You know you're the queen of K-Pop when: 1. Your live performance and MR removed are sounds the same. 2. You got your name in your personal microphone. 3. People complaining about the sound of you breathing while singing. 4. You are Taeyeon.
geez people just couldn't stop finding something to complaint about. when she slays the song, people be complaining about her audible breath sounds, or the loud back track, or the absence of backup singers, etc. yes, those are your opinions but in my opinion, y'all better have a seat and let Taeyeon do her job.
she sings with only the instrument and no backtrack at all, sometimes few words are missing (well it happens to soloist singing live, you dont have all the breath to sing every word), but she still makes the song sound amazing and it doesnt even feel weird when some words are not there. i just love her and her voice so much
The comments about her breathing is ridiculous. Do you guys not know anything about singing a solo song? Listen her audio and think how the hell is she supposed to sing that without taking breaths in between. This is normal. She's not tired at all.
Since when is it a 'technical flaw', do they gotta stop breathing LMAO. The reason her breathing is so loud is cause 1. the song has NO pauses in the lyrics, she's continuously singing and 2. this song barely has any instrumentals to cover up the breathes like is usually done. Listen to her Fine performance where you can barely hear it. If it was a 'technical flaw' it would've shown in her other 2 performances in the same hour too lol
Ania A Haha. You should ask older and experienced singing teachers about audible breath and you will get the same answer, that's why teachers will ask students to learn about silent breathing. Of course, the breath will still be audible on softer songs but not as loud as this. performance.
rebi no HAHAHA, first someone came up with the boring "jealous" and "hater" argument, and now the "Twice" argument. FYI I'm not jealous, not a hater and I also don't listen to Twice. Read again about my original comment and you'll clearly understand.
if you are wondering about why is her breathing sound so apparent in here, its because how the lyrics are so tightly laid out. The lines are practically linked to one another, making the singer quite hard to catch a breath. Especially at 0:50- 0:59, that bit is particularly tricky, it does actually requires the singer to catch a breath, but when she does it, she has to do it in a hurry. That line wouldn't sound good even if she sang it in one go. The only way that can solve this problem is getting another person to continue the line at 0:55. If you listen to the recorded version, instead of her taking a breath there, they overlaid the clip of her next line right after the previous one. But since this is a solo song, she can only take a breath quickly there.
i know right! her audible breath sound here is almost unnoticeable to me until i read the comments. i used to be Jordin Sparks' fan, and in her songs, the breath sounds are so prominent even in studio version that Taeyeon's audible breath sounds here are nothing to complaint about.
luvlinda1314520 i think it's also because the volume of the mic had to be higher due to the absence of the backing track, so that audience would be able to hear her singing well. the backing track would also usually hide her breaths slightly.
Because they don't really understand how singing works. They can edit out the breathing sound in the music track but performing live is an absolutely different thing, which is why some singers only sounds good in the recording room but never on the stage.
Find "11:11 instrumental" here on youtube and try to sing it from start to beginning including the nanana part and also all the adlib. You guys will understand about the BREATHING SOUND.
MrYoonJan couldn't agree with you. even for me that just joking with singing, I mean I never serious to sing because I'm a bad singer, hehe... find it hard to sing this song.
This song is so easy-going & eases your mind but once you try singing it its actually harder than it sounds lmao i sound horrible so I applaud kim taeyeon for making it look so effortless! Please keep singing & im anticipating SNSD's comeback 😄
I think it's more that she hasn't really practiced her other new songs, so it's easier to sing this song and the other one which she's use to singing. Tae will never disappoint us.
