now I would have preferred remote learning. I was bullied at school and my classmates distracted my learning. Thats all behind me for a long time. I understand that some pupils struggle with remote learning. Either because of problems at home and their struggle with remote schooling. This has advantages and disadvantages Amazing documentary. Teachers should help and its a shame that they choose not to.
Even before the pandemic, german schools are known for overwhelming the kids with too much homework and assigments. Now learning online, it became even easier for teachers and schools to give kids even More homework to do. There must be a balance, they are only kids, they need time to live and enjoy their childhood.
these guys are really studing, all i did during online classes was to watch netflix, i studied own my own. online classes are useless, most of the time
I'm an adult teacher, I teach chemistry in primary school for adults. It's near to impossible to teach them anything.
Many have difficult background, are just not so independent at learning, head trauma because of car accidents.
I really can't teach them much via video. Now we are able to have live class and it feels much better.
Here in Sri Lanka, my brother didn't able to visit school for almost two years now. And the thing is due to lack of internet infrastructure and electronic devices lots of people lagging behind. And they don't operate in normal school time because most kids using there parents laptop or mobile and because parents work in day time most of school schedule held on nigh. Other thing is electricity brake down, in my country electricity is very unreliable even he using a mobile device the internet connection get lost.
And my brother's grade getting low, day by day. He is not interested like before due to lack of competition. It's really a big problem right now. How much we try to make him focus in his studies, there are so many things here to make his distracted.
my niece is 4.5 year old has gotten a year and half old in these times. She has been attending online classes and she doesn't enjoy the class at all. Its boring and her learning and playing has taken a HUGE hit. Kids her age go to school to play with friends and have fun conversations about the cartoons they watch and what not. But due to this pandemic she is stuck at home. Till Delta variant things were still a bit okay, now she is completely stuck in home as her parents won't let her out cuz of the fear. I play with her all day long but I can tell she misses her friends and school. Whenever I inquire her answer is ... YESS!! I miss school & friends. They said it will open soon, now I don't know when will that happen." I have to distract her ASAP 'cuz I don't want her to feel totally sad. I hope things get better soon and she and all the kids around the world start playing and learning again. I hope their mental toll won't read to a highest that they become dependent on medicines at their age.
I really hope Leandro's parents listen to him more because what he's expressing is concerning. He's describing depression symptoms. I'm sure they are doing the best they can and hopefully he'll go back to school soon.
During face to face classes, it's the same thing with schoolwork and deadlines at least for those who can afford to pay for internet. It's just that you don't have anyone to talk to this time to study lessons and do homework with. I think it's a big factor on top of self discipline.
l like your documentary ,olso they are amazing and profetionals ,thanks you very mech for your videos
Hi @naon védio, thank you too for watching and commenting!
The pandemic started in my last year of highschool and I couldn't really get out of my house....even I had severe learning problems as a senior in highschool and with good facilities.... I can't even imagine kids younger than me who have to deal with this constantly.... not least poor kids who are the most disadvantaged
I wished this doc would last a little more, maybe just 10 minutes more ! the topic is so interesting. u should give kids more time..... I really wonder if they need anything else than attention....at least it's their first and biggest need.
not just the students, but THE TEACHERS are exhausted as well
Well this is how it looks like in a very developed country, imagine being in a non developed country and trying to learn things online
This is so sad and so true! My son is 7th grader and stitting on the computer 9-10hrs a day to do school work and still behind...He pulled his front hair out when he is stressed.
Well stop having kids. Easy solution. The physical schools have worse problems with no solutions.
so he is left with 6-7 hours of free time, whats the problem?
Teenagers should not endure such stress like this...
I feel sad for these children especially because lost time at this age is much more critical than for older people. Six months for a primary pupil can feel like eons.
The old school pattern was also fraught with its problems but is the only solution to isolate pupils at home with a machine.
There are other solutions like community hubs, library gatherings, anything to restore human contact and the secret factor of good teaching and learning which comes from the heart.
Children feel if someone cares because there is time and effort involved.
4:08
Very cute girl. God bless you and bless the steps you take in the years ahead of you.
I keep telling myself that if I win a big jackpot someday I am going to start a better school that will make children of the future ready for anything. No one likes to be stuffed with facts that hv no use cases in real life. Please pray for my dream to come true
It's a real crisis for students in the poor countries now we must change our education strategy
amazing video showed my beautiful students this video ;)
Picture this, in Colombia most kids don't have access to electronic devices or internet, they do what we call "radio validation" basically they have to hear the radio to take their lessons (this happens the most in rural areas), 45% of the country lives in poverty and as a Colombian student, this kids have everything to take proper online lessons. I'm supposed to be part of the "privileged middle class" but the internet sucks, teachers aren't enough qualified to work in virtual environments so we do, we don't have much reliable information since books are expensive, I have to ask for pictures of textbooks, and you know, my parents barely earn enough to survive due to all the employment crisis, thanks God they stayed at their jobs , libraries, were I used to take tons of references for are closed, an the social, political and health crisis are making this unlivable. I can't be ungrateful, because as I mentioned before, my situation isn't as hard as it's been al this year for some people but I'm a truly believer the unique way to progress as a human and asa nation is through education, something politicians know and they are not going to give to keep the community silent.
I question my existence as a 14 year old wow at this point it’s cruel to keep kids inside
most of the kids play on pc anyway
Seriously... Working on computer for long hours make us more tired.. I m too suffering
@N Fairchid how to do sir?
I felt so sorry for the 14 year old kid. He needs help
he is lazy like we all, he needs some belt
Man, I couldn't wait for the bell to ring and get out.
I agree with this video
More topics on children pls
Modern Education System needs Creativity , it should be based upon Real Life Skills !
8:10 slapping that bass! Sounds like Red Hot Chili Peppers
Cute kids. Learning 🌹☮️🌟🕊️😇
Online schooling might be good for some kids, and might be bad for some of them, because every family situation are different
It is like homeschooling, except its instruction from a teacher and not the parent. So you get the advantage of fewer distractions, and traveling, and you can also go to sleep early and wake up late. No having to deal with stupid stuff on the way to school or at school. I can excersise whenever I want too!
we are 3 siblings , one my brother in my class , little sister and 3 classes happen at same time in a small house , we found it very difficult to study because voice s mixed moreover dads also works at home , its been also like this here in Saudi Arabia for about a 15 months since our normal classes
then what? any solution or advise for the parents and for the kids?
I thought only India is suffering. But it's all over the world. I truly liked the 12-grade student, cause I'm almost similar to her, classroom sometimes distracts me.
I'm in my first year of college, With only a worn out phone, a simple laptop and a turtle like internet speed in the Philippines, but still, I want to continue. I don't know If I am learning or not.
I had the same situation studying in Colombia and I got my degree done in April 2021. I hope you can go through this situation. Best regards👍
Thank You so much, I wish the best for all of us.