@@this.science ohhhhh that makes sense Oh hello :3 You saw this, nice And that's smart, do that, so it isn't compressed when it's first posted I'm gonna start to do that
Oh I agree. But that plays into OP's point: if Pluto spun like that, it could well be similarly-distorted. Because Pluto, like Haumea, is mostly frozen slush.
Rules don't matter? Okay then (I can't argue with you because anytime I see a person who doesn't care about rules/facts, it's impossible to change their mind)
IAU says Pluto is not a planet. It can be a planet in your heart, but it is forever classified as a dwarf planet and people will have to accept the new planet definition someday.
correction: haumea does have enough gravity to make itself a spheroid. there are objects smaller than haumea and are made of the same stuff that are spheres. the reason it has that weird shape is because of its ultra fast rotation. when the rotation is fast enough, it can elongate a planet like that. you ever notice how saturn seems slightly oblate? yeah, that’s why.
Pretty cool through, there's enough big circular rocks that we could actually land on, bit risky in an asteroid belt but hey maybe we'll mine them someday or something.
He does have some solid points about how if Pluto and all of the discovered Dwarf Planet Candidates were planets, that means more planets in the solar system to memorize. The IAU saved many kids from the headache of having to memorize more planets... *Until we found so many planets outside of the solar system. A.K.A Exoplanets.*
@@Jellyman1129 It still doesn't clear its orbit. If an object orbiting a star can't be massive enough to be spherical and can't clear its orbit, then it can't be a planet. Pluto may be spherical, but it breaks Rule #3 of being a planet. Therefore, it is a dwarf planet. Planets can have moons and satellites in their orbits, but they have to absorb stuff like asteroids, comets & other planets from their orbits by either colliding with them or capturing them. And the planets do that, but the 6 confirmed dwarf planets (if you count Sedna) don't do it because they aren't massive enough. But no elementary school kid wants to learn about over 100 planets in the solar system, so my point still stands.
Love how Pluto apologists can never explain why they think Ceres shouldn't count when it had the exact same story as Pluto just not specifically when they were kids. Either all the dwarfs count or none of them do. I'm fine either way but it's the consistency that bugs me. Pluto doesn't deserve favoritism over Eris or Makemake or Quaoar or Sedna.
@@theoncomingstorm7903 False. Ceres was initially demoted to an asteroid because telescopes couldn’t resolve its shape. We now know that it’s in hydrostatic equilibrium and is therefore a planet.
@@theoncomingstorm7903 Yes, they were called “minor planets”. But as we started to learn more about planets like Mars and Jupiter and understood their geology and size, we realized they were physically distinct from objects like Juno, Pallas, and Vesta. Planets were large dynamic worlds with potential geologic activity, while “minor planets” were dead, tiny rocks. So we separated these “minor planets” from being planets and gave them their own classification.
oh my god back when I was in like 1st grade we did a play and I was cast as a scientist who ran on stage and announced very loudly (and very lispy) that PLUTO WASNT A PLANET ANYMORE!! so yes good memories
Honestly I think Pluto getting demoted was my earliest memory I can place. I came along with my Dad taking my sister to school, and he was telling us about it because the news broke that morning.
I was the pluto in my 1st grade play, and during final rehearsals my planet crown with pluto on it was taken away to represent it not being a part of solar system anymore. I felt sad :(
I disagree. Pluto is definitely not a planet, but that doesn't mean it's not an uninteresting body or uncool. There are a ton of incredibly interesting properties about Pluto, even if it's just a somewhat common Kuiper belt dwarf planet. Gorgeous ice formations, its atmosphere, its moons, its geology.. Charon even gets covered in red debris on its Pluto-facing side from cryovolcanoes. Honestly, every aspect of Pluto- and every body in the solar system, is absolutely fascinating. You don't need to be a planet to be cool :)
See, this is why nobody liked you in elementary school. You were always trying to learn some fucking bullshit that nobody cared about. This is why when you asked Jessica if she could be your girlfriend, she laughed at your face. This is why everyone laughed at you when your pants fell down and it revealed that big ass burn scar. You are at fault for your own failures.
