I’m not gonna lie, when I first heard Arthur ingame, I immediately knew it was an Irish guy putting on an American cowboy accent - it works because he’s supposed to be THE og cowboy, but 🤷♂️
I think Reverend Swanson is a very underrated character. He lost everything in his life and gets drug addicted, but pulls himself together and becomes the head of this NY church. And besides that he‘s funny as hell
My favorite part with him was when you move camp in chapter 3 and you ask how he’s doing and he says “oh yes we moved didn’t we”? And Arthur says god help us lol
Roger Clark sounds like a drunk because most of the time I can't understand half of Arthur speech. Hosea is my favorite. I could listen to him all day. 😅
My fiancé casually watched me play this game from time to time. She fell in love with it. She is someone who never plays video games or even has a slight interest in watching me. It just shows how masterful this game really is.
Ikr, I was never into video games until I started watching my brother play it, he had so much fun playing that I asked to play it when he was done, he agreed and I stopped watching to avoid spoilers. Best video game ever!
Iv never been a huge video game person besides like Spyro and the casual sly fox etc. but this Iv played this game FOUR TIMES and I get emotional every time
All of us hate Micah but admit, Peter Blomquist did a great job, if it was some random guy from the street doing the voice acting and motion capture, Micah wouldn't be as hated as he is
Trelawny was one of my favorites..he would just dissappear and id forget about him but he would pop up and it made them special moments when playing. He was unique and liked his personality.
I stumbled across his house in St Denis and heard him arguging with his family. It was 2am and I was under the influence of cannabis and I thought I was tripping.
@@phoebechandler8932 omg a tlou fanboy...if someone doesnt like the ur game they arent tranphobic but im fanboy-phobic. btw if u use "*u probably didnt even play the game*" youll fail miserably i played tlou 2 and didnt like it ( im a lifetime ps4 fan )
@@ruty_bolzga424 if you’re not transphobic then why did you call it a transgender tragedy.. it’s a tragedy alright but not in the way you think.. the trans character in it is such a minor part of the game and it’s never actually explicitly said he’s trans.. it’s not a forced agenda or anything like that it’s a perfectly reasonable decision as in a normal world, shocker, there’s actually a lot of trans people.. I’m actually surprised there wasn’t more than one trans person in the game
I love how games are bordering on movie quality production. My first playthrough I thought Micah was voiced by Steve Ogg, he reminded me a lot of Trevor.
I can see why people think this but Trevor would never sell us out to the pinkertons, he was loyal af. The whole point of his character was he valued loyalty and friendship above anything so that's pretty much the opposite of Micah really
Absolutely amazing how they incorporated what all the real actors did on break on set to the real actions of the characters lounging around the camp in between missions
my favorite camp interaction is when Bill Williamson comes up to you, shoves a phone in your face and says "Oh hey Arthur, have you seen this video? It's really funny, just... it gets funny. Ya just gotta wait for the good part! ... Yeah hold on, it's coming up... Uh, w-wait, is this the right one?... Ah hell! Goddamn piece of shit!"
Rockstar seems to do that quite often. Almost every character in the main cast very closely or exactly resembles their character. It's a great way to sell a character especially with performance capture.
I always wondered if he had that epic mustache beforehand or if he just grew it out of fondness for his role. Amazing actor. Surprised he hasn't gotten any more prominent roles since.
Knowing that all of Uncle's singing is still John O'Creagh makes the scene where the trio drink together after the barn is built so bittersweet. I always tear up a bit when I get to that part in my playthroughs.
The voice actors seem like such genuine people. I actually was going to play red dead online with the voice actor for young jack (running w the gang) once, but we were on different consoles. Such a cool interaction
One detail that is hard to miss in the game is when at the end, when Dutch and the rest of the gang are pointing their guns at Arthur and John, Javier is the only one who points the gun up in the air. Kind of showing a little resistance of turning on his fellow gang brothers.
Gabriel, the actor that plays Javier said in a panel that he had to fight for it too. He had to convince Rockstar that it wouldn't make sense for Javier to betray his brothers, Arthur and John.
That makes it worse honestly. He could've helped but instead chose the side with access to the money and then didn't even help them either. Passive SOB
@@gothxm It really doesn't make it worse. It makes it so much better. Javier personified blind loyalty throughout the entire story. No matter how bad, how crazy, how immoral, how petty and how irrational Dutch and his decisions became, Javier stood by him AND he tried to convince everyone around him to be just as loyal. For him to doubt his ambition and his loyalty in the end because it would force him to kill his two brothers is just amazing character development
I really wish we could have seen Dutch crying as he walked away from Arthur. I feel like knowing that he felt something from it would have added to the satisfaction of him shooting Micah
I disagree. That would show the old Dutch and his regret wich would probably make a lot of people happy. It would kinda outbalance the sadness of the scene But, in the credits they could have shown Dutch at his grave, or show Dutch taking a look at Johns new ranch, or he watches how John rides back with the money, with Sadie and Charles. That would boost the satisfaction of the ending and doesn’t affect Arthur’s death scene
People in those days never cried. I remember my father who died a couple of years ago at the age of 90. He told me he never saw his father or mother crying in all his life, and they had shitty lives. I only once saw my father cried in all my life and he really was at the end of his rope. I am half native American and all my ancestors on both sides weren't the kind of people to show their emotions. And boy it was not because we never saw people dying or not having problems...
It’s also a classic case the nicest guy playing the bad guy everyone hates, from what I have watched of other RDR2 interviews everyone loves Peter Blomquist saying he’s the nicest guy ever playing the most detestable character ever, same thing happened in game of thrones with Joffrey’s actor Jack Gleason, honestly the sweetest guy you’d ever met playing an inbred lunatic king
This is really well put together! Hearing Ben Davis talk about crying after leaving Arthur on the cliff is always really sad to me, but I think I remember him saying that one of the very last scenes he did was the fishing trip with Arthur and Hosea, so he got to end his story on a happy note.
@@theotherdinoyt1455 Then hearing the Wheel as you take control of John for me, made even more so. Miss Arthur yet was happy to see an old friend. Mr. Marston!
