This has to be one of the hardest songs to sing/perform live. The stamina he has, the breath control, the speed. He’s really like an Olympian of this art form
@@roberthall7127no sabes nada se conciertos si dices esa pavada virgen😂 Se llama acompañamiento y todo loa artistas lo usan, lo que pasa esque otros lo ocultan, el no. Y a pesar de eso, lo hace exactamente igual a sus canciones Regresate a escuchar anuel con todo ese autotune pajero😂
Some people dont understand Proof gave Eminem his Slim Shady persona. He was his only motivation growing up to be Slim Shady. Without Proof there wouldnt be an Eminem this big. R.I.P Proof. Great rapper, MC, hype man. Another genius. Needs more respect to his name
+Sun Mo Drake? If you catch a Drake concert he only mumbles ad llibs. most is a backing track. All of Drake's signing hooks are backing tracks. He doesn't sing that shit live. Eminem relies on backing tracks too. Not as much as drake, but almost any of Eminem's songs with strong melodies on the chorus he has a back up track
I love the unorganized stage with the singers the dancers and the troll person instead of the 10 person pro dancers with perfect bodies. It makes a live concert full of casualty and simplicity and greatness and i love it
@@ward5305 why you want a religion at all or worse to be forced on you? Soul you fine? Being gay is a lie, being lesbian is a lie, being trans is a lie, what else there to say? We all been deceived on a major scale. Whence the truth been known, it can stop a heart. Truth can blow a mind, as the lies collapse. The reality is opposite to what we been told. Many live in delusions and proudly so. Can a soul survive, while seeking truth? Can a mind stay sane, as lies get exposed? Can a heart stay beating, whence the old life collapsed? What a wonderful testimonies from souls, as they found the truth. What a heartbreaking tragedy from those who stayed in lies. Be fruitful and multiply is a message for the matures. One male one female, thats how you make a home. But where`s the adults, the wise and the old? Who supposed to share the truth, where`s lies been told? Many complain about the evil, then why they bowing down? Why they serve the master of many lies? Many call themselves “educated”, yet fill their minds with lies. Lies which been told by masons, again and again.
2:07 this is skills. He went off beat acapella for a split second and his own voice and flow went off and caught the exact upbeat to catch the flow back up w the random Scratch freestyle. Wow Omg. Not many people can rap like this anymore. 2022
Oh it was the TIME to be alive I went to so many concerts we had cameras but we weren’t able to see the photos until after we got them developed at Walgreens and before shows they would say “please not flash photography” that didn’t stop us 😅
Why is everywhere where people who if I go to concert? I’m enjoying myself. I’m not caring what if anybody’s holding a damn cell phone I don’t care. I’m going to a continent and enjoy myself. I’m not worried about people holding a damn phone.
he had the best voice to be honest. Such a nice resonance he had man, he could also spit fire too! He was awesome, the only other D12 member after Em that didn't annoy me lmfaoo
Being a young teen when eminem dropped his first album was an amazing time to be alive Rap and hip hop is not the same. The legends we had in the 90s are un matched. R.I.P Proof who helped make Em the God he is today.
I had his ticket concert in Toronto I think it was in 2000, unfortunately my work finish was very late and I missed out the concert. And then I just sat at the Cafe and not far away from concert hall. And then I met and had a conversation with a so beautiful and smart girl with the same fate late come to the concert and could not get in and she came from Quebec. So we just sat and talked that evening. I missed out on the show but I got the girl as my wife now.😅
Eminem's speech: "I'm sure everybody who has ever met him, even just once, can testify to the fact that he illuminated a room when he walked in it. I believe that Proof loved people and people loved him. He was a magnet. He lured you in. You wanted to learn about him, follow his swagger. Without Proof, there would be no Eminem, no Slim Shady, and no D12
i agree, but its funny because back in the day people would say rap isnt real music....people also said that about rock n roll too.....like it or not, even some of these kids are just artists makin music man. not all of them of course, but theres always been shitty chart topping record label manufactuers
as a little kid i listened to this stuff.. and i actually knew the words. over 10 years later, i listen to this old stuff , and i still know the words. Eminem just never leaves you
And Proof, never forget Proof. Without him, we wouldn't have Slim Shady. And besides that, he was a genuinely good and caring person who touched a lot of lives positively. RIP man.
