Manik Ratan Part 3 -- Sharmila Tagore & Soumitra Chatterjee
Вставка
- Опубліковано 26 сер 2024
- Kolkata Literary Meet 2014, Day Four, January 28. Iconic actors and Satyajit Ray regulars Sharmila Tagore and Soumitra Chatterjee on being mentored by the master. In conversation with Chinmoy Guha, at Victoria Memorial Hall, Kolkata. A special session by EMTA.
শর্মিলা ঠাকুরের মতো একজন অভিনেত্রীর কাছ থেকে বাংলাদেশী একজন অভিনেত্রীকে নিয়ে এমন মন্তব্য একেবারেই অনভিপ্রেত এবং দুখঃজনক।
সৌমিত্র চাটার্জী আপনি অসাধারণ অভিনেতা, আবৃত্তিকার এবং সর্বোপরি মানুষ হিসাবে। আমরা আপনার জন্য গর্বিত।
This interview was wonderful!
মানিক রতন এই সাক্ষাৎ কার থেকে অনেক কিছু ই জানতে পারলাম। মানিকদা সম্পর্কে এবং আমার প্রিয় নায়ক ও অভিনেতা ও অভিনেত্রী শর্মিলার সম্পর্কে আরও গভির ভাবে জানতে পারলাম। ধন্যবাদ জানাই সবাই কে। ❤❤🎉🎉🎉
What you have seen is that when someone smiles, nature also smiles with her!!! Yeah I have seen.
I am no her time yet I think I am her age because I love Sharmila more than anyone in this world.
In the next birth or if we are reborn again, I am born as her own.
We all admire these great people, hence we expect even broad outlook from them. Sharmila Tagore is a fantastic actress. However, it seemed really disappointing watching at her confidence/ overconfidence. She not necessarily has to act in such manner comparing her talent with others. They are beyond the popularity and legendary personalities. Therefore, she shouldn't say directly in this manner. She didn't even mention Babita's name. Satyajit Ray films have been equally measured by her which is fair I believe. To a public questioner she uttered, "ask him to ask a question not comment", which shows her impatience and rather arrogance. Public may have opinion or questions either, so there is no need of being so directive to them.
I don't want to make comparison between them but the entire talks seems she is more dominating even on the mic. Best wishes for them!
You are probably aggrieved because you are from BD. I watched Ashani Sanket and to me (an ordinary viewer) Babita did excellent. Now if Sharmila Tagore cannot have confidence who else can? Do we always need politically correct answer or frank and candid response? Everyone has flaw. I'm huge fan of Sharmila and I took her comments as professional jealousy (which we all have in our limited spheres) and again I think Babita was too good in that role.
,@@justineray9001 I got your point too. However, I must clarify to you that I am not aggrieved at all. It's nothing like I and Babita are both from Bangladesh, therefore I felt low for the comment made by Sharmila Tagore.
Even if it was anybody else in the role that Babita played there, I would have reacted similarly due to the expression of Sharmila Tagore. There is nothing personal, but we always expect extensive outlook from such persons, rather than getting a reflection of even "professional jealousy". As a human we all have jealousy, but as a legendary public figure, nevertheless, they shouldn't reveal it towards media. Cheers!
@@ShakibKhanMimo I respectfully beg to differ with you. I don't like sugar coated politically correct interview from legends. Seen too many. They are rokto-mangsher choritro after all and it is much better to listen to what they really feel. Just like Yuvraj Singh excluded Dhoni from friends list in a recent video. Many female singers lost their career due to one lady (whom I immensely like otherwise) but only Shamshad Begum could point an oblique reference "Meri gaana jitni hit huyi, kaam utni kam milne laagi". And if Babita hits back someday against Rinku di, I'll love that too! Just me! Regards.
@@justineray9001 I got your point. Again, this is subject to personal perception, which you stated. Hence, we all have different preferences and opinions on things such as you prefer legends in order not to be "sugar-coated", so do I. However, I had simply expressed my opinion too and didn't mean to cause debate. Cheers! 🙏
অসাধারন আলোচনা।
একটা কথা শর্মিলা ঠাকুরের আমার ভালো লাগল না উত্তম কুমার সত্যজিৎ রায়ের সাথে কাজ করার পর ভালো অভিনয় করেছেন। হাসি পেল আবার অভিমান হলো।
Anchor is not a good listener. He is restless and not listening to the speakers. More concentrating on the list of questions
17:32 - কেটে গেলো। অন্য একটা প্রসঙ্গে আলোচনা শুরু হয়ে গেলো।
English subtitles please 😢
I will tell you in English... Do u like satyajit roy.... Then contact with me . I will give you more vedios of him with English subtitles.
@@sid2372 Satyajit ray not roy.
I agree with Sharmila Thakur that she could’ve done it better than Babita
Kin ,ctg
Treasurer
Try to speak in your mother tounge madam sharmila tagore. Mr soumitra chatterjee is all along expressing himself in bengali language which does not mean that he is illeterate.
Let her talk herself. She is a legend and we r nothing. So don't be so bengali. Bcoz we r not really very proud of bengali always.
অশনি সংকেতে ববিতার চেয়ে ভালো করতে পারতেন এ কথাটার মধ্যে শর্মীলা ঠাকুরের একটা অহংবোধ কাজ করেছে। এটা মোটেই ভালো লাগেনি। সমিত্র চট্রপাধ্যায় এক কথায় অসাধারণ।
No, it was the confidence. It was really an ordinary performance by Babita.
Soumitra name bananta bul. Sata thike karun, tarpara balban.
@@sukhenduchakraborty5606 অল্প বিদ্যা ভয়ংকর।
@@mjron1269 oti puthigata bidya ahankar .
@@mjron1269 bangladeshhi ra indiar sab byaparey nak galate ase,jemon apni .ahankare purno mon .apni ki dekhechen kar katodur bidya ? Bobita bd er bole gaye lagchhe naki ? Indian actor actress der sathe bd kono ovineta ovinetri tulona hayna .indian der acting international maner . Apnader katha barta vishon biroktikar .indiar sab avyontorin byapare katha bola chay ei chay januk r na januk .
No mam . impossible . Bobita is better than you. you can not do batter than bobita . you are a great artist but manikda thinks different . bobita is class.
Anchor ta k bhai.😂😂😂. Bangla bolte e jane na.
😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣😆😆😆
Irritating anchor. Emon ki microphone bujhte perechilo o jeno mukh na khole...😁
Sharmila Tagore aka Ayesha Begum is sounding arrogant and nonsensical
Bura hoye gese
Very poor anchoring.
Such a nonsense interviewer.
Should have made some home work, before interviewing such personalities.