Aaaand this is Shirk 100% You left the قال تعالى To قال الرب فال اليسون وانتم تقولون مال محمد... أين قال الله يا أهل السنه؟!! كتابا مهجورا،،eh?!! Get the fudge outa here
Please brothers, you need to know we don’t say Allah peace be upon we only say peace be upon for messengers. Encourage what you’re doing guys, May Allah guide us all. I enjoyed your show as well.
Justin’s arrogance can be a little off-putting at times, but I really appreciate James’ perspective on things. It’s James that keeps me subbed to this channel. Thank you 😊
@@acy2004 To be honest this is a very insufficient answer! Who is "he" and my left or theirs! It's simple to say for example, James is the one in the teddy bears shirt or Justin.
The two of you do a good job of presenting and critiquing the videos you choose to curate. And each of you brings your own skills. James selects and presents ideas he is curious about, with openness and honesty, and Justin offers more questions, critical thinking and a healthy dose of skepticism. Both are like a yin and yang and work well together and that seems to be the strength of your videos, imo. Truth withstands all scrutiny and, If not, well it's not truth, whether in the Qur'an or Hadith, the OT or NT, the Torah or Talmud. Expose all texts, teachings, history, claims and beliefs to scholarship and criticism and let's see how they all hold up. Good show, fellas.
I feel like James comes with a little more openness to the subject and knows how to take the information and deal with it without influencing it too much with his previous experiences, while Justin seems more angry, closed off and likes to put his preconceived ideas of what religions are when reacting to these kinds of videos sometimes. Its not very serious but it does put me off sometimes, as a believer i feel judged and seen like a brainwashed sheep who follows blindly and doesn't know better than religion while james does 😂😂😂not that it really matters to me but i just felt the need to comment this as constructive criticism cause i do believe that since Justin is willing to learn about all these religions, he isn't that close minded and he just need to hear this maybe 😂😂 other than this i do really enjoy your videos, i find them very constructive and its nice hear someone's opinion from outside our religion keep going ! 🤍🤍🤍
Dude like how these who follow only Quran pray , praying was mentioned in Quran but it doesn't explain how many rakas to pray each Salah and number of prayers their exact timing
the hadidth contain of what prophet spoke to sahabah(companion), what shabah saw prophet doing things, and many more action of the prophet. This thing being record for future generation to knowing what prophet do and done back then to follow him as Quran instructed us to do. While this all being narated by the companion of prophet. Scholar double check triple check, fourth check and so on to unsure it is legitimate and aunthenticity.
i can now see where this attitude coming from. you inner desire gets justified by your newly found intelligence when you grew up (i am sure you were not so intelligent about life when you were getting formed inside womb). we all have limited time allocated to get our personality in order before you get to be placed in the final stage. look around in this earth everything is made for a purpose for a balance. and somehow you think you are made to speak some intelligent observations and get garbage collected even though you as human are the most advance, intelligent and (freewill) species on planet. as it says in quran ("Who created seven heavens in layers. You do not see any in the creation of the Most Merciful any inconsistency. So return your vision to the sky, do you see any breaks? Then return your vision twice again. Your vision will return to you humbled while it is fatigued."Surah Al-Mulk (67:3-4))
You don't say Allah peace be upon him. For Allah you say the most holy the most high. But you're not muslims anyways, so you don't need to do all these praise and respect. For muslims, mentioning a prophet's name without adding the 'peace be upon him' behind the name is considered arrogant/ high in pride. And when mentioning Allah, we don't have to add anything behind the name but we muslims praise the God a lot so we add those praise words and sometimes every one of His 99 attributes: The most holy, The most high, The greatest, etc.
No real muslim will exclude hadith thats a fact. Authentic hadith is known and there r books for authentic hadiths Hadith is a complete science on its own and a huge field and there always been qualified people in that field centuries ago with Phds and complete dedication to it and all contributed to wat we have now of known books and we know wats authentic and wats not So simple .dont know y some people just liks to complicate things unless they have a hidden agenda behind such weird opinions
Thank you, gentlemen. Abrahamic videos are difficult for me to watch, as they only work in a vacuum. Your homour helps me to understand ideas that large swaths of people accept.
