@@BringMeTheProofdid we see the same debate or not?!! The muslim lantern showed how ignorant and deceiving Dyer is!! The goal from the start was to show how the likes of him do not listen, keep interrupting, mix up words (attribute doesn't equal person), act like he knows about muslim sects and what they actually argue about without actually reading one book about one scholar from them, never answer the fact of knowledge limitation of Jesus in contrast to the Father... I mean he went full retard there!!
@@abdmahi7449 Nope. By having the Muslim Lampshade admit he didn't know what aqeedah were, making him compare his Meccan deity to a Tshirt, and busting him for misrepresenting the responses to his inane questions.
Because Atheist always have the same BS argument. They are too arrogant to believe in God, they will latch onto anyone person's belief (Richard Dawkin) and worship them instead of worshipping God.
@@BringMeTheProof Do you mean the guy who is so obsessed with Arabs ..🍆? And the other one who admitted that Jesus and Father are not equal , and Jesus submitted to God Yes I watch the debate W The Muslim Lantern 😁
I agree with everything you said, but one thing I need to tell you from an islamic point of view. We don't say we are part of god. We would rather say we are the creation of God because we weren't at any time a physical part of God like you gave the example with your skin. Allah say be, and it is. Anything he wants to bring to existence from nothing, he just say to it be and it comes into existence. He is THE Creator. How exactly does this work ? As humans and with our limited comprehension, we can't imagine it, so we accept what Allah tells us about himself in the Quran without going too deep into the matter. Love your videos guys, keep going :)
Exactly Also how can we be "a part of God" when we literally can sin, and do the most horrible things, while God is perfect We r creations, just like angles, animals and Jinns We may be special from other creations, but we r still a creation
Amazing explanation!!! I just brushed it off because he hasn’t look in to the deen as much therefore he holds that opinion but thank you for saying exactly what I wanted to say and hopefully they see this. May Allah reward you and peace be upon you.
Atheist : all religions are man's made,. Muslim : you know islam? Atheist : no. Muslim : you read the quran? Atheist : no. Muslim : you need a free copy? Atheist : no, I don't need it. 😂😂😂
I'm not an atheist, but I've studied Quran and it is in no way from God. The only miracle about that book is that people actually still believe that it is.
@@QuranDBunkedpreservation proving it was indeed recited 1400 Years ago along with the prophecy’s that have come true after the time prove it’s from Allah, no other scripture has been preserved except the Qur an & it is recited in a way that is a melody that rhymes along with showing moral values, stories showing it is the direct words of Allah Verbatim. Tor ah Jews have today does not claim to be the “words of the creator” but scripts from people who they believe are inspired by God which is quite silly & Bible is the same, they are not preserved and have zero evidence to back that up unlike the Qur an the final revelation
@@sactownizzy9312 Go into the real world of academia and tell them your method of preservation is memorization and you will be laughed out of the building. You have 37 Arabic Quran with thousands of variants and multiple qira'at. Your scholars don't even know what ahruf are and you have no complete Uthmanic Quran from the 7th century. That's why Yasir Qadhi said the "Islamic narrative has serious holes in it" and he's a Muslim. Which one of those is al-Lah's original Quran? Next!
@@QuranDBunked not just memorization, but writings, scribes & even having qur ans today that are carbon dated to the lifetime to the prophet SAW, answer yourself this question, why would the prophet claim the angel Gabriel who’s nickname is literally the Holy Spirit come to him with the creator and have him claim things that Christians say the opposite of, like God never sleeps, Christian’s think god rests, or saying David had a loyal soldier killed just to sleep with his wife, the qur an says that did not happen, or saying Moses never made idols for the children of Israel to worship, qur an also says that’s false, or saying Noah build the arc while drinking alcohol, Qur an says he never had alcohol or desired to drink it, but Christians believe these fallacy’s even when the text is not preserved and written by people who wanted to own slaves and make money, Qur an is the only truth, study it with an open heart and see that stuff like Solomon also never worshiped idols and it’s idiotic to think so.
@@sactownizzy9312 Great. So where is the original Uthmanic manuscript from the 7th century? What are ahruf that your prophet said the Quran were revealed in? Why are there 37 Arabic Qurans? You just keep regurgitating Islamic doctrine that comes from hadith written 200 years after the events by an Uzbek hundreds of miles away. You cannot answer any of those questions.
Amin, it is a journey the key is sincerity: establish if God exist then if so does he send message and if so follow it, rather than speaking about her taste "I don't think we need praying etc.." he was trying to establish the truth with her, not about her taste, our taste and feeling is irrelevant to establish the truth. many confuses taste with the truth, following desire of the immediate, while ignoring the serious consequence of the next eternal life. No other chance to correct belief. Now is the time.
@@sutil5078that's true, brother. we just want the best for them, ..but it's their choise ofcourse. Repeating the true message is the best that we can do. Greetings from Belgium🇧🇪
@@revertedrf978what a ridiculous comment she doesn’t even believe in a God & you labelled her shia 😵💫 she’s an atheist you’l find many Iranians who were happy with Shahs rulings & against the islamic revolution in Iran because they do not want to live by Islamic rules
Creator and creation is not the same. We live and die Bc of Him. God on the other hand is self-sustaining, undependable, ever-living, no fatigue or sleep touches Him. This is why he is Ahad (One and Undevisable). He is in control and supervises All things, not a leaf falls without His knowledge.
We are not part of Allah because he doesn't need us but we need him, Allah always existed but we're not, We can't say Allah is this and that with our limited knowledge but he's the only one can tell about himself and he's all knowing and we're not. this is logic You guys should react to brother shamsi videos from DUS dawah channel who explains islam very well with proofs and logic
With all due respect to you Han. I have to disagree with you there. We're not apart of Allah. 12:51 We're his creation. If you make soup or build a staircase that don't make them part of you right? Allah said in the Quran 42:11 [He is] Creator of the heavens and the earth. He has made for you from yourselves, mates, and among the cattle, mates; He multiplies you thereby. There is nothing like unto Him, and He is the Hearing, the Seeing."