You never knew what to expect from an Eminem concert, and it could be, just from the singing and the microphone, or bring dancers, entertainers and all. But what was certain was that you were going to see a great concert and that Eminem would give you everything he had to offer 🖤
If and when they ever make an actual Eminem biopic, I feel like they gotta use this performance as reference for a scene. Cuz just the way this vid was shot makes it feel like it's already from a movie.
Just the part that he is performing with his best friend is the reason why he was so great at entertaining. I wanna go back in time to see eminem as this kind of person
Para los que hablan español... .. les doy un dato, eminem es de otro mundo no necesitaba tener bailarinas con un cuerpo perfecto y nunca usa autotone y siempre da conciertos perfectos que cuanda acaba dices tu: no manches he idó al concierto mas grandioso de mi vida
Can't imagine seeing him in Detroit at his peak, that must have been one hell of an experience!
ikr
S U P E R N O V A was the ”:3” really necessary
It's crazzzy... Best era eva. Plus for me being the same age as Em. I remember Proof from Saint Andrews, too. Everyone in Detroit knew Proof!
I'd do anything to be able to be at this concert!
He's been peaking for decades. He's just less angry now.
0:02 Proof's timing is EPIC
ahah damn right!
You didn't any of you guys bother saying R.I.P. proof ?
Chris Lewis R.I.P Big Proof :((
I thought I was the only one that noticed that XD
Daniel Delouya I always think how he did not fall off the stage.
This has to be one of the hardest songs to sing/perform live. The stamina he has, the breath control, the speed. He’s really like an Olympian of this art form
Half the song is a recording
That’s why he doesn’t say a lot of the last word(s) at the end of a line. So he can breathe.
@@roberthall7127no sabes nada se conciertos si dices esa pavada virgen😂
Se llama acompañamiento y todo loa artistas lo usan, lo que pasa esque otros lo ocultan, el no. Y a pesar de eso, lo hace exactamente igual a sus canciones
Regresate a escuchar anuel con todo ese autotune pajero😂
I know my daughter was saying that the other day :)💯🎄
S/o to his BFF Proof buying him breaths throughout the song lol
Goddamn, Proof really was the best hype man alive.
R.I.P. BIG PROOF
Eric Wright he was more
True that
Well Tony Yayo is a full time hypeman tbf
@@thegehxy9319 porno
Porno seno@@thegehxy9319 ,
Some people dont understand Proof gave Eminem his Slim Shady persona. He was his only motivation growing up to be Slim Shady. Without Proof there wouldnt be an Eminem this big. R.I.P Proof. Great rapper, MC, hype man. Another genius. Needs more respect to his name
Rip Proof. Best partner for Eminem.
Mortyy VC
Rip proof.
Miss him
Truely Rest In Peace Proof, we all love you forever...
Italy?
Ik, I love PROOF ,R.I.P.
I am 51 and still grooving to this 😂Love the energy. ❤
Legends ❤
"Billie Eilish thinking she was the main attention in the Oscars"
Eminem: This looks like a job for me!
*“I’ll end this little girl’s whole career! “*
@Carter Yt yeah I am also serious
The oscars? You mean the emmys?
@@wyebruh No I mean the Oscars
@@daansmets oh
1:28 the greatest moment in the career of one rapper
+Maldroit That's the best part, cuz he can come back and say FUCK YOU IM RICH AND TALENTED AND I CAN GIVE ZERO FUCKS!
Excuse me sir, it's "Fuck you Debbie"*.
+Netko tréci actually Eminems all his shots against his mother, go listen to Headlights and you understand
Netko treći that was great
The gun store in NY keep in mind this was whenever he was still doing drugs and proof was still alive
Eminem, one of the world's most valuable performers!
Probably one of the only rappers thats nearly as good in live peformances
+SmokerFace12 I can only think of him and Drake. Both sound just like what they sound on the albums
+Sun Mo Drake? If you catch a Drake concert he only mumbles ad llibs. most is a backing track. All of Drake's signing hooks are backing tracks. He doesn't sing that shit live. Eminem relies on backing tracks too. Not as much as drake, but almost any of Eminem's songs with strong melodies on the chorus he has a back up track
Good live? His song is playbacked -_-
+blekhero exactly
the queens
I love the unorganized stage with the singers the dancers and the troll person instead of the 10 person pro dancers with perfect bodies. It makes a live concert full of casualty and simplicity and greatness and i love it
he keep every body any shape and size have a job . good guy Slim Shady
things of the past basically :\
Yeah back then it was funny but if it happened today it would be some cringe political stunt
@@theharshtruthoutthere if it’s not about religion then stop forcing yours on other people
@@ward5305 why you want a religion at all or worse to be forced on you?
