GoPro Hero 11 vs DJI Action 4 - SHOULD YOU WAIT?

Поділитися
Вставка
  • Опубліковано 15 лип 2024
  • NEW T-SHIRT COLORS ON THE MERCH STORE
    shopdavidmanning.com
    The video you've all been asking for with TONS of comparison footage! In August of 2023, which of these two cameras should you be picking up?
    DJI Osmo Action 4: geni.us/DMdjiAction4
    GoPro Hero 11 - geni.us/DMGoPro11
    MY CAMERA GEAR:
    Main Camera: Sony a7SIII - geni.us/DMA7Siii
    Photo Camera: Sony a7IV - geni.us/DMSonyA7IV
    Best Travel Tripod: geni.us/DMUlanziTripod
    Vlog Tripod: PolarPro Apex Base - geni.us/DMApexBase
    Vlog Tripod Head - Joby Ballhead - geni.us/DMJobyBallhead
    F38 Quick Release Plate: geni.us/DMF38
    Support the channel and BUY SOME MERCH: shopdavidmanning.com
    🎵DOWNLOAD THE COPYRIGHT FREE MUSIC I USE: bit.ly/epidemicsoundDM
    INSTA - / david_manning
    TWITTER - / david_manning
    MY CURRENT VIDEO GEAR:
    My Video Camera: Sony a7SIII - geni.us/DMA7Siii
    Main lens: 16-35mm - geni.us/DM16-35
    Favorite Lens: 24-70mm - geni.us/DM24-70
    Best Travel Tripod: geni.us/DMUlanziTripod
    💰 USE CODE "DAVID" TO SAVE 20%
    Pocket camera: Sony ZV-1 II -
    My Quick Release System: geni.us/DMF38
    Mini Quick Release System: geni.us/DMF22
    Backpack Clip: bit.ly/3jQvqri
    MY CURRENT PHOTO GEAR:
    My Photo Camera: Sony a7IV - geni.us/DMSonyA7IV
    Favorite Lens: 24-70mm - geni.us/DM24-70
    Long lens: 70-200mm - geni.us/DM70-200
    35mm - geni.us/DM35mm
    50mm - geni.us/DM50mm
    85mm - geni.us/DM85mm
    90mm - geni.us/DM90mm
    The leather camera strap: cleversupply.co/?ref=MKNDV
    ----Use Code "MANNING" for 10% DISCOUNT
    ACTION CAMERA GEAR:
    Insta360 ONE X3 - geni.us/DMVX3
    DJI Action 4: geni.us/DMdjiAction4
    GoPro Hero 11 - geni.us/DMGoPro11
    Quick Release Action Gear: geni.us/DMF22
    THE BEST GOPRO ACCESSORY: geni.us/DMSnapMount
    📫 I LIKE MAIL:
    David Manning Vlog
    PO Box 2622
    Valley Center, CA 92082
    Chapters:
    00:00 - Intro
    02:00 - Blind Side By Side Comparison
    03:50 - Physical Features
    08:03 - Hyperlapse Comparison
    09:09 - WHICH CAMERA IS WHICH
    9:45 - Image Quality Breakdown
    10:51 - Audio Test Comparison
    11:26 - Wind Reduction Comparison
    13:50 - Usability - WHAT REALLY MATTERS
    *Most links in the description are affiliate links, meaning I earn a small commission when you purchase.

КОМЕНТАРІ • 412

  • @kennethpreston9813
    @kennethpreston9813 11 місяців тому +51

    Ordered my OA4, I’m not interested in GoPro 12 due to the buggy nature of their products. Of course the new GoPro will have some improvements over the OA4 but the issues with reliability will continue. DJI products just seem easier to use and more intuitive.

    • @montecristo9017
      @montecristo9017 11 місяців тому +3

      Well said..the reliability issues are huge at gopro.. always were...

    • @DavidManningvlog
      @DavidManningvlog  11 місяців тому +4

      This is the biggest feedback I always bring to GoPro. I’m stoked that they’ve prioritized it in the 11 and made the most stable GoPro so far, but there’s still more work to do on that from to make a rock solid GoPro. Hoping we see more of that in the future!

    • @10G3x7
      @10G3x7 10 місяців тому

      Correct!

    • @TouchofDepth
      @TouchofDepth 10 місяців тому +1

      Wow I can't believe GoPro has lasted this long. RIP

  • @TheDeterminedRunner
    @TheDeterminedRunner 10 місяців тому +8

    I'm pleased with my Action 4, biggest reason is it actually works unlike GoPro's that freeze just too often.

  • @Hobbies4Hire
    @Hobbies4Hire 11 місяців тому +4

    Great job on the video David! Thanks for making it. The ability to hook in the wireless mics is the killer app for the DJI.

  • @FINNDESIGNSTUDIO
    @FINNDESIGNSTUDIO 11 місяців тому +3

    Always enjoy your videos, very honest and thorough assessments, thanks for creating this content

  • @scottgivens27
    @scottgivens27 4 місяці тому +2

    Just ordered the refurbished Action 4 and glad I waited till the Gopro 12 came out. Most of my friends like their Hero 11 over the Hero 12. I already have most Action 2 accessories and the the DJI Action 4 can be picked up on DJI's website for $239 and I got the 2 year extended for only $39. No brainer for my case use. Great comparison video!! Thanks

  • @demang0405
    @demang0405 11 місяців тому

    Really appreciate your opinion and how you present information. You can tell that you’re not biased and I like that neither sponsored this video in any way.
    FYI. They sell a mount for the GoPro that you can use the dji mounting system and GoPros system at the same time. Can’t wait to see the 12 review. Thanks again.

