LUMS's students proved that they know how to express their point of view with courage in front of dictators even but our Country's rotten system doesn't have any tolerance for such freedom of speech. Just Bravo for such courage ... May Allah protect you from any harm.
Hiw could u say that have those students who put their point of view across have been punished . No no one has said any wrong to them . Neither the caretaker pm said anything bad to them . Then how u can say what u have said
Well said Sir. At University of Toronto, they groom PhD students by inviting leading academic scientists to share their life experiences in an informal way. Students can freely ask how they got where they stand today. Unfortunately, in our society old people tend to look down upon young people.
Hats off to the LUMS students!! The presence of so many army officers sitting there did not intimidate them. The PM did answer but his tone was condescending. First of all he should have apologized for being late even before the bold student pointed it out. I just saw a clip if Imran Khan addressing LUMS students quite a few years ago and his opening remark was “first I would like to apologize to you for being late!” That is the hallmark of a true gentleman. Kakar has a long way to go!!
@@dharasutar student was right!! We are All ashamed of this puppet PM. The student had the courage to say it openly. In which country does a Caretaker PM go on foreign trips ??? His sole mandate is to ensure fair and free elections are held in 90 days. And he is supposed to be strictly neutral. So why is he giving an interview to a British journalist and saying elections can be held without PTI !!
Well, I’m DAMN sure that LUMS students were briefed before the session NOT to ask ANY question regarding IK at any cost. Army personnel were also seated amongst the guests to keep the situation AND the students under control..!!! I SO WISH students have dared a little more…!!!
کچھ بھی ہو، خان کا نام لیے بغیر باشعور و با حمیت یونیورسٹی سٹوڈنٹس نے کام تو خان کا ہی کیا ہے اور.....چڑا وچارا کی کرے، پانی، پانی پی مرے کے مصداق کاکڑ کُکڑ کو خوب سبق سکھایا ہے... کہ نہیں؟
*خان صاحب کے وکلاء سے درخواست ہے اگلی دفعہ جب ملاقات کے لیے جائیں تو انہیں بتائیے گا شعور کا جو پودا انہوں نے لگایا تھا وہ اب تنا آور درخت بن چکا ہے۔ پاکستان کے نوجوانوں نے ان کا مقدمہ لڑنا چھوڑا نہیں ہے۔ الحمدللہ*❤️❤️
جناب عالی ! ہم آپ کو بہت احترام اور غور سے سنتے ہیں ۔ مگر Sir آج آپ نے “ معذرت کے ساتھ “ بہت مایوس کیا ۔ اور کاکڑ صاحب تو مایوس کرتے ہی ۔ ان کے پاس نہ تو سچ تھا اور نہ کچھ علم ، بھلا ان کو آنا ہی نہیں چاہئے تھا اگر ان کے پاس proper جواب نہیں تھا ۔ پھر یہ تو ھونا ہی تھا ۔ مزید یہ کہ اس topic کو آج آپ نہ چھیڑتے ! نیکی کی سب سے نیچی مگر اچھی سطح ہے کہ بری بات کو کم آزادی کم دل میں برا سمجھا جائے ۔ معذرت !