Soul you fine?
Being gay is a lie,
being lesbian is a lie,
being trans is a lie,
what else there to say?
We all been deceived on a major scale.
Whence the truth been known, it can stop a heart.
Truth can blow a mind, as the lies collapse.
The reality is opposite to what we been told.
Many live in delusions and proudly so.
Can a soul survive, while seeking truth?
Can a mind stay sane, as lies get exposed?
Can a heart stay beating, whence the old life collapsed?
What a wonderful testimonies from souls, as they found the truth.
What a heartbreaking tragedy from those who stayed in lies.
Be fruitful and multiply is a message for the matures.
One male one female, thats how you make a home.
But where`s the adults, the wise and the old? Who supposed to share the truth, where`s lies been told?
Many complain about the evil, then why they bowing down?
Why they serve the master of many lies?
Many call themselves “educated”, yet fill their minds with lies.
Lies which been told by masons, again and again.
WOW Eminem is on fire here! 🔥 Amazing live! So smooth....love this guy
Almost 10 years has passed after the death of Proof. We will never forget you.
R.I.P. BIG PROOF
Porno seno
Cu cu
ua-cam.com/video/4G6e4TaJxkI/v-deo.html
👌🏼
Rip
do u message every year
Probably the best Eminem show ever
Gennaro rossi probably not, eminem is good looking as fuck
Gennaro rossi I don't care mr rossi
Get it "eninem show" 😆
Raghav Tyagi not funny
😂😂😂@@raghavtyagi6345
2:07 this is skills. He went off beat acapella for a split second and his own voice and flow went off and caught the exact upbeat to catch the flow back up w the random
Scratch freestyle. Wow Omg. Not many people can rap like this anymore.
2022
Its not random at all...its 4/4 beat, very simple.
Acapella is without accompaniment.
@@albertorochareyes2427you’re not understanding what he’s saying. He had to catch up.
No phones, everyone just enjoying the moment jumping and dancing. Wish I could’ve had the chance to experience something like this. Fucking legend
Fucking truth right here. If we ever get time travelling machines THIS is the first thing I want to experience.
Every moment lived in our memories as a story waiting to be retold. Become a great story teller love.
Right, I was born on the ass end of millennial years so I was pretty young when em was in his prime.. smh
Oh it was the TIME to be alive I went to so many concerts we had cameras but we weren’t able to see the photos until after we got them developed at Walgreens and before shows they would say “please not flash photography” that didn’t stop us 😅
Why is everywhere where people who if I go to concert? I’m enjoying myself. I’m not caring what if anybody’s holding a damn cell phone I don’t care. I’m going to a continent and enjoy myself. I’m not worried about people holding a damn phone.
Proof was a great hype man no doubt these two were meant to cross paths!
R.I.P PROOF
+Manny W since proofs death em's music has suffered greatly
You're right about that.
+eiji niizuma but he still one of the best rappers alive :D
he had the best voice to be honest. Such a nice resonance he had man, he could also spit fire too! He was awesome, the only other D12 member after Em that didn't annoy me lmfaoo
you know proof and eminem where childhood friends?
Being a young teen when eminem dropped his first album was an amazing time to be alive
Rap and hip hop is not the same. The legends we had in the 90s are un matched.
R.I.P Proof who helped make Em the God he is today.
2:08 my god that flow.
Kept rewinding it it’s impeccable
Unreal! Who would have thought you could write a rhyme to the batman na na na na! Just epic.
literally gives me chills
ua-cam.com/video/4G6e4TaJxkI/v-deo.html
👌🏼
Same listened that part over over. Skills
I want concerts like this, no phones just people having fun and knowing lyrics
Love the different choice of dancers. Made me love M even more.
1:28 first time I've seen that work!
i love the whole crowd screaming fuck you debbie, idk why :')
Fuck you Debbie is the best part of the song. Don't know why either.
Isn't that Debbie, his mother who sued him for $10 million? I think she lost.
when did they say that??
Vasili, yes, she sued him for a lot of money.
