Telecaster shootout | Haar • Maybach • Fender
Вставка
- Опубліковано 13 лип 2024
- Timeline:
0:00 - Intro
1:10 - Dry Soundtest
1:37 - Amped Soundtest
5:46 - Conclusion
6:13 - Band
Haar: www.haarguitars.com
Maybach: maybach-guitars.de
Fender: shop.fender.com
Just Music: www.justmusic.de
I have a haar strat which I ordered from Erik. Took him 4 months to build. I've played guitars ranging from 100 euros to 4000 euros. I am afraid I haven't gone more than that. Haven't played any vintage instruments either. But from all the guitars I've played the haar is the best one for me.
Selten findet man einen so ausgedehnten und nachvollziehbaren Vergleichs-Test, Chapeau !
Danke Dir!
The Maybach has that crunch... My favorite - soundwise! Cheers!
I liked it a lot as well.
Danke für einen solchen Vergleichstest! Ja, die Haar hat definitiv das gewisse Etwas. Rock on!!
Tolles Video 👌🏻👌🏻 Toller Ton, cooler Stil und richtige schicke Aufnahmen
Viiiiiielen Dank!
Best review ever! The unplugged comparison was really cool. It was clear the Haar had more resonance and "harmonic" vibrations.
I am looking for a strat, and i was comparing Haar and Maybach. Maybachs have an awesome reputation for les paul type guitars, but their strats look a bit dull to me. Too basic. They sound awesome to my ears but the Haars have that something special, that puts them to a closer level to custom shop fenders IMO.
Ein sehr schöner Test, für mich schneidet Haar am besten ab, dann die Maybach....besitze selber 2 tolle Haar´s, sowie eine Maybach Strat, die urig und vielleicht etwas roh aber trotzdem toll klingt, hab aber auch das Gefühl das die Holzqualität bei Haar vielleicht etwas besser ist. Die Maybach scheppert auch mehr, gut zu wissen, das
Haar die Gitarren plekt.
I listened very carefully and my decision was the same after hearing all 3 guitars.The Van der Haar sounds more dynamic to me than the others.
i have a maybach T 54, it's the better telecaster i had plaing all along my life, i'm 74 years old !!!!!
Very Nice demo Man ! Thank's for that !
Thx mate!
Klasse Demo, genauso soll das sein! Lustige Notiz am Rande, ich war kürzlich im Key-Music Rotterdam um eine Reihe Haar-Gitarren zu testen. die hatten aber keine einzige auf Lager. Ich glaube die werden alle in Deutschland verkauft
Die Maybach ist ja göttlich!
maybach is the best guitar his sound is perfect
Thank you Mr !
What ever You mean, you´re welcome ;-)
Maybach ❤❤❤❤
Your guitar playing is superb and all three sounded great in your hands. The final piece with the Haar was outstanding and I respect your choice. However, for me, the Fender was the one for me. Neither of us is is wrong, but diversity is a great thing, and long may we continue to like different tones, whilst enjoying the same music. All in all a great video, on many levels, and thank you for that.
Thx mate! Every single guitar of the three was great. There would not have been any wrong choices. The Haar just had a few percent more for me to offer.
wao such an amazing vidéo. great guitar, super sound quality . Danke aus Frankreich
Merci beaucoup!
@@jomitie de rien !! I like the way you introduce the guitar with a speech at the beginning
@@christopherblair6636Thx! I thought it was worth it and still is.
What a first-rate demo! Outstanding. Thx. Where can I get that backing track?
Thx a lot, mate! The BT is selfmade.
mapleneck and tele is the match, otherside sounds like custom made guitars and fender sounds most like fender little more slinky with more chang a lang i would prefer
The Maybach wins, whar a guitar!!!
Vette gitaren, heb zelf ook een telecaster, blauw
I didn’t expect this but the Maybach tone has more body than the fender. This is obvious in the lead tone.
Yes, both the Maybach and the Haar have more body. You can hear that even in the dry comparison.
@@jomitie Actually the dry comparison reaveals A LOT and kudos for doing it. Most people won't, and I always like a guitar that sings unplugged. Unplugged sound between fender and maybach were worlds apart. The haar always sounded awesome more present that's due to the tonewoods I guess, you would expect a maple board guitar to sound more present than a rw one.
Hello! Great choice imo. Would you mind sharing which amp you were running them through or pedals, if you were using a drive pedal as well? Thanks!
Hey Joao, I used Poulin Lextac & Poulin LeCab VSTs for this.
Man, you sound amazing!!