For me, it was pretty heartwarming to know that Dutch cried over Arthur dying, coz it showed he still did care about him. To add to that, if you look very very carefully you can actually see Dutch on the verge of crying from 16:49 - 16:51. It's so subtle.
Amazing how they placed the veteran at O'Creaghs run. You connected with the veteran, and when you can consider him as a friend, you lose him. I got the feeling that is not by accident, knowing R*.
I have never once in my life *mourned* the death of a fictional character. But when Arthur lied there, wheezing his last breath, staring at the rising sun, oh how I cried. Oh how I missed him as I played as John Marston. I had to stop for a while and think and sit on what I just played through. I wanted Arthur Morgan back so much. Every little piece of this game came together so absolutely perfectly, all serving their purpose to a fine T. I will never hate Rockstar, even with their gross mishandling of Red Dead Online, because I know what they can do now. I know what they are capable of. And I love them for it. Well done, guys. Seriously. I love you all.
I wrote RIP Arthur Morgan with a cross in my diary just like Arthur would when his friend dies. Felt like a ritual was necessary to say goodbye to Arthur. But still can’t let him go.
This is somewhat a late reply but I kinda felt the need to say that although I didn't cry, I was sad but more than that I was very angry. After some point in the game, most players (including me) thought that Arthur was going to die but I just hoped maybe he would survive. But on top of all the important and minor characters that died before him, they (Rockstar Games) just had to kill him too. I was really angry at them and I swore at them for about 2 minutes.
Agreed there is only 1 other game that legitimately made me cry at the end. I knew for sure Authur would die when he was coughing before the dr told him, even though it was a blind playthrough, i was convinced he had TB then the dr confermed it. So i was expecting him to die, but never expected it would make me cry as he weesed on the cliffs edge. Doubt I'll ever be able to finish the game again knowing how much it wripped my heart out to watch that cut scene.
Covid had a lot to deal with the online bein mishandle... n because the media wants a race riot from George Floyd Rockstar had to drop the releases for GTA n RDR2.... N it sucks cause RDR2 had so much potential.. i was waiting to rob banks with a group or solo buy houses and properties..
The first time I played through I sobbed like a baby when Arthur was thanking and saying goodbye to his dying horse. He was riding Old Beule which made it even sadder because he had promised to look after him after The Veteran died.
best game ever created. I am deeply attached to the characters. Congrats to everyone who worked on this masterpiece. and thank you for making this video
@@darthkenobi415 How? I beat it twice and a third playthrough would still be very nice but doesn't get it boring playing the game for ten times? And what about the feeling? I mean, moments like when Arthur is diagnosed with tb or when he dies are so sad but playing it for ten times you know what happens, you know. But still a great game and sorry for this long text 😂
That's funny because as soon as I looked up the actor that plays Micah, I immediately knew it was him haha. I had played LA Noire in its entirety a few times before RDR2.
What? I've been watching RDR2 stuff for weeks now, and I've literally JUST finished binge watching LA noire. Did not realize there's a Micah voice there...
Either that or he's actually a total monster in real life so doesn't have to act much to play such characters! I have played LA Noire through thrice, about to finish RDR2 for the 2nd time, and I had no idea it was the same guy. Genuinely impressive
The guy who played Bill killed it in his monologue! I’m glad they kept his take for the final version. That monologue actually made me really feel for Bill. That character is just a broken man with a lot of heart to give. Not just a meathead who “implores” you to go back a bring someone more impressive (lol). Great job to everyone!!
Bro the writers of red dead redemption 2 should get a godman raise they created a astonishing, brilliant, emotional story! Edit: yes i get the understatement and know the writers are rich but you get the point...
@@kaneunmaskedal Yeah Dan Houser who’s one of the founders of Rockstar has been the lead writer on most of their games since Gta 3. Since Gta 4 they’ve had the same group of writers.
As far as storytelling in games go this was by far the best story I ever had the privilege of playing through. I was very much brought to tears as Arthur lay dying on the mountainside staring at his sunrise. Never in my thirty-five years of playing video games have I ever been so emotionally involved with a character. I can't say enough good things about this game
I love how passionate these people are about the series. It makes me happy that everyone wants to largely what contribute to this game and it's what made it so great. Especially that addition where Bill talks about how he first met Dutch.
I had no idea they had to physically act out the scenes. I always just pictured them in a sound booth reading off random lines that got out together later. Amazing. Amazing game. I'll never forget arthur dutch John and the gang.
@Bobby Papoutsis they're not in front of a green screen. They're in a mocap studio, filled with tons of cameras, and microphones. If you look up The last of us motion capture on here, you'll get a better understanding of what it looks like when they film.
Shame they didn't do the same for their programmers. Equally as important, they need to get their shit closer together so the programmers aren't collapsing in work during crunch time.
@@armose2243 I mean you gotta remember that the Rockstar that CJ dealt with and the Rockstar that the rdr2 cast dealt with are completely different because it's almost a 10-13 year time gap
I can’t imagine the amount of laughter they got from mo capping Arthur being drunk with Lenny and just have Arthur keep calling for Lenny really loudly while he stumbles
After playing this game for so many hours it's surreal to hear the characters' voices coming from real people on video. Seeing this kind of video makes you realise the incredible effort they all put in to make this game and makes you really appreciate what a masterpiece it is.
The thought of a RDR3 game where there's another prequel, getting to see Arthur young again and getting to know what happened in the black water massacre, really gives me the will to live for the next 10 years for when they announce that its coming. And that says a lot about how this game affected me
It's incredible how Rockstar made us all get emotional for a tragic end of the story of some fictional thieves and murderers, where we would have been happy if nowadays a dangerous Gang like the Van der Linde gang would be shut down. Played the game about 8 or 9 times and I still get a little emotional, amazing Game😢😍
The fact that Micah is as widely despised as a character as he is just shows how well Peter was able to personify that role. They all deserve oscars for these character roles. Voice and mocap actors are so talented they really have to sell the scene with their emotions and it comes through beautifully
he did great as micah, but i think he even did better as dr harlaine fontaine in la noire. basically the same character but much more sophisticated. muuuuuuuch more. this guy can act.
I've been gaming since the mid 80's...This game sits at the very top with a few others as the greatest ever. Such a remarkable achievement not only in gaming, but in story telling. Can't praise it enough.