جن سٹوڈنٹس نے سوال کیے غلام ڈمی وزیر اعظم سے، اللہ تعالٰی ان سٹوڈنٹس کو نامعلوم افراد سے بچائے اب تک وہ نامعلوم افراد ان سٹوڈنٹس کے گھر وغیرہ کا پتہ کروا چکے ہوں گے۔
جائے استاد خالی است.... لمز میں جو خوشگوار واقعہ رونما ہوا اس پہ بھانت بھانت کے تبصرے، تبرے، تجزیے پڑھنے کو ملے لیکن.... واللہ آپ کی گفتگو اس باب میں حرف آخر ہے.... اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کی توفیقات میں اضافہ فرمائے.... اللہ جبر و ستم کے اس دور نامسعود میں آپ ایسی مؤثر اور مفید شخصیت کو تادیر سلامت رکھے... آمین
جی آپ نے بالکل درست فرمایا کہ یہ مہذب معاشرے میں بہت عام سی بات ہے مگر ہم ٹہرے ہمیشہ کے غلام اور غلام کے منہ سے نکلنے والے سچ کے بھیانک نتائج نکلتے ہیں 😢 آپ ایسی بات کی حوصلہ افزائی نہ کریں جو ہمارے حکمرانوں کو ناگوار گزرے اور نتیجتاً ہمارے بچوں پر یہ زمین مزید تنگ کردی جائے۔ یہاں زخم تو کیا گلے سڑے پھپھوند زدہ وجود سے بھی آنکھیں چرائی جاتی ہیں
یونیورسٹی تک پہنچ کر بھی اگر سوال کرنے کی اجازت نہیں دیں گے ، یا سوال کرنے کی اگر جرت نہیں کریں گے تو بہتر ہے دیہاڑی دار پیدا ہوں۔ اسی رویے نے تباہ کیا ہے ۔ ڈبویا مجھ کو ہونے نے نہ ہوتا میں تو کیا ہوتا
ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت اچھی باتیں کیں آپنے،میرے خیال میں بچوں نے بہت شستہ لہجے میں سوالات کیئے،یہ ان کا حق تھا،لیکن کچھ لوگوں نےجن کا کام سوائے بوٹ پالش کرنے کے اور کچھ نہیں، بلا وجہ بچوں پر تنقید شروع کر دی،
بہت کم لوگوں نے اس بارے مثبت بات کی ۔ کوئ اسے وزیراعظم کی جیت قرار دے رہا ہے تو کو طلباء کی ۔ کیونکہ ہمارا معاشرہ ڈائلاگ کی بجائے محاذ آرائی کا قائل ہے ۔ ایسی گفتگو سننے کا عادی نہیں اس لیے عجیب تبصرے ہو رہے ہیں ۔ اللّٰــــــــــــــــہ تعالیٰ ہمیں ہدایت و شعور دے
Yes , as always thank you for wisely putting it in a nutshell that group dynamics respect empathy & values must always be kept in mind during such conversations and Im glad Kakr sb is genuinely a down to earth and a humble man 👏👏🙌🙌
Hats off to the students. I recommend whole generation to speak such critical questions about all issues related problems of country and all other institutions. Why people condemn these students
Not, questioning & holding authority accountable was forced on us by the British, unfortunately, it is still in our society. Hopefully, our future generation will break this cycle.
HE IS A GOOD PRIME MINISTER. HE EXPLAINED VERY WELL TO THE STUDENT. ACTUALLY OUR SOCIETY HAS BECOME SO NEGATIVE THAT THEY HAVE BROUGHT THE OUTCOME OF THAT CONVERSATION NEGATIVE.
I totally agree with it we are way behind than other countries in terms of medical knowledge. As a LUMS old student I want let we have all knowledge on the bases of research what is going on in developed countries rather than stuck on old knowledge which was done hundred yrs ago. Science is totally changed after specially COVID. These are my some thoughts to support our education system!!!!
So true ...100 percent agree.....nothing new only media given hype... they are our future and the plus point that our PM replied patiently.... yes there should be proper discussion ❤❤
The best part of LUMS & IBA is to developed opinion leaders, and this is the best example how these youngsters take up challenges & life. PM sb shoud have focused on his primary task of being a Caretaker, instead of going to places like LUMS, as he accepted, visiting a university is not his part of his responsibilities, so what triggered him to do this? Bilawal visited LUMS school of law in the past and was grilled by the students and ran away. Someone close to the PM sb should have told him on advance that it will be a bumpy ride 😊
Surely the freedom of expression is the basis of knowledge but unfortunately in Pakistan there are a numbers of laws and culture which forbids us to do this.
Great sir... Students of lums are great every student and every person should learn from them how to talk about their right and how to make accountable our servants
Thank God at least we have at least one institution where people can think on their own unlike the rest of them which aee nakal factories. I give kakar credit for showing up and listening what they had to say
When you empower your youth, be prepared to answer questions you are too afraid to answer. All the students remained respectful and asked whatever intrigued them. The PM on the other hand did not have any answers and instead mocked them, but he remained calm so props to that! I have always liked your videos, however in this video i cannot decipher your pov. Diplomatic statement!
