@@HosCreates Not working women, but there was an incident where two high society women (A duchess and countess?) Got into an argument and decided to duel. Then someone suggested that they duel topless to not only to avoid ripping their clothes, but so the torn shreds don't infect any wounds. I believe this set off a trend of painting dueling topless ladies.
"Once again, bigoted art trying to take a dig at masc women and gender nonconforming people backfires and ends up making them look fucking badass..." I adore you, Kaz.
As they're reading the whole list I'm giggling at the idea of Victorian women just throwing their "Wright around" and the men being like 🥴 guess we need to set some "boundaries." 😂 stfu and FEEL HER MUSCLE AND GOSSIP ABOUT OTHER PEOPLES LEGS WITH HER haha
Guy: "Ladies belong to a sex which for centuries has not been accustomed to exercise in the open air" Women who've been working in agriculture for generations: "Am I a joke to you?"
Worrying about the effects of bicycle seats on women's anatomy is funny to me, because of the two sexes I'm pretty sure men's anatomy is far more likely to be damaged.
I've always wondered how that worked. Like does it not, eh, squish things? And I see someone mentioned horseback riding too... imagine you're just chilling in a pasture, eating some fine grass, trying to hook up with that new appaloosa mare, (you have a thing for spots) and then all of a sudden a dude jumps on you and now his stuff is bouncing on your back 😆 🤣
I support a woman's right to be the 'angry, macho angel of the house.' But actually yes, it's pretty amazing that you made that in two days. Kaz got mad skills 😎
It's so nice to hear about the history of women in fencing. When I fenced in college they never talked about this, only about how fencing came about when fancy men didn't know how to use their rapiers do during drunken duels, no one won and both participants died of infection lol
Same! I fenced from middle school through college and I rarely ever heard about fencing’s history. I honestly never heard about women only being allowed to fence saber in the year 2000. That might actually help to explain why there so few women’s saberists.
I'm nearly 60 and fence with females from teens to my vintage) some are at national level (Spain). We learn from each other, fencers commenting here knows the importance of footwork which I learnt from the most part from female fencers. For the females, as I'm larg-ish and fence at a slower pace, they become more aware of distance and have to be more aware of patience, using psychology...We are learning, having fun and getting medals 😃🤺🤺🤺🤺
It’s insane that this historical context for the XIX century was never explained and detailed on ANY of the many clases I took at uni for psychoanalysis. We spend plenty of time talking about the therapy (torture) used / inflicted by men like Breuer and Freud to their female patients that were “hysteric”, but not one second talking about how gender speciations and patriarchy can destroy your life.
“I wonder why all this women are so hysterical Breuer” “I don’t really care Freud, let’s force them to masturbate and take pictures while they are at it”
It's unfortunately super common in history, too. Students are taught an overview of top-down events; wars fought, laws passed, and the people at the very top of the government. But this information is rarely contextualized by social norms, living conditions, and economic pressures.
That story about receiving a porcelain bowl instead of a gold medal reminds me of a childhood insult: Our basketball team participated in the boys' tournament in the early 2000s, because we were far ahead of teams in our own division at the time. We ended up winning all but the final match, but instead of receiving the silver medal we were awarded gold medals for "the best girls' team in the tournament". We were the only girls' team in the tournament... Sure, the intentions were probably good, perhaps they had an idea of having this ready in case we lost to the Obviously Superior Boys and would thus have our Feminine Feelings hurt (I mean, what if a girl began crying? Utter chaos!), and wanted to have a consolation prize ready or something: But it would've served them- and us - better to just pretend it didn't exist once we fought our way to the finals. I remember being upset despite not really understanding why (oh, the naivety of youth!), but even more clearly I remember my mom being absolutely livid which was a rare occurence indeed. I still go back to that (at least in my head) when people like to pretend that there's no room for improvement in the sports + I'd be very pleasantly surprised if I learned this stuff no longer happens.
You have single-handedly convinced my great big queer self to get back to fencing. I miss it so much sometimes, but I've always worried how people will see me since transitioning and that has held me back.
It's been a while since I fenced, but I don't remember ever raising my sword and seeing anything other than a mask. I have beaten, and been beaten by, every type of human imaginable. Even watching the mask go on, once I raised my épée I forgot the race, sex, everything. We just fenced. If you miss it, please go back.
I want to do so many competitive things post-transition, but I'm terrified at having all of my success stolen away from me by people who want to "protect the position of women in competition" who see the success of a trans woman as robbing cis ("real" as they often say) women of the opportunity. I know, screw them, forget them, but competition is formed best by community, and the leaders of community may have their ears bent by folks I would otherwise ignore. Call me thin-skinned, but I handle enough bullyig in my life, I don't want to invite more.
"we can't let men know you have a torso and limbs under there" has the same energy as " *If the men find out we can shape shift, they're going to tell the church* "
I bike a 12 mile round trip to go to class, 5 days a week, and I wear a corset every day. It’s really no more difficult than uncorseted, and I have no more trouble going up the hills. My long skirts really are the biggest issue. Since I don’t have any divided skirts, I often pull the back hem through to the front and fasten it with paperclips, so it becomes a pair of makeshift bloomers.
If it fits your aesthetic, wide leg/palazzo pants may be a happy medium. When standing they give the flowing appearance of a skirt but the separation of pants.
Oh, cool! Might I ask how you wear your hair, if it is long? I wear long skirts and a corset too and have never had issues with them, but I wear my hair in a little 1840s bun style and it is *impossible* to cram under my bike helmet, but I don't just wanna let it be loose or it gets everywhere (and for whatever reason braids always come undone).
Oh man this was great, and the cherry on top was bringing the issue home with regard to still existing arbitrary weirdness in women’s sports. Thank you!!
I remember one time, there was a foto of the olympics, with an arabian team vs the brazilian team on voleibol, and some people here (in brazil, were we are "obessed" with women in short clothes) were talking about how "patriarcal" were the arabian uniformes, because they hat long sleeves and leggings! female "normal" sportsweare are so short and sometimes unconfortable, and I am sure is mostly cause men said it had to be
@@gisela_oliveira happens Here in Europe as Well. I remember when Adidas or Nike introduced whats basically a Sports Hijab or the "burkini" to enable conservative Muslim Girls to participate in Sports, and Europe went: oh we cant have that it's sexist to Wrap a Girl in all that clothing. Women shouldnt be forced to wear that! Fast Forward to 2021 and See the norwegian beach Volleyball Team find for playing in shorts. Because they didnt want to wear Bikini bottoms. So.... Yh.... Sexism is only when other people do it? Nice Take, everyone.