The fandom cannot stop blowing Charles, what are you on about? The most underrated Character is Adult Jack. Easily. Not going for your throat over this, just saying, almost too many people dig Charles. Including me.
12:35 it's so cool to see that the actors and the charachters they perfom aren't that different. i mean sitting quietly doing crosswords puzzles is so Dutch
Damn hearing that the actor for Micah would literally practice his gun movements just made me really respect the actor a lot even tho Micah really is a piece of shit 😂
The way that Dutch and ben both raise their hands in sync at 3:54 is a thing of beauty!! I freaking love every aspect of this game !!! I've always been a UA-cam gamer , much preferred watching People play but this game genuinely changed my gaming life and I'm on my 2nd full play through after months just free roaming on my hubbies chapter 3 game. I know I need to try other games but I just cant let go yet 😂
For me the saddest part was when Arthur started to remember the words of people he helped as he was riding to beaver hollow, also every time he told either John or Charles to run and don’t look back made me tear up, it seemed like Arthur felt completely stuck in a situation that he couldn’t get out of but gets a piece of mind when he remembers that all though he did bad he also helped out many people, therefore he died satisfied and at the same time empty.
Micah’s actor was in the L.A. Noire game as the doctor?! Nice 👍. I just noticed that he looks like both characters. With his mustache he looks like Micah. With a shaved face, he looks like the doctor.
I feel like John should’ve Atleast shed a tear because he knew Arthur, the only person that was there for him at that moment was going to die to save him
@@AsteroidSpy They grew up together, I think he should’ve showed emotion of Some kind once he realized that his brother whom has always had his back for as long as he can remember is about to look out for him one last time.
I love this video man. I’ve seen all those interviews you took clips from but I’m so thankful you edited it together with in game footage like this instead of me playing it in my head
Amazing stuff. Loved this & thanks again so much for reaching out about using the clips. Really appreciate that. Fantastic content. Will be sharing EVERYWHERE :) Long live The Outlaws :)
I wanted to rewatched your wolves edit and I just realized that you made this video. Over the years I watched this video multiple times already. This is probably the best behind the scenes video for the rdr series I have ever seen. There are so many interesting things I didnt know until watching this video. You are truly a talented member of the Red Dead community.
As an actor, by far my favorite part of acting is the relationships you build with your fellow actors and actresses. The respect and love that everyone has for each other makes me miss acting whenever I’m not working on something performance related.
I really like that they make the characters look like their real life actors for the most part. It gives it a sense of realism and it lives on in a way after the game.
I love that at the end of shooting the end scenes, you all felt the emotion & utter sadness that we all feel everytime we play this amazing game. Ty all for such a Stella job x
Man this one video made me appreciate the game so much more hearing the compassion love and hard work that all these voice actors put into this project really brings a tear to my eye
Movies used to be this good, now it seems that the talent and effort is in video games. They all deserve an Oscar for this. I could sit back and watch this as a movie over and over. If, I could stop playing long enough. My hats off to everyone who worked on this project. You made people cry at a video game who would not cry at a movie!
13:50 I said this in an other video before but the shoot-out where someone of the gang got killed (no spoilers xd), Micah drew his guns so freaking fast.. I had to replay that a couple of times becausr if that was performance capture, he really is an amazing gun slinger
when arthur says "see you around john marston" when he goes for the money i balled my eyes out. and when john says "you're my brother" and arthur goes "i know" i also balled my eyes out this is such a amazing game and it's so amazing that i got emotionally attached to each and every character. my hatred for micah my love for arthur and john the confusion i witnessed with dutch and the sadness when each and every character died i felt like that person was real and died in real life. these actors completely brought these characters to life
This video just shows how much rockstar cares about their content and how perfect they want it to be. This also explains why gta 6 took so long to make and it was definitely worth the wait!
This clip makes me realize that this story is 100% accurate. Maybe not to each individual character, but in the summation of the human experience this story has played out across countless people in the late 18th century.
This was the first game that got me emotionally invested. It had mead at other characters, had me sad and shedding some tears in some scenes. I've played the whole game multiple times and still feel the same emotions. Absolutely beautiful game
It’s crazy to imagine the actors for Dutch, Micah and Arthur to be a group of good friends. It’s always heartwarming stuff like that that makes me really happy.
Edit 2: This video has now surpassed 200k views. I am beyond honored that so many people enjoyed this video. Thank you to everyone! Edit: WOW. I can't believe this got 100K views! My most popular video yet. Thank you so much to everyone who watched and subscribed! ❤ If you want to see more RDR2 videos from me, (possibly even a part 2???) leave a like and comment! My other RDR2 content can be found here: ua-cam.com/play/PLQMtbLiEv8EvyUlEaCV-T7SfbWvxl5gQQ.html Follow me on Instagram: instagram.com/zebra3girl/
the scene where Arthur loses his horse ripped my heart out of my chest, would be insane to see that motion capture scene, i'd probably sob again over it. then immediately losing Arthur, too. i was numb for a week. never felt like that from a video game in my life. rock star really killed it with this game, and everybody involved.
And thank you for this beautiful and informative video you put together! I actually got emotional a few times throughout the video but definitely teared up when I learned that Uncle was played by two actors and that they kept his singing 🥹 then you playing the clip of Uncle Charles and John singing together just killed me. The appreciation and the thanks to everyone behind this amazing game is truly heartwarming and again thank you for the beautiful video and for the information I have learned today. 💯
I never was so anxious to continue the story in a game like i was playing rdr2. I played the whole game without any spoilers and it was such an amazing experience I never had before playing any other game. You really start to care for the gang and feel the pain when everything slowly deteriorates at the end.
This makes me appreciate the game a whole lot more than I already did. I never actually gave a thought about them actually actually acting the parts. I always just assumed they just read scripts in front of a microphone. Amazing work. Great video.
Music used from RDR2 soundtrack:
0:00 Loading screen music
0:52 Mountain Banjo
09:25 The Course of True love
15:30 Table Top
Thank you for making this video
@@TerryMcQ79 hh8 hihiv89
This video is very well put together.
I'm on my second playthrough trying to get 100% completion. Table Top always hits me harddd.
i have no idea how i can thank u
“I was Mary!” :D
This man lmao
Best factoid of the game.
lmao i loved that
@Mateusz Abramczyk I know this is late, but here you go.
