Battle Of Mono Amps, Topping B200 Vs Schiit Aegir

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 7 лис 2024

КОМЕНТАРІ • 74

  • @clarencehoover6748
    @clarencehoover6748 2 місяці тому +14

    On a fine point, Aegir seems to render the snare drum attack (leading transient dynamics) more accurately. I’ve played drums for a few decades and collect and tune snare drums, so I think I have a decent reference point. Thank you for the sound samples! 💜

    • @IHearEverythingDude
      @IHearEverythingDude Місяць тому

      🤦‍♂

    • @mik8352
      @mik8352 Місяць тому +2

      I agree and the Topping were more thin/bright, like not my taste... :)

  • @deanfisher1656
    @deanfisher1656 2 місяці тому +4

    Purchased the Aegir 2 about a month ago based on your review and another. Run it with my LTA MZ3 Headphone amp in pre-amp mode…..wow….defined, but rich midrange with good bass control. Was looking for that class A sound and it delivers. They drive my little Dali Minuet SE Speakers just fine. Topping sounds very nice…..As always, I think ancillary gear will play into the equation and both are great buys. Nice review as always. 😊

  • @billmcginley
    @billmcginley Місяць тому +1

    Thank you for the review Tharbamar- seems like either one will be a smart choice

  • @nudawas
    @nudawas 2 місяці тому +3

    Topping B200 for me ... cleaner, more details and airy . Thank you for your work . At the moment im burning out my new Muzishare x7 which ive decided to buy after watching your review... probability nex one will be X9 . Love there sound. Also im waiting for GUSTARD DAC-A26 also thanks to your review. Did you tey use streaming directly from a26 ?? Any good ?

  • @rogerdinh
    @rogerdinh Місяць тому +1

    Great review! Wondering how the B200 compares to the LA90 you previously assessed? Was considering LA90 for mono configuration also. Also, does the LA90 volume control functional in mono configuration?
    thank you

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  Місяць тому +1

      As of right now I don’t know if would use LA90 over B200 because I would rather use proper mono amps, thanks

  • @JamesJones-qs7rr
    @JamesJones-qs7rr 2 місяці тому +1

    Another great video,
    Do you prefer the Accuphase 4000 amplifier vs these mono block options?
    I’m currently considering accuphase 800 or 4000 and the AGD mono blocks.
    I have Cornwall 4’s and Monitor Audio Gold Towers.

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  2 місяці тому +1

      Thanks, E-4000 is my reference amplifier these amps are review samples and just sharing my experience.

  • @willbrink
    @willbrink Місяць тому +2

    I have not heard either, but "on paper" I'd take the Topping easily.

  • @dangoh2237
    @dangoh2237 Місяць тому +3

    I much prefer the topping they sound better!!

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  Місяць тому +1

      Many would agree that but Aegir has musicality that we can listen to for hours, as always to each own.

  • @AdiMaco
    @AdiMaco 2 місяці тому +2

    I really don't know which one is better but I like Aegir more. Good review, as always!

    • @rogerdinh
      @rogerdinh 26 днів тому

      did you compare A/B side by side may I ask

  • @audiofuturnumerique8976
    @audiofuturnumerique8976 2 місяці тому +2

    Très bon matériel moderne, pour ma part j'ai opté pour fosi za3 🎉❤

  • @valentinvalentin8916
    @valentinvalentin8916 2 місяці тому +5

    Nice comparison! For me topping it s sounds better, more airy, more detailed😊 Can you tell me please how b200 it s sound comparing to pa7?

  • @dragonstone6594
    @dragonstone6594 2 місяці тому +2

    Can you review the new Monitor Audio Gold 100 6G?

  • @peterjanssens7578
    @peterjanssens7578 28 днів тому +1

    Hi. I'm in Canada and I'm wondering where I would be able to purchase a pair of the B200s.

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  28 днів тому

      Amazon could be the best place to buy them.

    • @peterjanssens7578
      @peterjanssens7578 28 днів тому +1

      @@Tharbamar Thank you so much. There is a third party seller on Amazon in Canada and it says they are sold out. But I will keep trying.
      By the way, I enjoy listening to your reviews. I have learned so much.
      Thanks again. 😊👍🏻

  • @RosemarySoriano-n6v
    @RosemarySoriano-n6v 2 місяці тому +1

    Thank you so much.❤

  • @ccdccd8615
    @ccdccd8615 Місяць тому +1

    Do you have a recommendation between the 2 if you are only using them for the woofer part of your speaker (My speakers are bi-amped). Frequency range is 200 hz to 35 hz. Thanks

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  Місяць тому

      For the woofer I will always choose higher power, thanks

    • @ccdccd8615
      @ccdccd8615 Місяць тому +1

      @@Tharbamar After a little research, you are definitely right. My woofers are wired in parallel for a 4 ohm load. The Aegir in mono block configuration is 100 watt into 8 ohms. No rating for 4 ohms. The B200s are rated at 200 watts in 8 and 4 ohms. So the B200s have twice the power (I was looking to 200-300 watts) and rated for the load my woofers have. Done deal.