  • @robinhilliermodernagents7432
    @robinhilliermodernagents7432 11 місяців тому +9

    I do believe that the GoPro does a lot of processing in camera. I’d expect the straight out of camera shots to be better on that. If you color grade at all I feel like the capability of shooting in Log will allow fo the best videos.

  • @tomcaron9113
    @tomcaron9113 11 місяців тому +3

    My GoPro 11 is working great along with the mod kit and battery mount. But, the DJI is looking really nice. Really like the app monitoring in video recording on the DJI.

  • @DesertNovice
    @DesertNovice 11 місяців тому

    David, You are so good at your job - these reviews pardoner. Excellent reviews always !!

  • @AutoAuctionRebuilds
    @AutoAuctionRebuilds 11 місяців тому

    Thank you for this.

  • @furtherupthetrack7583
    @furtherupthetrack7583 11 місяців тому

    David thanks for the comparison video 👍👍

  • @M1ke_A
    @M1ke_A 11 місяців тому +4

    I like the color on the GoPro but like the wider field of view and battery life on Action4.

  • @phucmapvlog
    @phucmapvlog 10 місяців тому +1

    I've had the GoPro 11 since release, and filmed a ton of UA-cam videos with it. That being said, I honestly thought the camera on the right was the GoPro. I generally get a more contrasty image with mine like the video on the right.

  • @kernzilla
    @kernzilla 11 місяців тому

    Thorough test! A4 looks similar to my Action2, have to be .3-1 EV overexposed to get easier to use SOOC footage/shadow detail.

  • @KayakFishingAddict
    @KayakFishingAddict 11 місяців тому +1

    Nice comparison. I’m waiting but most likely definitely jumping on the OA4 and ditching GoPro. That said, on the straight out of camera images they’re close but the edge goes to GoPro. The real comparison that I’d suggest you do is the 10-bit DLogM vs GoPro’s version and see who captures the most detail. My guess is that they’re essentially the same. So that leaves other things that DJI wins in like mounting system, external audio connectivity via USB-C (no need for an adapter or media mod), timecode support without the need for “lab” firmware and a media mod, etc.

  • @biggooseadventures
    @biggooseadventures 11 місяців тому +10

    It definitely goes to show you that sensor size is not as important as everybody makes it out to be because the GoPro definitely has better picture quality than the DJI. And as far as low light is concerned, neither camera is a low light camera. Great video

    • @axelmogr
      @axelmogr 10 місяців тому +1

      Difference here is the signal processing. GoPro have had a decade’s head start extracting every drop of image quality from their action cam sensors vs DJI

    • @biggooseadventures
      @biggooseadventures 10 місяців тому +1

      @@axelmogr thank you 🙏

  • @Dan_B_Rides
    @Dan_B_Rides 11 місяців тому +1

    Great video David, the side by sides are to close to call. Sometimes the Go-Pro looks better in more brighter conditions and the DJI looks better in some darker conditions like when you were sitting at the end with the big head behind you, you could see more detail with the DJI compared to the Go-Pro but you could see more details in the clouds with the Go-Pro.
    Tough one but I do love the mounting system for the DJI as it is so much quicker than the Go-Pro 100%. If I had to buy one tomorrow (if I had the cash) I would go for the DJI but for anyone who wants a action camera, like you I would say wait until the Go-Pro 12 comes out. I am sure it will be good. Carnt wait for the next video David.

  • @Panda.gultom
    @Panda.gultom 11 місяців тому +1

    I Just Got my DJI OS4 ( combo one) , I was so impressed with the video quality,battery and the package.

  • @bigdreamsphilippines
    @bigdreamsphilippines 10 місяців тому

    Great vid ! What is the extension pole you are using ? Very cool 😎. Thx 🙏

  • @destino2portugal
    @destino2portugal 11 місяців тому

    Thanks David, I have to say we love your channel.
    I trust your judgement and have ordered a dji action 4 as we are going on an ATV ride up a mountain and the kit I use would not be conducive to me staying on said vehicle.
    Do your tees ship to Portugal?

  • @mynusten
    @mynusten 11 місяців тому +3

    Excellent comparison review of two top-notch, action cameras. GoPro, DJI, Insta360 are all dubyas...I think action cameras differentiators now are each brands eco-system and 3rd party add-ons. In additional to your review, very cool creativity in how you plan out your video & edit all the footage.

    • @DavidManningvlog
      @DavidManningvlog  11 місяців тому +3

      Thanks man, I appreciate that! And I'm totally with you that when I'm looking at image quality and audio, they're pretty much a tie. They're both so dang good! But when you look at the mounting systems, battery life, and reliability, it's easy to pick the DJI out of the two

    • @MadamTV007
      @MadamTV007 10 місяців тому

      @@DavidManningvlogthanks so much. I do like the go pro Quik Ap for rough edit of clips and cloud storage, but when there’s a technical problem, tech support on quik ap is nonexistent!!! Does DJI have something to compete with that? and if so please share your opinion of it.
      Really put out with failing batteries, quirks, and zero tech support with current go pro.