If you think Pluto has a poor excuse for an orbit then you should check out Sedna: its orbit is 5x more eccentric than Pluto's and it take about 11,400 years to complete it just once.
@@NikodAnimations You mean 2015Tg87 Ans the furthest object from the sun is 2014fe72 it takes about 92,000 years to orbit the sun. And is 3050Au from the sun at aphelion..
This is the best start to a channel I've ever seen, can't believe you made it to the top 0.5 percentile in just 2 months. Can't wait to see what you upload next.
That message at the end is too easy, give me something harder like darkening the image a lot so I have to take it into Photoshop and brighten it, and the words are actually put through some kind of cipher, while also being converted into hex code, which is actually a hex code of binary code, which represents an audio wav file of your voice saying the message, reversed, and sped up a lot. I think that might make it harder.
About that orbit, have you seen Sedna’s? Also, Haumea *does* have enough gravity to pull itself into a sphere, it’s just spinning so fast that it’s being stretched into that shape.
what i learn from solarball: Pluto is from the Kuiper belt and the reason why pluto was out of the kuiper belt cause of neptune's gravity but pluto had a moon like their size getting them out from neptune
The second rule says that it has to have enough gravity To keep its shape. So that doesn’t mean it has to be a sphere. Else earth isn’t a planet as well since it isn’t perfectly round
It should be noted that the IAU's new definition of what makes a planet is pretty dumb, for example anything that orbits a different star than our sun can't be a planet. A new new definition is needed for sure. Maybe that would include Pluto, but I doubt it.
haumea actually does have enough gravity to form a sphere. it just spins so unbelievably fast for a planet that its equator bulges extremely, making it look very oblate
One thing you failed to mention, is that plutos discovery was through unimaginable luck. It was nowhere near large enough to produced the observed effect on neptune, and as it turns out, thanks to Voyager 2 we found out neptunes mass was 0.5% less then previously calculated, which as it turns out is just enough of a difference to explain what we thought was another object pulling on it. So not only did the planet they were searching for not exist, and as such the flawed calculations were entirely pointless, but by through some divine stroke of luck, a speck of dust happened to be in the night sky at the time, which we would name pluto.
A fascinating what-if, is what if Eris had been seen when closer to Earth. Its orbit too is elliptic - but it was found returning from the FAR point (which had been reached 1977). Eris is also inherently brighter than Pluto, not having all those dark red tholins on its surface. Perihelion 37.7 AU was passed at 1699. The 13" astrograph was assembled at Flagstaff around 1930. But this sort of astrograph was not top-of-the-line; they could do that in 1887.
@@nikivalx Well, just for starters, Haumea DOES have enough gravity to be a sphere, it just spins really fast so it looks misshapen. Look at Saturn, it spins fast, just not as fast as Haumea. Saturn is also flattened a bit. And Pluto is like, the coolest object ever. It's objectively awesome. It literally has an ocean of LIQUID WATER underneath the ice. It is geologically active. It's moon. Charon, has a deposit of organic molecules on it, called MORDOR.
![[UA] Eternal Fire проти NAVI | EPL Season 20 Malta](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/chvlsDygrZM/mqdefault.jpg)
secret merch --> thismerch.com/
i designed all of it myself :D
How is this posted like a minute ago, and this comment is 18 mins ago
lol
@@timeywimeybrony i wrote the comment when the video was unlisted lol
@@this.science ohhhhh that makes sense
Oh hello :3 You saw this, nice
And that's smart, do that, so it isn't compressed when it's first posted
I'm gonna start to do that
love ur channel, might buy
Plutos enemy’s:
1.) Nasa
2.) This man.
+Neil Degrasse Tyson..
@@BananaJuice-ue6pi and that too
the This. man
3.) CGP Grey
I really, really, don't want to be that guy, cuz my reply doesn't even have proper grammar, but it's *Pluto's Enemies,* not the other way around 😭
This channel grew so important so soon
😭???
@@prodbymalek prolly an exam or test?
