I think subconsciously Lucas wanted Peyton to feel the hurt she did to him by not accepting his proposal so he kept rejecting her and wanting to prove he could move on and that she couldnt affect his future happiness. Everyone was telling him he was still in love with Peyton and he was like wanting to prove he wasnt. But everytime she spilled her heart to him he was like on the verge of breaking down and telling her he still was in love with her. He told her he hated her because she didnt stay away and with her moving so close and then telling him she still loved him it drove him crazy and blew up his new happy life with Lindsay. He didnt hate her he hated the fact she could still affect him the way she always did. I think this is very realistic because most people cant get that first true love out of their mind especially if they have a chance at rekindling it or making it permanent. This is a great scene and i could always feel the regret in their lines and the fact they were apart but shouldnt be as the love was still there. They always had that deep connect no matter who else came between them. I think their scenes together were always so subtly passionate and sad as they were both so unhappy apart. Lucas and Brooke were always fighting because he never made her feel totally loved and that he would step up for her. WIth Peyton he knew she had this hold on him that he could never cut off. And she couldnt give her herself totally to anyone but him. Thats why my friends they ended up together for life. They always seemed to me so perfect together whenever they had a scene. Like when he gives her that chocolate bar and a hug and tells her all will be fine. You cant fake that look they have. No hot tubs needed. Subtle and deep.
It’s 2020 and I still ship Leyton more than any other TV couple. The chemistry. The love. You can see it in the way that they look at each other. I don’t think any other couple on the show looks at each other the way these two do. It really is like they look into each other’s souls every time they lock eyes. ❤️
These two were amazing but also on this UK TV show bad girls, Nikki and Helen (one of the first ever lesbian storylines to air back in 1999) they looked at eachother intense, just like these two used to. Also Ross/Rachel in Friends and X files Mulder/Scully aswell
"It's just a dream right?" It's my dream" OMG i miss them SO much. Forget clay and Quin you can NEVER replace Lucas and Peyton. True Love Always Leyton 4ever
I love how they try and make it seem like it's some big choice he has to make after this scene between Peyton, Lindsey, and Brooke. I mean, bish please. Lucas & Peyton = True Love always.
The way Peyton says "I know" at 1:02 in that soft whisper and her expression just breaks my heart. It seems like she was just hurting so much that she could barely speak.
He loved Brooke and Lindsey but he could never give them his full heart because a part of it always belonged to Peyton. Peyton was the only one he could fully love.
This scene might be a little underrated. I mean this is the first time in this season Lucas is actually kind of honest about his feelings towards Peyton. He was always afraid of beeing hurt again but then Peyton said, that she has this dream of accepting his proposal. That tells him that he won't be rejected anymore by Peyton and because of that he takes action wants to go to Vegas with her and marry her finally. He wants her to be his wife and that as soon as possible because he still is afraid to loose her again. I love them so much #leyton
i really like this two...i didnt watch season 2 cause lucas and payton were nothing...but whan i watched season 4 i rushed and watched what ive missed...these two are what made one tree hill...these two ARE tree hill
@@sallycoach6238 not really...i think even if she'd accepted and had a long engagement, he wouldn't have been satisfied and seen it as 'someday'. he seemed to think proposing was gonna fix their relationship problems at the time (i.e distance, lack of communication).
@@lunalove9395 I mean they were what? 19/20 when he proposed? Someday is someday really is someday when you are still a teenager. Peyton isn't wrong for being freaked out, and saying this wasn't the right time. Lucas was being ridiculous most likely because he too is a goddamn teenager.
I don't get why people hated season 5. Seriously, one of the best seasons. Maybe it's just because I love angst between couples but yeah most of leytons best scenes were in this season. Season 5 made me ship them more than Nathan and Haley.
Season 5 was definitely one of the best seasons of OTH. Easily the best finale, I remember flipping out after Lucas made the call but I knew it was Peyton!