2:10
I can’t imagine anyone else besides Roger Clark as Arthur Morgan, he plays him so well.
Ellen would be a good Arthur She has the beard for it.
You wouldn’t know any different if someone else played him, I know what you mean tho
I’m not gonna lie, when I first heard Arthur ingame, I immediately knew it was an Irish guy putting on an American cowboy accent - it works because he’s supposed to be THE og cowboy, but 🤷♂️
Thats because he is him
@@MannFace51 isn’t roger clark Australian?
I think Reverend Swanson is a very underrated character. He lost everything in his life and gets drug addicted, but pulls himself together and becomes the head of this NY church. And besides that he‘s funny as hell
One night when I was frisky
@@samtheman._.6532 over some potent whisky
he can be annoying when you are trying to walk from point a to point b within the camp.
@@goblinkillahd8396 lol
My favorite part with him was when you move camp in chapter 3 and you ask how he’s doing and he says “oh yes we moved didn’t we”? And Arthur says god help us lol
When I hear Roger Clark's voice I immediately get happy because I feel like Arthur got an extra secret dialog for me
Interesting how much more I hear the Irish tints of his accent when he's at BAFTA
@@stalfithrildi5366 he switches them.
Roger Clark sounds like a drunk because most of the time I can't understand half of Arthur speech.
Hosea is my favorite. I could listen to him all day. 😅
@@condorX2that’s the beauty of his accent, I myself understand 95% of the despite the fact that eng is second language
Yes 😢😭😭😭👌
My fiancé casually watched me play this game from time to time. She fell in love with it. She is someone who never plays video games or even has a slight interest in watching me. It just shows how masterful this game really is.
Ikr, I was never into video games until I started watching my brother play it, he had so much fun playing that I asked to play it when he was done, he agreed and I stopped watching to avoid spoilers. Best video game ever!
It's story is just that good yo. Video games are like playable movies in a way.
Iv never been a huge video game person besides like Spyro and the casual sly fox etc. but this Iv played this game FOUR TIMES and I get emotional every time
All of us hate Micah but admit, Peter Blomquist did a great job, if it was some random guy from the street doing the voice acting and motion capture, Micah wouldn't be as hated as he is
This sentence sounds very strange =))
@@cineva-241 oh, now i realised how many likes i have
No one hates him everyone hates his character though
Never realized he also played Harlan Fontaine in LA Noire. Dude is just an amazing actor.
He so good at playing the worst villain in Rockstar history (imo)
Trelawny was one of my favorites..he would just dissappear and id forget about him but he would pop up and it made them special moments when playing. He was unique and liked his personality.
Had some of the best missions also
Dear boahh
I stumbled across his house in St Denis and heard him arguging with his family. It was 2am and I was under the influence of cannabis and I thought I was tripping.
That voice actor starred and co-wrote the film Session 9 which is pretty damn good
Honestly I liked him
No video game had ever made me that emotionally invested until Red Dead Redemption 2.
It was a brilliant story.
The only other times a game did that, was Red Dead Redemption 1, and Telltales The Walking Dead season 1, and a few others.
@Bobby Papoutsis lol don't tell me that the transgender tragedy that is TLOU2 ever had you emotionally invested.
@@A-A-RonDavis2470 disgusting transphobe
@@phoebechandler8932 omg a tlou fanboy...if someone doesnt like the ur game they arent tranphobic but im fanboy-phobic. btw if u use "*u probably didnt even play the game*" youll fail miserably i played tlou 2 and didnt like it ( im a lifetime ps4 fan )
@@ruty_bolzga424 if you’re not transphobic then why did you call it a transgender tragedy.. it’s a tragedy alright but not in the way you think.. the trans character in it is such a minor part of the game and it’s never actually explicitly said he’s trans.. it’s not a forced agenda or anything like that it’s a perfectly reasonable decision as in a normal world, shocker, there’s actually a lot of trans people.. I’m actually surprised there wasn’t more than one trans person in the game
I love how games are bordering on movie quality production. My first playthrough I thought Micah was voiced by Steve Ogg, he reminded me a lot of Trevor.
I think he voiced the leader of the larmie gang in the pronghorn chapter it sounds a lot like him
I can see why people think this but Trevor would never sell us out to the pinkertons, he was loyal af. The whole point of his character was he valued loyalty and friendship above anything so that's pretty much the opposite of Micah really
He is the head of the Laramie gang in the epilogue
trevor is actually quite the opposite to micah
@@ObiJohnKenobi67 actually that's not true, steve himself has said that he did not play that character.
Absolutely amazing how they incorporated what all the real actors did on break on set to the real actions of the characters lounging around the camp in between missions
my favorite camp interaction is when Bill Williamson comes up to you, shoves a phone in your face and says "Oh hey Arthur, have you seen this video? It's really funny, just... it gets funny. Ya just gotta wait for the good part! ... Yeah hold on, it's coming up... Uh, w-wait, is this the right one?... Ah hell! Goddamn piece of shit!"
@@insanelyheinousbeefer I read that in bill's voice. Bravo
It really does feel like it would be in character for if they had modern technology, especially Charles and the weightlifting
@@insanelyheinousbeefer “Hey Arthur, check out this funny video I found! It’s called Meatspin! It’s-hey, wait! Wh-where ya goin’!? ….awww, SHIT!”
5:55 calling roger back was the best decision that perticular rockstar employee has ever done, my lord, what an actor and what a voice
I couldn't imagine anyone else playing arthur, roger played him amazingly
Elias Toufexis in my opinion would be the only option. Adam Jensens voice actor
That employee was a good boah.
Get that employee a promotion
Sendhelp get that boah’s name in a ledger
I love how the guy who plays Micah actually looks like his character
Plus he’s a funny dude
Rockstar seems to do that quite often. Almost every character in the main cast very closely or exactly resembles their character. It's a great way to sell a character especially with performance capture.
Wait till you see Trevor from gta 5s VA
I always wondered if he had that epic mustache beforehand or if he just grew it out of fondness for his role. Amazing actor. Surprised he hasn't gotten any more prominent roles since.
