People married when they were in their teens then, and tried to procreate immediately. So if they lived to late 60s (granted that was long life then), and since they had big families, 4 generations would not be that strange.
@@ssli1298 Of course it was diffiicult, that is why they made it to be such a big deal both in this movie and 瘋婦. As for your porbability, you failed to take into account of multiple offsprings and multiple wives.
@@ssli1298 Let me just give my first hand experience. My grandfather died young, so he only saw three generations. My grandmother was his concubine and had one son. My father had three sons. Only my second brother had children and both were daughters. After his first daughter was born, my grandmother lived for another 20 plus years. If my oldest brother had children (and I), chance of her seeing 3 generations of male would be very good, although my grandfather would not.
I wish they had developed the brother's story more. His was easily the more interesting story. To be asked by parents to commit a crime that would mean execution (yes, back in those days, lots of crimes were punished by death), and to go because is filial duty, and then to be caught and died. That was powerful.
You probably be too young to know how to appreciate this type of movie, these movie are classic movies which reflects the problems of that generation! They are not stupid movies!
黃曼梨的演技真是登峰造極！與白燕的對手戲感人至深，每每看起都會忍不住落淚
現今世代一定拍不出這種好戲，每-位演員都是頂級的。百看不厭，服裝十分適合朝代。
這個年代沒有人懂得欣賞這類電影的了!
@@mariawong6965😅
呢部肯定係經典作品，網上甚少上載，扁姨，活游叔，全是重量級人馬，謝謝分享！🙏🙏
好人一生平安快樂。❤❤❤
雖然此劇年代已甚久遠, 唯劇情內容很好看, 特別是每一位演員自然流露的演技, 很高的専業水準, 讚!!
白燕真的美，演技又好，其他個個都演得出色！
好好看❤
70年前的天水圉真的山明水秀，人稀地大，抬橋還見到坑尾村~真的歷史風貌~
非常好百看不厭
白燕好靚呀！❤🎉 🥰😍🤩😘
石堅叔做得好好，呢套好睇👍
白燕真美😍
不論演員、導演都非常出色👍👍👍👍👍😘😘😘😘期待再有下套🥳🥳🥳
經典電影經典
演員💯💯💯
好慘又好看的舊电影，就多出白燕，張活游，張英，梅椅，吳楚帆，紫羅蓮的电影，謝謝！！😊
好好睇 感謝分享影片❤
舊社會重男輕女的觀念很大的剂禍害現代社會相反都愛生女兒😂❤
有五個女兒好過有十個兒子。
今時今日都仲有好多父母重男輕女！
其實， 自八十年代以還，「重男輕女」這社會現象是漸漸淡化了；皆因教育普及造就了男女平權。
女子多受教育便可以經濟獨立， 何須仰男子鼻息？ 說白了， 「重男輕女」只是封建社會衍生的文化意識而已！
沒有錯，還有這種重男輕女的整個家庭，即使在北美的華人家庭人人存在。黑人與印度民族一樣是重男輕女的民族。
兒時不太明白此片到現在觀看又與1964年“瘋婦”相同是封建思想對婦女迫害的悲劇，但後者片的老太爺在結尾時有所覺悟。盧敦叔演這類電影十分到家且他在1982年參演電視劇“家春秋”。此片中的三姑娘是當年新人馮奕薇在十多年前電台訪問她說曾參與工展小姐選舉而入影圈後結婚便息影移民。當中片頭的古塔應該是現今仍屹立於天水圍天耀邨附近的聚星樓，難得可看見當年塔旁的柳樹和漁塘及村屋。很希望片主能上載“狂人塔”上下集。
很多謝你的資料!
當年的馮奕薇年輕又漂亮!!!
幾拾年細紀，又講到天水圍，華達片場，係大墈邨，而家冇左幾耐，不過以前老戲骨，個個自然好戲，白燕又靚。
黃金组合，百看不厭
封建時代的人真可憐自己把自己的自由幸福困死在那些無用和無理的家一.家規裏有點作繭自縛害人害己和無很慶幸自己能出生在這個年代和有開明疼愛的父母和哥哥呀感謝主耶穌基督和上帝安排❤❤
"作繭自縛"! "感謝主耶穌基督和上帝安排" -這是另一種 "作繭自縛"形式嗎? 宗教 , 家規不是問題，問題在於人們如何選擇實踐. "Fundamentalism" 原教旨主義以及對不符合自己所選擇的信仰和行為方式的事物的拒絕導致了許多粵語電影中所描述的悲劇。多少人類悲劇是以宗教的名義引發的? 歷史總是重演，因為人類的本能與人性.