I only liked the leyton scenes in season 5. Besides that the season was boring and kind of annoying. But yeah the leyton scenes were beautiful! That's the only good thing I took from this season.
Awesome Guy That's true but season 3 didn't have an writers strike to contend with S5 like did. Post wedding episodes definitely would have been about LP rebuilding if it wasn't for the strike and it would have an decent build since we would have gotten 10 episodes instead of the 6 we actually got. But admittedly the LL storyline was still really stupid and I didn't see the point of putting putting another third party between LP when it would have been better for both characters if they worked their way to back together without any third parties in the picture.
Totally agree with this. Season 5 LP was amazinggg. Nobody does angst the way they do. While they’re ALWAYS great, I’d take angsty season 5 LP over fluffy season 4 or 6 LP any day. ❤️
Lucas and brooke were always a very young love, Peyton and Lucas always found their way back to each other and it made their love strong and able to last through all of the obsticles
Sarah Kaiser Brooke never loved him. Point blank lol season 4 she said "I gave him to you Peyton and I can take him back whenever I want" she never loved him.
Hil has been fantastic not only in this scene but in all of this season. Actually she is fantastic in all the seasons she's been in! I love her!!! Peyton totally stole this scene with her last line, "Its My Dream". It breaks my heart every time. lol L&P = TLA Bring on Leyton in S6. Wooohoooo!!!!! =D =D
For Lucas it was hard letting Peyton go to LA to pursue her dream, and when Peyton didn't show up at the book signing it was hard for Lucas to lose her. But after 3 years Peyton shows up, and it hard for Lucas to see her because he attempting to move on and he obviously still loves her. They both miss each other and both are clearly sad and miserable. Ugh angst at its best amazing actors.n
I didn’t watch OTH until season 5. My friend told me I could watch from season 5 on since the show was fast forwarding and it would be fine. So I went in blind and from the moment they shared their first awkward conversation on the river court I felt so bad for Peyton and knew there was history and pain there. I got the flu a few weeks later and my roommate had the first four seasons on dvd and I binged them all and got caught up by episode 5 of season 5 and I was a diehard Peyton and Leyton fan from that point forward.
Never thought before that Peyton is pretty until this scene when she says "it's MY dream!" like she's saying much more than she really is! And I'm not a leyton fan, but this is a great scene!
I wasn't a fan of the first half of season 5 because it just didn't seem the same as the first 4 seasons, and after season 6, it didn't feel the same at all. They were still good season but just seemed like a different show, without these two it wasn't One Tree Hill, because the cast for the first few seasons will always be more than a cast but the show. Brooke, Peyton, Lucas, Nathan and Haley.
This scene is so realistic and the way lucas say it was hard letting you go and see you again show all the pain he has been in I feel so sad for him payton actually had really hurt him
Geo JAB Agreed. OTH was one of a kind for me...The way the characters interact and the evolution in the relationships always moved me. Specially Nathan. Take care.
I watched this scene over and over and from the way they both were talking(and the rivercourt drawing!)they both sound likek they are saying goodbye! Nooooooooooooooooooo! I really want leyton back!!! :D
I think Brucas fan lie when they say there's no love in lucas's eyes!They know the truth:that is Lucas always loved peyton(yes he had a crush for brooke but nothing more)From the beginning IT WAS ALWAYS BE LUCAS AND PEYTON!And everyone knows it..brucas is over and I'm really HAPPY!I know that True Love wins in the end..LP=ENDGAME!!!
I don't think that the fact than Leyton is'nt in the show anymore ruins it. But Leyton would be in our hearts for the rest of our lives. It's like a model of love ♥. Only One Tree Hill !
The only time I did see Brucas was when they were together season 2-3 and even during that time I hoped that Lucas would come to his sences and get together with Peyton...
