EGO VS Stihl Chain Saws. Electric vs Gas. Watch to the end.

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 18 жов 2024
  • If you are trying to make a decision as to which chain saw to buy, this video will make your decision clearer.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 83

  • @chausonharmon693
    @chausonharmon693 Рік тому +30

    That Stihl chainsaw is 3 times the cost of that Ego one you are testing it against. The Ego 18” new one is rated at 45cc the equivalent would be the MS 251. Are you going to now show us that a Nissan Leaf can’t tow as much as an F250?

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +3

      but the right tool for the job is the message. EGO has it's place. I'm just saying it like it is. Nissan Leaf has it's place too. Spend the money as needed is what I'm saying. Electric chainsaws are for branches, not trunks. Some people like me thought EGO was equivalent to gas. Now I know, jut has to spend the money on both to learn, and sharing my experience so expectations are clear.

    • @chausonharmon693
      @chausonharmon693 Рік тому +2

      @@everydaypawel9193 If you purchased the newer model the 18” there would be a tremendous difference. You are also using the 2.5 amp hour battery which is horrible due to the battery overheating and essentially running out of power. Buy a product of a similar cost and compare it. Even the highest rated chainsaw that is battery powered is not even close to your comparison. Did you know that if you buy a truck that is rated to tow 8,000 lbs that one that is rated to tow 10,000 lbs can tow more?

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      @@chausonharmon693 it is a 5 amp hour battery, (i might have said 5.5 in the video). the new EGO model was not available 2-3 years ago. Tow capacity and duration of cut are 2 different things. There was minimal resistance (force) on the saw. Either way, there is a place for EGO, and it is smaller stuff.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  3 місяці тому

      @@chausonharmon693 good comparison explanation!!! I learned the electric saw starts to fail because the battery needs replacing not charging… even if the battery still works fine in leaf blower and string trimmer. I believe chainsaw resistance has a high ramp demand.😃 live and learn.

  • @danielmarkleblanc1800
    @danielmarkleblanc1800 Рік тому +3

    I have the new ECHO 56V eFORCE Cordless 18-inch Rear Handle Chain Saw with 2/5Ah Batteries and it's amazing. It certainly doesn't shut down during large cuts like the Ego does and it gives my Stihl MS 250 a run for it's money. Sure it doesn't have the staying power of my gas powered saw unless I you purchased additional batteries but it still a strong saw which is only limited by its battery source like a gas powered saw is limited by its fuel source. Not all electric saws are made equal. Love you're video, keep them coming.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      Thanks. right tool for the job. tools may be interchangeable but not equal.

    • @John-cj3ve
      @John-cj3ve 4 місяці тому

      I agree! I have a pair of CS1800's; and I think they're great. In my younger years; I used to have half a dozen Stihl saws; three of them over 100cc's; so I know what power is like.
      You can stall ANY saw; but my 1800's don't stall in normal use.

  • @donaldvosburgh8337
    @donaldvosburgh8337 5 місяців тому +2

    I have a Husqvarna 51. I bought the EGO 16” to stand in a stream while cutting downed tree limbs into smaller pieces to clean up the mess. Taking the gas saw means it’s always idling and the chain can move. The EGO only moves when you pull the trigger. Safer operation. The limbs are rarely larger the 6”, so it does what it’s designed to do. I don’t get the battery wet because I only cut what’s out of the water. I get what you’re saying about the power of gas in getting through larger pieces.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  5 місяців тому +1

      Yes, every tool has its place, I left me green works electric in the rain for 2 days, found it in a 1 inch puddle, let it dry for a couple days, worked great later!!!!!

  • @yensive826
    @yensive826 3 місяці тому +1

    i bought a 500i last year (the baddest saw on the planet) and today i cut fire wood for the 1st time with the ego 16 inch (ive got plenty of batteries) did all the cutting i could handle today. Put the 500i up for sale and getting the ego commercial chainsaw next (ego csx5000). but if i was cutting 25inch+ logs all day id be keeping the 500i

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  3 місяці тому +1

      @@yensive826 I learned the saw fails only because the battery needs replacing… not charging.

  • @JaceDrummer
    @JaceDrummer 3 місяці тому +1

    My cousin brought over his gas Stihl chainsaw to help me cut a large tree limb that fell on my shed. He takes very good care of his tools. His worked well but he had a few stalls and had to play with it more than once. Afterwords I then asked him cut a tree down for me, it was about 9", he could not get his chainsaw started again no matter what he did. I got out my Ego 14" and it cut it no problem. I since upgraded to the 18" which is around 11,000 rpm, more a fair comparison to gas. I agree, if I was cutting trees all day , use a gas one, batteries can be a pain for a lot of work like that. But the 18" could cut that log and is great for a majority of what you need to do if you are not doing heavy duty work. Different tools for different things.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  2 місяці тому

      I agree, I can't start my Stihl now. Same shop that sold it to me said$700 for repairs, same cost of a new one. They are smoking shit. I bough spark plug, an engine rebuild kit is $45 on amazon. We'll see. that's why I end up doing everything my else. Also the only issue with the electric saw was I needed New Battery.