Tillys actress was her spitting image too 😃
Knowing that all of Uncle's singing is still John O'Creagh makes the scene where the trio drink together after the barn is built so bittersweet. I always tear up a bit when I get to that part in my playthroughs.
@_Bagginshield L U M B A G O
I always pay attention to the vioce change when uncle to talking to when he starts singing
Uncle can’t do it cuz he has
L U M B A G O
The voice actors seem like such genuine people. I actually was going to play red dead online with the voice actor for young jack (running w the gang) once, but we were on different consoles. Such a cool interaction
dude
"i aint the one playing red dead online with jack!" "yeah, you aint!"
One detail that is hard to miss in the game is when at the end, when Dutch and the rest of the gang are pointing their guns at Arthur and John, Javier is the only one who points the gun up in the air. Kind of showing a little resistance of turning on his fellow gang brothers.
Interesting.... I didn't notice this. Thanks for pointing it out.
I thought someone else too
Gabriel, the actor that plays Javier said in a panel that he had to fight for it too. He had to convince Rockstar that it wouldn't make sense for Javier to betray his brothers, Arthur and John.
That makes it worse honestly. He could've helped but instead chose the side with access to the money and then didn't even help them either. Passive SOB
@@gothxm It really doesn't make it worse. It makes it so much better. Javier personified blind loyalty throughout the entire story. No matter how bad, how crazy, how immoral, how petty and how irrational Dutch and his decisions became, Javier stood by him AND he tried to convince everyone around him to be just as loyal. For him to doubt his ambition and his loyalty in the end because it would force him to kill his two brothers is just amazing character development
I really wish we could have seen Dutch crying as he walked away from Arthur. I feel like knowing that he felt something from it would have added to the satisfaction of him shooting Micah
I don’t think he would’ve cried right then, maybe years later when he knew he made the wrong decision. I think at the time he was just so conflicted
that and john crying for the first time ever when aurthur gives his hat to him tho
I disagree. That would show the old Dutch and his regret wich would probably make a lot of people happy. It would kinda outbalance the sadness of the scene
But, in the credits they could have shown Dutch at his grave, or show Dutch taking a look at Johns new ranch, or he watches how John rides back with the money, with Sadie and Charles. That would boost the satisfaction of the ending and doesn’t affect Arthur’s death scene
I don’t know if we could’ve handled anymore emotion at that point
People in those days never cried. I remember my father who died a couple of years ago at the age of 90. He told me he never saw his father or mother crying in all his life, and they had shitty lives. I only once saw my father cried in all my life and he really was at the end of his rope. I am half native American and all my ancestors on both sides weren't the kind of people to show their emotions. And boy it was not because we never saw people dying or not having problems...
Peter Blomquist didn't really look like Micah until he turned on the crazy at 7:17
Ah, I see you Micah you bastard
He pulled a sneaky sneaky on ya
Lol
Yes that laugh, Micah there you are.
@@incubus1160 gatta love the laugh, it sells it all.
It’s also a classic case the nicest guy playing the bad guy everyone hates, from what I have watched of other RDR2 interviews everyone loves Peter Blomquist saying he’s the nicest guy ever playing the most detestable character ever, same thing happened in game of thrones with Joffrey’s actor Jack Gleason, honestly the sweetest guy you’d ever met playing an inbred lunatic king
This is really well put together! Hearing Ben Davis talk about crying after leaving Arthur on the cliff is always really sad to me, but I think I remember him saying that one of the very last scenes he did was the fishing trip with Arthur and Hosea, so he got to end his story on a happy note.
I cried
@@theotherdinoyt1455 Then hearing the Wheel as you take control of John for me, made even more so. Miss Arthur yet was happy to see an old friend. Mr. Marston!
For me, it was pretty heartwarming to know that Dutch cried over Arthur dying, coz it showed he still did care about him. To add to that, if you look very very carefully you can actually see Dutch on the verge of crying from 16:49 - 16:51. It's so subtle.
Amazing how they placed the veteran at O'Creaghs run. You connected with the veteran, and when you can consider him as a friend, you lose him. I got the feeling that is not by accident, knowing R*.
❤ good eye
I have never once in my life *mourned* the death of a fictional character. But when Arthur lied there, wheezing his last breath, staring at the rising sun, oh how I cried. Oh how I missed him as I played as John Marston. I had to stop for a while and think and sit on what I just played through. I wanted Arthur Morgan back so much. Every little piece of this game came together so absolutely perfectly, all serving their purpose to a fine T. I will never hate Rockstar, even with their gross mishandling of Red Dead Online, because I know what they can do now. I know what they are capable of. And I love them for it.
Well done, guys. Seriously. I love you all.
I wrote RIP Arthur Morgan with a cross in my diary just like Arthur would when his friend dies. Felt like a ritual was necessary to say goodbye to Arthur. But still can’t let him go.
This is somewhat a late reply but I kinda felt the need to say that although I didn't cry, I was sad but more than that I was very angry. After some point in the game, most players (including me) thought that Arthur was going to die but I just hoped maybe he would survive. But on top of all the important and minor characters that died before him, they (Rockstar Games) just had to kill him too. I was really angry at them and I swore at them for about 2 minutes.
I never had a game make me cry till rdr2 when i played arthur as a bad guy n they killed my fav horse n then watch him die.. i was devastated....
Agreed there is only 1 other game that legitimately made me cry at the end. I knew for sure Authur would die when he was coughing before the dr told him, even though it was a blind playthrough, i was convinced he had TB then the dr confermed it. So i was expecting him to die, but never expected it would make me cry as he weesed on the cliffs edge. Doubt I'll ever be able to finish the game again knowing how much it wripped my heart out to watch that cut scene.
Covid had a lot to deal with the online bein mishandle... n because the media wants a race riot from George Floyd Rockstar had to drop the releases for GTA n RDR2.... N it sucks cause RDR2 had so much potential.. i was waiting to rob banks with a group or solo buy houses and properties..
The first time I played through I sobbed like a baby when Arthur was thanking and saying goodbye to his dying horse. He was riding Old Beule which made it even sadder because he had promised to look after him after The Veteran died.
Yeah same I also had Buell. RIP Hamish
I had Buell too. Even though he was the best horse in the game, it only felt right. Hamish was a real one.