Everyone should stop fighting about bloody Brucas vs Leyton This is a beautiful scene and its being ruined by ridiculous comments from jealous, bitter people. Pull your heads out your asses and realise this is a TV SHOW!! And we all love it but let's just agree to disagree Stop commenting on a Leyton scene how horrible Peyton is, because she isn't!! Anyway LP FTW! Loove this scene :D
I basically hated lucas in season 5. Treating peyton that way. He was so mean to her.sometimes I wondered if he still loves her because he was so persistent that he loved lindsay.But I guess I get it, Peyton really hurt him when she said no to his proposal because he loved her so much..so, hes just scared to accept peyton back in his life because he didnt want to get hurt again. Still, I just hated how the break up was so easy though.
I agree but season 5 requires a lot of reading between the lines. In the first scene of season 5 you see Lucas on the river court and you can see how unhappy he is with his life saying "sometimes it feels like someone else's memory". He wouldn't have said that if he and Peyton were still together. Also it's been years and he still couldn't write a second book. Then when Peyton returns he finally has the inspiration to write a second book and it was all about his love for her and how he was willing to wait his entire life for her to return to him. That's what his heart was telling him. His head was telling him stay with Lindsey because there's nothing wrong with her and Peyton already hurt him. So that's what season 5 was pretty much all about, Lucas's heart vs. Lucas's head. At the end of season 5 he finally listened to his heart and chose Peyton.
He acted like a bit of a dick, but it was also understandable, and very human. Rightly or wrongly, he misinterpreted Peyton's rejection of his proposal as a rejection of him. To have finally moved past that, to have settled into a life with someone else that he cares about (enough to be contemplating marriage), thinking you're never going to see that person that hurt you again... only for her to show up in one of his most memorable childhood haunts, looking to pick-up where they left off? He was angry. This was the love of his life, and it seemed like he was only an option when it was convenient, and now his whole world is crashing down because OF COURSE he wants her, but he's too proud to admit it after she hurt him, and he wants to be the honourable guy and stand by Lindsay. Love is hard, and sometimes it brings out the worst in us.
Greeneyelove but if you really think about it, those are responsible qualities. No one wants to think of dan as responsible because he was the villain but he did the right thing in that the SECOND PERSON he knocked up, he married. That’s honorable, even if he loved karen the whole time. I really wish they never had dan kill Keith because I always felt like dan was just a teenager who screwed up and deserved a second chance with karen. It’s really sad to see Lucas didn’t realize how much he was his fathers son and LINDSEY had to be the one to call off the wedding, instead of Lucas doing what was right.
Last episode he really was transferring the way he felt she broke his heart more than the I said I do she didn't what he kept repeating because he sure wasn't jumping up and down that Lindsay had not moved on. I loved this scene because the directing felt like a s1 scene with the inter-lay of her face as he talked, vice versa. He was finally honest to himself.
omg I freaking love one tree hill! haven't watched it since there was no lucas and peyton - chad michael murray is what got me hooked. but i love the old episodes so much! Lucas and Peyton are the cutest. couple. ever.
if he really loved he would have waited for her, because she said SOMEDAY, she didn't say no. i don't really understand lucas sometimes. SPOILER! Peyton: You do not just ask someone to marry them over the phone. Lucas: Then why did you come? (Kissing) Peyton: Because you're a mess, Lucas Scott, but you're my mess and I love you. Lucas: I love you too. (Kissing)
God. I sat there and cried my eyes out. Is there a single person out there who has not been changed or saved or touched by this show? By these people? It's okay...it's...okay.
I don't why person are hating Lucas in season 5 , saying they hate him for how he treated Peyton . What do you expect him to do - break up with Lindsey just because Peyton came back . And then he was left at the altar . He was hurting . He was hurt when Peyton said someday . So he picked up the pieces and moved on and never expected to see her again and never expected her to return to tree hill because she herself said that there were too many bad memories for her in tree hill. And she wanted to move on from that with her new life in LA .