@@Rubellite-jq2kg bro what? 💀
@@Rubellite-jq2kgWhat?
bogos binted
Not cool dude
LMAO GET F-
I agree with ya
#JusticeForPluto
I Kinda Agree But Its Still A Dwarf Planet
As a haumea fan, it does have enough gravity to be a sphere, but it spins too fast and which due to centripital force makes it an elipsoid.
Yeah. I couldn't imagine a Planet or Dwarf Planet with a day that only lasts 3 hours, and the Planet/Dwarf still stays round.
Oh I agree. But that plays into OP's point: if Pluto spun like that, it could well be similarly-distorted. Because Pluto, like Haumea, is mostly frozen slush.
Why did I imagine a Haumea PC fan? 💀
0:01 but Pluto is still bigger than humans
not as big as American wal*mart shoppers
bro, at this upload rate and quality of videos, ur gonna hit 500k-1mill subs in no time bro. Just try to not loose yourself when u get there tho. Gl
Pluto is still a damn planet
Rules don't matter? Okay then
(I can't argue with you because anytime I see a person who doesn't care about rules/facts, it's impossible to change their mind)
It isn't
IAU says Pluto is not a planet. It can be a planet in your heart, but it is forever classified as a dwarf planet and people will have to accept the new planet definition someday.
@@PlanetGuy901 Why are people so upset about this years later- large solar system bodies do not have feelings!
@@PlanetGuy901why do you even want it to be a planet? Isn't it much cooler to have Pluto be a king of dwarf planets?
Leave the poor lil dude alone he's still my fav dwarf planet 😭
0:26 wait until you see the sednoids
rick and morty typa situation:
"pluto is a planet"
*HOT TAKE:*
Pluto on the Thumbnail should have :0 emoji instead
How Pluto is a planet just
Small.
This is why Pluto gets bullied 😢
1:40 Haumea has the gravity, it just spins too fast that its an oval
Pluto is my fav planet
"Pluto has one of the most weird and disrespectful orbits I've ever seen." Nobody show this man Sedna's orbit
correction: haumea does have enough gravity to make itself a spheroid. there are objects smaller than haumea and are made of the same stuff that are spheres. the reason it has that weird shape is because of its ultra fast rotation. when the rotation is fast enough, it can elongate a planet like that. you ever notice how saturn seems slightly oblate? yeah, that’s why.
Some others include Varuna and Quaoar. Jupiter is also shaped weird btw.
I'm subscribing rn, this channel is too good
Pluto is gonna come for you
Saw some guy say poor Clyde, I’m sorry but the planet (rock) has got to feel worse than the guy right
Pretty cool through, there's enough big circular rocks that we could actually land on, bit risky in an asteroid belt but hey maybe we'll mine them someday or something.
i will not stand for this pluto slander
💀 And here i was happy with my friends giving me the nickname Pluto....
I 10000% DISAGREE.
And I agree 10000000%.
these keep getting better and better, i applaud you
He does have some solid points about how if Pluto and all of the discovered Dwarf Planet Candidates were planets, that means more planets in the solar system to memorize. The IAU saved many kids from the headache of having to memorize more planets...
*Until we found so many planets outside of the solar system. A.K.A Exoplanets.*
Ah, so you admit it was an unscientific decision. I like to focus on data, not emotion. According to the data, Pluto is a planet.
Imagine if there was 200 countries the kids wouldn’t be able to learn geography
@@Jellyman1129 It still doesn't clear its orbit. If an object orbiting a star can't be massive enough to be spherical and can't clear its orbit, then it can't be a planet. Pluto may be spherical, but it breaks Rule #3 of being a planet. Therefore, it is a dwarf planet. Planets can have moons and satellites in their orbits, but they have to absorb stuff like asteroids, comets & other planets from their orbits by either colliding with them or capturing them. And the planets do that, but the 6 confirmed dwarf planets (if you count Sedna) don't do it because they aren't massive enough. But no elementary school kid wants to learn about over 100 planets in the solar system, so my point still stands.
Sailor Pluto: …
Its 2 am here in India rn and I legit laughing out SOO loud at the whole Charon animation. Brilliant stuff man.
