In the movie business, you have to be able to work with others to succeed. Unlike other professions, if you have a bad personality type, nobody will work with you. For example, he understands that you need to give creative liberty to the filmmakers. If he was stubborn and said no the CGI should be like this, he would be out of the job
@@Jmgjgdjd5 No, that is a guy who just hit 30 to a guy who just hit 50. In this video I wouldn't place him any older than 53, and he might be as young as 47, his salt and pepper hair and beard with the receding hair line make him look older, but his skin is still pretty healthy. I wouldn't be surprised if he was mid-40s, but the Troll scan clip from 2000 isn't doing him any favors.
@@itsboyaknow I still don't see it. edit: Having looked for other sources, the actual armor is clipping. When Niko said finger bits I was assuming the actual fingers of the Thanos model would be clipping.
Wren: I just noticed that each of those portals have their own color schemes, that represent the infinity gauntlet. Matt: Maybe you've discovered something we didn't even intend to put in the movie. The guy who secretly went in last minute, and changed the hue sliders on the portals because he thought it was super clever even though his supervisors turned his idea down: “YESSS!!”
The entire final fight scene was so overwhelmingly awesome to watch and the thing that got me so hyped for no reason was watching Antman straight up clocking one of the space whales.
@Drake Barnes I know I've seen all their names but none of them stuck with me. He was a seriously underused character because he should have been fighting with hulk or at a minimum with Thor. The first fight with iron Man and Spider-Man was cool but then we don't see him again until wakanda and he doesn't really do anything until the hulkbuster armor. That should have been the part of the movie for Hulk to get his payback.
Keep a very close eye on the base of the middle finger that as he is closing his hand for the snap, the finger goes into his palm. Very subtle and hard to notice if you don't know exactly what you're looking for, I initially thought it was one of his fingers slightly poking through of the glove.
After this, I could believe that they were each in a different country on greenscreen, and Weta stitched the three of them together in a CGI Corridor Studios office. I don't think they did, but I think Weta could if they wanted to.
Olly I remember people thought at the time it was a little funny stunt by him and Cheadle. Only afterwards did I realise he actually was about to spoil the film before he just said the generic “everyone dies.”
The gauntlet clipping was so subtle, you don't even realize! Kudos to the crew working on Endgame! They did Mark Ruffalo dirty, showing him everytime they talk about spoilers 😂
Do you know that Mark has leaked the end of Ragnarok, Infinity War and Endgame in press interviews? It's not doing him dirty, he just can't keep a secret.
Chief the wraiths have shot their mortars, hurry up Activate the bubble shield, and deliver that line " NOT YET!" *sprints* * jumps infront of a pack of brutes* * Halo 3...Bungie...Xbox*
I'm a direct relative of the vfx supervisor at ILM... I can speak with her about doing the show if y'all like, I'm sure she'd love it and would be awesome to see her on here!
11:32 I can't believe they actually hit Chris Hemsworth with actual lightning. I guess the amount of CGI they used in this film they had no budget left for a cgi lighting. Poor Chris.
Honestly, I didn't quite appreciate that "The Oner" was all one cut until he literally mentioned it. You're so engrossed in the scene that you miss things like that, and it's probably because it's all one cut that everything going on just draws you in so deeply. Amazing
I loved the oner when I first watched it and still do. A similar-looking oner I really like too is when the armies clash in the final battle in Ready Player One
I liked being able to see them in the green screen move doing all their signature moves at once. It is so overcrowded in the final cut that you don't see a lot of that. Much respect to the actors for selling it so hard despite literally not seeing anything but a big empty green room.
There are a crap ton of NDA and contracts you sign before joining a vfx team. Sure you can leak the spoilers, if you don't mind losing your job and get blacklisted from the industry.
Y'all should do a VFX artists react to practical effects in the Star Wars prequels with Adam Savage, since he worked on them wile he was a part of ILM.
A: I agree because Adam and Jamie are amazing human beings. B: There were practical effects in the prequels? I just wrote it off that George got a CGI boner and spooged all over the movies with it, basically abandoning his practical effects roots.
@@PamperedDuchess From what I've seen from behind-the-scenes videos, George seemed pretty reluctant to adopt new CGI technology. After all, it was the animators' initiative to replace puppet Yoda with a CG model.
@@PamperedDuchess More in Episodes I and II than in III, but yeah, there were TONS of practical elements. Loads of vehicle miniatures (the explosion of the Droid Control Ship in TPM is a model for example), buildings and locations (e.g. the Geonosis arena), and some pretty big sets (like the hangar on Naboo. There are even practical elements in the lava rivers on Mustafar.
Pretty much, especially since a lot of those old stories were just written by people high on some drug and teachers think there’s a hidden meaning when the author had no idea what they were doing
Ruffalo: Everybody Dies Cheadle: Dude! Dude! Dude. Ruffalo: Not Everybody Recovery: Unsuccessful Me: In my opinion if Cheadle didn't make a big deal out of it. No one would've known
Taetaer - Chances are it really was a blunder, not a joke. Ruffalo and Tom Holland are the leaky faucets of the franchise-always leaking juicy goss by accident 😆(Case in point, that time Ruffalo accidentally left his phone recording during an early film screening)
Damn it must feel really good to have a veteran in the business compliment your work like that. Especially when I'm sure that Lord of the Rings CG inspired at least one of them.
5:25 "Some people pointed out to us there is a scene where thanos's armour clips through a little bit *bites fingernails nervously* "I know...I know" Jesus, the level of perfection this guy must be used outputting.....
My GF and I randomly watched Riann Wilson's "Super" from 2010.. seeing Ellen Page's character after getting killed still haunts me. Although it looked to be mostly practical...