Great sir, take the very positive conversation with our pride students Lifafa's journalist make the negative propaganda's of very valuable and intellectual discussion of our beloved Students
He didn't go there to listen yo the voice of youngsters. He went there to make them believe that establishment is on the right path and they're wrong. As advised by his supervisor Mr munir
The interim government cannot be asked the policy questions as they are not mandated for this. However the step was welcoming and should be continued. There should be open and on all open debate and dialogue on every matter.
جس طرح گاڑی بغیر پٹرول کی نہیں چلتی اس طرح پاکستان میں حکومتیں جنرلز کرنلز کے بغیر نہیں چلتی یہ دونوں چیزیں لازم آور ملزوم ہیں۔۔ہمیشہ سے چیف آرمی کی سمری پینٹاگان سے منظور ہو کر پاکستان پہنچتی ہیں۔ پھر وہی ناپاک ہندو نسل امریکی مفادات کا تحفظ کرے گا۔ماں دھرتی کا نہیں کیونکہ اس کے سب کچھ یورپ امریکہ دبئی میں ہوتے ہیں۔۔سوچنے والی بات ہے۔۔میرے محب وطن پاکستانیوں
سر نہ ہم MIT ہیں ،نہ Oxford, نہ ہی مہذب معاشرہ. ہم ایک ایسا معاشرہ ہیں جس کو اشرافیہ نے مستقل اپنے دباؤ میں رکھا ہوا ہے، اور یہ آج کی بات نہیں، اسکا تسلسل پچھلے 75 سال سے ہوتا چلا آرہا ہے. جو سوالات ان بچوں نے کیئے وہ سوالات اگر آپ کی عمر کا کوئی فرد کرتا تو آج وہ کہاں ہوتا یہ آپ بھی اچھی طرح جانتے ہیں 😢
I agree that this kind of opportunity should be provided to students across the board. Students at this event were very polite and at the same time spoke their hearts. In my opinion, you should address the following points in your Vlog too. 1. I don't think Mr. Kakkar was prepared or open to these types of questions from the students. His attitude, arrogance, and confusion reflected that throughout the event. Mocking and calling names to the student who pointed out the tardiness of CTPM left a very bad taste. 2. Pretending to be the macho man who knows everything about the country and everyone else (bloody civilians) is an idiot is a behavior we the adults need to fix first before we try to show off that I am the best leader the land has produced.
In addition, the elections is going to be held in Feb 2024. In this connection all parties are going to announce their manifesto. I would suggest that the heads of political parties visit atleast one university of every province of the country and present their manifesto before the students and prove that it is workable. Prevailing practice is that they announce manifesto in a press conference of selected reporters, jo bohet wah, wah kertay hain and on one ask how they implement it.
Agree with some of your comments. Sadly when an individual is an implanted prime minister with no credentials and pitches up for a photoshoot opportunity to face the younger and brighter students then humiliation is inevitable. You cannot order police raid on those who dared to ask the difficult questions because of lack of ability and unjust appointment as PM of the country. Unfortunately this heavy handed approach has no place in the modern society. Shamim Khan
More than anything the freedom of expression leads to thinking process which should be encouraged. It is the thinking process that leads to development from art to literature, science and new inventions; suppressing freedom of expression is discouraging thinking leading to inertia in all walks of life.
Good step by care taker p.m. Students were unable to ask any critical thinking based question . The contents of questions were not focusing on any research or analytical ideas. They just wanted to get projection on social media .
Sir hamara mulk ore doosrey countries main bohat farq hay woh caretaker government permanent nahi apney aap ko wazireazam samajti In bachon ki bahadri ko salam hay
Your statement is justified. Unfortunately things happening in Pakistan is so unusual and one sided. People will take normal things towards extremism. Still i must say caretaking government is acting like puppet..... may be this might be the reason of extra focus on such incident
Thank you Professor Dr. Javed Iqbal for explaining the LUMS event in a civilized manner to some uncivilized people. Respectfully, I disagree with your opion that Kakar's behavior was normal. I strongly believe he was rude, hypocrite, pharone, arrogant and proved himself to be a part of notorious fascist regime of Banana Republic of Pakistan. Puppet Kakar seriously suffers from inferiority complex and personality syndrome. Salute to LUMS bold and braved students who courageosly dared to face a stooge of the brutal Establishment.