  • @Hiking-guide-and-scenery
    @Hiking-guide-and-scenery 11 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for giving the info that gopro still has the freezing events (that requiring the battery out-in solution). Most Yubers avoid it or say it is gone in 10, 11... It is the main reason I stayed away in recent years.

  • @HenriqueTavares
    @HenriqueTavares 11 місяців тому +1

    22:31 Look at the cloud in the back. What difference in sharpness and image. But having a Hero 8 today, I would try DJI for my next camera. The GoPro reset is really annoying.

  • @someguysomewhere100
    @someguysomewhere100 11 місяців тому +3

    Choosing the DJI is like opting for a potato to snap your photos. Its picture quality rivals that of a $5 action camera you'd fish out of a cereal box. And the contrast? Let's just say it can turn a tropical beach into a scene from a Dickensian winter!

    • @paulguerrero972
      @paulguerrero972 11 місяців тому +1

      And with the GoPro you can cook that potato as it overheats!!!! Mine never runs cool....🤬

  • @goldentapes
    @goldentapes 11 місяців тому +12

    I fell in love with the Action 1 and am currently on an Action 3. I must say - to me - the image of DJIs cameras just looks way more pleasant. I am just not a fan of extreme saturation and sharpness in general, I like soft contrast and pleasant colors, which is why I will always prefer Osmo Action. Thanks for the great comparison.

    • @itzdylans
      @itzdylans 10 місяців тому

      hello there @goldentapes, i'm sorry for disturbing your time but may i ask about your experience using Osmo Action ? I'm new in "action cam world" cause i want to buy this action camera to shoot a motorcycle ride vlogging and music cover. I stumble across some video who use DJI Osmo Cam and they upload in Tiktok or Instagram but the quality is bad (?) But in youtube the quality of video is good ? I mean like blurry or it seems like 360p or 480p video but they record it at 4K60FPS. Do that kind of issues happend to you or it's about resolution setting in the camera when recording ? Also do you think Osmo Cam 3 and 4 have a lot of difference cause i'm in quite tight budget so i'm trying to choose the right option-

    • @goldentapes
      @goldentapes 10 місяців тому

      @@itzdylans I have never experienced blurry or bad quality footage. Maybe it's the compression that happens when uploading to TikTok? If you're tight on budget I would recommend the 3, since it holds up very well even with the 4 out. I'm gonna get the 4 some day when my budget allows it but until then I'm happy with action 3.

    • @MadamTV007
      @MadamTV007 10 місяців тому +2

      Thanks for sharing. I am furious at go pro for the complete failing of support to address problems.

  • @kennethdavis5230
    @kennethdavis5230 11 місяців тому

    Great comparison as alway. curious if you have seen/used the mount adapter from falcam that allows you to convert the GoPro mount to a DJI magnetic compatible one? It looks pretty cool and seems like it would be perfect if you live in both systems.

  • @AndreasChristouSaltwater
    @AndreasChristouSaltwater 10 місяців тому

    Hey David thank you so much for making this video! I had a quick question. Does the action 4 have a way to mark the clip while your recording? Also how user friendly is the action 4 app?

  • @skinbones
    @skinbones 11 місяців тому +2

    before u said it, I was in love with the camera A .. was the go pro, colors looks more natural... Im excited to see what gopro 12 will have and compare them again.

  • @miltoncallan1471
    @miltoncallan1471 11 місяців тому +12

    The Action 4 has a bit of an advantage in low light (I do a lot of night driving videos) but the Hero 11 outshines the Action 4 with cinematic realism. And as for mount problems, I fixed that issue years ago with the Snap Mount System. I am anxiously waiting for the Hero 12, too. Good comparison, though.

    • @filipemonteiro5504
      @filipemonteiro5504 10 місяців тому

      Hi Milton, what is the snap mount system you mention above? Thanks

  • @shinertom142
    @shinertom142 11 місяців тому +1

    I knew straight away … ( well I got it right ) DJI has a Wider field of view … which I think looks better … btw David was the go pro battery as new as the DJI ? just something I thought of, but I still feel the DJI would of lasted longer … great comparison… looks like it’s all down to GoPro 12 once out … can’t wait for that comparison from you 👍✌️🙏

  • @SethJ-2525
    @SethJ-2525 11 місяців тому +9

    Already ordered my OA4 after having a GoPro hero 11. You just can’t beat the Action 4 batteries in the cold for snowboarding.

    • @algar2003
      @algar2003 11 місяців тому

      Gopro 12 is coming in September.

    • @SethJ-2525
      @SethJ-2525 11 місяців тому +2

      ⁠@@algar2003Yeah but honestly in my opinion the action 4 is just better. Sure you can argue that the quality and features will be better on the GoPro hero 12 but really how often do you use them? For me the Actions reliability, ease of use, and good quality video is worth more than any of the new rumored features. The Action just does everything an action camera needs to do without the unnecessary features and problems.

    • @algar2003
      @algar2003 11 місяців тому

      @@SethJ-2525 you are right. I like DJI action 4 magnetic mounting system.