Thank You, Victor!
I prefered the Maybach, then the Haar. But I'm a rosewood guy.
Very nice demo !
Soundqualitywise they were kind of on the same level. But the feeling of the Haar is definitely outstanding.
All 3 guitars sound great to me, because of your excellent and emotional playing, Sir. But only the Haar created goose bumps on my arms. Incredible sound with quite some character. The Maybach sounds very nice too and the Fender spoke least to me. Is the Haar equipped with Amber or Kloppmann pickups?
These are Barenuckle 50's
@@jomitie Thank you.
Hey, very nice video! Would you mind saying something about what the decisive factors for you were? Tried a Haar and a Maybach the other day and liked them both... but I think the Haar I tried had a very flat radius which felt unfamiliar to me. Maybach maybe a little more traditional?
1. The neck really feels great
2. The weight is around 3 kg, i guess (Edit: 2,97 kg!!!)
3. The body (one piece swamp ash) is resonating very rich an warm. It sounds really awesome
4. The frets are perfect (Jescar 55090)
5. The Bareknuckle PUs are fantastic.
Maybach is indeed a bit more traditional, i guess. A normal Tele is 7,25 i think. My Haar has a compund radius from 8,5 to 10,5.
I cannot compare haar with the other two, but regarding the RW guitars I'm amazed how better the maybach sounds. On the other hand you cannot compare a production guitar with a handmade guitar
About haar it's an awesome manufacturer, but they make their guitars a bit too relic for me. I wish they did some light relicing or no relicing at all
Well I hope you get something out off your demos :-) just Music just sold a guitar. Thank you for an excelent demo
You´re welcome, mate! :-)
Well after watching this video and others of Haar Teles like 1000 times, I made my decision of ordering one of them. The guitar was ok, however found also disadvantages. The neck shape was not so comfortable for me, and somehow the bridge pick up didn't sound like I was expecting. I am sending it back :(.
well, little update for my last review, I went to a shop and played another Haar Guitar and played/sounded pretty well, it felt quite better the one I ordered. The neck shape still being a C one, however it felt different.
The best sounding one unplugged is the Fender. In order to preserve the unplugged tone while amplified, remove the tone knob.
I found it the worst sounding unplugged actually. I thought the haar was the best and the maybach a close second
@@topografer That´s exactly what i thought.
I also found the Haar to have the fullest unplugged sound. Fender sounded more "nasaly". However it doesn't seem to transport to amplified sound.
Toller Vergleich ... 3 Hammer Gitarren ... aber wieder mal hat HAAR die Nase vorne für mich. 👌🎸
LG aus Oberösterreich
Jürgen
Danke, Jürgen! Ja, das kann ich nur bestätigen. Der Erik hat anscheinend gutes Holz auf Lager und weiß ziemlich genau, was er damit anstellen muss.
@@jomitie das ist definitiv so, ich hab zwei Gitarren von ihm und durfte kurz in sein Holzlager blicken.
Amazing video. I only have one question can you tell me the price of each guitar because I'm looking forward to get one of these. Thanks
In Germany the prices range from 1700 - 2100 Euros for these 3 models. They could be different in your region.
@@jomitie ok man thanks a lot
you play amazing. I have seen your video a thousand times. I'm like you between Maybach and Haar. I want to ask to have it built. What made you buy the Haar? the objective factor. thanks!
Thx mate! It was everything but an objective decision. Objectively there wasn´t any difference qualitywise. Subjectively the Haar just felt better in my hands :-)
@@jomitie I love your answer. I live in Galicia (spain) and I want to buy one. I have no chance to touch them before. I'll order it from the factory. I spoke to both houses and they make it to me in 3 months. but I can't decide which one. I don't know if one of the houses is better than the other or they are just as good. I can't find the answer on the internet. Your comment helps me a lot.
@@iagowski I wouldn´t buy any guitar i can´t touch before if i were you. Go to a big store to find a Guitar that suits you 100%. On the other hand: Chances are good that you´ll get a very good instrument from both companies Maybach and Haar.
@@jomitie thanks man, i apreciate a lot your words. thanks.
I buy one. With my preferences. Thanks for the help. In 3 months i will play it. Long waiting 😅
You sound great on all three brands … Maybe Haar was better for your playing needs! Good music and superb control, Cheers 👍
Thx Mate!
1:45 3:06 4:29
Hi, the Haar has the perfect pitch and sound I'm looking for, unfortunately I'm struggling to find one or to a price for one, any info you have on them would be most appreciated.
Thanks Rik.