I think it was because of how he treated the situation. He kissed Peyton (even though she kissed him first - he kissed her back), and then proposed to Lindsey and planned a quick wedding immediately after. Not only did that hurt Peyton, but it was also unfair to Lindsey as you know he was never going to tell her about the kiss. Had she not figured out the whole comet thing, he would've carried on with it.
Nooo!He still loves her!Look at him when he talk to her..he's soo afraid!He was really hurts when she's gone..but I know they will get together.This scene was amazing!They have stolen my heart! :(
@protectit2 I did the same.... when season 6 endeed, One Tree Hill ended for me... they are the best I hope they come back for S9, if they do, I´ll watch season 7 and 8
Aww :) This is why I think he called Peyton, now. Because he knows that she'd say yes. Michaela's done so I don't even really think that Lindsay's an option (my guess is that he never gets her call). And Brooke wouldn't make sense because you don't call up your friend and ask them to marry you.
I think subconsciously Lucas wanted Peyton to feel the hurt she did to him by not accepting his proposal so he kept rejecting her and wanting to prove he could move on and that she couldnt affect his future happiness. Everyone was telling him he was still in love with Peyton and he was like wanting to prove he wasnt. But everytime she spilled her heart to him he was like on the verge of breaking down and telling her he still was in love with her. He told her he hated her because she didnt stay away and with her moving so close and then telling him she still loved him it drove him crazy and blew up his new happy life with Lindsay. He didnt hate her he hated the fact she could still affect him the way she always did. I think this is very realistic because most people cant get that first true love out of their mind especially if they have a chance at rekindling it or making it permanent. This is a great scene and i could always feel the regret in their lines and the fact they were apart but shouldnt be as the love was still there. They always had that deep connect no matter who else came between them. I think their scenes together were always so subtly passionate and sad as they were both so unhappy apart. Lucas and Brooke were always fighting because he never made her feel totally loved and that he would step up for her. WIth Peyton he knew she had this hold on him that he could never cut off. And she couldnt give her herself totally to anyone but him. Thats why my friends they ended up together for life. They always seemed to me so perfect together whenever they had a scene. Like when he gives her that chocolate bar and a hug and tells her all will be fine. You cant fake that look they have. No hot tubs needed. Subtle and deep.
Jeri Lane EXACTLY. Well said indeed.
Been in this situation before. And that is exactly what it is.
So well said, and so true!
Jeri Lane thank you for this
so true kudos
It’s 2020 and I still ship Leyton more than any other TV couple. The chemistry. The love. You can see it in the way that they look at each other. I don’t think any other couple on the show looks at each other the way these two do. It really is like they look into each other’s souls every time they lock eyes. ❤️
All American (Olivia and Spencer)
@@estheodetola5782 I actually agree with this! I think Olivia and Spencer are on the same level. I love them.
Nahhhhhh, they were great for sure but CHUCK AND BLAIR HAD THE BEST TV CHEMISTRY AND RELATIONSHIP LOL
Joey and Pacey( Dawson Creek), Doug and Carol (ER)... but definitely not many other couples
These two were amazing but also on this UK TV show bad girls, Nikki and Helen (one of the first ever lesbian storylines to air back in 1999) they looked at eachother intense, just like these two used to. Also Ross/Rachel in Friends and X files Mulder/Scully aswell
'its my dream'.. get me everytime
Yep, every damn time. Hilarie's acting just sucks you in.. She really hits you hard with how she delivers her lines.
How about the its hard losing u, its hard seeing u again
Me too
"It's just a dream right?"
It's my dream"
OMG i miss them SO much.
Forget clay and Quin you can NEVER replace Lucas and Peyton.
True Love Always
Leyton 4ever
I love how they try and make it seem like it's some big choice he has to make after this scene between Peyton, Lindsey, and Brooke. I mean, bish please. Lucas & Peyton = True Love always.
Such a damn good scene. This was the last season I connected to. I was never a Leyton fan but the writing in the 5th season sold me.
The way Peyton says "I know" at 1:02 in that soft whisper and her expression just breaks my heart. It seems like she was just hurting so much that she could barely speak.