It’s really wonderful how you make sure to be clear on topics surrounding genders, sexualities, etc. Thank you for being cautious by saying “gender norms of that time” and different things to make sure no one feels out of place. Great video as always, it’s so important to know the racist, sexist, and homophobic tendencies of the time. So interesting! ❤️
I was waiting for some mention of women's uterus' "falling out" as a result of riding a bike, not going to lie. But anyway, very informative and thorough presentation. I really enjoyed learning about this topic.
I always appreciate Kaz's interpretations of gender from the past. I keep looking at what we are like today and it often feels like nothing has changed in all these years. But then again, at least we have the words to talk about these days.
Me whenever I see a 1890s woman in a novel bemoaning the fact she can't go on adventures because of her corset and skirts: "CYCLING OUTFITS EXIST, AND THEY LOOK SO CUTE 😭"
I was extremely weak for Kaz in this episode. I normally have a little crush on them, but with the addition of a sword I was melting. Absolutely amazing content as per usual!
I had assumed their gender which I now feel bad about but anyway I finally checked their bio and see that Kaz's pronouns are in fact they/them, anyways your comment was the first I've seen that used pronouns instead of just saying their name. I really hope I haven't used the wrong pronouns in previous comments, I'll go and check (I'm just commenting to say thanks for using the right pronouns so that I finally noticed)
Remarcable that you took the time to make outfits and get out there showing it was perfectly fit to use. Not only super well researched (like everything you make) but really cool to actually watch you in action
Hey Kaz! Love your vids. Have you thought about doing a video on the history of bartending in the US? I work at a bar myself and was required to take a course called BarSmarts, which is supposed to be an all-encompassing history of the cocktail and spirit world in order to prepare you for a career as a bartender. However, I found the history super cis-male-centric and, as a queer woman of color, I found it hard to believe that there were no women or queer bartenders before 1970. I'd love to hear your take because you're so good at condensing things into digestible content! Xoxo keep doin you
Oh wow! That would be fascinating! There's a lot of historical weirdness that has gone in terms of women being inn-owners and brewers, or just serving in inns (often heavily sexualised or even crossing over with prostitution), but I've never seen any discussion of women & BIPOC in post-1900 bartending.
Funny thing at my church. A 70 years old woman, who was absolutely a female person, married for years and had children and grand children.Decided to get a passpory to travel outside USA. She discovered her original birth certificate identified her as a male, because of a clerical error 70 years ago! She had a lot of trouble correcting it!
May I also recommend Shannon Makes Channel? She is a professional acrobat, and made several videos about sports corsets for women athletes. The video of her performing her act in a corset is amazing!
When I was 12 I started fencing with the influence of my Dad. My fencing school had lots of vintage weapons and posters on the walls, including the "concours des crime" poster that I adored. I love fencing and its history. I wish it could be more accessible to kids and teens today.
Look up Prior Attire here on UA-cam! She's done many videos showcasing sportswear and sport specific corsets. I think she has a few earlier period sports-related videos too but I know she has many Victorian era ones. (And she covers how to make some of the undergarments and outfits in her books.)
I want to thank you for recommending the "June's Journey" game on a previous video. I know they were a sponsor, but I am so entranced with this game. It is WAY better than anything I was able to find before. As a matter of fact, I found myself thinking about "Myst" as far as the safety and feel of play go. I enthusiastically second your recommendation. Also, many thanks for all your videos. I think often about J.C. Leyendecker. He was one of my favorites in illustration class. Brilliant video in a series of brilliant videos. Keep up the good work.
Hey, I played Myst also! Riven as well. I love finding another fellow player 😊 I haven't tried June's Journey but since you like it and we seem to have a favorite game in common your comment has inspired me to try it. Thanks 💜
OH MY GOSH THE WINK IN THE JULIE D'AUBIGNY COSTUME MY HEART Edit: yeah her outfit is way off for the 17th century, but I believe the reason the painting is associated with Julie D'Aubigny is because it was used as the cover of La Maupin, a book about Julie.
It was great to hear some new fencing history! I started fencing in the early 2000s and became captain of my high school's women's epeé team in the mid 2010s. In that time, foil has remained very much the woman's weapon, with most sabreists and epeeists being men. Due to how competitions are divided by gender, it is at times impossible to fence anything but foil if one is shoehorned into the women's section. Today, fencing is still very much a sport for the upper class and upper-middle class. Due to how class and race are entwined in the United States, the elitism in competitive fencing is often expressed through racism. Most fencers of color who I know (myself included) only gained access to the sport through public university teams or graduates of those universities who worked to offer affordable access to the sport. In the same way men have historically feared being bested by women, white people may fear being bested by people of color. Sports can be an incredible way to gain confidence in one's abilities. It's no wonder why athletics have been so closely gatekept by those in power over the centuries.
To cite my experience as a dancer of moving and performing athletic feats in corsets, ballet tutu bodices, especially lace-up models are often modelled after the corset and fit quite tightly so they don't move around and are often boned for support and structure. Despite modern improvements, full platter tutus can still be quite heavy due to the layers of the net and the steel hoop inside. Because classical ballet was while very moving was designed to be danced in a sort of modified corset when you are actually in these costumes not only does the tightness of the bodice provide some nice support, but the structure lifts some of the weight of the costumes off your body and makes moving somewhat easier.
Thanks for the fascinating story. I am straight. I fenced at the college level, and was a competitive cyclist & tri-athlete. As if this wasn’t enough, I am currently recovering from a stroke, (I lived) so please excuse my errors in phrasing. As I am dying to comment, let me add that while training / cycling in Brooklyn, NY, I often encountered a nuance of an experience un-addressed. The training ride in Prospect Park often included an Orthodox Jewish woman; hair braided, despite her helmet, and wearing a denim skirt, wrapped appropriately. her Hasidic rules undoubtedly fulfilled. From a cyclist’s standpoint, “she could motor”. The struggle, for her, was real, and no less brave. Thanks!