***** 1:28
I had his ticket concert in Toronto I think it was in 2000, unfortunately my work finish was very late and I missed out the concert. And then I just sat at the Cafe and not far away from concert hall. And then I met and had a conversation with a so beautiful and smart girl with the same fate late come to the concert and could not get in and she came from Quebec. So we just sat and talked that evening. I missed out on the show but I got the girl as my wife now.😅
Not sure if W or L
damn, bro lost then procedeed to win
one of the best live performances ive seen. everything was so slick
Damn Proof's timing! 0:02
Elias Jakobsson what does he said? At 0.2
C'mon
@@souravkhanna6636 he jumped at the end of the stage as the beat started
@@souravkhanna6636 you're 4 years late
Im sad he died
One of life’s goals is to see eminem live and a shame I didn’t think of that years ago
Тоже на днях об этом думала.Была возможность ,а я не поехала😔❤
Its never too late Alex 💪
@@Софья-ш3р But you have oxxxymiron now
Eminem's speech: "I'm sure everybody who has ever met him, even just once, can testify to the fact that he illuminated a room when he walked in it. I believe that Proof loved people and people loved him. He was a magnet. He lured you in. You wanted to learn about him, follow his swagger. Without Proof, there would be no Eminem, no Slim Shady, and no D12
So true
@@shady_loni he is the best man 👨
No matter how many years have passed.. this will always be the best performance ever
He always nails his live performances!
proof is the only hype man for eminem
Maaan i wish proof was still alive and I wish eminem would tour in Canada. Proof hypes him up so much
adrian golosky not anymore
The worst thing is that I don't think I'll ever in a concert like this or close to this.This shit is legendary.
Am I the only one that loves the way he moves haha
Haan metoo
I love it 😂 fucking legend
True Artist!
Wlodar Piano Covers i
i agree, but its funny because back in the day people would say rap isnt real music....people also said that about rock n roll too.....like it or not, even some of these kids are just artists makin music man. not all of them of course, but theres always been shitty chart topping record label manufactuers
Real motherfuckin' hip hop
ua-cam.com/video/4G6e4TaJxkI/v-deo.html
👌🏼
damn.... i dont have much on my bucket list but finally seeing em in concert after all these years is one
my favorite rapper! i love slim!
Nice Chester dp.
as a little kid i listened to this stuff.. and i actually knew the words. over 10 years later, i listen to this old stuff , and i still know the words. Eminem just never leaves you
i used to listen to this over over again i got my smoking days go back and forth between u kid rock farner
Proof was barely a hype man, he was so good it was a performance in itself
2:08 i god damn love this flow
with the beat
Шедевральный Эминем....навсегда этот Гений.....это Гений 21 века.......здоровья ему......
The most loyal fans in the world are Emin3m fans. I am proud to be one of them.
Love the energy and chemistry between Em & Proof. R.I.P Big Proof!
Em & proof were so great together on the stage .. proof was em best friend ever.. RIP
EMINEM ! Minha infância, fã muito fã deste ser humano q traz em suas músicas o desabafo, Eminem sempre.
Shoutout to the DJ, killed that shit
Yeah
+martin bevin
IKR. he killed the song c:
Nah jk. it was really fucking good doe
Alchemist
ua-cam.com/video/4G6e4TaJxkI/v-deo.html
👌🏼
lol
Finally- a rapper that sounds the same love as he does on his cds. That is really rare if not unique to M.
Am i the only one who appreciates the kick ass DJ? Green lantern enhanced that soooo much!!!
I was definitely there that night! hahahah I was probably like 11 or 12
You're so lucky, I woluld like to be there
Really?!
At the time i wasn't born
@@altinstafa3445 2003+
2024 I had turn back the clock and revisit 2004 hit. My favorite rapper of all time.
Was there. One of the most memorable moments of my childhood.
Eminem legend, his moves just virus, cannot listen this music without dancing like him
One of the few musical artists of the 21st century that doesn't suck and is truly impressive, but that's because he originated in the last century.
One of
The best live performances I’ve ever
Heard thank you slim Marshall and animal
And Proof, never forget Proof. Without him, we wouldn't have Slim Shady. And besides that, he was a genuinely good and caring person who touched a lot of lives positively. RIP man.
Одна из сложных песен в смысле звучания....это шедевр от гения Эминема.....❤ браво!!!!!!
Was Für Eine Wunderschöne Zeit
year 2022, who’s watching this until now? man, I miss this. VCD day’s.
