Curiosity Public Presents : The Bourbon Contender | Middleweight Round 1
Вставка
- Опубліковано 15 вер 2024
- Help support our channel with a "Super Thanks" ^^
Join our Patreon:
/ curiositypublic
Join us in our Bourbon Contender series where we are pitting bourbons against one another in a blind weight class based tournament! Who knows what will happen. Will you favorite bourbon win?
T-Shirts:
curiosity-publ...
www.redbubble....
Need tasting glasses? Use our link to help our channel:
amzn.to/2OKCt9S
Get your tequila tasting glasses here:
amzn.to/3buYn9A
Join us at Curiosity PRIVATE for EXCLUSIVE content and early access to videos:
/ @curiositypublic
email us: info@curiositypublic.com
Check us out on Instagram @curiosity_public
/ curiosity_public
Listen to this on our podcasts here:
podcast.curios...
Venmo: @curiosity_public
All claims made here about alcohol, whether in this episode, in this description, or on our Podcast, are solely our opinions and intended only for those of legal drinking age. All links provided here should only be accessed by those of legal drinking age.
You guys gotta keep the bottles hidden from each other until after the decision on the favorite. THEN reveal the bottles
Yeah I agree, the contenders are all going to be well known bottles where they’re familiar with what each should taste like, so yeah the extra level of blindness is ideal.
I feel like 100-107 proof should be it’s own weight class, then 108-120, then 120+. All the bottled in bonds would compete against each other, then all the cask strength/full proof/barrel strength/etc would all compete against each other, then all the hazmat stuff. The way it is now, something like EHT SmB (4y) could be put up against ECBP (12y), which is too wide a difference imo. Definitely a great series idea though, will be watching them all 🍿
Old Forester 1920, Bakers single barrel, New Riff single Barrel & Russels Reserve single barrel
Completely agree with RR
Remus Repeal Batch 3 or 5...to dethrone the WFP. Great series again fellas!!!
Old Forester 1920 best middle weight hands down!
Great blind flight guys, no surprise to me that Weller FP won.
Hmm more contenders for the Middleweight belt I’d say OF 1920, Smoke Wagon Uncut / Unfiltered, Remus Repeal, Cream of Kentucky, Bardstown Discovery, Still Austin Cask Strength.
For next round: Russell's reserve single barrel, Knob creek 12, Old Forester 1920
What do you guys think about doing them blind before showing what you picked? That way you’re not looking for those flavors you know.
I feel two seconds and a third trumps a first and two thirds. Maker's for second place.
Dutch and Jules both chose "their bottle", as the last place. I still feel like doing this semi-double-blind (not revealing to each other which bottle you brought), would allow more transparency in the tasting - as you wouldn't be able to guess the bottle.
Smoke Wagon Uncut Unfiltered.
For an everyday drinking contender id go with 1920...for something a bit more rare, Doc Swinsons Exploratory Cask 15 year.
Pick Seagrass for Dillion!
We all want another Apricot rant!
I would recommend Smoke Wagon UCUF or Belle Meade Reserve
Side note- 100-119 is tough. So many good 100proofs that just aren’t going to stand out against the 115+ - need a Strictly 100/101 proof weight class
That Maker's 46 CS would have been my only suggestion in this weight class (proof). I haven't tried that much Bourbon, and that one was by far my favorite.
For Heavyweight (proof), I was wondering if JD counts as Bourbon? Yesterday I opened up my second bottle of a certain JD product, and was reminded just how much I love it. It might even be my favorite whiskey that I've ever tried.
I really like this format, please do with scotch :) really good, only thing maybe go in blind like not knowing the others? But either way I really like this series. I’m gonna start doing this with my buddies
Calumet 16
3 of my favs! Love this series. Keep it going.
Put up Larceny BP or a Rebel cask strength against the Weller FP. Your guys’ results were interesting too bc Stuff and Whiskey also picked Weller FP over Makers 46CS in a blind.