While agreeing to your point of view, it is unfortunate the way social media players picked up the tinted questions and deliberately avoided the responses by the worthy Prime Minister. This post action induced controversy.
Sir, only those should visit universities, who have some moral values like truthfulness, honesty, dignity, fear of God, some high standards of norms n values, self consciousness, patience, etc. Kakar has nothing like this. He doesn't deserve to visit universities. What students of lums have done with him actually he deserves this.
Sir aap ne bachon ko tameez k dairay mein baat karne ka tto keh diya. Par prime minister aur other bureaucrats ko bhi yehi talkeen karte tto bohat acha hota. Kyun k bachon ne tto darr darr kar sawal poochay hain aur kukkar sahab ne tto un mein se kafi bachon ko lafzon se dhamkane aur un ki insult bhi ki hai.
Sir gee Pakistan mein kahan SE woh ilm kahan SE haasil ho ga jisko hasil krnay k Baad Pakistan ka rule of law or judicial system ki ranking World ki top 100 ranking mein aa skay???
Sir you should realize its definitely not the conduct of the students that should be debated. It was a straight forward approach by the students which doesn't need to be discussed. In fact they were quite reserved in their questioing. Not one of them mentioned IK. What you should be talking about is the poor conduct of Kakar and his superfluous response to the questions.
LUMS's students proved that they know how to express their point of view with courage in front of dictators even but our Country's rotten system doesn't have any tolerance for such freedom of speech. Just Bravo for such courage ... May Allah protect you from any harm.
Hiw could u say that have those students who put their point of view across have been punished . No no one has said any wrong to them . Neither the caretaker pm said anything bad to them . Then how u can say what u have said
Well said Sir. At University of Toronto, they groom PhD students by inviting leading academic scientists to share their life experiences in an informal way. Students can freely ask how they got where they stand today. Unfortunately, in our society old people tend to look down upon young people.
Hats off to the LUMS students!! The presence of so many army officers sitting there did not intimidate them. The PM did answer but his tone was condescending. First of all he should have apologized for being late even before the bold student pointed it out. I just saw a clip if Imran Khan addressing LUMS students quite a few years ago and his opening remark was “first I would like to apologize to you for being late!” That is the hallmark of a true gentleman. Kakar has a long way to go!!
But the boy started the question condenwnding manner , he said he is ashamed of his prime minister act ……
@@dharasutar student was right!! We are All ashamed of this puppet PM. The student had the courage to say it openly. In which country does a Caretaker PM go on foreign trips ??? His sole mandate is to ensure fair and free elections are held in 90 days. And he is supposed to be strictly neutral. So why is he giving an interview to a British journalist and saying elections can be held without PTI !!
@rehanapotter1042 Totally agree on your all points of view.
You absolutely right 👍
Sir thank you so much for your endorsement of the essential dialogue between the caretaker PM & the students of LUMS❤❤.❤ ❤❤❤
Everybody need a freedom of expression with respect .🙏🏻
good
Well, I’m DAMN sure that LUMS students were briefed before the session NOT to ask ANY question regarding IK at any cost. Army personnel were also seated amongst the guests to keep the situation AND the students under control..!!!
I SO WISH students have dared a little more…!!!
It was not a platform to politicise , students should not drag it into such sessions
But it was only way to ask about our leader
@@khaledaziz8533When a ‘caretaker’ pm is made to visit a knowledge hub, the intention is nothing but pure politics…
Dr. Sb.
Today student is on-line....and broad visioned.