  • @gregkocher5352
    @gregkocher5352 9 місяців тому +1

    I get good results with the Kobalt 80V Max 18inch chain saw. I do have 2 batteries. Very nice for quick clean up and small jobs. I keep it in the truck for cleaning wind falls.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  9 місяців тому +1

      All chain saws are good. They all have a place and limitations. Not all are created equal.

  • @vstromrider625
    @vstromrider625 Рік тому +9

    The EGO's 14" and the older 16 " have a weaker motor that runs at a much lower RPM than their new 16 and 18 inch which has rpm of 11000 rpm. Those little 14 and 16 inch also run a much smaller gauge chain. They are definitely not up to task for the big wood you have. Comparing a 261 to any box store electric saw is a bit of a stretch. As you said $700 vs $200. That is about what I would expect for a result.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +3

      True, it is not an equal comparison.. but that is kind of the point. I recently saw info on the faster speed EGO saw. The Point I was trying to get across is to get the right tool for the job, my EGO saw was not good enough and that is what I want people to be aware of when they make their purchase decision. I was not informed and just trying to share reality. I have cut a lot of wood with the EGO so it certainly has a place in the market. Thanks for your comments and thanks for watching!

    • @vstromrider625
      @vstromrider625 Рік тому +3

      One of the things I really like the electric saw for is when I am using the chipper. I use a 40-volt WEN saw for the chipper. It tends to throw the chain sometime, Can’t expect too much for $157. But it is nice to not have to start a gas saw just to trim a branch that is too snaggy to get down the chipper chute. Just pull the trigger and let go.
      I use an MS211 for falling and bucking but most the stuff I process is 12 inches of less. I put that little Stihl threw the ringer removing a 12 foot water oak stump a couple of years ago. I thought I the saw was a dead. New blade, chain, sprocket/clutch and a thorough cleaning, put her back an action. The motor strong as it ever was. Stihl makes a tough product. The 211 being a homeowner saw does not come close to the quality of your 261.
      I had bought a couple of other EGO products for yardwork last year and was quite impressed with the quality and power. I wanted another 5 amp hour battery but the cost of the battery alone was $249. The EGO 18” Saw package with charger and 5.0 amp battery was $399, With my veteran discount I picked it up for $359. After I deduct the $249 it would have cost me to buy just a battery I ended up paying $110 for the saw and another charger. EGO has upgraded the motor on the 16- and 18-inch saws. The old 14 and 16 inch spun at 6800 rpm. This 18 inch and the new 16 inch spin at 11,000 rpm. The 18 inch also runs a .050” gauge vs the .043” run on the smaller saws.
      EGO claims the 18 inch is on par with a 45cc saw. I think that might be a stretch. The biggest difference I see between a gasser and electric is the batteries overheat when you push the load limits of the saw. We saw that with your demo. A gas saw handles over loads much differently. Motor bogs a bit , back off and hit it again. If it runs at least like my MS 211 I will be OK with that I never had a need for a Pro saw. Everything I have used over the last 40 years was 35 -40 cc. My favorite was a McCulloch "Mac Cat" back in the early 90's. It was a beast of a small saw. Keep on chucking wood!

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      Thanks.

  • @Gunk8642
    @Gunk8642 3 місяці тому +1

    Try that again with the correct sized saw. Try the 20inch Ego, more powerful motor. If it stalls easily then I buy your argument. By the way I have two Gas saws, big and small. Love your comment about cold weather and batteries. trying not to annoying Wife and neighbors is reason to look. Keeping wife happy, sure I can live with three saws.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  3 місяці тому +1

      I just figured out the battery just started dying is the reason the saw kept stalling. The battery worked great on blower and string trimmer, but the saw takes a lot of juice. I started using 10amp hour EGO batteries and it works great!!!!

  • @nikhuynh7045
    @nikhuynh7045 Рік тому +3

    Watched your video more than a few times. You said that it was brand new out of the box. The battery was blinking before it stalled. It probably stalled because there wasn't any bar oil in it and it was overheating. From what I can see in your video, the bar oil tank on the Ego you used was empty.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      The chain was brand new, meaning sharp. I haven't used the EGO Since. I'm going to check the oil level. The battery was fully charged at room temperature. The battery in my leaf blower works great.