Jared Devan yeah when glen got his head beat in by Lucille it was brutal seeing Glenn’s eye hanging out of Glenn’s eye socket. I cried myself to sleep that night. Poor Abe got killed too
This episode was awesome having an actual person from Weta come on the show to talk about their work. Weta and ILM are two of my favorite VFX studios working in Hollywood together they have made some of the best looking effects in movies. Their work includes movies like: Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Planet of the Apes trilogy, Avatar, District 9, Transformers, Jurassic Park films, Game of thrones and the MCU films.
Damn, the Oner has got to be one of my favorite single shots not just in the MCU, but in any film. It was a lot of work, but those vfx artists, animators and everyone involved should be proud of that shot.
On a shot like that, you key what you can, and send out the rest for roto. There's a lot of roto and paint required anyway to insert all the cg characters.
Them showing the mistake on Thanos’ gauntlet and him saying “yep, we missed it...there’s always a little bit more than you can do.” just breaks my heart for how overworked these artists can be.
It happens pretty often when you visit your work back later, you see you missed things or feel you could do more. Not necessarily that is because of over work.
@@Entropy-Machine the base of the fingers move inside of the palm slightly. If they noticed it, they may have edited a tiny bit more clearance in the gauntlet metal.
@@DASPRiD Thanos literally holds all 6 infinity stones that determine the rules of the universe, including the reality stone. So as laws of physics still apply in movies, they don't apply to a being who has all 6 infinity stones. Not to mention it's a figurative snap, the sound comes from the finger hitting his palm, not his curled up fingers like it would in a regular snap
It does take guts to tell someone above you that they've messed up. But anyone who is serious about their craft will be happy to hear about where they messed up and how to improve, that is, unless they've heard the same thing loads of times and can't do anything about it anymore. Honest critique is hard to get and extremely useful. It's a valuable thing to anyone serious about their craft.
It's funny because when I saw the movie I really had this feeling about Thanos being different in some shots and now I confirmed it. I personally prefer the "WETA" model rather than the "DD" one because the second one isn't as detailed.
I like how almost all people from New Zealand I've ever heard in an interview are so humble, down to earth and just generally friendly. No matter how famous they are, or how high their social status is. Must be a great country to live in if it produces such pleasant human beings.
They really are great. My mother is from New Zealand, so between her and her family I've gotten a first had look into "Kiwis". They really are friendly people!
Well, you’ve only heard interviews with people of a certain social status. If you were to hear an interview with a crack dealer and rapist she probably wouldn’t seem so nice.
Emmanuel Joseph Santos probably. The people who made this (the artist who worked on lord of the rings) were kinda pushed hard for this scene so there’s some details they missed.
If anyone finds themselves in Wellington, NZ, I highly recommend taking a tour of the Weta campus. These guys are the best or nearly the best at everything they do.
Totally agree. I live here in Welly and have been a few times. It's excellent! First place I lived after moving here from Canada was the suburb of Kilbirnie - in 2002, I would walk this little pathway next to my house over to a big "WalMart" style store nearby, to buy cheap crap ... and I'd pass this series of non-descript looking metal garages, all side by side (with no windows), and one had a small sign on them that simply said "Weta". It was their first studio setup ... when I learned what Weta was a bit later, I was all "WHOA!" They got their much larger studios of course for LOTR, but still ... seeing the original 'sheds' they worked in so close to my house was awesome.
I just remember in theaters, when Tony said “and I am Iron Man”, it seemed to last a minute. Then when you watch it again, it only lasts for the 3-5 seconds that actually happened in the film lol
Just how perfect and tense the scene is. You KNOW the line and what it means and your mind is racing to the result and its full ramifications....your mind is thinking fast and your likely have a drip of adrenaline.
They should do sound designers react. I’d love to see Sam and someone else and someone else react to the music of scenes and talk about how it goes with the scene. Along with sound effects. And maybe even guessing what the sound effects were made from.
If I was Ruffalo I'd have just doubled down hard immediately. "Nah it's cool we can tell em, so Thanos rocks up and just glasses Earth, wipes everybody out. I die, Thor dies, Cap dies, War Machine gets ripped in half while in his armor, it's just an absolute slaughter, and Thanos basically wins."
Main Stream ouf that wouldn’t work since people would’ve believed him because ruffalo and Holland are the spoiler royalty. Maybe could’ve worked with other actors to do that type of save.
Matt at the end: "We are working on the Black Widow movie." Me: Yes!! Really cool insight in to the CGI in Endgame. Gotta say, the making of Thanos still blows my mind.
@@lacroixpoison9030 No lol I opened the movie file on my computer and skipped through until I found the shot I was referring to and noted the time index.
@@fredfredburger5150 Thanos is just mindblowing at times, in the theatre i literally forgot he was a cg element for a second and was like "wow that makeup is really good"
@@GamingOS I know right? As an older guy (42) I'm genuinely amazed at how good cgi has gotten since it started showing up in movies in the 90's. It's only in very recent years we've got human/humanlike characters that don't trigger the "Uncanny Valley" response (such as the Wolverine clone in Logan), Thanos is one of them, like you I often forgot I was watching a cgi character.
You really know a moment in a movie is great when it makes you cry even though you watch it without most of the building up to it. 10:00 pepper coming in
I remember seeing that in the Cinema and my mind was totally blown away.. Remember, in that time I played with Unreal Tournament and Quake 2 I believe.. so I was stunned that they can make such realistic humans with computer. Looking back, it doesn't look so great, but can't pull it out of context and time.
Square's huge mistake was calling it Final Fantasy. If they had just left it at Spirits Within and call it an original movie made by the creators of FF it would have been received 10 times better.
@@jasonblalock4429 I'm not totally sure, but the shot before he pops the question (the sorta dance routine they do with working on the ship in the moonlight) might be one continuous shot, I'd love to see their input on that being done, especially back then.