Just your comment made me tear up to think about haha. Man this game still has me fucked up
Who’s cutting onions in here?!
Since i know Aurther and one of the horse have to die. I chose the white Arabian and leave John finish the Veteran mission and get Buell.
best game ever created. I am deeply attached to the characters. Congrats to everyone who worked on this masterpiece. and thank you for making this video
Hands down best game ever. Beat it 10x.
truly. it’s perfect to me.
It was so sad when hosea died
@@darthkenobi415 How? I beat it twice and a third playthrough would still be very nice but doesn't get it boring playing the game for ten times? And what about the feeling? I mean, moments like when Arthur is diagnosed with tb or when he dies are so sad but playing it for ten times you know what happens, you know. But still a great game and sorry for this long text 😂
@@lk0512 why do people rewatch movies for? Same reason.
I didn't know Peter Blomquist played Dr. Fontaine in LA Noire until a few weeks ago. What a talented actor.
That's funny because as soon as I looked up the actor that plays Micah, I immediately knew it was him haha. I had played LA Noire in its entirety a few times before RDR2.
What? I've been watching RDR2 stuff for weeks now, and I've literally JUST finished binge watching LA noire. Did not realize there's a Micah voice there...
@Bobby Papoutsis LA Noire used performance capture as well (though a slightly different kind) so it wasn't just voice, but full body and face too!
Either that or he's actually a total monster in real life so doesn't have to act much to play such characters!
I have played LA Noire through thrice, about to finish RDR2 for the 2nd time, and I had no idea it was the same guy. Genuinely impressive
Now hearing that Dr. speak, He does sound quite similar to Micah
5:11 I’m so glad Roger Clark got the role as Arthur! Truly one of my favorite acting performances! I can’t imagine anyone else as Arthur
The guy who played Bill killed it in his monologue! I’m glad they kept his take for the final version. That monologue actually made me really feel for Bill. That character is just a broken man with a lot of heart to give. Not just a meathead who “implores” you to go back a bring someone more impressive (lol). Great job to everyone!!
Rodger Clark is just so precious like “I was Mary” and the little innocent face he pulled was just 😩😩
Bro the writers of red dead redemption 2 should get a godman raise they created a astonishing, brilliant, emotional story!
Edit: yes i get the understatement and know the writers are rich but you get the point...
I'm pretty sure one of the writers was the owner of the company so I think he got paid pretty well
@@kaneunmaskedal Yeah Dan Houser who’s one of the founders of Rockstar has been the lead writer on most of their games since Gta 3. Since Gta 4 they’ve had the same group of writers.
A raise? They making a shit ton of money lol
They're already rich they don't need to be richer
@@jgunner94 Sad that he left the company along with Lazlow and Leslie
I wish we would see more of Curzon Dobell (Hosea), his character and performance were incredible.
His death hurt me so much, even more than Sean, and I didn’t think that was possible.
As far as storytelling in games go this was by far the best story I ever had the privilege of playing through. I was very much brought to tears as Arthur lay dying on the mountainside staring at his sunrise. Never in my thirty-five years of playing video games have I ever been so emotionally involved with a character. I can't say enough good things about this game
I love how passionate these people are about the series. It makes me happy that everyone wants to largely what contribute to this game and it's what made it so great. Especially that addition where Bill talks about how he first met Dutch.
I had no idea they had to physically act out the scenes. I always just pictured them in a sound booth reading off random lines that got out together later.
Amazing.
Amazing game. I'll never forget arthur dutch John and the gang.
Hosea
@Bobby Papoutsis they're not in front of a green screen. They're in a mocap studio, filled with tons of cameras, and microphones. If you look up The last of us motion capture on here, you'll get a better understanding of what it looks like when they film.
They have always do mocap, as early during GTA 5 development.
@@hazim9529RDR1!
It's great to hear Rockstar respects and love their actors.
Makes rdr online look shit
Shame they didn't do the same for their programmers. Equally as important, they need to get their shit closer together so the programmers aren't collapsing in work during crunch time.
Man you know that most of gta actors hate rockstar like cj tommy
@blur really shows you that rockstar isn’t always the greatest
@@armose2243 I mean you gotta remember that the Rockstar that CJ dealt with and the Rockstar that the rdr2 cast dealt with are completely different because it's almost a 10-13 year time gap
I cant get over the fact that they dressed actual horses in spandex
You think that’s how they got horses balls shrinking in the cold lmao
@@thiccbaby2967 hey for all we know they held them up or something you know how rockstar is XD
@@yasserboumediane1010 ohhh jeez. Imagine the person that had to probably spend weeks come up with the coding for it.
@@thiccbaby2967 man what a poor soul XD
@@thiccbaby2967 weeks? that takes like 30 minutes of coding at the most, if you know what are you doing of course
I can’t imagine the amount of laughter they got from mo capping Arthur being drunk with Lenny and just have Arthur keep calling for Lenny really loudly while he stumbles
Start of the game: Haha fun western survival shooter. End of the game: *sobbing intensifies*
Start: what a fun cowboy game
End: red dead depression
After playing this game for so many hours it's surreal to hear the characters' voices coming from real people on video. Seeing this kind of video makes you realise the incredible effort they all put in to make this game and makes you really appreciate what a masterpiece it is.
You said it perfectly.
The thought of a RDR3 game where there's another prequel, getting to see Arthur young again and getting to know what happened in the black water massacre, really gives me the will to live for the next 10 years for when they announce that its coming. And that says a lot about how this game affected me
A prequel of a prequel?
@@solitudeguard2316 I'd rather play the man with the plan instead tbh.
@@kcgaming0017 Playing as Dutch does sound a bit interesting imo
Or uncle, finally we will discover how lumbago got him so hard
I always imagined RDR 3 following Charles or maybe Sadie
It's incredible how Rockstar made us all get emotional for a tragic end of the story of some fictional thieves and murderers, where we would have been happy if nowadays a dangerous Gang like the Van der Linde gang would be shut down.
Played the game about 8 or 9 times and I still get a little emotional, amazing Game😢😍
8 times??? I'm only on my 3rd playthrough after 3 years
@@capital_beaz4725 ahahaha, if you in love with a game you try to play it as much as you can
@@capital_beaz4725 Oh god, if you think 8 is a lot I don't even what to tell you the number of playthrough I'm on ha.