  • @michman2
    @michman2 Рік тому +1

    Well, DUH. The larger, more powerful saw with the longer blade cut better than a smaller one.
    Buy an equivalent electric and do that test over. Your results will change.
    I cut, cleaned and stacked 27 8" to 15" poplars last week with that very 16" Ego on 3 charges. The battery outlasted me every time I went out to work. No gas, no fumes, no idling, no pull starting.
    I'll never own a gas saw again.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +1

      Unfortunately, I had to learn the hard way, firsthand, because I didn't know. So I was hoping to share something if others didn't know. I am not aware of equivalent high-power electric says is the lesson I learned.

  • @John-jw7cq
    @John-jw7cq Рік тому +1

    Great video. For the big wood you should get a bigger chainsaw like a stihl 462,500i or 661. I own 261 and 462 love them. Cheers!

  • @lousweet6878
    @lousweet6878 Рік тому +2

    Bar. Not blade. They both have their place. I have a gas Stihl and Husqvarna and an ego 1803. I use them all.

  • @Nono-rh4lr
    @Nono-rh4lr Рік тому +1

    Noticed the battery was flashing red right before it cut out on you. Maybe overheating. Def something to think about. I guess I'm going to stick with my MS250 gas. I could rip that 10" log way faster with my 250.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +1

      yes, battery was flashing. It will do that with the battery low or when you press too hard. the battery was fully charged in a warm room, I was not pressing hard, and brand-new sharp chain in this video. I think the resistance of a chain on a wider log just causes it to stall. if you cut smaller logs or branches, there is minimum resistance and a stop in between cuts, it will keep going. I guess they already make a upgraded version of this saw. My opinion, electric is ok for small stuff. Happy I got a more powerful gas saw. Each has it's place. Thanks for watching!

  • @JamesCouch777
    @JamesCouch777 2 місяці тому

    My issue with the electric saw would be that, if it's anything like all the other battery powered tools I have, the battery will only last a couple of years before it's worthless. A gas saw will last 10-20 years if you take care of it.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  2 місяці тому

      @@JamesCouch777 I don’t know how to take care of a gas saw. That’s why I broke mine. I’m a loser big time! The battery is equal to gasoline you waste, electric motors last longer than gas motors.

  • @danno180
    @danno180 Рік тому

    How sharp is the blade? You need to buy to tool for the job. The EGO there isn’t in the same class as that model of STIHL. A fairer comparison would be with the STIHL 170

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      Brand new out of the box blade.. Ego vs log was not a sufficient tool, regardless versus model of Sthil.

    • @danno180
      @danno180 Рік тому

      @@everydaypawel9193 that’s about the most ignorant thing I’ve read today

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      @@danno180 ok

  • @iannorton4463
    @iannorton4463 Рік тому +1

    I would say the chain is dull on the ego but it would still lose by far next to the petrol saw ✌️👍🇬🇧

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +3

      The chain was brand new of the box. Thanks for watching!

  • @calvinro6166
    @calvinro6166 Рік тому

    This is most honest review about ego chainsaw. I would not buy one if I could see this video prior to make purchases even after all the good reviews. I have 18inch one, however, this chainsaw can not cut if diameter is more than 14inch. Spend more money for new Stihl MSA 300 or stick with Gas chainsaw.

  • @JusCals
    @JusCals Рік тому +2

    Well I never ever have cut a log that big so mabe an electric is good for me. Then I dont have the acquiring of fuel , mixing it then the regular expence of servicing the petrol one(probably a visit to the dealer 300kms away)and the fuckn damn awfull noise. I am going EGO 18 inch, it runs faster than the one depicted here. Of cours you go petrol if you cut alot of timber but I am just living off grid in a small home and dont need that much saw.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +1

      you are correct. Big logs=big high power saw. smaller stuff can be managed with smaller less power saw. The right tool for the job. I think I was trying to share the saws/tools are different and have different capabilities.

  • @joshangel8020
    @joshangel8020 Рік тому +1

    Why are you wearing ear muffs with an electric chainsaw, my point is you don’t have to = pros and cons + do your homework to what suits you best before purchasing.
    I just bought an Ego 18” with plenty of power without pissing off the neighbours and great for camping, dunno if you can do that with a two stroke especially if they are banned in the future

  • @krazor8
    @krazor8 6 місяців тому

    To do logs like that with the elextric, u should have just gotten the 18 inch...

  • @benjaminleslie3155
    @benjaminleslie3155 7 місяців тому

    Someone give this man a greenworks 82CS34 😏

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  7 місяців тому +1

      I have a greenworks too!... going back to 2013 I think. I prefer the EGO over Greenworks. but I am sure the newer models have improvements.