2:40 Rock the flip off johnson
I love pluto because it's a dwarf planet
i subbed to this channel when it had 1k subs ,it's crazy it's now at 300k subs
Damn, there should be an award for that :) Also join early, not first 1k tho
but its a dwarf planet
THE best channel that i’ve discovered so far
great vid. subscribed! keep making vids like these brother
What did poor pluto do to you man 😢
Pluto's still cool in my heart :(
I love this channel
Is anyone here also binge all of his videos the minute you watched the first video?
I mean, you didn't knock it for any points outside of it's non-planetness.
1:33 you re in this council, but we do not grant you the rank of master
PLUTO ROCKS, PLUTO IS A PLANET, ITS A SPACE ROCK
Alright then
Just adding 99942 Apophis to my list of planets
Niel Degrass Tyson disliked this video.
all the edits are so good im dying
this channel is so good what the, im subscribing
Bro to is channel explains the most confusing things in a simple way
0:14 NASA doesn’t give a definition I think you have mistaken them with the IAU
Love how Pluto apologists can never explain why they think Ceres shouldn't count when it had the exact same story as Pluto just not specifically when they were kids.
Either all the dwarfs count or none of them do. I'm fine either way but it's the consistency that bugs me. Pluto doesn't deserve favoritism over Eris or Makemake or Quaoar or Sedna.
Ceres and Pluto do not share the same story. And yes, all dwarf planets should be planets.
@@Jellyman1129 Ceres was considered a planet for over 50 years before being demoted to 'asteriod' after more objects in the belt were discovered.
@@theoncomingstorm7903 False. Ceres was initially demoted to an asteroid because telescopes couldn’t resolve its shape. We now know that it’s in hydrostatic equilibrium and is therefore a planet.
@@Jellyman1129 The shape criterion didn't exist back then, Juno was very obviously not a sphere and yet it was a planet for a while.
@@theoncomingstorm7903 Yes, they were called “minor planets”. But as we started to learn more about planets like Mars and Jupiter and understood their geology and size, we realized they were physically distinct from objects like Juno, Pallas, and Vesta. Planets were large dynamic worlds with potential geologic activity, while “minor planets” were dead, tiny rocks. So we separated these “minor planets” from being planets and gave them their own classification.
I DONT CARE YOU CANT TAKE PLUTO FROM ME
For now on, I believe there are only 10 planets in the solar system
What about Ceres and many other planets though D:
@@bloswi Ok I’ll include them in my list
The Earth is not a sphere...
I guess we demote it from planet status.
..it is though. Just a little flat on Noth and south due to the force of rotating like a chad
Make a video on how cameras can give pictures.
Incorrect, I’ve decided
poor pluto :(
so fun!
I love these science videos.
Eyyyy....put some respec on my boy Plutos name
Quality Content
This channel’s growing so fast
Pluto dont suck, MAYBE YOU SUCK, let me explain, he didn't finished orbiting the sun and hes sad
(During Add before video) why is Pluto not cool anymore?
Pluto is a cute dwarf planet.
The editing this guy does is INSANE
Poor Clyde.
bro how have you already gotten that far xD
@@this.sciencei just instantly clicked the notification
I feel special finding this channel before it really takes off, keep up the amazing work!
this has taken off lmao
id call a channel with more than 200k subs “taken off”
💀
It's about to hit 300k subs
I subbed to this guy when he had 73k subs :)
I have to debate whether or not Pluto is a planet in my astronomy class and this came in clutch
i do what i can
@@this.scienceand i love what you can do, so.... ❤
Should also mention that Pluto's status as a planet is a matter of American pride, which the rest of the world doesn't care about.
why can't everyone just leave Pluto alone at this point. Is it necessary to kick him while he's down?
Pluto is his biggest op and i don't know why
Pluto was always down
Think about the elementary kids
Yes
Why bro having feelings for a celestial object 💀
oh my god back when I was in like 1st grade we did a play and I was cast as a scientist who ran on stage and announced very loudly (and very lispy) that PLUTO WASNT A PLANET ANYMORE!!
so yes good memories
Honestly I think Pluto getting demoted was my earliest memory I can place. I came along with my Dad taking my sister to school, and he was telling us about it because the news broke that morning.