  • @stefpix
    @stefpix 11 місяців тому +1

    If photo resolution matters, the Hero 11/Hero 10 are a better option with the higher resolution and taller sensor.
    Also by shooting 5.3K video you can extract high resolution still frames about 16 megapixels.
    I came face to face with a sandtiger shark in clear water, while spearfishing in NY. I was happy I was recording 5.3K, so I got also decent stills when it made a U turn in front of me. GoPro has also burst mode that captures 3 - 5 shots in a second, which is useful when photographing sea life.
    The GoPro is reliable to me. Never overheats (but shoot mostly 1 min clips). Rarely freezes. No need to remove the battery to restart it. Just hold the power button 10 seconds or so then press again. I can do it in the ocean.
    Otherwise the Action 4 is appealing with better user interface, quick menu button, longer battery life. But I heard it has no burst mode.
    Also even if it is water resistant to 18 meters below the surface, I prefer the beefier single door of the GoPro, one single point of failure, rather than the 2 doors than the DJI. Even if better water resistance on spec, the battery door seal of the GoPro seems to be better designed.
    Customer service of GoPro seems also better.
    I have the Action 2, which I rarely use, as in cold water it turns itself off, the field of view is too wide, and storage/battery life are not so good.
    I will wait for the Hero 12 and see if it has a larger sensor. Otherwise the Action 4 could be good for low light/murky water.

  • @aaronmelson2887
    @aaronmelson2887 11 місяців тому +2

    The image quality of the GP is better. Better color accuracy to me and image detail is better. I've had 4 GP's over the years (the last one being the 10) and I have always had issues with them. If not glitching out, they would overheat. I have never had any issues with the A3 but I am thinking of selling my A3 and buying the A4.

    • @MadamTV007
      @MadamTV007 10 місяців тому

      Yes! I’ve noted overheating with gopro

  • @briangschaefer7048
    @briangschaefer7048 11 місяців тому +3

    I thought the GoPro footage seemed better and the DJI audio was better. I have the GoPro and can't comprehend how they have same issues they have had since the start. Insanely poor business model. It is so good seeing DJI pushing the boundaries. I love the DJI mounts, battery life, touchscreens and app features. We all stand to benefit from the advances in technology both brands are making, but I won't be getting any more GoPros.

  • @brianb6603
    @brianb6603 11 місяців тому +1

    Excellent as usual!!! OA4 is clearly the choice...

  • @GunnTales
    @GunnTales 11 місяців тому

    great video, thanks, I like the action sound quality but the gopro video quality. What is the orange chin mount that you used?
    cheers

  • @frankygoestocanada
    @frankygoestocanada 10 місяців тому

    First, I must say I don't have a gopro to compare (except that I own two gopros, but there are like first editions, like 10 years ago, without screens and very complicated to remember how to use it when you needed it (that's why I've almost never used them)). But now, I'm going Hawaï, and I wanted to have a reliable good camera! So I've been watching youtube videos like yours and boy, I don't regret having bought an action 4 from DJI! (3 days ago) Works flawlessly! Eaaaaaasy to understand! But your video made me confortable with my choice! Thanks dude and continu your great work! 😊

  • @eGazTheFirstAustralian
    @eGazTheFirstAustralian 11 місяців тому

    You have a chapter on Physical features but I didn't see where the USB port is or where the memory card goes or how these two areas are waterproofed.

  • @TweakMusicTips
    @TweakMusicTips 11 місяців тому

    Did you color grade this footage or record a flat profile? If not what settings did you use for the video. Great video!

  • @tomnielsen3661
    @tomnielsen3661 11 місяців тому

    I put the decal on my large water bottle people ask me about it. being older the audio sounds the same the color I think is better on the go pro, but the better battery life is nice and the glitch where you could lose what you have taken and have to stop and do a reset. I don't need either right now, so I'll wait. Now I have to go check the shirts.

  • @biggooseadventures
    @biggooseadventures 11 місяців тому

    Wonderful video maybe I missed it but what setting is the GoPro on the GoPro color flat or neutral

  • @blackmamba6938
    @blackmamba6938 11 місяців тому

    I haven't watched the whole video yet, but I'm gonna say the left is the GoPro. I feel like I like the look of the left more just cause it looks slightly brighter and warmer, which is the look I like. With that said, the Osmo Action has the better features in my opinion with the mounting system, triple battery case, and better battery life.

  • @MaxwellAdventuress
    @MaxwellAdventuress 11 місяців тому

    No discussion on low light,that’s the biggest change!

  • @JeffreyTadlockPhotography
    @JeffreyTadlockPhotography 11 місяців тому +5

    Great side-by-side!
    For me the it will be the DJI moving forward. My GoPro Hero 11 (with the Enduro) batteries just cannot handle the cold at all. I'm a landscape photographer and on multiple cold weather outings earlier this year, the GoPro couldn't even stay on to record video. Ended up doing most of my Colorado trip vlog off the iPhone because the GoPro didn't last past the first photo stop on the hike.
    Meanwhile, a DJI Action 1 (borrowed) that I had with me for b-roll ran the whole time.
    None of the video specs or quality matter if the camera can't actually stay running. So next cam will be the DJI.
    Thanks for the video! Well done as always!

    • @MadamTV007
      @MadamTV007 10 місяців тому

      Really needed this to make a decision. Thanks

  • @Rushfan74
    @Rushfan74 11 місяців тому

    It seems like the DJI A4 needs an exposure adjustment in the settings as it does appear a little darker.