You never knew what to expect from an Eminem concert, and it could be, just from the singing and the microphone, or bring dancers, entertainers and all. But what was certain was that you were going to see a great concert and that Eminem would give you everything he had to offer 🖤
Gotta be my favourite rap tune of all time, always brings a smile.
The jump at the beginning when the beat drops is freaking epic
Eminem is greatest performer ever, he sounds just exactly how he’s sounds like in his albums no auto tunes no anything
Some hype.. imagine having a friend like that. Has Eminem throwing at the start its class
If and when they ever make an actual Eminem biopic, I feel like they gotta use this performance as reference for a scene. Cuz just the way this vid was shot makes it feel like it's already from a movie.
I absolutely love it when the audience yells "Fuck you Debbie!" and "BITCH!" It's so funny!
HELL YEAH PERFECT CROWD! lol
I am amazed at his stage presence. ❤ Beautiful man. Hard working spitter/rapper.
I LOVE THIS SO MUCH OMG AND THIS WAS 14 YEARS AGO HE IS AN TRUE LEGEND NO ONE CAN PROVE ME WRONG!
I’m really enjoying the music from here, imagine being there that would been one of the best experiences in my life
I really enjoy watching this video… The energy is just amazing. The way Proof leaped out front …
Love how he stays so in time with himself, makes him a G
Sometimes I wish that I was in his era but then I remember that he is still rocking till date ...G.O.A.T
Hell yes! Damn those juicy dancers I miss these days we have grown up together Marshall
No auto tune and sounds the exact same. What a legend
How well he sings! He was and is a good artist! This year he turns 50!🥳
Just the part that he is performing with his best friend is the reason why he was so great at entertaining. I wanna go back in time to see eminem as this kind of person
I never listened to Eminem before this
AS IN I HAVEN'T TRIED TO LISTEN TO HIS MUSIC but i've heard it around
this is SO GOOD
you listened to his music just about now? Dayum, I've known him since 1998 or '99. Feel old.
Welcome to the Eminem show... Enjoy :)
+EETFUK never thought I'd see someone on an Eminem video with James Hetfield as their pic 😜
Zak Storey fuck YEAH bro. Metallica and Eminem are my favorite artists 👍🏽
listen to rap the. fast rap part
0:27-
It always cracks me up to see that dwarf person dance in the background!
😁😆🤣
the mother of all performersss what a vibeee
Proof was definitely the man, but to Dr. Dre's defense, this beat blows up stadiums with no hype. The bassline is insane. To this day.
BEST BEAT , BEST SONG , BEST RAPPER !
Ok bad boy, keep it real. Thanks for so many years of awesome music. ❤❤
On this day (May 15) in 2002 Eminem released Without Me as a single. Happy 20th anniversary to an Eminem classic
melhor DVD que eu tinha, me ajudo a ser um BAD BOY na escola.
Here in Brazil, I love this song.
he deserves everything. he's the fucking god.
DAMN RIGHT!!!!
***** Damn right nigga!
hell yea dawg
No, god is the Eminem
Rebecca Bruce Mathers III no he's a rap god
2:08 is the smoothest thing i've ever heard
No fancy flashy clothes real rap!! Miss this
I really miss Proof at his side.
And he does as well i guess
What happened to proof?
@@raven-fo4bk got into an altercation and was shot and killed in 2006
@@MaxAutoCare no se ñ.ll
Proof... :/ BIG PROOF we miss you ! R.I.P
He's a legend back then, now and forever.
Without me, greatest song from Em ever
The most hyped crowd I've ever seen.
RIP Proof!!! Eminem has not been the same since you passed. This was the hey day of hip hop. I grew up on this music.
Eminem, é tudo no rapper acompanho esse mito a milhões de anos.
@@benicio2347 KKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKKK
Para los que hablan español...
.. les doy un dato, eminem es de otro mundo no necesitaba tener bailarinas con un cuerpo perfecto y nunca usa autotone y siempre da conciertos perfectos que cuanda acaba dices tu: no manches he idó al concierto mas grandioso de mi vida
apenas se nota que usa autotune en sus videos musicales
The best raper
Pura Gordi buena😘
TEMAZO!!! Grande Eminem 😍 el mejor rapero de todos los tiempos el blanco como negro más respetado❤️❤️❤️❤️
Eminem knows how to make great music funny and serious at the same
Eminen top demais slk... Curto demais sou seu fã Eminem
What a guy... What bloody awesome music...
It's hard to find such insane performances nowadays
Never heard of Justin bieber?