過這個女婿真辛苦走來走去那孕婦心理壓力很大因為定要生男孩子呀！人都是貪心的想要有兒子有了兒就想要男孩子希望天從人願就皆大歡喜😊❤
塔的位置～今天的天水圍！
以前去到天水圍拍，真係太遠啦，估計拍幾日。
@@waileunglip4779
俾你認到！好嘢！
係依家青衣影去荃灣九咪半一帶！
历久以来，陈旧的封建思想，重男轻女的观念，弄垮了所有愚蠢的人们。
张活游正气禀然，白燕瑞莊娴淑，非常登对。值得一看再看的好电影。
感謝你對我們的支持！我們會繼續努力，上載更多精彩節目，記得要把影片分享給親朋好友喔！
張活游當年45歲都算靚佬。
這是白燕張活游自組的山聯公司第二部作品，秉承中聯的一貫宗旨，無情揭露舊時重男輕女的迂腐思想。要四代男丁同堂，有啲似中四重彩，有啲難度。
People married when they were in their teens then, and tried to procreate immediately. So if they lived to late 60s (granted that was long life then), and since they had big families, 4 generations would not be that strange.
@@dadama925 男子要16歲才能生育，假設16歲就結婚，17歲生男丁，之後三代都生男丁，老人家都已經17x3=51歲了，但中間有1/2機會生女，則三代都生男丁的機會率祇有1/2x1/2x1/2=1/8，這時老人家已差不多60歲了，以前人的壽命短，因此四代男丁同堂是有難度。
@@ssli1298 Of course it was diffiicult, that is why they made it to be such a big deal both in this movie and 瘋婦. As for your porbability, you failed to take into account of multiple offsprings and multiple wives.
@@dadama925 你說的也有道理，多生幾個男丁機會率會高咗，但一年祇能生一個，中途生女丁又冇用，因嫁人後變外姓，這樣老人家又老了幾年。多娶幾個妾侍也是辦法，但總不能一年同時娶幾個吧，如果一年娶一個，則老人家又老了幾年，他有沒有這麼長壽看到第四代？說到底要四代男丁同堂確實有難度，可能做戲咁做，舊時都未必有。
@@ssli1298 Let me just give my first hand experience. My grandfather died young, so he only saw three generations. My grandmother was his concubine and had one son. My father had three sons. Only my second brother had children and both were daughters. After his first daughter was born, my grandmother lived for another 20 plus years. If my oldest brother had children (and I), chance of her seeing 3 generations of male would be very good, although my grandfather would not.
黃曼梨其實都好後生㗎，唔知點解佢成日做老角呢？❤🎉😂😅
這就是她的長處，無人可代!!!
黃曼梨真係有啲顛, 完全失控嚇𠒇死人! 人地普通問句佢老公幾好嗎, 佢就長篇大論話成日去妾士度, 求其講句門面”幾好, 你有心”都唔識
做戯嘛，你咁認真😂
重男輕女的習俗，搞到而家男多女少，多人做王老五，生仔係蝕本貨哩！❤🎉😂😅
😂😅😊!!!
片頭地點是今日天水圍之聚星樓! 當時旅行，在此地和農家漁戶買雞和魚，就地取材煮食。
多謝資料!!!
堅叔唔止功夫好，拍文藝片一樣掂，繼《天長地久》後，又一部出色之作，馮亦薇小姐，再次睇佢嘅影片，演技不差。
這個老太爺才是應該早死的一個，為了自己的所謂 "四代同堂" 不顧孫媳婦的死活，還強逼孫兒纳妾; 他的兒子死了，他沒有流露半點傷心，仍然只顧著那"四代同堂" 的思想!!!
片頭是否天水圍西鐵站旁的聚星樓？
👍👍👍🙏
I wish they had developed the brother's story more. His was easily the more interesting story. To be asked by parents to commit a crime that would mean execution (yes, back in those days, lots of crimes were punished by death), and to go because is filial duty, and then to be caught and died. That was powerful.
"were punishable by death", not "punished by death". Please check your English grammar.
👏👏👏🌹🌹🌹👍🤗
Note the similarities between this movie and 瘋婦.
其實瘋女人是瘋婦！❤🎉😢
可惡的四代同堂！
Ms white swallow is a classic beauty 🤩🤩🤩
做古代嘅女人真係好淒涼， 生唔到仔更加惨。
此片演员表何其简单，只侧重于六位主角，负责监制与参订的男女主角也未免太粗心了吧。
对呀，漠视其他演员对影片的贡献。
病等這樣嚴重還要舟車勞頓的是為什麼呢！就是因為做戲
Sick , sick , sick , no more happiness .
I hate this move , it makes people's too much worry .
Cryind Crying crying 😢 😭 all the times
Stupid move .
You probably be too young to know how to appreciate this type of movie,
these movie are classic movies which reflects the problems of that generation! They are not stupid movies!
Don’t watch if you think it is stupid
Hi Maria … Your words like one of my well educated aunt in US …. Thank you !
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