کچھ بھی ہو، خان کا نام لیے بغیر باشعور و با حمیت یونیورسٹی سٹوڈنٹس نے کام تو خان کا ہی کیا ہے اور.....چڑا وچارا کی کرے، پانی، پانی پی مرے کے مصداق کاکڑ کُکڑ کو خوب سبق سکھایا ہے... کہ نہیں؟
کاکڑ صاحب کا کام الیکشن کی طرف توجہ دینی چاہیے۔
منتخب شدہ وزیراعظم ضرور یونیورسٹیوں میں جایں۔
*خان صاحب کے وکلاء سے درخواست ہے اگلی دفعہ جب ملاقات کے لیے جائیں تو انہیں بتائیے گا شعور کا جو پودا انہوں نے لگایا تھا وہ اب تنا آور درخت بن چکا ہے۔ پاکستان کے نوجوانوں نے ان کا مقدمہ لڑنا چھوڑا نہیں ہے۔ الحمدللہ*❤️❤️
جناب عالی ! ہم آپ کو بہت احترام اور غور سے سنتے ہیں ۔ مگر Sir آج آپ نے “ معذرت کے ساتھ “ بہت مایوس کیا ۔ اور کاکڑ صاحب تو مایوس
کرتے ہی ۔ ان کے پاس نہ تو سچ تھا اور نہ کچھ علم ، بھلا ان کو آنا ہی نہیں چاہئے تھا اگر ان کے پاس proper جواب نہیں تھا ۔ پھر یہ تو ھونا ہی
تھا ۔ مزید یہ کہ اس topic کو آج آپ نہ چھیڑتے ! نیکی کی سب سے نیچی مگر اچھی سطح ہے کہ بری بات کو کم آزادی کم دل میں برا سمجھا جائے ۔ معذرت !
😢 !
“If you want to be the best, you have to do the things that other people aren’t willing to do.” -Michael Phelps - - - Imran Khan zindabad
جن سٹوڈنٹس نے سوال کیے غلام ڈمی وزیر اعظم سے، اللہ تعالٰی ان سٹوڈنٹس کو نامعلوم افراد سے بچائے اب تک وہ نامعلوم افراد ان سٹوڈنٹس کے گھر وغیرہ کا پتہ کروا چکے ہوں گے۔
Time is money, time is success, time is everything.
This shows how youth is anxious about their future.
سر، آپ نے سچ اور حق بات کی ہے. جزاک اللہ خیرا.
Asim Muneer should come to Lums too 😂.
The students asked great questions from Mr Kakar. Unfortunately, he failed to answer them honestly. What a shame.
Which question did he fail to answer?
@@syedhussainalishah1104 In my opinion, all.
Ok it's your opinion.. Nothing else 🤷♀️
جائے استاد خالی است....
لمز میں جو خوشگوار واقعہ رونما ہوا اس پہ بھانت بھانت کے تبصرے، تبرے، تجزیے پڑھنے کو ملے لیکن.... واللہ آپ کی گفتگو اس باب میں حرف آخر ہے.... اللہ تعالیٰ آپ کی توفیقات میں اضافہ فرمائے.... اللہ جبر و ستم کے اس دور نامسعود میں آپ ایسی مؤثر اور مفید شخصیت کو تادیر سلامت رکھے... آمین
جی آپ نے بالکل درست فرمایا کہ یہ مہذب معاشرے میں بہت عام سی بات ہے مگر ہم ٹہرے ہمیشہ کے غلام اور غلام کے منہ سے نکلنے والے سچ کے بھیانک نتائج نکلتے ہیں 😢
آپ ایسی بات کی حوصلہ افزائی نہ کریں جو ہمارے حکمرانوں کو ناگوار گزرے اور نتیجتاً ہمارے بچوں پر یہ زمین مزید تنگ کردی جائے۔ یہاں زخم تو کیا گلے سڑے پھپھوند زدہ وجود سے بھی آنکھیں چرائی جاتی ہیں
یونیورسٹی تک پہنچ کر بھی اگر سوال کرنے کی اجازت نہیں دیں گے ، یا سوال کرنے کی اگر جرت نہیں کریں گے تو بہتر ہے دیہاڑی دار پیدا ہوں۔
اسی رویے نے تباہ کیا ہے ۔
ڈبویا مجھ کو ہونے نے
نہ ہوتا میں تو کیا ہوتا
LUMS k students ny bht achy treeqay sy apna point of view convey kiya
Hats off to those students! They asked Qs what we all wanted to knw the answers for. Well done!
As a matter of fact CT PM failed badly to justify his position.