05:25 , I've also noted similiar thing in Transformers Revenge of the fallen , when Megatron sits inside Lincoln memorial , His feet would clip through the concrete bottom
@@astralgen Antman has superhuman invulnerability similar to MCU hulk when he shrinks, which is why he instinctively shrunk as soon as thanos attacked. It's completely in his ability that he'd survive. It wasn't a direct hit either. Rocket and hawkeye are definitely fucked though lol
Veloziraptor111 I mean they can't really make it much smaller than that because let's be honest here a battle field with tens of thousands of people can't really be created from an explosion that only blew up a building.And like he said it had to look big enough to create a sizable crater.I think not being logical for just a short while is a small price to pay if you want to have a stunning setting for the climax.
For future vfx video: *adventure's of merlin!* i'm curious whatta think of that. And also I'd like to see a reaction to the *Chronicles of Narnia* especially Aslan!
I had the pleasure of working on the "Avengers Assemble" shot and "The Oner" as the lighter/rendering TD. Despite seeing this scene and those shots HUNDREDS of times, it still gives me goose bumps every time. We had a great team and ill never forget what we accomplished 🙂
My whole life, my whole damn life waiting for someone to "just do it good!" And they did. They did the comic book movies good! I get goosebumps during this scene EVERY time. The amount of work it takes to make a goddamn comic book movie look good is insane! Thank you!
Thanks for watching er'body! If you want to watch this entire show from the beginning you can do that here ►
ua-cam.com/video/_4WrKeoeZhk/v-deo.html
9
lil late aint it
9
bro forgot
this guy is so humble, like his team is the frontline of vfx art industry now, and he said nothing about praising himself at all.
salute to you sir.
Adi Ricky Everyone at WETA is like that. They’re amazing.
Because that's what hero do.
I thought i read horrible at first and i got very confused
I love how he admires CGI in general like I could go to a bar and have a 2 hour conversation with this guy
In the movie business, you have to be able to work with others to succeed. Unlike other professions, if you have a bad personality type, nobody will work with you. For example, he understands that you need to give creative liberty to the filmmakers. If he was stubborn and said no the CGI should be like this, he would be out of the job
"Sir, what are your credentials?"
"I once scanned a Troll for Lord of the Rings..."
"WE'RE NOT WORTHY!"
He aged fast in these 20 years
Jmgjgdjd5 it's 20 years, he just aged
yep, pretty much. Just a human aging without any hair dyes etc.
@@meloncheck from a guy in his 20s to a guy in his 60s
@@Jmgjgdjd5 No, that is a guy who just hit 30 to a guy who just hit 50. In this video I wouldn't place him any older than 53, and he might be as young as 47, his salt and pepper hair and beard with the receding hair line make him look older, but his skin is still pretty healthy. I wouldn't be surprised if he was mid-40s, but the Troll scan clip from 2000 isn't doing him any favors.
Oof that look of pain on his face when they bring up the gauntlet clipping.
That's how you know he cares about his work
Honestly if I didn't watch the video I would never see this detail x)
I never noticed it either
@@itsboyaknow I still don't see it.
edit: Having looked for other sources, the actual armor is clipping. When Niko said finger bits I was assuming the actual fingers of the Thanos model would be clipping.
ReatuKrentor me either I watched it like 6 times
“Let’s make this portal blue, that one yellow-“
Fans - “ *IT REPRESENTS THE INFINITY STONES* “
Yeah. People be reaching.
LoFio MuffHugger the guys at WETA we’re probably like “it’s just the lighting from where they came from what is wrong with you people”
Yeah, it's funny coz he's wrong. The only colour missing is Orange or maybe Red if you don't count one of them as being Red, so it'd be 5 out of 6.
All the stones use commonly found colours so with so many on screen there were bound to be similarities.
@@30secondstomarsMBH p
"How bad could this shot be?"
*Shows One-er*
"...I see..."
... I see
( ͡° ͜ʖ ͡°)
SirMan McDude Don’t read my name
SirMan McDude ua-cam.com/video/aaka6xh8lW4/v-deo.html
Anytime any studio has a "Oner" then that means it's a personal nightmare for someone for a loooooong time
Thanos: I am inevitable.
Niko: and I am simulating pore-stretching.
You are correct. I am inevitable.
@@thanosthemadtitan3233 you're also dead so....
Wren: I just noticed that each of those portals have their own color schemes, that represent the infinity gauntlet.
Matt: Maybe you've discovered something we didn't even intend to put in the movie.
The guy who secretly went in last minute, and changed the hue sliders on the portals because he thought it was super clever even though his supervisors turned his idea down: “YESSS!!”
Haha yeah
But prop got no raise
No pat on the shoulder
And his boss get all the grats for it
Heeeey im number 69
@@zacharydavis83 ayyyyy my guy XD
Joash Britto this is now part of my evidence that half the symbolism in media is unintentional.
housegirlfakenew.link/l_kAWV3Nvyoa
The entire final fight scene was so overwhelmingly awesome to watch and the thing that got me so hyped for no reason was watching Antman straight up clocking one of the space whales.
It reminded me of the History Lesson in Justice league. (Can't wait for the Snyder Cut btw)
I liked when he stepped on the "Hulk" bad guy. That was pretty epic.
@Drake Barnes I know I've seen all their names but none of them stuck with me. He was a seriously underused character because he should have been fighting with hulk or at a minimum with Thor. The first fight with iron Man and Spider-Man was cool but then we don't see him again until wakanda and he doesn't really do anything until the hulkbuster armor. That should have been the part of the movie for Hulk to get his payback.
Yessss I'm glad someone agrees I watched this shit in theaters day one & I was popping off at that specific moment lmao
Thanos has Ezra Bridger in his team?
Them: THE FINGERS CLIPPED THROUGH THE GLOVE!!
Me: *pausing the vid and squinting to see what the heck they are talking about*
Keep a very close eye on the base of the middle finger that as he is closing his hand for the snap, the finger goes into his palm. Very subtle and hard to notice if you don't know exactly what you're looking for, I initially thought it was one of his fingers slightly poking through of the glove.