"But it's my dream." FAVORITEEEEEE SCENEEEEEEEEE!
He loved Brooke and Lindsey but he could never give them his full heart because a part of it always belonged to Peyton. Peyton was the only one he could fully love.
This scene might be a little underrated. I mean this is the first time in this season Lucas is actually kind of honest about his feelings towards Peyton. He was always afraid of beeing hurt again but then Peyton said, that she has this dream of accepting his proposal. That tells him that he won't be rejected anymore by Peyton and because of that he takes action wants to go to Vegas with her and marry her finally. He wants her to be his wife and that as soon as possible because he still is afraid to loose her again.
I love them so much
#leyton
It still makes me cry everytime she says "it's my dream"
i really like this two...i didnt watch season 2 cause lucas and payton were nothing...but whan i watched season 4 i rushed and watched what ive missed...these two are what made one tree hill...these two ARE tree hill
hilarie burton did so well in this season... Really amazing
They were my favorite characters on One Tree Hill.
She didn't say no... She said Someday... But Lucas didn't hear that.... He heard No...
Someday usually means no.
@@sallycoach6238 no it doesn’t. No means no.
@@sallycoach6238 not really...i think even if she'd accepted and had a long engagement, he wouldn't have been satisfied and seen it as 'someday'. he seemed to think proposing was gonna fix their relationship problems at the time (i.e distance, lack of communication).
@@lunalove9395 I mean they were what? 19/20 when he proposed? Someday is someday really is someday when you are still a teenager. Peyton isn't wrong for being freaked out, and saying this wasn't the right time. Lucas was being ridiculous most likely because he too is a goddamn teenager.
@@sallycoach6238 Not when they have just graduated high school... That's what most 18-year-olds would say, even if they think it's their soulmate.
I love this scene. when she says "Its my dream" and the tears in her eyes is awsome.
‘I know’ and ‘ its my dream’ get me every damn time
One of my fav scenes....i cry everytime :(
fuck, i miss them so bad!! shit..my life sucks without OTH early seasons :(
I don't get why people hated season 5. Seriously, one of the best seasons. Maybe it's just because I love angst between couples but yeah most of leytons best scenes were in this season. Season 5 made me ship them more than Nathan and Haley.
Season 5 was definitely one of the best seasons of OTH. Easily the best finale, I remember flipping out after Lucas made the call but I knew it was Peyton!
I only liked the leyton scenes in season 5. Besides that the season was boring and kind of annoying. But yeah the leyton scenes were beautiful! That's the only good thing I took from this season.
Yasss💝
Awesome Guy That's true but season 3 didn't have an writers strike to contend with S5 like did. Post wedding episodes definitely would have been about LP rebuilding if it wasn't for the strike and it would have an decent build since we would have gotten 10 episodes instead of the 6 we actually got. But admittedly the LL storyline was still really stupid and I didn't see the point of putting putting another third party between LP when it would have been better for both characters if they worked their way to back together without any third parties in the picture.
Totally agree with this. Season 5 LP was amazinggg. Nobody does angst the way they do. While they’re ALWAYS great, I’d take angsty season 5 LP over fluffy season 4 or 6 LP any day. ❤️
I was so set on team Brucas until season 5. Peyton just loved Lucas way more than Brooke ever did.
Lucas and brooke were always a very young love, Peyton and Lucas always found their way back to each other and it made their love strong and able to last through all of the obsticles
g
Sarah Kaiser Brooke never loved him. Point blank lol season 4 she said "I gave him to you Peyton and I can take him back whenever I want" she never loved him.
@@AmarieWright hahaha she loved him...but she deserves better than lucas ...so she sacrifised him for her friend
UhM I’m team bruliAn all thE waYy
And he made her dream come true! (In one way or another) OTP af
Hil has been fantastic not only in this scene but in all of this season. Actually she is fantastic in all the seasons she's been in! I love her!!!