I know honey but i say what i want to say right ? and no one can say to me anything this is my life who you are to come and say to me that and i know she is love baeky and fany but when i say she is mine idont mean it beacuse i'm not gay but i love her too much and i want her and anyone be with taeyeon idont care if she's happy ok baby? do you ander stand me? And in the second time dont enter yourself and dont talk with me about taeyeon so now get out from me
Honestly because of her beautiful performance..i didnt notice the breathing that other people talking about 😂...that is part of singing thou..anw such a beautiful performance taengoo 😍❤️❤️
It’s 11:11 오늘이 한 칸이 채 안 남은 그런 시간 우리 소원을 빌며 웃던 그 시간 별 게 다 널 떠오르게 하지 네 맘 끝자락처럼 차가운 바람 창을 열면 온통 네가 불어와 이 시간이 전부 지나고 나면 이별이 끝나 있을까 Yeah 널 다 잊었을까 모든 게 자릴 찾아서 떠나가고 넌 내 모든 걸 갖고서 떠나도 내 맘은 시계 속의 두 바늘처럼 같은 곳을 두고 맴돌기만 해 Na na na na na na na na na na na na na oh Na na na na na na na na I believe I will be over you 달력 안에 있는 오래 전에 약속했던 몇 월의 며칠 너에겐 다 잊혀져 있었다면 내가 지워야지 뭐 지나고 나면 별 거 아니겠지 뭐 모든 게 자릴 찾아서 떠나가고 넌 내 모든 걸 갖고서 떠나도 내 맘은 시계 속의 두 바늘처럼 같은 곳을 두고 맴돌기만 해 Na na na na na na na na na na na na na oh Na na na na na na na na I believe I will be over you 계절 틈에 잠시 피는 낯선 꽃처럼 하루 틈에 걸려 있는 새벽 별처럼 이 모든 건 언젠가는 다 지나가고 말겠지 모든 게 자릴 찾아서 돌아오고 내가 아무 일 없는 듯이 웃게 되면 너의 이름 한 번쯤 부르는 게 지금처럼 아프지 않을 거야 Na na na na na na na na na na na na na oh Na na na na na na na na I believe I will be over you Na na na na na na na na na na na na na oh Na na na na na na na na I believe I will be over you
What made my jaw dropped on this performance was that, she was able to convey the message of the song as if she experienced it. It's like, she's narrating every line of the song that comes out of her mouth. Her voice itself is an art. I can't find any words to describe how amazing this performance was. I literally cried. I don't know why, I just feel the emotion, really. Ahhh taeyeon's the best.
Flawless in my opinion she's the best singer ever. Other people may disagree, but I believe that it's up to the person to decide who is the best singer for them. Everytime I hear Taeyeon sing,I feel so relax and laid back, she always manage to express her emotions into the song. Her voice alone is enough to send me to heaven.
Many of these people watching Sketchbook for the first time because of Taeyeon be like: "WHY IS HER BREATH SO LOUD", "OMG SHE'S SINGING WITHOUT A BACKING TRACK." etc., well...that's what happens on an actual live stage XD
Taeyeon, is one perfect fine lady. Although I have been with Girls Generation since Gee period, she never fails to impress me every single time she performs 😍 Taeyeon has grown alot! She's so good OMG
A AWESOME live performance.....such a classy lady......Hiyeol's Sketchbook is the best quality...great musicians and a awesome sound and mixing crew.......
Taeyeon's live vocals is astounding as ever. I won't get tired of listening to this. You can clearly hear her raw, unedited vocals. I always fall in love with Taeyeon's voice regardless if she's singing a love song or a break up song.
I am in awe at the fact that the voice that comes out of her is so serene and soft despite the fact that the song is so tightly structured there's almost no time for her to breathe at all. Queen Slayeon Slayyyyyyy
![[MMF2016] TAEYEON - 11:11, 태연 - 11:11, MBC Music Festival 20161231](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/YGMlEq6t810/mqdefault.jpg)
![[2016 SAF 가요대전] ‘여신’ 태연(Taeyeon)의 감미로운 발라드 ‘11:11’](/img/n.gif)
한국인이 왜 이렇게 없어,,,, 태연 노래 짱 좋은데 한국인 모여라 !!!!!
여기
어셈블
여기
여기도 추가요
모여따!!!
You know you're the queen of K-Pop when:
1. Your live performance and MR removed are sounds the same.
2. You got your name in your personal microphone.
3. People complaining about the sound of you breathing while singing.
4. You are Taeyeon.
이노래 11:11이라는 노래는 우울하거나 위로받는 느낌을 많이 받았다 태연언니 노래 다 좋아하지만 내 최애곡 평생 함께 제 청춘 함께해주세요
geez people just couldn't stop finding something to complaint about. when she slays the song, people be complaining about her audible breath sounds, or the loud back track, or the absence of backup singers, etc. yes, those are your opinions but in my opinion, y'all better have a seat and let Taeyeon do her job.