I was the pluto in my 1st grade play, and during final rehearsals my planet crown with pluto on it was taken away to represent it not being a part of solar system anymore. I felt sad :(
your feelings were irrational@@thatchillguy03
@thatchillguy03 How is it not a part of the solar system. That's literally in the solar system.
Haumea technically has reached hydrostatic equilibrium. That’s why it’s a dwarf planet and not an asteroid 👍
Yes, it's only a bit like a football cuz it spinz so fast. Look at saturn, it is flattened too.
I disagree. Pluto is definitely not a planet, but that doesn't mean it's not an uninteresting body or uncool. There are a ton of incredibly interesting properties about Pluto, even if it's just a somewhat common Kuiper belt dwarf planet. Gorgeous ice formations, its atmosphere, its moons, its geology.. Charon even gets covered in red debris on its Pluto-facing side from cryovolcanoes. Honestly, every aspect of Pluto- and every body in the solar system, is absolutely fascinating. You don't need to be a planet to be cool :)
😇💕💕☺️☺️😊🤗
😇💕💕☺️☺️☺️🤗
👿💢💢😡😡😡🤬 (I am the epitome of negativity)
@@doomjuice.1652 😇💕💕☺☺😊🤗
im sorry wasn’t this whole video satire ??
"Think of the kids" bro elementary school me would've LOVED memorizing planets I was obsessed with space back then and I STILL AM.
Bro I don't wanna learn 18 fuckin planets you get 8 max
Space lovers gonna go through this easy
Rip to all those who don't really have an interest in space though.
See, this is why nobody liked you in elementary school. You were always trying to learn some fucking bullshit that nobody cared about. This is why when you asked Jessica if she could be your girlfriend, she laughed at your face. This is why everyone laughed at you when your pants fell down and it revealed that big ass burn scar. You are at fault for your own failures.
Yes, and we learned 50 states and their capitals. Surely kids can handle 30+ planets.
YESS ME TOO
If you think Pluto has a poor excuse for an orbit then you should check out Sedna: its orbit is 5x more eccentric than Pluto's and it take about 11,400 years to complete it just once.
Sedna sounds worthless
"The Goblin" has that kind of orbit, but worse
@@NikodAnimations You mean 2015Tg87 Ans the furthest object from the sun is 2014fe72 it takes about 92,000 years to orbit the sun. And is 3050Au from the sun at aphelion..
@@xiangliuthefox3071 "The Goblin" is a nickname for a dwarf planet
@@NikodAnimations I know since they're running out of gods to name planet's and dwarf planet's..
THE FUCK DID I DO
Go away from this solar system
Not clear your orbit
@@Sky5Gamer99no you should go away
Pluto, no matter how people disrespect you... I'll still love you!
@@Sky5Gamer99nah you go away to hell
“Dwarf people are people. Dwarf planets are planets. End of argument.”
the difference is is that dwarf planet SUCK compared to actual planets and you can't really make that argument about dwarf people
@@Mister_Sun.Actually some are at perfect sucking height 😈
@@Mister_Sun. yes you can
@@Mister_Sun.Yes you can and thats a terrible argument
@@newhybrid101 so is the original comment
I used to think those red spots were blood, that shit made pluto sooo interesting for me 💀💀
This is the best start to a channel I've ever seen, can't believe you made it to the top 0.5 percentile in just 2 months. Can't wait to see what you upload next.
Plutos still a planet in my heart :(
Ur stupid then
Poor pluto...
womp womp
Gone but not forgotten
@@mostlime12195 pluto is a damn planet, these people have just lost their minds.
i wonder what clyde's reaction would be to see the planet he discovered no longer be a planet
It wouldn’t be good, that’s for sure.
i heard that clyde's family made a protest that pluto is a planet
@@SuperGibaLogan They did, and hundreds of planetary scientists did too.
That message at the end is too easy, give me something harder like darkening the image a lot so I have to take it into Photoshop and brighten it, and the words are actually put through some kind of cipher, while also being converted into hex code, which is actually a hex code of binary code, which represents an audio wav file of your voice saying the message, reversed, and sped up a lot. I think that might make it harder.
wow, i thought there was no way to make it harder than one frame. but you my friend, just opened my eyes. good luck on the next one ;)
Haumea does have enough gravity to be a sphere it just spins way too fast
Nasa, your mom thought I was big enough.