Perfect approach and very essential points discussed sir. Allah bless you always
سر عمران ریاض کے بارے میں کچھ روشنی ڈالیں گے ۔
ڈاکٹر صاحب بہت اچھی باتیں کیں آپنے،میرے خیال میں بچوں نے بہت شستہ لہجے میں سوالات کیئے،یہ ان کا حق تھا،لیکن کچھ لوگوں نےجن کا کام سوائے بوٹ پالش کرنے کے اور کچھ نہیں، بلا وجہ بچوں پر تنقید شروع کر دی،
بہت کم لوگوں نے اس بارے مثبت بات کی ۔ کوئ اسے وزیراعظم کی جیت قرار دے رہا ہے تو کو طلباء کی ۔ کیونکہ ہمارا معاشرہ ڈائلاگ کی بجائے محاذ آرائی کا قائل ہے ۔ ایسی گفتگو سننے کا عادی نہیں اس لیے عجیب تبصرے ہو رہے ہیں ۔
اللّٰــــــــــــــــہ تعالیٰ ہمیں ہدایت و شعور دے
Yes , as always thank you for wisely putting it in a nutshell that group dynamics respect empathy & values must always be kept in mind during such conversations and Im glad Kakr sb is genuinely a down to earth and a humble man 👏👏🙌🙌
Hats off to the students. I recommend whole generation to speak such critical questions about all issues related problems of country and all other institutions.
Why people condemn these students
ماشاءاللہ بہت بہت شکریہ جاوید بھائی آپ نے
قوم کی رھنمائ فرمایئھے
Not, questioning & holding authority accountable was forced on us by the British, unfortunately, it is still in our society. Hopefully, our future generation will break this cycle.
HE IS A GOOD PRIME MINISTER. HE EXPLAINED VERY WELL TO THE STUDENT.
ACTUALLY OUR SOCIETY HAS BECOME SO NEGATIVE THAT THEY HAVE BROUGHT THE OUTCOME OF THAT CONVERSATION NEGATIVE.
I totally agree with it we are way behind than other countries in terms of medical knowledge. As a LUMS old student I want let we have all knowledge on the bases of research what is going on in developed countries rather than stuck on old knowledge which was done hundred yrs ago. Science is totally changed after specially COVID. These are my some thoughts to support our education system!!!!
Students asked very clear questions, salute
Sir bilkul sahi farma rahy hyn ap. Baddkismati sy hm ny sawal poochny ko badtamizi shumaar krlia hy.
Zabardast baat ki aap nay.bacho ko mentor milnay chahiye.
So true ...100 percent agree.....nothing new only media given hype... they are our future and the plus point that our PM replied patiently.... yes there should be proper discussion ❤❤
The best part of LUMS & IBA is to developed opinion leaders, and this is the best example how these youngsters take up challenges & life.
PM sb shoud have focused on his primary task of being a Caretaker, instead of going to places like LUMS, as he accepted, visiting a university is not his part of his responsibilities, so what triggered him to do this?
Bilawal visited LUMS school of law in the past and was grilled by the students and ran away. Someone close to the PM sb should have told him on advance that it will be a bumpy ride 😊
Ur analysis is always best.... You can speak the truth and the reality.. ❤
I believe the questions should be asked respectfully n they should’ve to ask questions which impact their future
The questions asked had an impact on their future.
Could you please list down the questions which the students asked and didn't have any impact on their future. Let's examine.
Surely the freedom of expression is the basis of knowledge but unfortunately in Pakistan there are a numbers of laws and culture which forbids us to do this.
It's not laws as we have non...its the corrupt structure and 4 mafia pillows that carry this cancer
Only military intervention forbid us to do this. We are not worried about dumb laws and culture.
بلکل ٹھیک کہا آپ نے سر I agree with you 💯
Dr sab thanks 😊 Our students are our proud. And future of Pakistan zindabad 😊
I am unable to understand what intelligent questions the students of Lums University asked ?
FULLY AGREED WITH YOU .👍👌DUNYA KEE BURREE BURREE UNIVERSITIES MEIN YE AAM BAAT HAI LEKIN YAHAN TOU JUMHUREYUT K NAAM PER BAADSHAHUT HAI .
Great sir...