Try this: www.haarguitars.com/ It´s the official Website of Haar Guitars. You may find a contact there.
Greg is a certified reseller: www.gregsguitars.de/en/products/21/Haar_handmade_guitars_from_NL.html
Aaand of course: www.justmusic.de/
Hello Rik. You can contact Erik (van der Haar) and order one. Just did. For a strat
Brass saddles on the European guitars
1 Maybach
2 Haar
3 Fender
Can you please share what pickups each guitar has?
The Haar has a set of Bareknuckle Flat 50s, the Maybach and the Fender came with stock Pickups. You can find the links in the description.
Haar because of the Maple Sound. I don,t like rosewood fretboard sound.
Great video, I appreciate the effort. It's a shame you didn't do a Bridge comparison too... :) What amp have you used?
Nuno, you are absolutely right! RME Fireface UC --> Cubase 7.5 --> Poulin Lextac & Poulin LeCab VSTs
@@jomitie Wow, I'm surprised, that's a very convincing sound! I thought it was a real amp.
I’ve got the Teleman 61 but I have to say in this video Haas won
Haar guitars are PLEK’d. That makes the difference in playability. Do you agree?
I don't. But it can make a difference if your guitar is not built that well. But a nicely built guitar can be as good as a plek'd one.
Maybach is the best
Interesting comparison and superb playing :) For me -
Haar, Fender, then Maybach.
Would have been nice to hear the Fender with brass saddles.
...der Vergleich hinkt,denn eine Esche-Tele mit Maple-Griffbrett klingt nun mal anders wie eine Erle mit Rosewood - das ist der berühmte Äpfel mit Birnen-Vergleich
Ja genau. Und die Esche-Tele mit Maple-Griffbrett hat mir besser gefallen.
Ja genau! daran muss es liegen! die unterschiedlichen Pickups haben natürlich keinerlei Einfluss auf den Sound!.. Aber esche, Ahorn und Rosewood! E-Gitarren klingen ja so unterschiedlich wegen der botanischen Systematik!....
Ja genau, daran muss es liegen. Das Holz hat keinerlei Einfluss auf den Sound! Als würden Westerngitarren wegen der Holzsorten unterschiedlich klingen.
@@everic Mal wieder was grundlegendes nicht kapiert, die alte Leier: bei akustischen Gitarren überträgt die Holzdecke die Saitenschwingung, bei elektrischen Gitarren die Tonabnehmer. Aus diesem Grund hat das Korpusholz und dessen Lackierung bei mit Tonabnehmern bestückten Brettgitarren auch praktisch keinen Einfluss auf den Klang. Das ist mittlerweile seit einigen Jahren von Prof. Zollener wissenschaftlich untersucht und dokumentiert, wird aber von Nitrojüngern, Flacherdlern und sonstigen Gitarre spielenden Postfaktikern geflissentlich ignoriert und geleugnet.
Nein! Sie klingen objektiv betrachtet nicht anders. Sie klingen nur dann anders, wenn man Unterschiede hören WILL!
Prof. Zollner hat in einem Hörversuch 26 Gitarristen Sondfiles von 4 unterschiedlichen Holzkombinationen vorgespielt. Die meisten Probanden hörten keine bis geringe Unterschiede. Einige hörten große Unterschiede. Die letzteren hörten aber auch dann große Unterschiede, wenn man ihnen die selben Soundfiles nacheinander vorspielte, und sie nur meinten, es handele sich um unterschiedliche Holzkombinationen.
Zum Versuch:
gitec-forum.de/wp/gitec-community/hoerversuche/
Bei einer akustischen Gitarre wird die Saitenschwingung und damit der Ton über den Holzkorpus zum Luftschall, den wir hören.
Bei einer Elektrischen Gitarre wird die Saitenschwingung via Tonabnehmer und Verstärker letztendlich durch die Speakermembran zum Luftschall. Was also bei der Akustiggitarre der Holzkorpus ist, sind bei der E-Gitarre Tonabnehmer, Verstärker und Lautsprecher und eben NICHT das Holz.
Im Übrigen können Boxenbespannstoffe die Höhen um bis zu 2dB bedämpfen. 3dB bedeuten eine Verdoppelung der wahrgenommenen Lautstärke. Warum wird nur so viel über Hölzer und Lacke diskutiert und hanebüchener Unsinn verzapft? Warum redet niemand über Gitarren Setup, LS Membranen und Bezugsstoffe? Die haben im Gegensatz zu Holz und Lack tatsächlich Einfluss auf den E-Gitarrensound.