Barely noticeable
Oh it’s so minor you couldn’t even see it in iMAX
I've tried and I still don't see it
Facts
11:32, turns out Chris Hemsworth is actually god of thunder without any VFX
Exactly
oh my fucking god
@@Frank_Ditch oh my fucking thor
You didn't know this?
Lol
Legend has it that they weren't even sitting on a couch for this episode and WETA just added it in.
After this, I could believe that they were each in a different country on greenscreen, and Weta stitched the three of them together in a CGI Corridor Studios office. I don't think they did, but I think Weta could if they wanted to.
legend has it this comment was just cg'd after the fact/
Legend has it, i am just CGI
I’m not gonna lie I looked at the “bad” glove scene and couldn’t figure out what was wrong with it 😂
the fingers sort of phase through his palm. Like innvideogames lol
It’s very tiny but when I first saw it when this episode premiered I was like “oh no way!!!”
The bottom pad of the middle and ring finger kinda go through the top of the palm. Barely noticeable.
You can see the very bit of the tip of his finger it's as if its phasing through the glove only only shows for like 1 second
The part of his glove that covers his middle and ring fingers clipped through into the part of the glove that covers his palms.
“We’re working on Black Widow, *which is coming out soon* “
Coronavirus: *laughs*
this is a nightmare
Laughs in quarantine
It is in November. Probably and most likely on Disney+
Disney+? Alright, piratebay it is then...
“We’re working on Black Widow, *which is coming out soon* “
Coronavirus: *laughs and says* IM GONNA END THIS MAN'S WHOLE CAREER
I just realised when Mark says, everyone dies, he nearly says half
Olly I remember people thought at the time it was a little funny stunt by him and Cheadle. Only afterwards did I realise he actually was about to spoil the film before he just said the generic “everyone dies.”
he says well only half , after he says everyone dies. Watch that part of the interview beyond it, he spoils it even more.
He made it worse by saying that only half of them dies 😂
i thought it was a bit that he was doing, not actual spoilers lmao
Ur likes are exactly 911
The gauntlet clipping was so subtle, you don't even realize! Kudos to the crew working on Endgame!
They did Mark Ruffalo dirty, showing him everytime they talk about spoilers 😂
He deserves it LOL. Clearly kind of a thick dude. Great actor, though.
Do you know that Mark has leaked the end of Ragnarok, Infinity War and Endgame in press interviews? It's not doing him dirty, he just can't keep a secret.
Hahaha, I like how the shot of Hemsworth on green screen at 11:31 implies that both his suit/weapons AND the lighting were all practical haha
Yeah little known fact Chris Hemsworth is Thor and no visual effects were used for his lightning
Thor is living on Earth with the name of Chris Hemsworth
Chief the wraiths have shot their mortars, hurry up Activate the bubble shield, and deliver that line " NOT YET!" *sprints* * jumps infront of a pack of brutes* * Halo 3...Bungie...Xbox*
All australians learn that in school
yep, that lightning completely practical, no cgi on that. Just the green screen XD
11:32 Chris Hemsworth summons actual lightning from the sky, and the visual effects just replace the green screen background... :O
My guess is another visual effects studio worked on the lightning, and then passed that onto WETA for the background.
@@zai3208 Most likely
Gotta love his dedication to the role. Wonderful Method acting there.
@@zai3208 bro, really???🤣🤣🤣
@@samzilla567 Chris Evans also had to age 60 years into the future, true method acting
“Reacting to Avengers Endgame good and bad cgi”
Literally the only bad cgi was the gauntlet clipping for .2 seconds 😂
I don't see where it happens.
Elijah Shells 5:25
@@elijahshells 5:24
Yeah even when they showed the shot I still could barely tell
I can't see it
This was impressive, bringing WETA themselves to the Corridor couch. Loved the Endgame coverage! Best ep yet!
Weta being the best shop right now. And the chief effects supervisor on their couch... Must be like meeting Jesus , For them..
Next is ILM
I'm glad that they didn't have to replace the lightning Hemsworth called down at 11:32
Not being disrespectful, but this guys head is the perfect shape for Thanos.
i thought the same thing
This guy is Thanos himself
Thats a blessing not disrespect
ua-cam.com/video/vt-LLrpGhG8/v-deo.html
You are speaking about me
I'm a direct relative of the vfx supervisor at ILM... I can speak with her about doing the show if y'all like, I'm sure she'd love it and would be awesome to see her on here!
Of course tell her !!!
Send them an email about it! Would love to see another view point too!
Make it so
Are you kidding? Of course, tell her to get on here LOL!
I would love to see that and the corridor boys would never say no to that. Please do it.
11:32 I can't believe they actually hit Chris Hemsworth with actual lightning. I guess the amount of CGI they used in this film they had no budget left for a cgi lighting. Poor Chris.
Geek Nation haha
He's just that committed to his role!
Poor poor Chris
It's not real.
Geek Nation very underrated comment
Honestly, I didn't quite appreciate that "The Oner" was all one cut until he literally mentioned it. You're so engrossed in the scene that you miss things like that, and it's probably because it's all one cut that everything going on just draws you in so deeply. Amazing
I loved the oner when I first watched it and still do. A similar-looking oner I really like too is when the armies clash in the final battle in Ready Player One
I liked being able to see them in the green screen move doing all their signature moves at once. It is so overcrowded in the final cut that you don't see a lot of that. Much respect to the actors for selling it so hard despite literally not seeing anything but a big empty green room.
I thought he said runner, so I thought it'd be the running the gauntlet scene, but oner is cool too😂
@@LordSeth-hf8ew Same! :D
Dude, I had no idea Howard the Duck was in that shot at all! xD
17 frames is less than a second
Can we just appreciare that vfx artist, even knowing Tony's demise, they don't spill spoilers.