Students of lums are great every student and every person should learn from them how to talk about their right and how to make accountable our servants
Thank God at least we have at least one institution where people can think on their own unlike the rest of them which aee nakal factories. I give kakar credit for showing up and listening what they had to say
We appreciate the students. Very well done
I appreciate these students they have right to question
When you empower your youth, be prepared to answer questions you are too afraid to answer. All the students remained respectful and asked whatever intrigued them. The PM on the other hand did not have any answers and instead mocked them, but he remained calm so props to that!
I have always liked your videos, however in this video i cannot decipher your pov. Diplomatic statement!
Great sir, take the very positive conversation with our pride students
Lifafa's journalist make the negative propaganda's of very valuable and intellectual discussion of our beloved Students
He didn't go there to listen yo the voice of youngsters. He went there to make them believe that establishment is on the right path and they're wrong. As advised by his supervisor Mr munir
اللهم صل و سلم و بارك على' نبينا محمد و آله
Very well said 👍🏻🎉
,جو بات قابل فخر تھی اسے میڈیا نے اسے غلط رنگ دیا سٹودنٹ صاحب شعور ھیں یہ سوال کرنے کا شعور اور جرّاحت رکھتے ھیں
کاش کہ ہمارے میڈیا مین بھی اسی طرح کی پڑھی لکھی سوچ کے لوگ ہوتے تو یہ سب نہ ہوتا۔
Absolutely right. Stay blessed.
The interim government cannot be asked the policy questions as they are not mandated for this. However the step was welcoming and should be continued. There should be open and on all open debate and dialogue on every matter.
Really love you sir i heard your videos daily sir ❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
جس طرح گاڑی بغیر پٹرول کی نہیں چلتی اس طرح پاکستان میں حکومتیں جنرلز کرنلز کے بغیر نہیں چلتی یہ دونوں چیزیں لازم آور ملزوم ہیں۔۔ہمیشہ سے چیف آرمی کی سمری پینٹاگان سے منظور ہو کر پاکستان پہنچتی ہیں۔ پھر وہی ناپاک ہندو نسل امریکی مفادات کا تحفظ کرے گا۔ماں دھرتی کا نہیں کیونکہ اس کے سب کچھ یورپ امریکہ دبئی میں ہوتے ہیں۔۔سوچنے والی بات ہے۔۔میرے محب وطن پاکستانیوں
سر نہ ہم MIT ہیں ،نہ Oxford, نہ ہی مہذب معاشرہ.
ہم ایک ایسا معاشرہ ہیں جس کو اشرافیہ نے مستقل اپنے دباؤ میں رکھا ہوا ہے، اور یہ آج کی بات نہیں، اسکا تسلسل پچھلے 75 سال سے ہوتا چلا آرہا ہے.
جو سوالات ان بچوں نے کیئے وہ سوالات اگر آپ کی عمر کا کوئی فرد کرتا تو آج وہ کہاں ہوتا یہ آپ بھی اچھی طرح جانتے ہیں 😢
Thank you my respected sir
Sir, its not about what students said and what PM replied.
Events just showed how much youth abhors current regime
Exactly. The students asked intelligent questions but the response did not meet criteria of intelligent response
Dr. Sb.he is not caretaker pm,ge is occupied pm. Say him occupied pm.
These were totally normal questions but feels awkward to those who are hypocrite to their responsibilities and loyalties beyond their self interests.
I agree that this kind of opportunity should be provided to students across the board. Students at this event were very polite and at the same time spoke their hearts. In my opinion, you should address the following points in your Vlog too.
1. I don't think Mr. Kakkar was prepared or open to these types of questions from the students. His attitude, arrogance, and confusion reflected that throughout the event. Mocking and calling names to the student who pointed out the tardiness of CTPM left a very bad taste.
2. Pretending to be the macho man who knows everything about the country and everyone else (bloody civilians) is an idiot is a behavior we the adults need to fix first before we try to show off that I am the best leader the land has produced.
Excellently explained Sir !
Highly appreciated.
Well done students😅. These so called politicians shouldn’t be called leaders.
Go Nawaz go
You are so right dr sb. ❤
Value of others' time is a universal right. Why can a person not ask another why he/she came to an event 50 minutes late?
In addition, the elections is going to be held in Feb 2024. In this connection all parties are going to announce their manifesto. I would suggest that the heads of political parties visit atleast one university of every province of the country and present their manifesto before the students and prove that it is workable. Prevailing practice is that they announce manifesto in a press conference of selected reporters, jo bohet wah, wah kertay hain and on one ask how they implement it.