Peyton totally stole this scene with her last line, "Its My Dream". It breaks my heart every time. lol
L&P = TLA
Bring on Leyton in S6. Wooohoooo!!!!! =D =D
“Hard seeing you again and still is.”
such a great actors in this cast! hilary and chad are just breathtaking
Ughh, the emotions in this though 😭😭
wow. the first time i watched this on tv, it made me cry. and it still does, every time. I love them so much, they just belong together.
Everytime she says "It's my dream" I feel like aaw, c'mon Lucas! *-*
For Lucas it was hard letting Peyton go to LA to pursue her dream, and when Peyton didn't show up at the book signing it was hard for Lucas to lose her. But after 3 years Peyton shows up, and it hard for Lucas to see her because he attempting to move on and he obviously still loves her. They both miss each other and both are clearly sad and miserable. Ugh angst at its best amazing actors.n
we need Peyton back I was so happy when he choose her, they were always meant for each other everything else was just the road to them getting there.
After he talks about how hurt it was to see her, her little "I know" is so sad because that is exactly how she feels.
I didn’t watch OTH until season 5. My friend told me I could watch from season 5 on since the show was fast forwarding and it would be fine. So I went in blind and from the moment they shared their first awkward conversation on the river court I felt so bad for Peyton and knew there was history and pain there. I got the flu a few weeks later and my roommate had the first four seasons on dvd and I binged them all and got caught up by episode 5 of season 5 and I was a diehard Peyton and Leyton fan from that point forward.
Beautiful scene!!!!!!!!!LP has beautiful chemistry...he doesnt hate her, but hes too afraid to tell he that he loves her...Im so rooting for LP...
God! He still Loves her! That much is obvious!
LP FTW!!!!
"ITS OUR DREAM !"
One Tree Hill can never get back to when Peyton and Lucas were together. I don't even watch it anymore because they're not in it.
god i love that one line.
"its my dream."
=D
im so happy he picks her!
leyton fan all the way!!!!
I love this moment in Season 5. I'm going to miss Leyton in Season 7. Chad & Hilarie are great actors.
I love them together. their scenes make my heart melt
God, the way he looks at her.. is just breathtaking..
this is such a beautiful show, it changed my perspective on life & love .
One Tree Hill saved my soul
Never thought before that Peyton is pretty until this scene when she says "it's MY dream!" like she's saying much more than she really is! And I'm not a leyton fan, but this is a great scene!
I wasn't a fan of the first half of season 5 because it just didn't seem the same as the first 4 seasons, and after season 6, it didn't feel the same at all. They were still good season but just seemed like a different show, without these two it wasn't One Tree Hill, because the cast for the first few seasons will always be more than a cast but the show. Brooke, Peyton, Lucas, Nathan and Haley.
Summer Raine ikr i hated lucas and lindsay
Lindsey was the most annoying character of the show. A whole season wasted on a rebound when it’s obvious that Lucas & Peyton were endgame.
Couldnt agree more
i miss peyton and lucas so much! one tree hill just wasnt the same without them
tangled mes-s-y ha-ir...
gotta love the way lucas says it to her
This scene is so realistic and the way lucas say it was hard letting you go and see you again show all the pain he has been in I feel so sad for him payton actually had really hurt him
i miss Lucas and Peyton!!
i wish we could've seen more of them as a married couple and parents, and more of baby Sawyer!!
oh I remember when he got his phone out in the airport... I was begging for it to be Peyton!
Lucas always looks like he was about to cry xD!!!!
+hanakun he always cried everytime they had their private conversations that season shows how much it still hurt not having her
Geo JAB Agreed. OTH was one of a kind for me...The way the characters interact and the evolution in the relationships always moved me.
Specially Nathan.
Take care.
This scene is just amazing!
Me either. It's my dream. I cry every time she says it.
I watched this scene over and over and from the way they both were talking(and the rivercourt drawing!)they both sound likek they are saying goodbye!