SM is the luckiest companies ever
even tho she is the worst how lmoa
@@omaimus wym the worst she's probably one of the best singers in all of kpop. On par with Ailee, Gummy and IU at the least
@@lulgrim calm down, the other person is talking about the company not about taeyeon
어떻게 매순간 이쁘지,.?
she sings with only the instrument and no backtrack at all, sometimes few words are missing (well it happens to soloist singing live, you dont have all the breath to sing every word), but she still makes the song sound amazing and it doesnt even feel weird when some words are not there. i just love her and her voice so much
Ha Anh Nguyen exactly, this is real live perform
Honestly it's my first time watching that kpop idol sings without any backup music 😍
Alika Nee I think me too. usually they have a back track
Alika Nee Yesss
You don't know much then.
It's beautiful
you should listen to mamamoo. taeyeon and mamamoo are my favs
The comments about her breathing is ridiculous. Do you guys not know anything about singing a solo song? Listen her audio and think how the hell is she supposed to sing that without taking breaths in between. This is normal. She's not tired at all.
Zayida Esmeralda LOL. An audible breath is considered as a technical flaw but because nowadays everyone does it, it became acceptable.
Since when is it a 'technical flaw', do they gotta stop breathing LMAO. The reason her breathing is so loud is cause 1. the song has NO pauses in the lyrics, she's continuously singing and 2. this song barely has any instrumentals to cover up the breathes like is usually done. Listen to her Fine performance where you can barely hear it. If it was a 'technical flaw' it would've shown in her other 2 performances in the same hour too lol
Ania A Haha. You should ask older and experienced singing teachers about audible breath and you will get the same answer, that's why teachers will ask students to learn about silent breathing. Of course, the breath will still be audible on softer songs but not as loud as this. performance.
rayn sity complaining about the prove she sang live . untalented twice fckin lipsync on sketchbook yet you guys still stan them
rebi no HAHAHA, first someone came up with the boring "jealous" and "hater" argument, and now the "Twice" argument. FYI I'm not jealous, not a hater and I also don't listen to Twice. Read again about my original comment and you'll clearly understand.
if you are wondering about why is her breathing sound so apparent in here, its because how the lyrics are so tightly laid out. The lines are practically linked to one another, making the singer quite hard to catch a breath. Especially at 0:50- 0:59, that bit is particularly tricky, it does actually requires the singer to catch a breath, but when she does it, she has to do it in a hurry. That line wouldn't sound good even if she sang it in one go.
The only way that can solve this problem is getting another person to continue the line at 0:55. If you listen to the recorded version, instead of her taking a breath there, they overlaid the clip of her next line right after the previous one. But since this is a solo song, she can only take a breath quickly there.
luvlinda1314520 at least the breathing prove that she sing live not lipsync
i know right! her audible breath sound here is almost unnoticeable to me until i read the comments. i used to be Jordin Sparks' fan, and in her songs, the breath sounds are so prominent even in studio version that Taeyeon's audible breath sounds here are nothing to complaint about.
luvlinda1314520 i think it's also because the volume of the mic had to be higher due to the absence of the backing track, so that audience would be able to hear her singing well. the backing track would also usually hide her breaths slightly.
rebi no yes, I prefer these small "flaws" over singers lip syncing
Maybe that's why I love the live version on SM channel.
It's slower, so that Taeyeon does not have to rush
노래잘하지 얼굴예쁘지 너무좋아요 ㅛㅛ
Voice of an angel
자기 전에 들으면 너무 좋아 태연이오래보자사랑해💜
how can someone expect a singer to sing without breathing... that doesn't make sense
Because they don't really understand how singing works. They can edit out the breathing sound in the music track but performing live is an absolutely different thing, which is why some singers only sounds good in the recording room but never on the stage.
IY's G7 her breathing sounds fine!
Lmao 🤣
the fuck i didnt even realize her 'loud' breathing until i scrolled down the comments section. it was perfect for me
me too
Same
same, and honestly her breathing noises are actually quite soothing in this lol
옷 얼굴 음색 다 예쁘다..
찐라이브 ㅎㄷㄷ 역시 믿고 듣는 탱구♡♡♡
Find "11:11 instrumental" here on youtube and try to sing it from start to beginning including the nanana part and also all the adlib.
You guys will understand about the BREATHING SOUND.
MrYoonJan couldn't agree with you. even for me that just joking with singing, I mean I never serious to sing because I'm a bad singer, hehe... find it hard to sing this song.
11-11 I love the song!
할튼 이쁘긴 드릅게 이뻐
Because of her confidence, her skills and her experiences, she became an overwhelming presence, a *queen*.