Allah says BE and it is there! Allah doesn’t need to take apart of him to create something. I’m surprised Han believes that God needs something in order to create something. That makes God limited
My skin is not me, when it's stuck to me it's part of me, when it's peeled off it's no longer a part of me. So, this example is kind of weird to give to God. From an Islamic point of view, Allah creates out of his will, not by transforming or separating parts of him. You should think about like you are making a chair or a table, you gather he necessary materials, assemble them in a certain way and there you have your product. Now, the chair is not you, not is it a part of you, it's your creation ! Using the same principle, Allah creates out of his will, he commands things into existence as said in the Quran 36:82
The moment you say you are part of God, you have in effect attached a concept to God that makes sense to you. The reason we as Muslims don't subscribe to this concept is because Allah SWT explicitly states there is no example, or likeness of him. This means that the moment you have captured any attributes about him that he doesn't state about himself, you have in effect made your own version of an 'understandable' god. May Allah SWT guide you both. Ameen.
I guess you already know that God is separate from his creation. You have been told that many times here by me and other brothers and sisters. This one point is very fundamental to Islam.
@@mohammaddoofesh4963 My boy still giving dawaganda. What happened to the contradiction in Quran regarding how many angels visited Mary in Surah 3 and 19?
@@umairmukhtar6702 Sure. Your akhi has no answer. How many angels visited Mary when it was announced she was going to give birth to the Messiah. 1 angel or many?
@@BringMeTheProof so i looked those verses, below is my understanding in simple words: there are many angels and one step higher from them is Gabriel. When Gabriel came down on earth to bring message from god many angels accompanied him. So surah 3 verse 42 is talking about all those angels. Surah 19 verse 17 is specifically talking about Gabriel what he said to Mary(PHUH). I don’t believe there is any contradiction.
WITH RESPECT: Sometimes we make a quick conclusion when thinking about a main topic, and our conclusion on a subtopic may have been off the line of truth just a little because the secondary topic was not really cooked, and a wrong conclusion may have occurred! I think, this is what had happened here on saying we are gods or part of god etc.! So as many are pointing out ... according to God Allah, the Most High and cannot have other gods or parts like us humans associated with Him as being part of ... THAT, in fact, is the greatest, unforgivable sin in Islam, and it is called "Shirk" (associating anything with Allah; and this is mentioned in The Quran (and The Bible as well!) RESPECT and APPRECIATION TO YOU BOTH AND YOUR HELPERS if any. YOU ARE DOING A GREAT SERVICE.
respect to all the Muslims explaining this. I don't subscribe to them anymore because I realized they don't bother reading the actual Quran themselves, esp not with tafseer which is important to clarify, or Seerah, or anything. if they do read the Holy Quran they would probably only do it in front of the camera, which to me is making a sport and entertainment of something that is a very private, important, serious matter that is between you and God, and should be done with zero ulterior motives if you're sincere.
We r not a part of God!! This concept doesn't make sense if u think about it I mean i don't see any reason to support such a claim God is perfect, we r not God always existed, we didn't God is nothing like us and doesn't look like us, bcz we r just a creation, he is the creator God is God, humans r just a creation, just like angles, animals and Jinns r I feel like claiming we r from God is a very arrogant claim no h8 to u But who r we to say such a thing
@AfridiZindabad Ik, but it doesn't make any sense, and ppl just started making it up, it wasn't even a part of Christianity few hundred years ago So this is just some weird belief
Hello guys hope all is well. Your relationship is inspiring and the way you both are on this journey together fully supporting each other and searching for the truth is special. May God bless us all and guide us all. PEACE AND LOVE Brother and Sister.
People tend to ponder upon life and their existence during times of hardship If hardship comes to you, it’s Allah calling you to recognise Him and for you to ask Him for His help
"God can do anything," particularly focusing on logical contradiction 1. **Can God create a rock so heavy that He cannot lift it?** (This paradox addresses the contradiction of an omnipotent being creating something it cannot control.) 2. **Can God make a square circle?** (This question tests the limits of logical coherence, as a square circle is a logical impossibility.) 3. **Can God create a number greater than all numbers?** (This question highlights the contradiction inherent in the concept of an "absolute maximum" number.) 4. **Can God make 2 + 2 equal 5?** (This addresses the idea of altering basic mathematical truths, which are logically consistent and unchangeable.) 5. **Can God create a situation where He is not omnipotent?** (This challenges the coherence of omnipotence by questioning if it can include self-contradiction.) 6. **Can God make Himself cease to exist?** (This tests the paradox of omnipotence versus necessary existence, as ceasing to exist would contradict the nature of an omnipotent being.) 7. **Can God perform an action that contradicts His own nature, such as lying or being unjust?** (This question explores whether omnipotence includes the power to act in ways that violate divine attributes.) 8. **Can God create a contradiction?** (This question tests whether omnipotence extends to creating logical contradictions, which are inherently impossible.) 9. **Can God alter the fundamental laws of logic, such as the law of non-contradiction?** (This question examines if omnipotence can extend to changing logical principles that are essential to coherent thought.) 10. **Can God make Himself less powerful?** (This question explores whether an omnipotent being can diminish its own power, which seems contradictory to the nature of omnipotence.)
If God has parts he is no longer God. God is absolute, One, has unlimited attributes, self sufficient, no gender.. , nothing like Him. doesnt need anything but everything is in need of Him. Us being part of God is illogical tbh , there is nothing divine about humans. N the universe is created, therefore the One who created it is not the universe and everything within. At end of the day where do you get this idea from? Does God spoke to you ? Sent you scripture ? If not. Why not check mohamed (pbuh) s claim ? either he is a liar. Or he is telling the truth. And if you find that he is telling the truth. Then believe in what God tells you about Him in the Quran. Better than speculating.
Han! We are not parts of God. stop saying that word. Don't tell me, can a game character in a computer game be part of the engineer who wrote the codes of the game? How ridiculous this idea is. Your statement that we are parts of your god is just as ridiculous. illogical. This perspective within you comes from Christianity.