O my dear brother you reaton this video treatment for parent in Islam one Allah TV with English subtitles by mufti Menk with English subtitles you will be caring this video brother you don't miss this video
yo guy in black u should start a youtube alone , it will be more interesting to watch and more with more benifit thinking , not stupid jokes the is enugh channels for dumbs
I've seen your comments come by many times, but you are pushing it too much brother. The way you talk is becoming very rude as well. You think this works? Behave like a proper muslim, with wisdom and kindness, and leave guidance to Allah swt.
@SoufBouchahati iean no harm , but i think the older guy have a great insight and more smart idias to discus thing i dont mean ISLAM but all topics in general but the clown interfere u know ...so will bey last comment , again i mean no harm
May Allah guide you both to straight path and open your hearts to the truth Ali from morocco
Amin, im moroccan too
Accept only the hadiths that do not contradict the Quran. It is that simple.
That makes no sense What would you follow something that is already in the Quran already. You do not need hadith at all The sects are all cults
99% muslim believes in Hadith, and supported top Hadith books
Aaaand this is Shirk 100%
You left the
قال تعالى
To
قال الرب
فال اليسون
وانتم تقولون
مال محمد...
أين قال الله يا أهل السنه؟!!
كتابا مهجورا،،eh?!!
Get the fudge outa here
Please brothers, you need to know we don’t say Allah peace be upon we only say peace be upon for messengers. Encourage what you’re doing guys, May Allah guide us all. I enjoyed your show as well.
Justin’s arrogance can be a little off-putting at times, but I really appreciate James’ perspective on things. It’s James that keeps me subbed to this channel. Thank you 😊
Who is Justin and who is James please?
@ he is the guy always on the left and the one that is able to pay attention to videos.
@@acy2004 To be honest this is a very insufficient answer! Who is "he" and my left or theirs! It's simple to say for example, James is the one in the teddy bears shirt or Justin.
@ my apologies for the ambiguity. Justin is the one with the teddy bear shirt, James in black.
@acy2004 Not at all. Thank you so much, it's clear now :)
Thank you for this reaction 🥰🥰🥰
May ALLAH guide ALL humans to islam
No
Dawah UA-camr Arabic, this channel is very good, and answer your questions
Beautiful Islam Quran my Ferind
The two of you do a good job of presenting and critiquing the videos you choose to curate. And each of you brings your own skills. James selects and presents ideas he is curious about, with openness and honesty, and Justin offers more questions, critical thinking and a healthy dose of skepticism. Both are like a yin and yang and work well together and that seems to be the strength of your videos, imo. Truth withstands all scrutiny and, If not, well it's not truth, whether in the Qur'an or Hadith, the OT or NT, the Torah or Talmud. Expose all texts, teachings, history, claims and beliefs to scholarship and criticism and let's see how they all hold up. Good show, fellas.
Stop comparing to your experiences with Christianity!!!! Defeated way to learn
❤ Everyone say:
33 subhanallah
33 alhmadulillah
34 allahuakber
that hadith video was NOT a muslim video. that was a shia video and we consider them disbelievers, they are a minority sect. sunni is the majority
You are wrong that shaykh is sunni
I feel like James comes with a little more openness to the subject and knows how to take the information and deal with it without influencing it too much with his previous experiences, while Justin seems more angry, closed off and likes to put his preconceived ideas of what religions are when reacting to these kinds of videos sometimes. Its not very serious but it does put me off sometimes, as a believer i feel judged and seen like a brainwashed sheep who follows blindly and doesn't know better than religion while james does 😂😂😂not that it really matters to me but i just felt the need to comment this as constructive criticism cause i do believe that since Justin is willing to learn about all these religions, he isn't that close minded and he just need to hear this maybe 😂😂 other than this i do really enjoy your videos, i find them very constructive and its nice hear someone's opinion from outside our religion keep going ! 🤍🤍🤍
Dude like how these who follow only Quran pray , praying was mentioned in Quran but it doesn't explain how many rakas to pray each Salah and number of prayers their exact timing
By the way, Justin we call to all prophets (PBUH) not only our prophet Mohammed. And please show respect for all.😡
I think the distraction you had comes from the cheikh tone. It was steady and calme to the point to make its message fuzzy.