No.....They are professionals
some times they make two or more versions, so sometimes they actually don't know
There are a crap ton of NDA and contracts you sign before joining a vfx team. Sure you can leak the spoilers, if you don't mind losing your job and get blacklisted from the industry.
They can't. You can get really screwed if you violate a NDA.
@@jinnimoo and getting a massive fine
When you realize it is only Weta Digital who has an access of a nude Thanos.
😳
Didnt they mentioned that an other studio had an other thanos model to work with
That means there are multiple nude ThanASSes
Ever heard about the amazing bulk?
how do i delete someone else's comment?
@James Coombs James Coomba Did you just rick rolled me>>>>>>PL{P}+_{P{:{P>_:>}_P_:}+___)P_P>
>:)(&#%#%#$^$&$%%
"The black widow movie coming soon..."
@BladeZ_ adymany yes and
@BladeZ_ adymany its a prequel
Black Widows release is akin to reaching the end of the universe.
You keep getting closer but never actually get there.
Rip
No it is out
8:46 "leave a comment in the description below." how tho
Gonna use the reality stone
Lol
I still have comments on
whenever we comment on youtube we are actually commenting in the description
:bigbrain:
Onimirare Legit read this comment as soon as he said it lmao
“We have an ongoing relationship with marvel, it’s FANTASTIC”.... I see what he did there 👌🏻
Pretty sure it wasnt intended
@@corcs2037 A man can dream
Corcs20 im optimistic lol
If it was intentional, that’s some great foreshadowing!!
I hope it's true.
1:51 i love how you can hear him almost say "half" instead of everybody, but he exaggerated to make it less believable
thetrashslingingasher whoa
Man, I discovered that clip a few months before Endgame came out and I was shocked, amazed and happy that almost no one picked up on it 😂🤣😊
That clip is classic haha mostly because of Don Cheadle’s reaction
But why did he spoiled it? Lol so stupid ..
Ptyler Beats hes the one that gave it away as a leak 😂 if he just played along then no one would have been able to tell if it was a joke or not
I’m very worried for the person that noticed the Thanos hand clipping.
Poor guy must have watched that scene like 40+ times
I thought the nanotech was adapting to his fingers lmao
Lol, I saw it the first time I watched Endgame. Dunno how. But I just looked at his hand and saw it.
Damn I was focusing more on fingers and Thanos face then down there, it's just such a small error lol.
I have watched it like 100times and still didnt figured it out until they said it
i think i first noticed it on my 4th watch of the movie.
Y'all should do a VFX artists react to practical effects in the Star Wars prequels with Adam Savage, since he worked on them wile he was a part of ILM.
You can see him in one if the behind the scenes videos for the Matrix sequels. IIRC, he was working on the Zion miniature.
A: I agree because Adam and Jamie are amazing human beings.
B: There were practical effects in the prequels? I just wrote it off that George got a CGI boner and spooged all over the movies with it, basically abandoning his practical effects roots.
@@PamperedDuchess From what I've seen from behind-the-scenes videos, George seemed pretty reluctant to adopt new CGI technology. After all, it was the animators' initiative to replace puppet Yoda with a CG model.
omgitssupercheese they have an episode where they react to Star Wars prequels
@@PamperedDuchess More in Episodes I and II than in III, but yeah, there were TONS of practical elements. Loads of vehicle miniatures (the explosion of the Droid Control Ship in TPM is a model for example), buildings and locations (e.g. the Geonosis arena), and some pretty big sets (like the hangar on Naboo. There are even practical elements in the lava rivers on Mustafar.
8:25 is every English teacher talking about hidden meanings lmao
Yah and most of them will shoot down anyone who sees something they hadn't.
8:33 The author: That's not what I intended...
Or alternatively, a straight up jordanpetersonism.
Author: Nah fam, it's just different colors.
Pretty much, especially since a lot of those old stories were just written by people high on some drug and teachers think there’s a hidden meaning when the author had no idea what they were doing
Ruffalo: Everybody Dies
Cheadle: Dude! Dude! Dude.
Ruffalo: Not Everybody
Recovery: Unsuccessful
Me: In my opinion if Cheadle didn't make a big deal out of it. No one would've known
Insight Verified I’m pretty sure it was supposed to be a joke.
Taetaer - Chances are it really was a blunder, not a joke. Ruffalo and Tom Holland are the leaky faucets of the franchise-always leaking juicy goss by accident 😆(Case in point, that time Ruffalo accidentally left his phone recording during an early film screening)
exactly what I was thinking
That moment between cheadle and ruffalo was obviously a joke in context
I think this moment was before infinity war.
This guy is AWESOME. Not only did him and his team deliver awesome resluts, the guy is very down to earth, funny, and just an overall cool person.
Yeah legit would love to see him back on here
Damn it must feel really good to have a veteran in the business compliment your work like that. Especially when I'm sure that Lord of the Rings CG inspired at least one of them.
GlitterFairyLilo *all of them
5:25 "Some people pointed out to us there is a scene where thanos's armour clips through a little bit
*bites fingernails nervously* "I know...I know"
Jesus, the level of perfection this guy must be used outputting.....
Fuck you
@@leoglanninger7112 you good?
@@oraclegear1687 no
@@leoglanninger7112 what's wrong?
@@leoglanninger7112 Dude
Fans: "I noticed you did thing."
Weta: "Thing was not intentional."
“We’re working on the Black Widow movie which opens soon”
Oh honey you have no idea
In just 3 months, it will be the year anniversary of when it was supposed to come out lol
@@thebananamelon5065 no way
Feels like an eternity ugh....
I wish these episodes were like half an hour long. I’ve NEVER thought “Wow, that VFX artists react was TOO long.”
Don't they have longer reactions on Patreon?
LordManda2 you know, you’re probably right! My brokeass wouldn’t know haha
I'm glad they didn't have Tony Stark's eye hanging out or his face melting off
oh man, can you imagine the number of kids who would need therapy after seeing something like that!