Amazing content, yet again! It's amazing how true these women were to themselves back then. That takes a lot of bravery, especially with the social expectations they faced.
@Man who is missing two toenails not at all! I only started fencing when I was 16. A lot of the best fencers at my club that I know started as adults, so 17 is a great age! Because fencing isn't the most common sport, it's not like the majority of people who have been playing do it sense elementary school, like soccer or lacrosse. I really hope you pursue fencing! I know at my club we always need more fencers- especially in foil, like me lol. I wish you the best of luck!
I started fencing at 52 years old, currently training with a lot of females from teens to my vintage (59). From the female fencers, I learnt footwork. The females learn about distance, timing, tempo when fighting me. We are all getting medals, even me😊 So you are never too old to learn....No excuses, do fencing🤺🤺🤺🤺
Me: “you know as much as I might like them, I really can’t justify buying a sword. It’d be an impractical use of my limited resources. And besides, I don’t want to become a sword guy.” My brain: “yO tHoSe ARe sOme frikeN sWeeT SwoRds They’Ve got RIghT THere riGhT TheRe!”
i friggin love this. breaks the stereotypes we hold about a historical era, and opens my eyes to what sports we can enjoy today in reenactment/costume!!
I know I am late to this video but as someone who loves gymnastics I would love a video on it. Specifically how a sport that was at one time a men's sport has now turned to a sport we associate with women.
Thanks Kaz! I've loved your channel since your Green Knight video. I had literally seen that movie the day before. Frankly, I was struggling to put it together but I knew I liked it. Your video definitely made me understand it a bit better
Hopefully we will finally move away from the myths surrounding corsets sometime soon. Loved this video and your final points about how discrimination in sports effects us all. Would be nice to live in a world where we can all get outside and exercise just as we are. Just accepted and encouraged. I also always find the arguments that refer to nature or going 'against nature' so ridiculous because nature itself is so fluid and diverse.
Fun fact, one of the first accounts of an ice hockey goalie wearing a face mask in a game was when Elizabeth Graham wore a wire fencing mask while playing goalie for the Queens University hockey team on February 7, 1927. Great video! I love all of the well researched information you presented. Cheers!
I honestly have never felt more comfortable than when I wear my historically accurate corset. Thank you so much for giving so much amazing information on this part of history that is rarely discussed.
PriorAttire's channel has also featured sport corsets from the 19th century. Also ,I had never heard about side-saddle bicycles before this video. How strange!
I was sooo excited for this video ever since you posted about the fencing suit and I have to say, you exceeded my expectations! Thank you so much for another amazing video, I hope you're keeping well!
Somber yet necessary ending! I mean, we are clearly not far enough from these issues, sadly. And the sooner we realize how much it affects all of us the sooner we can do something about it. And on that note, thank you for the video! 🖤✨
Madge Syers, the first woman to compete at the figure skating world championship, in 1902, was able to do so because despite figure skating being considered an all-male sport, there where no rules that explicitly banned women from competing. She won the silver medal, although, supposedly, at the time many experts and fellow skaters thought she should have won. Ulrich Salcow, the gold medalist that year and the man that later dominated the sport for a decade, was apparently so impressed that he offered her his medal.
i just love your videos, you explain things in an easy to understand way that doesn't feel patronizing, your voice is soothing but it keeps me interested in what you're saying (you should do audiobooks), your background and your look are always on point and the fact that you always present the topics from bipoc points of view in history which are rarely ever mentioned at all makes my heart swell, honestly you are one of my favorite content creators even if your content is very niche and deals with topics that i didn't even realize i was curious about before reading the titles, i always look forward to your uploads, i hope you are doing well, keep up the good work❤️
I must say, I've watched the last 10 videos on your channel so far and it has been amazing. Please keep up with it, your work is amazing. Especially since im a truck driver they really help pass the time and I'm learning a LOT!
Great video! Karolina Zebrowska also made a video where she tries on turn of the century sportswear and goes rock climbing. Yes. Rock climbing. (Spoiler alert, she’s fine.)
Claiming saber is a more advanced weapon than foil is ludicrous, a valid strategy is literally just swinging wildly and hoping to brake your opponents defense. Saber also allows you to use the entire blade while foil requires you to hit with the tip and usually center mass.
The bicycle debacle is so silly and It’s funny to see that cycling stills has some of these silly ideas on the male vs female bike designs such as the type of saddles and the middle bar location
I have had men mess up my bike when i just take it in to get a flat fixed… someone switched my bike from single speed (and back peddling to break) to regular brakes it was so annoying
This is such a fascinating topic!! Coming into this video I had only ever known about cycling bloomers from blips of fashion history I've come across, I had no idea how much womens sports and physical activity has changed the social climate!! Yet another excellent video, I always come away from your content with so much more knowledge and broader interests!! Can't wait to see what else you have in store!! 😊😊😊
when i finally make a pair of well fitting stays i want to try going biking in them. my posture is always terrible when im riding a bike and i wonder how id feel after doing it in stays. im not going to make a corset, at least for a while, because im more interested in 18th century costuming
Thank you very much for your wonderful video presentation. It's truly thought-provoking, entertaining, and informative. One thing you left out, curiously enough, is women in swimming, and the restrictions placed on them in that particular sport/activity/recreation, the types of swimwears they were allowed and not allowed to wear, etc. Gertrude Ederle and Helen Wainwright, for instances, became sensations for what they were able to accomplish in the midst of societal restrictions, norms, and mores placed on them and on women in general. Just a thought. Thanks again.
Only one problem with this video: you didn't wear a helmet when riding your bike! It's very important, even if it isn't period! lol, I was genuinely anxious during that part, but in all seriousness, this is an awesome and really informative video
Fencing is great exercise! I have to say that because I fence in Historical European Martial Arts and it basically saved me from being almost completely disabled by back problems and very overweight/unhealthy. It took a lot of work, but it's super fun and it's really a non-pretentious sport. Look up your local HEMA club!
Sadly I know from personal experience how dangerous even large baggy pants can be on a bicycle: I was a teenager in the 90s, when those really huge JNCO jeans were in style. They were just about as wide as the legs of a split skirt would have been, and more than once they got tangled either in the back wheel or in the chain (which was nice and embarrassing as well as painful, since I inevitably fell over). I'm not surprised that specific cycling outfits with bloomers/trousers were developed.