Muslim: “So, you don’t believe in God?” Atheists: “No.” Muslim: “How about the creator?” Atheists: “No.” Muslim: “Ok, then what do you believe in?” Atheists: “Higher power that is unknown to us”. Muslim: “Then you believe in God.” Atheists: “No, we don’t!” Muslim: “I’m sorry, but just for your information, in Islamic faith, God is also a higher power that cannot be imagined.” Atheists: “You’re delusional”. Muslim: “And you’re just confused by linguistics and terminologies.” Atheists: “I just consider myself as a learner who is still looking for the truth, and I question everything.” Muslim: “Ok, so here’s a Qur’an for you to study.” Atheists: “No, thank you.” What? 😂
لا اله الا الله سبحانه وتعالى عما يصفون واتوب اليه واسبحه واحمده واكبره واعبده واسغفره ولا حول ولا قوة الا بالله العلي العظيم واسجد له ليلا ونهارا ولا اله الا الله وحده لا شريك له له الملك وله الحمد وهو على كل شيء قدير ومحمد عبده ورسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم لا اله الا الله سبحانه وتعالى عما يصفون واتوب اليه واسبحه واحمده
Just because we originate from God does not mean we are a part of him as we know God can expend power without losing power as he is boundless and infinite so he never gives up a part of himself and is completely disassociated from his creation and this also stems from the idea that God create something out of nothing requiring no materials or part of himself to create and this is the extent of his power hope this explanation helped guys if you like this comment so they could see it I'd appreciate it
These guys started as ‘Christian couple’ now they’re ‘aetheist couple.’ Other week they talking about shahada now they selling books on spirituality and seeking donations. May Allah guide them but they not getting my ‘donation.’ Getting paid to be interested in Islam doesn’t sit right with me. Plus every episode this brother keeps saying gods inside him and part of him even though Muslim brothers and sisters keep correcting him. Beginning to think he’s just just here to sell his meditation books. Islam already gives us meditation and more for free
Why are so many Muslims so naive? Stop giving views to these individuals!! The current state of the ummah is so weak because so many Muslims are being so easily manipulated and are not sticking to Islam and each other. JUST STOP!!!! Watch our brother Muslim Lantern and not any of these individuals!!!
The first thing to know God is, the Creator, all we can see and imagine is creation, so never equate God with His creation. May we all get guidance and salvation in the hereafter, aamiin 🙏
🔖I agree Han: people are scared of the idea of "God" because it implies compliance , doing works in this life, but if this length of this life is literally a millimeter, less than mustered seed length compared to billion and billion of miles (actually eternity) then the task of worshiping in this mustard seed's length of life is literally nothing, trading this short life for eternity without a second chance is not intelligent, it deserves lengthy reflection at least. the eternity is real either in good shape or not that good shape..
MILLIONS OF PPLS THERE, THAT CONCIOULY TRYING TO BELIEVE THAT THERE'S NO GOD(even though they know thereso many miracles & rational facts)😪 cuz, they r afraid, if there's a god, then, they have have to follow a religion. & if they believe in a religion, they won't be able to do many immoral things, which is not allowed in religions😪
Lets see if this comment get removed again or not; To our muslim friends, Hans has been repeatedly saying "we are part of God" is his way preaching Christianity, intentionally or not. Someone who said they cant look Christianity the same way again but still using it as their belief. Im fine if he want to use other religion's belief beside Islam or Christianity coz one he doesn't believe in it and the other he's cant look at it the same way. Be careful my friend. I hope this couple will find the truth if they truly sincere.
That logic of everything come from something must be same is proved to be fallacy scientifically. for an example as a human i make a chair with help of raw materials, my knowledge, language and etc but that doesn't that chair is a human. quran supports this claim by "THERE IS NOTHING ALIKE HIM" you can beleive whatever you want but just saying. we may have attributes of god but it's in a very less proportionate and god has it perfect.
Exactly!!! Also we r a creation, that's the entire meaning of being created We didn't exist before, bcz we were created, didn't exist before that at all, that's literally what a creation stands for
Hi bro, i heard a lot of time from you, that we (human) are part of God, totally wrong and against Islam and basic concept of Creator and Creation, we are creation, cannot be a part of Creator. you need to re-think and think deep, btw, if you die, does the part of God also die? Just think, Allah is on His throne, not every where and not fully or partially in any thing, yes His power, His mercy , His control , His attributes are every where, not Himself. Hope you will understand, no offence
Allah (SwT) exists, He is The Most High, over the mighty throne, He is not part of his creation, Neither we are part of him, He is The only True God, worthy of worship, But if you and your wife insist that we are part of Allah and you die on this belief you will not succeed. Protect yourselves from a fire whose fuel is people and stones.
I understand the concerns being raised about Han's statement, "we are part of God." However, after hearing Han's explanation that there was only God initially, and then He created everything else, I believe Han meant to convey that we originate from God. This is similar to the phrase "Innaa lillaa wa innaa ilayhi raaji'oon," which means "We belong to God, and to Him we return." It seems Han's choice of words was not appropriate, and he may not fully grasp the gravity of such a statement. God has godly attributes, like all Powerful, whereas we human do not. May Allah guide us all.
It's so sad when you see some people close their eyes and lock their brains and hearts to the truth when it's very clear to them. Seriously, what are you going to say to God when He ask you in the day of judgment about the truth that came to you and rejected them?
"Anything created by god has to be god. Come on bro thats illogical. That's like saying the architect IS the building. The baker IS the bread, or a mother is literally her son. We are a creation of god. Therefore, by definition, can't be god.
Simple proof. When we are in the most desperate or dangerous situation, whom we pray or asking for help from? Jesus? Trinity? Idols? No. We pray from GOD.
I don't mean to hate or anything but sometimes you will title your videos as "Christians react" and now it's "Athiest couple react". I could be very wrong but I don't you guys are consistent in your beliefs...
it doesn't say atheist couple react.. it says the atheist couple challenge A MUSLIM lantern (i.e. the couple in the video that these two are reacting to)
@@AfridiZindabad @AfridiZindabad The couple who are challenging are challenging the Muslim lantern. They are reacting to a couple challenging the Muslim lantern. The couple is not them but the couple who are challenging the Muslim lantern. It's pretty obvious but hey, maybe you didn't watch the video.
that film is terrible. there was a time when (better) Muslims, in a time before us, used to disqualify anything if it even slightly changed the words of Rasulullah SAW or Quran. THE MESSAGE FILM DOES BOTH AND IT MAKES UP ENTIRE SCENES THAT ARE TOTALLY DIFF FROM THE ACTUAL INCIDENTS (e.g. the scene showing Hamza RA's conversion -- completely made up -- the actual incident, you are welcome to read about) -- it's a terrible film and i despise any muslim that recommends it because obviously they do not value basic honesty and would be immediately disqualified as reliable people, by the standards of prior Muslims
We are not PART of God. We are the CREATION of God. Just like a maker of cars. Cars are not part of the maker. They are just maker's creation. Also, God is not energy. Energy is one of His creations. Energy is just some kind of force that cannot do anything but that force. We have lots of forces in the universe. And We can manipulate these forces in some extent.