My GF and I randomly watched Riann Wilson's "Super" from 2010.. seeing Ellen Page's character after getting killed still haunts me. Although it looked to be mostly practical...
Jared Devan yeah when glen got his head beat in by Lucille it was brutal seeing Glenn’s eye hanging out of Glenn’s eye socket. I cried myself to sleep that night. Poor Abe got killed too
@Jared Devan It was like that in the comics, so a lot of people were already aware of what was coming.
@Jared Devan yep! That's exactly what im saying. It's not the violence it's who it happens to.
8:40 is basically the author telling the English teacher that the meaning isn't that deep
the door was red
@@lilHDMI 😮😲😯
What, you egg? [he stabs him]
Teacher: Omg the door was red 🥺
Well most authors from your native lang class don't live anymore but they still turn around in their graves when they hear these interpretations
10:06 surprised they didn’t comment on the fact that Pepper shoots at nothing here
But it looks cool so
What about the 3 alien pillar ships
Because that was her first time wearing that suit. Goes back to Tony telling Morgan that Pepper never wears what he gifts her.
This episode was awesome having an actual person from Weta come on the show to talk about their work. Weta and ILM are two of my favorite VFX studios working in Hollywood together they have made some of the best looking effects in movies. Their work includes movies like: Star Wars, Lord of the Rings, Planet of the Apes trilogy, Avatar, District 9, Transformers, Jurassic Park films, Game of thrones and the MCU films.
“Maybe you have discovered something we didn’t even intend to put in the movie” @ every marvel fanboy
He did called peter parker spidey.
@@Gilgamoth 😂 *call
R L lmao found the nerdy grammar police
@@JonathanMandrake Sftu this isn't an English essay.
New rockstars do it all the time
11:32 I thought that was CGI, but I guess Chris is LITTERALY thor
The man can actually summon lighting
@tanya ice r/woooosh
@tanya ice Human With no humor
lol
HAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAHAHAHAHAHA
Damn, the Oner has got to be one of my favorite single shots not just in the MCU, but in any film. It was a lot of work, but those vfx artists, animators and everyone involved should be proud of that shot.
The Bearded guy in the middle: Black widow will be out soon
Earth 2020 April: Nope
That gives me depression
@@mallerschwab980 Same...
I guess it went viral
Son of a bitch i forgot that was coming out
Earth 2020 July: still nope
I love ducks.
why would that be up to just one random employee?
Woulda been cool to see him shoot his gun
@@its1899 why not
He was in gotg movies to
He made a credits cameo in one of the GotG films as well.
7:31 “they’re good green screens, they’re clean”
shows a literal nightmare in green.
Apparently that means clean in this context.
On a shot like that, you key what you can, and send out the rest for roto. There's a lot of roto and paint required anyway to insert all the cg characters.
11:46 You can feel Wren's "Hoh boy... :)" is backed up by experience and isn't just an empty acknowledgement of the massive task it represented xD
“We have an ongoing relationship with Marvel and its fantastic” Fantastic 4 movie confirmed
Oh shit I didn't think like that at all
"Leave a comment in the description below"
-Niko 2020
Give the time stamp
@@Digthewolverine 8:46
@@Digthewolverine 8:46
@@Digthewolverine 8:46
@@TopdeckNuII 😂😂
Them showing the mistake on Thanos’ gauntlet and him saying “yep, we missed it...there’s always a little bit more than you can do.” just breaks my heart for how overworked these artists can be.
Them talking about it, and zooming in on it. I can't see what they're talking about
They're well paid though, and I'm pretty sure they love their job. It shows
It happens pretty often when you visit your work back later, you see you missed things or feel you could do more. Not necessarily that is because of over work.
@@Entropy-Machine the base of the fingers move inside of the palm slightly. If they noticed it, they may have edited a tiny bit more clearance in the gauntlet metal.
Greg Weller I couldn’t either. Look at the base of his middle finger to really see it.
"Wait til you see this next one, everybody dies"
Hurts me everytime
Love how people still don't get about every line in those interviews is staged to the dots ;)
@@peterpain6625 yea it was definitely planned lol, not that great acting tbh
No one notices he was about to say “half”
I always wondered: can you even snap the fingers, wearing a metal gauntlet?
You already know the answer
You can't, Because Science tested that already ;)
@@DASPRiD but we are talking about a dimension that has a talking racoon,waling tree that can talk,etc
@@sunnysideggo2821 The MCU still follows the laws of physics… at least in the non-complex terms ;)
@@DASPRiD Thanos literally holds all 6 infinity stones that determine the rules of the universe, including the reality stone. So as laws of physics still apply in movies, they don't apply to a being who has all 6 infinity stones.
Not to mention it's a figurative snap, the sound comes from the finger hitting his palm, not his curled up fingers like it would in a regular snap
Stunt men react to Kung Fu hustle . Literally any fight scene. Trust me. You’ll love it
YES!
FUCK YES!
Yes I love that movie !
Marvel: about to release Black Widow
Coronavirus: I'm about to end this man's whole career
Probably my favorite shot in the movie is when Tony and Pepper are firing both of their big beams back to back.
I dunno, the Ancient One slapping Bruce Banner out of the Hulk and him being like "wait wtf" was pretty awesome
Even though Pepper wasn't actually shooting at anything.
ASS TO ASS
I like that you guys had the balls to call him out on his own error straight to his face lol
yeah when the rest of the video is "your work is unbelievable" I think among professionals laughing about a small error was pretty safe
@Sofa I like that he owned it too
Because that error is nothing compared to the rest of his amazing work
Along with if you don't point it out, how can they improve? Calling out on their error isn't a insult
It does take guts to tell someone above you that they've messed up. But anyone who is serious about their craft will be happy to hear about where they messed up and how to improve, that is, unless they've heard the same thing loads of times and can't do anything about it anymore. Honest critique is hard to get and extremely useful. It's a valuable thing to anyone serious about their craft.