And the low rise flare jeans of the early 2000s weren't much better in that way- a lot of my pants at the time ended up with one hem all chewed up from catching in the chain.
Yet another wonderful and informative presentation. Thank you for sharing this. Secret Habits and Evil Practices? Both sound more exciting than plain old self pollution. That Fencing Suit looks so cool. Bloomers look fabulous. "Voluminous Bloomers" sounds like a great name for a heroine. 38:53 FREE WHEELING!?? Are you QUITE mad?! You earlier informed us of the inherent danger of this pernicious practice! 😍😂
Considering any woman who went out in public alone had to fend off being groped by "mashers" by literally using a hat pin as a weapon, I think fencing was probably an appropriate sport to partake in.
I was having a really rough time feeling awake today for various reasons, but 'champlions' and 'spoitswear' made me laugh enough to get some energy going, so thanks for that Kaz.
I only found your channel a couple months back and I've never had the confidence to leave a comment as I don't have a lot of historical knowledge. But I want to say just how much I enjoy your videos, you have very quickly become one of my favourite people on UA-cam not only for your awesome content but also your personality. I've found watching your videos has been helping me on my own journey of identity/gender etc as well. I know you mentioned doing a tove jansson video soon and I really really hope you do as that would be beyond cool!
on the point of corsetry and tight lacing; most women weren't lacing down to those extremes as seen in victorian art - most typically only laced down to a 26-29 inch waist, which is not an unhealthy size. most of the time, the real shaping was down by padding in the bust and on the hips.
I have to say I didn't think I'd enjoy this video as much as others I've watched since I really care not for sports...but I was wrong. First it was very entertaining and informative and well done. Title IX was passed in 1972, and from the moment I stepped into my Jr. High PE class the fall of 1973 our PE teacher was all about it - she was so excited about, but I honestly couldn't fathom why... :) I really had never known a world pre-Title IX - in Elementary School everyone played everything and there were no sports teams. Since I wasn't interested I could see the importance. As an adult now of course I understand, and the older and hopefully wiser I get the more I understand the implication of Title IX and all the different things of the past like the Women's Sport Movement of the Victorian Era did for Women and help the world and us see ourselves as more than the just the rolls assigned to us for soooo long.
"People were quickly developing a grave mistrust of medical men in general, while simultaneously somehow believing most of the ideas that many doctors promoted." Sounds like our relationship with Victorian doctors now, and uh, *ahem* certain myths against specific undergarments.
6:10 This reminds me of ‘The Yellow Wallpaper’ by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. I would highly recommend it if you haven’t read it because it beautifully addresses this exact issue.
Holy shit victorian era working women "stripping down to the waist and beating the shit out of each other" made me laugh so hard. I am devastated it took me this long in life for someone to plant that visual into my head.
not only was this video SUPER informative and taught me a lot, but Kaz, you're so wonderfully dressed!!! i just recently found your channel and all of your outfits are fantastic! much love
Hey Kaz! I found your channel a while back, but only recently started to watch your videos. (binge watch tbh) I want to applaude you for making such educational and curiosity sparking videos! It shows how much effort and thought you put in every single one. Discovering your videos lit up a long lost passion for history in me. I've been watching your videos while drawing, inspired by anything and everything you talk about. So thank you for lighting up that spark again!
... I'm intrigued by the working class women beating the shit out of each other in bar fights
Same! Did they lossen their corsets to move better? Did they take off their tops to fight as not to rip them? As a seamstress I'm wondering..
@@HosCreates Not working women, but there was an incident where two high society women (A duchess and countess?) Got into an argument and decided to duel. Then someone suggested that they duel topless to not only to avoid ripping their clothes, but so the torn shreds don't infect any wounds.
I believe this set off a trend of painting dueling topless ladies.
@@Rozdlc Oh by heavens, people don't change do they?
Heck yeah tits out fists up
"Once again, bigoted art trying to take a dig at masc women and gender nonconforming people backfires and ends up making them look fucking badass..."
I adore you, Kaz.
"Don't say feel my muscles, don't criticize peoples legs."
A small muscled man suggested these
Ben Shapiro in a previous life.
People’s “legs”
@@angelasmith5019 yup!😆
This was too funny :D
As they're reading the whole list I'm giggling at the idea of Victorian women just throwing their "Wright around" and the men being like 🥴 guess we need to set some "boundaries." 😂 stfu and FEEL HER MUSCLE AND GOSSIP ABOUT OTHER PEOPLES LEGS WITH HER haha
Guy: "Ladies belong to a sex which for centuries has not been accustomed to exercise in the open air"
Women who've been working in agriculture for generations: "Am I a joke to you?"
Worrying about the effects of bicycle seats on women's anatomy is funny to me, because of the two sexes I'm pretty sure men's anatomy is far more likely to be damaged.
Same with horse riding. While hitting the saddle too hard after jumping hurts as heck for women, at least, they're not going to go sterile from it
good, I always thought bikers could use a lil emasculation
I've always wondered how that worked. Like does it not, eh, squish things? And I see someone mentioned horseback riding too... imagine you're just chilling in a pasture, eating some fine grass, trying to hook up with that new appaloosa mare, (you have a thing for spots) and then all of a sudden a dude jumps on you and now his stuff is bouncing on your back 😆 🤣
@@hblackburn5580 they sell specialty cups that are molded to bike seats, and jostling the huevos has been bike magazine fodder for at least a century.
As a man: can confirm through experience- FAR more likely to be damaged indeed 😂
I support a woman's right to be the 'angry, macho angel of the house.'
But actually yes, it's pretty amazing that you made that in two days. Kaz got mad skills 😎
It's so nice to hear about the history of women in fencing. When I fenced in college they never talked about this, only about how fencing came about when fancy men didn't know how to use their rapiers do during drunken duels, no one won and both participants died of infection lol
Same! I fenced from middle school through college and I rarely ever heard about fencing’s history. I honestly never heard about women only being allowed to fence saber in the year 2000. That might actually help to explain why there so few women’s saberists.