-pluto
About that orbit, have you seen Sedna’s? Also, Haumea *does* have enough gravity to pull itself into a sphere, it’s just spinning so fast that it’s being stretched into that shape.
So what I get is that Pluto wasn't a planet anymore only because of the sake of kids🤦
Bro's having beef with a planet ☠️
Dwarf ******🤓
He'll be attacking the 41 others.
and won
ok but i want the 100s of planets just to mess with the children
be disaponted. the end, i reddit in 0.1x sped
what i learn from solarball: Pluto is from the Kuiper belt and the reason why pluto was out of the kuiper belt cause of neptune's gravity but pluto had a moon like their size getting them out from neptune
solarballs fan in the wild ‼️
@@Dione_me YOOOO
The second rule says that it has to have enough gravity To keep its shape. So that doesn’t mean it has to be a sphere. Else earth isn’t a planet as well since it isn’t perfectly round
Look up “Planetary Mass Object”.
That should be our only definition.
The inclusion of orbit into the definition of “planet” is a hard step backwards.
thank you.
The geophysical planet definition states any planetary-mass object is a planet. Indeed, using orbit to define a planet is ridiculous and inconsistent.
👏
POST FAST 💀💀I FINISHED ALL THE VIDEOS 💀💀 I NEED MORE 💀💀 I'M ADDICTED 💀💀
Not cool bro, stop bullying my boy Pluto :(
It should be noted that the IAU's new definition of what makes a planet is pretty dumb, for example anything that orbits a different star than our sun can't be a planet. A new new definition is needed for sure. Maybe that would include Pluto, but I doubt it.
The geophysical planet definition is superior.
You want kids to suffer in school by having to learn over 100 planets?
@@NikodAnimations Why would they suffer? Who says they have to memorize them?
Any planet that orbits a star other than the sun is called an Exoplanet. Exoplanet is the term for a planet that orbits a star other than the sun.
@@PlanetGuy901 But they’re not planets under the IAU’s definition.
3:09 funniest moment I’ve ever seen
bro does NOT like pluto 😭🙏
i agree but no need to dis my guy Pluto like that 😢
haumea actually does have enough gravity to form a sphere. it just spins so unbelievably fast for a planet that its equator bulges extremely, making it look very oblate
One thing you failed to mention, is that plutos discovery was through unimaginable luck. It was nowhere near large enough to produced the observed effect on neptune, and as it turns out, thanks to Voyager 2 we found out neptunes mass was 0.5% less then previously calculated, which as it turns out is just enough of a difference to explain what we thought was another object pulling on it. So not only did the planet they were searching for not exist, and as such the flawed calculations were entirely pointless, but by through some divine stroke of luck, a speck of dust happened to be in the night sky at the time, which we would name pluto.
A fascinating what-if, is what if Eris had been seen when closer to Earth. Its orbit too is elliptic - but it was found returning from the FAR point (which had been reached 1977). Eris is also inherently brighter than Pluto, not having all those dark red tholins on its surface.
Perihelion 37.7 AU was passed at 1699. The 13" astrograph was assembled at Flagstaff around 1930. But this sort of astrograph was not top-of-the-line; they could do that in 1887.
So much of the information in this video is false
How so?
@@nikivalx Well, just for starters, Haumea DOES have enough gravity to be a sphere, it just spins really fast so it looks misshapen. Look at Saturn, it spins fast, just not as fast as Haumea. Saturn is also flattened a bit. And Pluto is like, the coolest object ever. It's objectively awesome. It literally has an ocean of LIQUID WATER underneath the ice. It is geologically active. It's moon. Charon, has a deposit of organic molecules on it, called MORDOR.
Pluto will always be cool in our hearts
1:38 Haumea spins to fast lioe 3.9 hours to fast and Sad part is MakeMake slightly smaller is a sphere.
Tiramisu dwarf
some would describe it that way
heart decoration on top