  • @Nickhifi88
    @Nickhifi88 2 місяці тому +1

    Nice review, but with your own experience with classD, why go for A/B?

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  2 місяці тому +3

      I prefer to listen to Class AB/A or SET.

    • @Nickhifi88
      @Nickhifi88 2 місяці тому +1

      @@Tharbamar sure, but for which reasons? In blind tests, I wonder if you can detect any differences.

    • @nudawas
      @nudawas 2 місяці тому +6

      ​@@Nickhifi88you can sir

    • @mattmiller4978
      @mattmiller4978 2 місяці тому +1

      Ah the amp class wars. I bought a class A to answer this for myself, and these answers follow my experience.

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  2 місяці тому +1

      @@Nickhifi88 yes absolutely I’ve even won speaker cable double blind tests in past.

  • @2undrpar787
    @2undrpar787 5 днів тому +1

    What about turn on and turn off pops and thumps....do either of them have this terrible feature or are they dead silent.

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  5 днів тому

      No noise with them in my system.

  • @이창만-q8k
    @이창만-q8k Місяць тому +1

    Amplifiers with a high S/N ratio, such as the Topping B200, require a DAC with a higher S/N ratio to achieve sufficient performance. I recommend Topping E70(for DAC and preamplifier) because it has an extremely low THD that is somewhat equivalent to a high S/N ratio in the 200Hz-2kHz range.

  • @robertwang7825
    @robertwang7825 2 місяці тому +4

    B200 for me and in China its 20% cheaper while the Schitt is 30% more , so its a no brainer , also its more neutral and micro details n more powerful

  • @Jil8840
    @Jil8840 2 місяці тому

    Great test. Schiit sounds a little better. More clear, neutral and fresher.

  • @dennis3779
    @dennis3779 19 днів тому +1

    Nice test. Of course Class A and Tube amps are more pure, real and analog. But works best without nasty impedance behaviour of the speakers. All other type amps are more artificial processing amps and so are more artificial and plastic clinking.

  • @rustydeffy7586
    @rustydeffy7586 11 днів тому +1

    I have a Gustard a 26 how would the b200 sound using it as a preamp?

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  11 днів тому

      It might be a little too transparent but as always sound is subjective and depending of paring speakers.

  • @LexusAllTerrain1
    @LexusAllTerrain1 2 місяці тому +2

    How about FONZY V3 vs. Aegier vs. Topping
    Should be interesting 🤔

    • @wegardfjeld3789
      @wegardfjeld3789 2 місяці тому +2

      No it's not. Fozi V3 over rating needs to end. It's only good for what it is.. not vs the better stuff

    • @LexusAllTerrain1
      @LexusAllTerrain1 2 місяці тому

      @@wegardfjeld3789 It sounds very CLEAN, with great stage and air! Tell me why you disagree!

    • @wegardfjeld3789
      @wegardfjeld3789 2 місяці тому +1

      @@LexusAllTerrain1 Since I have the b20 bt pro2, the first V3 and the mono's i can start by saying it's not because I don't know what I'm talking about... Now let's move on with the history of being an audiophile over somewhat 35+ years with equipment in different price ranges and always looking for value for money. The V3 lacks depth, soundstage, low end and details all over. The mid range is sterile and unnatural. I doubt you want to hear this, but my old Cambridge Audio 640 Azur in my parents house with a decent streamer, Gheshelli J2 akam dac on a good pair of monitors, outperform them in any sound related aspects as well as power, so hard it's not funny. Google the date on that thing. Now vs actually good gear the difference is so big it's not funny. To make the V3 decent you really need better op amps. At this point it's already fighting vs decent low end integrated like Yamaha. Next that Yamaha comes with a okey pre, a dac and it will sound better. Adding all that suddenly the V3 fights vs decent integrated in low mid. At this point you wasted your money and that's how this story goes. Now what it does well is for a small size desktop system. I can say that something like the Tangent power ampster 2 in mono really outperforms it and if you op amp roll that's a better way to go.

    • @LexusAllTerrain1
      @LexusAllTerrain1 2 місяці тому +1

      @@wegardfjeld3789 thanks the input!