I'm nearly 60 and fence with females from teens to my vintage) some are at national level (Spain). We learn from each other, fencers commenting here knows the importance of footwork which I learnt from the most part from female fencers. For the females, as I'm larg-ish and fence at a slower pace, they become more aware of distance and have to be more aware of patience, using psychology...We are learning, having fun and getting medals 😃🤺🤺🤺🤺
It’s insane that this historical context for the XIX century was never explained and detailed on ANY of the many clases I took at uni for psychoanalysis. We spend plenty of time talking about the therapy (torture) used / inflicted by men like Breuer and Freud to their female patients that were “hysteric”, but not one second talking about how gender speciations and patriarchy can destroy your life.
“I wonder why all this women are so hysterical Breuer”
“I don’t really care Freud, let’s force them to masturbate and take pictures while they are at it”
It's unfortunately super common in history, too. Students are taught an overview of top-down events; wars fought, laws passed, and the people at the very top of the government. But this information is rarely contextualized by social norms, living conditions, and economic pressures.
That story about receiving a porcelain bowl instead of a gold medal reminds me of a childhood insult:
Our basketball team participated in the boys' tournament in the early 2000s, because we were far ahead of teams in our own division at the time. We ended up winning all but the final match, but instead of receiving the silver medal we were awarded gold medals for "the best girls' team in the tournament". We were the only girls' team in the tournament...
Sure, the intentions were probably good, perhaps they had an idea of having this ready in case we lost to the Obviously Superior Boys and would thus have our Feminine Feelings hurt (I mean, what if a girl began crying? Utter chaos!), and wanted to have a consolation prize ready or something: But it would've served them- and us - better to just pretend it didn't exist once we fought our way to the finals.
I remember being upset despite not really understanding why (oh, the naivety of youth!), but even more clearly I remember my mom being absolutely livid which was a rare occurence indeed.
I still go back to that (at least in my head) when people like to pretend that there's no room for improvement in the sports + I'd be very pleasantly surprised if I learned this stuff no longer happens.
Cishet men have always been the real threat to women in sports.
You have single-handedly convinced my great big queer self to get back to fencing. I miss it so much sometimes, but I've always worried how people will see me since transitioning and that has held me back.
If you like it, do it! (Personally I'm terrible. Pity, because it looks so cool when people know what they're doing.)
Go for ittttt 😁
It's been a while since I fenced, but I don't remember ever raising my sword and seeing anything other than a mask. I have beaten, and been beaten by, every type of human imaginable. Even watching the mask go on, once I raised my épée I forgot the race, sex, everything. We just fenced. If you miss it, please go back.
Do YOU friend! Celebrate what ever makes you happy! It breaks my heart, hearing someone held back by fear
I want to do so many competitive things post-transition, but I'm terrified at having all of my success stolen away from me by people who want to "protect the position of women in competition" who see the success of a trans woman as robbing cis ("real" as they often say) women of the opportunity. I know, screw them, forget them, but competition is formed best by community, and the leaders of community may have their ears bent by folks I would otherwise ignore. Call me thin-skinned, but I handle enough bullyig in my life, I don't want to invite more.
"we can't let men know you have a torso and limbs under there" has the same energy as " *If the men find out we can shape shift, they're going to tell the church* "
We can't let the church messing with our plans...
You mean shape shifting like “putting makeup on”? I mean, many man are even confused by that 😂
You must not have nostrils.
You must not have nostrils.
You must not have nostrils.
I bike a 12 mile round trip to go to class, 5 days a week, and I wear a corset every day. It’s really no more difficult than uncorseted, and I have no more trouble going up the hills.
My long skirts really are the biggest issue.
Since I don’t have any divided skirts, I often pull the back hem through to the front and fasten it with paperclips, so it becomes a pair of makeshift bloomers.
If it fits your aesthetic, wide leg/palazzo pants may be a happy medium. When standing they give the flowing appearance of a skirt but the separation of pants.
Oh, cool! Might I ask how you wear your hair, if it is long? I wear long skirts and a corset too and have never had issues with them, but I wear my hair in a little 1840s bun style and it is *impossible* to cram under my bike helmet, but I don't just wanna let it be loose or it gets everywhere (and for whatever reason braids always come undone).
Oh man this was great, and the cherry on top was bringing the issue home with regard to still existing arbitrary weirdness in women’s sports. Thank you!!
I remember one time, there was a foto of the olympics, with an arabian team vs the brazilian team on voleibol, and some people here (in brazil, were we are "obessed" with women in short clothes) were talking about how "patriarcal" were the arabian uniformes, because they hat long sleeves and leggings! female "normal" sportsweare are so short and sometimes unconfortable, and I am sure is mostly cause men said it had to be
@@gisela_oliveira happens Here in Europe as Well. I remember when Adidas or Nike introduced whats basically a Sports Hijab or the "burkini" to enable conservative Muslim Girls to participate in Sports, and Europe went: oh we cant have that it's sexist to Wrap a Girl in all that clothing. Women shouldnt be forced to wear that!
Fast Forward to 2021 and See the norwegian beach Volleyball Team find for playing in shorts. Because they didnt want to wear Bikini bottoms.
So.... Yh.... Sexism is only when other people do it? Nice Take, everyone.
The fencing outfit gave me life! The new seating area gave me life! The well written and researched info gave me LIFE!!! Great job!
Omg that fencing outfit, I'd die happily with it
It’s really wonderful how you make sure to be clear on topics surrounding genders, sexualities, etc. Thank you for being cautious by saying “gender norms of that time” and different things to make sure no one feels out of place. Great video as always, it’s so important to know the racist, sexist, and homophobic tendencies of the time. So interesting! ❤️
I was waiting for some mention of women's uterus' "falling out" as a result of riding a bike, not going to lie. But anyway, very informative and thorough presentation. I really enjoyed learning about this topic.
I always appreciate Kaz's interpretations of gender from the past. I keep looking at what we are like today and it often feels like nothing has changed in all these years. But then again, at least we have the words to talk about these days.
Me whenever I see a 1890s woman in a novel bemoaning the fact she can't go on adventures because of her corset and skirts: "CYCLING OUTFITS EXIST, AND THEY LOOK SO CUTE 😭"
There is now no reason why we cannot have a lady superhero movie set in Victorian England.
There is now no reason why we cannot have a lady superhero movie set in Victorian England.
I was extremely weak for Kaz in this episode. I normally have a little crush on them, but with the addition of a sword I was melting.
Absolutely amazing content as per usual!
Oh, absolutely!