Never heard that before "cheikh tone" 🤔🤔
@@stayspiritual I mean Cheick voice tone
@@stayspiritualthey mean the man’s tone of voice; he was kind of monotone.
@@stayspiritual some people spell like that but actually meant shaykh or scholar
the hadidth contain of what prophet spoke to sahabah(companion), what shabah saw prophet doing things, and many more action of the prophet. This thing being record for future generation to knowing what prophet do and done back then to follow him as Quran instructed us to do. While this all being narated by the companion of prophet. Scholar double check triple check, fourth check and so on to unsure it is legitimate and aunthenticity.
i can now see where this attitude coming from. you inner desire gets justified by your newly found intelligence when you grew up (i am sure you were not so intelligent about life when you were getting formed inside womb). we all have limited time allocated to get our personality in order before you get to be placed in the final stage. look around in this earth everything is made for a purpose for a balance. and somehow you think you are made to speak some intelligent observations and get garbage collected even though you as human are the most advance, intelligent and (freewill) species on planet. as it says in quran ("Who created seven heavens in layers. You do not see any in the creation of the Most Merciful any inconsistency. So return your vision to the sky, do you see any breaks? Then return your vision twice again. Your vision will return to you humbled while it is fatigued."Surah Al-Mulk (67:3-4))
There are lots of misconception regarding these themes. So we all should be careful. Any narration conflict or against Quran ayas should be rejected.
He can't focus that's why he chooses his whims and desires over reason and evidence.
Hi Guys, Justin you look at his beard and his thoup, but you don’t look at what you wear, baby 👕. It's not suitable for you.😂😂😂😂
React to surah AL-mouminoun THE-believers by the most merciful channel in youtube ❤💯 really good RECITETION ❤
You don't say Allah peace be upon him. For Allah you say the most holy the most high. But you're not muslims anyways, so you don't need to do all these praise and respect. For muslims, mentioning a prophet's name without adding the 'peace be upon him' behind the name is considered arrogant/ high in pride. And when mentioning Allah, we don't have to add anything behind the name but we muslims praise the God a lot so we add those praise words and sometimes every one of His 99 attributes: The most holy, The most high, The greatest, etc.
No real muslim will exclude hadith thats a fact.
Authentic hadith is known and there r books for authentic hadiths
Hadith is a complete science on its own and a huge field and there always been qualified people in that field centuries ago with Phds and complete dedication to it and all contributed to wat we have now of known books and we know wats authentic and wats not
So simple .dont know y some people just liks to complicate things unless they have a hidden agenda behind such weird opinions
Thank you, gentlemen. Abrahamic videos are difficult for me to watch, as they only work in a vacuum. Your homour helps me to understand ideas that large swaths of people accept.
The Bible cannot be said to be holy verses, even the hadiths are not included, because these verses are disconnected from the preaching of Jesus
Army of Satan is your genre. Bring them back asap
🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰❤️❤️❤️
Quran alone is true Islam. And Muft Menk has been refuted by Quran alone Muslims easily
LAUREL AND HARDY YOU DONT KNOW WHAT YOU TALKING ABOUT
Love that you watching and commenting 👍
You guys should react to quran from start to end surah by surah...
React to HAMZA YUSUF
{A different view}
Pov from an intp..stop reacting to islam videos just to gain views!!
Bro cmon get over christiany and look at things from a new perspective stop comparing and droping everything onto your past christian experiences
Pls change your profail gays
Nah 😘
O my dear brother you reaton this video treatment for parent in Islam one Allah TV with English subtitles by mufti Menk with English subtitles you will be caring this video brother you don't miss this video
yo guy in black u should start a youtube alone , it will be more interesting to watch and more with more benifit thinking , not stupid jokes the is enugh channels for dumbs
I've seen your comments come by many times, but you are pushing it too much brother. The way you talk is becoming very rude as well. You think this works?
Behave like a proper muslim, with wisdom and kindness, and leave guidance to Allah swt.
@SoufBouchahati iean no harm , but i think the older guy have a great insight and more smart idias to discus thing i dont mean ISLAM but all topics in general but the clown interfere u know ...so will bey last comment , again i mean no harm
No hadiths in holy prophets time , prophet didn't follow hadith only the koran ,which is hadith in itself
such a Cancer for world.....this is a evil indeed...
typical cow worshipper comment. lindu.