This guy when he looks at the cgi work they did when endgame wasn't out yet: "This does put a smile on my face"
Cording karma I had a stroke reading this
@@joseiscorrect2902 don't worry I had a stroke writing it as well glad to see I'm not alone
Avengers: oops we missed his fingertips
Game of Thrones: oops we missed the giant Starbucks coffee cup
10:05 so we are not going to talk about the part that pepper is literally firing at no body and is just aiming in the air?
Lmao
She shoot the outriders farms
The Canadian Lad🙏
She was turning to shoot at something else while her laser was already shooting
I don’t like you for pointing that out
Disney Treasure planet: John Silver's mechanical arm, just for the fluent movement of the CG arm with the hand drawn animation.
Hunter Zickafoose Hell yeah. One of my favorite movies as a kid.
The scene where the avengers assembled, up until now, still gives me the goosebumps. Damn.
It's funny because when I saw the movie I really had this feeling about Thanos being different in some shots and now I confirmed it. I personally prefer the "WETA" model rather than the "DD" one because the second one isn't as detailed.
I like how almost all people from New Zealand I've ever heard in an interview are so humble, down to earth and just generally friendly. No matter how famous they are, or how high their social status is. Must be a great country to live in if it produces such pleasant human beings.
They really are great. My mother is from New Zealand, so between her and her family I've gotten a first had look into "Kiwis". They really are friendly people!
How could it be any different? They live with hobbits.
I live in NZ and it’s great
You probably haven't heard of isreal adesanya.
Well, you’ve only heard interviews with people of a certain social status. If you were to hear an interview with a crack dealer and rapist she probably wouldn’t seem so nice.
9:50 I love when ant-man punches that chitauri leviathan
That’s always been my favorite part of that fight
Same
Yep.
Emmanuel Joseph Santos probably. The people who made this (the artist who worked on lord of the rings) were kinda pushed hard for this scene so there’s some details they missed.
It's like:
I'm a big monster rawr
👊
If anyone finds themselves in Wellington, NZ, I highly recommend taking a tour of the Weta campus. These guys are the best or nearly the best at everything they do.
Totally agree. I live here in Welly and have been a few times. It's excellent!
First place I lived after moving here from Canada was the suburb of Kilbirnie - in 2002, I would walk this little pathway next to my house over to a big "WalMart" style store nearby, to buy cheap crap ... and I'd pass this series of non-descript looking metal garages, all side by side (with no windows), and one had a small sign on them that simply said "Weta". It was their first studio setup ... when I learned what Weta was a bit later, I was all "WHOA!" They got their much larger studios of course for LOTR, but still ... seeing the original 'sheds' they worked in so close to my house was awesome.
I just remember in theaters, when Tony said “and I am Iron Man”, it seemed to last a minute. Then when you watch it again, it only lasts for the 3-5 seconds that actually happened in the film lol
Just how perfect and tense the scene is. You KNOW the line and what it means and your mind is racing to the result and its full ramifications....your mind is thinking fast and your likely have a drip of adrenaline.
those few seconds between when Cap says "Avengers!" and "Assemble" were my biggest geekgasm feeling ever :D
Same
Except he waited until everyone had already assembled
@@joeb8935 that is so infinitely beside the point of the scene.
Grow up
@@erravi Stay youthful
When cap gets the little hammer you can hear him say “yes!” Under his breath
I think that was just a "heh" or some other "breathing heavily" noise
How did he get a hammer that was only supposed to be able to be wielded by Thor or Vision?
@@ShivaServer2009 really?
@@ShivaServer2009 it says some like you gotta be worthy enough to be able to pick it up.
ShivaServer2009 maybe you should watch the movie...
You should react to the pirates of the caribbean series and breaking bad's "missing face scene" from the ending of season 4.
Definitely pirates
wasn't the missing face scene mostly makeup and prosthetic?
bournechupacabra no it looks pretty cg
They did react to Davy Jones. Maybe skeleton pirates in Curse of the Black Pearl?
Face is 100% cg... Basic stuff nowadays...
They should do sound designers react. I’d love to see Sam and someone else and someone else react to the music of scenes and talk about how it goes with the scene. Along with sound effects. And maybe even guessing what the sound effects were made from.
"Wait till u see the next one. Everybody dies."
"Dudude dude"
If I was Ruffalo I'd have just doubled down hard immediately.
"Nah it's cool we can tell em, so Thanos rocks up and just glasses Earth, wipes everybody out. I die, Thor dies, Cap dies, War Machine gets ripped in half while in his armor, it's just an absolute slaughter, and Thanos basically wins."
Main Stream ouf that wouldn’t work since people would’ve believed him because ruffalo and Holland are the spoiler royalty. Maybe could’ve worked with other actors to do that type of save.
He started saying "half of everybody"...
Matt at the end: "We are working on the Black Widow movie." Me: Yes!! Really cool insight in to the CGI in Endgame. Gotta say, the making of Thanos still blows my mind.
That scene in infinity where Thanos shows up looks 100% real as far as I'm concerned. 2:05:12 in the movie.
fred fredburger Jesus Christ you know the exact time
@@lacroixpoison9030 No lol I opened the movie file on my computer and skipped through until I found the shot I was referring to and noted the time index.
@@fredfredburger5150 Thanos is just mindblowing at times, in the theatre i literally forgot he was a cg element for a second and was like "wow that makeup is really good"
@@GamingOS I know right? As an older guy (42) I'm genuinely amazed at how good cgi has gotten since it started showing up in movies in the 90's. It's only in very recent years we've got human/humanlike characters that don't trigger the "Uncanny Valley" response (such as the Wolverine clone in Logan), Thanos is one of them, like you I often forgot I was watching a cgi character.
You really know a moment in a movie is great when it makes you cry even though you watch it without most of the building up to it.
10:00 pepper coming in
The film is bang average
@@daniel15yearsago66 That's like, your opinion man.