  • @ridingwithmarshall
    @ridingwithmarshall 11 місяців тому

    Can you plug in the Action 4 and retrieve video, or do you have to pull the little card?

  • @BassManStrikes
    @BassManStrikes 11 місяців тому

    Are the 4k 24fps file sizes still gigantic on the Action 4? With the Hero 11 I can get almost 11 hours of recording time with medium bit rate etc.
    when I had the action 3 for a day it created just insane amount of files that really reduced recording time. So I need the long recording time while kayak fishing as I just let the camera record continuously . The action 3 with it's lower recording time with 256gb sd cards and the mushy focus was a big NO LOL

  • @arturaszaleskis8907
    @arturaszaleskis8907 11 місяців тому +1

    I tried GoPro 10 and sold it just after a month of use.
    If you watch your videos on smartphone then it does not really matter but once I put my GoPro clips on TV all footage was grainy and its with lowest sharpenning settings, lowering resolution helped a tiny bit but still that grainy image was visible.
    Tried editing but couldn't get rid of it by not loosing picture quality.
    Whats weird though that all my videos taken in very bright day.

    • @MadamTV007
      @MadamTV007 10 місяців тому

      Thank you for this opinion. Have you used the quik ap?

  • @a.m.b.erlight
    @a.m.b.erlight 10 місяців тому

    i like the warmer colors of the gopro but i hate how it distorts the body in selfie. i feel like you have to buy both and buy that double mount and turn the action 4 toward you and have gopro face forward. and then edit ur video and use the action 4 footage of selfie.

  • @quickaudi
    @quickaudi 11 місяців тому

    Regarding software, GoPro 11B really let me down last night. Had Scheduled Capture ready to go, external battery plugged in, hoping to catch some decent Perseids footage. Apparently, that's not possible with 11B as it can't charge and shoot if you have Auto Upload enabled. The workaround is to either run on external battery only or internal battery only. I'm crushed.
    David, can DJI do scheduled capture with external battery plugged in?

  • @brianruiz7966
    @brianruiz7966 11 місяців тому

    Love the action 4 I just wish they had a vibrant color option. Sometimes I want the go pro color but action 4 video

  • @retroonhisbikes
    @retroonhisbikes 10 місяців тому

    Now i have the dji OA4, my gopro fan boy days are over.
    From the mounting system that allows you to remove the battery while in its case compared to the gopro media mod.
    Battery time is better
    Imagine is crisp and bright after colour grading beating gopro.
    The only thing about the gopro is the lens fitting and the available lenses ie anamorphic and nd/cpl filters

  • @DigginSoCal
    @DigginSoCal 11 місяців тому

    This was an awesome side by side... I am currently using Gopro 8 & 10 and have the DJI Pocket 2.... waiting like you said to see what GP does with it's next release. The GP in your video did look better. I was hoping A was gonna be the DJI..lol. Thank You

    • @frankygoestocanada
      @frankygoestocanada 10 місяців тому +1

      The gopro is just "warmer" in there colors. The DJI is more like reality. But, like with the "sound", people prefers loud base, with images people prefer warmer colors. But it so easy to correct that when editing. So, that's why I perchased a DJI A4 3 days ago! Good luck in your choice.

    • @DigginSoCal
      @DigginSoCal 10 місяців тому

      @@frankygoestocanada I am still seriously considering it as an extra and it would be nice to try it out. I do have more issues than I like with the GoPro freezing and other hiccups

    • @FrankChen-mp2je
      @FrankChen-mp2je 10 місяців тому

      @@frankygoestocanadaI buy ac4 too

  • @popeyerubi1981
    @popeyerubi1981 11 місяців тому +1

    Reliability is my main concern. I don’t want to lose my video of my trip. Also, would you be able to do a comparison video underwater?

  • @gayshrink3190
    @gayshrink3190 11 місяців тому

    Hi David. By any chance, do you know if any ND filters that fit the Osmo Action 1 would fit on the 4? I have Freewell, PGYtech and I think one more brand of Action 1 filters and was hoping to save some money. Thanks in advance.

  • @vagnsteen5130
    @vagnsteen5130 11 місяців тому +7

    right off the rip I preferred the A camera. Assuming both were un-edited in any way, the A camera seemed to pop and had more color saturation overall. Although the magnetic mounts on the DJI are sweet.

    • @lynchy3562
      @lynchy3562 11 місяців тому

      I felt the same. I was shocked with the result

    • @javiere.gonzalez1021
      @javiere.gonzalez1021 10 місяців тому

      Agreed the colors and pop look better but that's the default color settings in gopro. For some people it can be a little artificial. you can adjust to the same look for the Action 4.

  • @vagnsteen5130
    @vagnsteen5130 11 місяців тому

    what editing software would you recommend for either camera? Is the format native from the camera or is there some trans-coding involved? thank you.

  • @thebowlerusa1
    @thebowlerusa1 11 місяців тому

    Nice review... How is DJI Action 4 compared to Insta360 GO 3? TYVM

  • @YTFPV
    @YTFPV 10 місяців тому

    you can see in the white of the cloud the difference of the dji action 4 vs Gopro hero 11 not a lots but in colour correction software it will make a difference

  • @stevencarrier5060
    @stevencarrier5060 11 місяців тому +9

    Be back in a month when we can compare both NEW cameras.
    But I do love the new magnetic mounting system.
    I’ve owned several GoPros and luckily never had an issue. Ever. No resets or lost footage. But I lost a lot of love for GoPro when they REMOVED the Apple Watch app that allowed me to see what the camera was seeing on my watch. Just trying to sell more remotes I guess.