    • @wegardfjeld3789
      @wegardfjeld3789 2 місяці тому

      @@LexusAllTerrain1 No worries. I just want things to be clear and true to the buyers/users. UA-cam hyping goes wrong many times. The old magazines were also a part of that, but less crazy than current days. With that said getting the Fosi V3, wiim ultra, decent monitors and a sub might bring you more audiophile joy then what was around before and I really think it's a great time for audiophiles 😉. Enjoy your music

  • @derekf7772
    @derekf7772 2 місяці тому +1

    Redondo Beach!! South Bay!!

  • @ColocasiaCorm
    @ColocasiaCorm 2 місяці тому +1

    Why man. I dont want to buy another dac. But you keep tempting me with that x30

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  2 місяці тому +1

      I love the way it sounds like five figure DACs 😎

  • @restcarl83
    @restcarl83 2 місяці тому +1

    Have you thought of using them in a bi-amping setup!?
    On paper, the B200's gain in high mode is the same as in the Aegir. Also, the B200 seems to control the bass better while the Aegir's soundstage might be broader and richer. They could compliment very well in a biamping setup... Anyways, it might be an interesting experiment

    • @justinyugm
      @justinyugm 2 місяці тому +1

      This is my setting right now. I use two B200s and aegirs combination for my martin logan F200. It is so wonderful.

  • @twitchbook-1
    @twitchbook-1 2 місяці тому

    i love how quiet is the b200 compare to the aegir, better emi filter less steep curve the gain its amazing

  • @eldloppa2
    @eldloppa2 2 місяці тому +7

    I was surprised with how MUCH more airy the Topping sounded.

    • @Tharbamar
      @Tharbamar  2 місяці тому

      Yep.

    • @wegardfjeld3789
      @wegardfjeld3789 2 місяці тому

      @@eldloppa2 Airy, that's something people say about the fosi V3, it lacks the fundamental depth that makes music sound good. I will try the toppings because I always look for a tweak to my cabin, summer house or even desktop system as the V3 mono just doesn't cut it and I don't want a full size system there

  • @ColocasiaCorm
    @ColocasiaCorm 2 місяці тому +1

    Wow surprisingly i find the topping much less bright, much more well behaved than the aegir

  • @이창만-q8k
    @이창만-q8k Місяць тому

    Both the DAC and amplifier must have a high S/N ratio to express their performance well. Even if only one of the DAC or amplifier has a low S/N ratio, it will be adjusted to that low S/N ratio.

  • @CarlVanDoren61
    @CarlVanDoren61 2 місяці тому

    Battle? First one into the bin? 😮

  • @BoRerunn
    @BoRerunn 2 місяці тому +2

    Amazing battle, Topping wins 🎉

  • @Evolved_ue7
    @Evolved_ue7 2 місяці тому

    Power bricks, I don't have the real estate for them, shame but will have to pass on them ..

  • @funnyworld9784
    @funnyworld9784 2 місяці тому

    a lot of robots here...managing comments

  • @stevenconnectingtogether6703
    @stevenconnectingtogether6703 2 місяці тому +3

    In your samples, I noticed that the Aegir delivers a slightly stronger bass note, whereas the B200 offers more transparency and a sense of airiness.

    • @wegardfjeld3789
      @wegardfjeld3789 2 місяці тому

      @@stevenconnectingtogether6703 Trough a recording on UA-cam and I'm sorry to say if the so-called airyness is something like the fosi V3 mono it means low and mid end lackluster where the soul of music lies

  • @derrickthomas4603
    @derrickthomas4603 2 дні тому

    You lost me at switching psu

  • @DanCyn-b6q
    @DanCyn-b6q 2 місяці тому +1

    you're out of your mind to even compare that Schiit with the Topping.

    • @ChicagoRob2
      @ChicagoRob2 2 місяці тому

      How many Topping amps made Stereophile’s Class A recommended components?

    • @didioentoro7575
      @didioentoro7575 2 місяці тому +3

      What's wrong if you or anyone compare US made vs China made ? We talk about the sound and not the patriotic feeling....talk about the fact !

    • @wegardfjeld3789
      @wegardfjeld3789 2 місяці тому

      He was making a schiit joke. Sigh

    • @capdew
      @capdew 2 місяці тому

      Some people live their lives as audio politicians, just because their corrupted leaders feed them with enough lies

    • @bryanwilliams3665
      @bryanwilliams3665 2 місяці тому +1

      ​@@didioentoro7575I may ve wrong , but I'm pretty sure most electrical components are made in China these days in any case...So even stuff that claims to be USA built has a large China content inside.