Same😅 It feels rather disrespectful to be distracted from the topic they are covering and have spent hours of research on
I had assumed their gender which I now feel bad about but anyway I finally checked their bio and see that Kaz's pronouns are in fact they/them, anyways your comment was the first I've seen that used pronouns instead of just saying their name. I really hope I haven't used the wrong pronouns in previous comments, I'll go and check (I'm just commenting to say thanks for using the right pronouns so that I finally noticed)
Same tbh. The posing, the sword, the wink... I'm ruined.
I feel this with every video of theirs I watch.
Remarcable that you took the time to make outfits and get out there showing it was perfectly fit to use.
Not only super well researched (like everything you make) but really cool to actually watch you in action
Now I'm wondering if we could get up a petition for the next video to be Kaz fencing in that ultra-extra custom-tailored black-and-white number!
@@mcjohn5420 I would sign for sure!
And it was so funny that the only wardrobe malfunction came from the modern piece of clothing 😂
Hey Kaz! Love your vids. Have you thought about doing a video on the history of bartending in the US? I work at a bar myself and was required to take a course called BarSmarts, which is supposed to be an all-encompassing history of the cocktail and spirit world in order to prepare you for a career as a bartender. However, I found the history super cis-male-centric and, as a queer woman of color, I found it hard to believe that there were no women or queer bartenders before 1970. I'd love to hear your take because you're so good at condensing things into digestible content! Xoxo keep doin you
Oh wow! That would be fascinating! There's a lot of historical weirdness that has gone in terms of women being inn-owners and brewers, or just serving in inns (often heavily sexualised or even crossing over with prostitution), but I've never seen any discussion of women & BIPOC in post-1900 bartending.
I am so torn... I love discussions of women's fencing, but... The outfit... IT'S SO FRESH!! HOW AM I TO FOCUS WITH SUCH AN ICONIC LOOK BEFORE ME?!?!
Funny thing at my church. A 70 years old woman, who was absolutely a female person, married for years and had children and grand children.Decided to get a passpory to travel outside USA. She discovered her original birth certificate identified her as a male, because of a clerical error 70 years ago! She had a lot of trouble correcting it!
I love that lady was like " bikes, devils stuff." Men bothering women " he gets the umbrella." I love that for her 😂😂😂😂
May I also recommend Shannon Makes Channel? She is a professional acrobat, and made several videos about sports corsets for women athletes. The video of her performing her act in a corset is amazing!
The fencing outfit is striking and has you looking like a majestic handsome character from an old school shoujo manga
I like your "somber" note at the end, it was helpful to hear a clear argument on the continuum of sexual identity.
When I was 12 I started fencing with the influence of my Dad. My fencing school had lots of vintage weapons and posters on the walls, including the "concours des crime" poster that I adored. I love fencing and its history. I wish it could be more accessible to kids and teens today.
Look up Prior Attire here on UA-cam! She's done many videos showcasing sportswear and sport specific corsets. I think she has a few earlier period sports-related videos too but I know she has many Victorian era ones. (And she covers how to make some of the undergarments and outfits in her books.)
I want to thank you for recommending the "June's Journey" game on a previous video. I know they were a sponsor, but I am so entranced with this game. It is WAY better than anything I was able to find before. As a matter of fact, I found myself thinking about "Myst" as far as the safety and feel of play go. I enthusiastically second your recommendation.
Also, many thanks for all your videos. I think often about J.C. Leyendecker. He was one of my favorites in illustration class. Brilliant video in a series of brilliant videos. Keep up the good work.
Maybe
Hey, I played Myst also! Riven as well. I love finding another fellow player 😊 I haven't tried June's Journey but since you like it and we seem to have a favorite game in common your comment has inspired me to try it. Thanks 💜
OH MY GOSH THE WINK IN THE JULIE D'AUBIGNY COSTUME
MY HEART
Edit: yeah her outfit is way off for the 17th century, but I believe the reason the painting is associated with Julie D'Aubigny is because it was used as the cover of La Maupin, a book about Julie.
It was great to hear some new fencing history! I started fencing in the early 2000s and became captain of my high school's women's epeé team in the mid 2010s. In that time, foil has remained very much the woman's weapon, with most sabreists and epeeists being men. Due to how competitions are divided by gender, it is at times impossible to fence anything but foil if one is shoehorned into the women's section.
Today, fencing is still very much a sport for the upper class and upper-middle class. Due to how class and race are entwined in the United States, the elitism in competitive fencing is often expressed through racism. Most fencers of color who I know (myself included) only gained access to the sport through public university teams or graduates of those universities who worked to offer affordable access to the sport. In the same way men have historically feared being bested by women, white people may fear being bested by people of color. Sports can be an incredible way to gain confidence in one's abilities. It's no wonder why athletics have been so closely gatekept by those in power over the centuries.
The end of this video was *chefs kiss* so perfectly said.
To cite my experience as a dancer of moving and performing athletic feats in corsets, ballet tutu bodices, especially lace-up models are often modelled after the corset and fit quite tightly so they don't move around and are often boned for support and structure. Despite modern improvements, full platter tutus can still be quite heavy due to the layers of the net and the steel hoop inside. Because classical ballet was while very moving was designed to be danced in a sort of modified corset when you are actually in these costumes not only does the tightness of the bodice provide some nice support, but the structure lifts some of the weight of the costumes off your body and makes moving somewhat easier.
Thanks for the fascinating story. I am straight. I fenced at the college level, and was a competitive cyclist & tri-athlete. As if this wasn’t enough, I am currently recovering from a stroke, (I lived) so please excuse my errors in phrasing. As I am dying to comment, let me add that while training / cycling in Brooklyn, NY, I often encountered a nuance of an experience un-addressed. The training ride in Prospect Park often included an Orthodox Jewish woman; hair braided, despite her helmet, and wearing a denim skirt, wrapped appropriately. her Hasidic rules undoubtedly fulfilled. From a cyclist’s standpoint, “she could motor”. The struggle, for her, was real, and no less brave. Thanks!
I think it’s so funny how the padded jacket and bloomers combo has a silhouette reminiscent of tudor men’s wear
Amazing content, yet again! It's amazing how true these women were to themselves back then. That takes a lot of bravery, especially with the social expectations they faced.