The only thing I don’t agree with as a muslim is that “we are part of God”. We are creation of God, like when you create like a chair, the chair is not a part of you, and being part of Him would mean that God took something from Him, and taking something from Him makes Him no longer God. And He says in the Quran “there is nothing like onto Him” and that He is not in our world. Beside this, you have a belief of a Muslim
i really like Kelly's point about curiousity will lead us to where we need to go, but the idea that we are part of God is a delusion. God is Exalted above ALL that we associate with God (including ourselves) as the Quran clearly says, and basic logic would say too.
To these kind of people i wanna say:"My dear, do you really think you gonna live forever? One day you'll die and meet your Lord. The fact that you are saying: "Maybe there is a higher power....." How ppl can be that much stupid and arrogant 🤷🏻♀️?
Is the creation part of the creator? Take worldly matters where mankind creates so for example, is the iphone part of its Creator? Logic and common sense is the key. After seeing so many videos on islam this cane as a surprise when I heard it. May Allah Guide. Aameen!
Dear Han, in Islam, we say; Allah says BE and it IS. He is the ONE who can do something from nothing, and he doesn't need to take something from himself to create something else. And that idea of part of God contradicts with the ONENESS of the only one true God and his might and majesty, because by saying we are parts of God means that God NEEDS something to do something else. Indeed Allah is All powerful and All mighty. Yes, we ARE his creations, and to him, we will return. And we ARE connected with Allah, which is an innate thing that many people try to ignore. And that connection can get stronger the more we pray that way, which HE, the most Beautiful, wants. Ma'as-Salam.
Quran Surah Al-Ikhlas (112) In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful. Say: He is Allah, the One and Only; Allah, the Eternal, Absolute; He begetteth not, nor is He begotten; And there is none like unto Him.
Han, ive enjoyed watching your learning about religion especially the Islamic videos... with all due love and respect... please ponder over your thats that "we are a part of God"... i have pondered over the implications of this when i heard you say it.. as a muslim this is not something we belive however i still thought of it logically.... If we are parts of God that would make God Tangeable and would give him limitation... if he keeps creating and using up parts of him then that implies that he has an ending, if was to keep creating would he run out? if each time he creates he creats from himself then that would mean ther may be a time when he runs out of matter... Allah swt is above our logic and reasoning if he wants wants to do something he just says "Be" and it is... we live in a world thats transfer of matter, God is above his creation and isnt bound by it. Its great to ponder over Allah and how great he is 😊
So you made a big jump you said your logic is the same as his in terms of coming from God therefore meaning being a part of God. That’s not what he said at all. He said we come from God not apart of God. Coming from God doesn’t necessitate being a part of him logically. In fact it’s opposite we are finite god is eternal. So we can’t be a part of him in any way by definition.
Muslim Lantern 🌟
These two are Satanists, don't suuport them.
@@realt1984 Crushed in 1 hour debate with Dyer. 😂
@@BringMeTheProofdid we see the same debate or not?!! The muslim lantern showed how ignorant and deceiving Dyer is!! The goal from the start was to show how the likes of him do not listen, keep interrupting, mix up words (attribute doesn't equal person), act like he knows about muslim sects and what they actually argue about without actually reading one book about one scholar from them, never answer the fact of knowledge limitation of Jesus in contrast to the Father... I mean he went full retard there!!
@@BringMeTheProof by insulting him and interpting him sure why not hhh
@@abdmahi7449 Nope. By having the Muslim Lampshade admit he didn't know what aqeedah were, making him compare his Meccan deity to a Tshirt, and busting him for misrepresenting the responses to his inane questions.
No matter how smart you think you are as an atheist , The Muslim Lantern is always one step ahead of you
May Allah reward him with all good
Because Atheist always have the same BS argument.
They are too arrogant to believe in God, they will latch onto anyone person's belief (Richard Dawkin) and worship them instead of worshipping God.
@@XIII13X Muslim Lantern got clapped by Jay Dyer. Andrew Wilson too. You missed the debate?
@@BringMeTheProof
Do you mean the guy who is so obsessed with Arabs ..🍆?
And the other one who admitted that Jesus and Father are not equal , and Jesus submitted to God
Yes I watch the debate
W The Muslim Lantern 😁
@@BringMeTheProofthey both embarrassed themselves, watch his analysis on it
@@BringMeTheProoflying and saying you got kicked when you didn’t, and trying to change the rules mid debate😂😂😂 “clapped”
We are not PART of God.
We are the CREATION of God
We are PART of God is POLYTHEISM
Agree bro,
That's the right way to say it
just like the bike which is created by humans but we call it machine not human
@@RehanShaikh-gc4lf YES.
CREATOR creates CREATION
however, CREATOR ≠ CREATION, CREATION ≠ CREATOR
CREATOR = CREATOR
CREATION = CREATION
He has a Stupid Hindu believe in his mind and heart
We are not PART OF GOD
We are the CREATION OF GOD
I agree with everything you said, but one thing I need to tell you from an islamic point of view. We don't say we are part of god. We would rather say we are the creation of God because we weren't at any time a physical part of God like you gave the example with your skin. Allah say be, and it is. Anything he wants to bring to existence from nothing, he just say to it be and it comes into existence. He is THE Creator. How exactly does this work ? As humans and with our limited comprehension, we can't imagine it, so we accept what Allah tells us about himself in the Quran without going too deep into the matter.
Love your videos guys, keep going :)
Exactly
Also how can we be "a part of God" when we literally can sin, and do the most horrible things, while God is perfect
We r creations, just like angles, animals and Jinns
We may be special from other creations, but we r still a creation
Amazing explanation!!! I just brushed it off because he hasn’t look in to the deen as much therefore he holds that opinion but thank you for saying exactly what I wanted to say and hopefully they see this. May Allah reward you and peace be upon you.