@@antthomas7916 Tell😂😂 the highest i heard from somebody was 16
For some not everybody knew that tragic ending of Arthur.
The fact that Micah is as widely despised as a character as he is just shows how well Peter was able to personify that role. They all deserve oscars for these character roles. Voice and mocap actors are so talented they really have to sell the scene with their emotions and it comes through beautifully
he did great as micah, but i think he even did better as dr harlaine fontaine in la noire. basically the same character but much more sophisticated. muuuuuuuch more. this guy can act.
“John Marston does not cry!” Can someone edit that clip together with the scene of John crying after he kills Javier in the first game?
He cries during that scene?
@@Jaceb77 He sheds a tear after he spits.
I've been gaming since the mid 80's...This game sits at the very top with a few others as the greatest ever. Such a remarkable achievement not only in gaming, but in story telling. Can't praise it enough.
Which are the other top games that you have played? Sincerely, an 18 year old
man imagine going from super mario bros to this… quite a journey
Man the most underrated character in Red Dead 2 has to be Charles Smith he was my favorite character in the game next to Lenny
YES he was loyal, smart, a snacc and brave. I want sooo bad for them to bring him, Sadie and Jack back in RDR3 if it takes place after rdr2
@@DanB666 but isn’t rdr2 the prequel to rdr1?
The fandom cannot stop blowing Charles, what are you on about? The most underrated Character is Adult Jack. Easily. Not going for your throat over this, just saying, almost too many people dig Charles. Including me.
@@Broken_Savior Because Jack is only playable long after John Marston dies in RDR1, the story is long dead by then.
LEEEEEEENNNNNNNYYYYYY!!!!!
Everybody hates Micah. That’s how good Peter Blomquist is. I wish he could land a lead in the future, I’m sure it would make for an awesome character.
He's incredible. I first saw him in LA Noire and and when I found out he plays Micah in this, I was very impressed. He's very versatile.
@@zebra3girl110 whoa he was in LA Noire??
@@CLA82529 He was Doctor Harlan Fontaine
12:35 it's so cool to see that the actors and the charachters they perfom aren't that different. i mean sitting quietly doing crosswords puzzles is so Dutch
Damn hearing that the actor for Micah would literally practice his gun movements just made me really respect the actor a lot even tho Micah really is a piece of shit 😂
the fact everyone hates micah so much shows how good of a job his actor did
@@nutball3756 he did such a good job that according to him, he also hated Micah too when he played the game.
The way that Dutch and ben both raise their hands in sync at 3:54 is a thing of beauty!! I freaking love every aspect of this game !!! I've always been a UA-cam gamer , much preferred watching People play but this game genuinely changed my gaming life and I'm on my 2nd full play through after months just free roaming on my hubbies chapter 3 game. I know I need to try other games but I just cant let go yet 😂
its crazy how good the casts are for these roles
For me the saddest part was when Arthur started to remember the words of people he helped as he was riding to beaver hollow, also every time he told either John or Charles to run and don’t look back made me tear up, it seemed like Arthur felt completely stuck in a situation that he couldn’t get out of but gets a piece of mind when he remembers that all though he did bad he also helped out many people, therefore he died satisfied and at the same time empty.
"everybody had worked so long and hard for on this game" and it shows! A true masterpiece!
6:30 She's been in the single worst and best games ever made.
I wonder who she was in ride to hell
I forgot about that game. Wow, what a range.
@@nousername2942 I would say what a jump in career. She went from the shittiest game in existence to one of the greatest games of all time
Most emotional game I've ever played. I feel like we'll never see another game this unique.
A voice actor in Ride to Hell can also end up voicing in one of the best video games ever. Anything can happen.
Fuck yeah
This is truly one of the best games in history I hope they make a third one someday
just started crying at 16:22. this game is so great, it made me emotionally attached to it. thank u, RS!
Thank you for making this! I've seen many of these clips throughout the years but it's nice to see them compiled and edited together well!
it's easy to forget how long it took them to make the game, i mean Roger was cast five years before it came out, to me thats crazy
Micah’s actor was in the L.A. Noire game as the doctor?! Nice 👍. I just noticed that he looks like both characters. With his mustache he looks like Micah. With a shaved face, he looks like the doctor.
My thoughts as well!
I feel like John should’ve Atleast shed a tear because he knew Arthur, the only person that was there for him at that moment was going to die to save him
I agree! It’s disappointing that they didn’t let him show that emotion
@@Zireaells I think he’s just not that kinda guy. When he meets Mary years later, he says “I don’t talk about him much, but I think about him a lot”
Arthur didn't have much of an impact on john
@@AsteroidSpy they were still arguably one of the closer ones in the gang though thats for sure.
@@AsteroidSpy They grew up together, I think he should’ve showed emotion of Some kind once he realized that his brother whom has always had his back for as long as he can remember is about to look out for him one last time.
Makes me respect even more how much of a work of art this was.
Attention to detail was nothing beyond perfect for the time
This game made me laugh, made me cry, made me happy, and made me sad, what a wonderful game
I love this video man. I’ve seen all those interviews you took clips from but I’m so thankful you edited it together with in game footage like this instead of me playing it in my head
ROB HAS THE MOST BADASS VOICE :D
Amazing stuff. Loved this & thanks again so much for reaching out about using the clips. Really appreciate that. Fantastic content. Will be sharing EVERYWHERE :) Long live The Outlaws :)
I appreciate it a lot, Paddy 😊❤
Oh hey man
I wanted to rewatched your wolves edit and I just realized that you made this video. Over the years I watched this video multiple times already. This is probably the best behind the scenes video for the rdr series I have ever seen. There are so many interesting things I didnt know until watching this video. You are truly a talented member of the Red Dead community.
Thank you so much for the kind comment and the support!
13:04 so that's why john's voice sounds like that lol
"I was Mary :D" OMG ROGER IS SO ADORABLE (edit: words changed/added)
I really hope that the next RDR if it ever comes out is about Arthut Dutch and Hosea when they were young.