  • @Olivierus
    @Olivierus 9 місяців тому

    Why upgrade to longer chain? Use a cs1800 it has a much better motor

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  9 місяців тому

      I like Gas when more power is needed. I like Electric when there is a simple job and you don't want to mess with a pull start.

    • @Olivierus
      @Olivierus 9 місяців тому

      That I can understand but the comparison you are making in this video doesn’t seem fair, it’s not the right ego model for this kind of job. I am pretty sure you could struggle with an undersized gas one

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  9 місяців тому

      @@Olivierus You are very correct that the comparison is unfair. That was kind of the point, some people don't know and think a chain saw is a chain saw. I used to think that way and had to learn the hard way. I was pretty frustrated with the Ego, struggling for days just to cut one piece of wood, and it kept stalling. I spend $700 on a great saw + accessories. Partially out of frustration and the need to share the struggle so others stop and consider to buy the right saw for the job. Us having this conversation is a success regarding the goal to share knowledge. and Yes, not a fair comparison... and not everyone knows there is a different chain saw for a different job.

  • @richardshear2285
    @richardshear2285 Рік тому +1

    ;EGO is for light work NOT cutting 24 inch logs 4 to 6 inch logs , get real

  • @dscottperry
    @dscottperry Рік тому

    DO NOT BUY THE EGO ELECTRIC SAW! I bought it and at first thought it was good, but after only a few times of use IT SUCKS! WISH I COULD GET MY MONEY BACK. What it is good for is sending back to EGO and telling them to refund your money!

  • @Trackhoe075
    @Trackhoe075 6 місяців тому

    The only thing that you said that makes any sense is pick the right tool for the job your doing
    If you need help on that stay away from chainsaws period !!

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  5 місяців тому

      I usually don’t say anything that makes sense.😃

  • @mkbmj
    @mkbmj 4 місяці тому

    That’s BS. The ego chomps that. You’ve pinched the blade and it’s probably dull as crap

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  4 місяці тому

      Nope, Brand new blade. Not sure what the issue was. battery was warm. I just had the problem over and over again. that's why I bought the Stihl. I didn't have the problem with the Ego before. The battery was kept and charged at room temperature before I brought it out. Think about it. I have nothing to gain by going out of my way talking smack about a chain saw I already own. It was just driving me crazy.

  • @paweldomejczyk
    @paweldomejczyk Рік тому

    It's simple, use the right tool for the job. Ego had to make an upgraded version.

  • @13MAM13
    @13MAM13 Рік тому

    You can't cut redwoods down with it: JUNK 😂 🤡🤡🤡

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +1

      Ego is good, sometimes you need more cowbell.

    • @13MAM13
      @13MAM13 Рік тому

      @@everydaypawel9193 😄👍

  • @geert6165
    @geert6165 Рік тому

    ef iets anders ik heb de ego 765 accu blasdblazer ik heb de stihl bladblazer op benzine gehad zijn allebij handbladblazers kan je zeggen ego bladblazer vele male beter veel krachtiger dan de benzine bladblazer van stihl wil je een stihl die in de buurt kom betaal je 1400euro tege over 600euro ik betaalt heb voor de ego

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому

      Ego is a good tool, but electric is not always equal to gas. Power = Power, the same units of measure need to be compared.

  • @geert6165
    @geert6165 Рік тому

    blasblazer bedoel ik bladblazer foutje bericht hieronder

  • @John-cj3ve
    @John-cj3ve 3 місяці тому

    I think your video is ridiculous! It's like comparing a Corvette to a Honda Prius.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  3 місяці тому

      @@John-cj3ve it’s like comparing how much a Ford F150 can tow compared to a Toyota Prius. The truth is I’ve learned over time that my battery was crapping out, even though it still worked good and a leaf blower and string trimmer, I think the chainsaw takes a lot more amps so it was crapping out, I added a new battery and it works great.😃

    • @John-cj3ve
      @John-cj3ve 3 місяці тому

      @@everydaypawel9193 hahaha! My mistake; TOYOTA Prius!

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  3 місяці тому

      @@John-cj3ve 😃😃😃

  • @mas3ymd
    @mas3ymd Рік тому +1

    You're missing the point. First: electric chainsaws can tackle pretty-much anything a gas-powered saw can, with some very modest changes in how you approach your tasks. Second: the simplicity and convenience of electric is their main selling point, and not how much wood they can plow through in five seconds. You bring up "frustration" in your video but fail to mention the fact that an engine that is difficult to start (or outright unable to start) can be incredibly frustrating too. Electric is simple, clean, reliable, and convenient as can be.

    • @everydaypawel9193
      @everydaypawel9193  Рік тому +1

      You're right. All the points you make are valid and should be considered.