This song is so easy-going & eases your mind but once you try singing it its actually harder than it sounds lmao i sound horrible so I applaud kim taeyeon for making it look so effortless! Please keep singing & im anticipating SNSD's comeback 😄
no back up singers, no backup music .... still slaying #SLAYEON
I'm so happy to hear this but I expect more.. I think tae will perform any songs in my voice album
Blueberry Coffee i really want to hear her sing fire. I love that songg
Blueberry Coffee I want her to sing cover up ^^
Love in Color is my absolute favorite from this album!
Blueberry Coffee she said she will do the other songs in the album at her concert so be expecting that 😊
I think it's more that she hasn't really practiced her other new songs, so it's easier to sing this song and the other one which she's use to singing. Tae will never disappoint us.
nowadays she is wearing long dresses and I really like it fits her so well 😍😍
She's become so comfortable as a soloist now, her presence and aura on stage is so great. I am proud :')
i want u kim taeyeon!
lol she's mine😊
Shit up she is mine if you like that or not
sorry but she already has Baekhyun and Fany
I know honey but i say what i want to say right ? and no one can say to me anything this is my life who you are to come and say to me that and i know she is love baeky and fany but when i say she is mine idont mean it beacuse i'm not gay but i love her too much and i want her and anyone be with taeyeon idont care if she's happy ok baby? do you ander stand me? And in the second time dont enter yourself and dont talk with me about taeyeon so now get out from me
lmao please don't take it seriously. I didn't mean anything. My comment was supposed to be a joke✌ I also love her so much
there are no words to describe how good taeyeon’s voice is.. this woman's voice suits every damn genre 🙌
11:11 여전히 명곡이죠 가끔 들으러 옵니당 ㅎ
No backing track just pure live vocals and it's amazing! In love with this
Perfection. Literal perfection.
so clear that she is enjoying this stage so much
her live is really no joke..
This kids voice is so freaking beautiful 😇😇😇
To people questioning the way Taeyeon breathe while singing, try singing this alone by yourself and you'll know why :)
Honestly because of her beautiful performance..i didnt notice the breathing that other people talking about 😂...that is part of singing thou..anw such a beautiful performance taengoo 😍❤️❤️
same! I even repeat the parts that I saw in the comments about the breath lol
She sounds so good live ❤❤❤
여기서 부를 때 나오는 MR 좋다
묘하게 슬픈 노래…
가사가 슬픈 노래라서…ㅎㅎ
태연 노래 잘한다 사랑해!!!
I really like to see her expression when she was singing ❤
이 노래 너무 진짜 좋지❤️
너무 이쁘다...ㅎ
Your voice is a beauty❤
난 이 노래가 좋더라 잔잔하게
Her breath is a music to my ears 😍
Her voice is so relaxing to hear
The nanana part and her voice got me like💕✨so dreamy✨ ~
Btw she looks so pretty here 🙊☺️
OH MY GOD, NO BACKTRACK, I'M SO HAPPY!!!!!!! 😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍😍
귀 살살 녹는다
Slay my heart, queen ❤
썸네일 보고 반한 태연 처돌이인데 어캐 지나칠수 있겠어 ,,
Love your voice,Taeyeon.
It’s 11:11
오늘이 한 칸이 채 안 남은 그런 시간
우리 소원을 빌며 웃던 그 시간
별 게 다 널 떠오르게 하지
네 맘 끝자락처럼 차가운 바람
창을 열면 온통 네가 불어와
이 시간이 전부 지나고 나면
이별이 끝나 있을까 Yeah
널 다 잊었을까
모든 게 자릴 찾아서 떠나가고
넌 내 모든 걸 갖고서 떠나도
내 맘은 시계 속의 두 바늘처럼
같은 곳을 두고 맴돌기만 해
Na na na na na na na
na na na na na na oh
Na na na na na na na na
I believe I will be over you
달력 안에 있는
오래 전에 약속했던 몇 월의 며칠
너에겐 다 잊혀져 있었다면
내가 지워야지 뭐
지나고 나면 별 거 아니겠지 뭐
모든 게 자릴 찾아서 떠나가고
넌 내 모든 걸 갖고서 떠나도
내 맘은 시계 속의 두 바늘처럼
같은 곳을 두고 맴돌기만 해
Na na na na na na na
na na na na na na oh
Na na na na na na na na
I believe I will be over you
계절 틈에 잠시 피는 낯선 꽃처럼
하루 틈에 걸려 있는 새벽 별처럼
이 모든 건 언젠가는
다 지나가고 말겠지
모든 게 자릴 찾아서 돌아오고
내가 아무 일 없는 듯이 웃게 되면
너의 이름 한 번쯤 부르는 게
지금처럼 아프지 않을 거야
Na na na na na na na
na na na na na na oh
Na na na na na na na na
I believe I will be over you
Na na na na na na na
na na na na na na oh
Na na na na na na na na
I believe I will be over you
I don't know how anyone can dislike this.