  • @CallMeMrBill
    @CallMeMrBill 10 місяців тому

    I am looking to get an action camera. It appears that the DJI 4 is on backorder. Would getting the DJI Action 3 be a good way to go for now? Looking at the Adventure Combo for the 3

  • @proedgebiker
    @proedgebiker 11 місяців тому

    David, has the Mimo app worked with the A4? I cannot get it to work with the A3 for the life of me. Tried the hack from a YT video, worked for a bit and once again it doesn’t work.

  • @KennethGreenCMP
    @KennethGreenCMP 11 місяців тому +1

    Do the current GoPro owners not use buckle mounts? I have have not removed my bite mount from my GoPro in forever. It goes from the suction cup to my 3 way in two clicks. Why would any one take the thumb screw off on buckle mount then remount it to another buckle mount?

  • @BirdDogOffRoadAdventures
    @BirdDogOffRoadAdventures 11 місяців тому

    Have only used Go Pros thus far (Hero7, Hero9, and Hero10) for our off road adventures. I have a DJI Mavic Mini Pro drone that I love. I'm inclined to try out their action camera since GoPro seems to be taking their market share for granted with the lack of ingenuity. Definitely like the quick release you demonstrated with the DJI units.
    What is that device in your right hand in this video? Is that some sort of remote controller?

    • @johntanchin2545
      @johntanchin2545 11 місяців тому

      it's the throttle controller for the electronic skateboard

    • @BirdDogOffRoadAdventures
      @BirdDogOffRoadAdventures 11 місяців тому

      Ahhh, that makes sense. I'm showing my age, LOL
      @@johntanchin2545

  • @SeKaiNation
    @SeKaiNation 11 місяців тому +1

    Personally now I will be waiting some time to see if they come out with the 12 soon rather than buy now lol. So thank you!

  • @nicknick099
    @nicknick099 10 місяців тому

    Hai,
    Can I also use GoPro clamps with the DJI, for example GoPro wrist strap or official GoPro suction cup?
    Thanks

  • @ss-5813
    @ss-5813 11 місяців тому

    ahh was waiting for your video after your last one with action 3

  • @chrisjones7281
    @chrisjones7281 11 місяців тому +5

    Both are close enough in image quality. In some cases I prefered the GP11 in other cases it didnt matter. I was seeing more detail in the clouds in the GP11 in the closing, I actually do like the slightly wider FOV of the OA4. I dont think if you have 1 or the other you would be able to tell without side by side. But as you mentioned and Ive been saying it since the OA4 came out, its the wrong comparison since GP12 is coming but i get it. The old GP11 is all there is right now. Content needs to be made to sell the OA4. Great video though😊

    • @DavidManningvlog
      @DavidManningvlog  11 місяців тому +2

      I'm totally with you Chris! I can't imagine buying an Osmo Action 4 right now if you could wait to at least see what GoPro has coming out. I don't think you can go wrong either way, but for now in my opinion of these two cameras, the Osmo Action 4 has a very healthy lead in that I know when I hit record, it's going to record👍

    • @someguysomewhere100
      @someguysomewhere100 11 місяців тому

      Close enough in image quality??? Are you on crack, the DJI looked like a grey dystopia.

    • @lyric.kayden
      @lyric.kayden 5 місяців тому

      Chris I agree with you. I noticed on this video and another video I watched that the DJI lost detail in the background a lot and kept annoying me. I don’t either so I’m not married to either but I’m leaning towards the GoPro but DJI does have a few nice features but I can’t understand all these UA-camrs saying go for DJI especially with these background focus issues. I am starting to question there eyes or makes me wonder something else possibly hmm

  • @ntauzaug9595
    @ntauzaug9595 11 місяців тому

    The action 4 color is a little weak, but against the sky background the action 4 blue sky looks better. I think increase the action 4 one stop will make it better. Action 4 audio is better, UI is friendlier, longer battery and quick charging, quick mount, no over heat. I never owned a GoPro or DJI Action camera before, but I just bought the Action 4.

  • @artistjoh
    @artistjoh 10 місяців тому

    I have lots of GoPro mounting gear, sticks, clamps etc etc etc. Does the DJI magnetic mounts attach to GoPro gear?

  • @davidpoo66
    @davidpoo66 10 місяців тому +2

    I was very close to purchasing the GP 11 until I read issues like over heating among others. Consumers need to be beware of reviews these days because in my opinion they can more like a commercial 😢. Thanks for your review, im more impressed ❤

    • @TheProCut17
      @TheProCut17 10 місяців тому

      I just returned my gp11 because front screen stopped working and it overheated

    • @davidpoo66
      @davidpoo66 10 місяців тому

      @@TheProCut17 Did you exchange it ?

    • @TheProCut17
      @TheProCut17 10 місяців тому

      @@davidpoo66 i returned it to Costco with no problem as it was less than 90 days when it malfunctioned thankfully they have a good return policy

  • @AussieLifestyle208
    @AussieLifestyle208 11 місяців тому

    Should I get the action 3 or 4? I'm just not sure if it is worth the extra money.