Perfect Explanation
@@sadadinmahamud6703 and peace be upon you brother, thank you ❤️
@lana_354 Yes, exactly
God didn’t cut a piece of him to create us… cmon please
we are the creation of God
😊❤
Atheist : all religions are man's made,.
Muslim : you know islam?
Atheist : no.
Muslim : you read the quran?
Atheist : no.
Muslim : you need a free copy?
Atheist : no, I don't need it.
😂😂😂
I'm not an atheist, but I've studied Quran and it is in no way from God. The only miracle about that book is that people actually still believe that it is.
@@QuranDBunkedpreservation proving it was indeed recited 1400 Years ago along with the prophecy’s that have come true after the time prove it’s from Allah, no other scripture has been preserved except the Qur an & it is recited in a way that is a melody that rhymes along with showing moral values, stories showing it is the direct words of Allah Verbatim. Tor ah Jews have today does not claim to be the “words of the creator” but scripts from people who they believe are inspired by God which is quite silly & Bible is the same, they are not preserved and have zero evidence to back that up unlike the Qur an the final revelation
@@sactownizzy9312 Go into the real world of academia and tell them your method of preservation is memorization and you will be laughed out of the building. You have 37 Arabic Quran with thousands of variants and multiple qira'at. Your scholars don't even know what ahruf are and you have no complete Uthmanic Quran from the 7th century. That's why Yasir Qadhi said the "Islamic narrative has serious holes in it" and he's a Muslim. Which one of those is al-Lah's original Quran? Next!
@@QuranDBunked not just memorization, but writings, scribes & even having qur ans today that are carbon dated to the lifetime to the prophet SAW, answer yourself this question, why would the prophet claim the angel Gabriel who’s nickname is literally the Holy Spirit come to him with the creator and have him claim things that Christians say the opposite of, like God never sleeps, Christian’s think god rests, or saying David had a loyal soldier killed just to sleep with his wife, the qur an says that did not happen, or saying Moses never made idols for the children of Israel to worship, qur an also says that’s false, or saying Noah build the arc while drinking alcohol, Qur an says he never had alcohol or desired to drink it, but Christians believe these fallacy’s even when the text is not preserved and written by people who wanted to own slaves and make money, Qur an is the only truth, study it with an open heart and see that stuff like Solomon also never worshiped idols and it’s idiotic to think so.
@@sactownizzy9312 Great. So where is the original Uthmanic manuscript from the 7th century? What are ahruf that your prophet said the Quran were revealed in? Why are there 37 Arabic Qurans? You just keep regurgitating Islamic doctrine that comes from hadith written 200 years after the events by an Uzbek hundreds of miles away. You cannot answer any of those questions.
She is searching and that's a good thing. May Allah guide her.
Amin, it is a journey the key is sincerity: establish if God exist then if so does he send message and if so follow it, rather than speaking about her taste "I don't think we need praying etc.." he was trying to establish the truth with her, not about her taste, our taste and feeling is irrelevant to establish the truth. many confuses taste with the truth, following desire of the immediate, while ignoring the serious consequence of the next eternal life. No other chance to correct belief. Now is the time.
@@sutil5078that's true, brother. we just want the best for them, ..but it's their choise ofcourse. Repeating the true message is the best that we can do.
Greetings from Belgium🇧🇪
i think her problem was that she was a shia
@@revertedrf978what a ridiculous comment she doesn’t even believe in a God & you labelled her shia 😵💫 she’s an atheist you’l find many Iranians who were happy with Shahs rulings & against the islamic revolution in Iran because they do not want to live by Islamic rules
MashaAllah Muhammad Ali is a legend, May Allah s.w.t protect him...Aameen!!
We are not all part of God
rather we all are creation of God
If you say we are all part of God, that is "pantheism".
Love Muslim Lantern x best example of a decent Muslim ❤
Creator and creation is not the same.
We live and die Bc of Him. God on the other hand is self-sustaining, undependable, ever-living, no fatigue or sleep touches Him. This is why he is Ahad (One and Undevisable). He is in control and supervises All things, not a leaf falls without His knowledge.
Muslim Lantern is my favorite person to watch on UA-cam. We need more reactions of his discussions
We are not part of Allah because he doesn't need us but we need him, Allah always existed but we're not,
We can't say Allah is this and that with our limited knowledge but he's the only one can tell about himself and he's all knowing and we're not. this is logic
You guys should react to brother shamsi videos from DUS dawah channel who explains islam very well with proofs and logic
Good video and I advise you guy if you have any questions to ask the Muslim lantern he goes online nearly two days weekly
More The Muslim Lantern videos !
Muslim Lantern is best
With all due respect to you Han. I have to disagree with you there. We're not apart of Allah. 12:51 We're his creation. If you make soup or build a staircase that don't make them part of you right? Allah said in the Quran 42:11 [He is] Creator of the heavens and the earth. He has made for you from yourselves, mates, and among the cattle, mates; He multiplies you thereby. There is nothing like unto Him, and He is the Hearing, the Seeing."
Allah says BE and it is there! Allah doesn’t need to take apart of him to create something. I’m surprised Han believes that God needs something in order to create something. That makes God limited
My skin is not me, when it's stuck to me it's part of me, when it's peeled off it's no longer a part of me. So, this example is kind of weird to give to God. From an Islamic point of view, Allah creates out of his will, not by transforming or separating parts of him.
You should think about like you are making a chair or a table, you gather he necessary materials, assemble them in a certain way and there you have your product. Now, the chair is not you, not is it a part of you, it's your creation !
Using the same principle, Allah creates out of his will, he commands things into existence as said in the Quran 36:82
Exactly.
Steve Jobs is in my pocket 🤭
React more of him, He's a true genius 🇧🇩🇧🇩
The moment you say you are part of God, you have in effect attached a concept to God that makes sense to you. The reason we as Muslims don't subscribe to this concept is because Allah SWT explicitly states there is no example, or likeness of him. This means that the moment you have captured any attributes about him that he doesn't state about himself, you have in effect made your own version of an 'understandable' god. May Allah SWT guide you both. Ameen.