This series is great
Calumet 15
Hmmm I am protesting this tasting. A store pick that is more accessible for 300 vs retail. and 2 bottles that can be easily found. I say this as a Weller FP barrel pick from a resturant in Savannah is one of my favorite all time pours.
No holds barred!
Gotta put in Woodford batch proof 2022 it’s 118.4
Bardstown Discovery 4, GTS 2019, Russell’s Reserve 13, or Elijah Craig Barrel Proof B521
Absolutely love the format, whether seeing the bottles beforehand or not. I was curious from the beginning at what point you would realize that full proof is over middleweight, but it just never happened 🤷♂️
Thanks! The Weller Full Proof is only 114 proof, so it fits in the middleweight field (100-119)
Smooth ambler old scout
Great series guys. It’s so interesting how much things change over a bit of time and when put against other bourbons. Makes it hard to pick a fav! Stagg Jr. would dethrone WFP.
Where did Dillon pick up a bottle of Weller Full Proof and for how much? I've been chasing that for quite awhile. Jealous!
So you're saying Rare Breed is the winner? Because i have a giant, obnoxious LOL for anyone who sees this and thinks "ok, let's try Weller Full Proof then."
Gonna be hard to beat that one in that proof bracket, honestly. My pick to do it would've been the WT. I might've gone RRSiB over Rare Breed, but same zone.
Keep going, like it.
Throw 2022 woodford batch proof in the mix
Y’all should try the Chattanooga founders blend bourbon
Fun series! Love the format. However I think each bottle should be the standard offering, and not a store pick. That would give the competition a level playing field. A store pick could be a honey barrel, and give an unfair advantage. Out of public curiosity (see what I did there???)… which store pick was the Weller FP? Nice video guys! Cheers
I'll have to double check, but I think it's a Bevmo pick
You Do have a second place because two of the three of you preferred the green. Even though both scores are 7 points, 2 of 3 judges preferred green so that's 2nd place. It always pays to have an odd number of judges because then judge preference can serve as the tie-breaker.
Would the Rare breed possibly won if it was the non-chill filtered version? I remember how much you guys loved it during the Wild turkey line up tasting!
Maybe! We might have to see how the NCF would do in a future episode!
This is awesome!
MAYBE Smoke Wagon UC/UF, but not sure that can, er, cut it…
Middleweight is a tough class.
If i were to pick two challengers, might go with one of those 15 year totes (doc swinsons, GOAT, etc) and a Remus (b3 or 5 if you have it).
Great guys, keep these coming. I sensed a bias in favor of the wheated mash bill profile.Jules always surprises me on his take though.
How about calumet farm 16 and old forester 1920
Great format. Unfortunately you picked a bottle that is literally unobtanium in my area. I have never seen a bottle of Weller FP in the wild here, even going back toe the pre-boom days. I am curious how Knob Creek would do but unfortunately the base expression gives up 14 proof points to the Weller FP (and the 120 proof ends up in the heavy weight category).
Old forester 1920, David Nicholson Reserve
Nice job guys
Remus V, OF1920, or Smokewagon UCUF
1920
TRY KNOB CREEK 12 or OF 1920 in the next round
a good batch of ECBP, some Jack Daniels Barrel Proof, Stagg Jr. or mr. George T. Stagg Sr.
although i think the delightful one might go george t himself so be careful
Love the video and format, but disappointed since Weller Full Proof might as well be a white elephant. I have never seen a bottle and secondary is just stupid. I do love Makers 46 CS. Even Rare Breed and the 46CS can be challenging to find at times. My vote for next round is Old Forester 1920. It is $%$#%#@ scrumptious.
Stagg Jr or Elijah Craig Barrel Proof
Bottle rules #1 - Single barrel picks should not be allowed, only Shelfies. Jules 🤦🏽♂️
Stagg jr
1816 Chattanooga beats them all....unfortunately you can't get it anymore
Have you tried the founders blend I like it more
@@empirebesh I have but the 1816 cask is my choice
I feel like price and availability are more important distinguishing characteristics than proof. I don't give a rats ass about Weller Full Proof because I'll never buy it.