Nooooooooooooooooooo! I really want leyton back!!!
:D
it HAS to be Peyton!!! They belong together!!!
Lucas’ face after she says ‘it’s my dream’ like ‘you would still take me back?’.
I think Brucas fan lie when they say there's no love in lucas's eyes!They know the truth:that is Lucas always loved peyton(yes he had a crush for brooke but nothing more)From the beginning IT WAS ALWAYS BE LUCAS AND PEYTON!And everyone knows it..brucas is over and I'm really HAPPY!I know that True Love wins in the end..LP=ENDGAME!!!
Oh it broke my lil heart man.
OMG I'm crying :(
God they love each other so much!!
"It's my dream."
Ughhhh I love them.
I don't think that the fact than Leyton is'nt in the show anymore ruins it. But Leyton would be in our hearts for the rest of our lives. It's like a model of love ♥. Only One Tree Hill !
The only time I did see Brucas was when they were together season 2-3 and even during that time I hoped that Lucas would come to his sences and get together with Peyton...
To all those lost souls who have forgotten to believe in the immensity of love 16.05.2019
one of my faves, honestly
@@kitpunzalan1542
Hope you've found it ..
i love when peyton said " It's my dream"
"it's my dream" for Leyton to be together!
you can telll how much he still is in love with her
Its still breakes my heart :(
I cannot watch this clip without tearing up...lucas loves peyton, and peyton loves lucas END OF STORY!! Leyton forever!
Love how they go into Bethany’s feel this song. Perfect representation of this scene
Magic.
its my dream, reminds me of when they're at the airport and she says something simmilar: you're a mess lucas scott,but you're myy mess
i love leyton
i absoutly love this scene! :)
So romantic :)
Its Our Dream!!! Leyton FTW!!!!!
Everyone should stop fighting about bloody Brucas vs Leyton
This is a beautiful scene and its being ruined by ridiculous comments from jealous, bitter people.
Pull your heads out your asses and realise this is a TV SHOW!!
And we all love it but let's just agree to disagree
Stop commenting on a Leyton scene how horrible Peyton is, because she isn't!!
Anyway LP FTW! Loove this scene :D
I basically hated lucas in season 5. Treating peyton that way. He was so mean to her.sometimes I wondered if he still loves her because he was so persistent that he loved lindsay.But I guess I get it, Peyton really hurt him when she said no to his proposal because he loved her so much..so, hes just scared to accept peyton back in his life because he didnt want to get hurt again. Still, I just hated how the break up was so easy though.
I agree but season 5 requires a lot of reading between the lines. In the first scene of season 5 you see Lucas on the river court and you can see how unhappy he is with his life saying "sometimes it feels like someone else's memory". He wouldn't have said that if he and Peyton were still together. Also it's been years and he still couldn't write a second book. Then when Peyton returns he finally has the inspiration to write a second book and it was all about his love for her and how he was willing to wait his entire life for her to return to him. That's what his heart was telling him. His head was telling him stay with Lindsey because there's nothing wrong with her and Peyton already hurt him. So that's what season 5 was pretty much all about, Lucas's heart vs. Lucas's head. At the end of season 5 he finally listened to his heart and chose Peyton.
THat's not fair. Most people date a few people before finding the one.
He acted like a bit of a dick, but it was also understandable, and very human. Rightly or wrongly, he misinterpreted Peyton's rejection of his proposal as a rejection of him. To have finally moved past that, to have settled into a life with someone else that he cares about (enough to be contemplating marriage), thinking you're never going to see that person that hurt you again... only for her to show up in one of his most memorable childhood haunts, looking to pick-up where they left off? He was angry. This was the love of his life, and it seemed like he was only an option when it was convenient, and now his whole world is crashing down because OF COURSE he wants her, but he's too proud to admit it after she hurt him, and he wants to be the honourable guy and stand by Lindsay. Love is hard, and sometimes it brings out the worst in us.