God can't be the universe, because the universe is limited but not God
May Allah guide all the humanity Aameen ❤❤❤
I guess you already know that God is separate from his creation. You have been told that many times here by me and other brothers and sisters. This one point is very fundamental to Islam.
All the Messengers of Allaah had one message: "O people, say there is no God but Allaah and be successful".
That's it. End of discussion.
@@mohammaddoofesh4963 My boy still giving dawaganda. What happened to the contradiction in Quran regarding how many angels visited Mary in Surah 3 and 19?
@@BringMeTheProofverse number?
@@umairmukhtar6702 Sure. Your akhi has no answer. How many angels visited Mary when it was announced she was going to give birth to the Messiah. 1 angel or many?
@@umairmukhtar6702 Read 3:45-47 and 19:17-20 and give me the correct answer.
@@BringMeTheProof so i looked those verses, below is my understanding in simple words:
there are many angels and one step higher from them is Gabriel. When Gabriel came down on earth to bring message from god many angels accompanied him. So surah 3 verse 42 is talking about all those angels. Surah 19 verse 17 is specifically talking about Gabriel what he said to Mary(PHUH). I don’t believe there is any contradiction.
WITH RESPECT: Sometimes we make a quick conclusion when thinking about a main topic, and our conclusion on a subtopic may have been off the line of truth just a little because the secondary topic was not really cooked, and a wrong conclusion may have occurred!
I think, this is what had happened here on saying we are gods or part of god etc.!
So as many are pointing out ... according to God Allah, the Most High and cannot have other gods or parts like us humans associated with Him as being part of ... THAT, in fact, is the greatest, unforgivable sin in Islam, and it is called "Shirk" (associating anything with Allah; and this is mentioned in The Quran (and The Bible as well!) RESPECT and APPRECIATION TO YOU BOTH AND YOUR HELPERS if any. YOU ARE DOING A GREAT SERVICE.
respect to all the Muslims explaining this. I don't subscribe to them anymore because I realized they don't bother reading the actual Quran themselves, esp not with tafseer which is important to clarify, or Seerah, or anything. if they do read the Holy Quran they would probably only do it in front of the camera, which to me is making a sport and entertainment of something that is a very private, important, serious matter that is between you and God, and should be done with zero ulterior motives if you're sincere.
People afraid of God because if they believe they would have to stop sinning
We r not a part of God!!
This concept doesn't make sense if u think about it
I mean i don't see any reason to support such a claim
God is perfect, we r not
God always existed, we didn't
God is nothing like us and doesn't look like us, bcz we r just a creation, he is the creator
God is God, humans r just a creation, just like angles, animals and Jinns r
I feel like claiming we r from God is a very arrogant claim no h8 to u
But who r we to say such a thing
this is a very common belief in new age and some forms of christianity both
@AfridiZindabad
Ik, but it doesn't make any sense, and ppl just started making it up, it wasn't even a part of Christianity few hundred years ago
So this is just some weird belief
True. The purpose of life. ❤
Lord Allah bless you both🙏🏻🎩🌹🌹
Please react to "BEST RECITATION EVER? Al-Mu'minun - Yasir ad-Dawsari", it is one of the best recitations :D
Hello guys hope all is well. Your relationship is inspiring and the way you both are on this journey together fully supporting each other and searching for the truth is special. May God bless us all and guide us all. PEACE AND LOVE Brother and Sister.
People tend to ponder upon life and their existence during times of hardship
If hardship comes to you, it’s Allah calling you to recognise Him and for you to ask Him for His help
"God can do anything," particularly focusing on logical contradiction
1. **Can God create a rock so heavy that He cannot lift it?**
(This paradox addresses the contradiction of an omnipotent being creating something it cannot control.)
2. **Can God make a square circle?**
(This question tests the limits of logical coherence, as a square circle is a logical impossibility.)
3. **Can God create a number greater than all numbers?**
(This question highlights the contradiction inherent in the concept of an "absolute maximum" number.)
4. **Can God make 2 + 2 equal 5?**
(This addresses the idea of altering basic mathematical truths, which are logically consistent and unchangeable.)
5. **Can God create a situation where He is not omnipotent?**
(This challenges the coherence of omnipotence by questioning if it can include self-contradiction.)
6. **Can God make Himself cease to exist?**
(This tests the paradox of omnipotence versus necessary existence, as ceasing to exist would contradict the nature of an omnipotent being.)
7. **Can God perform an action that contradicts His own nature, such as lying or being unjust?**
(This question explores whether omnipotence includes the power to act in ways that violate divine attributes.)
8. **Can God create a contradiction?**
(This question tests whether omnipotence extends to creating logical contradictions, which are inherently impossible.)
9. **Can God alter the fundamental laws of logic, such as the law of non-contradiction?**
(This question examines if omnipotence can extend to changing logical principles that are essential to coherent thought.)
10. **Can God make Himself less powerful?**
(This question explores whether an omnipotent being can diminish its own power, which seems contradictory to the nature of omnipotence.)
Ya Allah. Please fulfill the wishes of all insan all humanity in this world. Syukur alhamdulillah.
Absolutely 💯
If God has parts he is no longer God.
God is absolute, One, has unlimited attributes, self sufficient, no gender.. , nothing like Him. doesnt need anything but everything is in need of Him.
Us being part of God is illogical tbh , there is nothing divine about humans. N the universe is created, therefore the One who created it is not the universe and everything within.
At end of the day where do you get this idea from? Does God spoke to you ? Sent you scripture ?
If not. Why not check mohamed (pbuh) s claim ? either he is a liar. Or he is telling the truth. And if you find that he is telling the truth. Then believe in what God tells you about Him in the Quran. Better than speculating.
Han! We are not parts of God. stop saying that word.
Don't tell me, can a game character in a computer game be part of the engineer who wrote the codes of the game?
How ridiculous this idea is. Your statement that we are parts of your god is just as ridiculous. illogical. This perspective within you comes from Christianity.
Muslim: “So, you don’t believe in God?”
Atheists: “No.”
Muslim: “How about the creator?”
Atheists: “No.”
Muslim: “Ok, then what do you believe in?”
Atheists: “Higher power that is unknown to us”.