As some who studied The Yellow Wallpaper in English, hearing the name S. Weir Mitchell in this context almost stopped my heart
I love the androgynous yet clearly victorian/rococo-esque style you have. It also looks very comfortable. Amazing video as always.
As a female fencer, I am so happy that someone is discussing the history of women in fencing 🥰
I'm 17 and always wanted to do fencing, am i too old to get into it?
@Man who is missing two toenails not at all! I only started fencing when I was 16. A lot of the best fencers at my club that I know started as adults, so 17 is a great age! Because fencing isn't the most common sport, it's not like the majority of people who have been playing do it sense elementary school, like soccer or lacrosse. I really hope you pursue fencing! I know at my club we always need more fencers- especially in foil, like me lol. I wish you the best of luck!
I started fencing at 52 years old, currently training with a lot of females from teens to my vintage (59). From the female fencers, I learnt footwork. The females learn about distance, timing, tempo when fighting me. We are all getting medals, even me😊 So you are never too old to learn....No excuses, do fencing🤺🤺🤺🤺
I recognizedthe painting of Chevalier d'Eon fencing you used when first talking about women fencing.
Me: “you know as much as I might like them, I really can’t justify buying a sword. It’d be an impractical use of my limited resources. And besides, I don’t want to become a sword guy.”
My brain: “yO tHoSe ARe sOme frikeN sWeeT SwoRds They’Ve got RIghT THere riGhT TheRe!”
i friggin love this. breaks the stereotypes we hold about a historical era, and opens my eyes to what sports we can enjoy today in reenactment/costume!!
I know I am late to this video but as someone who loves gymnastics I would love a video on it. Specifically how a sport that was at one time a men's sport has now turned to a sport we associate with women.
Thanks Kaz! I've loved your channel since your Green Knight video. I had literally seen that movie the day before. Frankly, I was struggling to put it together but I knew I liked it. Your video definitely made me understand it a bit better
Hopefully we will finally move away from the myths surrounding corsets sometime soon. Loved this video and your final points about how discrimination in sports effects us all. Would be nice to live in a world where we can all get outside and exercise just as we are. Just accepted and encouraged. I also always find the arguments that refer to nature or going 'against nature' so ridiculous because nature itself is so fluid and diverse.
Fun fact, one of the first accounts of an ice hockey goalie wearing a face mask in a game was when Elizabeth Graham wore a wire fencing mask while playing goalie for the Queens University hockey team on February 7, 1927. Great video! I love all of the well researched information you presented. Cheers!
I honestly have never felt more comfortable than when I wear my historically accurate corset. Thank you so much for giving so much amazing information on this part of history that is rarely discussed.
Side-saddle bicycles are frankly terrifying contraptions.
PriorAttire's channel has also featured sport corsets from the 19th century. Also ,I had never heard about side-saddle bicycles before this video. How strange!
I was sooo excited for this video ever since you posted about the fencing suit and I have to say, you exceeded my expectations! Thank you so much for another amazing video, I hope you're keeping well!
Great drag name...”welcome to the staggeeee...VOLUMINOUS BLOOMERS”
The sound effect at "evil practices" sent me into the stratosphere
Another great job! You really hit all the important points. And you looked snazzy af and not at all out of shape in the cycling sequence!
Kaz!! I love when you drop a new video!! You are seriously one of my favorite UA-camrs. This one is great. Loving the longer time as well 🖤
It's lovely to hear you point out repeatedly about the misconceptions people have about biological sex and how it's absolutely not binary
Somber yet necessary ending! I mean, we are clearly not far enough from these issues, sadly. And the sooner we realize how much it affects all of us the sooner we can do something about it. And on that note, thank you for the video! 🖤✨
“We can’t let men know you have a torso and limbs under there” is my favorite line. I love the way you articulate information in your videos!!
Hey nice shout out to my alma mater, Mount Holyoke College (Female Seminary). I've seen that photo of the calisthenics class many times :) great vid!
Madge Syers, the first woman to compete at the figure skating world championship, in 1902, was able to do so because despite figure skating being considered an all-male sport, there where no rules that explicitly banned women from competing. She won the silver medal, although, supposedly, at the time many experts and fellow skaters thought she should have won. Ulrich Salcow, the gold medalist that year and the man that later dominated the sport for a decade, was apparently so impressed that he offered her his medal.
i just love your videos, you explain things in an easy to understand way that doesn't feel patronizing, your voice is soothing but it keeps me interested in what you're saying (you should do audiobooks), your background and your look are always on point and the fact that you always present the topics from bipoc points of view in history which are rarely ever mentioned at all makes my heart swell, honestly you are one of my favorite content creators even if your content is very niche and deals with topics that i didn't even realize i was curious about before reading the titles, i always look forward to your uploads, i hope you are doing well, keep up the good work❤️
10:00 and the sweat. So many layers, so much fabric, those things were personal saunas in the summer.
ive been waiting for someone to bring up this topic! as someone who loves historical fashion, its so interesting to see :)
A someone who bikes every day to work an back in skirts and either corset or stays I find it endlessly amusing how many myths are still alive today.
I must say, I've watched the last 10 videos on your channel so far and it has been amazing. Please keep up with it, your work is amazing. Especially since im a truck driver they really help pass the time and I'm learning a LOT!
Great video!
Karolina Zebrowska also made a video where she tries on turn of the century sportswear and goes rock climbing. Yes. Rock climbing. (Spoiler alert, she’s fine.)
I would love it if you made a video on Sylvia Plath, including her infamous stay at the psychiatric ward
Claiming saber is a more advanced weapon than foil is ludicrous, a valid strategy is literally just swinging wildly and hoping to brake your opponents defense. Saber also allows you to use the entire blade while foil requires you to hit with the tip and usually center mass.
This was a tour de force! Thank you for educating us. Here's to more growth.
The bicycle debacle is so silly and It’s funny to see that cycling stills has some of these silly ideas on the male vs female bike designs such as the type of saddles and the middle bar location
I have had men mess up my bike when i just take it in to get a flat fixed… someone switched my bike from single speed (and back peddling to break) to regular brakes it was so annoying
@@MopMop1234 Wait, what? Why?
38:13 made my day! Just the best example of mobility in a corset by far 👍
Ah yes…. Sports. The art of… sportsing. Life is Balls or whatever.