  • @johantoong4357
    @johantoong4357 7 місяців тому

    Can I charge the osmo while it is recording video? Say for at home fixed in place scenarios.

  • @GDoggProductions
    @GDoggProductions 11 місяців тому

    i like eating my dinner whilst watching your videos 😄😅 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾 great stuff

  • @NightWatcher23
    @NightWatcher23 10 місяців тому

    I like everything about the OA4 but the Hero11 has better colour on the videos, OA4 has a darker brightness balance. Is there a manual setting you can use to override so it matches the Hero11? It will be a winner then for me.

  • @arthurtorricer4544
    @arthurtorricer4544 10 місяців тому

    I have the DJI o3.. I haven't surfed with it yet. I didn't like with my GOpros, the waves would mess up my settings on the screen.. do you have any issues while surfing with DJI 0sm3 or 0sm4?
    2nd Q: can I use osmo 3 and 4 camera on the same DJI mimo app?

  • @joshuadanger904
    @joshuadanger904 11 місяців тому +5

    Straight out of the camera, the Go Pro looks better. If you’re going to edit your videos then that probably doesn’t matter. However, if you’re going to shoot and use that footage, then the Go Pro looks like a winner (minus any reliability concerns, which I personally haven’t had on my Go Pro).

  • @tlsmoke23
    @tlsmoke23 11 місяців тому

    preset button not a game changer. Whats important is better low light (back lit sensor) and battery life audio connection. keep the reliable feet get rid of the mod no need for a cage. how bout some motion record and yes fix the freeze issue.

  • @dadlifetravel
    @dadlifetravel 11 місяців тому +2

    I'm waiting to see what the gopro has to offer. I really enjoy my hero 11 .

  • @OlehKolos
    @OlehKolos 11 місяців тому +1

    Thanks for comparison. Does your Action 4 have any focus issues like previous A3 ? A lot of info in web were people rotate A3 lens physically to get right focus. What about Action 4?

    • @HellbellyUK
      @HellbellyUK 11 місяців тому

      Not from what I've seen on youtube. The minimum focus distance has increased form 30 to 40cm because of the bigger sensor though.

  • @Coaster_Crazy
    @Coaster_Crazy 11 місяців тому +1

    What did you use to record the audio dude in the first clips ??? Super crystal clear

    • @DavidManningvlog
      @DavidManningvlog  11 місяців тому

      That's a Zoom F2 recorder to a Rode Lav 2 that I have rigged up in my helmet

  • @llamaSHORTS1
    @llamaSHORTS1 11 місяців тому

    GoPro picks up sky/cloud details better. Also am I seeing both cameras stutter a bit during pans? More apparent on the action 4 - is this from their built in stabilization algo’s? Or just the shutter speed? It’s like 2-3 times per second

  • @silverpro8356
    @silverpro8356 11 місяців тому

    Too many problems with go pros i got the action 4 and loving it. Plus its got a reliable app and no overheating.

  • @gordon3988
    @gordon3988 10 місяців тому

    Just watched your great GP12 review and then this one…suspect really no difference in these results with the GP12. I tended to prefer the GP FOV and exposure…the OA4 seems a bit too wide (just slightly) and a bit darker (fix with exposure setting?). Neither likely noticeable if not side by side. Loved the functionality and reliability of the OA4! 4 or 5 times in a year to have the GP fail sounds like a lot to me…it should be 1 or 2 or zero. So you can get a very slightly better look with the GP ( IMO) that may freeze, but pretty much the same with the OA4 and know that it always works. Great video and love you made a recommendation. Few reviewers will take a solid position.

  • @scottxb
    @scottxb 11 місяців тому

    Can you make some tee's with pockets? Love the colors!

  • @ztkrx
    @ztkrx 11 місяців тому

    l’d have to say, visually the gopro 11 is much better… but the audio in the action 4 is by far superior. l have them all, the insta360 x3, the insta360 GO3, the gopro 11 and just ordered the osmo action 4 today, can’t wait.

  • @jannarobert8282
    @jannarobert8282 11 місяців тому +1

    Thanks David, great and thorough review, as always 😀
    I see a real difference in image quality though, at least on UA-cam. At 20:10 in your video for example, the clouds behind you are sharp as expected with the GoPro and all blurred and mushy with the Action 4. Looks like a deal breaker for me with the Action 4. Can you confirm or deny that looking at the real footage you shot?

    • @DavidManningvlog
      @DavidManningvlog  11 місяців тому +1

      On the computer, the image between the two looks almost identical. You could probably argue small details one way or the other, but without looking at them side by side, it would be impossible to guess which is which👍

    • @m7rayven195
      @m7rayven195 11 місяців тому

      Yeah, I can see higher detail in the go pro clouds too. However, you can see more detail on David's body in the Action 4. Idk 😂

  • @onnie1968
    @onnie1968 11 місяців тому +1

    I have the gopro 7, 8, 9, 10 & 11 never had any of them freeze up on me..... I still have the 1st osmo action works great same as my dji pocket 1. I was a bit put off by the action 2 & 3, so I'll hold off on the action 4 and see what the Gopro 12 brings to the table.