Muslim: “Then you believe in God.”
Atheists: “No, we don’t!”
Muslim: “I’m sorry, but just for your information, in Islamic faith, God is also a higher power that cannot be imagined.”
Atheists: “You’re delusional”.
Muslim: “And you’re just confused by linguistics and terminologies.”
Atheists: “I just consider myself as a learner who is still looking for the truth, and I question everything.”
Muslim: “Ok, so here’s a Qur’an for you to study.”
Atheists: “No, thank you.”
What? 😂
لا اله الا الله سبحانه وتعالى عما يصفون واتوب اليه واسبحه واحمده واكبره واعبده واسغفره ولا حول ولا قوة الا بالله العلي العظيم واسجد له ليلا ونهارا ولا اله الا الله وحده لا شريك له له الملك وله الحمد وهو على كل شيء قدير ومحمد عبده ورسوله صلى الله عليه وسلم لا اله الا الله سبحانه وتعالى عما يصفون واتوب اليه واسبحه واحمده
Just because we originate from God does not mean we are a part of him as we know God can expend power without losing power as he is boundless and infinite so he never gives up a part of himself and is completely disassociated from his creation and this also stems from the idea that God create something out of nothing requiring no materials or part of himself to create and this is the extent of his power hope this explanation helped guys if you like this comment so they could see it I'd appreciate it
Our friends are waiting. IYKYK
ISLAM "THE WAY OF LIFE ✨
React to Madina (prophets mosque in madina Saudi arabia).You will love it.Therr is prophets Muhammad (PBUH) grave
Young man... You can believe something or nothing. But remember every soul will taste death....remember that.
Masha Allah
These guys started as ‘Christian couple’ now they’re ‘aetheist couple.’ Other week they talking about shahada now they selling books on spirituality and seeking donations. May Allah guide them but they not getting my ‘donation.’ Getting paid to be interested in Islam doesn’t sit right with me. Plus every episode this brother keeps saying gods inside him and part of him even though Muslim brothers and sisters keep correcting him. Beginning to think he’s just just here to sell his meditation books. Islam already gives us meditation and more for free
I was waiting for you guys to wake up. 👍
They are not referring themselves as atheist, instead they refer the couple in the Mohammed Ali's video as atheists
@@0OmerErgun0 They are a New Age Zen couple leading Muslims along to our food in their table.
Why are so many Muslims so naive? Stop giving views to these individuals!! The current state of the ummah is so weak because so many Muslims are being so easily manipulated and are not sticking to Islam and each other. JUST STOP!!!! Watch our brother Muslim Lantern and not any of these individuals!!!
The God created thing from nothing, not from his part, so we are not part og GOD, we created by God
The companions of the fire are those say
There is no God
There are multiple Gods
Everything is part of God
Kelly absolutely nailed it
The first thing to know God is, the Creator, all we can see and imagine is creation, so never equate God with His creation. May we all get guidance and salvation in the hereafter, aamiin 🙏
12:09 exactly!!!!😊
🔖I agree Han: people are scared of the idea of "God" because it implies compliance , doing works in this life, but if this length of this life is literally a millimeter, less than mustered seed length compared to billion and billion of miles (actually eternity) then the task of worshiping in this mustard seed's length of life is literally nothing, trading this short life for eternity without a second chance is not intelligent, it deserves lengthy reflection at least. the eternity is real either in good shape or not that good shape..
Mashallah
Please react to surah as sajdah next! 🙏
If I make a chair, I am in the chair
Dude apart of cheese is a cheese, apart of broccoli is a broccoli. So apart of god would make you a god…
God is Goodness. Religion poisons that goodness.
MILLIONS OF PPLS THERE, THAT CONCIOULY TRYING TO BELIEVE THAT THERE'S NO GOD(even though they know thereso many miracles & rational facts)😪
cuz, they r afraid, if there's a god, then, they have have to follow a religion. & if they believe in a religion, they won't be able to do many immoral things, which is not allowed in religions😪
I always make dua for you and your wife. may Allah guide you to the truth. you're both wonderful ❤️
muslim lantern is very nice and calm speaker
Lets see if this comment get removed again or not;
To our muslim friends, Hans has been repeatedly saying "we are part of God" is his way preaching Christianity, intentionally or not.
Someone who said they cant look Christianity the same way again but still using it as their belief.
Im fine if he want to use other religion's belief beside Islam or Christianity coz one he doesn't believe in it and the other he's cant look at it the same way.
Be careful my friend.
I hope this couple will find the truth if they truly sincere.
Shiehk uthman is also good to react to if you want
It's not the eye that blind it's the heard
That logic of everything come from something must be same is proved to be fallacy scientifically. for an example as a human i make a chair with help of raw materials, my knowledge, language and etc but that doesn't that chair is a human. quran supports this claim by "THERE IS NOTHING ALIKE HIM" you can beleive whatever you want but just saying. we may have attributes of god but it's in a very less proportionate and god has it perfect.
Exactly!!! Also we r a creation, that's the entire meaning of being created
We didn't exist before, bcz we were created, didn't exist before that at all, that's literally what a creation stands for
True, just because God created us doesn't mean we are cut out of God, doesn't that make God incomplete then?
dude whats your point , u didnt disprove that everything comes from something
For God to create something he does not need to take something from himself to create it he just has to say be and it'll be
Mohammad Ali Muslim lantern is the best one of all time (from my point of view)
Hi bro, i heard a lot of time from you, that we (human) are part of God, totally wrong and against Islam and basic concept of Creator and Creation, we are creation, cannot be a part of Creator. you need to re-think and think deep, btw, if you die, does the part of God also die? Just think, Allah is on His throne, not every where and not fully or partially in any thing, yes His power, His mercy , His control , His attributes are every where, not Himself. Hope you will understand, no offence
Allah (SwT) exists,
He is The Most High, over the mighty throne,
He is not part of his creation,
Neither we are part of him,
He is The only True God, worthy of worship,
But if you and your wife insist that we are part of Allah and you die on this belief you will not succeed.
Protect yourselves from a fire whose fuel is people and stones.