I'm in love with this song 😔💖💖💖💖💖💖
Who else from an idol girl group member can sing with so much emotions? Only Taeyeon. She slays and doesnt even need background voices.
this performance is soo.. delicate. T.T
she never dissapoints.. Tae Tae the Queen. 😘😍
I really love the melody!
we could actually see years and years of training and experience from the way she sang. so beautiful.
Why even the sound of her breathing is also beautiful huhu 😍❤
고막이 너무 행복해
Believe me! This song is too hard!! We really need a soft voice to sing it! Taeyeon you did it!
i love her breath sound...
I'm happy that Taeyeon looks more confident now compared to her first solo debut 'I'. She looks comfortable performing alone on stage :)
이노래 너무 좋은데 부르기 너무 어려워,,ㅠㅜ
This song makes me so sad,but hopeful.
It's much better than original version. Thank God for bringing you to the world, my tae.
What made my jaw dropped on this performance was that, she was able to convey the message of the song as if she experienced it. It's like, she's narrating every line of the song that comes out of her mouth. Her voice itself is an art. I can't find any words to describe how amazing this performance was. I literally cried. I don't know why, I just feel the emotion, really. Ahhh taeyeon's the best.
Flawless in my opinion she's the best singer ever. Other people may disagree, but I believe that it's up to the person to decide who is the best singer for them. Everytime I hear Taeyeon sing,I feel so relax and laid back, she always manage to express her emotions into the song. Her voice alone is enough to send me to heaven.
I wonder if Taeyeon knows she sings like the angels 🤔🤔
Many of these people watching Sketchbook for the first time because of Taeyeon be like: "WHY IS HER BREATH SO LOUD", "OMG SHE'S SINGING WITHOUT A BACKING TRACK." etc., well...that's what happens on an actual live stage XD
only Taeyeon can sing like this tho :)
lol she dance like a hip hop style
swag :)
my favourite stage of 11 11!
She seems to be really enjoying singing this song, and it makes it even better to watch her performing.😍😍😍
Queen ❤
Taeyeon, is one perfect fine lady. Although I have been with Girls Generation since Gee period, she never fails to impress me every single time she performs 😍 Taeyeon has grown alot! She's so good OMG
태연아 사랑해
사랑해 태연아
노래해줘서 고마워 태연아
평생 고마워요
감사해
💜
que bonita voz OMG♥♥
태연 ... 아이돌이라는 편견 없애준 내 최애 가수 ...목소리 너무 좋다 . 캬 >_
love this stage so much
A AWESOME live performance.....such a classy lady......Hiyeol's Sketchbook is the best quality...great musicians and a awesome sound and mixing crew.......
역시 김태연!!!!!!!!!
my queen..
TAEYEON unnie never dissapoints us in her singing and all...
Is there nothing she cannot make beautiful? Love that voice.
beautiful voice 😙
SOUNDS SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO GOOD. I LOVE HER
Love all songs from Taeyeon
Love you forever Taeyeon 🥰❤️
I want her solo comeback😂😄 but i want snsd comeback first ❤️ snsd sone today, tommorow, and forever 😍
i tried singing this and damn i lost my breath.... i even sang in a lower key and i still find it hard to catch my breath rip
Taeyeon's live vocals is astounding as ever. I won't get tired of listening to this. You can clearly hear her raw, unedited vocals. I always fall in love with Taeyeon's voice regardless if she's singing a love song or a break up song.
MA FAV SONG OMG
I like her dress ❤ and her beautiful voice
2020에 보러오신분!
나요
I am in awe at the fact that the voice that comes out of her is so serene and soft despite the fact that the song is so tightly structured there's almost no time for her to breathe at all. Queen Slayeon Slayyyyyyy
I wonder if Baekhyun is listening to Queen Taeyeon songs 😍😍😍 #baekyeonForever
I can listen Taeng's voice all day 😳😝😍
I find this live soooooo good i mean her gesture and voice blend so well and the way she improvised was damn! King Taeyeon!!