No thank you
I want jack’s story after he got revenge
@@ShinyUmbreon106 there is no story for him, jack gets revenge and then that’s it
@@ShinyUmbreon106 Jack just goes on to write a novel about his father and the gang. There's an Easter Egg about it in GTAV.
@@fr0stycam373 That’s non-canon gta and rdr can’t be connected. To many world building inconsistencies.
As an actor, by far my favorite part of acting is the relationships you build with your fellow actors and actresses. The respect and love that everyone has for each other makes me miss acting whenever I’m not working on something performance related.
You can see just in the way he talks that Steve J. Palmer really enjoyed and care for the rdr series
I really like that they make the characters look like their real life actors for the most part. It gives it a sense of realism and it lives on in a way after the game.
I love that at the end of shooting the end scenes, you all felt the emotion & utter sadness that we all feel everytime we play this amazing game. Ty all for such a Stella job x
Man this one video made me appreciate the game so much more hearing the compassion love and hard work that all these voice actors put into this project really brings a tear to my eye
I got teary eyes when Ben spoke about the death scene with Arthur. He knew it was over and got emotional.
Movies used to be this good, now it seems that the talent and effort is in video games. They all deserve an Oscar for this. I could sit back and watch this as a movie over and over. If, I could stop playing long enough. My hats off to everyone who worked on this project. You made people cry at a video game who would not cry at a movie!
13:50 I said this in an other video before but the shoot-out where someone of the gang got killed (no spoilers xd), Micah drew his guns so freaking fast.. I had to replay that a couple of times becausr if that was performance capture, he really is an amazing gun slinger
Trelawny’s VA is also in Bioshock infinite as an NPC in the carnival area where Booker gets the first Vigor.
Peter was so good at his role that he even hated himself lol
when arthur says "see you around john marston" when he goes for the money i balled my eyes out. and when john says "you're my brother" and arthur goes "i know" i also balled my eyes out this is such a amazing game and it's so amazing that i got emotionally attached to each and every character. my hatred for micah my love for arthur and john the confusion i witnessed with dutch and the sadness when each and every character died i felt like that person was real and died in real life. these actors completely brought these characters to life
This video just shows how much rockstar cares about their content and how perfect they want it to be. This also explains why gta 6 took so long to make and it was definitely worth the wait!
This clip makes me realize that this story is 100% accurate. Maybe not to each individual character, but in the summation of the human experience this story has played out across countless people in the late 18th century.
Honestly it makes it twice as funny that its Dutch throwing a chair as charles xD
Thanks for putting all of these together I can’t imagine how much work this is
It was a TON of work but I'm glad to do it for the other amazing fans and to show my appreciation for this masterpiece!
So glad i was around for this masterpiece. Truly a masterpiece. that word is thrown around a lot. This truly is one tho.
This was the first game that got me emotionally invested. It had mead at other characters, had me sad and shedding some tears in some scenes. I've played the whole game multiple times and still feel the same emotions. Absolutely beautiful game
It’s crazy to imagine the actors for Dutch, Micah and Arthur to be a group of good friends. It’s always heartwarming stuff like that that makes me really happy.
Edit 2: This video has now surpassed 200k views. I am beyond honored that so many people enjoyed this video. Thank you to everyone!
Edit: WOW. I can't believe this got 100K views! My most popular video yet. Thank you so much to everyone who watched and subscribed! ❤
If you want to see more RDR2 videos from me, (possibly even a part 2???) leave a like and comment! My other RDR2 content can be found here: ua-cam.com/play/PLQMtbLiEv8EvyUlEaCV-T7SfbWvxl5gQQ.html
Follow me on Instagram: instagram.com/zebra3girl/
We love to see more hun! You did awesome job with this video! I just followed you on Instagram yay! 🥰🥰❤️❤️❤️
Congrats on getting so many views and would love to see more
Bro! You deserve a million
PART 2!!!!!!! 😄 YES! Subscribed, good luck and thank you!
Wait whoa, the actresses for Tilly and Karen look so freaking pretty what the
same with Sadie's actress
@@canObeans4we oh yea especially her 🤩
@@luckyxiong1675 definitely lol
“ you simps, all of yah” - Arthur Morgan
Okay?? I was not expecting that little cutie 😍
3:28 FINALLY! Now I can brag with this information to anyone I know 😁🙏
Glad I could help 😂
the scene where Arthur loses his horse ripped my heart out of my chest, would be insane to see that motion capture scene, i'd probably sob again over it. then immediately losing Arthur, too. i was numb for a week. never felt like that from a video game in my life. rock star really killed it with this game, and everybody involved.
Wow didn’t know that Fontaine and Micah shared the same VA and play major antagonistic roles in both games such an insane talent
This is so amazing to watch, and cool to see how much fun the actors had while playing these amazing characters.
6:40 Imagine being in both Ride to Hell Retribution and RDR2, the difference in quality is so massive
Masterpiece.
RDR2 and Witcher 3 are my favourite games of all time. Bravo rockstar. You created something that will always be remembered.
I’m playing this game for the first time. It’s an absolutely beautiful game. The emotions, the scenery. The game is amazing.
Man, this makes me love the game so much more. You don’t realize how much work was put into this production.
And thank you for this beautiful and informative video you put together! I actually got emotional a few times throughout the video but definitely teared up when I learned that Uncle was played by two actors and that they kept his singing 🥹 then you playing the clip of Uncle Charles and John singing together just killed me. The appreciation and the thanks to everyone behind this amazing game is truly heartwarming and again thank you for the beautiful video and for the information I have learned today. 💯
Thank you for the lovely comment!
I never was so anxious to continue the story in a game like i was playing rdr2. I played the whole game without any spoilers and it was such an amazing experience I never had before playing any other game. You really start to care for the gang and feel the pain when everything slowly deteriorates at the end.
Notice how at 16:55 Dutch turns his back on Micah and not Arthur.
You're right and it's a good point, but Dutch did turn his back on Arthur in another scene...😭
@@zebra3girl110 True but this one is the final time Dutch and Arthur see each other.
This makes me appreciate the game a whole lot more than I already did. I never actually gave a thought about them actually actually acting the parts. I always just assumed they just read scripts in front of a microphone. Amazing work. Great video.
Thanks for stitching this together, a bunch of bits I hadn’t heard about in there. Well done