I understand the concerns being raised about Han's statement, "we are part of God." However, after hearing Han's explanation that there was only God initially, and then He created everything else, I believe Han meant to convey that we originate from God. This is similar to the phrase "Innaa lillaa wa innaa ilayhi raaji'oon," which means "We belong to God, and to Him we return." It seems Han's choice of words was not appropriate, and he may not fully grasp the gravity of such a statement. God has godly attributes, like all Powerful, whereas we human do not. May Allah guide us all.
It's a goat even if it flies😂
They all have problem with the suffering on earth, culture of bad people...etc.
They see that as religion instead of scriptures and prophecies.
It's so sad when you see some people close their eyes and lock their brains and hearts to the truth when it's very clear to them. Seriously, what are you going to say to God when He ask you in the day of judgment about the truth that came to you and rejected them?
"Anything created by god has to be god. Come on bro thats illogical. That's like saying the architect IS the building. The baker IS the bread, or a mother is literally her son. We are a creation of god. Therefore, by definition, can't be god.
If you create a table is it becomes your part?
Or you are separate of your creation? 🤨
Please do watch “The Miraculous KABA”. 🕋
ua-cam.com/video/XkYksIdA3FQ/v-deo.htmlsi=TW4-BAh4heW8br4p
Simple proof. When we are in the most desperate or dangerous situation, whom we pray or asking for help from?
Jesus? Trinity? Idols? No. We pray from GOD.
I don't mean to hate or anything but sometimes you will title your videos as "Christians react" and now it's "Athiest couple react". I could be very wrong but I don't you guys are consistent in your beliefs...
You read it wrong. Read the title again.
it doesn't say atheist couple react.. it says the atheist couple challenge A MUSLIM lantern (i.e. the couple in the video that these two are reacting to)
@@AfridiZindabad @AfridiZindabad The couple who are challenging are challenging the Muslim lantern. They are reacting to a couple challenging the Muslim lantern. The couple is not them but the couple who are challenging the Muslim lantern. It's pretty obvious but hey, maybe you didn't watch the video.
Film the message
that film is terrible. there was a time when (better) Muslims, in a time before us, used to disqualify anything if it even slightly changed the words of Rasulullah SAW or Quran. THE MESSAGE FILM DOES BOTH AND IT MAKES UP ENTIRE SCENES THAT ARE TOTALLY DIFF FROM THE ACTUAL INCIDENTS (e.g. the scene showing Hamza RA's conversion -- completely made up -- the actual incident, you are welcome to read about) -- it's a terrible film and i despise any muslim that recommends it because obviously they do not value basic honesty and would be immediately disqualified as reliable people, by the standards of prior Muslims
God is not apart of his creation
We are not PART of God. We are the CREATION of God. Just like a maker of cars. Cars are not part of the maker. They are just maker's creation. Also, God is not energy. Energy is one of His creations. Energy is just some kind of force that cannot do anything but that force. We have lots of forces in the universe. And We can manipulate these forces in some extent.
If We are part of god then pantheism is the best thing to follow for you.
Please React to more of Muslim Lantern videos 💯
Han i am muslim i like you act like muslim i wish you one day you say i ombress islam with your wife Allah bless you i like you my brother
The only thing I don’t agree with as a muslim is that “we are part of God”. We are creation of God, like when you create like a chair, the chair is not a part of you, and being part of Him would mean that God took something from Him, and taking something from Him makes Him no longer God. And He says in the Quran “there is nothing like onto Him” and that He is not in our world. Beside this, you have a belief of a Muslim
i really like Kelly's point about curiousity will lead us to where we need to go, but the idea that we are part of God is a delusion. God is Exalted above ALL that we associate with God (including ourselves) as the Quran clearly says, and basic logic would say too.
We are creation of God. This statement sounds more accurate. ❤
More Muslim lantern videos please
just like we use nt to exist then we come into existence.we should ask where we were b4 coming in this world..
To these kind of people i wanna say:"My dear, do you really think you gonna live forever? One day you'll die and meet your Lord. The fact that you are saying: "Maybe there is a higher power....." How ppl can be that much stupid and arrogant 🤷🏻♀️?
Allah Akber
Is the creation part of the creator? Take worldly matters where mankind creates so for example, is the iphone part of its Creator?
Logic and common sense is the key.
After seeing so many videos on islam this cane as a surprise when I heard it.
May Allah Guide. Aameen!
I don't think God created us from a part of him. God created everything from substances he created, and not parts of himself.
Dear Han, in Islam, we say; Allah says BE and it IS. He is the ONE who can do something from nothing, and he doesn't need to take something from himself to create something else. And that idea of part of God contradicts with the ONENESS of the only one true God and his might and majesty, because by saying we are parts of God means that God NEEDS something to do something else. Indeed Allah is All powerful and All mighty.
Yes, we ARE his creations, and to him, we will return. And we ARE connected with Allah, which is an innate thing that many people try to ignore. And that connection can get stronger the more we pray that way, which HE, the most Beautiful, wants.
Ma'as-Salam.
Waiting for the Inshallah you both will soon be Muslim comments. 😂
Quran
Surah Al-Ikhlas (112)
In the name of Allah, Most Gracious, Most Merciful.
Say: He is Allah, the One and Only;
Allah, the Eternal, Absolute;
He begetteth not, nor is He begotten;
And there is none like unto Him.
We are NOT a part of God
We are his creation
Han, ive enjoyed watching your learning about religion especially the Islamic videos...
with all due love and respect... please ponder over your thats that "we are a part of God"... i have pondered over the implications of this when i heard you say it.. as a muslim this is not something we belive however i still thought of it logically.... If we are parts of God that would make God Tangeable and would give him limitation... if he keeps creating and using up parts of him then that implies that he has an ending, if was to keep creating would he run out? if each time he creates he creats from himself then that would mean ther may be a time when he runs out of matter...
Allah swt is above our logic and reasoning if he wants wants to do something he just says "Be" and it is...
we live in a world thats transfer of matter, God is above his creation and isnt bound by it.
Its great to ponder over Allah and how great he is 😊
So you made a big jump you said your logic is the same as his in terms of coming from God therefore meaning being a part of God. That’s not what he said at all. He said we come from God not apart of God. Coming from God doesn’t necessitate being a part of him logically. In fact it’s opposite we are finite god is eternal. So we can’t be a part of him in any way by definition.