Agree with some of your comments. Sadly when an individual is an implanted prime minister with no credentials and pitches up for a photoshoot opportunity to face the younger and brighter students then humiliation is inevitable. You cannot order police raid on those who dared to ask the difficult questions because of lack of ability and unjust appointment as PM of the country. Unfortunately this heavy handed approach has no place in the modern society. Shamim Khan
All credit goes to IK who has given awareness to masses check and Balance is the rule of progress
Lums being Lums kudos to all those students ❤❤❤
More than anything the freedom of expression leads to thinking process which should be encouraged. It is the thinking process that leads to development from art to literature, science and new inventions; suppressing freedom of expression is discouraging thinking leading to inertia in all walks of life.
Good step by care taker p.m.
Students were unable to ask any critical thinking based question . The contents of questions were not focusing on any research or analytical ideas.
They just wanted to get projection on social media .
Sir hamara mulk ore doosrey countries main bohat farq hay woh caretaker government permanent nahi apney aap ko wazireazam samajti
In bachon ki bahadri ko salam hay
A very good talk.
I agreed..dono side ki questioning answering best thi.
Well said dr sab ❤❤
May Allah SWT protect those students of LUMS from Agencies high hindrance, who put questions to Dummy PM and shown him mirror
Your statement is justified. Unfortunately things happening in Pakistan is so unusual and one sided. People will take normal things towards extremism. Still i must say caretaking government is acting like puppet..... may be this might be the reason of extra focus on such incident
Buhat hi zabardast❤
Beautifully said ❤️
Weidone sir very well justification n explanations.
Beautiful analysis 👌
Thank you Professor Dr. Javed Iqbal for explaining the LUMS event in a civilized manner to some uncivilized people. Respectfully, I disagree with your opion that Kakar's behavior was normal. I strongly believe he was rude, hypocrite, pharone, arrogant and proved himself to be a part of notorious fascist regime of Banana Republic of Pakistan. Puppet Kakar seriously suffers from inferiority complex and personality syndrome. Salute to LUMS bold and braved students who courageosly dared to face a stooge of the brutal Establishment.
Great Sir, you're my ideal.
Zabardast!!
Bahut he behtareen
While agreeing to your point of view, it is unfortunate the way social media players picked up the tinted questions and deliberately avoided the responses by the worthy Prime Minister. This post action induced controversy.
Khoobsoraat baataien.
Sir, only those should visit universities, who have some moral values like truthfulness, honesty, dignity, fear of God, some high standards of norms n values, self consciousness, patience, etc. Kakar has nothing like this. He doesn't deserve to visit universities. What students of lums have done with him actually he deserves this.
No one is ready to speak out about this fact that this kakar's interaction with students was a new version of ISPR's media interaction.
A positive and objective analysis
Any question was about democracy , foreign policy and other related issues?
Sir aap ne bachon ko tameez k dairay mein baat karne ka tto keh diya. Par prime minister aur other bureaucrats ko bhi yehi talkeen karte tto bohat acha hota.
Kyun k bachon ne tto darr darr kar sawal poochay hain aur kukkar sahab ne tto un mein se kafi bachon ko lafzon se dhamkane aur un ki insult bhi ki hai.
شکر ہے سر جی آپ نے تو کچھ اچھا بولا
Well said doctor sahib
Sir gee Pakistan mein kahan SE woh ilm kahan SE haasil ho ga jisko hasil krnay k Baad Pakistan ka rule of law or judicial system ki ranking World ki top 100 ranking mein aa skay???
Sir you should realize its definitely not the conduct of the students that should be debated. It was a straight forward approach by the students which doesn't need to be discussed. In fact they were quite reserved in their questioing. Not one of them mentioned IK.
What you should be talking about is the poor conduct of Kakar and his superfluous response to the questions.
Agreed. P.m responded well.impartial view.
LUMS University k tamaam talaba o talibaat bohot SANJEEDAH aur SULJHAY howay hain. Allah salamat rakhay, hifz o aman me rakhay, aameen🤲🤲.