@@mohammedmohiuddin8622 and it's just as valid is you opinion. And you opinion is just as invalid as mine....
@@daniel15yearsago66 Ok
@@mohammedmohiuddin8622 He's not wrong you know
This was a awesome episode, you really need to have this gentleman back on!
I just spent this whole episode in pure awe of this man's knowledge and skill.
11:32 Love how that makes it look like the lightning was done in-camera ;D
Please react to any scene from "Final Fantasy: The Spirits Within". The history of how it got made is very interesting.
I remember seeing that in the Cinema and my mind was totally blown away.. Remember, in that time I played with Unreal Tournament and Quake 2 I believe.. so I was stunned that they can make such realistic humans with computer. Looking back, it doesn't look so great, but can't pull it out of context and time.
Square's huge mistake was calling it Final Fantasy. If they had just left it at Spirits Within and call it an original movie made by the creators of FF it would have been received 10 times better.
Honestly the final fantasy movies CG still holds up now. Only slight uncanny valley in spirits within.
And Final Fantasy VII: Advent Children
, I'd like to see a reaction to that too.
"We're working on the black widow movie and that's opening soon" is like hearing "see you in a minute"
Pirates of the caribbean 1 : Jack Sparrow vs Barbossa sword fight
Also, the "do you believe in ghost stories?" sequence.
(I'd also love to see them cover the "hamster wheel" sword fight from POTC2.)
@@jasonblalock4429 I'm not totally sure, but the shot before he pops the question (the sorta dance routine they do with working on the ship in the moonlight) might be one continuous shot, I'd love to see their input on that being done, especially back then.
Pirates of the Caribbean in general. Kraken scenes for example.
My roommate was watching that movie the other day and I stopped and remembered how blown away I was in theaters at how seamless it was.
🍻
12:14 That makes sense, since the shot itself was a late reshoot.
"The Hitchiker's Guide to the Galaxy" (2005) still holds up well. I'd be curious how much of it is practical vs cg.
Keep up the good work y'all!
05:25 , I've also noted similiar thing in Transformers Revenge of the fallen , when Megatron sits inside Lincoln memorial , His feet would clip through the concrete bottom
Seeing him scanning the troll in Lord of the Rings, then seeing him now, makes me feel hella old.
Yeah he really let himself go.
p fuller I actually think he looks like he came into his own
@@Soul-cry1 or you know, he aged 20 years...
p fuller shut THE FUCK up this man looks great no homo, especially being older
hello Fulcan. btw n word
2:20 let's be honest, no one would survive the explosion that was put in the movie either.
I mean Thor and Hulk could, but Hawkeye, Antman, and Rocket are fucked
@@astralgen Antman has superhuman invulnerability similar to MCU hulk when he shrinks, which is why he instinctively shrunk as soon as thanos attacked. It's completely in his ability that he'd survive. It wasn't a direct hit either. Rocket and hawkeye are definitely fucked though lol
Pretty much only Thor and Hulk
Veloziraptor111 I mean they can't really make it much smaller than that because let's be honest here a battle field with tens of thousands of people can't really be created from an explosion that only blew up a building.And like he said it had to look big enough to create a sizable crater.I think not being logical for just a short while is a small price to pay if you want to have a stunning setting for the climax.
they were all mostly in a very secure building, so yes they would
My head canon: the nanomachines in the gauntlet allowed it to "clip" into itself.
... NANOMACHINES SON!
YOU CAN’T HURT ME, TONY! *snaps*
They harden in response to physical trauma
Nice ref 🤣
4:02 I like that they put the "orange soda clip.😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
For future vfx video: *adventure's of merlin!* i'm curious whatta think of that.
And also I'd like to see a reaction to the *Chronicles of Narnia* especially Aslan!
nightspicer YES. Those Narnia films were my childhood, and I know they had to do some very specific innovations to make Aslan work.
OOOOOOh my gosh, I totally agree!!
nightspicer ua-cam.com/video/_4uIHOiYoYg/v-deo.html
I need Narnia now!
I only just noticed Cpt Marvel's "oh shit" look when Thanos grabbed the power stone
That hit was so hard she basically got punched out of the MCU by Thanos.
@@fnors2 Thanos "don't push me girl, or I'll smack you back to the Room you came from"
8:52 omg the scene, the music always gives me goosebumps!
SAME LIKE MEGA GOOSEBUMPS
I have goosebumps clicking this timestamp 😂
@civilsimmy Dave Seriously? Some people just don't want to enjoy a movie. Also, how is that cringy at all 😂
I had the pleasure of working on the "Avengers Assemble" shot and "The Oner" as the lighter/rendering TD. Despite seeing this scene and those shots HUNDREDS of times, it still gives me goose bumps every time. We had a great team and ill never forget what we accomplished 🙂
@civilsimmy Dave Do u know the meaning of cringe? Whatever idc. Ur opinion.
My whole life, my whole damn life waiting for someone to "just do it good!" And they did. They did the comic book movies good! I get goosebumps during this scene EVERY time. The amount of work it takes to make a goddamn comic book movie look good is insane! Thank you!
Clint's not in this one because he has yet to see any MCU films.
10:04 i just realize that Pepper pots was aiming at nothing
Doesn’t seem very safe to shoot a continuous beam, especially in the direction of the avengers lol
Kinda bothered me tbh, the only time I see Pepper fighting with tony in a suit she shoots nothing :(
@@eyeyamjstn628, correction, she shoots everything.
@@eyeyamjstn628 Her accuracy is 100%, you just don't know what she's aiming at!
She's about as useful has her bullshit products.
You guys should react to "The Mandalorian". I would love to see that!!
Cuursad_ig yes
Cuursad_ig i need to see them gush about the scattering of baby yodas ears
Jesus you gotta admire the sheer amount of detail in just the final battle of the movie (essentially the entire third act)
Quantum Realm also