Joking aside, thanks for more great content! 🌈
i love this person so much i’m so happy that their videos popped up on my feed, every single video is amazing and have so much wonderful information
You riding that bike was kinda cute 🥰 thank you for putting so much effort in your videos! Well done once again 💕
This is such a fascinating topic!! Coming into this video I had only ever known about cycling bloomers from blips of fashion history I've come across, I had no idea how much womens sports and physical activity has changed the social climate!! Yet another excellent video, I always come away from your content with so much more knowledge and broader interests!! Can't wait to see what else you have in store!! 😊😊😊
when i finally make a pair of well fitting stays i want to try going biking in them. my posture is always terrible when im riding a bike and i wonder how id feel after doing it in stays. im not going to make a corset, at least for a while, because im more interested in 18th century costuming
Thank you very much for your wonderful video presentation. It's truly thought-provoking, entertaining, and informative.
One thing you left out, curiously enough, is women in swimming, and the restrictions placed on them in that particular sport/activity/recreation, the types of swimwears they were allowed and not allowed to wear, etc.
Gertrude Ederle and Helen Wainwright, for instances, became sensations for what they were able to accomplish in the midst of societal restrictions, norms, and mores placed on them and on women in general.
Just a thought. Thanks again.
"amoebas blob of undefined energy"
Guys, a new gender just dropped, and it's a good one!
Only one problem with this video: you didn't wear a helmet when riding your bike! It's very important, even if it isn't period! lol, I was genuinely anxious during that part, but in all seriousness, this is an awesome and really informative video
I would suggest that you make a video on the history of the suffrage movement.
Fencing is great exercise! I have to say that because I fence in Historical European Martial Arts and it basically saved me from being almost completely disabled by back problems and very overweight/unhealthy. It took a lot of work, but it's super fun and it's really a non-pretentious sport. Look up your local HEMA club!
What's up fellow HEMA fencer?
@@nathanielwilcox4947 Hey hey!! What's your main weapon? Mine's the montante, I like the big suckers, lol.
@@repeat_defender i am more experinced in German Longsword, but do like a good montante.
Thanks for all the hard work and study of this subject.
I had a horrible day and it was so nice to have a notification saying there was a new video!!! You saved my day! ❤️
Sadly I know from personal experience how dangerous even large baggy pants can be on a bicycle: I was a teenager in the 90s, when those really huge JNCO jeans were in style. They were just about as wide as the legs of a split skirt would have been, and more than once they got tangled either in the back wheel or in the chain (which was nice and embarrassing as well as painful, since I inevitably fell over). I'm not surprised that specific cycling outfits with bloomers/trousers were developed.
And the low rise flare jeans of the early 2000s weren't much better in that way- a lot of my pants at the time ended up with one hem all chewed up from catching in the chain.
Yet another wonderful and informative presentation. Thank you for sharing this.
Secret Habits and Evil Practices? Both sound more exciting than plain old self pollution.
That Fencing Suit looks so cool. Bloomers look fabulous.
"Voluminous Bloomers" sounds like a great name for a heroine.
38:53 FREE WHEELING!?? Are you QUITE mad?! You earlier informed us of the inherent danger of this pernicious practice! 😍😂
Considering any woman who went out in public alone had to fend off being groped by "mashers" by literally using a hat pin as a weapon, I think fencing was probably an appropriate sport to partake in.
I was having a really rough time feeling awake today for various reasons, but 'champlions' and 'spoitswear' made me laugh enough to get some energy going, so thanks for that Kaz.
I only found your channel a couple months back and I've never had the confidence to leave a comment as I don't have a lot of historical knowledge. But I want to say just how much I enjoy your videos, you have very quickly become one of my favourite people on UA-cam not only for your awesome content but also your personality. I've found watching your videos has been helping me on my own journey of identity/gender etc as well. I know you mentioned doing a tove jansson video soon and I really really hope you do as that would be beyond cool!
on the point of corsetry and tight lacing; most women weren't lacing down to those extremes as seen in victorian art - most typically only laced down to a 26-29 inch waist, which is not an unhealthy size. most of the time, the real shaping was down by padding in the bust and on the hips.
I have to say I didn't think I'd enjoy this video as much as others I've watched since I really care not for sports...but I was wrong. First it was very entertaining and informative and well done. Title IX was passed in 1972, and from the moment I stepped into my Jr. High PE class the fall of 1973 our PE teacher was all about it - she was so excited about, but I honestly couldn't fathom why... :) I really had never known a world pre-Title IX - in Elementary School everyone played everything and there were no sports teams. Since I wasn't interested I could see the importance. As an adult now of course I understand, and the older and hopefully wiser I get the more I understand the implication of Title IX and all the different things of the past like the Women's Sport Movement of the Victorian Era did for Women and help the world and us see ourselves as more than the just the rolls assigned to us for soooo long.
Wow! A perfect joy for my week! Thanks so much Kaz. 💜💜❤️❤️🙏
"People were quickly developing a grave mistrust of medical men in general, while simultaneously somehow believing most of the ideas that many doctors promoted."
Sounds like our relationship with Victorian doctors now, and uh, *ahem* certain myths against specific undergarments.
old timey women's bike wear looks REALLY cool! ✨✨✨
6:10 This reminds me of ‘The Yellow Wallpaper’ by Charlotte Perkins Gilman. I would highly recommend it if you haven’t read it because it beautifully addresses this exact issue.
Definitely! That's one of my favorites.
Scandalous! 38:54, the rules said 'No coasting.'
The new setup up gorgeous 💕
It makes it look like you live in a museum.
Holy shit victorian era working women "stripping down to the waist and beating the shit out of each other" made me laugh so hard. I am devastated it took me this long in life for someone to plant that visual into my head.
not only was this video SUPER informative and taught me a lot, but Kaz, you're so wonderfully dressed!!! i just recently found your channel and all of your outfits are fantastic! much love
Hey Kaz!
I found your channel a while back, but only recently started to watch your videos. (binge watch tbh)
I want to applaude you for making such educational and curiosity sparking videos! It shows how much effort and thought you put in every single one. Discovering your videos lit up a long lost passion for history in me. I've been watching your videos while drawing, inspired by anything and everything you talk about.
So thank you for lighting up that spark again!
Tennessee State University was Oprah's university. They currently have a good astronomy program. I used to live nearby.