Greeneyelove but if you really think about it, those are responsible qualities. No one wants to think of dan as responsible because he was the villain but he did the right thing in that the SECOND PERSON he knocked up, he married. That’s honorable, even if he loved karen the whole time. I really wish they never had dan kill Keith because I always felt like dan was just a teenager who screwed up and deserved a second chance with karen. It’s really sad to see Lucas didn’t realize how much he was his fathers son and LINDSEY had to be the one to call off the wedding, instead of Lucas doing what was right.
Last episode he really was transferring the way he felt she broke his heart more than the I said I do she didn't what he kept repeating because he sure wasn't jumping up and down that Lindsay had not moved on.
I loved this scene because the directing felt like a s1 scene with the inter-lay of her face as he talked, vice versa. He was finally honest to himself.
Hilarie looks so gorgeous in this scene!
When LP get back together in s6 they'd best just stay together!
omg I freaking love one tree hill! haven't watched it since there was no lucas and peyton - chad michael murray is what got me hooked. but i love the old episodes so much! Lucas and Peyton are the cutest. couple. ever.
Leyton and MerDer are the greatest TV couples ever!
if he really loved he would have waited for her, because she said SOMEDAY, she didn't say no. i don't really understand lucas sometimes.
SPOILER!
Peyton: You do not just ask someone to marry them over the phone.
Lucas: Then why did you come? (Kissing)
Peyton: Because you're a mess, Lucas Scott, but you're my mess and I love you.
Lucas: I love you too.
(Kissing)
bellissimoooo!!
yeah she does!!
God. I sat there and cried my eyes out. Is there a single person out there who has not been changed or saved or touched by this show? By these people? It's okay...it's...okay.
2018 y no supero esta escena 💔
AWWW
i love.
No this is the song after!I mean the song of this scene,whene LP talk! Anyway thank you..I like that too! :D
I don't why person are hating Lucas in season 5 , saying they hate him for how he treated Peyton . What do you expect him to do - break up with Lindsey just because Peyton came back . And then he was left at the altar . He was hurting . He was hurt when Peyton said someday . So he picked up the pieces and moved on and never expected to see her again and never expected her to return to tree hill because she herself said that there were too many bad memories for her in tree hill. And she wanted to move on from that with her new life in LA .
I think it was because of how he treated the situation. He kissed Peyton (even though she kissed him first - he kissed her back), and then proposed to Lindsey and planned a quick wedding immediately after. Not only did that hurt Peyton, but it was also unfair to Lindsey as you know he was never going to tell her about the kiss. Had she not figured out the whole comet thing, he would've carried on with it.
IT'S OUR DREAM LUCAS!!!!
I hated the way Lucas treated peyton this season.,
I finished watching season 6 yesterday and woke up only to find out no layton.....so I rewatched season 6 and ended OTH with a happy ending
Right after Peyton says "Its my dream", Lucas looks at her and you can tell he's thinking "Shes the one"
Nice video .
It was hard letting you go...it was hard losing you and it was hard seeing you again...and it's still..really hard..
Nooo!He still loves her!Look at him when he talk to her..he's soo afraid!He was really hurts when she's gone..but I know they will get together.This scene was amazing!They have stolen my heart! :(
Awk (: When he says the whole, "It's still really hard." bit, it just makes me sad.
Thank you very much! :)
i love them more apart. it seems that they thrive on being apart, they play so much more beliveble when they have to fight for each other.
It must be Peyton because it started with them and it should end with them, Lucas and Peyton together, forever...
@protectit2 I did the same.... when season 6 endeed, One Tree Hill ended for me... they are the best
I hope they come back for S9, if they do, I´ll watch season 7 and 8
thanks so much XD
Aww :) This is why I think he called Peyton, now. Because he knows that she'd say yes.
Michaela's done so I don't even really think that Lindsay's an option (my guess is that he never gets her call). And Brooke wouldn't make sense because you don't call up your friend and ask them to marry you.