    • @quickaudi
      @quickaudi 11 місяців тому +1

      All GoPro freeze up, just keep using them. Had it on 3, Session 5, 7, 9, 11

    • @PierPeterVinylSound
      @PierPeterVinylSound 11 місяців тому

      Liar

    • @onnie1968
      @onnie1968 11 місяців тому

      nope never had any of my GoPros freeze on me.@@PierPeterVinylSound

  • @angelodedios8025
    @angelodedios8025 11 місяців тому +1

    Image quality details, smoothness on stabilization and color is still better in the Go Pro Hero 11.

    • @DavidManningvlog
      @DavidManningvlog  11 місяців тому

      That’s debatable, but like said, preference is very important when comparing these two👍

  • @caloyvideos
    @caloyvideos 11 місяців тому

    In Exporting, do you use H.264 or H.265,?

  • @cemkaplanck
    @cemkaplanck 10 місяців тому

    Hi David, it would be great to see full screen performance of both. You just give half of the screen most of the time.

  • @spyder_67
    @spyder_67 11 місяців тому

    Thanks for another great video. I am based in Australia, and I am seriously considering a DJI as an upgrade to my current Hero 8. I use the camera to capture rides on my Can-Am Spyder and regularly lose footage due to the gopro fail. Can you give any advice about using a Purple Panda mic with the DJI.
    Thanks . Seve.

    • @HellbellyUK
      @HellbellyUK 11 місяців тому

      Looks like you should be able to get a TRRS->USB-C cable and connect it that way. Or use the TRRS-TRS adapter with something like the Boya BY-K4. One problem you might have is the mic being too load, even with the gain turned all the way down in camera. I think Motofeelz and Wheelie Good TV have videos about them.

  • @thetigger240
    @thetigger240 11 місяців тому

    Overheating is my number one issue. Thermal management is important to me. I would like an all white version? I don’t know how much the color white would lower the temperature, but I do own a all black truck and also a white car and the temp difference is crazy the black vehicle in the sun is so much hotter, but I don’t know if a white version on the GoPro would change the temp significantly. I do a lot of shooting outside stationary leaving it in the sun and my GoPro overheats constantly and can be frustrating. Despite all this the reason I continue the gopro is the unlimited online storage for 4.99$ per month. I cannot find if dji has an online storage option but doing my research I couldn’t find one. So unlimited online storage for 4.99$ per month is so amazing, because it allows you to shoot as much as you want without having to worry about any storage caps or pay walls for more storage. I do wish this was mentioned in this video (or if dji has this same option). Thank you, amazing video.

  • @Vladimok
    @Vladimok 10 місяців тому

    Tu a quoi comme modele de perche à 4mn de la video ? Merci
    Merci pour le test.
    ---
    What kind of pole do you have at 4 minutes into the video? Thanks
    Thanks for the test.

  • @dudukossi
    @dudukossi 11 місяців тому

    Hi, does the Action 4 shoots in 360 or is there any 360 lenses available for it?Thanks 😁

  • @thegrumpygamer3081
    @thegrumpygamer3081 11 місяців тому +1

    Well I think my money is going to DJI. It's just the reliability of Go Pro that is putting me off enough not to even consider the 12 no matter what the specs. I would hate to lose a once in a lifetime moment, I know that probably would not happen, but just the thought of it puts me off, Like halfway into a 6 mile hike and it crashes and loses the footage. The Action 4 would do more than enough for what I would use it for anyway plus I like the lowlight footage I have seen.

  • @camackay
    @camackay 10 місяців тому +2

    Hi David,
    Love your content - keep it up.
    I bought a Hero11 and returned it within the 30 day period as it was buggy. I'm staying with my Hero9 until the H12 details are released. It doesn't sound promising either. If it's bad I'll buy the DJI 4.
    Question - what's your thoughts about the security of the DJI vs the Hero given various government's concerns about DJI as a company?
    Cheers and keep up the good work.

    • @MadamTV007
      @MadamTV007 10 місяців тому +2

      Good question

  • @krzysiekwtokio
    @krzysiekwtokio 11 місяців тому +1

    You sold Action 4 to me, but as you said GP12 is on the way so let's wait and see. I hope that GP12 price won't go sky high 👀 So far my iphone7 does the job as a Vlogging cam 😂

  • @JCDogpain
    @JCDogpain 11 місяців тому

    Gopro have mounts gadget you can buy online. After market one. It's not magnetic it's mount. They have it since gopro 10. Only it's after market.

  • @waihowong5866
    @waihowong5866 11 місяців тому

    Thanks for the review and comparison!! Your videos have been very helpful in helping me make a decision for my first action cam :) just waiting for your Hero 12 review! (Wonder if you’re probably already working on it right now under an NDA haha :P)
    I’m a little tripped out because I noticed a few times where you’re pointing at the camera to explain either one, you point to the DJI when explaining the GoPro and then you point at the GoPro to describe the DJI, eg. 10:20 and 15:35 mark :D
    Though it is obvious that the DJI has a wider fov, and there’s lot more detail in the shadows. It almost looks like the GoPro was set on HDR as the details in the clouds almost looks like some post work done to bring out the clarity whilst the DJI has significantly less clarity of detail. Was this footage straight out of the camera, or with some WB work done to make it more comparable??

    • @kean4582
      @kean4582 11 місяців тому +1

      Yeah, the way he points at the cameras were a little confusing. And that’s because the Hero 12 is actually mounted on the right, Dji on the left. But they way he edited the video, he made the Hero 12 footage on the left side and the Dji on the right side.